Title 〈論文〉ハイデガーのデカルト解釈について
Author(s) 君嶋, 泰明
Citation 哲学論叢 (2014), 41: 47-58
Issue Date 2014-11
URL http://hdl.handle.net/2433/200735
Right
Type Departmental Bulletin Paper
Textversion publisher
Kyoto University
- 47 -
aO]Sm2]Rh^ǰȧ0) +
Çÿſŕ
�����
� �êÚ-ŖȮ2Ƶ|Ȥ,aO]Sm3��êÚȄ2ŶÃ2ǰ��- �ȂȽ2A-�]
Rh^K¿Fq�Gzî,�(%�]Rh^3Rj^BMgY^\iY-wL,�êÚȄ
2ŶÃ2�żîƛ/ȅÛƇ�2n)K/�+ G�E,�G(SZ, 23)����ÅŚ2Ƶ|Ȥ
3ş§0DžJF��ǰ��2ȂȽ0) +3čȄ,#2Ůǩ���Ƽ¹0Ƨ�HG0-.=
(+ G(vgl., §6)�#�,3]Rh^-2ȯȜ,ų2Ó)2ȄƇ�Ҥ�H+ G�
(1) ]Rh^3�ƪ3Ǔ�Glƪ3�GɄcogito sumɅ�2ƙǪ0DFȖ�Îë2Œ%/¤
ƙƇKǶî�%��#2� Ę3�ƪ3Ǔ�G�2¡ï0) +3#H/F0ŅŻ�
%A22��ƪ3�G�0) +3=(%�ȄƯ! 0ōǑ�%�(vgl., 24, 46)
(2) ]Rh^3#2�JF0�Ɵó0� +��ĦǓ�GA2Ʉres cogitansɅ�-�+2�ƪ�
2êÚ0xuêÚȄKȢƕ���HK�°EH+�GA2Ʉens creatumɅ���ǨțƋ�
-�+ǫî�%�(vgl., 24)
(3) �êÚ�+ G�-3�ɄƩ0D(+Ʌ°ț�H+ G��-,�G�- �xuêÚ
Ȅ2�2ƒǰ03�Á�êÚȄ2�êÚ�+ G�-3�ɄČ ĬË,Ʌ¬��H+
G�-ɄHergestelltheitɅ�,�G�- �ƒǰ�¿Fȕ=H+ G�(vgl., ibid.)
(4) Á�êÚȄ0� +êÚǔ-3Ʉ�¬��KȚ�+ɅƑ0 =��0�Ƒ®��+ G
ĕ2A2KĿ��#HC�Á�êÚȄ0� +�êÚ�B�êÚǔ�KĬË�G�P
mXMmɄοὐσίαɅ�-3��2�Ƒ®ĨɄAnwesenheitɅ�Kǧ�Ǧǽ,A�(%�#�
+�2�-3�nǟ0�êÚ�Kƒǰ�G� 0�ŖȮ���-FJ��ƑÚ���
�Ķ��F-�+űǙ�+ G�-2n)2ǸĀ-/(+ G�%&�Á�êÚȄ3
ŖȮ2�2űǙ0Ź*��-3/�(%�(vgl., 25-6)
� qȘ2ȚF��HE2ȄƇ3�êÚ-ŖȮ,3�H�qșŻ�HG�-3/�(%�
#�,šƮ,3��2�' (2) 2 �ƛ¡ï0ǪĕK)�+>% �¼Ɗ\TY^3
1923/24ċ£ëŞȆǒ�ƑȊëƛƤƯ92�ȫ�Ʉ�r��ȫ�ȆǒɅ,�G�ÅȆǒ,a
O]Sm3��Ɵó0��G�ĦǓ�GA2�92xuêÚȄ2Ȣƕ- � (2) 2ȄƇ
- 48 -
0ƞĕ�GȉȄKýȭ�+ G2,�GɄěţ�=FĿŋ�H+�/�(%���êÚ-Ŗ
Ȯ,zî�H+ %]Rh^ǰȧ3ú/�E �2ȆǒKrŐ�0�+ G-Ǔ�EH
GɅ�#2��,�aO]Sm� (3) (4) KĤȻ0Ǒ�/�E]Rh^0Æ�D�-�+
% (1) 2ķª2ȌŔ0) +AǠĉ2ǓóKǹ>�n)2ÂǙ/Ǔ�œKŇƧ�% (1)�
� ȄȘ2ĶȺKȘ:+���aO]Sm3��ȫ�Ȇǒ,�]Rh^2�ĦǓɄcogitatioɅ�
ŮĤ3�ƑȊë,ƕ EHGĢÆƛ�Ɂ2ŮĤ-;<nǞ�+ G�(GA17, 132)�-KĔ
ȃ���2ǯƇ�E�ƟóKǰȧ�+ G�#�,��r,3= 1925/26 ċ£ëŞȆ
ǒ�Ȅƒë�0��GaO]Sm0DG�ĢÆĨ�2ǰǿKŮǯ��]Rh^2�ĦǓ�
ŮĤ0% �GĘ2ƒǰKŕƥ0�+��% Ʉ1ƺɅ�#2��,�ų0��ȫ�ȆǒK
¼Ɗ��q2 (2) 0ƞĕ�G�Ɵó2ȉȄKaO]Sm� �0ǰȧ�+ %�KŕE
�0�GɄ2ƺɅ�śĚ0�qKȎ=�� (1) 2ķª2ȌŔ0) +ɄǁĈ2ȦÄq·¥/
ȄǸ-3 �/ �Ʌnî2LJȄKŇƧ�GɄ3ƺɅ�
���$")�1����%,�
� ]Rh^3�Î뻃,��ĦǓ�Kǫî�+ų2D�0Ș:+ G�
� ƪ3ĦǓ- �DzǢ,�JHJH0D(+ĬȈ�H+�JHJH2�'0Ɠ G�
��A#2ĬȈ�JHJH2�'0�G��F2�:+2A2�-ƒǰ�G��%�
(+�ƒǰ�G�-�ĬĢ�G�-�ī��G�-&�,/��ĭǭ�G�-A=%
��,3Ǔ�G�--Å�,�G�(AT, VIII, 7)
#�+��ȑ�0D(+/�HGǬǭBŵǥ�-�ƾƩ0D(+/�HG�Ǫ%Fŵ %F
�G�-2ĭǭ�-K¶«�%��,�A��ƪ3ǪG��G 3ƪ3ŵ��C�0ƪ3
�G�- �ÞÄ��2LJȄ3ƥï/2&��#H35-�0�2�ǪG�B�ŵ��0
�(+ GɄ��,3�ĭǭ�-�+2Ʌ�ĦǓ�2êÚ0DG2&�-�+ G�
� aO]Sm3��ȫ�Ȇǒ,��2D�/]Rh^2�ĦǓ�ŮĤ3�ƑȊë,ƕ E
HGĢÆƛ�Ɂ2ŮĤ-;<nǞ�+ G�-Ș:+ G(2)(GA17, 132)�Ę2�2ƒǰ3
-�0ų2Ƈ0ƢƜ�G�-0Ü* + G��/J'��q2�ǪG�B�ŵ��K�Ǔ
�G�,Ǒ�ň�H4¥�GD�0��]Rh^0� +�ƪ3Ǔ�+ GɄcogitoɅ-3�
ƪ3Ǔ�+ G-ƪ3Ǔ�+ GɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆ
Ʉcogito me cogitareɅKĬË�+ G�(ibid.)�aO]S
m3ÅȆǒ2«2-�I,A�2ƇKĔȃ�+ G��#�,3�Ɵó2ų2nƺ�Ē
ƕ�H+ G(249, ĔȃĒƕǔ)�
aO]Sm2]Rh^ǰȧ0) +
- 49 -
Ɉ…ɉƪ�Ǫ+ GɆɆɆɆɆɆ
�E03Ʉcum videamɅ��G 3ƪ3Ǫ+ G-ƪ�Ǔ�+ ɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆ
GɆ�E03Ʉcum cogitem me videreɅɄ�2|)K =Bƪ3¶«�/
ɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɅ�ĦǓ�+
G#2ƪǜȑ��A2�,3/ �- ��-3���F�/ Ɉ…ɉ�(AT, VII, 33)
]Rh^0DH4��ǪG�0�I�ŵ��0�IɄ�G 3�Ǔ�G�0�IɅ�#HE
3#HEǜȑ,�G&�,/��ÅŖ0ǜ¥ǜȑ) +2�ĦǓ�,A�G��#2ȲF
,�]Rh^2�ĦǓ�3�ĢÆƛ�Ɂ�0�nǞ��+ G- �J�,�G�
� ,3��2D�0Ș:GaO]Sm3#A#A�ĢÆƛ�Ɂ�K �0ƒǰ�+ G2
���2ƇKŕƥ0�G%@0���,3�Ȅƒë�Ȇǒ0��Gb[WmhƁ2�ĢÆ
Ĩ�ŮĤ0% �GaO]Sm2ǰǿKƼ¹0Ǫ+���-0�% Ʉ/��ǰǿ3�Ǽ
ȈɄErkennenɅ�0º�+ǥJH+ GɅ�
� ǼȈ3ĢÆƛ,�G��/J'ǼȈ3���9-Æ�EH+ G�,3ǼȈ�Æ�EH
+ Gĕ2A22œ3��-ǰ�HG:�&I�����4Ȇǒx2aO]Sm3ÊFK
ǪÔ��Ę0-(+#H3�ȆǒKǖ + GȅÇ�Ʊ�à�ɃŤ�,�G�-Dz�(GA21,
100)�&��2D�0Ǫ�+ GA2K#2ȚF0Dz�&�,3�ǂŢ�0ȟ�G2,3
/ ��?�I���4�= Ƶn03ȅ�2ǧȊ2>�ĢÆƛ0t�EH+ G2,�
(+�Ę�Ǫ+ G23à/.,3/�n)2�ǧȊ�,�G�-,ADz(%œ�=&�
A�ëȈ�G�ƹ�œ,3/ �����aO]Sm3��Ǫ�+ GA23���0%
�G�2ƭ2Ôƹ���03�ĬȈ¡ò��ĭǭ��ŮĤ�����ŀ�EH+ G(ibid.)�
�3�:+�Ǫ�+ GA20Æ�(+�ƜK)8(+ɀ6��F�#HKǿŕ�G�D
�/A2,�G�-Dz��#H3Ñ 0% �Gƹ�- �DF�#2ǿŕ0-F��G
� 0Ǫ�+ G3 2A2�#2��ǿŕ�2ŪĎ0�G3 2A2�K��Dz��-�
/ �-�0;�/E/ (101)�?�I�ǼȈ33�@�E�êÚǔ#Hǜȑ���JH
JH��ǂŢ�0#�ƹ�G��à�B�Ʊ�#Hǜȑ��9-Æ�EH+ G��żîƛ
/�-3�2Ƶn2�cgd\Nk/ƥǼK�Ù��ľ�nj�G�-/2,�G�(ibid.)�
� -3 ���2�-KÝľ�%��,/E��ǧȊ�2ǽK�(+AsȢ¦,3/ Þȸ
3�G���4aO]Sm�Ȇǒx�®KǪ+ǺK�/�E�ǘĚ2ɃŤKƃ�+�HG
D�ȁ�0ȼL&-�G��2-�Ę3ɃŤK�%&ǧȊ�+ G&��,3�G�(ibid.)�
#H,AĘ3ɃŤ#HǜȑɆɆɆɆɆɆ
9-Æ�(+ GɄĘ3ǜ¥�ĺ + G�ɃŤ2ǧȊ�Kƃ
�+�H/.-ȼL, GJ�,3/ Ʌ�%&�2ÞÄĘ3�ɃŤK�ƣǭɄwarhnehmenɅ�
�+3�E ��Ɠȑ2�F�F-�%é,ɄleibhaftigɅ�ł�+3 / - �&�,�
- 50 -
G(ibid.)� ��G-�Ę3ɃŤ#HǜȑɆɆɆɆɆɆ
9-Æ�(+3 G�����#HK�šţƛ�
03ǼȈ�+ / �- ��-,�G�- �2A��êÚǔ#HǜȑKƓȑ2�F�F
-�%é,ł���ľ�G�-��#�ǼȈ2�G:�é�šţ2é&�E,�G��H
KƑȊë,3�ƝǯɄAnschauungɅ�-Ì8(104-5)�
� Ɲǯ3�Ǔ�BƣȈ�ƙDzBÍȽ/.0�ǸƧɄAusweisungɅ�Kt�G(105)�ïȳ�
JHJH2ƣȈBDzǿ2;-L.3�#2).�E�2�êÚǔ#Hǜȑ�KĦĤ�+3
+A��q,Ǫ%���ǘĚ0�GɃŤ0) +2Dzŕ�E�+#�,�(%D�0�
�#HK�Ɠȑ2�F�F-�%é�,ł�G�-/�0��ưǤɄleerɅ�0ǧȊ�+ G
0ȟ�/ ,�I�� ��G-��JHJH2ƣȈBDzǿ2ã¸3LJü2-�I�)1
0ǸƧKġǩ-�+ G�2,�F�ưǤ0ĦĤ�%êÚǔ�ĦĤ�%ȚF0êÚ�+
G�-K�Ɠȑ2�F�F-�%é,Ɲǯ����ïɄErfüllungɅ�9-A%E��#2�
-0DFǜE�ǸƧ�HG0ǝG�- ��ÛKâ�Hú/�Hĺ�+ G2,�G(ibid.)�
�H3�/J'��ï0ǝG�-�)=F�ưǤ0ǧȊ�H%A2-Ɲǯ�H%A2�n
Ǟ�G�-ɄZur-Deckung-kommenɅ���ÅnµɄIdentifizierungɅ���ưǤ/ǧȊ0-(+
�ĢÆƛ/İūɄintentionale AngelegenheitɅ�K/�+ G�- ��-,�G(107)�
� �nǞ�K�2D�0ǰ�G�-3�ų2D�/�ĠƛȟƬ�0Ü*�nǞ2ƒǰKŃ
�G�-KĬË�+ G��/J'�t�EH%ǧȊ-Ɲǯ�H%{Ȋ-��FÄJ!E
H�7%F-Ȩ/G-#�0�¾Ɵ�2Ɯ�Æ�EH��ǸƧ2Ğǧ�%GnǞ�Ɠ�%�
-��ƥǼ��HG(107)���2ƒǰ0DH4�ưǤ/ǧȊ3�#H&�,3¹/GǧȊ
�q2�A2,A/�� J4#2ǥ�Š0�L�+ƈǵƛ,�F��œ,ǸƧ-3�#
2���E0ǧȊ-Ɲǯ2nǞ2ƥǼA/�H%ÞÄ0��2ǧȊ0��±�EHA�G
A2,�G�- ��-0/G&I��&��H3ŕE�0�dz/īî,�G���4�
aO]Sm�ǜ¥2ǘĚ2ɃŤ2ǧȊKľ)- �ÞÄ�Ę3%&J�AJ�E ɃŤK
ưǤ0ǧȊ��#2ǧȊ-Æ�Ä(+ GJ�,3/ ��,0Ș:%D�0�#2-�
0AĘ3ǘĚ2ɃŤ#HǜȑɆɆɆɆɆɆ
-ĢÆƛ0LJ6) + G2,�F�#2ǸĽ0�Ę3ŁF
Æ�4 ),AƓȑ2�F�F-�%ɃŤ2Ɲǯ�ĜEHG�-Kì�0ƒǰ�+ G,
�I��#�+�2ƒǰ3�ɃŤKưǤ0ǧȊ�G�--ŕE�0n�-/(+ G�
� ��KưǤ0ǧȊ�G�-3�#H&�,A��,0�êÚǔ#HǜȑɆɆɆɆɆɆɆ
9-ĢÆƛ0Æ
� ))�ǜE�.��H4ǸƧ�HG0ǝG�Kƒǰ�+ G�-,A�G�#H3�
êÚǔ2A-,2Ånµ�ǸƧ2ïƑK�ĢÆƛ/İū�-�+ĺ�ȕ>�#H0¸4¿
F��(+�=(+ G�-0Ʒ� �JHJH3�F-�ECGA2KƝǯ�+ GJ
�,3/ ��J�AJ�E ưǤ/ǧȊ-ijH+ GJ�,A/ 2,�G�
aO]Sm2]Rh^ǰȧ0) +
- 51 -
ĢÆƛ/ưǤ/ǧȊ3��ï92�Æ2/��Ånµ�G�-2�'KƓ�+ G
Ɉ…ɉ�ǸƧ3ǚlj/�ȋ�G2,3/�Ʉnicht einfach vor sich gehenɅ�ǸƧ�))�
GưǤ/ǧȊ3�ĢÆƛ,�G�E03�ǜ¥ǜȑ2�-K�)=Fǜ¥�ǜ¥KǸ
Ƨ�GA2,�G�-K�¥�(+ G�Ɉ…ɉ
Ånµ�ǸƧ3�n)2ĢÆƛ/İū,�G�#H3ǜEKȞǥ�G--A0�ǜE
¾Ɵ�G�-/�0�ǜ¥ǜȑ0) +2�GǰŕɄAufklärungɅKA(+ G�(107)
� �q�E�aO]Sm� �/Gƒǰ2A-,]Rh^2�ĦǓ�K�ĢÆƛ�Ɂ�-
Ǫ/�+ %��ŕE�0/(%&I��]Rh^��ƪ3Ǔ�+ G�-�ƪ3Ǔ�+
G-ƪ3Ǔ�+ GɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆ
�K¶«�/ -Dz�-��#�,Ǫ+-EH+ G23�ĢÆĨ
0��qȘ2�ǜ¥ǜȑ0) +2�Gǰŕ���ƪ��KB(+ G��ƪ0-(+ŕ
G�/(+ G�-��&- �J�,�G�ïȳ0aO]Sm�]Rh^2�ĦǓ�K
êÚǔ#HǜȑɆɆɆɆɆɆɆ
9-ĢÆƛ0Æ�EH%A2-ǰ�+ %�-3�ųƺ,Ō@+ƥǼ�G�
���!�����������%,����� �
� ĢÆĨ0) +2ǰǿKǎ@��G� 0aO]Sm3��2�¾Ɵ/�2ǜĂǜȑ0
) +2ǜĂƒǰ��)=Fƪ�ƪ0-(+ŕE@EH�Ǫ�GD�0/(+ G�-K�
�5-�ŕǸɄEvidenzɅ-Ì8A2�-Ǫ/�+D -Ș:+ G(107-8)�Ę3��ȫ�
Ȇǒ,�Ɵó2ǰȧ0-F��G� 0A�]Rh^3�ŕřªŕ/ƣǭɄclara et distincta
perceptioɅ�- ��-,ÅŰ2ǜĂǰŕKĬØ�+ G�-KȘ:�ǰȧ0�%(+3�
2�-K�)10ĤȻ0Ǒ +��ġǩ��G��-KĔȃ�+ G(GA17, 132-3)�
� #2��,�aO]Sm3ƵpƟó�EƵÓƟó0��+2ȉȄKyȽƛ0¿Fq�+
G�Ę3�2ȉȄ2¤ƙƇKĻ��G�-�EǰȧKè@G��,0Ƶ|Ɵó,ƥǼ�
H+ G23��ƪ3�G�ƪ3êÚ�GɄego sum, ego existoɅ�- ��2ÍȽ3Ɉ…ɉ�
ƾƩ0D(+ł�EHG%6�-0�Ɉ#HKł�G�ĦǓ�2êÚ0D(+ɉġƉƛ0Ơ
,�G��- ��-,�G(AT, VII, 25)�ƪ3¹0ĦǓ�+ G&�,3/��ƪ�ĦǓ
�GA2,�G�-�ƪ0ƣEH+A G�- ��œ,ĦǓ�+ G���A#2D�
0�+ƣEHG�ƪ�ĦǓ�GA2,�G�-�K� =B3(�F-�ƪ3ƥƣ�+
GɄcertus sumɅ��#�&-�H4���2ś©2ǼȈ2�'03�ƪ�Ǘî�GA20)
+2�Gŕř,ªŕ/ƣǭK;�0�+3�A/ �2,�G�E���,0�+ƪ3�
�E�2{Ƌ0) +ƪ�ƥƣ�G- ��-2%@03��ǩŻ�HG�KAƣ(+
- 52 -
G2,3/ ���)=F�� =Bƪ03��J@+ŕř�)ªŕ0ƪ�ƣǭ�G-�I
2A22�:+3Ơ,�G- ��-K�nǟƛ/ǫ-�+ƥƲ�G�-�,�G�2
,3/ ���]Rh^3ƵpƟó2¢Ȼ�Ȗ,�2D�0ǓóKȝ@+ G(ibid., 35)�
� &��ƪ2êÚ�ƪ0-(+ƥï,�G�-KƣE!G�2�ŕřªŕ/ƣǭ���n
ǟ0IJG�-Kƪ�ƥƣ�+ G�-2ÜƆ,A�G2�3�)=F#HK�nǟƛǫ
Ʉregula generalisɅ�-�+ƥƲ�+AD 2�3��2ŖƇ,3=&żî�H+ / �
- �2A��A�A�2�œ,�)=Fŕřªŕ/ƣǭKȚ�+ƪ�ĸʼn�GA2���
,�GD�/�-��F�G-�%E�ƪ3�2ÜƆK�ȼ�G�-3,�/ ,�I��
�E,�G(GA17, 133)�aO]Sm�]Rh^K�Đ�+nj�G03��ƪ3ǼȈKÜƦ
*�G%@03�ƪ�ł�GA29-Ɉƪ�ɉĒ�)�EH+ GɄGezogenseinɅ�-
�D�¥�(+ / ɄdunkelɅȜȯKĕ+0�GJ�03 �/ �2,�F��nǟƛ
ǫ3�ǼȈ2ÂǙƛ/NjöƛÜƆ-�+�Ŵĕµ�HGġǩ��G�2,�G(ibid.)�
� aO]Sm0DH4�]Rh^3�2Ŵĕµ��ŕřªŕ0ƣǭ�H%A292Ē�)
�K��E0#HKÜƦ*�GD�/Ȝȯ2�'0Ǒ��NjöƛÜƆ-�+À��H+A
D -¥�GD�0�G�-��K�ų2|)2�-KƧ��-,ŧ%#�-�+ G�
�/J'��ĦǓ�GA23#2êÚ0� +Ʃ0D(+°ț�H+��F�#H, +�Ħ
Ǔ�GA22�'0ïȳqƓ�GǾȇ3Ʃ03Ɩţ��/ ��,�G�(141)�
� aO]Sm3�Ƶp�ƵÓƟó2ȉȄK��HE|)2ȂȽ0¿Fdž>�vȓ-/(+
nǟƛǫKŴĕµ�D�-�GA2-�+¿Fq�+ G��r,3�2ȉȄ0% �
GaO]Sm2ǰȧK#2ǩƇ0Lj(+Ǫ+C��
����%,�����-/&�
� ®ƺ,Ǫ%�-KŁFȗI��aO]Sm3]Rh^2�ĦǓ�K�ĢÆƛ�Ɂ�-ǰ
�GJ�&��#2� Ěǔ3ų2D�/Ȝȯ2A-,ƒǰ�H+ G��/J'�ĢÆ
ƛ,�G-3�â�Hú/�HưǤ/ǧȊKľ'/�E�#2�ï92�Æ2/���E
�2êÚǔ#HǜȑɆɆɆɆɆɆɆ
9-ȯ�*�EH+ G�-,�F��H3 ��H4�ǜ¥�
=�KB(+ +�.�9Æ�J14/E/ 2�Kƒǰ�+ G�- ��-,�G�
� �2Ȝȯ3�E0ų2D�0 ��G�-�,�G��/J'�ĢÆƛ,�G-3�
ǜ¥�ưǤ0ǧȊ�/�E#H9-Æ�(+ G-�I2êÚǔ#HǜȑɆɆɆɆɆɆɆ
K�#2ưǤ/
ǧȊK�ï�!�GD�/ƍî2êÚǔ-�+ɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆ
�ǜE0% �+Ƒ®�!G�-�,�GɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆ
�
- ��-,�G���4��E��@��KɃŤ-�+ǪD�-�+�ɃŤKưǤ0ǧ
Ȋ�/�E�ɃŤ,�G-�I2êÚǔ#Hǜȑ9-ĢÆƛ0Æ���- ��-�#A
aO]Sm2]Rh^ǰȧ0) +
- 53 -
#A,�/ ɆɆɆɆ
ǔɄ,�G��/ ǔ�,3/ Ʌ03�ĕ2êÚǔKɃŤ-�+ɆɆɆɆɆ
ǜE0%
�+Ƒ®�!G�-3,�/ ,�I�Ʉ�2D�/ǔ03ɃŤ3��«2A2-�+
����,�G�¥�E/ A2�-�+¤�JHG�-0/G,�I�Ʌ�
� �+�aO]Sm3�q2D�/ȜȯKĤȻ0Ǒ�/�E�ƵpƟó0��GĦǓ�G
A22ǨțĨ2ǸŕKȀ>ǰ��-�+ G-Ǔ�EHG�#2�-3��2Ǹŕ2ǩK
/�+ G�YVfÎë2nǟƛ/�ƒɄAxiomeɅ�(GA17, 143)2Ȣƕ0% �GĘ2ǰ
ȧ�EǪ+-HGɄšƮ¢Ȼ,�êÚ-ŖȮ,Ȅ�EHGzî,�(%-Ș:%���Ɵ
ó0��G�ĦǓ�GA2�2êÚ92xuêÚȄ2Ȣƕ�-3��2��ƒ�2Ȣƕ
KĿ�A2-Ǔ�EHGɅ��r�-�0�2�-KƥǼ�G�%',Ę2ǰȧKǪ+C��
� = ��2�ƒ2]Rh^0DGîđ3ų2D�/A20/(+ G(cf., AT, VII, 40)�
�/J'�êÚ�GA23�:+�#2�{ȊĨ(3)ɄrealitasɅ��#Hǜȑ-ÅƷ�q,�
GD�/»Õ0D(+�êÚ9-A%E�H%2,/�H4/E/ �#2��,]Rh
^3��2�ƒK�ǯĤ��A(+ G�ǧȊƛ{ȊĨɄrealitas objectivaɅ�0AȢƕ��
śDžƛ0ĦǓ�GA22ɄƩ0DGɅǨțĨKø�¤#�-�+ G�
� �H0% �+aO]Sm3��2Ķnj���ĊƉ-Ʉohne HemmungɅ�(GA17, 146)/
�H+ G�-0Ŏ�+ƘÑKÉ�G�- ��œ,�2ǸŕKƒǰ�D�-�G�/G
;.�ǯĤ2ǧȊƛ{ȊĨA=%�ǧȊ�H+êÚ�+ GA2- �ĬË,2êÚɄSein
im Sinne des VorgestelltseiendenɅ�(145)KA(+�F��%�(+n)2�êÚ�,3�G�
���#A#A�ǜƉƛêÚɄesse naturaleɅ�(ibid.)2ÕŧKǽG�2�ƒK�]Rh^�
Ȑȏ! �ǯĤ�0AȢƕ�+ G�-0% �+3�ƍ«2ƒǰ�ġǩ-/G2,3/
��¹/GĦĤ-A �G�ǯĤ�2êÚ��Ę0� +3ǜƉƛêÚ2Õŧ-Ũ0
ǽG�-�,�G;.0�ðǯƛ�/ȑ¥0�G23� (% .� �J�/2��
� �2ƘÑ0% �GaO]Sm2ƹ�3��r2D�/A2,�G�= �ǧȊƛ{Ȋ
Ĩ-3�ǯĤ2�',ǧȊ�H%{ƋɄres repraesentata in einer ideaɅ�2êÚ,�G�-
�q,Ș:%�-2>ɆɆ0ƢƜ�GȲF(142)��ƒ2Ȣƕ0�%(+�2êÚ2�ðǯĨ�
�ƘÑǬ�H+�G�-0/G,�I������œ,��2ǯĤ�êÚ�+ G�-
��-3�ÅŖ0�#2ǯĤKĺ + Gƪ�êÚ�+ G�- ��-,A�G�#�
+�2ƪ2êÚ2ðǯĨ3�ƪ�ǯĤKĺ + G�-K�ĦǓ��+ Gƪ2êÚ0D
F� ),Aƥ�@G�-�,�G2,�(%��2ĬË,�ǯĤ2êÚ2�'03 J
4�ĦǓ�G�-�2êÚ2ðǯĨ�ǏFȕ=H+ G��]Rh^3ǜƉƛêÚ2»Õ0
) +2�ƒKɈ…ɉǧȊ�H+êÚ�+ GA2- �ĬË,2êÚ9-Ȓƕ�+ G�
Ę0�H�,�G23��ðǯĨ��ǯĤ2ĖƞƛêÚɄens formaleɅ0þ�+ G�E,
- 54 -
�G�(145)Ʉ�2�ĖƞƛêÚ�-3q2�ĦǓ�G�-2êÚ�2�-,�G�]Rh
^ǜȑ��2ǯĤ2êÚ2|ȨĨKĬȈ�+�ǯĤ3�ĦǓ�HGA2�-�+ǧȊƛ{
ȊĨKA)&�,/��#2ƑïƛêÚK/��ĦǓ�G�-�-�+�Ƒïƛ/ �Ė
ƞƛ{ȊĨɄrealitas acutalis sive formalisɅ�(AT, VII, 41)KA)-�+ GɅ�
� #H&�,3/ ���,q,Ș:+� %�-KĦ ¤�% �#�,3���4Ƀ
Ť2�ǯĤ�Ʉ-��,3 ��D�ɅKĺ�/�EɃŤ,�G-�I2êÚǔ9-Æ�
��-�,�Gǔ3�ĕ2êÚǔKɃŤ-�+Ƒ®�!G�-�,�Gǔ,�G�- �
Ȝȯ0) +ƥǼ�%�aO]Sm3�#E��2ȜȯKĤȻ0Ǒ�/�E� =Ǫ%�Ħ
Ǔ�G�-�-�+3ðǯƛ,Ƒïƛ/êÚ,�G�ǯĤ3�#H.�I��Ǫ��!G
�-ɄSehenlassenɅ-�+êÚ�+ GɆɆɆɆɆɆ
�-Ș:+ G(GA17, 145)��ǯĤ2êÚ--A0�
���Ǫ+-EH+ G�-ɄGesichtetseinɅA=%êÚ�+ GɆɆɆɆɆɆ
�2,�F�#2Ǫ+-
EH%A22�Ƒ®Ĩ��ƣǭɆɆ2�¡�0�3�G- �2,�G (ibid.)�
� �q�E�ÑȽ2�ƒ2ǯĤ92Ȣƕ0% �GaO]Sm2ƒǰK�ų2D�0=-
@G�-�,�G&I���/J'�]Rh^0� +ǯĤ-3��E�2{ȊĨKA(
%IJGA2K�#2D�/ƍî2IJGA2-�+Ƒ®�!G�--�+êÚ�+ GɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆ
��
�A�2ǯĤ3�í0Ƃ %ĦĤ2D�/A2,3/��ĕ2ǯĤKĺ��ƪ�2Ƒïƛ
êÚKAÈĬ�+ G- �ĬË,�ðǯƛ�/A2,�G�#HC�]Rh^3��2
ǯĤ2êÚ0ÑȽ2�ƒKȢƕ���2ǯĤ�ǧȊ�Ƒ®�!GA22{ȊĨɄ�ǧȊƛ{
ȊĨ�Ʌ-ÅƷ�q2{ȊĨKA(%»ÕKÑ��-�,�G�#�+#H3LJü�#2ǯ
ĤKĺ��ƪ��#2D�/A2KƑ®�!�Gǔ,�G�KÑ��-�)=F�ƪ�2
êÚ03#H&�2{ȊĨɄqȘ2�Ƒïƛ/ �Ėƞƛ{ȊĨ�Ʌ�È=H+ G�KÑ
��-/2,�G�
� aO]Sm2�2ƒǰ�]Rh^0ģï/A2�.��3ȉȄ2�Û��G&I���
H0!D]Rh^3��ƒ0ě ��ƪǜȑ���Ʃ���Ƌ�ƛ,ȷƓÍƛ/{Ƌ���ä
����³Ƌ���ƪ-ȿ�2�2�Ȯ�2ǯĤ2�'�ƪǜȑ�#2»Õ-/F�/ A2
��G�.��KŬǴ�G- �ƸȠKȎL, G(AT, VII, 42-3)�%&aO]Sm3��
ȱ2ȉȄ03Ʋ'�E ��2�'�Ʃ2Ƒ®Ĩ3ŜȲ/GA2-�+2ƪ0D(+3�ê
Ú���/ �(GA17, 145)�-KƥǼ�G0-.@+ GɄ]Rh^�Ʃ2ŕřªŕ/ǯ
ĤKľ(+ G�-3®Ň,�F�aO]Sm3-�0#2Ƈ2ȉȄ3�+ / Ʌ�
� ,3�ƪ03Ƒ®�!G�-2,�/ 3 2Ʃ2ǯĤK�#H,Aƪ�A(+ G2
3/"/2��q,Ș:%D�0�ǯĤ2ƑïƛêÚK/�+ G23�ĦǓ�G�-2
êÚ�,�F��%�(+#H3�ǯĤ�- ��-0ÈĬ�H+ G�#�+�,0ƥ
aO]Sm2]Rh^ǰȧ0) +
- 55 -
Ǽ�%Ȝȯ0DH4��2�ĦǓ�G�-�3�ưǤ0ǧȊ�G�-���E03�Ƒ®�
!G�-�0Ʒ� ��%�(+�ƪ��Ʃ2ǯĤ�KA(+ G- ��-3�ƪ03
,�/ 3 2�-�Ƒ0,�GD�0/(+ G�-0Ʒ� ��H3/"/2��ƪ
�.�=,Aƪǜȑ0D(+ĵľ�H�Ǎľ�H+ G-Ǔ�GȲF��2�-3ƒǰ�
H�/ �?�I�2�-��ƿĜ�G0ȍG�--/G23�ĦǓ�GA22êÚKɈ…ɉ
°EH+�GA2ɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆ
Ʉens creatumɅ-�+ƒǰ�G-�,�G�(ibid.)�
� �q�ǩƇKLj(+,3�G��]Rh^0DGĦǓ�GA22ǨțĨ2Ǹŕ0% �
GaO]Sm2ǰȧKǪ%�šƺ2ŸF2ȉȄ0ȝA��
����%,�����# &�
� �+�ƪ��°EH+�GA2�,�G�-�ªŕ�% =�]Rh^2ų/GȂȽ3�
ƪ2�'0ïȳqƓ�GǾȇ��Ʃ0Ɩţ�GA2,3/ �-KƧ��-,�G��H
0D(+ŕřªŕ/ƣǭ��nǟƛǫ�-�+ÜƦ*�EHG�--/G��r,3#
2ȉȄ�/�HGƵÓƟó2aO]Sm2ǰȧK�šƮ0-(+ġǩ/ƻ×,Ǫ+C��
� ƪ�Ʃ0D(+°EH%A2,�GȲF��ƪ2�'0Ɠ GA23�:+�#H�êÚ
�+ GȲF�Ơ,�G�3 ,�G(136)�&�#H0A��JE �ƪ3Ű�/ǾȇK
Ə��#HC�ŅŻ�H14/E/ 23�Ʃ0D(+ƪ0t�EH%ǨțƋ-�+2�ì
�ĨɄperfectioɅ�2ïƑKȰñ��ŲŊ�!G�Ʃ0Ɩţ�G2,3/ �E�2æű,
�G�)=F�Ǿȇ- �ƍŷ/êÚ2�'0�(+�#HK�GŲçɄprivatioɅ%E�
@GD�/êÚæű3.�0ê�G2���ÑJH14/E/ 2,�G(309)�
� ��,3nȍɀ60]Rh^2ƹ�KǪ+�=���Ę0DH4�Ųç�Ɠ G23�
#H$H�«0-(+>H4Ųç%F�/ �ƣĨ�-�ĬĢ���} 0�ĩ���G
-�,�G(GA17, 147, 151-2; AT, VII, 56)�DFǻ�� �-�ƣĨ�ĬĢ9-ā�¤�ŕ
řªŕ/ƣǭ0ĬĢ�ÅĬ�/ ȲF�ƪ2ì�Ĩ3ŲŊ�HG�- ��-,�G�
� Ę3�2yēK��G|)2�ǜƖ�ŮĤKŀ��#2nœ0��KǼ@G- ��œ
,Ҥ�G2&��aO]Sm3ǰȧ0�%F��2|)2ǜƖŮĤ2Ɩţ-�+�]R
h^��ƟóKŚ + %ŖŞ0-FJ�ƀƙ0ȉȄ�H%�- �Ʃëq2ÑȽKDŽ
����HKȨǬ�+ G(GA17, 152-3)�#2ÑȽ-3�Īõ-ǜƖ3 �0vƲ�G�
- �A2,�F��Ȯ2ǜƖ2ǫî0�L�+|)2œÆ,ȉȄ�/�H%- ��#
2n)3�MgY^\iYƛ�-Ì4H��H0DH4ǜƖ3�Ĕ¬-żî2sÚ�0�
#ê�G�A�nœ3�MPUY\N`Yƛ�-Ì4H��H3?�I�u�ƛ/{Ũ9
2ȴþƐĮ�Eǰō�H%�śɂÒ92żî�- ��-�ǜƖ0-(+ůıƛ&-�G�
- 56 -
]Rh^3�Ɵó,�3�@®ǔ2�Å��-K�G�-A�/ �-A,�G�-
�ǜƖ�#��ĬĢ2ĖƞƛêÚ�,�G�2D�0Ș:G�(150)�ƝĚ0ų2D�0Ș
:+�Ěǔ2ǜƖ0��KǑ + G��/J'��nœ2�0��4��;.� D D
ǜƖ0#2�Kƪ3ȣĹ�G�2,�F��Ʃ2ĪõA�ǜƉƛ/ǼȈA�ǜƖK�(�+
Ƅú�!G�-3/��?�Ißã�Ĕµ�G�(AT, VII, 57-8)�
� �H0) +aO]Sm3� =Ǫ%ƩëƛǘŘKĔ�-F��Ʃë,Ʃ2Īõ2��-
Ì4HGA2K�]Rh^3ĬĢ9-ƣĨ2����Fȕ?ȯ�0Ȓƕ�+ G�-Ș:�
�2ƣĨ�ĬĢ9-ā�¤��ŕřªŕ/ƣǭ�Īõ2ė¯Kļ(+ G�-�+ G
(GA17, 156-7)��]Rh^0-(+�Ȯ2śɂ2êÚÂǙĨ-3�ŕřªŕ/ƣǭKĬĢK
A(+)�?�-,�G��(157)�#H3aO]Sm�EǪGȲF����%�ǀƽ0Ʃ
ëƛ/ƭȿ2ǘŘ���ǛƩëµ��H��ŕřªŕ/ƣǭK)�>�#2�',Ɠ�G�
-- ��Ȯ2ƍî2ƒĤ-#2ÂǙĨ��Ėı�HG�-0D(+/2,�G(311)�
� -A�H�aO]Sm2ǰȧ0DH4�]Rh^3���%MPUY\N`Yƛ/ǜƖ
ŮĤKǜ¥2A2-�+ G�#�+#H0DFĘ3�Ǿȇ2»ÕKƩ0t�EH%A2
0Ć�G�-/��?�I#HK�2�ǜƖKŴ���ƕ�/ �(GA17, 159; AT, VII, 59)
�-0Ż@�A(+ŕřªŕ/ƣǭKnǟƛǫ-�+ÜƦ*�G�-�,�%2,�G�
���*�����0���������+��� ��
� �+���,�qKƼ¹0ŁFȗF% �®ƺ,Ǫ%ĦǓ�GA22ǨțĨ2Ǹŕ0%
�Gǰȧ,Ⱦǣ,�(%D�0�aO]Sm2]Rh^ǰȧq2œȪ3�]Rh^2�Ħ
Ǔ�KğĎ�+�ĢÆƛ�Ɂ�-�+ł�G�- ��-,�(%�#2¡ï3- �-�
ưǤ0ǧȊ��ǯĤKĺ�/�E�êÚǔ#HǜȑɆɆɆɆɆɆɆ
9-Æ� �#HKǧȊ�H+ %ĕ
2êÚǔ-�+Ƒ®�!G�-�#�+ÅŖ0#2�-0� +�ƪ��KB(+ G2
��ƪ0-(+Ǫ�GD�0/(+ G�-���25-)/�F2Ȝȯ,�G�aO]
Sm3�2œȪ2A-,�Ɵó2ǰȧ0¿Fdž>�ĦǓ�GA22�ǨțĨ�-�ì�
Ĩ�Kų2D�0ƒǰ�+ G�= �ǨțĨ���ƪ03�(�+Ƒ®�!G�-2,
�/ Ʃ2ǯĤK�#H,Aĺ��#2Ƒ®Ĩ9-Æ���-�,�GD�0/(+ G�
#�+�ì�Ĩ���#�/GD�0°EH%�Ȯ2śɂ2êÚÂǙĨK�ŕřªŕ/ƣ
ǭ�Ʃ2Īõ2D�0�Ǹ�G��HKA(+�5-= šƮ2Ɯƛ2n),�(%�ê
Ú-ŖȮ0��G]Rh^ǰȧ2�'�3�@0 (2) -�+Ƨ�%ȄƇ0ǪĕK)�G
- �ȂȽ3ŧ%�H%-�D��
� ,3�]Rh^3�ĦǓ�GA2�K�2D�0ǫî�Gnœ,��ƪ3�G�0�L�
aO]Sm2]Rh^ǰȧ0) +
- 57 -
+3ȄƯ! 0ōǑ�%�- �aO]Sm2ķªɄ(1) -�+Ƨ�%ȄƇɅ3 �0ƒ
ǰ�H�G&I����2ķª��Á�êÚȄ2�Ǩ¬�Ĩ�B�PmXMm�2�Ƒ®
Ĩ�-�+2�êÚ��#�+#HKĸʼn�G� 2�ŖȮ�2űǙ0% �Gƈƒǰ-
(%�-KA��ĦǓ�GA22�ǨțĨ�0-A0Ɨ>ȕ=H%�NJ-�+��Ǭȩ0
�H%A2,�(%�-3�šƮ23�@0ƧÏ�+� %ȚF,�GɄ(3) (4) -�+Ƨ
�%ȄƇɅ���,�HKȄ�¦G�-3sÂǙ&-�+A�šƮ2śĚ0ú/�-Aƶǔ
�ƑŖƇ,Ŝŝ&-Ǔ�Gƒǰ2œÆĨ3Ƨ�+���-0�% �
� = �qȘ2�ĢÆƛ�Ɂ�2ȜȯK =nďǪ+>D��#�03�êÚǔ#Hǜȑ�
- �A2�È=H+ G��2êÚǔ3�#H�ƪ0�E��@t�EH+ /�H4�
��4#HKɃŤ-�+ɆɆɆ
Ƒ®�!G�-�,�/ D�/A2,�G� ��H4��
2êÚǔ3� =&ȳƲ%!EH+3 / A22�#H,A�GĬË,ƪ0D(+ĵľ
�H+�F�ƍî2êÚǔ-�+Ƒ®�!EHG2Kę'À�+ Gĕ2A2,�G�
� ��,žƜ�% 23�1 ƺ,¼Ɗ�%�Ȅƒë�Ȇǒ0� +�ĢÆĨ2³ƛ/ůț
2¡Ȥ,�2D�/|ȨĨKą6+ G�êÚǔ#Hǜȑ�2�Ǒ0��PmXMm��Ǒ
�H+ G- ��-,�G��H3MgY^\iY�ĖǕqëΘăƵ 10Ƴ2ǰȧKǥ
�őǚ,2�-,�G�(vgl., GA21, §13 b, c)���,3#2ǻǃ03Ʋ'�E �aO]
Sm�MgY^\iY2�'0Ȁ>ȕA�-�+ G�PmXMm�Kxũ-�%ĢÆĨ
2ůț�E�šƮ0-(+Ȩǩ/ų2pƇKƥǼ�G0-.@G�
� Ƶn0��2êÚǔ#HǜȑɇPmXMm3�ĢÆĨ2ůț2¡Ȥ0�(+�)10�
,0�DZHGɄθιγεῖνɅ�- ��œ,��ȳƲ%!EH+ / A2ɄUnabgehobenesɅ�-
�+ņȖ�H��E��@ĵľ�H+ G(189)�
� Ƶ|0��2êÚǔ#HǜȑɇPmXMm���Gƍî2êÚǔ-�+ȳƲ%!EHG
-��Ěǔ3®ǔ2�ŰĮɄModusɅ�-�+�®ǔ-2�NJnɄἕν, EinheitɅ�K�ľ�%
�%',ȳƲ%!EHG(190)��H3qȘ2|ȨĨ0ƞĕ�G&I��
� Ƶp0��2êÚǔ#HǜȑɇPmXMm3�#H��Gƍî2êÚǔ-�+ȳƲ%!
EHG-��#H3��ɄWasɅ�,�(%2��- ��œ,�ȡ½ƛ0��ƖţɄHerkunftɅ�
-�+ơā�KÆ�EH3�GA22(179)�q2ŰĮµl|ȨµK��/ �%',�#
H#2A2Kǀƽ0�ƝǭɄνοεῖνɅ��G�-3Öȶ,�G�#HK�Gƍî2êÚǔ-
�+�ĦĤɄδιανοεῖνɅ��G�-3�?�I#HKł�Ŋ/��-0Ʒ� (vgl., 181, 185)�
� �+��q�EƂ�6q�(+�G23�ƪ2ĢÆƛ�Ɂ3�#2ůț2¡Ȥ0�#H
ǜ�Kǀƽ0Ƒ®�!G�-3,�/ �Ʉ�G 3�J@+Öȶ&�Ʌ����=�0#
2�-0D(+�ƪ�#HKƑ®�!G�œɄ�G 3#HKł�Ŋ/��œɅ0âŰĨ
- 58 -
Kt�G��GƅŽɄêÚǔ#HǜȑɇPmXMmɅKĺ�+ G�- ��-,�G�
ǾǰKĥH 0 �4�aO]Sm�]Rh^0% �+ȄƯ2ħFKĿŋ�D�-�+
%23��2D�0ǐFȗ��ƑÚ�Kȭ�âŰ/êÚǔ2Ƒ®Ĩ9-Æ���)10
Œ%/�ƪ3�G�9-ȭ�H%�ƪ�2ÚFD�2�-,�(%-Ǔ�EHGɄ#�+
#H�#��aO]Sm��êÚ-ŖȮ,�ŖȮĨ�-�+¥ť�D�-�+ %ĕ2
A2,�G&I�Ʌ�- �2A�šƮ,Ǫ+�%D�0�]Rh^3�ƪ�2�ĦǓ�G
A2�-�+2ÚFœK��ǨțĨ�-�ì�Ĩ�KȚ�+Ðn2#H9-Ùîµ��#2
�-0DF�n)2ÂǙĨ-�+#2D�/ÚFœ0Aȭ�H+ G��#H03û�/
�ƪ3�G�92ơā�KȬ��+�=(%-ǪG�-�,�G�E,�G�
� �q�šƮ25-= 2LJȄ,�G��Ÿ�H%ȂȽ3â �-�0�šƮ2®¸,�ê
Úǔ#Hǜȑ�-Ì4H+�%A2K�PmXMm�-Ȩ1G03oô/ȄǸ�ġǩ,�
I���=%aO]Smǜȑ2PmXMmŮĤ2ƒǰB�#H-Ę�¥ť�G�ƪ3�G�
2ŖȮĨ-2ȯ�0) +AȎ>ȕL&ȉȄ�ġǩ&I�����šƮ3�ěţ�=FȄ
�EH+�/�(%aO]Sm2]Rh^ǰȧ-#2ÊȔ2ȅÑȽ0) +�ú/�-A
#2ȓȥ2nƴ3Ƨ�Ĝ%-Ǔ�G��HKA(+šƮ35-= Ȭ�G�--�G� . (1) aO]Sm-2ȯȜ,Rj^BMgY^\iYB_mZQ�Ȅ�EHG�-3�(+A�]Rh^�yȽ-�HG�-3ƫ,�G�y/ƤƯ-�+3Marion(1996)- Shockey(2010)��G��HE3¾]Rh^yǒ-Ǫ/�H�'/aO]Sm0?�I]Rh^-2ǮȖĨ�Ǽ@EHG�-KȄ�+ G� (2) �HKyē�+ G23ȁDFA= �O]mj Ⅰ2b[Wmhǜȑ,�G�(cf., Hua, III/1, §§ 35-6)�šƮ2ȯĠ3���%FaO]Sm2�� �/Gƒǰ2A-,�2D�0Ș:+ G�0�G� (3) �2ǽ3ŗȚ�ïÚĨ�-Ƿ�HG���êÚ- �ŮĤ0ȯJGD�/DFČ _eMjY�(ùŦ, 1995, 216ȹ, ž 9)KƎƌ0�+�1927ċáëŞȆǒ�ƑȊë2ŪšÑȽ,aO]Sm� realitas0Ɲņ�++ G SachheitɄ{ȊĨɅKńƕ�%(GA24, 50)� '(�
aO]Sm2�ȵɄGesamtausgabe, Frrankfurt am Main: Vittorio Klstermann, 1975ff.Ʌ�E2Ēƕ3GA�ăŏ�ȹŏKǵ���êÚ-ŖȮɄSein und Zeit, Tübingen: Max Niemeyer, 18 Aufl., 2001.Ʌ�E2Ēƕ3 SZ�ȹŏKǵ��/�aO]Sm2Ånǣ��Enj�+Ēƕ�GÞÄ3�į�0ě ȹŏ2>Kǵ��]Rh^2
ǣ�ɄŒuvres de Descartes, publiées par C. Adam & P. Tannery, Paris: CNRS/Vrin, 1964-1979Ʌ�E2Ēƕ3AT�ăŏ�ȹŏKǵ��b[Wmh2ǣ�ɄHusserliana. Gesammelte Werke, Dordrecht: Den Haag, 1950ff.Ʌ�E2Ēƕ3Hua�ăŏ�ȹŏKǵ��]Rh^2ǣ��E2Ƿ¤3Ů1�]Rh^ǣ�ȵɄƚźƨɅ0ě(+ G� ùŦȠå (1995). �]Rh^Îë2÷Ƭ��ǜƉëlĖǕqëlȠĝȄ, ²ǡŚĴ. Marion, J.-L. (1996). ‘Heidegger and Descartes’, in E. Macann (Ed.), Critical Heidegger (pp. 67-96), New York:
Routledge. Shockey, R. M. (2010). ‘Heidegger’s Descartes and Heidegger’s Cartesianism’, European Journal of Philosophy, 20,
285-311.
~ȦƔŭãëȷć´ȆĄlÎë�