1
Writing Better Consent Forms
Rick WagnerAssociate Director
Human Research Protection Program
2
Why Consent Forms?
Ethics: Participants must give voluntary
consent for research participation To be voluntary, consent must be informed
Ethical and regulatory standards: Written information, signed consent As part of in-person discussion
3
The Ideal and the Real
An ideal consent process but really… An ideal consent form but really…
4
Goals
Understand the purpose(s) of consent forms
Consider competing priorities Increase awareness of resources
available to help write consent forms Review and practice writing
techniques for clarity and readability
5
Who Reads Consent Forms and What Are Their Concerns?
Prospective participants
Understandable language, basic information about the study, what is expected of them, financial issues, alternatives
FDA/regulators Risks, Compliance with regulations,
Sponsor/Cooperative groups
Use the template, as few changes as possible,
Clinicians/nurses/technicians
Complete information, more technical?
6
Who Reads Consent Forms and What Are Their Concerns 2?
Family Members
Study staff Contact information, appropriate signature lines
IRB members All of the above
7
8 Required Elements of Consent(45 CFR 46) (21 CFR 50)
a statement that the study involves research, an explanation of the purposes of the research and the expected duration of the subject’s participation, a description of the procedures to be followed, and identification of any procedures which are experimental;
a description of any reasonably foreseeable risks or discomforts to the subject;
a description of any benefits to the subject or to others which may reasonably be expected from the research;
a disclosure of appropriate alternative procedures or courses of treatment, if any, that might be advantageous to the subject;
8
8 Required Elements of Consent (continued)
a statement describing the extent, if any, to which confidentiality of records identifying the subject will be maintained;
for research involving more than minimal risk, an explanation as to whether any compensation and an explanation as to whether any medical treatments are available if injury occurs and, if so, what they consist of, or where further information may be obtained;
an explanation of whom to contact for answers to pertinent questions about the research and research subjects' rights, and whom to contact in the event of a research-related injury to the subject; and
a statement that participation is voluntary, refusal to participate will involve no penalty or loss of benefits to which the subject is otherwise entitled, and the subject may discontinue participation at any time without penalty or loss of benefits to which the subject is otherwise entitled.”
9
6 Additional Elementsto be added when appropriate
a statement that the particular treatment or procedures may involve risks to the subject (or to the embryo or fetus, if the subject is or may become pregnant) which are currently unforeseeable;
anticipated circumstances under which the subject’s participation may be terminated by the investigator without regard to the subject’s consent;
any additional costs to the subject that may result from participation in the research;
the consequences of a subject's decision to withdraw from the research and procedures for orderly termination of participation by the subject;
a statement that significant new findings developed during the course of the research which may relate to the subject's willingness to continue participation will be provided to the subject; and
the approximate number of subjects involved in the study.
10
What Resources Are Available for Writing Consent Forms?
CHR website Overwhelming, not study-specific, ; What CHR members expect to see
Regulations
Study protocol, sample consent forms
Not UCSF language, too technical
Other studies in your group
May not be right in the details, may be obsolete, may not be the best
11
What Resources Are Available for Writing Consent Forms? - 2
12
CHR WebsiteConsent Guidance
• Consent Guidelines • Consent Form Standards - Section by Section Discussion • Waiver of Consent vs. Signed Consent •
Informed Consent for Research Subjects Who Do Not Read, Speak, or Understand English
• Surrogate Consent • HIPAA Consent Form Guidance • Sample Consent and Assent Forms / Annotated Outlines
(Revised January 2008) •
Standard Wording for Consent Forms Used in Letters to PIs (to be revised)
13
Sample Consent and Assent Forms
• Biomedical •Biomedical - Cancer •Social or Behavioral •One-time Survey (NEW January 2008) •Simple Blood Draw •Biological Specimens •Consent to Be Contacted For Future
Research (HIPAA Compliant)
•Humanitarian Use Device (NEW September 2007)
14
Sample Consent and Assent Forms
•Assent #1 - For children 7 - 12 (Simple)
•Assent #2 - For more complex study, more mature children
•Assent #3 - For adolescents 13 – 17 •Alternative Lay Language for Medical
Terms in Consent Forms
15
More CHR Consent Guidance
•VAMC 10-1086 Consent Form•Certificates of Confidentiality •Research Using Human Biological Specimens •Guidelines for Payment of Research Subjects •Consent Form and Review Checklist (to be
revised) • Guidelines on Vulnerable Subject Populations
16
And still more CHR Consent Guidance
• Treatment and Compensation for Injury Statement Background and UCSF Policy
• Experimental Subject's Bill of Rights Amharic/Ethiopian, German, Russian, Arabic, Hebrew, Spanish, Burmese, Hmong, Tagalog, Cambodian, Japanese, Thai, Chinese, Korean, Turkish, English, Laotian, Ukranian, Farsi, Portuguese, Vietnamese, French
• Lay Language Resources for Preparing Consent Forms Alternative Lay Language for Medical Terms in Consent Forms, Glossary of Lay Terms, MedicineNet.com
• Translation Services
17
UCSF Wording Required
Treatment and Compensation for Injury “Consent” section
Bill of Rights (“you have been given…”) HIPAA (“You will be asked to sign a separate
form authorizing…”) Voluntary If you wish to participate… Person Obtaining Consent Dated signature lines
18
Principles of Good Writing For Consent Forms
Everyday vocabulary Short Sentences Direct Address (you/we) Focus on what’s most important Avoid Repetition Short Paragraphs Format for easy reading and
reference
19
Everyday Vocabulary
The purpose of this study is to determine the nature and characteristics of immune cells and tumor cells in patients treated with concomitant cisplatin-based chemotherapy regimens and high-dose radiotherapy.
We want to study people who will get both chemotherapy and radiation. We want to see what the treatment does to their tumors and their immune system.
20
Everyday Vocabulary Continued
Determine the nature and characteristics
Concomitant The following concomitant
medications are excluded: Chemotherapy regimen High-dose radiotherapy
21
More Everyday Vocabulary
Baseline visit Dose titration Efficacious Prone Chronic Instrument
22
Limits on Everyday Language
23
The Goal
A consent form that conveys essential information as clearly and briefly as possible
8th-grade reading level Think of your grandparents or great
grandparents reading the form
24
Short Sentences
It has been explained to you that you have a cancerous lesion requiring surgical removal, and that because surgery alone may fail to completely eliminate all cancerous cells, you are being asked to participate in a randomized study to compare surgery alone to surgery plus concurrent radiation treatment.
You have a tumor that needs to be cut out in an operation. We may miss some of the cancer when we try to cut it out. We want to see if we can use radiation to kill any leftover cancer. We don’t know if radiation will help, so only half of the people in the study will get radiation.
25
Direct Address/Grammatical Person
Participants will be asked to respond to a quality-of-life questionnaire at days 8, 15, 22, 29 and 35.
26
Direct Address/Grammatical Person
I understand that study participants will be required to attend clinic visits during weeks 4, 8, and 12 to return completed diaries and undergo additional blood draws to test blood lipids and enzymes.
27
Focus on What’s Most Important (Don’t Overload)
If the screening tests show you qualify for the study, the anti-cancer drug therapy on this study will be divided into the following treatment phases: Induction, Consolidation, Interim Maintenance I, Delayed Intensification I, Interim Maintenance II (for Slow Early Responder (SER) patients only), Delayed Intensification II (for SER patients only), and Maintenance.
28
Avoid unnecessary repetition
In the discussion of procedures, be sure to avoid unnecessary repetition.
In the discussion of risks, be sure to avoid unnecessary repetition.
In the discussion of benefits, be sure to avoid unnecessary repetition.
In the discussion of confidentiality, be sure to avoid unnecessary repetition.
29
Use Short Paragraphs
You have a tumor that needs to be cut out in an operation.
We may miss some of the cancer when we try to cut it out. We want to see if we can use radiation to kill any leftover cancer.
We don’t know if radiation will help, so only half of the people in the study will get radiation.
30
Practice Sentence 1
I understand that by choosing to enroll in this study participants will not be excluded from other prescribed or over-the-counter treatments for their condition, except for other non-steroidal anti-inflamatories (NSAIDs).
31
Practice Sentence 2
The purpose of this Phase IIA study is to assess whether QA101, with or without I-680-N, at different dose levels injected intramuscularly or subcutaneously, is safe and well-tolerated in patients with late Stage III pancreatic carcinoma.
32
Summary
Use Resources Start with CHR samples
Keep It Simple Everyday vocabulary Short sentences and paragraphs Use CHR recommended wording…especially
if sponsor’s or group’s wording is twice as long and twice as legalistic
Check CHR website for special consent problems and special subject groups