+ All Categories
Home > Documents > TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS...

TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS...

Date post: 22-Feb-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 8 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
34
TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE Senior Principal Engineer September 9 – 11, 2015 Reno, Nevada
Transcript
Page 1: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH

RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENTZia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE

Senior Principal Engineer

September 9 – 11, 2015Reno, Nevada

Page 2: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

Acknowledgments

Xing Zheng, CaltransAnoosh Shamsabadi, CaltransJames Gingery, KleinfelderJohn Liao, Kleinfelder

Page 3: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

Smith River (Dr. Fine) Bridge Replacement

IntroductionSeismic Setting and Field InvestigationSeismic Hazard AnalysisTime HistoriesSite Response Analysis

1D2D

Results

Page 4: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

Smith River (Dr. Fine) Bridge Replacement

Located in Del Norte County1,000 feet long existing bridge with 2 abutments and 17 piersReplaced with 1,000 feet long 4-span box girder continuous deck bridgeDeck will be isolated by triple frictional pendulum (TFP) bearing

Page 5: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment
Page 6: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

Existing Bridge

Page 7: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

Rendering of the New Bridge

Page 8: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

Boring LocationsNew BoringsOld Borings

Page 9: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

T

Profile

Page 10: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

T

Profile

Page 11: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

Structural Model

Page 12: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

T

Fault and Seismicity Map

Page 13: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

T

Cascadia Subduction Zone

Site

Page 14: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

T

Pacific Northwest Seismicity

Page 15: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

T

Seismicity Sources

Page 16: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

T

Seismic Sources

Primarily seismic source is the Cascadia Subduction Zone (CSZ), with rupture distance of about 35 kmAdditional local shallow crustal faults

Big Lagoon – Bald Mountain fault, rupture distance of about 15 kmTrinidad fault, about 45 km

Page 17: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

T

Seismic Hazards

Use USGS seismic source modelPerform probabilistic seismic hazard analysis for 5% probability of exceedance in 50 years (return period of 975 years)Develop rock outcrop horizontal and vertical spectraSince CSZ controls, near-source and directivity effects were not needed

Page 18: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

T

Outcrop Spectra

Page 19: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

T

Time Histories

Seven sets (each set having two orthogonal horizontal motions) of time historiesTime histories were selected from historical records based on spectral shape, frequency content, source mechanism, and site conditionsEarthquakes from Japan, Chile, and Taiwan up to 300-sec long were selectedSpectrally matched to outcrop horizontal spectrum

Page 20: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

T

Spectrally Matched Time History

Page 21: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

T

Spectrally Matched Time History

Page 22: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

T

Original Time Histories

Page 23: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

T

Spectrally Matched Time Histories

Page 24: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

T

Shear Wave Velocity

Page 25: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

T

Site Response AnalysisSeven sets (14) of time histories1D analysis in transverse direction using DEEPSOIL at each abutment and bent location2D analysis in longitudinal direction using QUAD4MFree-field response at the surface at each abutment and bent location

Page 26: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

T

2D Model

1 Qal2 Grav el Elev +20 to 0 2 Qal2 Grav el Elev 0 to -20 3 Qal2 Grav el Elev -20 to -40 4 Qal2 Grav el Elev -40 to -65 5 Qal1 Elev +40 to +20 6 Qal1 Elev +20 to 0 7 af Elev . +65 to +40 8 af Elev . <= +40 9 Br Rock Elev . +40 to +20 10 Br Rock Elev . +20 to 0 11 Br Rock Elev . 0 to -20 12 Br Rock Elev . -20 to -40 13 Br Rock Elev . -40 to -80 14 Br Rock Elev . -80 to -120

Station (feet)29,250 29,350 29,450 29,550 29,650 29,750 29,850 29,950 30,050 30,150 30,250 30,350 30,450 30,550 30,650 30,750 30,850 30,950 31,050

-160-140-120-100-80-60-40-20020406080100120140160180200220240

Elev

atio

n M

SL (f

eet)

-160-140-120-100-80-60-40-20

020406080

100120140160180200220240

Page 27: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

T

Verification – QUAD4M and DEEPSOIL Comparison in Transverse

Page 28: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

T

Results – Surface Spectra

Page 29: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

T

Results – Surface Spectra

Page 30: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

T

Results – Surface Spectra

Page 31: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

Results – Surface Spectra

Page 32: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

Results – Surface Spectra

Page 33: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

T

QUAD4M and DEEPSOIL Comparison in Longitudinal

Page 34: TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS …...TWO-DIMENSIONAL SEISMIC SITE RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR SMITH RIVER BRIDGE REPLACEMENT Zia Zafir, PhD, PE, GE ... DEEPSOIL at each abutment

T

Questions?


Recommended