Towards Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings and
Communities:
Integration of Energy Efficiency and Solar
Technologies
Andreas AthienitisScientific Director, NSERC Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings strategic
Research Network (SNEBRN)
Director, Concordia Centre for Zero Energy Building Studies (CZEBS)
NSERC/Hydro Quebec Industrial Chair
Concordia University, Montreal
Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings
strategic Research Network (SNEBRN)
Why Smart Net-zero? Path to Net-zero
• Net-zero annual energy balance: many possible
definitions depending on control volume: House?
Community? Net-zero cost?
• NZEBs are becoming adopted by many countries as a
long term target; ASHRAE vision 2020.
• Objective target for high performance buildings
promotes an integrated approach to energy
efficiency and renewables - path to net-zero.
• Why smart? Because NZEBs must be comfortable
and optimally interact with a smart grid.
2
Solar Community Design Towards Net-zero Energy
� Heating load is not significantly affected by the layout of streets, provided solar access is respected
� Some house shapes (e.g L-shape) are more beneficial in a specific site layout
Electricity generation 85%-110% of the total energy use of the neighborhood
3
Living area Living area
Heig
ht
≈2 times Height
Seasonal thermal storage (e.g. Okotoks)
BIPV Systems
BIPV Systems
District heating
Solar collectors
Design: C. Hachem
Residential energy use in Canada
0
5000
10000
15000
20000
25000
30000
35000
40000
Conventional R2000 Advanced
Houses
En
erg
y C
on
su
mp
tio
n (
kW
h)
Space Cooling
Lighting
Appliances
Water Heating
Space Heating
A net-zero energy house produces from on-site renewables as much energy as it consumes in a year (ZEBA/B definition)
Fact: The annual solar energy incident on a roof of a typical house far
exceeds its total energy consumption
4
Source: NRCan
Commercial/Institutional Buildings
• Electric lighting: transformation in building design that moved towards smaller window areas until the 1950s
• Followed by evolution to air-conditioned “glass towers” with large window areas: more daylight – but higher cooling and heating requirements
• Currently: renewed interest in daylightingand natural/hybrid ventilation
• Need to integrate BIPV/STPV in facades to approach net-zero
5
Major international trends in high performance buildings
• Adoption by engineering societies and developed countries of net-zero energy as a long term goal (ASHRAE Vision 2020)
• Measures to reduce and shift peak electricity demand from buildings, thus reducing the need to build new power plants; integrate with smart grids
• Steps to efficiently integrate new energy technologiessuch as controlled shading devices and solar systems
6
NREL RSF Bottom-up shades STPV BIPV/T
Challenge of fast technological developmente.g. Photovoltaics (PV) declining in price
-
33%
PV price has dropped by ~ 90% from 2000 to 2011!Now feasible to use PV as building façade and roof element on surfaces facing East-South-West (depends on location)
7
Efficiency of commercial PV modules approaching 20%
Source: NRCan
Towards net-zero energyBUILDING
SYSTEMS
CURRENT
BUILDINGS
FUTURE SMART NET-ZERO
ENERGY BUILDINGS
Building
fabric
Passive, not
designed as an
energy system
Optimized for passive design and
integration of active solar systems
Heating &
Cooling
Large oversized
systems
Small systems optimally controlled;
integrate heat pumps with solar,
CHP; Communities: seasonal
storage and district energy
Solar
systems
/renewables
No systematic
integration – an
after thought
Fully integrated: daylighting, solar
thermal, PV+heat pumps, hybrid
solar, geothermal systems, biofuels
Building
operation
Building automation
systems not used
effectively
Predictive control to optimize
comfort and energy performance;
online demand prediction 8
Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings
strategic Research Network (SNEBRN)
Canadian Research in NZEBsFrom SBRN to SNEBRN
• The NSERC Solar Buildings Research Network (SBRN) has performed research and demonstration projects on technologically advanced solar buildings (2005-2011); the first initiative of its kind.
• Main energy & buildings university initiative in Canada; over 100 graduate students were trained, over 400 publications, innovative demonstration projects linked to research projects and four conferences.
• SNEBRN (2011-2016) is a network that continues and expands the work of SBRN with focus on smart NZEBs; about 30 researchers from 15 Canadian Universities, 20 partners, 100 grad students.
• Key approach: objective driven – strategic.
9
10
Construction
Industry, Engineers,
Architects, …
NSERC Smart Net-Zero
Energy Buildings
Strategic Research
Network
11Smart NZEB research and education at
Concordia University, Montreal
� Leader of the SBRN and SNEBRN Networks.
� A leader in building engineering (programs at
BSc, Master’s and PhD levels) in Canada.
� Established Concordia Centre for Zero Energy
Building Studies (CZEBS) – 8 Professors and
nearly 40 HQPs.
� Dept of Building, Civil and Environ. Engineering.
12
JMSB Building-integrated
photovoltaic/thermal (BIPV/T) system
– a world first:
Generates solar electricity, heats fresh
air and is fully integrated with the
building and its energy system
Solar simulator testing BIPV/T Environmental Chamber
Network Vision: to perform the research that will facilitate widespread adoption in key
regions of Canada, by 2030, of optimized Smart NZEB energy design and operation
concepts suited to Canada.
Concordia Centre for Zero Energy Building Studies
Vancouver
Edmonton
Calgary
Toronto
HalifaxMontreal
Ottawa
Some important facts
• Most of Canada is quite sunny,
with cold winters
• Ground temperatures 6-10 °C in
most populated areas (lat 42-53 N)
PV potential map of Canada with location of the 15 SNEBRN Universities
Lat 45 N
Degree-days
4519
Lat 53 N
Degree-days
5212
SNEBRN: 30 researchers from 15 Universities
• Building and energy industry leaders
(from solar, utilities, HVAC sectors)
• Govt labs (NRCan CanmetENERGY)
Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings
strategic Research Network (SNEBRN) 14
Optimal combination of solar and energy efficiency technologies and techniques provides different
pathways to reach net-zeroSolar energy: electricity + daylight + heat
Integrated approach to energy efficiency and passive design
Integrated design & operation
Solar optimization: requires optimal design of building form
Smart NZEB concept
Optimization of buildings for solar collection
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 904
4.5
5
5.5
6
6.5
Slope (degrees)
Dai
ly i
nci
den
t so
lar
rad
iati
on
(k
Wh
/sq
m)
Slopes 40-50 degrees desirable
Aspect ratio higher than 1; around 1.3
Two roof forms for
the same floor
plan
Solar energy on
roof
Important design variables:
Roof slope and aspect ratio L/W
Also window area
Aw
Optimize surfaces Ar and façade Aw simultaneously
Ar
15
Slope (degrees)Slope (degrees)In
cid
ent so
lar
rad
iation k
Wh
/m2
Slope = latitude
Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings
strategic Research Network (SNEBRN)
Electricity demand and generationTypical profile for NZEB (home, electric) on cold clear day
16
NZEBs need to be designed based on anticipated operation so as to have a largely predictable impact on the grid; reduce and shift peak loads
Ontario has a summer
(due to cooling) peak
demand
27 GWe
Quebec has a winter
peak demand
38 GWe on Jan. 24,
2011 7:30 am with
To = -33 C in Montreal
Peak heating demand can be reduced
through predictive control
Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings
strategic Research Network (SNEBRN)
Building Integration of PV
• Into roofs or facades, with energy system of
building.
• Roofs need to shed water: think of PV
panels doing some of the functions of roof
shingles; shingles overlap hiding nails.
• Functional integration, architectural and
aesthetic; recover heat, and transmit
daylight in semitransparent PV.
PV overhangs
Queen’s University
(retrofit)
Not just adding solar technologies on buildingsAthienitis house
Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings
strategic Research Network (SNEBRN)
EcoTerraTM EQuilibriumTM House (Alouette Homes)
Transformative SBRN work; IEA SHC Task 40 / ECBCS Annex 52 case study
2.84 kW
Building-
integrated
photovoltaic-
thermal
system
Passive solar
design:
Optimized
triple glazed
windows and
mass
Ground-
source heat
pump
NRCan, CMHC
Hydro Quebec
Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings
strategic Research Network (SNEBRN)
BIPV – integration in EcoTerra
• Building integration: integration with the roof (envelope) and with HVAC
• BIPV/T – (photovoltaic/thermal systems): heat recovered from the PV panels, raising overall solar energy utilization efficiency
• Heat recovery may be open loop with outdoor air or closed loop with a circulating liquid; possibly use a heat pump
• Open loop air system used because it can work for a long time with little maintenance and no problems
EcoTerraTM
Open loop air BIPV/T
19
Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings
strategic Research Network (SNEBRN)
BIPV/T roof construction in Maisons Alouettes factory as
one system
Warm/hot air
flow from
BIPV/T
Sun
Air intakes
in soffit
Building
integrated PV arrays
Air cavity
Graduate students and researchers involved in design and
monitoring; linked to Theme 1 projects
Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings
strategic Research Network (SNEBRN)
Assembly of House Modules (in about 4-5 hours)Prefabricated homes can reduce cost of BIPV through integration
House now occupied: feedback from owners on operation/comfort
Owners presented at CMHC workshop along with SBRN
Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings
strategic Research Network (SNEBRN)
BIPV/T roof in 5 sections for analysis - Energy model
INSULATEDDUCTBRINGS HOT AIRFROM ROOF
PHOTOVOLTAIC
PANELS
section 1
section 54
3
2
0 2 4 60
8
16
24
32
40
Distance along flow path (m)
Tem
per
ature
(C
)
An open loop air system is utilized for the BIPV/T system as opposed to a
closed loop to avoid overheating the photovoltaic panels.
Outdoor air
Solar-heated air
Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings
strategic Research Network (SNEBRN)
EcoTerra: Ventilated Concrete Slab (VCS) – store heat from
BIPV/T (also can be used for night cooling)
Full scale prototype and numerical model developed
115
89
76
64
38
Normal Density Plain Concrete
Steel Deck (Canam P-2436, galvanized steel)Ventilation Channel (cavity)
Metal Mesh (e > 5mm)Rigid Insulation
Water/vapor Barrier
Gravel (earth)
Unit in mm
Th
_cn
c
• Construction
Concrete
Air from
BIPV/T
Active and passive thermal storage to reduce peak electricity demand
Insulation
Passive design and integration with active systems
Near net-zero house; a higher efficiency PV system covering same area would result in net-zero.
Study of occupancy factors indicated importance of controls.
IEA Task 40 case study
Geothermal
heat pump
EcoTerra energy system 24
Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings
strategic Research Network (SNEBRN)
• Solar house with close to net-zero energy consumption: about 10000 kWh/yr (of which 3000 kWh is due to occupant additions); i.e. 7000 kWh based on design.
• Emphasis on integration and lowering of cost through prefabrication.
Family room
To get to net zero
1. Use of a more efficient BIPV system
(with PV efficiency = 15 %).
2. Better integration to utilize collected heat.
3. Replacement of garage electric heater
with heat from BIPV/T system.
Lessons learned
Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings
strategic Research Network (SNEBRN)
JMSB BIPV/T Solar Facade:
A NSERC Solar Buildings Research Network
Demonstration Project
Funded by NRCan TEAM Program
through CanmetENERGY Varennes
Brendan O’Neill – research engineer,
Josef Ayoub - NRCan
Back façade
of new building
(JMSB- Concordia)
Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings
strategic Research Network (SNEBRN)
Building Integration of PV – with HVAC and envelope: BIPV/T
• From one building surface with an area of about 288 m2 generate both solar electricity (up to 25 kilowatts) and solar heat (over 75 kW of ventilation fresh air heating);
• Total peak efficiency over 55%;
• The system forms the exterior wall layer of the building i.e. it is NOT an add-on.
• Mechanical room is directly behind the BIPV/T façade.
Mechanical room
BIPV/T
Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings
strategic Research Network (SNEBRN)
25 kWe
Up to
15000 cfm
fresh air =
over 75 kW heat
Partners: Concordia University, Conserval, Day4 Energy, NRCan,
Schneider Electric (Xantrex)
Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings
strategic Research Network (SNEBRN)
Air flow paths in BIPV/T system
Special design to promote heated air
behind PV to flow into transpired collector
PVAir flow
Clamp
25 kW electricity
Solar heating of up to 15000 cfm
of fresh air
Control of airflow will be optimized
- Variable speed fan
Transpired
Collector
cladding
Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings
strategic Research Network (SNEBRN)
Just 288 sq.m. was covered.
Imagine possible generation
with 3000 sq.m. BIPV/T
Note snow melting from BIPV/T roof
Integration
Passive air circulation in BIPV/T melts snow in winter.
40 degrees slope
Normal roof collects snow
Athienitis house, Domus award finalist
Note difference in south facing
window areas
Private
project
Integration – BIPV/T (1.9 kWe)
Passive solar – superior comfort
Geothermal system (2-ton)
Efficient controls
Passive solar design + BIPV/T + Geothermal + efficient 2-zone controls
Mass
Athienitis House
Domus award finalist
Modelling, Design, and Optimisation ofNet-Zero Energy Buildings (Pub. Wiley & Sons); edited by Athienitis & O’Brien
Authors:
Andreas Athienitis
Shady Attia
Josef Ayoub
Paul Bourdoukan
Scott Bucking
Salvatore Carlucci
José Candanedo
Maurizio Cellura
Yuxiang Chen
Véronique Delisle
François Garde
Francesco Guarino
Mohamed Hamdy
Ala Hasan
Konstantinos Kapsis
Aurélie Lenoir
Davide Nardi Cesarini
William O’Brien
Lorenzo Pagliano
Jaume Salom
Joakim Widén
Samson Yip
verify .
IEA SHC Task 40/ECBCS Annex 52: Towards Solar NZEBs - 5 year Task (2008-2013)
Book from Subtask B:
EcoTerra archetype redesign
34
-12000
-10000
-8000
-6000
-4000
-2000
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
12000
14000
Base C
ase
(a
s b
uilt
)
Re
moved
air c
lean
er
an
dre
du
ce
d fa
n u
se
Re
move D
ivid
ers
Sha
din
g C
on
tro
l
Basem
ent a
nd W
all
insu
lation
Add
ed
PV
Ele
ctr
icit
y U
se
(kW
h/y
ear)
Controls
Equipment
HRV/Air Cleaner
DHW
Heat Pump: Cooling
Heat Pump: Heating
Lighting, appliances, andplug loads
PV generation
Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings
strategic Research Network (SNEBRN)
Modeling, design and optimization of NZEBS
What is the appropriate model resolution for each stage of the design?
What is the role of simple tools versus more advanced detailed simulation?
What other tool capabilities are needed to model technologies such as building fabric-integrated storage (PCMs), BIPV/T + heat pumps?
IEA SHC Task 40 / ECBCS Annex 52 Subtask B
RSF archetype - alternative design investigation
Fixed louvers versus motorized (between glass)
36
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 900.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
Profile angle (Degree)
Tra
nsm
itta
nce
(Peng 2009)
Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings
strategic Research Network (SNEBRN)
Solar Neighborhood Design: optimizing solar potential
•Develop optimal energy design of solar homes with BIPV, BIPV/T, solar thermal, and/or combinations of technologies
•Consider different building forms and layouts, and street planning
•Consider community peak energy generation and peak demand
Renewable Energy Systems for Solar Communities
•Explore optimal community energy system options suitable for Canada through the development of modeling and optimization tools to maximize use of solar energy
•Consider energy generation and demand diversity of NZEBs in solar community energy planning systems
Solar Community Design and Density Effects
•Identify density effects on solar community design; Consider clusters of six or more heterogeneous mix of solar buildings arrangements using conventional, new urbanism, fused-grid etc.
•Consider building shapes and sizes, and spaces between buildings to examine the impacts on neighbourhood energy demand and generation
37
Example SNEBRN project: Design of New Solar Communities
Work under project 5.2a• Solar community concepts with non-rectangular or rectangular
house shapes and designs that may be employed with
appropriate BIPV/roof designs while also allowing for optimal
design passive solar gains.
• These designs also affect significantly the peak generation of
electricity and the peak demand.
• Can shift and reduce the peak of electricity supplied to the
grid, while also reducing the peak demand from the grid as well.
(c)
(a)
U2
U1
U5
U4
U3U2
U1
U5
U4
U3
U2
U1U5
U4
U3
U2
U1
U5
U4
U3U2
U1
U5
U4
U3U2
U1U5
U4
U3
(b)
U3U2U1 U1 U3U2 U1 U3U2
Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings
strategic Research Network (SNEBRN)
Road layout
Neighbourhood Design
� The average heating load is
not significantly affected by
the layout of streets.
� If energy use / energy
production is considered,
some configurations are more
beneficial in a specific site
layout.
Site I
Site II
Site III
Ratio of energy generation to energy use for all the neighborhood
Site Site I Site Site II Site III
Density
shape
Detached Attached Density
shape
Detached Attached Detached Attached
Rectangle 0.65 0.66 rectangle 0.62 0.58 0.63 0.70
L shape 0.74 0.75 L Variants 0.81 0.81 0.85 0.82
L variants 0.79 0.79 Obtuse 0.74 0.73 0.75 0.85
C. Hachem
Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings
strategic Research Network (SNEBRN)
Development and Optimization of BIPV/T systems:Solar simulator & Environmental Chamber (Concordia)
40
Concordia solar simulator
testing BIPV/T system
similar to EcoTerra
BIPV/T prototype (JMSB)
tested in vertical position;
JMSB BIPV/T: Peak efficiencies
(thermal + electric) of 55% +
Accurate model
development for
innovative systems
that was not
possible with
outdoor testing
2-storey high
environmental chamber
with solar simulator
Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings
strategic Research Network (SNEBRN)
Typical configuration of test in environmental chamber of SSEC facility with test façade and thermal storage
Test-room
Thermal storage
e.g. PCM panels
or VCSTest
facade
Environmental
chamber: -40 to 50 C
Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings
strategic Research Network (SNEBRN)
RETROFITS
• Renovation of existing buildings
provides the opportunity to
cover facades with cladding that
heats ventilation fresh air and
generates solar electricity,
42
JMSB BIPV/T
Peak eff. 55%
SIQ building (Montreal) considered for
possible BIPV/T retrofit 42Background
Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings
strategic Research Network (SNEBRN)
Concordia Engineering Building (hybrid ventilation schematic -original concept)
High mass building;
studied in 2 PhD and 1
MASc theses
MPC potential is
significant for night
cooling to reduce peak
demand.
Install variable speed
fan.
Fan
43
Atrium 1
Five 3-storey atria – solar chimney
Air inlet grilles
On two sides
Atrium 5
Atrium 1
Varennes NZEB Library final design (Montreal)
South elevation
SNEBRN provided advice: choice and integration of
technologies and early design building form
Design required several iterations - e.g. final choice of BIPV
system required minor changes in roof design for full
coverage; note also skylights that allow deep penetration
of daylight. Roof slope close to 40 degrees.
Design charettes organized by NRCan
2000 sq.m. NZEB
Smart Net-zero Energy Buildings
strategic Research Network (SNEBRN)
Solar source heat pump connected to BIPV/T
• The BIPV/T system can be used as the source of a heat
pump to heat a water tank.
• Can utilize excess electricity and heat to charge
chilled/hot storage for later use: REDUCE PEAK EXPORT
OF ELECTRICITY.
45
The path towards Smart NZEBs and Communities – an opportunity for innovation
• Buildings undergoing a transformation to reach net-zero
• Opportunity for leadership – construction is engine of economic growth, high quality of life
• NZEBs will lead to many novel products, exports, jobs
• Challenges:
– fragmentation of building industry
– transformative changes to building design and operation
– ambitious R&D programs: from basic research to full scale demos with a research component
– incentive measures with multiple benefits such as production of renewable energy at times of peak demand
– training of engineers and architects
46