of 27
8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
1/27
What an engineer needs to know about
patent law: Part I The Basics
Shu Wang [email protected]
LG Electronics Mobile Research, USA
mailto:[email protected]8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
2/27
Outline
Introduction to the patent business The value of patents and intellectual property.
US patents and patent applications numbers
Patent right and obligations
Patentability of inventions
Anticipation/Novelty Non-Obviousness
Patentable subject matters
Steps in invention Patentability search
Patent applications Application types Application content
Pre-granted publication (PG Pub or the 18 month rule)
8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
3/27
The Value of Patents
A U.S. appeals court on Wednesday set a sooner-than-expected end to Eli Lilly andCo.'s reign as the sole marketer of Prozac, the popular antidepressant drug, adevelopment that sent the pharmaceutical company's stock down by more than 30percent. -- Eli Lilly gets Prozac blues CNN Money, August 9, 2000.
It is about $36 billion in Lilly stock value, roughly a third of the pharmaceuticalgiants market capitalization.
Royalties from inventions earn an estimated $150B/year worldwide and are expected togrow 30% annually over the next 5 years. -- Trying to Cash in on Patents. NewYork Times, June 7, 2002.
From 1993 2003, IBM earned well over $10 Billion in revenue from licensing out itspatents and was awarded over 22,000 patents, more than the 10 largest U.S. ITcompanies combined, including Intel, Microsoft, Sun, Dell and Apple.
Microsoft, $8 Billion/year spent on Research and Development. 3,000 patent
applications filed each year in the U.S. BellSouths, now a part of AT&T, Patent Portfolio: 1998 50 patents, 2006 1,000
patents. Licensing out of BellSouths patent portfolio brings 100s of millions of dollarsto the bottom-line. -- Scott Frank, Esquire, President of BellSouth IP ManagementCorp. and BellSouth IP Marketing Corp. June 27, 2006.
8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
4/27
Intellectual Property: A Key Modern Corporate
Asset
Tangible assets as a percentage of US corporate value: 1982: 62%
2000: 30%
Recent a British study: 40% of a companys value is not shown in any way on its balance sheet.
More than 80% of the market value of these companies is said to be in IPassets:
Walt Disney
Microsoft
P&G
8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
5/27
Patenting Expense
It really depends on the complexity of the invention. One possible example is
preparing and filing application: $3,800
Corresponding with patent office: $1,800
USPTO fee schedule Basic filing fee Utility: $310.
Independent claims in excess of three: $210.
Claims in excess of 20: $50.
Multiple dependent claim: $370
Provisional application filing fee: $210 Utility issue fees: $1440
Maintenance fees: $930, $2360, $3910
Due at 3.5, 7.5 and 11.5 years after patent is issued.
8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
6/27
U.S. Patents granted, 18002004
Source: USPTO & Wikipedia
8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
7/27
Patent Office Statistics
Patent applications Year 1998: 260,889 applications filed.
Year 2002: 333,688 applications filed.
Year 2005: 384,228 applications filed.
Patents Issued:
66,000 in 1980. 176,000 in 2000.
152,090 in 2005.
Each week, the Patent Office issuesapproximately 3,500 new patents.
0
20000
40000
60000
80000
100000
120000
140000
160000
180000
200000
Patents Issued
1980
2000
2002
8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
8/27
Patent Right by Law
The Congress shall have Power ... to promote the Progress ofScience and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authorsand Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings andDiscoveries. -- US Constitutional Authority, Article 1, Section 8,Clause 8
The issue of patents for new discoveries has given a spring toinvention beyond my conception. -- Thomas Jefferson
The patent system added the fuel of interest to the fire ofinvention. -- Abraham Lincoln
Under such regional systems, an applicant requests protection for
the invention in one or more countries, and each country decidesas to whether to offer patent protection within its borders. -- WorldIntellectual Property Organization
8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
9/27
Patent Right and Obligation
Government grant right to exclude A U. S. patent provides its owner with the legal right to prevent
unauthorized making, using, selling, offering for sale in the U.S. and the importation into the U.S., of the invention set forthand claimed in the patent.
In exchange, the inventor must disclose how to make and use theinvention.
Not a Right to Practice But this right to exclude does not grant the right to practice the
invention (e.g., government regulation may interfere).
8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
10/27
Patent Rights: A Corporate Perspective
Use offensively as a right to exclude Exclusive use and sale may permit setting prices at a level not
possible without patent protection.
Erect barriers for entry into a market.
Revenue through licensing or assignment.
Use defensively as part of a patent portfolio to trade (crosslicense) right to exclude.
Maintain product differentiation
Develop reputation as innovator/prestige
Helps with credibility/advertising
8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
11/27
Patentable Application
Inventions patentable: 35 USC 101 A Process
A Machine
A Composition of Matter
A Manufacture
Specification and Drawings: 35 USC 112/113 First Paragraph: written description, enablement and best mode
Second Paragraph: requirements for the claims.
Sixth paragraph:
Novelty and Loss of Right to Patent: 35 USC 102
A person shall be entitled to a patent unless (a) ~ (g)
Non-Obvious Subject Matter: 35 USC 103 The Graham Factual Inquiries: Graham v. John Deere
8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
12/27
Patentable Subject Matters
35 USC 101 Whoever invents or discovers any new and useful process, machine,
manufacture, or composition of matter, or any new and usefulimprovement thereof, may obtain a patent therefor, subject to theconditions and requirement of this title.
Diamond v. Chakrabarty A nonnaturally occurring manufacture or composition of matter a
product of human ingenuity having a distinctive name, character,[and] use is patentable subject matter.
[T]he production of articles for use from raw materials prepared bygiving to these materials new forms, qualities, properties, or
combinations whether by hand labor or by machineryis amanufacture under 35 U.S.C. 101.
8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
13/27
Non-Patentable Subject Matter
Diamond v. Chakrabarty The laws of nature, physical phenomena and abstract ideas are not
patentable subject matter.
[A] new mineral discovered in the earth or a new plant found in thewild is not patentable subject matter. Likewise, Einstein could notpatent his celebrated E=mc2; nor could Newton have patented the law
of gravity. Such discoveries are manifestations of... nature, free to allmen and reserved exclusively to none.
Controversies, including naturally occurring biological material;
genetic sequences;
stem cells; computer programs. Gottschalk v. Benson, Parker v. Flook, Diamond
v. Diehr
business methods. State Street Bank decision
8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
14/27
Patent Types
Utility Patent Product/Apparatus: a cell phone
Machine: a machine for making the cell phone
Process: a method for assembling the cell phone
Compositions of Matter: the metal-feeling cell phone shell.
Design Patent Whoever invents any new, original and ornamental design for anarticle of manufacture may obtain a patent therefor, 35 USC171
Plant Patent Whoever invents or discovers and asexually reproduces any distinct
and new variety of plant, including cultivated sports, mutants, hybrids,and newly found seedlings, other than a tuber propagated plant or aplant found in an uncultivated state, may obtain a patent therefor, 35 USC 161.
8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
15/27
Steps of Invention
Conception Create the invention in general terms.
Complete when one perceives a specific result and a particular meansof accomplishing the result.
The criteria is the left reduction to practice is obvious to one of ordinaryskill.
Actual Reduction to Practice "[R]equires that the claimed invention work for its intended purpose.
Brunswick Corp. v. U.S.
Constructive Reduction to Practice "[O]ccurs upon the filing of a patent application on the claimed
invention." Brunswick Corp. v. U.S.
8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
16/27
16
Patentability Searches Why to Search?
Searches made to determine whether there is enough protection availableto go forward What is the risk of rejection by PTO?
Identifies the prior art and extent protection available over prior art
Helps with drafting process Aids preparer and makes for a stronger patent
Draft claims to reflect existing prior art
Identifies customary level of disclosure for a particular art
Helps the PTO examiner Guides the examiner to right technology
Helps accelerate the examination procedure if necessary.
8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
17/27
Patentability Searches What to Search for?
Look for identical or similar inventions on the internet
in publications and catalogs
in patents and published applications
Look for evidence that the invention is
not new or
obvious when multiple references are combined.
8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
18/27
Patentability Searches How to Search
Key word search Keywords that describe invention or product
It is good for starting a patent search
Classification search 436 utility classes, 100-500 sub-classes pre class
PTO index: www.uspto.gov/go/classification
Cross-reference search When a similar patent is found,
review cited patent
Review referenced by patents
http://www.uspto.gov/go/classificationhttp://www.uspto.gov/go/classification8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
19/27
Patentability Searches Where to Search?
PTO website: www.uspto.gov/patft complex and used by PTO examiners.
word searches from early 1970 tile now.
classification searches for all patents
easy to navigate cross-references
Google Patents: www.google.com/patents
Easy to use
Now downloads
FreePatentsOnline.com
http://www.uspto.gov/patfthttp://www.google.com/patentshttp://www.google.com/patentshttp://www.uspto.gov/patft8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
20/27
Anticipation/Novelty: 35 USC 102
Not first or true inventor 102(a): Before invention by applicant, invention is made known or usedby others in USA, or disclosed anywhere.
102(e): Another has disclosed invention in earlier filed US or PCTapplication that is published in English or, if not published, later issuesas a US patent
102(f): Invention was derived from another. 102(g): Another invented first in US and did not abandon, suppress or
conceal the invention, or another succeeds in an interferenceproceeding.
Not timely application 102(b): Disclosed anywhere or in public use or on sale in the US more
than one year before application. 102(c): Invention has been abandoned. 102(d): Applicant received a foreign patent before US filing on an
application filed more than a year before US filing.
8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
21/27
Non-Obviousness: 35 USC 103
Must not have been obvious Prior art discloses an invention that is so similar to the allegedinvention that it would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in theart based on the knowledge of the prior art
The court determines obviousness by examining the differencesbetween the prior art and the claimed invention in view of what wouldbe readily understood by one of ordinary skill in the art
Objective evidence of non-obviousness Commercial success attributable to the invention Long felt but unsatisfied need for the invention Copying by competitors Acclaim by the industry, etc.
Generally non-obviousness is established by showing the advantages of the invention a lack of motivation for modifying prior art to result in the invention the prior art actually suggests not making the modification (teaching
away)
8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
22/27
Application Types
Provisional Patent Application Needs only a Specification, and drawings (if needed)
Non-Provisional Patent Application Requires Specification, drawings (if needed), and claims
Continuing Patent Application
Continuation patent application Continuation-in-part application
Divisional patent application. 35 USC 121
8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
23/27
Application Content
Title Cross-Reference to Related Application(s)
Background of the Invention
Brief Summary of the Invention
Brief Description of the Drawings
Detailed Description of the Invention
Claim(s)
Abstract
8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
24/27
Prepare An Application
Disclose enough to enable one skilled in the art to make and use theinvention
Disclose best mode of carrying out the invention (that is, if the inventorhas the subjective belief there is a best way to carry out the invention).
If possible, disclose more than required
Disclose all alternative embodiments
Interferes with others attempts to obtain improvement patents ordesigning around the patent Broadens possible scope of protection and provides retreat positions
for claiming invention
Applications lacking in detail sometimes get broader interpretations, butare easier to invalidate
Define the scope of the invention Must be clear Must not read on the prior art Must define a novel, non-obvious and useful invention Provides notice to the public
8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
25/27
Office Action
Responses to an Examiners actions can occur through: interviews,
written arguments,
amendments to the text of the application including claims, and
affidavits or other documentary evidence supporting patentability
Generally present arguments twice for each office action fee
If USPTO denies application patent, a patent applicant may appeal to theUSPTO Board of three Administrative Patent Judges, then onto eitherDistrict Court to present more evidence or directly to the Court of Appealsfor the Federal Circuit
Allowance of claims and issuance upon payment of issue fee and now an
application publication fee
8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
26/27
18 Month Publication of U.S. applications
Provide for provisional rights No injunctions, but can get monetary award (reasonable royalty) if
issued claims are substantially identical to the claims in the
published application
Must provide actual notice to infringer
Voluntary publication possible but generally application published as
filed
May cause competitors apprehension
Can block others from getting similar rights
8/14/2019 What an Engineer Needs to Know About Patent
27/27
Interesting Patent Examples
7062320Device for the treatment of hiccups: Appears to be a glassthat shocks you when you drink from it, ostensibly stimulating specificnerves in an attempt to cure hiccups.
5878931Halloween Backpack A backpack that dispenses candy
4858627 Smokers Hat A hat with an air intake, which filters and thenexpels the air. Looks pretty much like wearing the exhaust hood for a
stove on your head.
4344424Anti-Eating Mouth Cage Just think Hannibal Lecter
4300473 Device For Moistening The Adhesive Coating On PostageStamps and Envelopes Describes a device containing an applicator tomoisten stamps. Check out this quote: "The applicator may be in the form
of a human tongue" Boy, that's novel.