7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

1/44

R@G^ BLNG^GJO OJRGNL @I^ FLLO VLCLVVLB RJ R@L \TTLV RVGF\OIA GO

JVBLV RJ BLRLVEGOL R@L ITTVJTVGIRL INRGJO CJV R@L CNI RJ RIKL

ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ

BLNG^GJO OJRGNL

ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ

Rj= Rirgq Nirrgemll Rj= ^jelrslt Isslt Eioihlelot AAT

C^I Vlc/

Oueflr= RPN4999>

C^I Vlc/

Oueflr= 220809

Ibbrlss= 79%7> Fiklr ^trllt

Ajobjo

X9\ 3YY

Ibbrlss= 79%7> Fiklr ^trllt

Ajobjo

X9\ 3YY

Bitl= 63 Eirn` 649>

INRGJO

9/ Cjr t`l rlisjos hgvlo go t`gs Blngsgjo Ojtgnl! t`l C^I `is blngblb tj=i' wgt`briw Er Nirrgemlls gobgvgbuia ipprjvias! pursuiot tj slntgjo 3> jc t`l Int;

f' eikl io jrblr pursuiot tj slntgjo

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

2/44

6

VLI^JO^ CJV R@L INRGJO

6/ R`l C^I `is blngblb tj tikl t`gs intgjo flniusl gt `is cjuob t`it Er Nirrgemll cigalbtj int wgt` gotlhrgty go frlin` jc ^titlelot jc Trgongpal 9 w`lo `l rlnkalssay issgstlb

`gs naglot! Er Viels`kueir Hjloki! go Er Hjlokis paio tj eiogpuaitl t`l najsgoh

prgnl jc Hizprje HBVs go Iprga 6494 iob Vlagionl HBVs go Jntjflr 6494/ Go eikgoh

t`gs cgobgoh! t`l C^I njosgblrs t`it Er Nirrgemll susplntlb t`it eirklt eiogpuaitgjo

wis t`l hjia jc `gs naglot iob Er Nirrgemll susplntlb t`it Er Hjloki `lab strunturlb

prjbunts w`gn` wlrl rlaitlb tj t`l gotloblb eiogpuaitgjo! ylt `l turolb i fagob lyl tj

t`l rgsk jc Er Hjlokis paioolb eirklt ifusl iob rlnkalssay issgstlb `gs naglot go `gs

ittlept tj in`glvl t`it hjia/

>/ Er Nirrgemll gotrjbunlb Er Hjloki tj F! cjr t`l splngcgn purpjsl jc tribgoh go t`lNajsgoh Iuntgjo cjr Hizprje HBVs iob Vlagionl HBVs/ @l eibl t`it gotrjbuntgjo!

pirtgngpitlb go bgsnussgjos ifjut tribgoh iob issgstlb wgt` t`l irriohlelots cjr tribgohblspgtl susplntgoh t`it t`l jfmlntgvl jc Er Hjlokis paio wis tj slnurl t`l prgnl jc

Hizprje HBVs iob Vlagionl HBVs it i ciasl jr irtgcgngia alvla/

2/ Er Hjlokis paio tj eiogpuaitl Hizprje HBVs wis ifiobjolb it i aitl stihl bul tjlvlots flyjob Er Hjlokis njotrja/ @jwlvlr! jo 90 Jntjflr 6494! Er Hjloki

t`rjuh` F' lcclntlb jrblrs tj tribl w`gn` irtgcgngiaay gocaitlb t`l najsgoh prgnl jc

Vlagionl HBVs jo t`it biy/ Fy gonrlisgoh t`l najsgoh prgnl! Er Hjloki wis ifal tj

ivjgb i ajss jc \^B >!94>!324 uoblr t`l tlres jc t`l strunturlb prjbunt `l `lab/

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

3/44

>

8/ R`l C^I njosgblrs t`it! is i njoslqulonl jc `gs njobunt! Er Nirrgemll cigalb tj intwgt` gotlhrgty go frlin` jc ^titlelot jc Trgongpal 9 w`gast intgoh go `gs nipingty is io

ipprjvlb plrsjo iob gs ojt cgt iob prjplr/ R`l C^I `is t`lrlcjrl blngblb tj wgt`briw

Er Nirrgemlls gobgvgbuia ipprjvias iob tj eikl i prj`gfgtgjo jrblr ihigost ge/ R`l

C^I `is iasj blngblb tj gepjsl jo `ge i cgoiongia ploiaty jc 07!442 uoblr slntgjo 33jc t`l Int/

0/ R`l C^I njosgblrs t`it Er Nirrgemlls egsnjobunt wis pirtgnuairay slrgjus iob `istiklo innjuot jc t`l cjaajwgoh eittlrs go njegoh tj t`gs vglw=

i' Er Nirrgemlls njobunt wis rlnkalss/ Er Nirrgemll susplntlb t`it Er Hjloki`ib io uatlrgjr ejtgvl cjr `gs tribgoh iob wiotlb tj eiogpuaitl t`l prgnl jc

Hizprje HBVs iob Vlagionl HBVs/ Blspgtl t`it `l turolb i fagob lyl tj t`l

rgsk jc Er Hjlokis paioolb eirklt ifusl/ Er Nirrgemll cigalb tj tikl ioy stlps

tj rlpjrt jr prlvlot t`l eirklt ifusl iob n`jsl gostlib rlnkalssay tj issgst ErHjloki tj gepalelot `gs paio tj nrlitl io irtgcgngia prgnl cjr fjt` Hizprje

HBVs iob Vlagionl HBVs/ @l t`lrlcjrl cigalb tj int wgt` gotlhrgty;

f' Er Nirrgemll wis i slogjr iob vlry lxplrglonlb ipprjvlb plrsjo/ It t`l tgel jct`l intgvgty blsnrgflb go t`gs Blngsgjo Ojtgnl! Er Nirrgemll wis ipprjvlb tj

plrcjre t`l N`glc lxlnutgvl NC>'! Tirtolr NC2'! Njepagionl jvlrsgh`t NC94'

iob Ejoly Aiuoblrgoh Vlpjrtgoh NC99' sghogcgniot gocaulonl cuontgjos jo

fl`iac jc ^jelrslt;

n' Er Nirrgemll put Er Hjloki go tjun` wgt` F iob issgstlb Er Hjloki tj put gopainl irriohlelots tj loifal `ge tj slnurl t`l najsgoh prgnl jc Hizprje HBVs

iob Vlagionl HBVs it i ciasl jr irtgcgngia alvla t`lrlfy loifagoh eirklt ifusl tj

tikl painl;

b' Er Nirrgemlls intgjos! go issgstgoh Er Hjloki! rlsuatlb go i slrgjus bgsruptgjojc t`l eirklt jo 90 Jntjflr 6494 fy irtgcgngiaay gonrlisgoh t`l prgnl jc Vlagionl

HBVs/ R`gs pjslb i t`rlit tj t`l jrblragolss jc iob njocgblonl go t`it eirklt/ Gt

curt`lr alb tj i sghogcgniot ajss jc ipprjxgeitlay \^B >/9 egaagjo' cjr t`l fiok

t`it wis t`l njuotlrpirty tj Er Hjlokis strunturlb prjbunt;

l' Er Nirrgemlls intgjos wlrl rlplitlb! go t`it `l issgstlb Er Hjloki go lcclntgoh`gs paio tj eiogpuaitl t`l najsgoh prgnl cjr Hizprje HBVs go Iprga 6494 iob

wis iasj govjavlb go t`l prlagegoiry stihls jc Er Hjlokis paio tj eiogpuaitl

t`l najsgoh prgnl cjr Vlagionl HBVs go Jntjflr 6494; iob

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

4/44

2

c' Er Nirrgemll flolcgttlb crje `gs njobunt t`rjuh` t`l rltlotgjo jc Er Hjlokisfusgolss cjr `gs cgre/

BLCGOGRGJO^

7/ R`l cjaajwgoh blcgogtgjos irl uslb go t`gs Blngsgjo Ojtgnl=t`l Int elios t`l Cgoiongia ^lrvgnls iob Eirklts Int 6444/

ITLV elios t`l ^titlelots jc Trgongpal iob Njbl jc Trintgnl

cjr Ipprjvlb Tlrsjos gssulb uoblr slntgjo 329' jc t`l

Int/

F elios i Ajobjo%fislb frjklr! gotrjbunlb tj Er Hjloki

fy Er Nirrgemll/

Er Nirrgemll elios Er Rirgq Nirrgemll/

Najsgoh Iuntgjo elios t`l najsgoh iuntgjo jc t`l A^L/ R`gs gs i agegtlb%

plrgjb iuntgjo w`gn` tikls painl it t`l najsl jc t`l eigo

tribgoh slssgjo/ R`l rlsuats jc t`l najsgoh iuntgjo

bltlregol t`l najsgoh prgnl jc agstlb slnurgtgls/

LH elios t`l Locjrnlelot Hugbl/

t`l C^I elios t`l Cgoiongia ^lrvgnls Iut`jrgty/

Hizprje elios t`l Vussgio his njohajelritl Hizprje/

HBVs elios Hajfia Blpjsgtjry Vlnlgpts/ R`lsl irl pirnlas jc

s`irls go i pirtgnuair njepioy! w gn` irl agstlb iob triblb

jo gotlroitgjoia lxn`iohls slpiritlay crje t`l njepioys

s`irls/ Jol HBV gs lqugvialot tj i euatgpal jc t`l

uoblraygoh slnurgty/

Er Hjloki elios Er Viels`kueir ^ityioiriyio Hjloki/

GJF elios t`l Gotlroitgjoia Jrblr Fjjk jc t`l Ajobjo ^tjnk

Lxn`iohl/

t`l G\T elios t`l Gobgnitgvl \onrjssgoh Trgnl/

t`l G\S elios t`l Gobgnitgvl \onrjssgoh Sjauel/

A^L elios t`l Ajobjo tjnk Lxn`iohl/

Vlagionl elios Vlagionl Gobustrgls Agegtlb/

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

5/44

W \^B T`jlogx Taus Xjrst jcHizprje*Aukjga* ^urhut gssulb jo >4 Iprga 6448 w`gn`

`ib i eiturgty bitl jc >4 Iprga 6494/

^trunturlb Trjbunt 6 elios io Igrfih Alvlrihlb Aihhirb Ojtl jo Gobgio

IBV Trgvitl Tainlelot gssulb jo 98 Jntjflr 6448

w`gn` `ib i eiturgty bitl jc 90 Jntjflr 6494/

t`l ^trunturlb Trjbunts elios ^trunturlb Trjbunt 9 iob ^trunturlb Trjbunt 6/

\pplr Rrgfuoia elios t`l \pplr Rrgfuoia Rix iob N`ionlry N`ieflr'/

VLALSIOR RIR\RJVW IOB VLH\AIRJVW TVJSG^GJO^

94/ R`l stitutjry iob rlhuaitjry prjvgsgjos rlalviot tj t`gs Blngsgjo Ojtgnl irl njotigolb got`l Ioolx/

CINR^ IOB EIRRLV^

Er Nirrgemll

99/ Er Nirrgemll gs io lxplrglonlb govlstelot ibvgslr iob t`l slogjr pirtolr it ^jelrslt! icgre `l stirtlb/ ^jelrslts prgeiry fusgolss gs t`l prjvgsgjo jc wliat` eioihlelotibvgnl/ Er Nirrgemll `is i sufstiotgia cgoiongia gotlrlst go t`l fusgolss jc jelrslt/

96/ It t`l tgel jc t`l intgvgty blsnrgflb go t`gs Blngsgjo Ojtgnl! Er Nirrgemll wisipprjvlb tj plrcjre t`l N`glc Lxlnutgvl NC>'! Tirtolr NC2'! Njepagionl Jvlrsgh`t

NC94' iob Ejoly aiuoblrgoh rlpjrtgoh NC99' sghogcgniot gocaulonl cuontgjos jo

fl`iac jc ^jelrslt/ @l gs iasj ipprjvlb tj plrcjre t`l Nustjelr NC>4' cuontgjo jo

fl`iac jc ^jelrslt/ @l `is `lab t`jsl cuontgjos sgonl Eiy 6443 sgonl Ojvleflr

6448 cjr NC>4'/ @l prlvgjusay `lab t`l Govlstelot ibvgslr NC69' cuontgjo/

9>/ Er Nirrgemll `ib rlnlgvlb trigogoh go rlaitgjo tj t`l eirklt ifusl rlhgel iob wisrlspjosgfal cjr t`l jvlrsgh`t jc njepagionl prjnlburls it ^jelrslt/

92/ Er Nirrgemll `ib kojwo F cjr ipprjxgeitlay 94 ylirs it t`l tgel jc t`l intgvgtyblsnrgflb go t`gs Blngsgjo Ojtgnl/

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

6/44

3

Er Hjloki

9

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

7/44

8

f' Vlagionl HBVs cjr ^trunturlb Trjbunt 6/R`l Najsgoh Iuntgjo

6>/ R`l gogtgia p`isl jc t`l Najsgoh Iuntgjo! stirtgoh it 94 HER! aists cjr tlo egoutlsiob gs kojwo is t`l iuntgjo niaa p`isl/ Burgoh t`gs p`isl! eleflr cgres painl jrblrst`it irl rlnjrblb fy t`l lxn`iohl fut bj ojt geelbgitlay rlsuat go i tribl/ Lin` tgel

io jrblr gs lotlrlb! blaltlb jr ieloblb! t`l t`ljrltgnia prgnl iob t`ljrltgnia vjauel

t`it wgaa rlsuat crje t`l najsgoh iuntgjo gs rl%nianuaitlb/

62/ R`l t`ljrltgnia prgnl iob vjauel! kojwo is t`l G\T iob t`l G\S irl vgsgfal tj t`leleflr cgres/

6

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

8/44

0

F jc Er Hjlokis wliat` iob ifgagty tj triosint airhl tribls/ Er Nirrgemll iasj issurlb

F jc Er Hjlokis `jolsty/

60/ Aitlr t`it biy i njoclrlonl niaa tjjk painl burgoh w`gn` Er Nirrgemll gotrjbunlb ErHjloki tj F/ Er Hjlokis jplogoh njeelot wis G must wiot tj uoblrstiob `jw t`gs

iuntgjo wjrks go tlres wgt` GJF/ X`gast Er Nirrgemll wis jo t`l niaa F t`lo

prjnllblb tj lxpaigo t`l Najsgoh Iuntgjo prjnlss go njosgblrifal bltiga/ Go pirtgnuair!

F lxpaigolb t`l agklay prgnl ejvlelots t`it egh`t rlsuat crje paingoh jrblrs jc virgjus

sgzls/ Er Hjloki lxpaigolb t`it `l wis ajjkgoh tj tribl go Hizprje cgrst iob lxpajrlb

wgt` F t`l olnlssiry stlps cjr gonrlisgoh t`l najsgoh prgnl! iob t`l aitlst tgel it w`gn`

io jrblr njuab fl painlb/ R`ly bgsnusslb i oueflr jc lxiepals/ Er Nirrgemll wis

pirty tj t`l bgsnussgjos/

67/ Go t`l njursl jc t`l njoclrlonl niaa Er Hjloki isklb nio G isk yju ojw najsgoh it6>/26 gc G wiot tj eikl gt 6>/2< `jw nio wl bj gt: F rlpaglb yju wgaa `ivl tj nalirjut lvlryjol t`it wis slaagoh it 26 iob cjr sicltys sikl hj iaa t`l wiy tj sjelfjby

najsgoh it 23 R`l pirtgls irriohlb cjr Er Hjloki tj slt up io joagol vgblj niaagoh

innjuot go jrblr t`it Er Hjloki njuab sll Fs snrllo go rlia tgel w`gast F wis tribgoh

go t`l iuntgjo/ Er Nirrgemll njocgrelb t`it `gs cgre! ^jelrslt! `ib io innjuot wgt`

Fs cgre t`lrlfy loifagoh Er Hjloki tj tribl t`rjuh` F/

>4/ Go t`l njursl jc t`l niaa go w`gn` Er Nirrgemll pirtgngpitlb! Er Hjloki iob F ihrllbt`it t`lrl s`juab fl i oueflr jc trgia ruos flcjrl intuia tribgoh/ Er Hjloki sigb t`lrl

wjuab fl tgel tj jfslrvl fltwllo < iob 94 iuntgjos flcjrl t`l intuia tribgoh iob t`it

t`ly wjuab `ivl i clw trgia ruos go jrblr tj try tj egogegsl t`l egstikls/

>9/ Jo 6> Iprga 6494 Er Nirrgemll niaalb F tj siy t`it `l `ib fllo t`gokgoh ifjut t`lnjoclrlonl niaa jo t`l wiy tj wjrk iob t`it ojfjby s`juab fl ifal tj pjgot i cgohlr

iob siy t`it yju wlrl eiogpuaitgoh i prgnl/ F bgsegsslb t`gs njonlro jo t`l fisgs t`it

t`ly wjuab fl tribgoh go i njepaltl iuntgjo iob t`it gc jt`lr pirtgls t`gok gts

eiogpuaitgoh jr t`it gts i wrjoh prgnl t`ly njuab njel iob cajh t`l stjnk/ I

s`jrt bgsnussgjo losulb fltwllo Er Nirrgemll iob F ifjut t`l rgsks jc ejvgoh t`l

prgnl fy i `ypjt`ltgnia

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

9/44

7

Hjloki wis stubygoh `jw t`l Najsgoh Iuntgjo wjrks/ F rlpaglb Wls! iob G bjot wiot

tj cgob jut tjj eun` tj w`it lob `l wiots tj bj gt/ Ge must `lrl tj lxlnutl gt cjr t`le/

>6/ Go i aitlr niaa jo 6> Iprga 6494! Er Nirrgemll wis isklb fy F w`it wjuab `ipplo tjEr Hjlokis stjnk jonl gt wis purn`islb go t`l Najsgoh Iuntgjo/ Er Nirrgemll

gocjrelb F t`it yju slaa gt iaa t`l olxt biy iob t`it Er Hjloki gs joay gotlrlstlb go

t`l jccgngia najsgoh prgnl jc t`l stjnk jo i pirtgnuair bitl/ Er Nirrgemll stitlb tj F

t`it crje rlibgoh fltwllo t`l agols G t`gok `l `is hjt i strunturlb prjbunt sj `l `is

hjt sjelt`goht`lrl gs i trghhlr gc t`l najsgoh prgnl gs ifjvl jr flajw i nlrtigo alvla/

Er Nirrgemll t`lo rlplitlb `gs jpgogjo tj F t`it `ls ihhrlssgvlay bjol sjel

strunturlb ojtl/ Curt`lr niaas tjjk painl fltwllo Er Nirrgemll iob F jo 63 Iprga

6494 it w`gn` tgel t`ly bgsnusslb Fs njeegssgjo ritls cjr t`l tribgoh/

>>/ Jo 67 Iprga 6494 i njoclrlonl niaa tjjk painl fltwllo Er Nirrgemll! F iob ErHjloki/ Trgjr tj Er Hjloki mjgogoh t`l niaa Er Nirrgemll iob F bgsnusslb t`l paioolbtribgoh/ F stitlb wl bjot wiot tj kojw w`it `l wiots tj bj! bj wl: Gts must

jol ejrl `libin`l wl bjot wiot tj kojw/ Er Nirrgemll ihrllb iob ibblb alts

kllp gt t`it wiy/ Er Nirrgemll iasj gostruntlb F jo t`l alvla jc tribgoh agegt t`it F

ollblb tj `ivl go painl tj cingagtitl t`l tribgoh iob issurlb F t`it `l wjuab ajjk ictlr

t`l ejoly isplnt jc t`l tribgoh/ Er Hjloki t`lo mjgolb t`l niaa iob t`l t`rll pirtgls

bgsnusslb irriohlelots cjr t`l cjaajwgoh biys tribgoh/ F njocgrelb t`it F `ib

gonrlislb Fs cgres tribgoh agegt crje \^B >4 egaagjo tj \^B 2/ It 6/99pe jo >4 Iprga 6494! F wis prjvgblb wgt` i agst jc t`l jrblrs Er Hjlokiwgs`lb F tj painl go t`l Najsgoh Iuntgjo/ R`l jrblrs wlrl iaa it prgnl alvlas ifjvl ioy

jc t`l tribgoh go Hizprje HBVs sj cir t`it biy iob wlrl iasj it alvlas ifjvl t`l

kojnk%go prgnl jc ^trunturlb Trjbunt 9/ R`l njst jc t`l jrblrs tjtiaalb \^B 33

egaagjo/ F niaalb Er Nirrgemll tj gocjre `ge t`it t`l jrblrs iejuotlb tj ejrl t`io

t`l \^B

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

10/44

94

>/4>pe tj gocjre Er Nirrgemll t`it ErHjloki `ib bgsnusslb t`l eittlr jc ejfgal p`jol niaas wgt` F/ Er Hjloki sigb t`it F

wis ojt njecjrtifal wgt` t`gs flniusl F cgre wjuab ojt innlpt naglot jrblrs fy ejfgal/

Er Nirrgemll sigb tj Er Hjloki X`y bjot yju bj jol t`goh! w`y bjot yju usl yjur

\K ejfgal: Er Nirrgemll t`lo stitlb X`y `ivl ioy njoolntgjo tj t`gs t`goh: ErNirrgemll tjab Er Hjloki t`it `l `ib rlissurlb F t`it F s`juab ojt wjrry ifjut t`l

usl jc ejfgal p`jols flniusl t`lrl gs oj pjssgfgagty jc i cgh`t! lre gt `is tj fl

iegnifal flniusl wl iaa kojw go w`it gotlrlst wlrl bjgoh t`gs/ It t`l lob jc t`l niaa

Er Nirrgemll tjab Er Hjloki ihigo tj Jk fut usl yjur \K ejfgal iob niaa [FU jo

[FsU \K ejfgal/ ^ufslqulotay! niaas wlrl eibl jo rlnjrblb agols iob jo uorlnjrblb

ejfgal tlalp`jols/

>3/ R`l prgnl jc Hizprje HBVs prlvigagoh go t`l eirklt it t`l tgel t`l jrblrs wlrl slot tjF it 6/99pe jo >4 Iprga 6494' wis ipprjxgeitlay \^B 6>/02! \^B 4/48 flajw t`l

kojnk%go prgnl/ @jwlvlr! s`jrtay flcjrl t`l iuntgjo wis bul tj njeelonl!

Trlsgblot Tutgo eibl i agvl ioojuonlelot jo Vussgio tlalvgsgjo ifjut i prjpjslb

elrhlr jc Hizprje iob t`l \krigogio his njepioy Oictjhiz/ R`l prgnl jc Hizprje

slnurgtgls claa jo t`l olws/ F niaalb Er Nirrgemll tj gocjre `ge jc t`l ioojuonlelot

iob t`it t`l prgnl jc Hizprje HBVs `is ojw njel bjwo tj ifjut 6>/>0 rgh`t w`gn`

eikls jur mjf eun` ejrl bgccgnuat rgh`t: Er Nirrgemll ihrllb/

>8/ Er Hjloki wis gocjrelb jc Trlsgblot Tutgos ioojuonlelot iob gts gepint/ Is irlsuat jc t`l ioojuonlelot Er Hjloki gostruntlb F ojt tj prjnllb wgt` t`l paioolb

iuntgjo tribgoh flniusl t`l Hizprje prgnl `ib ejvlb tjj cir tj loifal `gs paio tj flsunnlsscuaay lxlnutlb/ It >/>3pe Er Hjloki niaalb Er Nirrgemll tj gocjre ge t`it

wlrl ojt bjgoh ioyt`goh! wlvl ajst t`l hiel/ Er Hjloki lxpaigolb tj Er

Nirrgemll t`it fisgniaay! w`it `ipplolb gs t`l Tutgo olws niel jut t`l stjnk wlot

bjwo 6, sj wl niot bj ioyt`goh/ Er Hjloki gocjrelb Er Nirrgemll t`it `l `ib

iarliby spjklo tj F ifjut t`l eittlr/

>0/ Er Nirrgemll iob F bgsnusslb Er Hjlokis rlintgjo tj t`l olws go i sufslqulottlalp`jol niaa/ R`l twj ojtlb t`l iejuot jc paioogoh t`it `ib hjol tj wistl/ Er

Nirrgemll eibl rlclrlonl tj w`it t`l pirtgls wjuab `ivl in`glvlb gc Er Hjlokis paio

`ib wjrklb/ @l sigb= gc Er Hjloki eibl 94 egaagjo tjbiy g/l/ t`it Er Hjloki

wjuab `ivl rlnjuplb `gs govlstelot go cuaa' yju [FU wjuab `ivl fllo pigb 94 fisgs

pjgots go njeegssgjo/ F rlpaglb G bjot nirl rliaay flniusl ioy biy t`lyrl agvgoh fy

t`l swjrb iob bygoh fy t`l swjrb fut yju nio clla t`it bgsippjgotelot/

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

11/44

99

>7/ R`lrl wlrl virgjus rlclrlonls go t`l njovlrsitgjo fltwllo Er Nirrgemll iob F tj t`lojtl `lab fy Er Hjloki! w`gn` t`l C^I njosgblrs tj `ivl fllo rlclrlonls tj

^trunturlb Trjbunt 9/ Er Nirrgemll stitlb t`it t`l hiel wis iaa ifjut t`l najsgoh

prgnl iob jfslrvlb t`it wl bjot kojw w`it t`l upsgbl tj t`it ojtl gs ^jel jc t`le

`ivl i euatgpaglr /

f' ^trunturlb Trjbunt 6 iob t`l Najsgoh Iuntgjo cjr Vlagionl

24/ Go liray Jntjflr 6494 Er Hjloki gocjrelb Er Nirrgemll it i elltgoh go Bufig t`it `lwgs`lb tj fuy Vlagionl HBVs iob pirtgngpitl go t`l Najsgoh Iuntgjo/ Er Nirrgemll

put Er Hjloki go tjun` wgt` F sj t`it `l njuab bgrlntay triosint/ Er Nirrgemll

njocgrelb tj F t`it F wis iut`jrgslb tj blia bgrlntay up tj i nip jc \^B / Jo t`l biy jc t`l iuntgjo tribl! 90 Jntjflr 6494! Er Nirrgemll wis jut jc t`l njuotryjo i fusgolss trgp/ Fjt` Er Hjloki iob F sjuh`t tj njotint Er Nirrgemll it `gs jccgnl

jo slvlria jnnisgjos burgoh 90 Jntjflr 6494/ Er Nirrgemlls jccgnl gocjrelb Er

Hjloki t`it Er Nirrgemll njuab fl rlin`lb jo `gs ejfgal/ R`lrl wis i tlalp`jol niaa

crje Er Nirrgemll tj Er Hjloki w`gn` aistlb 8 slnjobs/

22/ R`l bltigas jc t`l jrblrs tj tribl painlb fy Er Hjloki irl slt jut go t`l Cgoia Ojtgnlgssulb tj `ge/ Go sueeiry! Er Hjloki painlb i slrgls jc airhl! prl%paioolb iob

nirlcuaay tgelb jrblrs go t`l cgoia slnjobs jc t`l Najsgoh Iuntgjo cjr Vlagionl HBVs/ Gc

cuacgaalb go t`lgr lotgrlty! Er Hjlokis jrblrs wjuab `ivl rlqugrlb io lxplobgturl jcipprjxgeitlay \^B

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

12/44

96

23/ R`l prgnl jc Vlagionl HBVs brjpplb fink t`l olxt biy tj najsl it \^B 28/94/ ErHjloki sjab t`l Vlagionl HBVs `l `ib inqugrlb/ Er Nirrgemll wis iwirl jc t`l sials

iob spjkl wgt` F cjaajwgoh `gs rlturo crje `gs fusgolss trgp/

VLTVL^LORIRGJO^ IOB CGOBGOH^

28/ Flajw gs i frglc sueeiry jc t`l kly wrgttlo iob jria rlprlslotitgjos eibl fy ErNirrgemll iob `jw t`ly `ivl fllo bliat wgt`/ Go eikgoh t`l blngsgjo w`gn` hivl rgsl

tj t`l jfaghitgjo tj hgvl t`gs Blngsgjo Ojtgnl! t`l C^I `is tiklo gotj innjuot iaa jc Er

Nirrgemlls rlprlslotitgjos! w`lt`lr jr ojt slt jut flajw/

Frlin` jc ^titlelot jc Trgongpal 9

20/ Er Nirrgemll eibl rlprlslotitgjos t`it t`l C^Is iaalhitgjo t`it `l frlin`lb^titlelot jc Trgongpal 9 fy kojwgohay issgstgoh Er Hjloki go `gs paio tj eiogpuaitl

t`l prgnl jc fjt` Hizprje iob Vlagionl HBVs jr turolb i fagob lyl is tj t`it rgsk gswgt`jut elrgt iob gs prlegslb jo i cigaurl tj prjplray uoblrstiob= 9' Er Nirrgemlls

kojwalbhl*iwirlolss jc Er Hjlokis paio*gotlotgjos jr 6' Er Nirrgemlls rjal go

rlaitgjo tj Er Hjlokis iccigrs it t`l rlalviot tgel/

Er Nirrgemlls kojwalbhl*iwirlolss

27/ Er Nirrgemll sufegttlb t`it=i' `gs iaalhlb egsnjobunt eust fl isslsslb go t`l njotlxt jc `gs intuia kojwalbhl it

t`l rlalviot tgel iob eust ojt fl vglwlb wgt` `gobsgh`t/ Er Nirrgemll isslrtlbt`it i cgobgoh jc i frlin` jc ^titlelot jc Trgongpal 9 gs ejst ipprjprgitl go nisls

jc intuia kojwalbhl iob blagflritl gotlot! olgt`lr jc w`gn` `l pjsslsslb/ Er

Nirrgemll stitlb t`it t`l C^I `is ojt sufegttlb ioy lvgblonl t`it `l fjt` kolw

jc! iob n`jsl tj intgvlay pirtgngpitl go jr kolw jc! ylt ghojrlb'! Er Hjlokis

eirklt eiogpuaitgjo sn`lel/ Er Nirrgemll isslrtlb t`it wgt`jut intuia

kojwalbhl jc Er Hjlokis paio*gotlotgjos! `l nioojt `ivl kojwgohay issgstlb go

Er Hjlokis ittlept tj eiogpuaitl eirklt prgnls;

f' `l `ib oj kojwalbhl jr lxplrglonl jc t`l Najsgoh Iuntgjo/ Er Nirrgemllisslrtlb t`it `l splngcgniaay sjuh`t tj govjavl F flniusl `l uoblrstjjb t`it F iob

Fs njaalihuls it Fs cgre `ivl lxplrglonl jc tribgoh burgoh t`l Najsgoh Iuntgjo/

Er Nirrgemll stitlb t`it `l rlaglb jo F tj lxpaigo t`l printgniagtgls iob issjngitlb

rgsks jc tribgoh go t`l Najsgoh Iuntgjo tj `ge iob Er Hjloki'/ Er Nirrgemll

sufegttlb t`it `gs lvgblotay agegtlb uoblrstiobgoh jc t`l Najsgoh Iuntgjo prjnlss

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

13/44

9>

nists bjuft jo t`l agklag`jjb t`it `l wis govjavlb go i eirklt eiogpuaitgjo

sn`lel tj w`gn` iuntgjo tribgoh wis nlotria;

n' `l `ib oj kojwalbhl jc t`l ^trunturlb Trjbunts/ Er Nirrgemll sufegttlb t`it `lbgb ojt kojw jc t`l lxgstlonl jr tlres jc t`l ^trunturlb Trjbunts/ Cjr t`l

^trunturlb Trjbunts tj `ivl `ib i flirgoh jo `gs ipprjin` tj Er Hjlokis tribls

`l wjuab `ivl tj `ivl kojwo jc= g' t`l lxgstlonl jc fjt` ^trunturlb Trjbunts;

iob gg' t`l eln`iogns jc t`l ^trunturlb Trjbunts sun` is `jw t`l piy%juts wlrl

tj fl nianuaitlb! w`gn` stjnks wlrl t`l pjtlotgia aihhirbs iob t`l rlalviot

eiturgty bitls'; iob ggg' t`l rlsplntgvl kojnk go prgnls jc t`l ^trunturlb

Trjbunts/ Er Nirrgemll stitlb t`it `l elrlay splnuaitlb ifjut t`l pjssgfgagty t`it

Er Hjloki(s paioolb tribls njuab rlaitl tj t`l `jabgoh jc t`l ^trunturlb Trjbunts/

Er Nirrgemll iasj splnuaitlb t`it Er Hjloki egh`t njoslqulotay `ivl sjel

geprjplr ejtgvls cjr t`l tribls iob bgsnusslb t`lsl wgt` F! io lxplrglonlb

gobustry prjclssgjoia/ Er Nirrgemll uoblrstjjb crje iob wis sitgscglb fy' F

t`it lvlo gc Er Hjloki(s gotlotgjo wis tj eiogpuaitl t`l prgnl jc pirtgnuair HBVs

go t`l Najsgoh Iuntgjo w`gn` Er Nirrgemll isslrtlb wis ojt kojwo tj `ge' sun`

io jutnjel wjuab fl vlry bgccgnuat! gc ojt gepjssgfal! tj sunnlsscuaay in`glvl/

Er Nirrgemll sufegttlb t`it `l wis t`lrlcjrl ojt rlnkalss is tj t`l pjssgfgagty Er

Hjloki egh`t fl sllkgoh tj fl`ivl geprjplray;

b' `l `ib oj kojwalbhl jc Er Hjlokis ejtgvls cjr*gotlotgjos fl`gob t`l HizprjeHBVs jr Vlagionl HBVs tribls flniusl `l `ib oj kojwalbhl jc t`l ^trunturlb

Trjbunts/ Curt`lr! Er Nirrgemll sufegttlb t`it `l `is kojwo Er Hjloki cjr 9/26 gc G wiot tj eikl gt

6>/2< `jw nio wl bj gt:/ Er Nirrgemll `ib! fy t`l olxt biy! njosgblrlb t`l

pjssgfgagty jc eirklt ifusl iob splnuaitlb wgt` F ifjut t`gs pjssgfgagty/ @l wlot

jo tj niutgjo F t`it ojfjby s`juab fl ifal tj pjgot i cgohlr iob siy yju wlrl

eiogpuaitgoh i prgnl/ Er Nirrgemll iasj kolw t`it Er Hjloki gotloblb tj slaa

t`l stjnk t`l olxt biy iob t`it Er Hjloki wis joay gotlrlstlb go t`l jccgngia

najsgoh prgnl jc t`l stjnk jo i pirtgnuair bitl/ R`l C^I iasj bjls ojt innlpt Er

Nirrgemlls sufegssgjos t`it `l bgb ojt kojw ifjut t`l Vlagionl HBV tribgoh jot`l biy iob t`it `l wis ojt tjab jc t`l tribgoh uotga ictlr gt `ib jnnurrlb/ R`l

C^I ojtls t`it Er Nirrgemll wis iwirl crje t`l jutslt t`it Er Hjloki `ib i

buia paio iob gotloblb tj tribl go fjt` Hizprje iob Vlagionl HBVs/ X`lo Er

Hjloki sufslqulotay ipprjin`lb Er Nirrgemll go rlaitgjo tj tribgoh Vlagionl go

t`l Najsgoh Iuntgjo! Er Nirrgemll iarliby kolw jc t`l liraglr! ifjrtlb tribgoh go

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

17/44

98

rlaitgjo tj Hizprje/ R`it kojwalbhl tjhlt`lr wgt` Er Nirrgemlls prgjr

suspgngjos t`it Er Hjloki `lab i strunturlb prjbunt iob t`it eirklt

eiogpuaitgjo wis `gs hjia eliot t`it Er Nirrgemll wjuab `ivl fllo iwirl t`it

Er Hjloki gotloblb tj lohihl go t`l siel jr sgegair fl`ivgjur go rlaitgjo tj

Vlagionl/ Go ibbgtgjo! F ialrtlb iob*jr rlegoblb Er Nirrgemll jo 9< Jntjflr6494 t`it Er Hjloki wis prlpirgoh tj tribl go Vlagionl HBVs iob t`it t`l

ciaagoh stjnk prgnl wis i prjfale/ Innjrbgohay! t`l C^I iasj rlmlnts Er

Nirrgemlls sufegssgjo t`it `l njuab ojt `ivl kojwo t`l jrblrs wlrl painlb

ifjvl t`l kojnk%go prgnl jc t`l Vlagionl HBVs is `l wis ojt iwirl jc

^trunturlb Trjbunt 6; iob

l' gt bjls ojt innlpt Er Nirrgemlls rlprlslotitgjo t`it lvlo gc `l bgb kojw jc ErHjlokis ejtgvls cjr*gotlotgjos fl`gob t`l ifjrtlb Hizprje HBV tribgoh iob

t`l Vlagionl HBV tribgoh! `l bgb ojt frlin` ^titlelot jc Trgongpal 9/ X`gast t`l

C^I innlpts t`it Er Nirrgemll joay `ib i agegtlb govjavlelot go t`l ifjrtlb

Hizprje HBV tribgoh iob t`l Vlagionl HBV tribgoh! gt njosgblrs t`it go iaa t`l

ngrnuestionls jc t`gs nisl! io ipprjvlb plrsjo intgoh wgt` gotlhrgty! pirtgnuairay

jol go Er Nirrgemll(s pjsgtgjo! i ^GC `jablr wgt` t`l njepagionl jvlrsgh`t

cuontgjo cjr `gs cgre! wjuab `ivl tiklo stlps tj losurl t`it Er Hjlokis paioolb

eirklt eiogpuaitgjo bgb ojt tikl painl/ R`l C^I njosgblrs t`it Er Nirrgemll

`ib succgnglot kojwalbhl*iwirlolss jc t`l paioolb eirklt eiogpuaitgjo tj

blnagol tj issgst Er Hjloki cjr t`l rlisjos slt jut `lrlgo'/ Curt`lr! t`l C^I

njosgblrs t`it Er Nirrgemll s`juab `ivl ibvgslb ihigost sun` intgvgty iob*jr

losurlb t`it t`l rlhuaitjry iut`jrgtgls wlrl ojtgcglb iob t`it suspgngjus

intgvgty*triosintgjo rlpjrts wlrl cgalb/ Cjr t`l rlisjos slt jut `lrlgo! t`l C^I

njosgblrs t`it Er Nirrgemll cigalb tj njepay wgt` ^titlelot jc Trgongpal 9 fy

rlnkalssay issgstgoh*cingagtitgoh Er Hjlokis paioolb eirklt eiogpuaitgjo/ R`l

C^I `is cjuob t`it Er Nirrgemll wis rlnkalss go rlaitgjo tj t`l njobunt t`it

uatgeitlay alb tj Er Hjlokis eirklt ifusl/ R`l C^I bjls ojt innlpt Er

Nirrgemlls sufegssgjo t`it `l `ib oj ejtgvl tj issgst go Er Hjlokis eirklt

ifusl sn`lel/ R`l C^I njosgblrs t`it Er Nirrgemll flolcgttlb crje `gs njobunt

t`rjuh` t`l rltlotgjo jc Er Hjlokis fusgolss cjr `gs cgre/ Iasj! is Er

Nirrgemll `is inkojwalbhlb! Er Hjloki i wlaa%kojwo govlstjr' rlprlslotlb iclit`lr go ^jelrslts nip iob is sun` Er Nirrgemll eiy `ivl `jplb tj `ivl

ittrintlb jt`lr wlaa%kojwo govlstjrs is naglots jc ^jelrslt t`rjuh` `gs rltlotgjo

jc Er Hjlokis fusgolss cjr `gs cgre/

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

18/44

90

Er Nirrgemlls rjal

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

19/44

97

ifusgvl triosintgjo*tribl fislb jo t`lgr pist `gstjry/ Iat`juh` `l wis wiry jc

t`l pjssgfgagty jc paioolb eirklt eiogpuaitgjo! Er Nirrgemll isslrtlb t`it `l

t`juh`t gt wjuab fl goipprjprgitl tj n`iaalohl Er Hjloki bgrlntay ifslot i cgre

uoblrstiobgoh t`it Er Hjloki wis sllkgoh! iob wjuab fl sunnlsscua go! eirklt

eiogpuaitgjo/ Er Nirrgemll iasj stitlb t`it `l bgb ojt njosgblr t`lrl tj flioyt`goh suspgngjus ifjut Er Hjloki iob F bgsnussgoh lxiepals jc `jw io

gobgnitgvl prgnl ejvlb burgoh t`l Najsgoh Iuntgjo/ Er Nirrgemll stitlb t`it t`gs

wis i plrclntay rlisjoifal eioolr go w`gn` tj lxpaigo `jw t`l Najsgoh Iuntgjo

wjrklb;

b' `l wis ojt fagob tj Er Hjlokis pjssgfal gotlotgjos go rlaitgjo tj t`l ifjrtlbHizprje HBV tribgoh is `l rigslb njonlros ifjut eirklt eiogpuaitgjo wgt` F go

Iprga 6494/ F rlcutlb t`jsl njonlros! splngcgniaay jo t`l fisgs t`it gt wis ojt

pjssgfal tj ejvl t`l prgnl jc t`l stjnk t`l Hizprje HBVs' is gt wis tjj agqugb/

Go agh`t jc t`gs! Er Nirrgemll isslrtlb t`it `l wis bjuftcua t`it Er Hjloki `ib

t`l cgoiongia elios tj eiogpuaitl t`l prgnl jc Hizprje/ Er Nirrgemll sufegttlb

t`it gt wis rlisjoifal cjr `ge tj innlpt Fs issurionl t`it t`l stjnk wis tjj

agqugb tj eiogpuaitl is njrrlnt/ Er Nirrgemll isslrtlb t`it `l `ib oj rlisjo tj

bjuft Fs ioiaysgs/ Er Nirrgemll stitlb t`it `l curt`lr uoblrstjjb crje F t`it

t`lrl wlrl eirklt siclhuirbs ihigost eiogpuaitgjo sgonl F tjab `ge t`it gt wis

tln`ogniaay gepjssgfal tj eiogpuaitl t`l prgnl jc i stjnk go t`l Najsgoh Iuntgjo

is t`l tln`ojajhy bgbot iaajw gt/ Gt wis t`lrlcjrl `gs uoblrstiobgoh `ivgoh

rigslb `gs njonlros wgt` iojt`lr prjclssgjoia! F' t`it eiogpuaitgjo jc t`l najsgoh

prgnl jc i stjnk go t`l Najsgoh Iuntgjo rlhirbalss jc ejtgvl' wis uoagklay tj

sunnllb iob njuab joay jnnur gc t`l nurrlot prgnl jc t`l stjnk wis vlry najsl tj

t`l blsgrlb prgnl/ Innjrbgohay! Er Nirrgemll sufegttlb t`it `l wis sitgscglb t`it

gt wis ojt pjssgfal cjr Er Hjloki tj eiogpuaitl t`l eirklt/ Curt`lr! Er

Nirrgemll sufegttlb t`it t`l prjpjslb Hizprje HBVs tribl bgb ojt prjnllb iob

t`l prjpjslb tribl wis ifjrtlb flcjrl t`l ioojuonlelot fy Trlsgblot Tutgo/ Er

Nirrgemll isslrtlb t`it Er Hjloki tjab `ge it 92=24 Iprga 6494 t`it `l

wjuab ojt tribl/ Er Nirrgemll stitlb t`it `l wis ojt surprgslb fy t`gs olws is

Er Hjloki crlqulotay n`iohlb `gs egob it i aitl stihl/ Go ioy lvlot! Er

Nirrgemll stitlb t`it `l bgb ojt t`gok gt wjuab fl pjssgfal tj eiogpuaitl t`liuntgjo wgt` 9/

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

20/44

64

l' `l wis joay plrgp`lriaay govjavlb go t`l tribgoh irriohlelots cjr Vlagionl HBVsgo Jntjflr 6494/ Er Nirrgemll sufegttlb t`it `l paiylb vgrtuiaay oj rjal go t`l

prjnlss fy w`gn` t`l Vlagionl HBVs wlrl inqugrlb iob wis ojt go t`l njuotry jo

t`l biy t`l tribgoh tjjk painl/ Curt`lr! iob is iarliby stitlb! Er Nirrgemll `ib

sitgscglb `geslac go Iprga 6494 t`it Er Hjloki wjuab ojt fl ifal tj eiogpuaitlt`l eirklt iob `ib oj rlisjo tj rigsl curt`lr suspgngjos w`lo t`l Hizprje HBV

tribls bgb ojt hj i`lib flniusl t`lrl wis oj lvgblonl ivigaifal tj Er Nirrgemll

tj njotribgnt `gs uoblrstiobgoh t`it Er Hjloki wjuab ojt `ivl fllo ifal tj

eiogpuaitl t`l eirklt/ Go ibbgtgjo! jo 98 Eiy 6494! Er Hjloki lotlrlb i tribl

cjr 04!444 Vlagionl HBVs w`gn` wis lxlnutlb fy F iob t`lrl gs oj lvgblonl t`it

gt wis geprjplr/ R`lrlcjrl w`lo `l flniel iwirl jc io gotlotgjo fy Er Hjloki

tj lotlr curt`lr tribls go Vlagionl HBVs go Jntjflr 6494 t`lrl wis oj rlisjo tj

njosgblr t`gs uotjwirb/

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

21/44

69

wiros ihigost eirklt ifusl govjavgoh prgnl eiogpuaitgjo/ R`l C^I njosgblrs

t`it is io ipprjvlb plrsjo `jabgoh t`l njepagionl jvlrsgh`t cuontgjo it

^jelrslt! Er Nirrgemll wjuab `ivl fllo iwirl jc t`l njotlots jc ^jelrslts

njepagionl eiouia/ Ojtwgt`stiobgoh t`l cjrlhjgoh iob go ioy lvlot'! t`l C^I

njosgblrs t`it t`l lvgblonl njotigolb go t`l rlnjrbgohs iob triosnrgpts jc t`ltlalp`jol njovlrsitgjos w`gn` tjjk painl virgjusay fltwllo Er Hjloki! Er

Nirrgemll iob F pirtgnuairay go Iprga 6494' naliray gobgnitl t`it Er Nirrgemll

bgb ojt stlp jut jc t`l irriohlelot ictlr gotrjbungoh F tj Er Hjloki/ Cjr t`l

cjrlhjgoh rlisjos! t`l C^I njosgblrs t`it gt gs grrlalviot w`lt`lr jr ojt Er

Nirrgemll gotrjbunlb F tj Er Hjloki wgt` t`l purpjsl jc cingagtitgoh eirklt

ifusl*eirklt eiogpuaitgjo iob `is cjuob t`it Er Nirrgemll wis rlnkalss go

rlaitgjo tj t`l njobunt t`it uatgeitlay alb tj Er Hjlokis eirklt ifusl/ R`it gs!

`l turolb i fagob lyl tj t`l rgsk t`it Er Hjloki wis sllkgoh tj eiogpuaitl t`l

Najsgoh Iuntgjo/ R`l C^I t`lrlcjrl njosgblrs t`it Er Nirrgemll cigalb tjnjepay wgt` ^titlelot jc Trgongpal 9 fy rlnkalssay issgstgoh*cingagtitgoh Er

Hjlokis paioolb eirklt eiogpuaitgjo;

n' gt ojtls Er Nirrgemlls isslrtgjos t`it `l wis njosngjus jc `gs rlspjosgfgagtglsiob t`l ollb tj fl vghgaiot tj t`l pjssgfgagty jc fl`ivgjur w`gn` pjtlotgiaay

iejuotlb tj eirklt ifusl/ @jwlvlr! t`l C^I bjls ojt innlpt Er Nirrgemlls

isslrtgjo t`it `l lxlrngslb ipprjprgitl niutgjo go rlsplnt jc Er Hjloki/ R`l C^I

njosgblrs t`it io ipprjvlb plrsjo go Er Nirrgemlls pjsgtgjo % wgt` njepagionl

jvlrsgh`t rlspjosgfgagtgls % gs rlqugrlb tj eikl rjfust loqugrgls iob tj n`iaalohl

t`l gocjreitgjo t`ly rlnlgvl/ Io ipprjvlb plrsjo iasj `is io jvlrrgbgoh

rlspjosgfgagty tj tikl prlvlotitgvl intgjo w`lrl t`l gocjreitgjo t`ly rlnlgvl

gobgnitls t`it tj bj ojt`goh eiy plregt eiogpuaitgjo jc t`l eirklt/ Gt gs t`lrlcjrl

gosuccgnglot cjr Er Nirrgemll tj sgepay isslrt t`it `l t`juh`t gt wjuab fl

goipprjprgitl tj n`iaalohl Er Hjloki bgrlntay ifslot i cgre uoblrstiobgoh t`it

Er Hjloki wis sllkgoh! iob wjuab fl sunnlsscua go! eirklt eiogpuaitgjo/ R`l

C^I iasj bjls ojt innlpt Er Nirrgemlls rlprlslotitgjos t`it `l bgb ojt njosgblr

t`lrl tj fl ioyt`goh suspgngjus ifjut Er Hjloki iob F bgsnussgoh lxiepals jc

`jw t`l gobgnitgvl prgnl ejvlb burgoh t`l Najsgoh Iuntgjo/ R`l C^I ojtls t`it

gt wis t`gs fl`ivgjur w`gn` rlsuatlb go Er Nirrgemll splnuaitgoh wgt` F' ifjutt`l pjssgfgagty t`it Er Hjloki gotloblb tj eiogpuaitl t`l eirklt;

b' gt innlpts Er Nirrgemlls sufegssgjo t`it `l rigslb njonlros ifjut Er Hjlokispjtlotgia eirklt eiogpuaitgjo wgt` F/ @jwlvlr! t`l C^I bjls ojt innlpt t`it gt

wis rlisjoifal cjr Er Nirrgemll tj innlpt Fs issurionl t`it gt wis ojt pjssgfal

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

22/44

66

cjr Er Hjloki tj eiogpuaitl t`l eirklt/ X`gast t`l C^I innlpts t`it Er

Nirrgemll eiy `ivl fllo alss lxplrglonlb go iuntgjo tribgoh t`io F! is io

ipprjvlb plrsjo iob i ^GC `jablr! `l wis rlqugrlb tj eikl rjfust loqugrgls iob

tj n`iaalohl t`l gocjreitgjo `l rlnlgvlb crje F/ R`l C^I njosgblrs t`it gt wis

gosuccgnglot cjr io ipprjvlb plrsjo sun` is Er Nirrgemll tj sgepay innlpt Fsissurionl t`it t`l Hizprje HBVs wlrl tjj agqugb tj eiogpuaitl iob t`it t`lrl

wlrl eirklt siclhuirbs ihigost eiogpuaitgjo/ Cjr t`l cjrlhjgoh rlisjos! t`l C^I

`is cjuob t`it Er Nirrgemlls cigaurl tj eikl rjfust loqugrgls jc F iob `gs

cigaurl tj n`iaalohl t`l gocjreitgjo `l rlnlgvlb crje F iob Er Hjloki'

gobgnitls t`it `l wis turogoh i fagob lyl tj t`l rgsk t`it Er Hjloki wis sllkgoh

tj eiogpuaitl t`l Najsgoh Iuntgjo/ R`l C^I iasj bjls ojt innlpt Er Nirrgemlls

isslrtgjo t`it flniusl t`l Hizprje HBVs tribgoh bgb ojt hj i`lib is gotloblb!

`l `ib oj rlisjo tj rlvgsgt t`l qulstgjo is tj w`lt`lr eiogpuaitgjo wis pjssgfal/

Io ipprjvlb plrsjo sun` is Er Nirrgemll! wgt` njepagionl jvlrsgh`trlspjosgfgagtgls! gs rlqugrlb tj eikl rjfust loqugrgls iob tj n`iaalohl t`l

gocjreitgjo `l rlnlgvls/ R`gs gs pirtgnuairay sj go ngrnuestionls sun` is t`gs!

w`lrl t`l C^I `is cjuob t`it Er Nirrgemll `ib succgnglot iwirlolss jc Er

Hjlokis gotlotgjo tj eiogpuaitl t`l eirklt t`it `l s`juab `ivl blnagolb tj int

iob*jr tiklo stlps tj losurl t`it t`l eiogpuaitgvl tribgoh bgb ojt tikl painl

gonaubgoh ibvgsgoh ihigost sun` intgvgty iob*jr tj losurl t`it t`l rlhuaitjry

iut`jrgtgls wlrl ojtgcglb'; iob

l' gt innlpts t`it Er Nirrgemll wis ifrjib jo t`l splngcgn biy jo w`gn` ErHjlokis ifusgvl tribgoh go t`l Vlagionl HBVs tjjk painl 90 Jntjflr 6494'/

R`l C^I t`lrlcjrl innlpts t`it Er Nirrgemll wis ojt intgvlay lohihlb go t`l

tribgoh jo t`it biy/ @jwlvlr! t`l C^I ojtls t`it `ivgoh gotrjbunlb Er Hjloki

tj F iob `ivgoh fllo najslay*plrsjoiaay govjavlb go t`l ifjrtlb Hizprje HBVs

tribgoh! Er Nirrgemll bgb ojt ollb tj fl najslay*plrsjoiaay govjavlb go t`l

Vlagionl HBVs tribgoh/ R`l C^I bjls ojt innlpt Er Nirrgemlls sufegssgjo

t`it flniusl t`l Hizprje HBVs tribgoh bgb ojt hj i`lib is gotloblb! `l `ib oj

rlisjo tj rlvgsgt t`l qulstgjo is tj w`lt`lr Er Hjloki njuab sunnlsscuaay

eiogpuaitl t`l eirklt/ R`l C^I njosgblrs t`it io ipprjvlb plrsjo wgt`

njepagionl jvlrsgh`t rlspjosgfgagtgls gs rlqugrlb tj eikl rjfust loqugrgls iob tjn`iaalohl t`l gocjreitgjo `l*s`l rlnlgvls/ Er Nirrgemll cigalb tj bj sj/ R`l

C^I bjls ojt innlpt t`it io ipprjvlb gobgvgbuia wgt` njepagionl jvlrsgh`t

rlspjosgfgagtgls go Er Nirrgemlls pjsgtgjo'! gs plregttlb tj ghojrl t`lgr

rlspjosgfgagty tj tikl intgjo tj prlvlot eiogpuaitgvl tribgoh jo t`l fisgs t`it t`ly

njosgblr t`l paio uoagklay tj sunnllb/ X`gast t`l C^I innlpts t`it jo 98 Eiy

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

23/44

6>

6494! Er Hjloki lotlrlb i tribl cjr 04!444 Vlagionl HBVs w`gn` wis lxlnutlb

fy F iob t`lrl gs oj lvgblonl t`it gt wis geprjplr! t`l C^I njosgblrs t`it gt gs

lvgblot crje t`l njotlepjrioljus rlnjrbgohs iob triosnrgpts jc t`l tlalp`jol

njovlrsitgjos govjavgoh Er Nirrgemll' t`it `l wis wlaa iwirl jc Er Hjlokis

gotloblb eiogpuaitgvl tribgoh lsplngiaay flniusl Er Nirrgemll ipprjvlb t`lcgoiongoh irriohlelots go rlaitgjo tj t`l Vlagionl HBVs tribgoh/

^iontgjo

/ Ojtwgt`stiobgoh Er Nirrgemlls rlprlslotitgjos t`it `l bgb ojt frlin` ^titlelot jcTrgongpal 9! Er Nirrgemll iasj eibl rlprlslotitgjos t`it t`l gepjsgtgjo jc t`l cgoiongia

ploiaty iob t`l prj`gfgtgjo jrblr irl bgsprjpjrtgjoitl go iaa t`l ngrnuestionls/

Cgoiongia Tloiaty

bgs`jolsty jr blagflritl egsnjobunt/ Er Nirrgemll iasj isslrtlb t`it t`l C^Is

isslsselot jc `gs fl`ivgjur is flgoh it slrgjusolss alvla < gs gonjosgstlot wgt` Er

Hjlokis egsnjobunt `ivgoh fllo isslsslb it slrgjusolss alvla 2 iob jt`lr C^I

nisls; iob

f' gt gs uonalir w`y t`l C^I `is blngblb tj ippay i bltlrrlonl euatgpaglr jc 2 cjr t`lpurpjsls jc nianuaitgoh t`l cgoiongia ploiaty/ Er Nirrgemll isslrtlb t`it gt

bgsprjpjrtgjoitl cjr t`l C^I tj ippay i bltlrrlonl euatgpaglr jc 2 w`lrl gt gs iasj

sllkgoh tj prj`gfgt `ge/

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

24/44

62

intgvgty/ Curt`lr! Er Nirrgemll wis ojt joay io ipprjvlb plrsjo! fut `l wis iasj

i ^GC `jablr wgt` t`l njepagionl jvlrsgh`t cuontgjo cjr `gs cgre! ^jelrslt/ R`l

C^I njosgblrs t`it t`gs lxinlrfitls t`l slrgjusolss jc Er Nirrgemlls egsnjobunt

go ngrnuestionls w`lrl cjr t`l rlisjos slt jut ifjvl'! t`l C^I `is cjuob t`it Er

Nirrgemll cigalb tj njepay wgt` ^titlelot jc Trgongpal 9 fy rlnkalssayissgstgoh*cingagtitgoh Er Hjlokis paioolb eirklt eiogpuaitgjo iob t`it Er

Nirrgemll wis rlnkalss go rlaitgjo tj t`l njobunt t`it uatgeitlay alb tj Er

Hjlokis eirklt ifusl/ Innjrbgohay! t`l C^I `is cjuob t`it t`l bgcclrlonl go

t`l nitlhjrgsitgjo jc Er Hjlokis egsnjobunt wgt` Er Nirrgemlls egsnjobunt gs

mustgcglb/ Go eikgoh t`gs cgobgoh! t`l C^I `is prjplray njosgblrlb ioiajhjus

nisls iat`juh` t`l C^I innlpts t`it t`lrl irl oj nisls t`it irl bgrlntay

njepirifal jo t`lgr cints tj t`gs jol;

f' i euatgpal jc 2! is io ibmustelot cjr bltlrrlonl! gs t`l egogeue t`it gs olnlssirytj in`glvl gts jfmlntgvl jc nrlbgfal bltlrrlonl cjr t`l rlisjos slt jut go t`gs

Blngsgjo Ojtgnl iob splngcgniaay go t`l ioiaysgs jc t`l siontgjo flajw'/ R`l C^I

rlmlnts Er Nirrgemll isslrtgjo t`it gt gs bgsprjpjrtgjoitl cjr gt tj ippay i

bltlrrlonl euatgpaglr jc 2 w`lrl gt gs iasj sllkgoh tj prj`gfgt `ge/ R`l

prj`gfgtgjo gs gotloblb tj in`glvl i bgcclrlot purpjsl tj t`l cgoiongia ploiaty

oielay t`l prjtlntgjo jc njosuelrs/ R`l C^I njosgblrs t`it Er Nirrgemll pjsls

i rgsk tj njosuelrs iob tj t`l cgoiongia systle gc `l plrcjres ioy cuontgjo go

rlaitgjo tj ioy rlhuaitlb intgvgty nirrglb jo fy ioy iut`jrgslb jr lxlept plrsjo jr

lxlept prjclssgjoia cgre/ Go ioy lvlot! t`l C^I njosgblrs t`it t`l cgoiongia

ploiaty gs fjt` ipprjprgitl iob prjpjrtgjoitl fy rlclrlonl tj t`l cintjrs slt jut go

BLTT 3/< sll t`l ioiaysgs jc t`l siontgjo flajw'/

Trj`gfgtgjo Jrblr

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

25/44

6/26 gc G wiot tj eikl gt 6>/2< `jw nio

wl bj gt: F wlot jo tj lxpaigo `jw t`it prgnl njuab fl in`glvlb/

f' Er Nirrgemll `ib! fy t`l olxt biy! njosgblrlb t`l pjssgfgagty jc eirklt ifusl iobtjab F t`it ojfjby s`juab fl ifal tj pjgot i cgohlr iob siy yju wlrl

eiogpuaitgoh i prgnl/

n' Er Nirrgemll spjkl wgt` F jo jt`lr jnnisgjos rlhirbgoh t`l paioolb tribgoh iobt`l lxtlot tj w`gn` Er Hjloki wis stubygoh t`l Najsgoh Iuntgjo prjnlss/

b' Er Nirrgemll lxprlssay gocjrelb F t`it `l t`juh`t Er Hjloki `ib i strunturlbprjbunt w`gn` wis icclntlb fy t`l najsgoh prgnl jc slnurgtgls flgoh ifjvl jr

flajw i nlrtigo alvla/

l' Er Nirrgemll wis iwirl jc t`l vjauel jc t`l tribls t`it Er Hjloki gotloblb tjpainl is `l `ib bgsnusslb t`l eittlr wgt` Er Hjloki iob wgt` F iob `l `ib tiklo

io intgvl rjal go irriohgoh t`l cgoionl/ Er Hjloki njuab ojt gostrunt F wgt`jut

Er Nirrgemlls kojwalbhl jr njoslot is t`l @irrgohtjo Eistlr Rrust Cuob t`l

cuob go w`gn` Er Hjlokis isslts wlrl `lab' wis wgt` `gs cgre! ^jelrslt/

^jelrslt wis i naglot jc iob t`lrlcjrl `ib i naglot innjuot wgt`' Fs cgre/

c' Er Nirrgemll kolw t`it Er Hjloki gotloblb tj painl airhl vjauel tribls go t`lcgoia slnjobs jc t`l najsgoh iuntgjo/ Er Nirrgemll iasj kolw t`it Er Hjloki

gotloblb tj slaa t`l stjnk t`l olxt biy iob t`it Er Hjloki wis joay gotlrlstlb go

t`l jccgngia najsgoh prgnl jc t`l stjnk jo i pirtgnuair bitl/

h' Er Nirrgemll kolw t`it Er Hjloki wiotlb tj painl `gs tribgoh gostruntgjos jo iouorlnjrblb agol iob lonjurihlb Er Hjloki tj splik wgt` F fy uorlnjrblbejfgal tj ejfgal tj ivjgb nrlitgoh rlnjrbs/

`' Jo t`l biy prgjr tj t`l Hizprje iuntgjo! Er Nirrgemll bgsnusslb t`l paioolbtribgoh wgt` F iob bgb ojt wiot tj kojw Er Hjlokis rlisjos cjr tribgoh/

@jwlvlr! gt wis nalir crje t`l rlnjrbgohs iob triosnrgpts jc t`l tlalp`jol

njovlrsitgjos govjavgoh Er Nirrgemll t`it `l wis iwirl t`it Er Hjloki wiotlb

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

29/44

67

tj ejvl t`l najsgoh prgnl/ X`lo! bul tj io uocjrlsllo ioojuonlelot! gt prjvlb

gepjssgfal tj lxlnutl t`l Hizprje paio! Er Nirrgemll sigb tj F t`it t`l hiel

wis iaa ifjut t`l najsgoh prgnl/

Go rlaitgjo tj Vlagionl

i' Er Nirrgemll wis iwirl crje t`l jutslt t`it Er Hjloki gotloblb tj tribl go fjt`Hizprje HBVs iob Vlagionl HBVs/ X`lo Er Hjloki sufslqulotay ipprjin`lb

Er Nirrgemll go rlaitgjo tj tribgoh Vlagionl HBVs go t`l Najsgoh Iuntgjo! Er

Nirrgemll iarliby kolw jc t`l liraglr! ifjrtlb tribgoh go rlaitgjo tj Hizprje/

R`it kojwalbhl tjhlt`lr wgt` Er Nirrgemlls prgjr suspgngjos t`it Er Hjloki

`lab i strunturlb prjbunt iob t`it eirklt eiogpuaitgjo wis `gs hjia eliot t`it

Er Nirrgemll wjuab `ivl fllo iwirl t`it Er Hjloki gotloblb tj lohihl go t`l

siel jr sgegair fl`ivgjur go rlaitgjo tj Vlagionl/

f' @ivgoh gotrjbunlb Er Hjloki tj F iob! `ivgoh najslay jvlrsllo t`l paioogoh joHizprje! Er Nirrgemll bgb ojt ollb tj fl iob wis ojt is plrsjoiaay govjavlb go

t`l Vlagionl HBVs tribgoh/ @jwlvlr! gt gs lvgblot crje t`l njotlepjrioljus

rlnjrbgohs iob triosnrgpts jc t`l tlalp`jol njovlrsitgjos govjavgoh Er Nirrgemll'

t`it `l wis iwirl jc w`it wis gotloblb/

n' Is wis t`l nisl wgt` Hizprje! Er Hjloki njuab ojt gostrunt F wgt`jut ErNirrgemlls kojwalbhl jr njoslot! is t`l @irrgohtjo Eistlr Rrust Cuob t`l cuob

go w`gn` Er Hjlokis isslts wlrl `lab' wis wgt` `gs cgre! ^jelrslt/ ^jelrslt

wis i naglot jc iob t`lrlcjrl `ib i naglot innjuot wgt`' Fs cgre/Ojtwgt`stiobgoh Er Nirrgemlls prgjr suspgngjos ifjut Er Hjlokis gotlotgjos

go rlaitgjo tj t`l ifjrtlb Hizprje HBVs tribgoh! `l wis njotlot tj iaajw Er

Hjloki tj splik tj iob bgrlntay triosint wgt` F go rlaitgjo tj t`l Vlagionl HBVs

tribgoh/

b' F ialrtlb iob*jr rlegoblb Er Nirrgemll jo 9< Jntjflr 6494 t`it Er Hjloki wisprlpirgoh tj tribl go Vlagionl HBVs iob t`it t`l ciaagoh stjnk prgnl wis i

prjfale/

l' Er Nirrgemll `ib ipprjvlb t`l cgoiongoh irriohlelots go rlaitgjo tj t`l VlagionlHBVs tribgoh/

3>/ Jo t`l fisgs jc t`l cints iob eittlrs sueeirgslb ifjvl! t`l C^I `is cjuob t`it ErNirrgemll rlnkalssay cingagtitlb Er Hjlokis paio tj lohihl go eirklt ifusl/ Blspgtl

Er Nirrgemlls suspgngjos is tj Er Hjlokis gotlotgjos! iob blspgtl Er Nirrgemlls

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

30/44

>4

stitus is io ipprjvlb plrsjo! splngcgniaay i ^GC `jablr wgt` t`l njepagionl jvlrsgh`t

cuontgjo it `gs cgre'! `l tjjk oj stlps tj prlvlot t`l ifusl iob cigalb tj eikl ioy

cgagohs go rlaitgjo tj t`l suspgngjus intgvgty/ Gostlib! Er Nirrgemll rlnkalssay n`jsl tj

bgsrlhirb iaa wirogoh sghos iob tjjk stlps tj cingagtitl Er Hjlokis eirklt

eiogpuaitgjo paio go rlaitgjo tj fjt` Hizprje HBVs iob Vlagionl HBVs/

32/ R`l stlps tiklo fy Er Nirrgemll tj cingagtitl Er Hjlokis paioolb eirklteiogpuaitgjo nio fl sueeirgslb is cjaajws=

i' Er Nirrgemll bgsnusslb iuntgjo tribgoh go rlaitgjo tj twj stjnks wgt` F iobgotrjbunlb Er Hjloki tj F cjr t`l lxprlss purpjsl jc tribgoh go t`l Najsgoh

Iuntgjos cjr Hizprje HBVs iob Vlagionl HBVs/ @l susplntlb t`it Er Hjloki

gotloblb tj sllk tj eiogpuaitl t`l prgnl jc slnurgtgls t`rjuh` iuntgjo tribgoh/ Er

Hjloki `ib oj prgjr bliagohs wgt` F/ Er Nirrgemll `ib kojwo F cjr

ipprjxgeitlay 94 ylirs iob kolw t`it F wis lxplrglonlb go iuntgjo tribgoh/

f' Er Nirrgemll wgaagohay pirtgngpitlb go i slrgls jc njoclrlonl niaas w`lrl ErHjloki bgsnusslb i oueflr jc lxiepals jc ejvgoh t`l prgnl jc stjnk go

njosgblrifal bltiga/ Er Nirrgemll wjuab `ivl fllo iwirl t`it Er Hjloki wis

gotlobgoh tj eiogpuaitl t`l najsgoh prgnl bltlregolb fy t`l iuntgjo/ Er

Nirrgemll issgstlb wgt` t`l irriohlelots cjr iob sn`lbuagoh jc t`l njoclrlonl

niaas/

n' Er Nirrgemll ihrllb tj Er Hjlokis usl jc ^jelrslts innjuot wgt` Fs cgre cjrt`l purpjsl jc t`l tribgoh go fjt` Hizprje HBVs iob Vlagionl HBVs iobjvlrsiw t`l cgoiongia irriohlelots cjr t`l cingagtitgjo jc t`l tribgoh/ Er

Nirrgemll iasj ibvgslb F go rlaitgjo tj t`l tribgoh agegts t`it wjuab fl olnlssiry

tj cingagtitl t`l tribgoh/

b' Er Nirrgemll prjvgblb gocjreitgjo tj F rlhirbgoh t`l paioolb tribgoh iob intlbis i njobugt fltwllo F iob Er Hjloki go rlaitgjo tj isplnts jc t`l paioogoh

gonaubgoh t`l cgoiongia isplnts jc t`l tribgoh/

l' Blspgtl `gs suspgngjos Er Nirrgemll turolb i fagob lyl tj Er Hjlokis purpjslcjr tribgoh/ Er Nirrgemll lonjurihlb Er Hjloki tj usl uorlnjrblb ejfgal

p`jols tj ivjgb nrlitgoh rlnjrbs/

c' Ojtwgt`stiobgoh Er Nirrgemlls suspgngjo higolb burgoh t`l ifjrtlb HizprjeHBVs tribgoh `l wis njotlot tj irriohl cjr Er Hjloki tj blia ihigo wgt` F iob

tj bgrlntay triosint go rlaitgjo tj t`l Vlagionl HBVs tribgoh/

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

31/44

>9

3' jc t`l Int t`l C^I `is t`lrlcjrl blngblb tj gepjsl i ploiatyjc sun` iejuot is gt njosgblrs ipprjprgitl jo Er Nirrgemll/

Cgtolss iob Trjprglty

84/ R`l C^I curt`lr njosgblrs t`it! is io ipprjvlb plrsjo! go cigagoh tj int wgt` gotlhrgty got`l eioolr blsnrgflb go rlaitgjo tj ^titlelot jc Trgongpal 9 ifjvl! Er Nirrgemll `is

blejostritlb t`it `l gs ojt i cgt iob prjplr plrsjo tj plrcjre ioy cuontgjo go rlaitgjo tj

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

32/44

>6

ioy rlhuaitlb intgvgty nirrglb jo fy ioy iut`jrgslb jr lxlept plrsjo jr lxlept

prjclssgjoia cgre/

89/ Ipprjvlb gobgvgbuias irl hitlkllplrs ihigost eirklt ifusl jc ioy kgob/ Ipprjvlbgobgvgbuias s`juab t`lrlcjrl prjvgbl crjot%agol prjtlntgjo ihigost ifusgvl intgvgty iob

ojt int is loifalrs/ Go Er Nirrgemlls nisl `l wis ojt joay io ipprjvlb plrsjo fut iasj

`lab sghogcgniot gocaulonl cuontgjos cjr `gs cgre w`gn` lxinlrfitl t`l slrgjusolss jc `gs

njobunt/ R`l C^I njosgblrs t`it Er Nirrgemlls njobunt it t`l tgel jc t`l intgvgty

blsnrgflb go t`gs Blngsgjo Ojtgnl blejostritls t`it `l gs prlpirlb tj rlnkalssay

cingagtitl eirklt ifusl/

86/ Is sun`! Er Nirrgemll gs ojt cgt iob prjplr tj `jab io ipprjvlb cuontgjo jr tj plrcjreioy cuontgjo go rlaitgjo tj ioy rlhuaitlb intgvgty nirrglb jo fy ioy iut`jrgslb jr lxlept

plrsjo jr lxlept prjclssgjoia cgre/

^IONRGJO

8>/ \oblr slntgjo 33>' jc t`l Int! t`l C^I eiy gepjsl i ploiaty jo ioy ipprjvlb plrsjogc gt gs sitgscglb t`it `l `is cigalb tj njepay wgt` i ^titlelot jc Trgongpal/

82/ R`l C^Is pjagny jo gepjsgoh i cgoiongia ploiaty gs slt jut go N`iptlr 3 jc BLTT!rlalviot lxnlrpts jc w`gn` irl njotigolb go t`l Ioolx/

8

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

33/44

>>

80/ R`l C^I ippagls i cgvl%stlp crielwjrk tj bltlregol t`l ipprjprgitl alvla jc cgoiongiaploiaty/ BLTT 3/

02/ R`l plrnlotihl jc Er Nirrgemlls gonjel w`gn` wgaa cjre t`l fisgs jc t`l ^tlp 6 cghurlblplobs jo t`l slrgjusolss jc t`l frlin`/ R`l slrgjusolss jc t`l frlin` wgaa fl

isslsslb jo i snial jc 9 alist slrgjus' tj < ejst slrgjus' blplobgoh jo t`l gepint iob

oiturl jc t`l frlin` iob w`lt`lr gt wis njeegttlb blagflritlay jr rlnkalssay/

0

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

34/44

>2

03/ R`l C^I njosgblrs Er Nirrgemlls njobunt tj fl pirtgnuairay slrgjus! cjr t`l cjaajwgohrlisjos=

i' @gs njobunt wis rlnkalss/ Er Nirrgemll susplntlb t`it Er Hjloki `ib iouatlrgjr ejtgvl cjr `gs tribgoh iob wiotlb tj eiogpuaitl t`l prgnl jc Hizprje

HBVs iob Vlagionl HBVs/ Blspgtl t`it `l wgacuaay turolb i fagob lyl tj t`l rgsk

jc Er Hjlokis paioolb eirklt ifusl/ Er Nirrgemll cigalb tj tikl ioy stlps tj

rlpjrt jr prlvlot t`l eirklt ifusl iob n`jsl gostlib tj rlnkalssay issgst Er

Hjloki tj gepalelot `gs paio tj eiogpuaitl fjt` Hizprje HBVs iob Vlagionl

HBVs/

f' Er Nirrgemll wis ^jelrslts N`glc Lxlnutgvl iob io ipprjvlb plrsjo/ R`legsnjobunt wis nirrglb jut go rlaitgjo tj t`l plrcjreionl jc Er Nirrgemlls

nustjelr cuontgjo! oielay t`l prjvgsgjo jc govlstelot ibvgnl/ Go ibbgtgjo! Er

Nirrgemll wis iasj i ^GC `jablr! wgt` t`l cuontgjos jc N`glc lxlnutgvl!Njepagionl jvlrsgh`t! Tirtolr iob Ejoly aiuoblrgoh rlpjrtgoh cjr ^jelrslt/ Er

Nirrgemll gs io lxplrglonlb cgoiongia slrvgnls gobustry prjclssgjoia/ @l `ib

rlnlgvlb trigogoh jo t`l eirklt ifusl rlhgel/

n' Er Nirrgemll put Er Hjloki go tjun` wgt` F iob issgstlb Er Hjloki tj put gopainl irriohlelots gotloblb tj loifal Er Hjloki tj slnurl t`l najsgoh prgnl jc

Hizprje iob Vlagionl HBVs it i ciasl jr irtgcgngia alvla/

b' I njoslqulonl jc `gs intgjos! go issgstgoh Er Hjloki! wis i slrgjus bgsruptgjo jct`l eirklt jo 90 Jntjflr 6494 fy irtgcgngiaay gonrlisgoh t`l prgnl jc VlagionlHBVs/ R`gs pjslb i t`rlit tj t`l jrblragolss jc iob njocgblonl go t`it eirklt/ Gt

curt`lr alb tj i sghogcgniot ajss jc ipprjxgeitlay \^B >/9 egaagjo' cjr t`l fiok

t`it wis t`l njuotlrpirty tj Er Hjlokis ^trunturlb Trjbunt 6/

l' @gs intgjos wlrl rlplitlb! go t`it `l issgstlb Er Hjloki go lcclntgoh `gs paio tjeiogpuaitl t`l najsgoh prgnl cjr Hizprje HBVs go Iprga 6494 iob wis govjavlb

go t`l prlagegoiry stihls go rlaitgjo tj Vlagionl HBVs go Jntjflr 6494/

c' Er Nirrgemll flolcgttlb plrsjoiaay crje `gs njobunt t`rjuh` t`l rltlotgjo jc ErHjlokis fusgolss cjr ^jelrslt! flgoh t`l cgre go w`gn` `l `ib i sufstiotgiagotlrlst/

08/ Rikgoh gotj innjuot t`lsl cintjrs! t`l C^I njosgblrs Er Nirrgemlls njobunt tj fl italvla < ejst slrgjus' go tlres jc gts slrgjusolss/

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

35/44

>3

^tlp

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

37/44

>8

94>/ R`l C^I gs sitgscglb t`it gt gs ipprjprgitl go t`l ngrnuestionls jc t`gs nisl tj eikl iprj`gfgtgjo jrblr go rlsplnt jc Er Nirrgemll go ibbgtgjo tj wgt`briwgoh `gs lxgstgoh

ipprjvias iob gepjsgoh t`l cgoiongia ploiaty slt jut ifjvl/

TVJNLB\VIA EIRRLV^

Blngsgjo Eiklr

942/ R`l blngsgjo w`gn` hivl rgsl tj t`l jfaghitgjo tj hgvl t`gs Blngsgjo Ojtgnl wis eibl fyt`l Vlhuaitjry Blngsgjos Njeegttll/

9400 jc t`l Int/ R`l cjaajwgoh stitutjry rgh ts irl

gepjrtiot/

\pplr Rrgfuoia

943/ Er Nirrgemll iob ^jelrslt `ivl t`l rgh`t tj rlclr t`l eittlr tj w`gn` t`gs BlngsgjoOjtgnl rlaitls tj t`l \pplr Rrgfuoia/ \oblr pirihrip` 66' jc ^n`lbual > jc t`l

Rrgfuoia Trjnlburl \pplr Rrgfuoia' Vuals 6440! Er Nirrgemll iob ^jelrslt `ivl 60

biys crje t`l bitl jo w`gn` t`gs Blngsgjo Ojtgnl gs hgvlo tj t`le tj rlclr t`l eittlr tj

t`l \pplr Rrgfuoia/ I rlclrlonl tj t`l Rrgfuoia gs eibl fy wiy jc i sgholb rlclrlonl

ojtgnl Cjre CRN>' cgalb wgt` i njpy jc t`gs Blngsgjo Ojtgnl/ R`l Rrgfuoias ibbrlss

gs= R`l \pplr Rrgfuoia! Rix iob N`ionlry N`ieflr! 2< Flbcjrb ^quirl! Ajobjo

XN9F >BO tla= 464 8396 7844; leiga cgoionliobtixippliasDtrgfuoias/hsg/hjv/uk'/

Curt`lr bltigas irl njotigolb go Eikgoh i Vlclrlonl tj t`l \TTLV RVGF\OIA Rix

iob N`ionlry N`ieflr' w`gn` gs ivigaifal crje t`l \pplr Rrgfuoia wlfsgtl=

`ttp=**www/trgfuoias/hjv/uk*cgoionliobtix*CjresHugbionl/`te

948/ Er Nirrgemll iob ^jelrslt s`juab ojtl t`it i njpy jc t`l rlclrlonl ojtgnl CjreCRN>' eust iasj fl slot tj t`l C^I it t`l siel tgel is cgagoh i rlclrlonl wgt` t`l

\pplr Rrgfuoia/ I njpy jc t`l rlclrlonl ojtgnl s`juab fl slot tj Klvgo R`jrpl it t`l

C^I! 6< R`l Ojrt` Njajooibl! Nioiry X`irc! Ajobjo L92

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

38/44

>0

Innlss tj lvgblonl

940/ ^lntgjo >72 jc t`l Int ippagls tj t`gs Blngsgjo Ojtgnl/ Go innjrbionl wgt` slntgjo >72!Er Nirrgemll iob ^jelrslt irl lotgtalb tj `ivl innlss tj t`l=

i' t`l eitlrgia upjo w`gn` t`l C^I `is rlaglb go blngbgoh tj hgvl t`gs BlngsgjoOjtgnl; iob

f' t`l slnjobiry eitlrgia w`gn`! go t`l jpgogjo jc t`l C^I! egh`t uoblregol t`itblngsgjo/

947/ Er Nirrgemll iob ^jelrslt `ivl fllo prjvgblb wgt` iaa t`l eitlrgia tj w`gn` t`l C^Ieust hriot t`le innlss/

Njocgblotgiagty iob pufagngty

994/ Er Nirrgemll iob ^jelrslt s`juab ojtl t`it t`gs Blngsgjo Ojtgnl eiy njotigonjocgblotgia gocjreitgjo iob s`juab ojt fl bgsnajslb tj i t`grb pirty lxnlpt cjr t`l

purpjsl jc jftigogoh ibvgnl jo gts njotlots'/ R`l lcclnt jc slntgjo >79 jc t`l Int gs t`it

olgt`lr Er Nirrgemll! ^jelrslt ojr i plrsjo tj w`je t`gs Blngsgjo Ojtgnl gs njpglb

eiy pufags` gt jr ioy bltigas njonlrogoh gt uoalss t`l C^I `is pufags`lb t`l Blngsgjo

Ojtgnl jr t`jsl bltigas/ R`l C^I eust pufags` sun` gocjreitgjo ifjut t`l eittlr tj

w`gn` i Blngsgjo Ojtgnl jr Cgoia Ojtgnl rlaitls is gt njosgblrs ipprjprgitl/ Er

Nirrgemll iob ^jelrslt s`juab fl iwirl! t`lrlcjrl! t`it t`l cints iob eittlrs njotigolb

go t`gs Blngsgjo Ojtgnl eiy fl eibl pufagn/

C^I njotint

999/ Cjr ejrl gocjreitgjo njonlrogoh t`gs eittlr hlolriaay! Er Nirrgemll iob ^jelrslts`juab njotint Klvgo R`jrpl go t`l Locjrnlelot iob Cgoiongia Nrgel Bgvgsgjo jc t`l

C^I bgrlnt agol= 464 8433 22

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

39/44

>7

IOOLP= Vlalviot ^titutjry iob Vlhuaitjry Trjvgsgjos

^titutjry prjvgsgjos

9/ R`l C^Is stitutjry jfmlntgvls! slt jut go ^lntgjo 66' jc t`l Int! irl eigotigogoheirklt njocgblonl! t`l prjtlntgjo jc njosuelrs! t`l rlbuntgjo jc cgoiongia nrgel iob t`l

stifgagty jc t`l \K cgoiongia systle/

6/ R`l C^I eiy prj`gfgt io gobgvgbuia crje nirrygoh jut rlhuaitlb intgvgtgls uoblr slntgjo' I prj`gfgtgjo jrblr eiy rlaitl tj

i' i splngcglb rlhuaitlb intgvgty! ioy rlhuaitlb intgvgty ciaagoh wgt`go i

splngcglb blsnrgptgjo jr iaa rlhuaitlb intgvgtgls;

f' iut`jrgslb plrsjos hlolriaay jr ioy plrsjo wgt`go i splngcglb naiss jciut`jrgslb plrsjos/

>/ R`l C^I eiy iasj wgt`briw io gobgvgbuias lxgstgoh ipprjvia tj plrcjre i njotrjaalbcuontgjo uoblr slntgjo 3> jc t`l Int w`gn` stitls=

9' R`l Iut`jrgty eiy wgt`briw io ipprjvia hgvlo uoblr slntgjo

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

40/44

24

f' t`l Iut`jrgty gs sitgscglb t`it gt gs ipprjprgitl go iaa t`l ngrnuestionls tjtikl intgjo ihigost `ge/

6' I plrsjo gs hugaty jc egsnjobunt gc! w`gal io ipprjvlb plrsjo

i' `l `is cigalb tj njepay wgt` i stitlelot jc prgongpal gssulb uoblr slntgjo

32; jr

f' `l `is fllo kojwgohay njonlrolb go i njotrivlotgjo fy t`l rlalviotiut`jrgslb plrsjo jc i rlqugrlelot gepjslb jo t`it iut`jrgslb plrsjo fy

jr uoblr t`gs Int

>' Gc t`l Iut`jrgty gs lotgtalb tj tikl intgjo uoblr t`gs slntgjo ihigost i plrsjo! gteiy

i' gepjsl i ploiaty jo `ge jc sun` iejuot is gt njosgblrs ipprjprgitl;

ii' susplob! cjr sun` plrgjb is gt njosgblrs ipprjprgitl! ioy ipprjvia jc t`l

plrcjreionl fy `ge jc ioy cuontgjo tj w`gn` t`l ipprjvia rlaitls;

if' gepjsl! cjr sun` plrgjb is gt njosgblrs ipprjprgitl! sun` agegtitgjos jrjt`lr rlstrgntgjos go rlaitgjo tj t`l plrcjreionl fy `ge jc ioy cuontgjo tjw`gn` ioy ipprjvia rlaitls is gt njosgblrs ipprjprgitl;

f' pufags` i stitlelot jc `gs egsnjobunt

C^I @iobfjjk

iob ITLV 2/

http://fsahandbook.info/FSA/glossary-html/handbook/Glossary/A?definition=G65http://fsahandbook.info/FSA/glossary-html/handbook/Glossary/C?definition=G224http://fsahandbook.info/FSA/glossary-html/handbook/Glossary/C?definition=G224http://fsahandbook.info/FSA/glossary-html/handbook/Glossary/C?definition=G224http://fsahandbook.info/FSA/glossary-html/handbook/Glossary/C?definition=G224http://fsahandbook.info/FSA/glossary-html/handbook/Glossary/A?definition=G65

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

41/44

29

7/ ITLV >/9/9H stitls t`it t`l purpjsl jc t`gs njbl gs tj `lap bltlregol w`lt`lr jr ojt ioipprjvlb plrsjos njobunt njepagls wgt` i ^titlelot jc Trgongpal/

94/ ITLV >/9/>H stitls t`it t`l sghogcgnionl jc njobunt gblotgcglb go t`l Njbl jc Trintgnlcjr Ipprjvlb Tlrsjos is tlobgoh tj lstifags` njepagionl wgt` jr i frlin` jc i

^titlelot jc Trgongpal wgaa fl isslsslb joay ictlr iaa t`l ngrnuestionls jc i pirtgnuairnisl `ivl fllo njosgblrlb/ Innjuot wgaa fl tiklo jc t`l njotlxt go w`gn` i njursl jc

njobunt wis uoblrtiklo! gonaubgoh t`l prlngsl ngrnuestionls jc t`l gobgvgbuia nisl! t`l

n`irintlrgstgns jc t`l pirtgnuair njotrjaalb cuontgjo iob t`l fl`ivgjur tj fl lxplntlb go

t`it cuontgjo/

99/ ITLV >/9/29'H stitls t`it io ipprjvlb plrsjo wgaa joay fl go frlin` jc i ^titlelot jcTrgongpal w`lrl `l gs plrsjoiaay nuapifal/ Tlrsjoia nuapifgagty irgsls w`lrl io ipprjvlb

plrsjo(s njobunt wis blagflritl jr w`lrl t`l ipprjvlb plrsjo(s stiobirb jc njobunt wis

flajw t`it w`gn` wjuab fl rlisjoifal go iaa t`l ngrnuestionls/

96/ ITLV >/9/8H stitls t`it ^titlelots jc Trgongpal 9 tj 2 ippay tj iaa ipprjvlb plrsjos/ Got`l ^titlelots jc Trgongpal iob go t`l Njbl jc Trintgnl cjr Ipprjvlb Tlrsjos! i

rlclrlonl tj &`gs njotrjaalb cuontgjo& gs i rlclrlonl tj t`l njotrjaalb cuontgjo tj w`gn`

t`l ipprjvia rlaitls/

9>/ ITLV >/6/96'L stitls t`it go bltlregogoh w`lt`lr jr ojt t`l pirtgnuair njobunt jc ioipprjvlb plrsjo wgt`go `gs njotrjaalb cuontgjo njepagls wgt` t`l ^titlelots jc

Trgongpal! t`l C^I wgaa tikl gotj innjuot w`lt`lr t`l njobunt rlaitls tj intgvgtgls t`it

irl sufmlnt tj jt`lr prjvgsgjos jc t`l C^I @iobfjjk iob w`lt`lr t`l njobunt gs

njosgstlot wgt` t`l rlqugrlelots iob stiobirbs jc t`l rlhuaitjry systle rlalviot tj t`l

cgre go qulstgjo/

Locjrnlelot Hugbl (LH'

92/ Tirihrip` 7/9 prjvgbls io gotrjbuntgjo tj t`l C^I usgoh gts pjwlrs tj prj`gfgt uoblrslntgjo

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

42/44

26

R`l C^I(s lcclntgvl usl jc t`l pjwlr uoblr slntgjo 3> jc t`l Int tj wgt`briwipprjvia crje io ipprjvlb plrsjo wgaa iasj `lap losurl `gh` stiobirbs jcrlhuaitjry njobunt fy prlvlotgoh io ipprjvlb plrsjo crje njotgougoh tj plrcjre

t`l njotrjaalb cuontgjo tj w`gn` t`l ipprjvia rlaitls gc `l gs ojt i cgt iob prjplrplrsjo tj plrcjre t`it cuontgjo/ X`lrl gt njosgblrs t`gs gs ipprjprgitl! t`l C^I

eiy prj`gfgt io ipprjvlb plrsjo! go ibbgtgjo tj wgt`briwgoh t`lgr ipprjvia/

93/ Tirihrip`s 7/> tj 7/8 jc LH t`lo slt jut t`l C^Is hlolria pjagny go rlaitgjo tjprj`gfgtgjo jrblrs iob wgt`briwia jc ipprjvia/ Tirihrip` 7/2! cjr lxiepal! stitls=

R`l C^I `is t`l pjwlr tj eikl i riohl jc prj`gfgtgjo jrblrs blplobgoh jo t`l

ngrnuestionls jc lin` nisl iob t`l riohl jc rlhuaitlb intgvgtgls tj w`gn` t`lgobgvgbuia(s aink jc cgtolss iob prjprglty gs rlalviot/ Blplobgoh jo t`lngrnuestionls jc lin` nisl! t`l C^I eiy sllk tj prj`gfgt gobgvgbuias crje

plrcjregoh ioy naiss jc cuontgjo go rlaitgjo tj ioy naiss jc rlhuaitlb intgvgty! jr

gt eiy agegt t`l prj`gfgtgjo jrblr tj splngcgn cuontgjos go rlaitgjo tj splngcgnrlhuaitlb intgvgtgls/ R`l C^I eiy iasj eikl io jrblr prj`gfgtgoh io gobgvgbuiacrje flgoh lepajylb fy i pirtgnuair cgre! typl jc cgre jr ioy cgre/

98/ Tirihrip`s 7/0 tj 7/92 jc LH slt jut ibbgtgjoia hugbionl jo t`l C^Is ipprjin` tjeikgoh prj`gfgtgjo jrblrs ihigost ipprjvlb plrsjos jr wgt`briwgoh sun` plrsjos

ipprjvias/

90/ Tirihrip` 7/7 jc LH prjvgbls t`it w`lo njosgblrgoh w`lt`lr tj lxlrngsl gts pjwlr tjeikl i prj`gfgtgjo jrblr ihigost sun` io gobgvgbuia! t`l C^I wgaa njosgblr iaa t`lrlalviot ngrnuestionls jc t`l nisl! w`gn` eiy gonaubl t`l cjaajwgoh fut irl ojt agegtlb

tj t`lsl cintjrs'=

9' R`l eittlrs slt jut go slntgjo 396' jc t`l Int/

6' X`lt`lr t`l gobgvgbuia gs cgt iob prjplr tj plrcjre cuontgjos go rlaitgjo tj

rlhuaitlb intgvgtgls/ R`l nrgtlrgi cjr isslssgoh t`l cgtolss iob prjprglty jcipprjvlb plrsjos irl slt jut go CGR 6/9 @jolsty! gotlhrgty iob rlputitgjo'; CGR6/6 Njepltlonl iob nipifgagty' iob CGR 6/> Cgoiongia sjuobolss'/

>' X`lt`lr! iob tj w`it lxtlot! t`l ipprjvlb plrsjo `is=

i' cigalb tj njepay wgt` t`l ^titlelots jc Trgongpal gssulb fy t`l C^I wgt`rlsplnt tj t`l njobunt jc ipprjvlb plrsjos; jr

f' fllo kojwgohay njonlrolb go i njotrivlotgjo fy t`l rlalviot cgre jc irlqugrlelot gepjslb jo t`l cgre fy jr uoblr t`l Int gonaubgoh t`l

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

43/44

2>

Trgongpals iob jt`lr ruals' jr cigalb tj njepay wgt` ioy bgrlntay ippagnifalNjeeuogty rlhuaitgjo eibl uoblr EgCGB/

2' X`lt`lr t`l ipprjvlb plrsjo `is lohihlb go eirklt ifusl/

jc LH prjvgbls t`it nlrtigo eittlrs t`it bj ojt cgt squirlay! jr it iaa!wgt`go t`l eittlrs agstlb eiy iasj ciaa tj fl njosgblrlb/ Go sun` ngrnuestionls! t`l C^I

wgaa njosgblr w`lt`lr t`l njobunt jr eittlr go qulstgjo gs rlalviot tj t`l gobgvgbuias

cgtolss iob prjprglty/

69/ Tirihrip` 7/6> jc LH prjvgbls t`it i prj`gfgtgjo jrblr iob*jr wgt`briwia jc ipprjviaeiy fl njefgolb wgt` jt`lr siontgjos sun` is t`l gepjsgtgjo jc i cgoiongia ploiaty'

w`lrl ipprjprgitl/

Cgt iob Trjplr Rlst cjr Ipprjvlb Tlrsjos (CGR'

66/ CGR H 9/>/9 stitls t`it t`l C^I wgaa `ivl rlhirb tj i oueflr jc cintjrs w`lo isslssgoht`l cgtolss iob prjprglty jc i plrsjo tj plrcjre i pirtgnuair njotrjaalb cuontgjo/ R`l

ejst gepjrtiot njosgblritgjos wgaa fl t`l plrsjos=

9' `jolsty! gotlhrgty iob rlputitgjo;

7/29/2019 UK FCA's Decision Notice to Tariq Carrimjee

44/44

6' njepltlonl iob nipifgagty; iob

>' cgoiongia sjuobolss/

6>/ CGR 9/>/> stitls=R`l nrgtlrgi agstlb go CGR 6/9 tj CGR 6/> irl hugbionl iob wgaa fl ippaglb gohlolria tlres w`lo t`l C^I gs bltlregogoh i plrsjo(s cgtolss iob prjprglty/ Gtwjuab fl gepjssgfal tj prjbunl i blcgogtgvl agst jc iaa t`l eittlrs w`gn` wjuab flrlalviot tj i pirtgnuair bltlregoitgjo/

62/ CGR 9/>/2 stitls=Gc i eittlr njels tj t`l C^I(s ittlotgjo w`gn` suhhlsts t`it t`l plrsjo egh`t ojt

fl cgt iob prjplr! t`l C^I wgaa tikl gotj innjuot `jw rlalviot iob `jw gepjrtiotgt gs/

Blngsgjo Trjnlburls iob Tloiatgls Eiouia (BLTT'

6