+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Utilization of Cement Kiln Dust in Concrete Manufacturing

Utilization of Cement Kiln Dust in Concrete Manufacturing

Date post: 16-Oct-2021
Category:
Upload: others
View: 3 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
15
Jordan Journal of Civil Engineering, Volume 7, No. 1, 2013 - 111 - Utilization of Cement Kiln Dust in Concrete Manufacturing Zainab Hasan Abdulabbas M.Sc., Construction Materials Engineering, College of Engineering, University of Kufa, Al-Najaf Al-Ashraf. Iraq. E-Mail: [email protected] ABSTRACT The present study aims to assess the properties of concrete containing cement kiln dust (CKD). Concrete specimens were prepared with 0% CKD, (10% and 20% CKD) as a replacement of cement weight, (10% and 20% CKD) as an addition of cement weight and 20% CKD as an addition of cement weight with super plasticizers. Ordinary Portland cement (O.P.C.) (ASTM C 150 Type I) and sulphate resisting Portland cement (S.R.P.C.) (ASTM C 150 Type V) were used throughout this investigation. The properties of concrete specimens were evaluated by measuring workability (using slump test), compressive strength, splitting tensile strength and absorption. The results of slump test showed that the using of CKD in concrete mixtures increases the water demand for a constant consistency. The compressive strength increased in the concrete mixtures including 10% and 20% CKD (as an addition of cement weight). A decrease in the compressive strength was noted in the concrete mixtures including 10% and 20% CKD (as a replacement of cement weight). A similar trend was noted in the splitting tensile strength and the increase in splitting tensile strength was less pronounced than that in compressive strength. The absorption percent increased when CKD was used in concrete mixtures. The using of super plasticizers enhanced workability, compressive strength, splitting tensile strength and absorption of the concrete for the two types of cement. The ordinary Portland cement concrete mixtures and the sulphate resisting Portland cement concrete mixtures including CKD had almost the same behaviors. KEYWORDS: Cement kiln dust (CKD), Portland cement, Mechanical properties of concrete, Absorption of concrete, Workability, Super plasticizers. INTRODUCTION A large quantity of dust, commonly known as cement kiln dust (CKD), is produced during the production of Portland cement. The bulk of this dust, mostly with high alkali contents, filled land with a significant financial loss to the local cement industry in terms of the value of raw materials, processing, energy consumption during preprocessing, dust collection and disposal (Daous, 2004). With modern manufacturing techniques, it is technically possible to introduce most of the CKD back into the clinker-making process. However, it is not done due to the high alkali content in the CKD. Most international specifications restrict the alkali content in cement to less than 0.6% equivalent of Na 2 O to avoid the possibility of alkali-aggregate reaction. Recently, there has been a trend of utilizing CKD in soil stabilization, treatment of sewage,… etc. Also, attempts were made at utilizing it in cement products. Most of the studies conducted so far have been restricted to assessing the properties of cement mortars (Maslehuddin et al., 2009). Wang et al. (2002) investigated the characteristics of a binder system containing cement kiln dust CKD, Accepted for Publication on 13/11/2012. © 2013 JUST. All Rights Reserved.
Transcript
Page 1: Utilization of Cement Kiln Dust in Concrete Manufacturing

Jordan Journal of Civil Engineering, Volume 7, No. 1, 2013

- 111 -

Utilization of Cement Kiln Dust in Concrete Manufacturing

Zainab Hasan Abdulabbas

M.Sc., Construction Materials Engineering, College of Engineering, University of Kufa, Al-Najaf Al-Ashraf.

Iraq. E-Mail: [email protected]

ABSTRACT The present study aims to assess the properties of concrete containing cement kiln dust (CKD). Concrete specimens were prepared with 0% CKD, (10% and 20% CKD) as a replacement of cement weight, (10% and 20% CKD) as an addition of cement weight and 20% CKD as an addition of cement weight with super plasticizers. Ordinary Portland cement (O.P.C.) (ASTM C 150 Type I) and sulphate resisting Portland cement (S.R.P.C.) (ASTM C 150 Type V) were used throughout this investigation. The properties of concrete specimens were evaluated by measuring workability (using slump test), compressive strength, splitting tensile strength and absorption. The results of slump test showed that the using of CKD in concrete mixtures increases the water demand for a constant consistency. The compressive strength increased in the concrete mixtures including 10% and 20% CKD (as an addition of cement weight). A decrease in the compressive strength was noted in the concrete mixtures including 10% and 20% CKD (as a replacement of cement weight). A similar trend was noted in the splitting tensile strength and the increase in splitting tensile strength was less pronounced than that in compressive strength. The absorption percent increased when CKD was used in concrete mixtures. The using of super plasticizers enhanced workability, compressive strength, splitting tensile strength and absorption of the concrete for the two types of cement. The ordinary Portland cement concrete mixtures and the sulphate resisting Portland cement concrete mixtures including CKD had almost the same behaviors.

KEYWORDS: Cement kiln dust (CKD), Portland cement, Mechanical properties of concrete, Absorption of concrete, Workability, Super plasticizers.

INTRODUCTION

A large quantity of dust, commonly known as

cement kiln dust (CKD), is produced during the production of Portland cement. The bulk of this dust, mostly with high alkali contents, filled land with a significant financial loss to the local cement industry in terms of the value of raw materials, processing, energy consumption during preprocessing, dust collection and disposal (Daous, 2004). With modern manufacturing techniques, it is technically possible to introduce most

of the CKD back into the clinker-making process. However, it is not done due to the high alkali content in the CKD. Most international specifications restrict the alkali content in cement to less than 0.6% equivalent of Na2O to avoid the possibility of alkali-aggregate reaction. Recently, there has been a trend of utilizing CKD in soil stabilization, treatment of sewage,… etc. Also, attempts were made at utilizing it in cement products. Most of the studies conducted so far have been restricted to assessing the properties of cement mortars (Maslehuddin et al., 2009).

Wang et al. (2002) investigated the characteristics of a binder system containing cement kiln dust CKD, Accepted for Publication on 13/11/2012.

© 2013 JUST. All Rights Reserved.

Page 2: Utilization of Cement Kiln Dust in Concrete Manufacturing

Utilization of Cement… Zainab Hasan Abdulabbas

- 112 -

blast-furnace slag and O.P.C. The system consists of 0 to 50% CKD and 0 to 75% slag replacement for O.P.C., with a total amount of supplementary cementitious materials equal to or less than 75%. The study evaluated the heat of hydration, rheological behavior and flexural and compressive strengths of pastes and mortars made with these binders. It also examined the effects of binder proportions on concrete properties. Tests demonstrated that properly designed O.P.C.-CKD-slag binders display properties comparable to pure O.P.C. or an O.P.C.-CKD blend. A CKD-slag specimen made without Portland cement also displayed satisfactory compressive and flexural strengths. This indicated that alkalis released from CKD may activate slag hydration.

Daous (2004) reported results of an investigation into the usage of CKD and fly ash in concrete. Test results showed that satisfactory mechanical strength (a minimum of 94% of compressive strength of ordinary Portland cement) could still be achieved in blends utilizing 90% cement and not more than 4% fly ash. Adequate mechanical strengths (a minimum of 80% of compressive strength of Portland cement) were achieved in blends utilizing as little as 70% cement when only kiln dust was blended.

Maslehuddin et al. (2009) evaluated the properties of cement kiln dust (CKD) blended cement concretes. The percentages of CKD were 0%, 5%, 10% and 15%, replacing cement ASTM C 150 Type I and Type V. The results showed that the compressive strength of concrete specimens decreased with the quantity of CKD. However, there was no significant difference in the compressive strength of 0 and 5% CKD cement concretes. A similar trend was noted in the drying shrinkage strain. The chloride permeability increased and the electrical resistivity decreased due to the incorporation of CKD. The performance of concrete with 5%, CKD was almost similar to that of concrete without CKD. Therefore, they suggested to limit the amount of CKD in concrete to 5%, since the chloride permeability and electrical resistivity data indicated that the chances of reinforcement corrosion would

increase with 10% and 15% CKD. Al-Mabrook (2010) studied the ability of using

CKD in mortar and hollow cement bricks. The percentages of CKD were 10%, 20%, 30%, 40% and 50% replacing cement. The best results of compressive strength were in mixtures containing 30% CKD. The absorption percents were within the limit of standard specifications for all mixtures. By using the chemical analysis of samples taken from all mixtures, it was concluded that: (a) there was an increase in C3S with the increase of CKD in mixtures, and that led to an increase in compressive strength at early ages. (b) there was a decrease in C2S associated with the increase in C3S.

Rahman et al. (2011) investigated the possibility of using CKD in the manufacturing of bricks. 12 different types of mortar bricks were investigated. Half of these mixes were prepared with crushed aggregates of limestone origin (Designated as Type-N). The other half were prepared with a mixture of light-weight aggregate of pozzolanic origin (from Western Saudi Arabia) and limestone aggregate (Designated as Type-P). In each of the two groups of specimens, the only variable was the content of CKD addition to each mixture. Six CKD additions were used in each group 0%, 10%, 20%, 30%, 40% and 50% by weight of cement. For Type-N blocks, the strength of the block increases from 52% to 82% at various percentages of CKD added. For Type-P blocks, the strength of the block increases from 38% to about 147% at various percentages of CKD added. The optimum dosage of CKD addition is 20% for both types of blocks (type N and type P). However, the improvement seemed to be higher when light-weight pozzolanic aggregate was used. For this type of aggregate, the increase in strength of the blocks was about 1.5 times when 20% CKD was added to the mix. At 30% CKD, a 75% increase in strength was observed. From these results, it could be concluded that CKD may be used in the future for replacing cement in the blocks without sacrificing the strength of the blocks.

This study was conducted to reveal the behavior of

Page 3: Utilization of Cement Kiln Dust in Concrete Manufacturing

Jordan Journal of Civil Engineering, Volume 7, No. 1, 2013

- 113 -

concrete incorporating from various percentages of CKD and evaluate its workability, compressive

strength, splitting tensile strength and absorption.

Table 1. Grading of sand and the requirements of IQS No.45 : 1984, zone 3

Table 2. Properties of sand

IQS 45:1984 limits Test results Property - 2.65 specific gravity - 1.2 absorption

≤ 0.5 0.32 sulfate content (SO3) ≤ 3.0 2.1 clay

Table 3. Grading of coarse aggregate

IQS No.45 : 1984 limits Percent passing Sieve size (mm)

100 100 37.5 95-100 100 20 30-60 58 10 0-10 8 5

Table 4. Properties of coarse aggregate

IQS 45:1984 limits Test results Property

- 2.6 specific gravity - 0.8 absorption

≤ 0.1 0.07 sulfate content (SO3) ≤ 1.0 0.5 clay

EXPERIMENTAL PROGRAM

MATERIALS Cement: Ordinary Portland Cement (O.P.C.)

(ASTM C 150 Type I) and sulphate Resisting Portland Cement (S.R.P.C.) (ASTM C 150 Type V) were used throughout this study, and they were accomplished according to the Iraqi standard specification (IQS No.5: 1984).

Fine Aggregate: Natural sand, from Al-Najaf sea region, was used as a fine aggregate. Its grading conformed to the Iraqi specification (IQS No.45 : 1984, zone 3) as shown in Table (1). The properties of the sand are listed in Table (2).

Coarse Aggregate: Crushed gravel with a maximum size of 20 mm was used in this investigation. Table (3) shows the grading of coarse aggregate which

IQS No.45 : 1984, zone 3 Percent passing Sieve size (mm)

100 100 10 90-100 98.7 4.75 85-100 90.75 2.36 75-100 81.86 0.15 60-75 65.18 0.6 12-40 20.7 0.3 10-0 4.6 0.15

Page 4: Utilization of Cement Kiln Dust in Concrete Manufacturing

Utilization of Cement… Zainab Hasan Abdulabbas

- 114 -

complied with the Iraqi specification No.45:1984. The properties of the coarse aggregate are illustrated in Table (4).

Cement Kiln Dust (CKD): Cement kiln dust produced in New Kufa Cement Plant as waste material was used in this study. It was passed through a sieve of size (0.15 mm). The chemical properties of CKD are reported in Table (5).

Water: Tab water was used for both mixing and

curing of concrete. Super plasticizers: Two types of super plasticizers

(high-range water reducing) were used throughout this study. The first type is called Glenium 51. It has accelerating effects on concrete. The second type is called (Flocrete W52) which reduces the permeability of concrete. The two types of super plasticizers comply with ASTM C 494. The typical properties of super plasticizers are shown in Table (6).

Table 5. Chemical properties of CKD

chlorides L.O.I. Na2O K2O SO3 MgO CaO Fe2O3 Al2O3 SiO3 Composition

0.92 28.86 1.42 2.44 6.34 2.98 43.4 3.05 3.41 15.46 Percent

Table 6. The typical properties of super plasticizers*

Property Glenium 51 Flocrete W52 Form Viscous liquid Viscous liquid Color Light brown Dark brown

Relative density 1.1@20˚C 1.15 @25˚C pH 6.6 6.9

Viscosity +128/-30 cps@20˚C - Transport Not classified as dangerous Not classified as dangerous Labeling No hazard label required No hazard label required

* From the catalog of manufacture.

Figure 1: Water reduction for super plasticizer Glenium 51 mixtures

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8

water red

uction

 (%)

super plasticizer (Glenium 51) addition by weight of cement(%)  

Page 5: Utilization of Cement Kiln Dust in Concrete Manufacturing

Jordan Journal of Civil Engineering, Volume 7, No. 1, 2013

- 115 -

Super plasticizer – cement compatibility: In order to assess the super plasticizer – cement compatibility, the percentage of water reduction for the super plasticizer mixtures having the same workability, using slump method (ASTM C 143-89, 1989) was

determined. Figures (1) and (2), obtained by experimental work, show the amount of super plasticizers by weight of cement and the percentages of water reduction.

Figure 2: Water reduction for super plasticizer flocrete W52 mixtures Mix Design: The concrete mixtures were designed

according to British mix design method (B.S. 5328, Part 2:1991). The target compressive strength was 30 MPa at an age of 28 days. CKD was added to concrete mixtures as a percent of cement content. A total of fourteen concrete mixtures were prepared. The details of the concrete mixtures were as follows: 1. The first mixture was a reference mixture (without

CKD or super plasticizer). 2. In the second and third mixtures, CKD was used

with 10% and 20%, respectively, as a replacement of cement weight.

3. In the fourth and fifth mixtures, CKD was used

with 10% and 20%, respectively, as an addition of cement weight.

4. In the sixth and seventh mixtures, CKD was used with 20% as an addition of cement weight with super plasticizers (Glenium 51) and (Flocrete W52), respectively.

5. In the first seven concrete mixtures, ordinary Portland cement was used. In the other seven concrete mixtures, sulphate resisting Portland cement was used with CKD proportions and super plasticizers remaining similar to those in ordinary Portland cement.

The mixture proportions are shown in Table (7).

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6

water red

uction

 (%)

super plasticizer (flocrete w52) addition by weight of cement(%)  

Page 6: Utilization of Cement Kiln Dust in Concrete Manufacturing

Utilization of Cement… Zainab Hasan Abdulabbas

- 116 -

Table 7. Properties of mixtures used

No. w/c Water kg/m3

Cement kg/m3

CKD kg/m3

Super plasticizer %

Fine aggregate

kg/m3

Coarse aggregate kg/m3

Slump mm

M1 0.47 190 405 --- --- 505 1365 60 M2 0.47 190 364.5 40.5 --- 505 1365 55 M3 0.47 190 324 81 --- 505 1365 47 M4 0.43 190 405 40.5 --- 505 1365 40 M5 0.39 190 405 81 --- 505 1365 32 M6 0.34 163 405 81 Glenium 51 (1) 505 1365 110 M7 0.35 171 405 81 Flocrete W52 (1.2) 505 1365 110

TEST PROCEDURES

Slump test: Slump test of each concrete batch was

conducted immediately after mixing by using slump method (ASTM C 143-89, 1989).

Compressive strength: The compressive strength

test was determined according to (B.S. 1881-part 116-1989). 100 mm cubes were tested using a standard testing machine with a capacity of 2000 kN at a loading rate of 15 MPa per minute. The average of three cubes was adopted at each test. The test was conducted at ages of 7 and 28 days .

Splitting tensile strength: The splitting tensile

strength test was conducted according to (ASTM C496 -86 -1989). Cylinders of (100×200) mm were used and load was applied continuously up to failure using a standard testing EIE–machine of 2000 kN capacity. The average splitting tensile strength of three cylinders was recorded at ages of 7 and 28 days for all concrete mixtures. Splitting tensile strength can be calculated by using the following equation:

DLP

tfπ

2= ...(1)

where:

tf =Splitting tensile strength (MPa); P=Applied load in (N); D=Diameter of cylinder (mm); L=Length of cylinder (mm).

Absorption: The absorption test was conducted

according to (ASTM C140). The test procedure involves drying a specimen to a constant weight at 105˚C, weighing it, immersing it in water for 48 hours and weighing it again. The increase in weight as a percentage of the original weight is expressed as its absorption (in percent). The average absorption of three test samples was recorded at an age of 28 days.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS

Slump test

Slump test was used to measure workability of the mixtures. The results of this test are shown in Table (7) and Fig. (3). In general, the results showed that CKD increases the water demand for a constant consistency. From the results of slump test, it is clear that the slump of concrete mixtures containing 20% CKD (as an addition of cement weight), (i.e., M5) was less than those of other mixtures. This reduction in slump may be attributed to high content of fine materials and high surface area. To obtain a desirable workability, high-range water-reducing admixtures were used.

Compressive strength

The compressive strength test results are abstracted in Table (8). The compressive strength development in O.P.C. concrete specimens prepared with and without CKD is depicted in Fig. (4). The compressive strength increased with age in all concrete mixtures. However, a decrease in the compressive strength was noted in concrete mixtures including 10% and 20% CKD (as a replacement of cement weight) over the control

Page 7: Utilization of Cement Kiln Dust in Concrete Manufacturing

Jordan Journ mixture withM1). It is c

nal of Civil Eng

hout CKD (i.ecommonly ac

Msy

0

20

40

60

80

100

120Slum

p (m

m)

ngineering, Vol

., M2 and M3ccepted becau

Figur

Tab

Mixture ymbol

Cemty

M1

O.PS.R.

M2

O.PS.R.

M3

O.PS.R.

M4

O.PS.R.

M5

O.PS.R.

M6

O.PS.R.

M7 O.PS.R.

lume 7, No. 1, 2

3 compared wuse of the lo

re 3: Slump t

ble 8. The com

ment ype

Comp(M

P.C. .P.C. P.C. .P.C. P.C. .P.C. P.C. .P.C. P.C. .P.C. P.C. .P.C. P.C. .P.C.

2013

- 117 -

with ow

hy

test results of

mpressive str

pressive strenMPa), 7 days

20.26 23.12 6.00 7.50 10.92 12.03 23.36 27.06 28.19 31.11 32.03 35.04 30.16 33.62

mixtures

ydraulic prope

f concrete mix

rength test res

ngth Compr(MP

erty of CKD (

xtures

sults

ressive strengPa), 28 days

31.33 34.03 10.86 12.32 19.71 20.22 39.88 45.82 35.12 40.32 44.85 48.95 41.68 45.83

Shoaib et al.,

gth

M 1

M 2

M 3

M 4

M 5

M 6

M 7

2000).

Page 8: Utilization of Cement Kiln Dust in Concrete Manufacturing

Utilization o

The comp

28 days in coCKD (as ancontrol mixcompared wcompressive was about 3respectively.strength of c8.55 MPa anThese resultcompressive concrete mixmaximum inconcrete mixstrength mayin the Portlathe dissolutioH in the syste

The com(containing 2and super p

of Cement…

F

pressive strenoncrete mixtun addition o

xture withoutwith M1). A

strength of c3.1 MPa and At the age concrete mixtnd 3.79MPa ts indicate tha

strength at thxture M5; whncrease in comxture M4. Ty be attributedand cement-Con of silicate sem (Shoaib et

mpressive stren20% CKD as plasticizer Gl

4

9

14

19

24

29

34

39

44

Compressive

 stren

gth ‐M

Pa

Figure 4: Dev

gth increased ures containingof cement wet CKD (i.e.,

At the age ooncrete mixtu

d 7.93 MPa of 28 days, ttures M4 andmore than Mat the maximhe age of 7 dile at the age

mpressive strenThe increase d to an appro

CKD system, wspecies and fot al., 2000). ngth of concran addition o

lenium 51 w

0 5

velopment of using ord

at ages of 7 ag 10% and 20eight) over t, M4 and Mof 7 days, tures M4 and Mmore than Mthe compressi

d M5 was aboM1, respectivemum increase days occurred

of 28 days, tngth occurredin compressi

opriate alkalinwhich increas

ormation of C-

rete mixture Mf cement weig

with accelerati

10

A

- 118 -

compressive dinary Portlan

and 0% the M5 the M5 M1, ive out ely.

in in

the d in ive

nity ses -S-

M6 ght ing

efM28coadWabm

cocowcodaMthcowre

wco

15 2

Age ‐ days

strength of cnd cement

ffects on concMPa more than8 days, respeoncrete mixtuddition of cem

W52 which redbout 9.9 MPa

mixture M1 at aThe compre

oncrete speciompressive stras almost sim

oncrete mixturays, the comp

M4 and M5 wahan M1, respompressive stras about 11.8

espectively. The compre

as about 11.9ontrol mixtur

20 25

Z

concrete cube

crete) was abn the control mectively. Theure M7 (cont

ment weight anduces the perma and 10.35 Mages of 7 and 2essive strengthimens is deprength of concmilar to that res after 7 anpressive strenas about 3.94

pectively. At rength of conc85 MPa and 6

essive strengt91 MPa and re M1at ag

30

Zainab Hasan

es

bout 11.77 MPmixture M1 at compressivetaining 20%

nd super plastimeability of c

MPa more tha28 days, respech developmenpicted in Ficrete mixturesof the analo

nd 28 days. Atngth of concr

4 MPa and 7.9the age of

crete mixtures6.29 MPa, m

th of concrete14.92 MPa m

ges of 7 an

M1

M2

M3

M4

M5

M6

M7

n Abdulabbas

Pa and 13.52ages of 7 and

e strength ofCKD as an

icizer Flocreteconcrete) wasan the controlctively. nt in S.R.P.C.ig. (5). Thes M1 and M2ogous O.P.C.t the age of 7rete mixtures99 MPa more28 days, thes M4 and M5

more than M1,

e mixture M6more than thend 28 days,

2 d f n e s l

. e 2 .

7 s e e 5 ,

6 e ,

Page 9: Utilization of Cement Kiln Dust in Concrete Manufacturing

Jordan Journ respectively.mixture M7 than the contrespectively.concrete mixwas not that

Splitting ten

The effestrength for Table (9) anO.P.C. concspecimens, rtensile strengsame trend. with age in awas noted i20% CKD (the control mcompared wiconcrete andthe splitting

nal of Civil Eng

The comprwas about 10trol mixture M However, thextures M7 ansignificant. T

F

nsile strength ect of CKD

all concrete nd representedcrete specimrespectively. gth and the c

The splittinall concrete min concrete m(as a replacemmixture withith M1) for bo

d S.R.P.C. contensile stren

4

9

14

19

24

29

34

39

44

49

Compressive

 stren

gth ‐M

Pa

ngineering, Vol

ressive streng0.5 MPa and M1 at ages ofe difference in

nd M4 at the The above resu

Figure 5: Devu

percent on mixtures is

d in Figures ens and S.RIt is clear th

compressive sg tensile stre

mixtures, and mixtures inclument of cemeout CKD (i.eoth types of mncrete. At the

ngth of concre

0 5

lume 7, No. 1, 2

gth of concre11.8 MPa mo

f 7 and 28 dayn the strengthage of 28 da

ults indicate th

velopment of using sulphate

splitting tenssummarized (8) and (9)

R.P.C. concrhat the splittistrength had tength increasa decrease in

uding 10% aent weight) ove., M2 and Mmixtures, O.Pe age of 7 dayete mixture M

10

A

2013

- 119 -

ete ore ys, of ays hat

thmbeco(cw

compressive e resisting Po

sile in

for ete ing the sed n it and ver M3 .C. ys, M4

wOmspabOmstrceTh

Mcocore

15 2

Age ‐ days

he O.P.C. concmixtures inclu

ehaviors. The ompressive scontaining 20eight) of the t

strength of cortland cemen

as about 0.13.P.C. concre

mixture, respeplitting tensilebout 0.40 MP.P.C. concre

mixture, respecrength of conement at the he same thing

The splittinM5 was about ontrol mixtureoncrete mixtuespectively; w

20 25

crete mixturesuding CKD using of supestrength of

0% CKD astwo types of c

concrete cubent

MPa and 0.1ete mixture ctively. At t

e strength of Pa and 0.43 ete mixture ctively. Howencrete mixtureage of 7 day

g was noted at ng tensile stre0.17 MPa an

e M1 at the ure and S.R

while the spl

30

s and the S.R.had almos

er plasticizers the concre

s an additioncements.

es

19 MPa more and S.R.P

the age of 2concrete mixMPa more tand S.R.P

ever, the diffe M4 for the

ys was not thathe age of 28

ength of concnd 0.23 MPa mage of 7 dayR.P.C. concrlitting tensile

M1

M2

M3

M4

M5

M6

M7

.P.C. concretest the same

enhanced theete mixturesn of cement

than M1, for.C. concrete28 days, the

xture M4 wasthan M1, for.C. concrete

ference in thetwo types of

at significant. days. crete mixturemore than theys, for O.P.C.rete mixture,e strength of

e e e s t

r e e s r e e f .

e e . , f

Page 10: Utilization of Cement Kiln Dust in Concrete Manufacturing

Utilization of Cement… Zainab Hasan Abdulabbas

- 120 -

concrete mixture M5 was about 0.48 MPa and 0.41 MPa more than the control mixture M1 at the age of 28 days, for the O.P.C. concrete mixture and the S.R.P.C. concrete mixture, respectively. It is obvious that the difference in the strength of concrete mixtures M5 for the two types of cement was almost similar to that of the parallel M4 mixtures after 7 and 28 days. However, the difference in the strength of concrete mixtures M4 and M5 at the age of 28 days was not that weighty, for both types of cement. The splitting tensile strength of concrete mixture M6 (containing 20% CKD as an

addition of cement weight and super plasticizer Glenium 51 which has accelerating effects on concrete) was about 0.67 MPa and 0.64 MPa more than the control mixture M1 at the age of 7 days, for O.P.C. concrete mixture and S.R.P.C. concrete mixture, respectively; while the splitting tensile strength of concrete mixture M6 was about 0.86 MPa and 0.93 MPa more than the control mixture M1 at the age of 28 days, for O.P.C. concrete mixture and S.R.P.C. concrete mixture, respectively.

Table 9. The splitting tensile strength test results

Mixture symbol

Cement type

Splitting strength(MPa), 7 days

Splitting strength (MPa), 28 days

M1

O.P.C. 1.26 2.1 S.R.P.C. 1.86 2.89

M2

O.P.C. 0.31 0.73 S.R.P.C. 0.52 0.80

M3

O.P.C. 0.90 1.40 S.R.P.C. 1.40 2.00

M4

O.P.C. 1.39 2.50 S.R.P.C. 2.06 3.32

M5

O.P.C. 1.43 2.58 S.R.P.C. 2.10 3.30

M6

O.P.C. 1.93 2.96 S.R.P.C. 2.51 3.82

M7 O.P.C. 1.71 2.77 S.R.P.C. 2.30 3.57

Table 10. The absorption test results

Mixture symbol

Cement type

Absorption percent(%), 28 days

M1

O.P.C. 4.42 S.R.P.C. 4.00

M2

O.P.C. 5.15 S.R.P.C. 4.82

M3

O.P.C. 6.58 S.R.P.C. 5.73

M4

O.P.C. 4.70 S.R.P.C. 4.35

M5

O.P.C. 4.82 S.R.P.C. 4.52

M6

O.P.C. 4.45 S.R.P.C. 4.32

M7 O.P.C. 3.60 S.R.P.C. 3.45

Page 11: Utilization of Cement Kiln Dust in Concrete Manufacturing

Jordan Journ

Figu th

The split

M7 (containweight and reduces the MPa and 0.4at the age of

nal of Civil Eng

ure 6: The cubhe compressiv

Figu

tting tensile sning 20% CK

super plastipermeability

43 MPa more f 7 days, for

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

Splliting

 stren

gth ‐M

Pa

ngineering, Vol

be and the mve strength te

ure 8: Develo

strength of coKD as an add

icizer Flocretof concrete) than the contO.P.C. concr

0

5

5

2

5

3

5

4

0 5

lume 7, No. 1, 2

mold of est

opment of splusing ord

oncrete mixtudition of cemete W52 whiwas about 0.trol mixture M

rete mixture a

10

A

2013

- 121 -

itting tensile dinary Portlan

ure ent ich .45 M1 and

S.spabmmis

15

Age ‐ days

Figure 7: Th

strength of cnd cement

.R.P.C. concrplitting tensilebout 0.67 MP

mixture M1 at mixture and S.R

evident that t

20 25

he compressi

concrete cylin

rete mixture, e strength of Pa and 0.68 M

the age of 28R.P.C. concrethe behavior o

30

ive strength t

nders

respectivelconcrete mix

MPa more tha8 days, for O.ete mixture, reof M6 and M

M1

M2

M3

M4

M5

M6

M7

test

ly; while thexture M7 wasan the controlP.C. concreteespectively. It

M7 was similar

e s l e t r

Page 12: Utilization of Cement Kiln Dust in Concrete Manufacturing

Utilization o to that of Mabove resultsall concrete

Figure 1 the s

of Cement…

M4 and M5, fos show that thmixtures was

Figu

10: The cylindsplitting tensi

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

Splliting

 stren

gth ‐M

Pa

or both types e difference ins not that sign

ure 9: Develou

der and the mile strength te

0

5

5

2

5

3

5

4

0 5

of cement. Tn the strengthnificant and t

opment of splusing sulphate

mold of est

10

A

- 122 -

The h of the

inpr

itting tensile e resisting Po

Figure

15

Age ‐ days

ncrease in thronounced tha

strength of cortland cemen

e 11: The spli

20 25

Z

he splitting an that in the c

concrete cylinnt

itting tensile

30

Zainab Hasan

tensile strencompressive s

nders

strength test

M1

M2

M3

M4

M5

M6

M7

n Abdulabbas

ngth is lesstrength.

s

Page 13: Utilization of Cement Kiln Dust in Concrete Manufacturing

Jordan Journal of Civil Engineering, Volume 7, No. 1, 2013

- 123 -

Figure 12: Absorption test results of concrete mixtures

Figure 13: The specimens inside the drying oven Figure 14: Determination of the specimen weight

Absorption

The absorption test results (at the age of 28 days) are illustrated in Table (10) and plotted in Fig.(12). It is

obvious that the absorption percent increased when CKD was used in concrete mixtures from M2 to M6 (i.e., in all the concrete mixtures except M7) for both

Page 14: Utilization of Cement Kiln Dust in Concrete Manufacturing

Utilization of Cement… Zainab Hasan Abdulabbas

- 124 -

types of mixtures, O.P.C. concrete and S.R.P.C. concrete. The maximum increase occurred in mixture M3 (i.e., the concrete mixture including 20% CKD as a replacement of cement weight). It was about 2.16 and 1.73 more than the control mixture M1, for O.P.C. concrete mixture and S.R.P.C. concrete mixture, respectively. The absorption percent of concrete mixture M2, the concrete mixture including 10% CKD as a replacement of cement weight, was about 0.73 and 0.82 more than the control mixture M1 for both types of mixtures, O.P.C. concrete and S.R.P.C. concrete, respectively; while it was- for the two types of mixtures –about 0.28, 0.35, 0.41 and 0.52 more than the control mixture M1 in concrete mixtures containing 10% and 20% CKD (as an addition of cement weight), respectively (i.e., M4 and M5 compared with M1 for O.P.C. concrete mixture and S.R.P.C. concrete mixture, respectively). The increase in the absorption percent may be attributed to the fact that CKD is a fine material and more absorbing.

The absorption percent of concrete mixture M6 (containing 20% CKD as an addition of cement weight and super plasticizer Glenium 51 which has accelerating effects on concrete) was about 0.03 and 0.32 more than the control mixture M1, for O.P.C. concrete mixture and S.R.P.C. concrete mixture, respectively. In concrete mixture M7 (containing 20% CKD as an addition of cement weight and super plasticizer Flocrete W52 which reduces the permeability of concrete), the absorption percent decreased and it was about 0.82 and 0.55 less than the control mixture M1, for O.P.C. concrete mixture and

S.R.P.C. concrete mixture, respectively. It is clear that the use of super plasticizers improved the absorption percent of the concrete mixtures (containing 20% CKD as an addition of cement weight) of the two types of cements.

CONCLUSIONS

1. The workability of both O.P.C. and S.R.P.C.

concretes decreased with increasing quantity of CKD. The slump of concrete mixtures containing 20% CKD (as an addition of cement weight) was less than for other mixtures.

2. The compressive strength increased in concrete mixtures including 10% and 20% CKD as an addition of cement weight. A reduction in compressive strength was noted in concrete mixtures including 10% and 20% CKD as a replacement of cement weight.

3. The splitting tensile strength and the compressive strength had the same tendency. The difference in the splitting tensile strength of all concrete mixtures was not that significant and the increase in splitting tensile strength is less pronounced than that in compressive strength.

4. The absorption percent increased when CKD was used in concrete.

5. The using of super plasticizers enhanced the properties of concrete including CKD.

6. O.P.C. concrete mixtures and S.R.P.C. concrete mixtures including CKD had almost the same manners.

REFERENCES

Al-Mabrook, F.A. 2010. Utilization of dust profile path of

cement factory in producing low-cost building materials. Civil Department, College of Engineering, Qar Younis, Libya. The 11th Arabic Conference of Mineral Wealth. Trablus.

ASTM C 143-89. 1989. Standard test method for slump of hydraulic cement concrete. Annual Book of ASTM Standards, 04.02: 85-86.

ASTM C 496-86. 1989. Standard test method for splitting tensile strength of cylindrical concrete specimens. Annual Book of ASTM Standards, 04.02: 259-262.

Page 15: Utilization of Cement Kiln Dust in Concrete Manufacturing

Jordan Journal of Civil Engineering, Volume 7, No. 1, 2013

- 125 -

ASTM C 494-82. 1982. Standard specification for chemical admixtures for concrete. Annual Book of ASTM standards, Philadelphia.

B.S.1881. Part 116. 1989. Method for determination of compressive strength of concrete cubes. British Standards Institution, 3 pp.

Daous, M. A. 2004. Utilization of cement kiln dust and fly ash in cement blends in Saudi Arabia. Chemical and Materials Engineering Department, KAAU. Eng. Sci., 15 (1): 33-45 (1425 A.H.).

Iraqi Organization of Standards IQS No. 5. 1984. Iraqi standard specification for Portland cements, ICOSQC. Baghdad, Iraq.

Iraqi Organization of Standards IQS No.45. 1984. Iraqi standard specification for aggregate, ICOSQC, Baghdad, Iraq.

Maslehuddin, M., Al-Amoudi, O.S.B., Rahman, M.K. and Barry, M.R. 2009. Properties of cement kiln dust concrete. Center for Engineering Research, Research Institute, King Fahd University of Petroleum and Minerals, Dhahran 31261, Saudi Arabia, Construction and Building Materials, 23: 2357-2361.

Rahman, M. K., Rehman, S. and Al-Amoudi, O.S.B. 2011. Literature review on cement kiln dust usage in soil and waste stabilization and experimental investigation. Center for Engineering Research, Research Institute, King Fahd University of Petroleum and Minerals, Dhahran, Saudi Arabia. www.arpapress.com/ Volumes/Vol7Issue1/IJRRAS_7_1_12.pdf

Shoaib, M. M., Balaha, M. M. and Abdel-Rahman, A. G. 2000. Influence of cement kiln dust on mechanical properties of concrete. Cement and Concrete Research, 30 (2): 371-377. (Cited by Wang et al., 2002).

Wang, K., Maria S. Konsta-Gdoutos and Surendra P. Shah. 2002. Hydration, rheology, and strength of ordinary Portland cement (OPC)-cement kiln dust (CKD)-slag binders. ACI Materials Journal/March-April, 99 (2): 173-179.


Recommended