FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
M.A. 156/2019 IN O.A. 246/2019 (The State of Maharashtra & Ors. Vs. Shriniwas Sureshrao Kulkarni & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : A.R. CHADHA, MEMBER (A). (This matter is placed before the Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019.
ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri V.R. Bhumkar, learned Presenting
Officer for the applicants in the present misc.
application / respondents in O.A. and Shri S.B.
Solanke, learned Advocate for the respondents in the
present misc. application / applicants in O.A.
2. O.A. no. 246/2019 has been filed by the
applicants for the following interim reliefs :-
“(C) Pending the hearing and final disposal of this Original Application, the respondent no. 2 may kindly be directed to issue an orders in favour of the applicants thereby appointing them as Law Instructors with the Police Training Centre, Babhalgaon, Tal & Dist. Latur, forthwith. (D) Pending the hearing and final disposal of this Original Application, the respondent no. 2 may kindly be directed to make an arrangement to accommodate the applicants on the posts of Law Instructors with the Police Training Centre, Babhalgaon, Tal. & District Latur on clock hour basis and for that purpose issue necessary orders.”
3. The Tribunal granted interim relief as per prayer
clause (C) of the original application without going into
the merit of the matter vide order dtd. 11.3.2019.
//2// M.A. 156/2019 IN O.A. 246/2019
4. The respondents in the original applicant have
now filed Misc. Application no. 156/2019 for vacating
the interim relief granted by the Tribunal in favour of
the applicants vide order dtd. 11.3.2019.
5. In the O.A. no. 246/2019 the following
submissions were made by the applicants :-
(A) Applicant nos. 1 & 2 have worked for
eleven years from 2007 and Applicant nos. 3 & 4
have worked for four years with the respondents.
(B) The claims of the present applicants
were not considered. Except the present
Applications all other Law Instructions were
continued, the names of the applicants were not
considered and enlisted in the list of Law
Instructors published by the Respondent no. 2.
(C) The persons / candidates selected are
junior and have less experience.
(D) All the Law Officers working have
given representation that they may be given
relaxation from appearing in the interview.
(E) It is well settled law that one ad-hoc
employee cannot be replaced by another ad-hoc
employee.
//3// M.A. 156/2019 IN O.A. 246/2019
6. The brief submissions of the applicants in the
misc. application / respondents in the O.A. are as
follows :-
(A) The applicants were appointed as Law
Instructions as per the G.R. dtd. 15.9.2006 for
the period of 11 months on contractual basis,
which was renewable for another two terms.
(B) The respondents issued fresh
advertisement on 17.11.2017 in response of
which total 266 applications were received. A
total of 155 candidates appeared in the interview.
(C) The applicants appeared in the interview
but they have failed in the interview.
7. In fact the applicants have not brought out the
corrects facts before the Tribunal in Original
Application that they were not considered in the
interview.
8. In reply to the misc. application the applicants in
the O.A. have now admitted that they were considered
and deliberately given less marks so that their services
can be discontinued.
9. In reply to the misc. application the applicants in
the O.A. have submitted that there are 12 sanctioned
posts at Babhalgaon Police Training Centre, Tal. &
District Latur and out of 10 selected candidates one
//4// M.A. 156/2019 IN O.A. 246/2019
candidate has not joined. Therefore as on today there
are total of three vacant posts of Law Instructors. In
reply to misc. application the applicants in O.A.
submitted that the applicant no. 1 is at sr. no. 55 and
applicant no. 2 is at sr. no. 64.
10. In view of above discussion, the interim relief
granted by the Tribunal vide order dtd. 11.3.2019 in
O.A. is hereby vacated. The respondents are liberty
filled up three vacant posts as per merit.
11. Accordingly, the Misc. Application no. 156/2019
is hereby allowed and disposed of without any order as
to costs.
MEMBER (A)
ARJ ORAL ORDER 15.04.2019.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
O.A. No. 246/2019 (The State of Maharashtra & Ors. Vs. Shriniwas Sureshrao Kulkarni & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : A.R. CHADHA, MEMBER (A). (This matter is placed before the Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019.
ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri S.B. Solanke, learned Advocate for
the applicant and Shri V.R. Bhumkar, learned
Presenting Officer for the respondents.
2. At the request of learned Presenting Officer for
the respondents, S.O. to 17.06.2019 for filing affidavit
in reply.
MEMBER (A) ARJ ORAL ORDER 15.04.2019.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.255/2019 (Subhash Devrao Thale V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15-04-2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri P.B.Salunke learned Advocate holding
for Shri V.G.Salgare learned Advocate for the applicant
and Shri V.R.Bhumkar learned Presenting Officer for
the respondents.
2. Issue notice to the respondents, returnable on
17-06-2019.
3. Tribunal may take the case for final disposal at
once and separate notice for final disposal shall not be
issued.
4. Applicant is authorized and directed to serve on
respondent/s intimation/notice of date of hearing duly
authenticated by Registry, along with complete paper
book of the case. Respondents are put to notice that
the case would be taken up for final disposal at the
stage of admission hearing.
5. This intimation/notice is ordered under Rule 11
of the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal
(Procedure) Rules, 1988, and the questions such as
limitation and alternate remedy are kept open.
6. The service may be done by hand delivery,
speed post, courier and acknowledgment be
=2= O.A.No.255/2019
obtained and produced along with affidavit of
compliance in the Registry before due date. Applicant
is directed to file affidavit of compliance and notice.
7. If notice is not collected within 7 days or proof of
service is not produced before 3 days of the next date,
case shall automatically stand dismissed without
further reference to the Tribunal.
8. S.O. to 17-06-2019.
9. Steno copy and hamdast allowed for the use of
both the sides.
MEMBER (A) YUK ORAL ORDERS 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.849/2018 (Dr. Vinod Kakade & Ors. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15-04-2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri S.G.Chapalgaonkar learned Advocate
for the applicants and Shri D.R.Patil learned
Presenting Officer for the respondents.
2. Heard both sides at length.
3. Interim relief in terms of prayer clause (D) is
hereby granted which is as under:
"(D) Pending hearing and final disposal of Original Application, in the event if exercise of promotions is undertaken by respondents, in that contingency claim of applicants for post of District Health Officer shall be considered provisionally without prejudice to Educational Qualification in form of DPH obtained by them."
4. Result of the Departmental Promotion Committee
would be kept in a sealed cover and will be subject to
outcome of this O.A.
5. O.A. be placed for final hearing on 16-07-2019. MEMBER (A) YUK ORAL ORDERS 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.267/2019 (Kashinath Ghumare V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15-04-2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri Kakasaheb B. Jadhav learned
Advocate for the applicant and Shri D.R.Patil learned
Presenting Officer for the respondents.
2. Respondents are directed to consider the
representations of the applicant dated 26-10-2016, 22-
08-2017 and 10-11-2017 and take decision thereon
expeditiously and in any case within 3 months from
the date of this order, as per rules on merit.
3. O.A. stands disposed of without any order as to
costs.
MEMBER (A) YUK ORAL ORDERS 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.334/2019 (Goroba Aaradwad & Ors. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15-04-2019
ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri Baliram B. Shinde learned Advocate
for the applicant and Shri S.K.Shirse learned
Presenting Officer for the respondents.
2. Issue notice to the respondents, returnable on
19-06-2019.
3. Tribunal may take the case for final disposal at
once and separate notice for final disposal shall not be
issued.
4. Applicant is authorized and directed to serve on
respondent/s intimation/notice of date of hearing duly
authenticated by Registry, along with complete paper
book of the case. Respondents are put to notice that
the case would be taken up for final disposal at the
stage of admission hearing.
5. This intimation/notice is ordered under Rule 11
of the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal
(Procedure) Rules, 1988, and the questions such as
limitation and alternate remedy are kept open.
6. The service may be done by hand delivery,
speed post, courier and acknowledgment be
=2= O.A.No.334/2019
obtained and produced along with affidavit of
compliance in the Registry before due date. Applicant
is directed to file affidavit of compliance and notice.
7. If notice is not collected within 7 days or proof of
service is not produced before 3 days of the next date,
case shall automatically stand dismissed without
further reference to the Tribunal.
8. S.O. to 19-06-2019.
9. Steno copy and hamdast allowed for the use of
both the sides.
MEMBER (A) YUK ORAL ORDERS 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION ST. NO.667/2019 (Dastagir Shirure V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15-04-2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri Arun S. Shejwal learned Advocate for
the applicant and Shri V.R.Bhumkar learned
Presenting Officer for the respondents.
2. In view of the office objection, the matter to be
heard by the regular bench.
3. S.O. to 24-04-2019.
MEMBER (A) YUK ORAL ORDERS 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.754/2019 WITH CAVEAT NO.24/2019 (Prashant Kachhawa V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15-04-2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri K.G.Salunke learned Advocate for the
applicant and Shri M.P.Gude learned Presenting
Officer for the respondents.
2. At the request of learned Presenting Officer, S.O.
to 24-04-2019.
3. Parties are at liberty to circulate the case as and
when required.
MEMBER (A) YUK ORAL ORDERS 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.986/2018 (Archana Patil V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15-04-2019 ORAL ORDER :
Shri Vinod Patil learned Advocate for the
applicant is absent. Shri D.R.Patil learned Presenting
Officer for the respondents is present.
Shri H.P.Randhir learned Advocate for
respondent no.4 is absent.
2. Learned P.O. submits that during the course of
the day he will file affidavit in reply on behalf of the
respondent nos.2 and 3. He also undertakes to serve
copy of the reply on the other side.
3. He states that reply of respondent no.1 is not
necessary.
4. S.O. to 20-06-2019.
MEMBER (A) YUK ORAL ORDERS 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.36/2019 (Dr. Sulbha Mulay V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15-04-2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri P.B.Salunke learned Advocate holding
for Shri V.G.Salgare learned Advocate for the
applicant, Shri D.R.Patil learned Presenting Officer for
the respondents and Smt. Supriya Bhilegaonkar
learned Advocate holding for Shri M.B.Bharaswadkar
learned Advocate for respondent no.5.
2. Learned P.O. submits that copy of the record is
now available and he files Xerox copy of the same on
record.
3. S.O. to 29-04-2019.
MEMBER (A) YUK ORAL ORDERS 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
M.A.NO.189/2019 IN O.A.NO.966/2018 (Suman Kamble V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15-04-2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri Rajendra Lone learned Advocate for
the applicant and Smt. M.S.Patni learned Presenting
Officer for the respondents.
2. At the request of learned Advocate for the
applicant S.O. to 16-04-2019.
MEMBER (A) YUK ORAL ORDERS 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
O.A.NO.825/2016, 864/2016, 865/2016, 866/2016 & 867/2016 (Prakash Gaikwad & Ors. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15-04-2019 ORAL ORDER :
Shri Vijay B. Jogdand Patil learned Advocate for
the applicants is absent. Shri V.R.Bhumkar learned
Presenting Officer for the respondents is present.
2. Since none is present for the applicants,
S.O. to 16-04-2019.
MEMBER (A) YUK ORAL ORDERS 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 325 OF 2019 (Shri Bapusaheb B. Chavre V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A). (This matter is placed before the Single
Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019. ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri Farooqui Kamaluddin Nuruddin,
learned Advocate holding for Shri N.L. Jadhav, learned
Advocate for the applicant and Shri S.K. Shirse,
learned Presenting Officer for respondents.
2. Issue notices to the respondents, returnable on
27.06.2019.
3. Tribunal may take the case for final disposal at
once and separate notice for final disposal shall not be
issued.
4. Applicants are authorized and directed to serve
on respondent/s intimation/notice of date of hearing
duly authenticated by Registry, along with complete
paper book of the case. Respondents are put to notice
that the case would be taken up for final disposal at
the stage of admission hearing.
5. This intimation/notice is ordered under Rule 11
of the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal
(Procedure) Rules, 1988, and the questions such as
limitation and alternate remedy are kept open.
//2// O.A. No. 325/2019
6. The service may be done by hand delivery, speed
post, courier and acknowledgment be obtained
and produced along with affidavit of compliance in
the Registry before due date. Applicants are directed
to file affidavit of compliance and notice.
7. If notice is not collected within 7 days or proof of
service is not produced before 3 days of the next date,
case shall automatically stand dismissed without
further reference to the Tribunal.
8. S.O. to 27.06.2019.
9. Steno copy and hamdast allowed for the use of
both the sides.
MEMBER (A) kpb ORAL ORDER 15.04.2019 arc.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 335 OF 2019 (Shri Avinash D. Nikam V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A). (This matter is placed before the Single
Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019.
ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri V.R. Dhorde, learned Advocate for the
applicant and Smt. Priya R. Bharaswadkar, learned
Presenting Officer for respondents.
2. Issue notices to the respondents, returnable on
26.06.2019.
3. Tribunal may take the case for final disposal at
once and separate notice for final disposal shall not be
issued.
4. Applicants are authorized and directed to serve
on respondent/s intimation/notice of date of hearing
duly authenticated by Registry, along with complete
paper book of the case. Respondents are put to notice
that the case would be taken up for final disposal at
the stage of admission hearing.
5. This intimation/notice is ordered under Rule 11
of the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal
(Procedure) Rules, 1988, and the questions such as
limitation and alternate remedy are kept open.
//2// O.A. No. 335/2019
6. The service may be done by hand delivery, speed
post, courier and acknowledgment be obtained
and produced along with affidavit of compliance in
the Registry before due date. Applicants are directed
to file affidavit of compliance and notice.
7. If notice is not collected within 7 days or proof of
service is not produced before 3 days of the next date,
case shall automatically stand dismissed without
further reference to the Tribunal.
8. The respondents are directed, in the meantime, one post be kept vacant/reserved for the applicant. 9. S.O. to 26.06.2019.
10. Steno copy and hamdast allowed for the use of
both the sides.
MEMBER (A) kpb ORAL ORDER 15.04.2019 arc.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 336 OF 2019 (Shri Anil S. Navale V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A). (This matter is placed before the Single
Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019. ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri J.B. Choudhary, learned Advocate
holding for Shri A.R. Tapse, learned Advocate for the
applicant and Smt. Priya R. Bharaswadkar, learned
Presenting Officer for respondents.
2. Issue notices to the respondents, returnable on
27.06.2019.
3. Tribunal may take the case for final disposal at
once and separate notice for final disposal shall not be
issued.
4. Applicants are authorized and directed to serve
on respondent/s intimation/notice of date of hearing
duly authenticated by Registry, along with complete
paper book of the case. Respondents are put to notice
that the case would be taken up for final disposal at
the stage of admission hearing.
5. This intimation/notice is ordered under Rule 11
of the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal
(Procedure) Rules, 1988, and the questions such as
limitation and alternate remedy are kept open.
//2// O.A. No. 336/2019
6. The service may be done by hand delivery, speed
post, courier and acknowledgment be obtained
and produced along with affidavit of compliance in
the Registry before due date. Applicants are directed
to file affidavit of compliance and notice.
7. If notice is not collected within 7 days or proof of
service is not produced before 3 days of the next date,
case shall automatically stand dismissed without
further reference to the Tribunal.
8. S.O. to 27.06.2019.
9. Steno copy and hamdast allowed for the use of
both the sides.
MEMBER (A) kpb ORAL ORDER 15.04.2019 arc.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET
IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 288 OF 2019 (Dr. Ramdas S. Gutte V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A). (This matter is placed before the Single
Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019. ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri J.S. Deshmukh, learned Advocate for
the applicant and Shri S.K. Shirse, learned Presenting
Officer for respondents.
2. Issue notices to the respondents, returnable on
28.06.2019.
3. Tribunal may take the case for final disposal at
once and separate notice for final disposal shall not be
issued.
4. Applicants are authorized and directed to serve
on respondent/s intimation/notice of date of hearing
duly authenticated by Registry, along with complete
paper book of the case. Respondents are put to notice
that the case would be taken up for final disposal at
the stage of admission hearing.
5. This intimation/notice is ordered under Rule 11
of the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal
(Procedure) Rules, 1988, and the questions such as
limitation and alternate remedy are kept open.
//2// O.A. No. 288/2019
6. The service may be done by hand delivery, speed
post, courier and acknowledgment be obtained
and produced along with affidavit of compliance in
the Registry before due date. Applicants are directed
to file affidavit of compliance and notice.
7. If notice is not collected within 7 days or proof of
service is not produced before 3 days of the next date,
case shall automatically stand dismissed without
further reference to the Tribunal.
8. S.O. to 28.06.2019.
9. Steno copy and hamdast allowed for the use of
both the sides.
MEMBER (A) kpb ORAL ORDER 15.04.2019 arc.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION ST. NO. 643 OF 2019 (Dr. Kulbhushan M. Kandarkar V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A). (This matter is placed before the Single
Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019.
ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri J.S. Deshmukh, learned Advocate for
the applicant and Shri N.U. Yadav, learned Presenting
Officer for respondents.
2. Issue notices to the respondents, returnable on
28.06.2019.
3. Tribunal may take the case for final disposal at
once and separate notice for final disposal shall not be
issued.
4. Applicants are authorized and directed to serve
on respondent/s intimation/notice of date of hearing
duly authenticated by Registry, along with complete
paper book of the case. Respondents are put to notice
that the case would be taken up for final disposal at
the stage of admission hearing.
5. This intimation/notice is ordered under Rule 11
of the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal
(Procedure) Rules, 1988, and the questions such as
limitation and alternate remedy are kept open.
//2// O.A. St. 643/2019
6. The service may be done by hand delivery, speed
post, courier and acknowledgment be obtained
and produced along with affidavit of compliance in
the Registry before due date. Applicants are directed
to file affidavit of compliance and notice.
7. If notice is not collected within 7 days or proof of
service is not produced before 3 days of the next date,
case shall automatically stand dismissed without
further reference to the Tribunal.
8. S.O. to 28.06.2019.
9. Steno copy and hamdast allowed for the use of
both the sides.
MEMBER (A) kpb ORAL ORDER 15.04.2019 arc.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
M.A. No. 193/2019 IN O.A. St. No. 812/2019 (Shri Nangesh N. Unche & Ors. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) (This matter is placed before the Single
Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri D.R. Irale Patil, learned Advocate for
the applicants and Shri N.U. Yadav, learned Presenting
Officer for the respondents.
2. This is an application preferred by the applicants
seeking leave to sue jointly.
3. For the reasons stated in the application, and
since the cause and the prayers are identical and since
the applicants have prayed for same relief, and to avoid
the multiplicity, leave to sue jointly granted, subject to
payment of court fee stamps, if not paid.
4. Accompanying O.A. be registered and numbered,
after removal of office objections, if any. The present
M.A. stands disposed of accordingly without any order
as to costs.
MEMBER (A) kpb ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019 arc.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION ST. NO. 812 OF 2019 (Shri Nangesh N. Unche V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A). (This matter is placed before the Single
Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019.
ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri D.R. Irale Patil, learned Advocate for
the applicant and Shri N.U. Yadav, learned Presenting
Officer for respondents.
2. Issue notices to the respondents, returnable on
29.04.2019.
3. Tribunal may take the case for final disposal at
once and separate notice for final disposal shall not be
issued.
4. Applicants are authorized and directed to serve
on respondent/s intimation/notice of date of hearing
duly authenticated by Registry, along with complete
paper book of the case. Respondents are put to notice
that the case would be taken up for final disposal at
the stage of admission hearing.
5. This intimation/notice is ordered under Rule 11
of the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal
(Procedure) Rules, 1988, and the questions such as
limitation and alternate remedy are kept open.
//2// O.A. St. 812/2019
6. The service may be done by hand delivery, speed
post, courier and acknowledgment be obtained
and produced along with affidavit of compliance in
the Registry before due date. Applicants are directed
to file affidavit of compliance and notice.
7. If notice is not collected within 7 days or proof of
service is not produced before 3 days of the next date,
case shall automatically stand dismissed without
further reference to the Tribunal.
8. Without filing any detailed affidavit in reply, in the meantime, the respondents are directed to decide the representation of the applicants in each of the cases, copies of which are placed on record in each of the cases, and shall file the report regarding taking decision on the next date. 9. S.O. to 29.04.2019.
10. Steno copy and hamdast allowed for the use of
both the sides.
MEMBER (A) kpb ORAL ORDER 15.04.2019 arc.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 762 OF 2018 (Shri Sahebrao D. Deshmukh & Ors. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) (This matter is placed before the Single
Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Shri M.C. Swami, learned Advocate for the
applicants (Absent). Shri S.K. Shirse, learned
Presenting Officer for the respondents, present.
2. Shri Sahebrao D. Deshmukh, party in person
appeared today in the Court and submits that he
wants to change the Advocate, as the earlier learned
Advocate is prolonging the matter unnecessarily.
3. Permission granted.
4. S.O. to 06.06.2019.
MEMBER (A) kpb ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019 arc.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 304 OF 2019 (Shri Pandharinath M. Ahire V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) (This matter is placed before the Single
Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri Harish Bali, learned Advocate for the
applicant and Smt. Priya R. Bharaswadkar, learned
Presenting Officer for the respondents.
2. Learned Advocate for the applicant seeks time to
place on record a copy of the relevant G.R. regarding
the issue involved in the present O.A.
3. S.O. to 16.04.2019.
MEMBER (A) kpb ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019 arc.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 305 OF 2019 (Shri Gokul S. Ingle V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) (This matter is placed before the Single
Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri Harish Bali, learned Advocate for the
applicant and Smt. Priya R. Bharaswadkar, learned
Presenting Officer for the respondents.
2. Learned Advocate for the applicant seeks time to
place on record a copy of the relevant G.R. regarding
the issue involved in the present O.A.
3. S.O. to 16.04.2019.
MEMBER (A) kpb ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019 arc.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 28 OF 2018 (Shri Shashank B. Kamble V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) (This matter is placed before the Single
Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri G.J. Kore, learned Advocate for the
applicant and Smt. M.S. Patni, learned Presenting
Officer for the respondent Nos. 1 & 2. Shri Mahesh
Kochar, learned Advocate for respondent Nos. 3 to 5,
absent.
2. S.O. to 20.06.2019 for filing affidavit in reply of
respondent Nos. 3 to 5, as a last chance.
MEMBER (A) kpb ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019 arc.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 470 OF 2018 (Smt. Mahadabai G. Dhulekar V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) (This matter is placed before the Single
Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Shri V.D. Kadam, learned Advocate for the
applicant (Absent). Shri S.K. Shirse, learned
Presenting Officer for the respondent Nos. 1 to 3,
present. None present for respondent Nos. 4 & 5.
2. As none present for the applicant, S.O. to
21.06.2019.
MEMBER (A) kpb ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019 arc.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 872 OF 2018 (Shri Arun M. Gir V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) (This matter is placed before the Single
Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Shri A.G. Ambetkar, learned Advocate for the
applicant (Absent). Shri M.S. Mahajan, learned Chief
Presenting Officer for the respondents, present.
2. As none present for the applicant, the present
matter is removed from the board and it be kept for
hearing whenever Division Bench is available.
MEMBER (A) kpb ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019 arc.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
C.P. No. 56/2018 in O.A. No. 535/2017 (Dr. Shrinivas R. Jadhav V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) (This matter is placed before the Single
Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri Shamsunder B. Patil, learned
Advocate for the applicant and Shri V.R. Bhumkar,
learned Presenting Officer for the respondents.
2. Learned Presenting Officer has placed on record
a copy of communication dated 12.04.2019 along with
accompanying documents and submits that the
prayers made by the applicant have been satisfied.
Copy of the said communication is taken on record
and marked as document-‘X’ collectively for the
purposes of identification.
3. Learned Advocate for the applicant has
submitted that in view of the communication filed by
the learned Presenting Officer, the present matter may
be disposed of.
4. In view of the submissions made by both the
parties, C.P. No. 56/2018 stands disposed of with no
order as to costs.
MEMBER (A) kpb ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019 arc.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 230 OF 2019 (Dr. Rekha G. Gaikwad V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : A.R. CHADHA, MEMBER (A). (This matter is placed before the Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019.
ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri Shamsunder B. Patil, learned
Advocate for the applicant and Smt. Priya R.
Bharaswadkar, learned Presenting Officer for
respondent nos. 1 & 2. None appears for respondent
no. 3.
2. Learned Presenting Officer seeks time to file
affidavit in reply. Time granted. It is made clear that
learned Presenting Officer shall file affidavit in reply
within next two weeks, if possible, and serve copy
thereof upon the learned Advocate for the applicant.
3. Matter to come up for filing rejoinder, if any, and
also for hearing on 12.6.2019.
MEMBER (A)
ARJ ORAL ORDER 15.04.2019.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 299 OF 2019 (Shri Rahul T. Pol & Ors. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : A.R. CHADHA, MEMBER (A). (This matter is placed before the Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019.
ORAL ORDER : Heard Ms. Preeti Wankhade, learned Advocate for
the applicants and Shri M.P. Gude, learned Presenting
Officer for respondents.
2. At the request of learned Presenting Officer, S.O.
to 17.6.2019 for filing affidavit in reply of the
respondents.
MEMBER (A)
ARJ ORAL ORDER 15.04.2019.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 96 OF 2019 (Shri Sudhakar R. Tak V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : A.R. CHADHA, MEMBER (A). (This matter is placed before the Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019. ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri K.B. Jadhav, learned Advocate for the
applicant and Smt. Priya R. Bharaswadkar, learned
Presenting Officer for respondent nos. 1 to 4. Shri
B.G. Deshmukh, learned Advocate for respondent no.
5 (absent).
2. Learned Advocate for the applicant submits that
the respondents have closed the departmental enquiry
pending against the applicant. He also files on record
copies of communication dtd. 26.3.2019 &
14/20.3.2019 issued by the concerned respondents in
that regard and the said communications are taken on
record and marked as document ‘X’ collectively for the
purpose of identification.
3. In the circumstances, with the consent of both
the sides, the present Original Application is disposed
of as per prayer clause (B) of the O.A., which reads as
under :-
“(B) To direct the respondent no. 2 to consider the
case of the applicant for promotion on the post of
Naib Tahsildar.”
::-2-:: O.A. NO. 96 OF 2019
4. The concerned respondents are hereby directed
to consider the case of the present for promotion to the
post of Naib Tahsildar as and when vacancy arises.
5. There shall be no order as to costs.
MEMBER (A)
ARJ ORAL ORDER 15.04.2019.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 339 OF 2019 (Dr. Kishor S. Ubale V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : A.R. CHADHA, MEMBER (A). (This matter is placed before the Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019.
ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri A.S. Deshmukh, learned Advocate for
the applicant and Smt. Priya R. Bharaswadkar,
learned Presenting Officer for respondents.
2. Registrar of this order has placed office note dtd.
11.4.2019, which reads as under :-
“1. Applicant Dr. Kishor S. Ubale initially filed O.A. bearing no. 296/2018 before the principal seat of this Tribunal at Mumbai.
2. By the order dtd. 16.3.2019 in the M.A. no. 134/2019 in O.A. no. 296/2018 the principal seat has rejected the prayer of the applicant for leave to file said O.A. before the principal seat at Mumbai with a direction that papers of O.A. be returned to the applicant, if he wants to present the same at Aurangabad Bench.
3. In view of above order, the applicant presented the O.A. at this Bench on 29.3.2019 & it is numbered as O.A. No. 339/2019.
4. In view of above O.A. is being placed before the Hon’ble Tribunal for hearing on 15.4.2019.”
3. In the circumstances, issue notice to
respondents, returnable on 17.6.2019.
::-2-:: O.A. NO. 339 OF 2019
4. Tribunal may take the case for final disposal at
once and separate notice for final disposal shall not be
issued.
5. Applicant is authorized and directed to serve on
respondent/s intimation/notice of date of hearing duly
authenticated by Registry, along with complete paper
book of the case. Respondents are put to notice that
the case would be taken up for final disposal at the
stage of admission hearing.
6. This intimation/notice is ordered under Rule 11
of the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal
(Procedure) Rules, 1988, and the questions such as
limitation and alternate remedy are kept open.
7. The service may be done by hand delivery, speed
post, courier and acknowledgment be obtained
and produced along with affidavit of compliance in
the Registry before due date. Applicant is directed to
file affidavit of compliance and notice.
8. If notice is not collected within 7 days or proof of
service is not produced before 3 days of the next date,
case shall automatically stand dismissed without
further reference to the Tribunal.
9. S.O. to 17.6.2019.
10. Steno copy and Hamdast is allowed to both parties.
MEMBER (A)
ARJ ORAL ORDER 15.04.2019.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 340 OF 2019 (Dr. Kishor S. Ubale V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : A.R. CHADHA, MEMBER (A). (This matter is placed before the Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019.
ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri A.S. Deshmukh, learned Advocate for
the applicant and Smt. Priya R. Bharaswadkar,
learned Presenting Officer for respondents.
2. Registrar of this Bench has placed office note
dtd. 11.4.2019, which reads as under :-
“1. Applicant Dr. Kishor S. Ubale initially filed O.A. bearing no. 297/2018 before the principal seat of this Tribunal at Mumbai.
2. By the order dtd. 16.3.2019 in the M.A. no. 135/2019 in O.A. no. 297/2018 the principal seat has rejected the prayer of the applicant for leave to file said O.A. before the principal seat at Mumbai with a direction that papers of O.A. be returned to the applicant, if he wants to present the same at Aurangabad Bench.
3. In view of above order, the applicant presented the O.A. at this Bench on 29.3.2019 & it is numbered as O.A. No. 340/2019.
4. In view of above O.A. is being placed before the Hon’ble Tribunal for hearing on 15.4.2019.”
3. In the circumstances, issue notice to
respondents, returnable on 17.6.2019.
::-2-:: O.A. NO. 340 OF 2019
4. Tribunal may take the case for final disposal at
once and separate notice for final disposal shall not be
issued.
5. Applicant is authorized and directed to serve on
respondent/s intimation/notice of date of hearing duly
authenticated by Registry, along with complete paper
book of the case. Respondents are put to notice that
the case would be taken up for final disposal at the
stage of admission hearing.
6. This intimation/notice is ordered under Rule 11
of the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal
(Procedure) Rules, 1988, and the questions such as
limitation and alternate remedy are kept open.
7. The service may be done by hand delivery, speed
post, courier and acknowledgment be obtained
and produced along with affidavit of compliance in
the Registry before due date. Applicant is directed to
file affidavit of compliance and notice.
8. If notice is not collected within 7 days or proof of
service is not produced before 3 days of the next date,
case shall automatically stand dismissed without
further reference to the Tribunal.
9. S.O. to 17.6.2019.
10. Steno copy and Hamdast is allowed to both parties.
MEMBER (A)
ARJ ORAL ORDER 15.04.2019.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
M.A. 179/2019 IN O.A. ST. NO. 774 OF 2019 (Shantaram M. Sonwane V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : A.R. CHADHA, MEMBER (A). (This matter is placed before the Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019.
ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri S.D. Dhongde, learned Advocate for
the applicant and Smt. Deepali S. Deshpande, learned
Presenting Officer for respondents.
2. Present misc. application has been filed by the
applicant for condonation of six months delay caused
in filing accompanying O.A.
3. For the reasons stated in the present misc.
application it is allowed and disposed of without any
order as to costs and the delay of six months caused in
filing accompanying O.A. is hereby condoned.
4. Accordingly, office to register the accompanying
O.A. on due scrutiny.
MEMBER (A)
ARJ ORAL ORDER 15.04.2019.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
O.A. ST. NO. 774 OF 2019 (Shantaram M. Sonwane V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : A.R. CHADHA, MEMBER (A). (This matter is placed before the Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019.
ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri S.D. Dhongde, learned Advocate for
the applicant and Smt. Deepali S. Deshpande, learned
Presenting Officer for respondents.
2. Issue notice to respondents, returnable on
21.6.2019.
3. Tribunal may take the case for final disposal at
once and separate notice for final disposal shall not be
issued.
4. Applicant is authorized and directed to serve on
respondent/s intimation/notice of date of hearing duly
authenticated by Registry, along with complete paper
book of the case. Respondents are put to notice that
the case would be taken up for final disposal at the
stage of admission hearing.
5. This intimation/notice is ordered under Rule 11
of the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal
(Procedure) Rules, 1988, and the questions such as
limitation and alternate remedy are kept open.
::-2-:: O.A. ST. NO. 774 OF 2019
6. The service may be done by hand delivery, speed
post, courier and acknowledgment be obtained
and produced along with affidavit of compliance in
the Registry before due date. Applicant is directed to
file affidavit of compliance and notice.
7. If notice is not collected within 7 days or proof of
service is not produced before 3 days of the next date,
case shall automatically stand dismissed without
further reference to the Tribunal.
8. S.O. to 21.6.2019.
10. Steno copy and Hamdast is allowed to both
parties.
MEMBER (A)
ARJ ORAL ORDER 15.04.2019.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
M.A. 172/2019 IN O.A. 152 OF 2007 (Vijaykumar B. Rathi V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : A.R. CHADHA, MEMBER (A). (This matter is placed before the Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019.
ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri M.M. Bhokarikar, learned Advocate
for the applicant and Shri V.R. Bhumkar, learned
Presenting Officer for respondents.
2. Present misc. application has been filed by the
applicant for restoration of O.A. no. 152/2007 to its
original file, which has been dismissed in default by
the Tribunal vide order dtd. 2.4.2019.
3. For the reasons stated in the present misc.
application it is allowed and disposed of without any
order as to costs and O.A. no. 152/2007 is hereby
restored to its original file.
4. O.A. no. 152/2007 to come up for final before the
Division Bench as and when it is available, with liberty
to learned Advocate for the applicant to ask for
circulation.
MEMBER (A)
ARJ ORAL ORDER 15.04.2019.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
O.A. NO. 50 OF 2015 (Rajesndra B. Patil V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : A.R. CHADHA, MEMBER (A). (This matter is placed before the Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019.
ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri K.G. Salunke, learned Advocate for
the applicant and Smt. M.S. Patni, learned Presenting
Officer for respondents.
2. Learned P.O. submits that pursuant to the order
of the Tribunal dtd. 1.12.2018 she has received copies
of D.P.C. meetings and the same would be filed within
a period of one week and copy thereof would be
supplied to the learned Advocate for the applicant.
3. In the circumstances, S.O. to 20.6.2019 for
hearing on the above line.
MEMBER (A)
ARJ ORAL ORDER 15.04.2019.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
O.A. NO. 713 OF 2017 (Venkat D. Mundhe V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : A.R. CHADHA, MEMBER (A). (This matter is placed before the Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019.
ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri K.G. Salunke, learned Advocate for
the applicant and Smt. M.S. Patni, learned Presenting
Officer for respondents.
2. Learned P.O. submits that there is no necessity
to file additional documents in the present matter. In
the circumstances, the present case be placed for final
hearing before the Division Bench on 20.6.2019.
MEMBER (A)
ARJ ORAL ORDER 15.04.2019.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
O.A. NO. 694 OF 2013 (Bashir Khan Daulat Khan Patel V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : A.R. CHADHA, MEMBER (A). (This matter is placed before the Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019.
ORAL ORDER : Heard Smt. Vidya Taksal, learned Advocate
holding for Shri A.S. Deshmukh, learned Advocate for
the applicant and Shri B.S. Deokar, learned Presenting
Officer for respondents.
2. At the request of learned P.O., S.O. to 18.6.2019
for filing affidavit in reply of the concerned respondents
to the amended O.A.
MEMBER (A)
ARJ ORAL ORDER 15.04.2019.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
O.A. NO. 583 OF 2014 (Bhausaheb B. Gaikwad V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : A.R. CHADHA, MEMBER (A). (This matter is placed before the Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019.
ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri R.D. Khadap, learned Advocate
holding for Shri S.S. Thombre, learned Advocate for
the applicant, Smt. M.S. Patni, learned Presenting
Officer for respondent nos. 1 to 4 and Shri A.C.
Deshpande, learned Advocate for respondent nos. 5 &
6.
2. With consent of both the sides, S.O. to 21.6.2019
for final hearing before the Division Bench.
MEMBER (A)
ARJ ORAL ORDER 15.04.2019.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
M.A. 394/2018 IN O.A. NO. 577/2017 (Ramesh G. Chaudhari V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : A.R. CHADHA, MEMBER (A). (This matter is placed before the Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench.)
DATE : 15.04.2019.
ORAL ORDER : None appears for the applicant. Smt. M.S. Patni,
learned Presenting Officer for respondent nos. 1 & 2
and Shri A.S. Deshmukh, learned Advocate for
respondent no. 3, are present.
2. At the request of learned P.O., S.O. to 7.6.2019
for filing reply of res. no. 2.
MEMBER (A)
ARJ ORAL ORDER 15.04.2019.
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 517 OF 2017 (Shri Anup S. Kulkarni V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) [The present case is placed before the
Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench].
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri S.B. Bhosale, learned Advocate for
the applicant and Mrs. Deepali S. Deshpande, learned
Presenting Officer for the respondents.
2. At the request of learned Advocate for the
applicant, S.O. to 25.06.2019.
MEMBER (A) ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019-HDD
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 925 OF 2018 (Shri Kisan Dasu Pawar & Ors. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) [The present case is placed before the Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench].
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri A.C. Deshpande, learned Advocate for
the applicant and Smt. Sanjivani Deshmukh-Ghate,
learned Presenting Officer for the respondents.
2. Learned Presenting Officer has filed affidavit in
reply on behalf of respondent Nos. 1 to 3 and the same
is taken on record and the copy thereof has been
served on the learned Advocate for the applicant.
3. S.O. to 26.06.2019.
MEMBER (A) ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019-HDD
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 960 OF 2018 (Shri Sunil B. Gaikwad V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) [The present case is placed before the
Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench].
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Smt. Vidhay Taksal, learned Advocate for
the applicant and Smt. Sanjivani Deshmukh-Ghate,
learned Presenting Officer for the respondents.
2. Learned Presenting Officer has filed affidavit in
reply on behalf of respondent Nos. 1 to 4 and the same
is taken on record and the copy thereof has been
served on the learned Advocate for the applicant.
3. S.O. to 26.06.2019.
MEMBER (A) ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019-HDD
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 958 OF 2018 (Shri Ramprasad S. Lahoti V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) [The present case is placed before the
Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench].
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri H.A. Joshi, learned Advocate for the
applicant and Shri D.R. Patil, learned Presenting
Officer for the respondents.
2. Learned Presenting Officer submits that there is
no necessity for filing affidavit in reply to the amended
O.A. and submits that the present case be placed
before the Division Bench for final hearing.
3. In the circumstances, the present case is
admitted. The learned presenting Officer waives
service of notice on behalf of the respondents for
admission.
4. The present case be placed before the Division
Bench for final hearing on 13.06.2019.
MEMBER (A) ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019-HDD
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 42 OF 2019 (Shri Ramraje G. Pawar V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) [The present case is placed before the
Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench].
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri K.G. Salunke, learned Advocate for
the applicant and Mrs. Priya R. Bharaswadkar, learned
Presenting Officer for the respondent Nos. 1 & 2. None
appears for respondent No. 3 though duly served.
2. Learned Presenting Officer has filed affidavit in
reply on behalf of respondent No. 2 and the same is
taken on record and the copy thereof has been served
on the learned Advocate for the applicant.
3. In the circumstances, S.O. to 24.6.2019.
MEMBER (A) ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019-HDD
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 43 OF 2019 (Shri Sharad B. Tote V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) [The present case is placed before the
Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench].
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri K.G. Salunke, learned Advocate for
the applicant and Mrs. Deepali S. Deshpande, learned
Presenting Officer for the respondent Nos. 1 & 2. None
appears for respondent No. 3 though duly served.
2. Learned Presenting Officer has filed affidavit in
reply on behalf of respondent No. 2 and the same is
taken on record and the copy thereof has been served
on the learned Advocate for the applicant.
3. In the circumstances, S.O. to 24.6.2019.
MEMBER (A) ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019-HDD
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 179 OF 2019 (Dr. Suryakant D. Sonkhedkar V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) [The present case is placed before the
Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench].
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri J.S. Deshmukh, learned Advocate for
the applicant and Shri N.U. Yadav, learned Presenting
Officer for the respondents.
2. At the request of learned Presenting Officer, S.O.
to 27.6.2019 for filing affidavit in reply.
MEMBER (A) ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019-HDD
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 180 OF 2019 (Dr. Padmaja W/o Ajay SAraf V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) [The present case is placed before the
Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench].
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri J.S. Deshmukh, learned Advocate for
the applicant and Shri N.U. Yadav, learned Presenting
Officer for the respondents.
2. At the request of learned Presenting Officer, S.O.
to 27.6.2019 for filing affidavit in reply.
MEMBER (A) ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019-HDD
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 248 OF 2019 (Shri Vikram Bansi Mate & Anr. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) [The present case is placed before the
Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench].
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri V.G. Pingle, learned Advocate for the
applicant and Shri M.S. Mahajan, learned Chief
Presenting Officer for the respondents.
2. At the request of learned Presenting Officer, S.O.
to 21.6.2019 for filing affidavit in reply.
MEMBER (A) ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019-HDD
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 77 OF 2017 (Shri Rajesh B. Yawalkar V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) [The present case is placed before the
Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench].
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri Kalyan Patil, learned Advocate for the
applicant and Shri S.K. Shirse, learned Presenting
Officer for the respondents.
2. Learned Presenting Officer has filed affidavit in
reply on behalf of added respondent Nos. 3 & 4 and the
same is taken on record and the copy thereof has been
served on the learned Advocate for the applicant.
3. At the request of learned Advocate for the
applicant, S.O. to 27.6.2019 for filing affidavit in reply.
MEMBER (A) ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019-HDD
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 815 OF 2018 (Shri Prakash G. Gadhe V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) [The present case is placed before the
Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench].
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri N.R. Thorat, learned Advocate for the
applicant and Mrs. Deepali S. Deshpande, learned
Presenting Officer for the respondents.
2. At the request and by consent of both the parties,
the present Original Application has been taken up for
final disposal.
3. Learned Advocate for the applicant submits that
the purpose of filing of the present Original Application
of the applicant has been served. He, therefore, seeks
permission of this Tribunal to withdraw the present
Original Application.
4. Permission granted. Withdrawal is allowed.
Accordingly, the present Original Application stands
disposed of as withdrawn without any order as to
costs.
MEMBER (A) ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019-HDD
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 615 OF 2018 (Desai Timma Gaikwad V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) [The present case is placed before the
Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench].
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Smt. Rebekah Daniel, learned Advocate
holding for Shri S.B. Talekar, learned Advocate for the
applicant and Mrs. Priya R. Bharaswadkar, learned
Presenting Officer for the respondents.
2. Learned Presenting Officer has filed affidavit in
reply on behalf of respondent Nos. 1 to 4 and the same
is taken on record and the copy thereof has been
served on the learned Advocate for the applicant.
3. In the circumstances, S.O. to 24.6.2019.
MEMBER (A) ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019-HDD
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 810 OF 2017 (Shaligram M. Sonawane V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) [The present case is placed before the
Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench].
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Smt. Vidya Taksal, learned Advocate
holding for Shri S.D. Dhongde, learned Advocate for
the applicant and Smt. Sanjivani Deshmuk-Ghate,
learned Presenting Officer for the respondents.
2. At the request of learned Advocate for the
applicant, S.O. to 27.6.2019.
MEMBER (A) ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019-HDD
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 824 OF 2017 (Shri. Jeevan B. Sutar V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) [The present case is placed before the
Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench].
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri V.B. Wagh, learned Advocate for the
applicant and Smt. Sanjivani Deshmuukh-Ghate,
learned Presenting Officer for the respondents.
2. Learned Advocate for the applicant submits that
the present OA may be kept before the Division Bench
for final hearing.
3. In the circumstances, the present OA is
admitted.
4. Learned Presenting Officer waives service of
notice on behalf of the respondents for admission.
5. To be heard in due course of time. Learned
Advocate for the applicant is at liberty to circulate the
present OA as and when exigency arises.
MEMBER (A) ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019-HDD
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 474 OF 2018 (Shri Prashant P. Vaidya V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) [The present case is placed before the
Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench].
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri S.G. Kulkarni, learned Advocate
holding for Shri Ajay Deshpande, learned Advocate for
the applicant and Smt. Sanjivani Deshmukh-Ghate,
learned Presenting Officer for the respondents.
2. It transpires from the proceedings that on
05.02.2019 the learned Advocate for the applicant had
sought leave of this Tribunal to delete the respondent
Nos. 3 to 5 from the array of the present O.A. and
accordingly leave was granted for the same. However,
till today the learned Advocate for the applicant has
not taken any steps to delete the respondent Nos. 3 to
5. In the meantime, necessary steps would be
completed.
3. At the request of learned Presenting Officer, S.O.
to 19.06.2019 for filing affidavit in reply for respondent
Nos. 1 & 2.
MEMBER (A) ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019-HDD
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 792 OF 2018 (Shri Keshav R. Bankar V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) [The present case is placed before the
Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench].
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri N.V. Borse, learned Advocate holding
for Shri J.M. Wagh Patil, learned Advocate for the
applicant and Mrs. Deepali S. Deshpande, learned
Presenting Officer for the respondents.
2. At the request of learned Presenting Officer, S.O.
to 25.6.2019 for filing affidavit in reply.
MEMBER (A) ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019-HDD
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 4 OF 2019 (Shri Govind P. Gite V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) [The present case is placed before the
Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench].
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri A.S. Kulkarni, learned Advocate for
the applicant and Mrs. Priya R. Bharaswadkar, learned
Presenting Officer for the respondents.
2. At the request of learned Presenting Officer, S.O.
to 24.6.2019 for filing affidavit in reply.
MEMBER (A) ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019-HDD
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 117 OF 2019 (Shri Sainath K. Matkar V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) [The present case is placed before the
Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench].
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri Prasad D. Jarare, learned Advocate
for the applicant and Mrs. Priya R. Bharaswadkar,
learned Presenting Officer for the respondents.
2. At the request of learned Presenting Officer, S.O.
to 24.6.2019 for filing affidavit in reply.
MEMBER (A) ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019-HDD
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
M.A.NO. 69/2019 IN O.A.ST.NO. 323/2019 (Smt. Sarika B. Patole V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) [The present case is placed before the
Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench].
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri R.P. Deshmukh, learned Advocate
holding for Shri V.M. Maney, learned Advocate for the
applicant and Shri B.S. Deokar, learned Presenting
Officer for the respondents.
2. At the request of learned Presenting Officer, S.O.
to 24.6.2019 for filing affidavit in reply.
MEMBER (A) ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019-HDD
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 689 OF 2015 (Dr. Shrikant B. Tambe V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) [The present case is placed before the
Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench].
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Ms. Rebekah Daniel, learned Advocate
holding for Shri S.B. Talekar, learned Advocate for the
applicant, Mrs. Deepali S. Deshpande, learned
Presenting Officer for the respondent Nos. 1 to 4, Shri
Pradeep R. Patil, learned Advocate for respondent No. 5
and Shri V.B. Wagh, learned Advocate for respondent
No. 6.
2. At the request of learned Presenting Officer, S.O.
to 24.6.2019 for filing fresh affidavit in reply of
respondent Nos. 1 to 3.
MEMBER (A) ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019-HDD
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD M.A. 509/17 IN O.A.ST.1671/17 WITH M.A.510/17 IN O.A.ST.1672/17
WITH M.A.511/17 IN O.A.ST.1673/17 (Sambhaji S. Patil & Ors. Vs. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri S.K. Choudhari, learned Advocate
holding for Shri Nitin K. Chaudhari, learned Advocate
for the applicants in all these cases and Shri V.R.
Bhumkar, learned Presenting Officer for the
respondents in all these cases. 2. At the request of learned Advocate for the
applicants, S.O. to 19.06.2019 for hearing.
MEMBER (A) ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019-HDD
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
O.A. NOS. 445, 446, 447, 449, 450, 451, 452, 453, 454, 455, 456, 457, 458, 459, 494 OF 2017 AND O.A. NOS. 113 AND 114/2018,
M.A. 325/2017 in O.A. St. 941/2017 WITH M.A. No. 36/2019 in M.A. St. 82/2019 in O.A. St. 83/2019 & M.A.NO. 144/19 IN O.A.ST.400/19 (Marathwada Van Va Samjik Vanikaran Rojandari Va Kayam Kamgar
Karmachari Va Sarva Shramik Sanghatana & Ors. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A)
DATE : 15.04.2019
ORAL ORDER :
Heard S/Shri A.S. Shelke, S.S. Shinde & V.G.
Pingle, learned Advocates for the respective applicants
in respective cases and Shri M.S. Mahajan, learned
Chief Presenting Officer for the respondents in all these
cases.
2. At the request of learned Chief Presenting Officer
for the respondents, S.O. to 19.07.2019 for filing sur-
rejoinder.
MEMBER (A) ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019-HDD
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
C.P.NO. 77/2018 IN O.A.NO. 494/2016 (Shri Laxmikant G. Ratnaparkhi V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) [The present case is placed before the
Single Bench due to non-availability of Division Bench].
DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER :
Heard Shri S.B. Deshmukh, learned Advocate for
the applicant and Smt. Sajnivani Deshmukh-Ghate,
learned Presenting Officer for the respondents.
2. Learned Advocate for the applicant has filed
rejoinder affidavit pursuant to the order dated
13.02.2019 and the same is taken on record and the
copy thereof has been served on the other side.
3. S.O. to 19.06.2019.
MEMBER (A) ORAL ORDERS 15.04.2019-HDD
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
R.A.NO.1/2019 IN M.A.NO.329/2017 IN O.A.ST.NO.1194/2017 (Narayan D. Shete V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Smt. Vidya Taksal, learned Advocate
holding for Smt. S.A. Dhongde, learned Advocate for
the Applicant and Smt. Deepali S. Deshpande, learned
Presenting Officer for the Respondents.
2. At the request of the learned Advocate for the
Applicant, S.O. to 13.06.2019.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019 bpp
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION ST. NO.629/2019 (Anil M. Chaudhari V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri H.A. Joshi, learned Advocate for the
Applicant and Shri M.P. Gude, learned Presenting
Officer for the Respondents.
2. At the request of the learned Advocate for the
Applicant, S.O. to 22.04.2019.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION ST.NO.577/2019 (Manchak K. Gurle V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri Vijay A. Dhakne, learned Advocate for
the Applicant and Shri M.P. Gude, learned Presenting
Officer for the Respondents.
2. At the request of the learned Advocate for the
Applicant, S.O. to 24.04.2019.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.379/2017 (Shri Sanjay N. Nade V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri Arvind Jadhav, learned Advocate
holding for Shri R.O. Awasarmal, learned Advocate for
the Applicant and Smt. M.S. Patni, learned Presenting
Officer for the Respondents.
2. At the request of the learned Advocate for the
Applicant, S.O. to 13.06.2019.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019 bpp
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.213/2017 (K.M. Jadhav V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri D.T. Devane, learned Advocate for the
Applicant and Shri N.U. Yadav, learned Presenting
Officer for the Respondents.
2. At the request of the learned Advocate for the
Applicant, S.O. to 24.06.2019.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019 bpp
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.581/2017 (Smt. M.S. Kathar V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri D.T. Devane, learned Advocate for the
Applicant and Shri B.S. Deokar, learned Presenting
Officer for the Respondents.
2. At the request of the learned Advocate for the
Applicant, S.O. to 24.06.2019.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.487/2018 (Ramchandra L. Kulkarni V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri S.G. Kulkarni, learned Advocate for
the Applicant and Smt. Deepali S. Deshpande, learned
Presenting Officer for the Respondents.
2. At the request of the learned Advocate for the
Applicant, S.O. to 02.07.2019.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.579/2018 (Shri Kapil I. Sontakke & Ors. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri S.C. Swami, learned Advocate holding
for Shri V.D. Gunale, learned Advocate for the
Applicants and Shri D.R. Patil, learned Presenting
Officer for the Respondents.
2. At the request of the learned Advocate for the
Applicants, S.O. to 29.04.2019.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.711/2018 (Sanjay N. Nade V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri V.G. Pingle, learned Advocate for the
Applicant and Smt. M.S. Patni, learned Presenting
Officer for the Respondents.
2. Learned P.O. for the Respondents files affidavit-
in-reply on behalf of the Respondent Nos.1 to 3. The
same is taken on record and copy thereof has been
served on the Applicant.
3. S.O. to 24.06.2019.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.755/2018 (Abhay R. Kadam V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri D.A. Bide, learned Advocate for the
Applicant and Shri M.P. Gude, learned Presenting
Officer for the Respondents.
2. At the request of the learned Advocate for the
Applicant, S.O. to 02.05.2019.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.977/2018 (Parag M. Nawalkar V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri S.G. Kulkarni, learned Advocate
holding for Shri Ajay S. Deshpande, learned Advocate
for the Applicant, Smt. Sanjivani K. Deshmukh-Ghate,
learned Presenting Officer for the Respondent No.1
and Smt. Vidya Taksal, learned Advocate holding for
Shri Avinash S. Deshmukh, learned Advocate for the
Respondent No.2 2. Learned Advocate for the Applicant files affidavit-
in-rejoinder. The same is taken on record and copies
thereof have been served on the other sides.
3. S.O. to 30.04.2019.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.39/2019 (Urmila P. Thakur & Ors. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri R.B. Temak, learned Advocate for the
Applicants and Smt. Priya R. Bharaswadkar, learned
Presenting Officer for the Respondents.
2. At the request of the learned Advocate for the
Applicant, S.O. to 02.05.2019.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.89/2019 (Rajendra A. Jehurkar V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri S.D. Joshi, learned Advocate for the
Applicant, Shri N.U. Yadav, learned Presenting Officer
for the Respondent Nos.1 to 3 and Shri V.B. Wagh,
learned Advocate for the Respondent No.4.
2. By consent adjourned to 02.05.2019.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.99/2019 (Dr. Vinayak S. Sirsat & Ors. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri S.D. Joshi, learned Advocate for the
Applicants and Shri V.R. Bhumkar, learned Presenting
Officer for the Respondents.
2. At the request of the learned Advocate for the
Applicant, S.O. to 22.04.2019.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.105/2019 (Rupesh V. Chavan V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri D.A. Bide, learned Advocate for the
Applicant and Smt. Sanjivani K. Deshmukh-Ghate,
learned Presenting Officer for the Respondents.
2. At the request of the learned P.O. for the
Respondents, S.O. to 02.05.2019 for filing affidavit-in-
reply.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.216/2019 (Bharat P. Rathod V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri V.B. Wagh, learned Advocate for the
Applicant and Shri M.S. Mahajan, learned Chief
Presenting Officer for the Respondents.
2. At the request of the learned C.P.O. for the
Respondents, S.O. to 25.04.2019.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.234/2019 (Kailas S. Mogale V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Smt. Vidya Taksal, learned Advocate
holding for Shri Suresh D. Dhongde, learned Advocate
for the Applicant and Shri V.R. Bhumkar, learned
Presenting Officer for the Respondents.
2. Learned P.O. for the Respondents submits that
the Applicant has been reinstated in service and
therefore, nothing survives in the present O.A.
3. Learned Advocate for the Applicant also submits
that in view of the submission of the learned P.O.,
grievance of the Applicant has been redressed and
nothing survives in the present O.A. Therefore, she
seeks permission of this Tribunal to withdraw the
present Original Application.
4. Permission granted. Withdrawal is allowed.
Accordingly, Original Application is disposed of as
withdrawn without any order as to costs.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
M.A.NO.197/2018 IN O.A.945/2018 (Musaddiq Ahmed Madni V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri Prafulla D. Bodade, learned Advocate
holding for Shri J.B. Choudhary, learned Advocate for
the Applicant and Shri V.R. Bhumkar, learned
Presenting Officer for the Respondents.
2. At the request of the learned Advocate for the
Applicant, S.O. to 24.06.2019.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
M.A.NO.91/2019 IN O.A.ST.192/2019 (Ashok B. Amrutkar & Ors. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Smt. Vidya Taksal, learned Advocate
holding for Smt. Suchita A. Dhongde, learned Advocate
for the Applicant and Shri M.P. Gude, learned
Presenting Officer for the Respondents.
2. Shri Subhash S. Chillarge, learned Advocate has
filed VAKALATNAMA on behalf of the Respondent No.3.
3. Learned P.O. for the Respondents seeks time to
file affidavit-in-reply on behalf of the Respondent Nos.1
& 2.
4. Time as prayed for is granted.
5. S.O. to 27.06.2019.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
M.A.NO.132/2019 IN O.A.ST.784/2018 (Yogesh B. Amrutkar V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri S.N. Suryawanshi, learned Advocate
for the Applicant and Shri S.K. Shirse learned
Presenting Officer for the Respondents.
2. At the request of the learned Advocate for the
Applicant, S.O. to 25.04.2019.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
M.A.NO.366/2018 IN M.A.ST.NO.1591/2019 IN
O.A.ST.NO.1592/2019 (Dr. Ravindra A. Daware & Ors. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri S.G. Kulkarni, learned Advocate
holding for Shri Ajay S. Deshpande, learned Advocate
for the Applicants and Shri S.K. Shirse learned
Presenting Officer for the Respondents.
2. At the request of the learned Advocate for the
Applicants, S.O. to 22.04.2019.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.27/2019 (Raosaheb D. Patil V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri S.N. Suryawanshi, learned Advocate
for the Applicant and Shri V.R. Bhumkar, learned
Presenting Officer for the Respondents.
2. At the request of the learned Advocate for the
Applicant, S.O. to 25.04.2019.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.265/2017 (Dr. S.M. Karamunge V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri I.D. Maniyar, learned Advocate for the
Applicant, Shri M.S. Mahajan, learned Chief
Presenting Officer for the Respondent Nos.1 to 3 and
Shri D.S. Mali, learned Advocate for the Respondent
No.4.
2. At the request of the learned Advocate for the
Applicant, S.O. to 10.06.2019.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.275/2017 (Shri Mohd. Asfiouddin and Ors. V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri I.D. Maniyar, learned Advocate for the
Applicant, Smt. Deepali S. Deshpande, learned
Presenting Officer for the Respondent Nos.1 to 3 and
Shri S.E. Madne, learned Advocate for the Respondent
No.4.
2. At the request of the learned P.O. for the
Respondents, S.O. to 02.05.2019.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.424/2017 (Sheshrao R. Kharate V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Smt. Vidya Taksal, learned Advocate
holding for Shri Suresh D. Dhongde, learned Advocate
for the Applicant and Shri N.U. Yadav, learned
Presenting Officer for the Respondents.
2. At the request of the learned Advocate for the
Applicant, S.O. to 13.06.2019.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.667/2017 (Sandip K. Patil V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri S.A. Gaikwad, learned Advocate for
the Applicant and Shri D.R. Patil, learned Presenting
Officer for the Respondents.
2. Learned P.O. for the Respondents has produced
the relevant documents. The same is taken on record
and marked as ‘X’ for the purpose of the identification.
3. S.O. to 02.05.2019.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019
FARAD CONTINUATION SHEET IN THE MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.69/2018 (Ajabrao R. Patil V/s. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OFFICE ORDER TRIBUNAL’S ORDERS -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : ATUL RAJ CHADHA, MEMBER (A) DATE : 15.04.2019 ORAL ORDER : Heard Shri A.D. Sugdare, learned Advocate for
the Applicant, Shri B.S. Deokar, learned Presenting
Officer for the Respondent Nos.1 & 2 and Smt. Vidya
Taksal, learned Advocate holding for Shri Suresh D.
Dhongde, learned Advocate for the Respondent No.3.
2. At the request of the learned Advocate for the
Applicant, S.O. to 24.06.2019.
MEMBER (A) SAS ORAL ORDER 15-04-2019