+ All Categories
Home > Documents > WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229...

WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229...

Date post: 17-Mar-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 0 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
24
NASA-CR-196134 19940030853 ' WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL, AND PALEOCLIMATIC EVOLUTION MSATT Mars SurfaceandAtmosphereThroughTime -------_-=_:_'°_,_'r _'7:7rER LANGLEY RESF-/_'£'.'4 (5 ,.!, L!gib",R'Y ".&_ _' i ' _ LPI Technical Report Number 93-04, Part 2 Lunar and Planetary Institute 3600 Bay Area Boulevard Houston TX 77058-1113 LPI/TR--93-04, Part 2 https://ntrs.nasa.gov/search.jsp?R=19940030853 2020-03-22T21:08:47+00:00Z
Transcript
Page 1: WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229 WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL, AND PALEOCLIMATIC

NASA-CR-19613419940030853

' WORKSHOP ONTHE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS:

SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL,AND PALEOCLIMATIC EVOLUTION

MSATTMars SurfaceandAtmosphereThroughTime

-------_-=_:_'°_,_'r_'7:7rERLANGLEYRESF-/_'£'.'4(5 ,.!,

L!gib",R'Y".&__' i

' _ LPI Technical Report Number 93-04, Part 2Lunar and Planetary Institute 3600 Bay Area Boulevard Houston TX 77058-1113LPI/TR--93-04, Part 2

https://ntrs.nasa.gov/search.jsp?R=19940030853 2020-03-22T21:08:47+00:00Z

Page 2: WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229 WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL, AND PALEOCLIMATIC
Page 3: WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229 WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL, AND PALEOCLIMATIC

DISPLAY02/2/i

94NS5359_#ISSUE11 PAGE4S54 CATEGORY91

RPT#:NASA-CR-196134NAS1.26:196134LPI-TR-gS-O4-PT-2CNT_:NASW-4574

93/00/0015PAGES UNCLASSIFIEDDOCUMENT

UTTL:WorkshopontheMartianNorthernPlains:Sedimentological,periglacial,

andpaleoclimaticevolution

AUTH:A/KARGEL,J.S.; B/PARKER,T.2.; C/MOORE,2. M. PAT:A/ed.;B/ed.;

C/ed.

CORP:LunarandPlanetaryInst.,Houston,TX.

SAP: Avail:CASTHC AOS/MFA01

C/O: UNITEDSTATES _orkshopheldinFairbanks,AK,12-13Aug.1993MAJS:/_ARCTICREGIONS/_GEOPHYSICSI_MARSSURFACE/_PLAINS/_PLANETARYGEOLOGY/_

TIMESERIESANALYSIS

MINS:/ EXPOSURE/GLACIERS/LANDFORMS/LOWALTITUDE

ABA: Author(revised)

ABS: ThepenultimatemeetingintheMarsSurfaceandAtmosphereThroughTime

(MSATT)seriesof workshopswasheldon thecampusoftheUniversityof

AIaskainFairbanks,Alaska,12-13Aug.1993.Thismeeting,entitled'The

MartianNorthernPlains:Sedimentological,PerigIacial,andPaleoclimatic

Evolution,'hostedby theGeophysicalInstituteat theUniversityof

Alaska,wasdesignedtohelpfosteran exchangeof ideasamongresearchersof theMarssciencecommunityandtheterrestrialgiaoialandperiglacial

sciencecommunity.Thetechnicalsessionsof theworkshopwereENTER: MORE

Page 4: WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229 WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL, AND PALEOCLIMATIC
Page 5: WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229 WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL, AND PALEOCLIMATIC

NASA Technical

3 1176 01413 7229

WORKSHOP ON

THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS:

SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL,

AND PALEOCLIMATIC EVOLUTION

Edited by

J. S. Kargel, T. J. Parker, and J. M. Moore

Held atFairbanks, Alaska

August 12-13, 1993

Sponsored byMSAq-TStudy Group

Lunar and Planetary InstituteUniversity of Alaska

Lunar and Planetary Institute 3600 Bay Area Boulevard Houston TX 77058-1113

LPI Technical Report Number 93-04, Part 2LPI/TR--93-04, Part 2

Page 6: WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229 WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL, AND PALEOCLIMATIC

Compiled in 1994 byLUNAR AND PLANETARY INSTITUTE

The Institute is operated by Universities Space Research Association under Contract No. NASW-4574 with the National Aero-nautics and Space Administration.

Material in this document may be copied without restraint for library, abstract service, educational, or personal research pur-poses; however, republication of any portion requires the written permission of the authors as well as appropriate acknowledg-mentof this publication.

This report may be cited as

Kargel J. S., Parker T. J., and Moore J. M. (1994) Workshop on The Martian Northern Plains: Sedimentological, Periglacial,and Paleoclimatic Evolution. LPI Tech. Rpt. 93-04, Part 2, Lunar and Planetary Institute, Houston. 8 pp.

This report is distributed by

ORDER DEPARTMENT

Lunar and Planetary Institute3600 Bay Area BoulevardHouston TX 77058-1113

Mail order requestors will be invoiced for the cost of shipping and handling.

Page 7: WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229 WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL, AND PALEOCLIMATIC

LP! Technical Report 93-04, Part2 iii

Preface

The penultimate meeting in the Mars Surface and Atmosphere ThroughTime (MSATI') series of workshops was held on the campus of the Uni-versity of Alaska in Fairbanks, Alaska, August 12and 13, 1993. Thismeeting, entitled "The Martian Northern Plains: Sedimentological,Periglacial, and Paleoclimatic Evolution," hosted by the GeophysicalInstitute at the University of Alaska, wasdesigned to help foster an ex-change of ideas among researchers of the Mars science community and theterrestrial glacial and periglacial science community. The technical ses-sions of the workshop were complemented by field trips to the AlaskaRange and to the Fairbanks area and a low-altitude chartered overflight tothe Arctic Costal Plain, so that, including these trips, the meeting lastedfrom August 9 to August 14, 1993. The meeting, field trips, and overflightwere organized and partially funded by the Lunar and Planetary Instituteand the MSATI"Study Group. The major share of logistical support wasprovided by the Publications and Program Services Department of theLunar and Planetary Institute. The workshop site was selected to alloweasy access to field exposures of active glaciers and glacial and periglaciallandforms. In all, 25 scientists attended the workshop, 24 scientists (plus 4guests and the meeting coordinator) participated in the field trips, and 18took part in the overflight. The field trips and overflight were led by TroyP6w6, James Beg&, Richard Reger, and David Hopkins. This meetingreaffirmed the value of expertly led geologic field trips conducted inassociation with topical workshops.

Page 8: WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229 WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL, AND PALEOCLIMATIC
Page 9: WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229 WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL, AND PALEOCLIMATIC

LPI Technical Report 93-04, Part 2 v

Program

Monday, August 9, 1992

6:30- 6:40 p.m.

Welcoming RemarksJ. S. Kargel

6:40-6:45 p.m.

Field TripLogisticsL. Simmons

6:45-7:30 p.m.

Science Objectives of the Field TripT. L. P6w6

Tuesday, August 10, 1993-Wednesday, August 11, 1993

FIELD TRIP I--ALASKA RANGE

Thursday, August 12, 1993

8:45 a.m.-12:00 noon

Workshop, Geophysical InstituteGLACIAL AND PERIGLACIAL GEOMORPHOLOGY OF ALASKA

Chair: J.M. Moore

Review of the Origin of Ground Ice on EarthT. L. P6w6

Milankovitch Insolation Forcing and Cyclic Formation of Large-scale Glacial, Fluvial, and EolianLandforms in Central Alaska

J. E. Beg6t

Cryoplanation Terraces of Interior and WesternAlaskaR. D. Reger

Calderas Produced by Hydromagmatic Eruptions Through Permafrost in Northwest AlaskaJ. E. Beg6t

Page 10: WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229 WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL, AND PALEOCLIMATIC

vi Workshop on The Martian Northern Plains

OVERVIEW OF THE NORTHERN PLAINSChair: T.J. Parker

Stratigraphy of the Martian Northern PlainsK. L.Tanaka

Observed Climatic Activity Pertaining to the Evolution of the Northern PlainsL. J. Martin

The Distribution of Ground Ice on MarsM. T. Mellon and B. M. Jakosky

Geomorphic Evidence for an Eolian Contribution to the Formation of the Martian Northern PlainsJ. R. Zimbelman

Morphologic and Morphometric Studies of lmpact Craters in the Northern Plains of MarsN. G. Barlow

Ice in the Northern Plains: Relic of a Frozen Ocean?B. K. Lucchitta

Friday, August 13, 1993

8:15 a.m.-12:00 noon

MODELS OF LANDFORM EVOLUTIONIN THE NORTHERN PLAINS

Chair: J. M. Moore

Seismic-Triggering History of the Catastrophic OuOqowsin the Chryse Region of MarsK. L. Tanaka and S. M. Clifford

Evidence for an Ice Sheet/Frozen Lake in Utopia Planitia, MarsM .G. Chapman

Possible Occurrence and Origin of Massive Ice in Utopia PlanitiaJ. S. Kargel and F. M. Costard

The Thumbprint Terrain: What Will Mars Observer Tell Us?M. W. Schaefer

A Model for the Origin of Martian Polygonal TerrainG. E. McGill

Page 11: WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229 WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL, AND PALEOCLIMATIC

LP! Technical Report 93-04, Part2 vii

A Formational Model for the Polygonal Terrains of Mars: Taking a "Crack" at the Genesis of theMartian Polygons

M. L. Wenrich and P.R. Christensen

Balloon Exploration of the Northern Plains of Mars Near and North of the Viking 2 Lander SiteF. R. West

HYDROLOGIC MODELS AND PROCESSESIN THE NORTHERN PLAINS

Chair: J.S. Kargel

A Wet Geology and Cold Climate Mars Model: Punctuation of a Slow Dynamic Approachto Equilibrium

J. S. Kargel

Role of Groundwater in Forming Periglacial Features onMarsA. D. Howard

West Deuteronilus Mensae Revisited: Can Near Be Extrapolated To(o)Far?T. Parker

The Marine Sedimentary Model for the Evolution of the Northern PlainsT. Parker and D. Gorsline

Hydrological Consequences of Ponded Water on MarsV. R. Baker

Summary and Discussion

Field Trip and Overflight LogisticsL. Simmons

Saturday, August 14, 1993FIELD TRIP IImFAIRBANKS AREA

Sunday, August 15, 1993OVERFLIGHT TO BARROW

Page 12: WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229 WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL, AND PALEOCLIMATIC
Page 13: WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229 WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL, AND PALEOCLIMATIC

LPI Technical Report 93-04, Part2 ix

Contents

Summary of Technical Sessions ............................................................................................................. 1

List of Workshop Participants ................................................................................................................ 7

Page 14: WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229 WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL, AND PALEOCLIMATIC
Page 15: WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229 WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL, AND PALEOCLIMATIC

LPI Technical Report 93-04, Part 2 1

Summary of TechnicalSessions

The Northern Plains workshop, includingassociated fieldtrips, took place August 9-15, 1993, inAlaska. The meetingwas most notable for its field setting and for the fact that it Beaufort Sea

broughttogether researchersfrom the planetaryandEarthscience communitieswho have special interests in cold-cli-mateprocessesandlandforms.Many of theplanetary scien- "...............tists who attendedthe meeting had neverbefore observedperiglacialandglacial ice ina field setting.

Program agenda follow this summary. The week-longprogramincludedthe following majorelements: .......--,= .."":':"....

Monday, August 9, evening: Welcomeand briefing for Bering Sea -ii::_:_:i!.i"!'ii': iifield trip I at the Geophysical Institute, University of Alaska, " "

ha.ks IFairbanks. ..: .Tuesday, August 10-Wednesday, August 11: Field trip

I to the Alaska Range, including overnight stay in Paxson.Thursday, August 12--Friday, August 13: Workshop at

the GeophysicalInstitute, includingaFriday evening informaldiscussion session.

Saturday, August 14: Field tripII in the Fairbanks area.Sunday, August 15: Overflightto the BrooksRange,Bar-

row, and the Arctic Coastal Plain, includingathree-hour fieldtrip in the Barrow area.

The primary purpose of the workshop's topical sessionswas to summarize knowledge of the northem plains of Mars,to present new ideas onthe possibleevolutionof the northern

plains, and to hear presentations on terrestrial cold-climate /_ Generally discontinuous permafrost in areas

processes and landforms. Most of the content of the formal l_]v,o:__--_.::;that were never glaciated; frozen groundpresentations is in theabstracts (Part 1of thisreport) and will generally exists in isolated bodies in areas ofnotbe repeated inthis summary. A highlightofthe lecture-hall favorable properties of slope, vegetation cover,sessions was an informal, two-hour discussion on Friday drainage, and rock type.

evening, August 13. The most lasting impressions for many

participants were from the field trips and overflight. The _ Generally continuous permafrost in areas that

weather was farfrom ideal, but it didnot prevent key observa- I_ were never glaciated; thickness variesfromtions. Figure 1 shows the routes of field trip I and the over- very thin to thick; permafrost is locally absentflight. A description of the field tripsand overflights follows near lakes and streams and on some slopes.the synopsis of the Friday evening discussion,below. A slideset is beingprepared tocomplement this writtensummary and

will be published separately by theLunar andPlanetary Insti- _ Extremely thick, continuous permafrost in

tute. am areas of the Arctic Coastal Plain and the NorthSlope that were never previously glaciated;SYNOPSIS OF THE DISCUSSION OF FRIDAY frozen ground is generally 300-400 m thick,

EVENING, AUGUST 13, 1993 except near the sea coast and large lakes andrivers, where it is generally 200-300 m thick.

During the informal session, four invited specialists (T. _ Areas that were glaciated at least once during

P_wt, J. Beg_t, R. Reger, and D. Hopkins) in cold-climate _!_,it the Pleistocene.processes andlandforms presented theiropinions onwhattheyhad heard duringthe formal presentations. Several presentersbrought to the discussion small selections of Mars slides that

Fig. 1. Map of Alaska showing the routes of field trip I and the over-had engenderedcontroversy. The discussioncentered mainly flight and the limit of Pleistocene glaciation (from | 1]), and the approxi-onpossible periglacialand glacial processesand landforms in matepresentboundaries of continuous and discontinuous permafrost inthe northern plains of Mars. areas that have not been glaciated (from [21).

Page 16: WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229 WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL, AND PALEOCLIMATIC

2 Workshop on The Martian Northern Plains

Referring to the slides presented by the Mars scientists, (but formerly glaciated) areas of that continent. There wasP6w6 asked his colleagues, "Has anyoneseen a pingo?" The general agreement about the possible existence of a ventifactresponse at first seemed to be a fiat"no," although Reger later in a lander image. This finding was of interest to field tripspoke of linear pingoes and other pingolike forms on Mars as participants because at one stop they collected wind-blastedreasonable possibilities, ventifacts from the upper surface of a moraine. The cold-

The cold-climate specialists had a unanimously favorable climate specialists accepted suggestions that the troughs ob-view of suggestions by B. Lucchitta and others that rock served at the Viking 2 landing site might be thermal contrac-glaciers exist in the northernplains andfretted terrain, andthat tion cracks, filled with sand wedges or ice wedges.solifluction or gelifluction has occurred there. Reger, par- All four cold-climate specialists accepted, as a reasonableticularly, was impressed by some of the evidence for peri- interpretation,amoraineanalogofcertaintypesof"thumbprintglacialflow. However,Reger,likemembersof theMarsscience terrain," notably that in southwestern Utopia Planitia. But M.community, was frustrated by the absence of virtually all Schaefer pointed out that not all so-called thumbprint terraingroundtruth for Mars. The major differences of scale between was necessarily formed by the same or similar processes.terrestrialandputativemartianrockglacierswerepointedout, Hopkins was especially skeptical of suggestions that thebut this discrepancy does not necessarily discredit the rock- thumbprintterrainoflsidisPlanitiamightconsistofmoraines.glacier interpretation: It was noted that physics should not P6w6 accepted the possible De Geer moraine analogy forlimit the size of rock glaciers, and long periods of time were thumbprint terrain, as suggested by Kargel, but this analogyavailable for their development, was notacceptable toBeg6tandReger because ofinconsisten-

The cold-climate specialists were intrigued by the large- cies of scale. Beg6tpointed out that recessional moraines inscale polygonal terrains on Mars. They, like the Mars science the plains of central North America are more analogous incommunity in recent years, did notaccept previous ideas that scale and form. P6w6 and Beg6t accepted Kargers interpre-large-scale polygonal terrainsmightconsistof ice-wedgepoly- tationthatsinuoustroughsand medial ridgesinArcadiaPlanitiagonsoranyotherfeaturecausedbythermalcontractioncrack- and Utopia Planitia could be tunnel channels and eskers;ing. Too many orders of magnitude of scale separate these Hopkins thought that some of the proposed tunnel channelsmartian terrains from ice-wedge polygons on Earth,and high- were too sinuous.amplitude thermal wavescannot penetrate deep enough in the The cold-climate specialists agreed with analogies by M.short times necessary tocause brittle failure and therebycause Chapman between subglacial volcanic landforms in Iceland,cracks of the observed scale. The cold-climate specialists suchas table mountains and moberg ridges, and features nearaccepted as reasonable possibilities the models ofG. McGill theElysiumPlateauinthenorthernplains. Theseanalogswereand M. Wenrich on theformation of these terrainsby sediment citedas supportingglacial interpretations of other features inloading and subsequent deformation. P6w6 suggested an the northern plains.alternative model, which he sketched during the discussion It was not clear whether the cold-climate specialists hadsession. This model draws a possible analogy between the developeda general consensus that glacial or periglacialpro-martian cracks and similar cracks that he studied in the allu- cesseshad been active on Mars. Therefore, V. Gulick asked,vium-filled desert basins near Phoenix, Arizona. All three "'Ifyou hadto venture a guess (without betting your life onit)models relate the origin of the cracks todeformation of sedi- as to whether glaciation or periglacial processes had everments that overlie an irregular bedrock surface, although the occurred on Mars, what would you say?" She stressed thatmechanisms of deformation differ, specific interpretationsof specific features were notthe point

Adistinction must bedrawnbetween thewell-knownlarge- ofher question. Rather, herquestion was to addressthe terres-scale polygonal terrains that were the topic of discussion and trialexperts' overall impressions of the glacial and periglacialthe small-scale polygonal terrains that Lucchitta, T. Parker, hypotheses. P6w6, Beg6t, Hopkins, and Reger respondedasand othershave discussed in theirpublications asmore reason- follows.able analogs of ice-wedge polygons. The small-scale martian P6w6 generally accepted evidence and hypotheses thatpolygons have scales comparable to the ubiquitous polygons Mars was glaciated and that periglacial processes had oper-on the Arctic Coastal Plain of Alaska, as observed by over- ated on Mars in the past, although he pointed out differencesflight participants, of scale between many martian features and their supposed

Although previous researchers interpreted theVikingland- terrestrial analogs.ing sites in terms of eolian modification of volcanic terrains Beg6t characterized the glacial hypothesis as "a perfectlyunder add conditions (the Mojave Desert has been cited as a reasonablehypothesisworthyoffurtherinvestigation," andhespecific analog), P6w6 remarked during the evening discus- agreed that periglacial processes have probably occurred onsion that the Viking2 landing site"looks just likeAntarctica," Mars. Beg6tstressed that the strength of these ideas was thatconsistent with J. Kargel's suggestion that the Viking 2 land- several types of putative glacial and periglacial features oning sitecould be a moraine. Particularly, the rock-size distri- Marsoccur in reasonably close spatial associations (temporalbution at the boulder-strewn landing site resembles ice-free associations of these features are still not too well docu-

Page 17: WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229 WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL, AND PALEOCLIMATIC

LP! Technical Report 93-04, Part 2 3

mented),and that these terrains look like some landscapes on landscape showsthecombined effects of glacial,glaciofluvial,Earth thathave beenshaped byglacial andperiglacial activity, and eolian processes. Participants collected ventifacts, which

Hopkins was hesitant to commit himself in favor of or wereshapedandpolishedbysandblastingcobblesatthetopofagainst the idea of glaciation on Mars, but he was more sup- this outwash depositduring a verydry and cold period shortlyportive of the idea of periglacial processes, after glaciers receded. The outwash was later capped by -I m

Regerwas favorably inclined towardmuch of the evidence of loess.that waspresented for periglacial processes, but he was more Stop 9. Overlook from the Federal Aviation Administra-reserved about glaciation. Particularly, he noted that he had tion station, milepost 262.7. Although clouds obscured whatnot beenpresented withgood evidence for glacial scour in the could have been a panoramic view of the Alaska Range, wenorthernplains, an aspect that R. Craddock also pointed out. could seeclearly the terminal moraine of the Donnelly glacia-

The discussion by the terrestrial cold-climate specialists tion (late Wisconsin, about 20,000-30,000 yr old).may be summarized as a unanimous "yes" on periglacial pro- Stop 11. Edge of Delta-age moraine and overlook ofcessesingeneral,mixed"yes"and"no"onspecificperiglacial outwash and Donnelly moraine.interpretations of specific features, mixed"yes" and"maybe" Stop 12. Polygons, ice-wedge casts, and tundra vegeta-onglaciation ingeneral, and mixed"yes" and"no" on specific tion.glacial interpretations of specific features. Thus, the collec- Stop 14. Pipelinecrossing and view of Donnelly-age mo-tive conclusionsof thecold-climate specialists were similar to raine with kettles.those of a large segment of the Mars science community; we Stop, milepost 237.5. Overlook of braided Delta River.will have to touch themartian surface andkick a few rocks, so The fiver plain has been a principal source of loess for theto speak, or at least we must obtain very-high-resolution im- Fairbanks area at least since the Delta glaciation. The far wallages and topographic data of key areas before we can expect of the Delta River valley and the adjoining uplands showto reachdefinite conclusions; in the meantime, there are many evidence for (1) the early Delta glaciation, which capped thehypotheses worthy of ongoing study, uplands and filled all nearby valleys with ice; (2) the later

The results of this discussion included some fresh perspec- Donnelly glaciation, which filled the Delta River Valley andtives on the evolution of the northern plains and on martian incised it deeper without affecting the unglaciated uplands ingeomorphology, and they offered specific directions for pos- this area; and (3) Holocene fluvial erosion of the wall of thesible future research. The discussion also provided a renewed Delta River valley. The uplands adjoining the Delta Riverinteraction between the terrestrial and Mars science commu- Valley were ice freeduring theDonnelly glaciation, and there-nities andthe promisethat this interactionwill continue. Prob- fore these uplands preserve the older, Delta-age glacial ero-ably the greatest deficiency of the evening session was that sional surface. Postglacial erosion during the Holocene ispossiblemarine and lacustrine processes and iandforms, such represented bya gully and an associated alluvial fan onthe faras advocated in recent years by Parker, D. Scott, and other bank of the Delta River.colleagues were not discussed at any length; several partici- Stop 15. Black Rapids Glacier overlook.pants felt that these subjects should be discussed at future Stop,milepost217. Dead ice (ice-cored moraine) left byameetings. Holocene advance of the Castner glacier. Field trip partici-

pants witnessed active thermokarst-forming processes here.Photos of theassembled field group and field trip leaders were

SYNOPSIS OF FIELD TRIP I TO THE ALASKA taken (Figs. 2 and 3).RANGE, AUGUST 10-11, 1993 Stop 16. Trans-Alaska Pipeline.

Stop for night, Paxson Lodge (Paxson, Alaska).Field trip I,planned and led by T. Pdwr, R. Reger, and J. Wednesday, August 11: Drove west from Paxson along

Begrt, covered part of the route along the Richardson and Denali Highway along ice-contact crevasse fill and ice-mar-Denali Highways as described in the field trip guidebook [3]. ginal drainages.The following description is keyed to those localities de- Stop, milepost7. Seven-Mile Lake. Many ice stagnationscribedintheguidebookwherewestopped. The onlydescrip- landforms related to Donnelly glaciation. Also stopped andtion beyond that in the guidebook pertains to our group's photographed a discontinuous, segmented esker in a tunnelparticular experiences, channel.

Tuesday, August 10: Drove on Richardson Highway Stop 22, milepost 20.4. Stop at Tangle Lakes along ansoutheastwardfromFairbanks, alongsideTanana River, which esker that is visible inLandsat images. Observed a sedimentreceivesmostly glacial outwash from the Alaska Range. fan that was constructed at the terminus of a small channel.

Stop I. Harding Lake. The channel was eroded by the outflow from a lake, formerlyStop 3. Tanana River overlook. 16m deep, that ruptured and spilled through an esker dam.Stop 8. Delta-age (middle to late Quaternary) terminal Stop 23. Roadcut in small esker. Group hiked across the

moraine and outwash on Jack Warren Road. This glacial crest and sides of the esker.

Page 18: WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229 WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL, AND PALEOCLIMATIC

4 Workshop on The Martian Northern Plains

Stop 24. Whistler Ridgecryoplanation terrace.Stop,milepost 32.2. Frost-sorted stonepolygons, circles,

and stripes on floors of kettles formed in a moraine of apiedmontglacier of the Denali glaciation.

Stop,milepost 32.5. Roadcut throughrock-glaciermbble.Stop, milepost 36.6. Overview of Crazy Notch and ice-

stagnationlandscapeinMaclarenRiver valley,which includeda transverse esker, kettles, alarge, flat-topped, terraced kame,and many palsas. Then we returned to Fairbanks on theRichardson Highway, making the followingstops.

Stops at two overlooks of Gulkana Glacier.Stop,near milepost 207. Rock glacier and talus slopesof

RainbowMountain.

Fig. 2. Leaders of field trip I, T. P6w6 (left of center, with MacArthur-like

stance),J. Beg6t(center), andR. Reger (right,withbaseballcap). M. SYNOPSIS OF FIELD TRIP II IN THE FAIRBANKS

Mellon,left.andN.Barlowatadistancein lowerright. Backgroundshows AREA, AUGUST 14, 1993thestagnant, thermokarsticdepositsof the ice-coredmoraineleft by arecentadvanceoftheCastnerGlacier(AlaskaRange)probablymorethan143yr ago,probablyless than200yr ago. This field trip focused on permafrost, periglacial land-

forms, frozen loess deposits, and construction that faces spe-

cial engineering problems pertaining to the periglacial envi-ronment. Some of thestops are described inmore detail by [4].

Stop 1. University of Alaska (Fairbanks campus). Discus-sion of the deposition of theWisconsin Fairbanks loess, whichis thought to include the oldest loess on Earth.

Stop 2 (described by [4], pp. 36- 43). Walk to old agricul-tural field, now forested thermokarst mounds.

Stop 3. New golf course along Farmer's Loop Road nearintersection with Ballaine Road. P(_w6predicts that in two orthree years it will be an area of evolving thermokarst.

Stop 4. Abandoned house, collapsing over thawing per-mafrost, along Farmer's Loop Road.

Stop 5. Stop near Alyeska pipeline along mining cut.Stop 6. Road cut through Fairbanks Loess.Stop 7. Big Eldorado Creek permafrost and peat bog.

Depths to ice at two locations, just 3 m apart, were 50 and70 cm. Creek forms icings 5-10 mthick during winter. Spruceare stunted ("elf spruce") due to thin active layer and harshconditions.

Stop 8. Thermokarst pits in grassy meadow.Stop 9. Thawing ice wedge beneath Trice Avenue.Stop I0. Musk ox research farm.Stop 11 (after lunch). Loess cliff, including thin (-1 cm)

"Pa tephra" layer, along Highway 3, near the Sheep CreekExtensionhighway.

Stop 12. Wiggers' gold mine. Mining operation has cutinto thick Wisconsin loess deposits that contain fossils ofreindeer, caribou, extinct bison (Bison priscus), musk oxen,

Fig.3. Fieldtriplparticipants.Backgroundisaboutthesameas shownin beaver, and mammoth. Ice-wedge ice occurs near the top ofFig,2. Fromfronttobackandleftto right,participantsareas follows:front theminecut;partofanicewedgehadtoppleddown, allowingrow:J. Kargel,V.Baker,P. Baker;secondrow:M.Wenrich,T. Parker,K. UStOexamine it closely.Tanaka,B.Schuraytz.T. Baker;thirdrow:F.West,B.Lucchitta,V. Gulick,M. Schaefer,J. Moore,J. Zimbelman,T. P6w6,J. Beg6t,M.Chapman.R.Reger;fourthrow:R.Craddock,N.Barlow,G. McGilI,C.Stoker,M.Mellon.A. Howard.

Page 19: WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229 WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL, AND PALEOCLIMATIC

LPI Technical Report 93-04, Part 2 5

OVERFLIGHT TO BARROW AND GROUND Upon turning south toward Fairbanks, we cruised at highEXCURSION NEAR BARROW, altitude because of low fuel; clouds generally obscured our

AUGUST 15, 1993 view, except for some of the highest peaks of the BrooksRange, until we reached the south side of the range; then the

• The aircraft was a 19-passenger,high-wing Casa. Wheels sky was partially clear until the aircraft landed in Fairbanks.up in Fairbanks occurred at 7:21 a.m. The sky was heavily On this part of the flight, we obtained good views ofcirques,overcast throughout the flight except for the last part of our ar_tes, kettles, and other Pleistocene glacial landforms,returnjourney. During the legtoBarrow, theaircraftgenerally cryoplanation terraces, gelifluction or solifluction sheets,stayedabovethecloudceiling, preventingaviewofthe_ound, periglacial thermokarst thaw basins, and meandering andParticipants stopped in Barrow for about four hours and en- braided streams (including the Yukon River).gaged ina brieffield excursion led by D. Hopkins. From the Overflight participants obtained abroad perspective onthegroundwe observed sea ice onthe beach, walkedover thawing physical natureof a classic periglacialterrain onEarth. Theseice-wedge polygons, examined fresh frost (thermal contrac- experiences no doubt will help shape our expectations andtion) cracks in the tundra, and photographed shallow thaw future observations of Mars.lakes and their low shoreline bluffs. References: [1] Coulter H. W. et al. (I 965) Map show-

The return flight took us east just slightly landward of the ingextentofglaciations inAlaska.h2_5OO,OOOMisc.lnv.Ser.coast almost toDeadhorse (near Prudhoe Bay), andfrom there Map 1-415. U.S. Geological Survey,Washington, D.C.south to Fairbanks. On the first leg, from Barrow to the [2] FerriansO.J.(1965)PermafrostmapofAlaska.l:2,500.O00.Deadhorse area,we flewbeneath a600' cloud ceilingand were Misc. Inv.Ser.Mapl-445. U.S.GeologicalSurvey,Washington,providedwithspectaeularviewsofperiglacial-marinecoastal D.C.[3] P6w6T.L.andRegerR. D.,eds. (1993)Richardsonbluffs,periglacial-marine riverdeltas,oriented lakes,polygo- and Glenn Highways, Alaska: Guidebook toPermafrost andnalterrain,streams inthe periglacialenvironment,and pingoes. QuaternaryGeology.Fairbanks,Alaska, StateofAlaska, Dept.Photography was hampered during this leg of the flight by of Natural Resources, Div. of Geological and Geophysicalpersistent cloud cover and the necessity of flying at low alti- Surveys. 289 pp. [4] P6w6T. L. (1982) Geologic Hazards oftude. The low altitude also made navigation difficult and theFairbanksArea, Alaska.SpecialReport 15,StateofAlaska,caused the aircraft to consume fuel more rapidly than hoped Dept.of NaturalResources, Div.of Geologicaland Geophysi-for. Nevertheless, thecollectivesetofcamerasrecordedmany cal Surveys. 109 pp.spectacular scenes.

Page 20: WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229 WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL, AND PALEOCLIMATIC
Page 21: WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229 WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL, AND PALEOCLIMATIC

LP! Technical Report 93-04, Part 2 7

List of Workshop Participants

Victor R. Baker Dave Hopkins

Department of Geosciences Department of Geology and GeophysicsUniversity of Arizona University of AlaskaTucson AZ 85721 Fairbanks AK 99775-1200Phone: 602-621-6003 Phone: 907-474-6894Fax: 602-621-2672

Alan Howard

Nadine G. Barlow Department of Environmental Sciences

Lunar and Planetary Institute University of Virginia3600 Bay Area Boulevard Charlottesville VA 22903Houston TX 77058 Phone: 804-924-0563

Phone: 713-280-9021 Fax: 804-982-2137Fax: 713-480-1279 E-maih [email protected] LPh:BARLOW

Bruce Jakosky

James E. Beg6t Laboratory for Atmospheric and Space PhysicsDepartment of Geology and Geophysics Campus Box 392

University of Alaska at Fairbanks University of ColoradoFairban_ AK 99775-1200 Boulder CO 80309-0392Phone: 907-474-5301 Phone: 303-492-8004Far: 907-474-5163 Fax: 303-492-6946

E-maih ZODIAC::JAKOSKY

Michael H. Cart

Mail Stop 946 Jeff KargelU.S. Geological Survey Astrogeology Branch345 Middlefield Road U.S. Geological SurveyMenlo Park CA 94025 2255 N. Gemini Drive

Phone: 415-329-5174 Flagstaff AZ 86001Far: 415-329-4936 Phone: 602-556-7034

E-maih [email protected] Fax: 602-556-7014

Mary G. Chapman Jurgen KienleU.S. Geological Survey Geophysical Institute2255 N. Gemini Drive University of Alaska

Flagstaff AZ 86001 Fairban "ksAK 99775-1200Phone: 602-556-7182Fax': 602-556-7014 Baerbel K. Lucchitta

U.S. Geological SurveyRobert A. Craddock 2255 North Gemini Drive

MRC 315 Flagstaff AZ 86001

Center for Earth and Planetary Studies Phone: 602-527-7176

National Air and Space Museum, Room 3775 Far: 602-556-7014Smithsonian Institution

Washington DC 20560 Leonard MartinPhone: 202-357-1457 Lowell ObservatoryFax: 202-786-2566 1400 West Mars Hill Road

E-maih [email protected] Flagstaff AZ 86001Phone: 602-774-3358

Virginia Gulick Fax: 602-774-6296Mail Stop 245-3 E-maih Ijm@lowelLeduSpace Science DivisionNASA Ames Research Center

Moffett FieM CA 94035Phone: 415-604-0781Fax: 415-604-6779

E-maih [email protected]

Page 22: WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229 WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL, AND PALEOCLIMATIC

8 Workshop on the Martian Northern Plains

George E. McGill Benjamin C. SchuraytzDepartment of Geology and Geography Lunar and Planetary InstituteUniversity ofMassachusetts 3600 Bay Area BoulevardAmherst MA 01003 Houston TX 77058Phone: 413-545-0140 Phone: 713-486-2187Fax: 413-545-1200 Fax: 713-486-2162E-mail: [email protected] E-mail: LPI::SCHURAYT"Z

Michael Mellon Carol StokerLaboratory for Atmospheric and Space Physics Mail Stop 245-3Campus Box 392 NASA Ames Research CenterUniversity of Colorado Moffett FieM CA 94035Boulder CO 80309-0392 Phone: 415-604-6490Phone: 303-492-7902 Fax: 415-604-6779Far: 303-492-6946 E-mail: stoker_A'aLarc.nasa.govE-mail: [email protected]

Kenneth TanakaJeff M. Moore U.S. Geological Survey

Mail Stop 245-3 2255 N. Gemini Dr.Space Sciences Division Flagstaff AZ 86001NASA Ames Research Center Phone: 602-527-7208Moffett Field CA 94035 Fax: 602-556-7014Phone: 415-604-5529 E-mail: ASTROG::KTANAKAFax: 415-604-6779

E-mail: GAL::JMOORE Don TriplehornGeology Department

Timothy Parker University of AlaskaJet Propulsion Laboratory Fairbanks AK 997754800 Oak Grove Drive Phone: 907-455-6723Pasadena CA 91109

Phone: 213-740-5121 Melissa Wenrich

Fax: 818-354-0966 Department of GeologyE-mail: JPLMW2::TJP342 Arizona State University

Tempe AZ 85287-1404Troy P_w_. Phone: 602-965-1790

Department of Geological Sciences Fax: 602-965-8102Arizona State University E-mail: [email protected] AZ 85287Phone: 602-965-5081 Frederick R. West

520 Diller RoadRichard Reger Hanover PA 17331-4805

3700 Airport Way Phone: 717-632-6055Fairbanks AK 99709

James R. ZimbelmanGreta Reynolds MRC 315

Geophysical Institute Center for Earth and Planetary StudiesUniversity of Alaska National Air and Space MuseumFairbanks AK 99775 Smithsonian Institution

Washington DC 20560Martha W. Schaefer Phone: 202-357-1424

Mail Code 921 Fax: 202-786-2566

NASA Goddard Space Flight Center E-mail: [email protected] MD 20771Phone: 301-286-7026Fax: 301-286-1616E-mail: [email protected]

Page 23: WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229 WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL, AND PALEOCLIMATIC
Page 24: WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: … · 2013-08-30 · NASA Technical 3 117601413 7229 WORKSHOP ON THE MARTIAN NORTHERN PLAINS: SEDIMENTOLOGICAL, PERIGLACIAL, AND PALEOCLIMATIC

NASA Technical Library

3 1176 01413 7229


Recommended