When To Consider Tricuspid Valve Repair
V. Jeevanandam, M.D.
2
ACC TV in CHF 2015
The “ignored” valve
• Rarely affected in isolation
• Manifestations are extra-cardiac – Peripheral edema – Liver congestion… ascites – Renal dysfunction by decreasing transrenal gradient
• Low pressure so hard to evaluate; volume dependent
• TR associated with poor prognosis in: – Primary: endocarditis, iatrogenic, rheumatic, carcinoid, myxomatous
– Functional : left sided lesions, cardiomyopathy, pulmonary HTN
– LVADs
– Transplantation
• Does repairing the TR make a difference?
• Three leaflets – Ant > post > septal
• Three clefts – do not extend to annulus
• Annulus not a fixed structure – Anterior and posterior
attached to RV free wall – Dynamic with change in
orifice area during cardiac cycle
– Saddle shaped to decrease leaflet stress
Fibrous skeleton - closed AV valves
3
ACC TV in CHF 2015
4
ACC TV in CHF 2015
TV abnormalities – primary
- Symptomatic
- Preserved RV function:
low RVEDP
- Low PA pressures
5
ACC TV in CHF 2015
TV abnormalities – primary • Stenosis
– Rheumatic
– Carcinoid
– Appetite suppressing drugs
6
ACC TV in CHF 2015
TV abnormalities – primary
• Regurgitation
– Endocarditis • IVDA
• Hemodialysis
• Pacing leads
– Trauma
– Myxomatous
– Post-infarction
7
ACC TV in CHF 2015
TV abnormalities – primary
• Regurgitation
– Iatrogenic • Pacemakers and ICD
• Transplant biopsies
• TIPPS catheters
• In-dwelling lines
8
ACC TV in CHF 2015
3D Echo
Post Ant
9
ACC TV in CHF 2015
Postoperative 3DE
10
ACC TV in CHF 2015
DeVega
annuloplasty
and tricuspid
valve annulus
Ruptured chordae
Septal
leaflet
11
ACC TV in CHF 2015
PTFE chordal
reconstruction
*
12
ACC TV in CHF 2015
13
ACC TV in CHF 2015
14
ACC TV in CHF 2015
TV abnormalities – functional
• Annular dilation – Perimeter increase 100-120 to >150mm – Diameter >40mm – Asymmetric
• Basis of repair
• RV dysfunction – Pressure, volume overload
• Pulmonary hypertension • Left sided lesions
– Infarction – LVAD placement
• Prognosis depends on RV function
• Treatment: reduction annuloplasty – Suture DeVega – Rigid ring
2D ECHO annulus dilation
15
ACC TV in CHF 2015
3D for TC annulus dilation
16
ACC TV in CHF 2015
17
ACC TV in CHF 2015
Functional TR: TVA concomitant with MV surgery • Guidelines •
18
ACC TV in CHF 2015
TVA concomitant with MV Surgery
• Why? Raja, Dreyfus. Basis for Intervention on Functional TR. Semin Thoracic Surg 22:79-83
• TR does not improve after MV procedure – especially if annulus dilated >4cm
• Actually worsens
• Survival benefit not proven
19
ACC TV in CHF 2015
Functional TR: TVA reoperation after MV Surgery
• Kim, Kwon, Kim, et al. Determinants of surgical outcome in patients with isolated TR. Circulation 2009; 120:1672-8
• 61 patients with TR after left sided procedure
• Favors – Concomitant procedure
– Earlier TVA before cardiac deterioration – marker for worsening RV
NYHA class % patients Event free 1 yr Event free 2 yr
II 34 95 90
III, IV 66 73 68
20
ACC TV in CHF 2015
TR repair: Concomitant with cfLVAD
• Saeed, Kidambi, Shalli, McGee, et al. TV repair with LVAD: is it warranted? JHLT 2011;30:530
– 72 LVADs, 42 > 3+ TR, 8 repaired / 34 no repair
– No benefit from TVR
– TVR : longer CPB, more blood, higher BUN / crt.
– Small study, selection bias
• Maltais, Topilsky, Park, et al. Surgical treatment of TR promotes early reverse remodeling in patients with cfLVAD. JTCVS 2012;143:1370
– 83 HMII, 37 severe TR (32 repair, 5 replacement)
– TR group worse – more TR vena contracta, more RV dysfunction (RVEDA), higher RA pressure, higher Kormos score, more IABP
– 30 days in TVR group – TR better than in LVAD only group (-50.2% vs 18.6% ); more RVEDA reduction
– Survival and RVF similar although TR group sicker
21
ACC TV in CHF 2015
TR repair: Concomitant with cfLVAD • Piacentino, Rogers, Milano, et al. Utility of concomitant TV procedures
for patients undergoing cfLVADs. JTCVS 2012;144:1217-21
– 200 consecutive LVADs; 61 significant TR (3 or 4+); 33 cfLVAD + TVP with 28 just receiving cfLVAD
• Summary: for cfLVAD, repairing TV improves RV function an decreases TR but without statistically significant survival benefit
22
ACC TV in CHF 2015
Prophylactic TVA with heart transplantation
• Significant TR after HT reported from 10-60%.
– Depends on bicaval/total vs biatrial; RV function; pulmonary hypertension
– TR associated with worse survival
• Jeevanandam, et al. Prophylactic TV DeVega Annuloplasty during heart transplantation. Ann Thor Surg 2004 78(3):759-66 – Randomized controlled trial – bOHT vs. bOHT + TVA; 30 patients in each arm
– Donor and recipient demographics similar
– Followed out to 6 years
23
ACC TV in CHF 2015
Results: severity of TR Group Avg. ≤ 1 2 ≥ 3 % > 2
Intra-operative A 1.1 ± 1.0 21 5 4 30.0%B .33 ± .38 30 0 0 0.0%
p=0.01 p=0.01
1 Week A 0.6 ± 0.9 24 2 1 11.1%B 0.4 ± 0.6 28 2 0 6.7%
ns ns
1 Month A 1.0 ± 0.9 20 4 2 23.1%B 0.3 ± 0.7 28 1 1 6.7%
p=0.006 p=0.05
1 Year A 1.3 ± 1.0 17 7 2 34.6%B 0.2 ± 0.3 27 0 0 0.0%
p=0.01 p=0.02
6 Years A 1.5 ± 1.3 14 2 6 36.4%B 0.5 ± 0.4 22 0 0 0.0%
p=0.01 p=0.02Mann Whitney U test
24
ACC TV in CHF 2015
Is there a correlation between >2+ TR and death?
Survival Functions
MO_ALIVE
120100806040200-20
Cu
m S
urv
iva
l
1.1
1.0
.9
.8
.7
.6
.5
.4
TR2
1.00
1.00-censored
.00
.00-censored
Yes: log rank p=0.005
25
ACC TV in CHF 2015
Results: renal function Group BUN Crt dCrt
Pre-operative A 22.3 ± 11.5 1.02 ± .3B 26.8 ± 15.6 1.34 ± .7
ns p=0.058
1 Week A 45.6 ± 28.9 1.21 ± .6 .2 ± .6B 40.2 ± 29.6 1.5 ± 1.3 .2 ± 1.5
ns ns ns
1 Month A 33.6 ± 12.4 1.2 ± .6 .2 ± .7B 33.2 ± 12 1.3 ± .5 0 ± .8
ns ns ns
1 Year A 42.5 ± 16.5 2.3 ± 1.3 1.3 ± .9B 37.7 ± 15 2.2 ± 1 1.1 ± .9
ns ns p=0.061
6 Years A 41.0 ± 14.4 2.9 ± 2.0 2.0 ± 2.0B 32.3 ± 12.1 1.8 ± 0.7 0.7 ± .8
ns p=0.04 p=0.02
26
ACC TV in CHF 2015
Is there a correlation between TR >2+ and creatinine >2.5?
AVG_TR
543210-1
CR
EA
T10
8
6
4
2
0
DEVEGA
1.00
.00
Yes: Fisher exact p=0.002
27
ACC TV in CHF 2015
Summary
• Increased appreciation of tricuspid valve – Regurgitation and chronic high CVP associated with decreased
survival – Renal / hepatic dysfunction, edema, ascites
• Repair technique: – rigid annuloplasty most durable – Suture reasonable for prophylactic or normal PA pressures
• Primary TV repair indicated if severe and symptomatic (Class IIa, evidence C)
• Functional TR (>3+) or annulus greater than 4cm – With MV surgery (class I, evidence B) – Isolated, after MV surgery, no PulmHTN (ESC – class IIaC). NYHA 3, 4
poor 2 year event free survival – cfLVAD: decrease RV failure, better RV remodeling, no survival benefit
• TVA with HT – survival and renal benefit.
ACC TV in CHF 2015
28
29
30
ACC TV in CHF 2015
Papillary Muscle and Chordae
• Marginal chords attached to free margin – Prevent regurgitation
• Basal chords attached to body – Maintain structure of RV
• Ant, post papillary muscle and septal band
ECHO - Normal tricuspid function
31
ACC TV in CHF 2015
32
ACC TV in CHF 2015
Surgeons view