Volume Information

Editorial Committee of the Cambridge Law Journal

Volume InformationSource: The Cambridge Law Journal, Vol. 6, No. 1 (1936), pp. i-xviPublished by: Cambridge University Press on behalf of Editorial Committee of the Cambridge LawJournalStable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/4502871 .

Accessed: 11/06/2014 01:58

Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

.JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range ofcontent in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new formsof scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].

.

Cambridge University Press and Editorial Committee of the Cambridge Law Journal are collaborating withJSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to The Cambridge Law Journal.

http://www.jstor.org

This content downloaded from 62.122.73.213 on Wed, 11 Jun 2014 01:58:22 AMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=cup

http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=ecclj

http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=ecclj

http://www.jstor.org/stable/4502871?origin=JSTOR-pdf

http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp


THK

CAMBRIDGE LAW

JOURNAL

EDITED BY

P. H. WINFIELD, LL.D., F.B.A.

Rouse Ball Professor of English Law

FOR

THE CAMBBIDGE UNIVEESITY LAW SOCIETY.

VOL. VI.

LONDON

STEVENS & SONSLIMITED

1938

Reprinted 1974



Published by the Syndics of the Cambridge University Press Bentley House, 200 Euston Road, London NW1 2DB

American Branch: 32 East 57th Street, New York, N.Y. 10022

First published by Stevens & Sons Ltd 1938 Re-issued by Cambridge University Press 1974

Reprinted in Great Britain by Kingprint Ltd, Richmond, Surrey

NOTE Whilst every effort has been made to reproduce this book to the highest standard, the poor quality of the previous reprint is unavoidably reflected in this impression.



( iii )

INDEX TO VOLS. I-VI.

INDEX OF LEADING ARTICLES. VOL. PAGE

Abuse of Rights (H. C. GUTTERIDGE) .... .... V 22

Angary, Right of (W. I. JENNINGS) .. ....... .iii 49

Appeal in English Law (Right Hon. Lord Justice ATKIN (Lord ATKIN) ) ...... .. .. .. .. .. iii 1

Attempts to Commit Crimes (J. W. CECIL TURNER) .. V 230

Bacon (Sir WILLIAM HOLDSWORTH) .. ....... .iii 10 Benefit of a Restrictive Covenant (S. J. BAILEY) .. .. vi 339 Blackstone's Commentaries (A. V. DICEY) .. ..... . iv 286 Blackstone and His Commentaries, Some Aspects of (Sir

WILLIAM HOLDSWORTH) ... . .. .. .. .. iv 261

Blasphemy, Evolution of the Law of (C. S. KENNY) .. i 127 Book of Assizes (W. C. BOLLAND) .. .. .. .. .. ii 192

Cambridge and Harvard Law Schools (A. L. GOODHART) .. i 323 Choice of Law (W. H. UPJOHN, K.C.) .. ..... . ii 321

Coke, Sir Edward (Sir WILLIAM HOLDSWORTH) .. .... V 322 Commercial Courts, Work in the (Right Hon. Lord Justice

SCRUTTON) . . ...... .. . i 6 Common Law, Thoughts About the (Right Hon. Sir JAMES

O'CoNNOR) .. .... .. .. .iii 161

Conspiracy, History of, and Abuse of Legal Procedure (RoscoE POUND) .. .. .. .. .... i 156

Contract, Undisclosed Principals in (A. L. GOODHART and C. J.

HAMSON) .. .... .. .. .. .. .. iv 320 Contributory Negligence (J. C. MACINTOSH) .. .. i 185

Corporate Liability in Tort and the Doctrine of Ultra Vires (A. L. GOODHART) .. .... .. .. ii 350

Corporations, Criminal Responsibility of (C. R. N. WINN) .. iii 398 Crown, Proceedings By and Against the (Right Hon. Sir THOMAS

INSKIP) ..... .. .. .. iv 1

Damages, The Measure of, in Contract and Tort (S. L. PORTER

(Right Hon. Lord PORTER)) .. .. .. .. .. v 176

Dangerous Things and Non-natural User of Land (W. T. S.

STALLYBRASS) .. .. .... .. iii 376

Day in Court at Home and Abroad (Sir MAURICE AMOS) .. ii 340

Defamation, Law of, in Scotland (Right Hon. Lord NORMAND) vi 327



iv Index of Leading Articles.

VOL. PAGE

Departmental Legislation (E. C. S. WADE) .... .. 77 Dominions, The, and the United Kingdom (G. G. PHILLIPS) .. iv 164 Dominions, The, and their Mother Country (C. S. KENNY) ii 157, 297 Droit Administratif (ACHILLE MESTRE) ... .. iii 355

English and Roman Law, The Inner Relationship between (FRITZ PRINGSHEIM) .......... .. v 347

English Private Law, 1870-1920 (Right Hon. Sir FREDERICK POLLOCK, Bt.) ............... . ii 19

Equitable Liens under Hire-Purchase Agreements (H. A. HOLLOND) .. .. .. .. .. .. .. iii 173

Equity in America (J. H. BEALE) .... .. .. i 21 Estates Tail under the New Law (C. P. SANGER) .. .. ii 212 Execrabalis in the Common Pleas (T. F. T. PLUCKNrTT) .. i 60

Foreword (H. D. HAZELTINE) .. .. . .. .. .. i 1 Fraud and the Statutes of Limitations (JOHN BRUNYATE) .. iv 174 Furtum Proprium and Improprium (DAVID DAUBE) .. vi 217

Imperial Conference and the Constitution (E. JENKS) .. .. iii 13 Insane, The Criminal Responsibility of the Alleged (TRAVERS

HUMPHREYS (Hon. Mr. Justice HUMPHREYS) and G. F. E. PRIDEAUX) .. ........ .. .. .. i 302

International Court of the League of Nations (Right Hon. Sir ERNEST POLLOCK (Lord HANWORTH)) .. .. . . i 29

International Law and Resort to Armed Force (J. L. BRIERLY) iv 308 Interpretation of Statutes (Sir MAURICE AMos) .. .. .. v 163 Irish Bar, The Last Forty Years of (Serjeant A. M. SULLIVAN,

K.C.) .. .. .. .. .. .. .. ., .. iii 365

Johnson, Dr., and the Old Bailey (T. MATHEW) .. .. .. iii 182 Judicial Life, Some Aspects of (Hon. Mr. Justice MCCARDIE) .. ii 169 Judicial Settlement of Industrial Disputes, The (JETrHiR BROWN) ii 51 Jury Trial To-day (R. M. JACKSON) .. .. .. .. .. vi 367

Land Companies (W. J. WHITTAKER) .. .. .. .. v 371 Law and the Courts of Palestine, The (N. BENTWICH) .. .. ii 37

Law, The Contact of Public and Private (Right Hon. Sir FREDERICK POLLOCK, Bt.) .. .. .... .. i 255

Law Reform (H. A. HOLLOUND) .. .. .. .. .. iv 146 Law Student, Happy State of the Modern (Hon. Mr. Justice

(Lord Justice) MACKINNON) .. .... .. iii 24 Law Tripos, Revision of the (H. A. HOLLOND) .. .. i 193

League of Nations, The Covenant of, and War (Sir JOHN FISCHER WILLIAMS) .. .. .. .. .. . v 1

Leaseholds and the Rule in Howe v. Dartmouth (S. J. BAILEY) iv 357

Legal History, Gossip About: Unpublished Letters of Maitland and Ames (H. D. HAZELTINE) .. .. .. .... ii 1

Liability for Things Naturally on the Land (A. L. GOODHART) iv 13



Index of Leading Articles. v

VOL. PAGE

Maitland, F. W. (W. W. BUCKLAND) .. .. .. .. i 279 Mandates (ARNOLD D. MCNAIR) .. .. .. .. .iii 149 Master of the Rolls, Some Notes on the Office of (Right Hon.

Lord HANWORTH, M.R.) .. .. .. .. .. v 313 Mens Rea and Motorists (J. W. CECIL TURNER) .. .. v 61 Mental Element in Crimes at Common Law (J. W. CECIL

TURNER) .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. vi 31 Misdemeanours, Common Law (R. M. JACKSON) .. .. .. vi 193

Negligence in Running-Down Cases, Burden of Proof in (E. WYNDHAM WHITE) .. .. .. .. .. .. vi 404

Nuisance as a Tort (P. H. WINFIELD) .. .. . . iv 189

Parliament and the Dominions, A Retrospect (R. L. SCHUYLER) iii 209 Personality of an Idol, The (P. W. DUFF) .. .. .. .. iii 42 Philosophy of Law, Some Reflections on the (Sir MAURICE AMOS) iii 31 Pleading and Proof at Common Law (H. A. HOLLOND) ... vi 1 Pleading, The New Rules of, Hilary Term, 1834 (Sir WILLIAM

HOLDSWORTH) .. .. .. .. .. .. .. i 261 Polemis Business, This (ARNOLD D. McNAIR) .. .. . iv 125 Police Powers and Public Meetings (E. C. S. WADE) ... vi 175 Portuguese Bank Note Case, The (M. TAPPAN HOLLOND) .. .. v 91 Possession, Three Cases on (A. L. GOODHART) .. .. .. iii 195 Precedents in Continental Law (ERNST J. COHN) ...... v 366 Private International Law, A New Approach to (H. C.

GUTTERIDGE) .. .. ..... . .... vi 16 Privy Council, The Work for the Empire of the Judicial Com-

mittee of the (Right Hon. Viscount HALDANE) .. .. i 143 Promises to Perform an Existing Duty (A. G. DAVIS) .. vi 202 Property Act, 1925, Law of, s. 130 (2) (S. J. BAILE) .. .. vi 67 Prosecution and Defence (Right Hon. Lord DABLING) .. .. ii 311 Public Meetings and Processions (A. L. GOODHART) .. .. vi 161

Reprisals as a Measure of Redress Short of War (S. MACCOBY) ii 60 Rescue and Voluntary Assumption of Risk (A. L. GOODHART) .. v 192 Roman Law, A Textbook of (F. DE ZULUrrrA) .. .. .. i 166 Roman Law as Illustrated by Pliny's Letters (D. T. OLIVER) .. iv 153 Roman Law in Aulus Gellius (D. T. OLIVEB) .. .. .. v 46 Roman Law, The Official Manuals of in the Eighth and Ninth

Centuries (EDWIN H. FRBSHFIELD) .. .. .. .. iv 34

Sinclair v. Brougham (Right Hon. Lord WRIGHT OF DUBLEY) vi 305 Societas as a Consensual Contract (DAVID DAUBE) .. .. vi 381 Solicitors' Work and Environment (S. GARRETT) .. .. .. i 42 Statutory Offences, Absolute Prohibition in (R. M. JACKSON) .. vi 83

Thomas v. Sawkins: A Constitutional Innovation (A. L. GOOD- HART) .. .. .... .. .. .. .. vi 22

Torts by Corporations in Ultra Vires Undertakings (E. H. WARREN) .. .. .. . . .. .. .. ii 180



vi Indeoc of Leading Articles.

Transeat in Exemplum (A. E. Randall)* .. Trusts for Sale (J. M. Lightwood).

Undisclosed Principals in Contract (see Contract, supra). Unjustified Enrichment, The Doctrine of (H. C. Gutteridge

and R. J. A. David) .v 204

War and Law (A. Pearce Higgins). .. .. i 177 Westminster, Since the Statute of (G. G. Phillips) .. .. vi 182



( vii )

INDEX OF CONTRIBUTORS OF LEADING ARTICLES.

VOL. PAGE

AMos, SIR MAURICE.-A Day in Court at Home and Abroad .. ii 340

Interpretation of Statutes .. .. .. .. .. v 163 Some Reflections on the Philosophy of Law .. .. .. iii 31

ATKIN, RIGHT HON. LORD JUSTICE (LORD ATxIN).-Appeal in

English Law .. . .. .. .iii 1

BAILEY, S. J.-Benefit of a Restrictive Covenant .. .. vi 339 Law of Property Act, 1925, s. 130 (2) .... .. vi 67 Leaseholds and the Rule in Howe v. Dartmouth .. .. iv 357

BEALE, J. H.-Equity in America .. .. . .. .. i 21 BENTWICH, N.-Law and the Courts in Palestine .. .. ii 37 BOLLAND, W. C.-Book of Assizes .. .. .. .. .. ii 192 BRIERLY, J. L.-International Law and Resort to Armed Force iv 308

BROWN, JETHRO.-Judicial Settlement of Industrial Disputes .. ii 51 BRUNYATE, JOHN.-Fraud and the Statutes of Limitations ..iv 174 BUCKLAND, W. W.-F. W. Maitland .. .. .. .. i 279

COHN, ERNST J.-Precedents in Continental Law .. .... v 366

DARLING, RIGHT HON. LORD.-Prosecution and Defence .. .. ii 311 DAUBE, DAVID.-Furtum Proprium and Impropriun .. .. vi 217

Societas as a Consensual Contract .. .. .. vi 381

DAVID, R. J. A.-Doctrine of Unjustified Enrichment .. .. v 204

DAVIS, A. G.-Promises to Perform an Existing Duty .. vi 202 DICEY, A. V.-Blackstone's Commentaries .. .. .. iv 286 DUFF, P. W.-Personality of an Idol .. .. .. .. iii 42

FRESHFIEID, E. H.-Official Manuals of Roman Law in the

Eighth and Ninth Centuries .... .. .iv 34

GARRETr, S.-Solicitors' Work and Environment .. .. i 42 GOODHART, A. L.-Cambridge and Harvard Law Schools .. i 323

Corporate Liability in Tort and the Doctrine of Ultra Vires ii 350 - Liability for Things Naturally on the Land .. .... iv 13

Public Meetings and Processions .. .. .. . vi 161 Rescue and Voluntary Assumption of Risk .. .... v 192 Thomas v. Sawkins: A Constitutional Innovation .. .. vi 22

- Three Cases on Possession .. .. .. .. .. iii 195 Undisclosed Principals in Contract .. .. .. .. iv 320

GUTTnRIDGB, H. C.-Abuse of Rights .. .. . .. v 22 Doctrine of Unjustified Enrichment .. . ... . v 204 New Approach to Private International Law .. .. vi 16



viii Index of Contributors.

VOL. PAGE

HALDANE, RIGHT HON. VISCOUNT.-Work for the Empire of the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council .. .. .. i 143

HAMSON, C. J.-Undisclosed Principals in Contract .. .. iv 320 HANWORTH, RIGHT HON. LORD.-Some Notes on the Office of

Master of the Rolls .. .. .. .. .. .. v 313

(See also POLLOCK, SIR ERNEST.) HAZELTINE, H. D.-Foreword .. . .. .. . . i 1

- Gossip About Legal History: Unpublished Letters of Mait- land and Ames .. .. .. .. .. ii 1

HIGGINS, A. PBARCE.-War and Law .. .. .. i 177 HOLDSWORTH, SIR WILLIAM.-Bacon .. .. .. .. iii 10

Sir Edward Coke .. .. .. .. .. .. .. v 322 New Rules of Pleading of Hilary Term, 1834 .. .. i 261 Some Aspects of Blackstone and His Commentaries .. iv 261

HOLLOND, H. A.-Equitable Liens under Hire-Purchase Agree- ments .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. iii 173

Law Reform .. .. ... .. .. .. iv 146 Pleading and Proof at Common Law .. .. .. .. vi 1

- Revision of the Law Tripos .. .. .. .. .. i 193 HOLLOND, M. TAPPAN.-Portuguese Bank Note Case .. . v 91 HUMPHREYS, TRAVERS (HON. MR. JUSTICE HUMPHREYS).-

Criminal Responsibility of the Alleged Insane .. .. i 302

INSKIP, RIGHT HON. SIR THoMAS.-Proceedings by and against the Crown .. .. .. .. .. .. .. iv 1

JACKSON, R. M.-Absolute Prohibition in Statutory Offences .. vi 83 - Common Law Misdemeanours .. .. .. .. .. vi 193

-- Jury Trial To-day .. .. .... .. vi 367 JENKS, EDWARD.-Imperial Conference and the Constitution .. iii 13 JENNINGS,* W. I.-Right of Angary .. .. .. .. .. iii 49

KBNNY, C. S.-Dominions and their Mother Country .. ii 157, 297 - Evolution of Law of Blasphemy .. .. .. .. i 127

LIGHTWOOD, J. M.-Trusts for Sale .. ....... . iii 59

MCCARDIE, HON. MR. JUSTICE.-Some Aspects of Judicial Life ii 169

MACcOBY, S.-Reprisals as a Measure of Redress Short of War ii 60 MACINTOSH, J. C.-Contributory Negligence .. .. .. i 185

MACKINNON, HON. MR. JUSTICE (LORD JUSTICE).-Happy State of the Modern Law Student .. .. .. .. .. iii 24

McNAIR, ARNOLD D.-Mandates .. .. .. .. .. iii 149 This Polemis Business .. .. .. .. .. .. iv 125

MATHEW, T.-Dr. Johnson and the Old Bailey .. .. .. iii 182 MESTRE, ACHILLE.-Droit Administratif .. .. .. .. iii 355



Index of Contributors. ix

VOL. PAGE

NORMAND, RIGHT HON. LORD.-Law of Defamation in Scotland vi 327

O'CONNOR, RIGHT HON. SIR JAMEs.-Thoughts About the Common Law ...... .. .. .. .. iii 161

OLIVER, D. T.-Roman Law in Pliny's Letters .. .. .. iv 153 Roman Law in Aulus Gellius .. .. .. v 46

PHILLIPS, G. G.-Dominions and the United Kingdom .. .. iv 164 Since the Statute of Westminster .. .. .. vi 182

PLUCKNETT, T. F. T.-Execrabilis in the Common Pleas .. i 60 POLLOCK, RIGHT HON. SIR ERNEST.-International Court of the

League of Nations. . . .. .. .. .. .. i 29 (See also HANWORTH, RIGHT HON. LORD.)

POLLOCK, RIGHT HON. SIR FREDERICK.-Contact of Public and Private Law .. .. .. .. .. .. .. i 255

English Private Law, 1870-1920 .. .. .. .. ii 19 PORTER, S. L. (RIGHT HON. LORD PORTER).-Measure of

Damages in Contract and Tort .. .. .. .. v 176 POUND, RoscoE.-History of Conspiracy and Abuse of Legal

Procedure .. .. ... .. .. .... i 156

PRIDEAUX, G. F. E.-Criminal Responsibility of the Alleged Insane .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. i 302

PRINGSHEIM, FRITZ.-Inner Relationship between English and Roman Law .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. v 347

RANDALL, A. E.-Transeat in Exeplum .. .. .. .. i 77

SANGER, C. P.-Estates Tail under the New Law .. .. ii 212 SCHUYLER, R. L.-Parliament and the Dominions: A Retrospect iii 209 SCRUTrON, RIGHT HON. LORD JUSTIcF.-Work of the Commercial

Courts .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. i 6 STALLYBRASS, W. T. S.-Dangerous Things and Non-natural User

of Land .. .... .iii 376 SULLIVAN, SEEJEANT A. M.-Last Forty Years of the Irish Bar iii 366

TURNER, J. W. CECIL.-Attempts to Commit Crimes .. .. v 230 Mens Rea and Motorists .. .. .. .. .. v 61

- Mental Element in Crimes at Common Law .. .. .. vi 31

UPJOHN, W. H.-Choice of Law . ... .... ii 321

WADE, E. C. S.-Departmental Legislation .. .. . v 77 Police Powers and Public Meetings .. .. .. vi 175

WARREN, E. H.-Torts by Corporations in Ultra Vires Under- takings .. ..... .. .. .. .. .. ii 180



x Index of Contributors.

VOL. PAGE

WHITD, E. WYNDHAx.-The Burden of Proof of Negligence in Running-Down Cases .. .. .. .. .. .. vi 404

WnrrrAxm, W. J.-Land Companies .... v 371 WIT-T.TAVS, SIX J. FISCmHB.-Covenant of League of Nations

and War .. .. .... .. .. .. v 1 WINnmID, P. H.-Nuisance as a Tort .. .... iv 189 Wnw, C; R. N.-Criminal Responsibility of Corporations .. iii 398 WBIHTr, RIGHT HON. LORD.-Sinclair v. Brougham .. vi 305

ZULurrA. F. DB.-A Textbook of Roman Law .. .. .. i 166



( xi )

INDEX OF CASES ANNOTATED.

VOL. PAOB Addie (Robert) v. Dumbreck .. iv 78 Adriatic, The. iv 368 Aitchison v. Page Motors- vi 256 Allen v. Whitehead. iv 66 Amalgamated Society of Car-

penters v. Braithwaite .... i 343 Anchor Line, Re .vi 249, 423 Anderson v. Daniel. ii 94 Andrews v. D. P. P. vi 435 Andrews Bros. v. Singer & Co. v 275 Anglo - Scottish Beet Sugar

Corpn. v. Spalding U. D. C. vi 428 Anichab, The . i 364 Anziani, Re . iv 210 Arcos v. Ronaasen & Son .... v 267 Arpad, The. v 391 Ardath Tobacco Co. v. Ocker iv 385 Arden, Re . vi 112 Arneil v. Paterson . iv 388 Arnell and Barmann Aviation

Co. v. The King . i 215 Ashby v. Tolhurst . vi 422 Aelan v. Imperial Airways .. v 255 Att.-Gen. v. Corke . v 122 Att.-Gen. for Canada v. Att.-

Gen. for Ontario. vi 425 Attwood v. Lamont . i 87 Auchteroni v. Midland Bank.. iii 419 Australia, Commonwealth of

v. N. S. W. iv 54

Badische Co., Re. i 201 Bailey v. Geddes. vi 448 Baker v. James Bros. i 209 - v. E. Longhurst & Sons v 271 Balden v. Shorter . v 269 Banco de Portugal v. Water-

low k Sons . v 91,103 Banco de Vizcaya v. Don

Alfonso de Borbon y Austria v 387 Barnett v. Sanker . ii 379 Barrow, Lane & Ballard v.

Phillips . iv 73 Bathe, Re . ii 391 Beard v. The Director of

Public Prosecutions . i 90

Beech, Re; Beech v. Public Trustee and Others . i 332

Behnke v. Bede Shipping Co. iii 264. Bell v. Lever . iv 370 Beresford v. Royal Insurance

Co.. vi 431 Berry v. Berry . iv 64 Besseler Waechter & Co. v.

S. Derwent Coal Co. vi 433 Blackwell, Re . iii 302, 459 Blay v. Pollard . iv 213 Blonde, The, and Others .... i 217 Blundell - Leigh v. A 11 e n -

borough . i 358 Blundy & Co. v. L. N. E. R. iv 390 Board of Trade v. Cayzer, etc. iii 268 Bohemian Union Bank v.

Admini8trator of Austrian Property . iii 249

Borman v. Griffith . iv 219 Bostock, Re; Norrish v.

Bostock . i 213 Bottomley v. Bannister. v 125 Bowden, Re . vi 251 Bradstreets British v. Harold

Mitchell, etc._ v 260 Brandon v. Osborne, Garrett

& Co. 113 Bremer Oeltraneport G.m.b.H.

v. Drewry. v 253 British-American Continental

Bank, Ltd,, Re .,. i 325 British and Beningtons v.

N. W. Cachar Tea Co. i 355 British Coal Corpn. v. R. vi 98 British Homophone v. Kunz,

etc., Ltd. vi 104 British Russian Gazette v.

Associated Newspapers_ v 254 Britt v. Galmoye . iii 455 Brooke v. Bool. iii 456 Broome v. Agar . iii 451 Buckle v. Holme8 . iii 76 Bull, A. H. v. W. African

Shipping Co. iii 288 Buller & Co. v. Brooks. iv 222 Burnyeat, Re; Burnyeat v,

Ward . i 333



Xll Index of Cases Annotated.

VOL. PAGB Burrell v. Leven . iii 79 Bntt v. Weston - super - Mare

U. D. C. i 346 Butwick v. Grant . ii 228 Byrne v. Deane . vi 439

Cammell, Laird & Co. v. Man- ganese Bronze and Brass Co. v 266,399

Canadian Pacific Ry. Co. v. Kelvin Shipping Co. iii 458

-v. R. iv 391 Cantiare San Rocco S. A. v.

Clyde Shipbuilding Co. ii 215 Carlton Hall Club v. Lau-

rence . iv 57 Cassidy v. Daily Mirror _ iv 75 Chamberlain, Re. i 198 Chambers v. Randall. ii 101 Champsey Bhara v. Jivraj

Balloo Co. ii 118 Chapman v. Ellesmere . v 111 Chardon, Re . iii 463 China Navigation Co. r. Att.-

Gen. v 101 Civilian War Claimants Assn.

v. The King. v 102 Clark v. Baraes . iv 71 Clayton and Waller v. Oliver iv 215 Cleghorn v. Oldhain . iii 294 Cohen v. Roche . iii 267 Coleshill v. Manchester Corpn. iii 290 Collins v. Henry Whiteway .. iii 292 Commonwealth of Australia v.

N. 8. W. iv 54 Commonwealth Trust, Ltd. v.

Akotey . ii 386 Condogianis v. Guardian

Assurance . i 204 Cooper v. Stubbs. ii 380 Corbett v. Burge. v 123 Cotterill v. Penn. vi 106 Craddock Bros. v. Hunt _ ii 75 Crown Milling Co. v. R. iii 275 Cunard v. Antifyre. v 270

Dadoo, Ltd. v. Municipal Council of Krugersdorp ....

Davis v. Lisle . vi - v. Mayhew . iii Debtor, Re A . Deen v. Davies . vi 114

200 260 297 82

Deuchar v. Gas Co. ii Dickinson v. Del Solar. iv

86 69

Donoghue v. Stevenson. v 116 Donovan v. Union Cartage Co. v 273

VOL. PAGR Doyle v. White City Stadium v 388 Drake v. Gray. vi 248 Duff Development Co., Ltd. v.

Gov. of Kelantan. i 363 Duncan v. Jones. vi 108, 239

Eastern Shipping Co. v. Quah Beng Kee . ii 99

Ecclesiastical Commissionere, Re . vi 247

Edwards v. Porter . i 339 - v. - . ii 260 Egton Settled Estate, Re .... iv 383 Ellerman Line, Ltd. v.

Smith's Dock, Ltd. ii 82 Ellesmere v. Wallace. iii 429 Ellis v. Fulham B. C. vi 437 - v. John Stenning & Son v 109 Elvin Powell v. Plummer

Roddis . v 407 Engelke v. Musmann. iii 441 English Hopgrowers v. Dering iii 433 Eshugbayi Eleko v. Officer,

etc. iii 426 Excelsior Wire Rope Co. v.

Callan . iv 228

Fagan v. Green & Edwards, Ltd. ii 382

Fagernes, The . iii 277 Fairman v. Perpetual Invest-

ment Building Society .... i 347 Fariton v. Denville. v 118 Fardon v. Harcourt-Rivington v 118 Farey v. Welch . iv 67 Farr v. Butters Bros. v 117 Farr & Co. v. Messers . iii 266 Fasbender v. Att.-Gen. i 199 Fender v. St. John-Mildmay

vi 102, 432 Ferdinand, Ex-Czar of Bul-

garia, Re . i 79 Fitch v. Dewes . i 203 Flint v. Lovell. v 407 Folkes v. King. i 351 Ford, Re . iii 478 Foster v. Driscoll . iv 59 Freeborn v. Leeming. ii 388

Galbraith Grant, Ltd. v. Block i 357 Gayler & Pope, Ltd. v.

Davies, Ltd. ii 261 General Union of Operative

Carpenters v. Taylor . i 343 George Wills & Sons v. Cun-

ningham, Son & Co., Ltd. .. ii 222 Gibaud v. Great Eastern Ry. i 86 Glanville v. Sutton . iii 287



Index of Cases Annotated.

Glasbrook Bros. v. Glamorgan C. C ....................

Glasgow Corpn. v. Taylor .... Gottliffe v. Edelston ........ Grant v. Australian Knitting

M ills ................... Gray, Re .................. -- v. Perpetual Trustee Co. Greer v. Downs Supply Co. .. Griffiths v. Studebakers, Ltd. Grosvenor Settled Estates, Re

v Grove-Grady, The .......... G. W. K. v. Dunlop Rubber

Co. ... ................

Hall v. Brooklands Auto Racing Club ..............

Halstead v. Bargh .......... Hambrook v. Stokes Bros... Harcourt, Re .............. Hardie and Lane v. Chilton .. Harrods v. Lemon :......... Haseldine v. Hosken ........ Hawkins, Re .............. Haynes v. Harwood ....... Hemmings v. Stoke Poges

Golf Club ................ Henshall v. Porter .......... Herd v. Herd .............. Hillen and Pettigrew v. I. C.

I. (Alkali) ................ Hilton v. Westminster Bank .. Hoare & Co. v. McAlpine .... Hodson v. Barnes .......... Holliday, Re ................ Hollywood Silver Fox Farm v.

Emmett .................. Holt v. Markham .......... Honeywill and Stein v. Larkin

Bros. .................. Hong Kong, etc., Corpn. v. Lo

Lee Shi .................. Hope's Will Trust, Re ...... Horton's Estate v. Jas. Beattie Hoskyns-Abrahall v. Paignton

U. D. C. ................ Houghton v. Nothard ........ Howard v. Odhams Press vi Howard, Houlder and Part-

ners, Ltd. v. Manx Isles S.S. Co., Ltd. ...........

Howell v. Evans ............ Hummeltenberg, Re ........ Humphery v. Bowers ...... Humphreys v. Dreamland .. Hunt v. Damon ............

VOL.

ii i

iv

vi ii

iii iii ii

PAGE

223 349 222

118 393 461 259 229

108, 268 iv 82

iii 105

v 105 iii 283 ii 247 i 82

iii 436 iv 373 v 258 ii 237 v 410

i 83 ii 90 vi 238

vi 120 iii 87 ii 111

iii 103 i 361

vi 258 ii 95

v 402

iii 242 iv 83 iii 90

iii 462 iii 245 242, 430

ii iii

i iv iv iv

79 75

327 76

389 229

Hussey and Green's Contract, Re ....................

Huyton and Roby Gas Co. v. Liverpool Corpn ...........

Hyde v. Taylor ............

Importers' Co. v. Westminster Bank ....................

Inche Noriah v. Shaik, etc... Ipswich Permanent Money

Club v. Arthy ............ Ironmonger v. Dyne ........

VOL. PAGE

i 83

ii 388 iii 79

iii 240 iii 440

i 89 iii 260

Jameson v. Kinmell Bay, etc., Co . ..................... iv 374

Jarvis v. Moy ............. vi 240 Job Edwards, Ltd. v. Pro-

prietors of Birmingham Navigations ............. ii 254

Johnston v. Davies .......... iii 463 Johnstone v. Pedlar ........ i 214 Jones (R. E.) v. Waring &

Gillow . ................. iii 83-84 - v. London C. C. ...... v 119 Jupiter, The ............... iii 80

Karflex v. Poole ............ Kasler v. Slavouski .......... Kempler v. Bravingtons .... Kennedy v. Thomassen ...... Keppel v. Wheeler ......... Kettle v. Dunster .......... King's Theatre, Sunderland,

Re ...................... Koechlin v. Kestenbaum .... Konskier v. Goodman ...... Koursk, The ................ Kursell v. Timber Operators ..

Lamb & Sons v. Goring Brick Co ......................

Langham v. Wellingborough School (Governors of) ....

Lanyon, Re ................ Lapish v. Braithwaite ...... Latter v. Colwill ........... Laubach v. Co-optimists' Syn-

dicate .................... Laurie and Morewood v. John

Dudin & Sons ............ Leaman v. The King ........ Legh's Settlement Trusts, Re Leigh's Settled Estates, Re .. L'Estrange v. Graucob ...... Letang v. Ottawa Electric Ry.

v iii ii iv iii iii

iv iii iii ii

iii

250 270 385 62

257 243

72 241 295 243 78

v 106

v 120 iii 299 ii 371 vi 427

iii 93

ii 383 i 93

vi 444 iii 110 v 389

iii 98

xiii




Liddle v. Yorks (N. Riding) C. C ....................

Liesbosch Dredger v. S.S. Edison ................

Lindsey C. C. v. Marshall .. Lloyds Bank, Re .......... - v. Chartered Bank, etc. Lockhart v. Harrison ...... London Corpn., The ........ London Jewellers v. Atten-

borough .................. Looker v. Law Union, etc.,

Co ...................... Low v. Fry ................ Lowther v. Harris .......... Lynn v. Bamber ............

M'Alister (or Donoghue) v. Stevenson ...............

Macartney, Re .............. Macaura v. N. Assurance Co.,

Ltd. .................... Mackenzie-Kennedy v. Air

Council ................ McNeall v. Hawes .......... Manchester Liners, Ltd. v.

Rea, Ltd. ................ Manton v. Brocklebank ...... Marbe v. George Edwardes .. Marie Leonhardt, The ...... Maritime National Fish, Ltd.

v. Ocean Trawlers, Ltd. .. Marriott v. Maltby Main Col-

liery Co. .................. Marshall v. Lindsey C. C. ..

Mason v. Lack .............. May v. May .............. Mercantile Union Guarantee

Corpn. v. Ball ............ Mercer v. S. E. & Chatham

Ry. ...................... Mersey Docks Board v. Procter Miles v. Easter........... Mills, Re .................. Minter v. Priest ............ Mogileff, The .............. Monk v. Warbey ............ Moore v. Att.-Gen. of Irish

Free State ................ Moore & Co. v. Donnelly .... More v. Weaver ............ Morelli v. Fitch ............ Motor Manufacturers and

Traders, Ltd. v. Motor Manufacturers Insurance Co ......................

VOL. PAGB

v 408

v 274 vi 254 iv 377 iii 423 iii 452 vi 113

v 898

iii 430 vi 99 iii 101 iv 214

v 116 i 81

ii 397

iii 252 i 339

i 359 ii 105

iii 253 i 79

vi 100

i 84 vi 119,

254 iv 53 iv 58

vi

i ii v

iv iv

i v

vi i

iii iii

426

349 108 264 218 286 216 400

97 85

450 447

VOL. PAGB Murdoch v. Wood .......... i 207 Murphy and Others v. Hurley i 360 Musgrove, In the Estate of .. iii 297 Mycroft v, Sleight .......... i 211

Nachimson v. Nachimson .... iv 208 Nanka Bruce v. Common-

wealth Trust, Ltd......... ii 387 National Sailors' Union v.

Reed .................... iii 99 Newsholme Bros. v. Road,

etc., Co ................... iv 61 Nicholls v. Ely Beet Sugar

Factory . ................. vi 259 Noble v. Harrison .......... iii 97 North Charterland Exploration

Co. v. The King .......... iv 211 Northwestern Utilities v.

London, etc., Co ........ vi 121 Nunan v. Southern Ry ....... ii 239

Oakley v. Lyster ............ Ogle's Settled Estates, Re .. Oliver v. Birmingham and

Midland Motor Omnibus Co. Osborn v. Boulter ........ Otto v. Bolton ..............

Paley, Olga (Princess) v. W eisz ..................

Palmolive Co. v. Freedman .. Parker v. Miller ............ Parker's Settled Estates, Re .. Pearce v. Brain ........... Pellworm, The .............. Penton v. S. R. ........... Percy v. Glasgow Corpn..... Phillips v. Britannia Hygienic

Laundry Co............... Piracy Jure Gentium, Re Place v. Searle ............. Poland v. Parr .............. Polemis v. Furness, Withy &

Co. ....... .......... Pontardawe R. D. C. v.

Moore-Gwyn ............. Porter, Re .................. Prager v. Blatspiel, Stamp &

Heacock, Ltd. ............ Pramatha Nath Mulick v.

Pradymuna, etc.......... Pratt v. Patrick and Others .. Price, Re ..................

iv 384 iii 280

v 115 iv 225 vi 253

iv iii iii iii iv

i iv i

i v v

iii

68 434 95

281 60

365 372 354

345 395 112 91

i 206

iv 80 ii 392

ii 241

iii 42 ii 107 iv 70

ii 396 Public Tristee v. Villar .... iii 465

xiv




Purkis v. Walthamstow Borough Council ..........

Putsnam v. Taylor ..........

R. v. Baldessare ............ v. Chesshire ..........

- v. Cory ................ v. Currell ............ v. Donovan ............

- . Godfrey ............ v. Hare .............. v. aslam ............

- . Hussey ............ - . Kopsch ............ - . Lapworth .......... - . Manley ............ - v. Maughan ..........

- v. Meyrick ............ v. Minister of Health ..

- v. Mortimer .......... -- v. Newport (Salop) Jus-

tices .................... v. Peckham .......... v. Peel ................

- v. Phillips ............ - v. Redd ..............

- . Smith (1936) ........ v. Stocks .............. v. Stone ..............

- v. Sugarman .......... - v. Wadey ............ - v. Wainwright ........ - v. Wheat .............

- v. Whitehead .......... v. W icks ..............

Ralston v. Ralston .......... Rawlings v. General Trading

Co ..................... Reckitt v. Barnett .......... Reference under Judicial Com-

mittee Act, Re ............ Rely-a-Bell, etc., Co. v. Eisler Reynolds v. Shipping Federa-

tion ...................... Richardson v. Moncrieff ..... Riley v. Brown ............ Robert Addie & Sons v. Dum-

breck ................... Robinson v. Graves .......... Rose v. Ford .......... vi Rose and Frank v. J. R.

Crompton Bros. ...... ii Ross, R .................. Rowland, etc., v. Air Council.. Royal London Insurance Socy.

v. Barrett ................

VOL. PAGE

v 403 iii 262

iv 217 iii 272 iii 274 vi 109 v 392 i 325 v 262 ii 366 ii 231 ii 366 iv 375 v 263 v 394

iv 65 iv 55 vi 246

iv 65 vi 109

i 336 vi 435 ii 88 vi 109

i 91 vi 436 vi 109 vi 109 ii 366 i 91

iii 438 vi 245 iv 224

i 88 iii 445

v 395 iii 103

ii 116 iii 79 iv 56

iv 78 vi 105

116, 442

219, 377 iv 209 iii 252

iii 431

v

Ruby Steamship Corpn. v. Commercial Union Assur- ance Co. ..............

Rugby School (Governors of) v. Tannahill ..............

Russell v. Russell .......... Rutherford v. Richardson ....

Sack v. Jones .............. St. Anne's Well Brewery Co.

v. Roberts ................ Sampson, Low, Ltd. v. J. M.

Dent, Ltd .............. - v. Dckworth Co..... Scammell v. Hurley ........ Scottish Mutual Insurance Co.

v. Samuel & Co. .......... Seager v. Seager ............ Sharpe v. Southern Ry. ...... Shawdon Estates, Re ...... Sigsworth, Re .............. Sinclair v. Brougham ..... Siveyer v. Allison ......... Slater v. Spreag ............ Smith, Ltd. v. G. W. Ry. .. Sorrell v. Smith aLd Others

ii Spyer v. Phillipson .......... Sterns, Ltd. v. Vickers, Ltd. Stonehouse v. Masson ...... Strangways-Lesmere v. Clay-

ton ...................... Sullivan, Re ................ Sun Life Assurance Co. of

Canada v. W. H. Smith & Son ......................

Sunnyfield, Re .............. Sutcliffe v. Clients' Invest-

ment Co. ................ Sutton v. Featherley ........ Swadling v. Cooper ........ Swan v. Sinclair .......... Swinburne, Re ............

Taylor, Re ................ Taylor's Settlement Trusts, Re Terry v. Variety Theatres .... Tetley, Re .................. Thomas v. Att.-Gen. ....... -- v. Sawkins .......... vi Thompson v. L. M. & S. Ry. - v. N. S. W. Branch of

B. M . A. ................ Thorne v. Motor Trade Asso-

ciation ..................

b*

OL. PAGE

v 21

v 896 ii 233 i 337

ii 394

iii 458

ii 395 ii 395 iv 74

ii 96 ii 376 ii 374 iv 221 vi 111 vi 305 vi 101 vi 116

i 866

114, 367 iv 380 ii 80 i 212

vi 255 iv 84

v 404 iv 382

ii 256 iii 86 iv 227 ii 103

iii 86

iv 380 iv 52 iii 427

i 330 i 81 22, 96

iv 63

ii 259

vi 440

XV



XVI Index of Cases Annotated.

VOL. PAOI Tidy v. Battman. v 272 Tolley v. Fry . iv 386 Tomkins v. Coates . iii 89 Tomline's WU1, Re . iv 392 Torni, The . v 100 Tournier v. National Provin-

cial Bank, Ltd. ii 226 Tubantia, The . ii 98 Turner v. Civil Service Supply

Association, Ltd. ii 382

Union of London and Smiths Bank, Ltd.'s, Conveyance, Re. v 264

Universal Steam Navigation Co. v. James McKelvie & Co. ii 85

Upton v. Great Central By. .. ii 117

Valeria, The. i 80 Van Oppen & Co. v. Trede-

gars. i 209 Vanbergen v. St. Edmunds

Properties . v 256 Vanderpant v. Mayfair Hotel

Co. iv 80 Villar, Re . iii 465 Visser, Re. iii 443 Volute, The . i 341

Walton Harvey v. Walker and Homfrays . iv 216

Ware and De Freville v. The Motor Trades Association .. i 210

VOL. PAQI Warner Bros. Pictures v.

Nelson . vi 244 Watt v. Longsdon . iv 76 Weigall v. Westminster Hos-

pital . vi 252 Welsh Hospital (Netley) Fund,

Re . i 81 Wessez Dairies v. Smith .... vi 103 Westminster (Duke of) v.

McKenna . v 268 White v. Riley . i 84 White (or Bennett) v. White vi 424 Widnes Foundry v. Cellulose,

etc.,Co. iv 369 Wiggins v. Lavy. iii 448 Wilchick v. Marks and Silver-

stone . v 411 Wilkes v. Allington . iv 378 -v. Jones and Goodwin ii 91 Wilkins v. Leighton . v 121 Williams v. Atlantic Assur-

ance Co. v 107 Wilsons and Clyde Coal Co. v.

English . v 441 Winkworth v. Raven. iv 376 With v. O'Flanagan. vi 243 Withers v. General Theatre

Corpn. v 257 Woollatt v. Stanley . iii 421 Woolmington v. D. P. P. .. vi 107 Wyatt v. Kreglinger. v 261

Youssoupoff v. Metro-Goldwyn- Mayer Pictures . v 405



Date post:	08-Jan-2017
Category:	Documents
Upload:	trinhtuong
View:	215 times
Download:	2 times

Volume Information

Documents