of 26
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
1/26
FINS3616
Week 9
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
2/26
Russia suffered a currency and stock crisis in 1998 that drove the dollar
value of Russian stocks down to 10% of their pre-crash value. The crash
caught investors by surprise, including hedge fund managers
specializing in emerging markets. One hedge fund manager was
quoted as saying:
If Russia had taken over a plant belonging to General Motors, the
government would have done something about it Essentially, the
Russian government has confiscated Western capital, and nobody is
doing anything about it
Is the risk of a market crash in an emerging economy a political risk or
a financial risk? Explain.
2FINS3616 Peter Kjeld Andersen
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
3/26
There is not always a clear distinction between political and
financial risks. Indeed, financial risks often result from political
decisions. In Russias case, the financial risks of investment in Russian have
been acerbated by the inability of the Russian government to
es a s an en orce aws an regu a ons or e or er y con uc
of business.
,
economic, financial country risk ratings in Russia.
,
manager clearly holds the Russian government responsible for his
losses.
3FINS3616 Peter Kjeld Andersen
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
4/26
Suppose the systematic risk of a domestic investment is:
i = iW (i /W), where iW = 0.4 is the correlation between
domestic asset returns and world market returns, = 0.2 is the
standard deviation of domestic asset returns, and W = 0.1 is the
standard deviation of the world market return.
A comparable foreign asset has fiW = 0.3 and fi = 0.3.
the domestic asset?
4FINS3616 Peter Kjeld Andersen
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
5/26
a) Is the total risk of the foreign asset more or less than that of
the domestic asset?
More. Total risk is measured b standard deviation, and the
foreign asset has the higher standard deviation.
b) What about the systematic risk?
i = iW i W = . . . = .
i
domestic = iW
(i/
W) = (0.4)(0.2/0.1) = 0.8.
Therefore, the foreign asset also has the higher systematic
risk.
5FINS3616 Peter Kjeld Andersen
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
6/26
You work for an Israeli company that is considering an
investment in China. The investment yields after-tax Chinese
Yuan cash flows (in millions) as follows:
OUTLAY YEAR 1 YEAR 2 YEAR 3
-CNY 600 CNY 200 CNY 500 CNY 300
The required return for this risk class is iILS = 15% in Israel new
. .
Expected inflation is 6% in shekels and 3% in Yuan. Risk-free
. .
Bank bonds are risky and yield 6.09% in Yuan.
e spo exc ange ra e s 0 = . .
6FINS3616 Peter Kjeld Andersen
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
7/26
Assume the international parity conditions hold. Calculate the
present value of the investment by using the Chinese discount
rate and then converting into Shekels at the current spot rate.
( ) ( ) ( )
CNY
0 1 2 3
200 500 300600
1 0.11745 1 0.11745 1 0.11745V = + + +
+ + +
CNY194.39m=
ILS CNY CNY ILS/CNY
0 0 0|V i V S =
. . .
7FINS3616 Peter Kjeld Andersen
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
8/26
Q. Assume the international parity conditions hold. Convert
the cash flows at expected future spot rates, and then find
the present value using the Israeli discount rate.
A. First, calculate the expected future spot rates
/1 0
1[ ]1
LS
ILS CNY
CNYE S S
+= = +
( )10.5526 1.06 1.03 ILS 0.5687/CNY=
( )2
2[ ] 0.5526 1.06 1.03 ILS 0.5853/CNYE S = =
30.5526 1.06 1.03 ILS 0.6023/CNYE S = =
8FINS3616 Peter Kjeld Andersen
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
9/26
Once we have the expected spot rates, we find the expected ILS
value of the cash flows.
= = = =
CFs in CNY CNY 600 +CNY 200 +CNY 500 +CNY 300
St / E[St] ILS 0.5526/CNY ILS 0.5687/CNY ILS 0.5853/CNY ILS 0.6023/CNY
CFs in ILS ILS 331.56 +ILS 113.74 +ILS 292.63 +ILS 180.69
ILS
0 1 2 3
113.74 292.63 180.69
331.56V = + + +
. . .
ILS 107.42 million=
9FINS3616 Peter Kjeld Andersen
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
10/26
You currently live in the Land-of-Leisure (currency is the L), and you are
considering investment in a shop in a foreign country called Land-of-Work
(currency is W). Financial markets are perfect and the international parity
. .
the following information.
LEISURE WORK
Nominal Risk Free 0% 50%
Real Required Return on Risk Free 0% 0%
Expected inflation 0% 50%
The spot exchange rate is W100/L.
10FINS3616 Peter Kjeld Andersen
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
11/26
Nominal Risk Free 0% 50%
Real Re uired Return on Risk Free 0% 0%
Expected inflation 0% 50%
Real Required Return on Shops 10% 10%
a) What is the nominal required return on print-shop projects in L. And in
W?nom real = + +
This is the Fisher equation.
( ) ( )L L Lnom reali 1 i 1 1= + + ( ) ( )1 0.10 1 0.00 1= + + 0.10 or 10%=
11FINS3616 Peter Kjeld Andersennom real
i 1 i 1 1= + + 1 0.10 1 0.50 1= + + 0.65 or 65%=
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
12/26
Nominal Risk Free 0% 50%
Real Re uired Return on Risk Free 0% 0%
Expected inflation 0% 50%
Real Required Return on Shops 10% 10%
b) Identify the expected future spot rates for the next two years.t
WW/L W/L
t 0 LE S S
1 =
+
W150/L=
1W/L
11.50E S W100/L W150/L
1.00 = =
12FINS3616 Peter Kjeld Andersen
W/L
2
1.50E S W100/L W225/L1.00
= =
W225/L=
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
13/26
c) We have the following information about the project:
It will last two years
The land for the shop costs W200,000 and will maintain its realvalue, before being
.
Building the shop will cost another W200,000, which will be straight-line
depreciated over two years to a salvage value of zero. The shop will have zero
market value at the end of two years.
No investment in working capital is necessary.
. ,
per year.
Variable costs are 20% of sales. Fixed costs are W45,000 in the first year and growwith inflation.
Income and capital gains taxes in both countries are 50%.
.
13FINS3616 Peter Kjeld Andersen
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
14/26
Identify the expected future cash flows in W on the investment
project. Discount them using the W discount rate and convert
them back at the spot rate.
Investment cash flows (initial outlays)
Terminal cash flows
14FINS3616 Peter Kjeld Andersen
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
15/26
OCF Calculation: YEAR 1
600,000
YEAR 2
900,000Revenue
120,000
45,000
180,000
67,500
Less: Variable Costs
Less: Fixed Costs
100,000
335,000
100,000
552,000
Less: Depreciation
= EBIT
,
167,500
100,000
,
276,250
100,000
= NOPAT
Add Back: Depreciation
W267,500 W376,250= Operating Cash Flows
15FINS3616 Peter Kjeld Andersen
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
16/26
Investment Cash Flows (Land) 200,000
Investment Cash Flows (Plant) 200,000
Operating Cash Flows 267,500 376,250
Terminal Cash Flows (Land) 450,000
Terminal Cash Flows (Tax on Land) 125,000
Net Cash Flow in W -W400,000 W267,500 W701,250
( ) ( )
W W
0 1 2
, ,V | i W400,000
1 0.65 1 0.65= + +
+ +
,=
L W W19,697= =
16FINS3616 Peter Kjeld Andersen
W/L
0S
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
17/26
Investment Cash Flows (Land) 200,000
Investment Cash Flows (Plant) 200,000
Operating Cash Flows 267,500 376,250
Terminal Cash Flows (Land) 450,000
Terminal Cash Flows (Tax on Land) 125,000
Net Cash Flow in W -W400,000 W267,500 W701,250
( ) ( )
L L
0 1 2
, . , .V | i L4,000
1 0.10 1 0.10= + +
+ +
=L197
17FINS3616 Peter Kjeld Andersen
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
18/26
CHAPTER 14 PROBLEM 6
Q. Consider the investment in China from problem 14.1.
Suppose each cash flow generated by the project must be
loaned to the China Construction Bank for one year at a zeropercent interest rate?
At what uan rate should ou discount these blocked funds?
What is the present value of the blocked funds in yuan?
18FINS3616 Peter Kjeld Andersen
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
19/26
CHAPTER 14 PROBLEM 6
A. The funds are invested with the China Construction Bank, so the
appropr a e oppor un y cos o cap a s e r s y an ra e o .
percent.
flows (in particular, the initial investment) from the analysis. Following the
threeste rocedure from the text:
a) The present value of blocked funds assuming they are not blocked is:
CNY200m CNY500m CNY300m
( ) ( ) ( )0 1 2 3
1 0.0609 1 0.0609 1 0.0609= =
+ + +
.
value of blocked funds is really only:
CNY200m CNY500m CNY300m
19FINS3616 Peter Kjeld Andersen( ) ( ) ( )
0 2 3 4
1 0.0609 1 0.0609 1 0.0609+ + +
.
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
20/26
CHAPTER 14 PROBLEM 6
c) The opportunity cost of the blocked funds is the difference between
pro ec va ue w an w ou e oc e un s:
SIDE EFFECT PROJECT WITH SIDE EFFECT PROJECT WITHOUT SIDE EFFECTV V V=
CNY 833.26m CNY 844.01m=
CNY 50.75m=
20FINS3616 Peter Kjeld Andersen
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
21/26
CHAPTER 14 PROBLEM 7
Q. Consider the investment in China from problem 14.1. China
Construction Bank is willing to provide you with a non-
amortizing loan of CNY 600m at their borrowing rate of6.09% per annum payable over 3 years.
If ou were to finance the ro ect locall in China our
borrowing rate would be 8.15% per annum.
effective tax rate is 40% in both China and Israel.
21FINS3616 Peter Kjeld Andersen
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
22/26
CHAPTER 14 PROBLEM 7
A. There are several steps:
I. Work out how much cash interest expense you save per annum by
financing through the subsidy rather than through your actual
(CNY600m)(0.08150.0609)(10.4) = CNY7.416 million.
. .
The after-tax market cost of debt is (8.15%)(10.4) = 4.89% in yuan.
. e presen va ue o a ree-year annu y o . m on
discounted at the after-tax yuan discount rate of 4.89% is:
( ) n
0
1 1 rPV CF
+= =
( ) 3
1 1 0.04897.416
+= CNY 20, 237,306
22FINS3616 Peter Kjeld Andersen
.
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
23/26
CHAPTER 14 PROBLEM 8
Q. Consider AGAIN (omg!!!) the investment in China from
problem 14.1. The Chinese government insists that you build
an airport near this project at a cost of CNY 100million.Should you still accept the project?
A. V0CNY = CNY 194.39 million without the side effect.
The air ort ro ect reduces this value b CNY100 million but the NPV with
the side effect is still positive (CNY 94.39 million).
You should accept the project even if the Chinese authorities are notwilling to renegotiate.
23FINS3616 Peter Kjeld Andersen
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
24/26
CHAPTER 14 PROBLEM 9
Q. Consider the investment in China from problem 14.1.
Suppose that in any given year there is a 10 % chance that
the Chinese government will expropriate your assets.
If your assets are expropriated in a particular year, then you
will not receive that ears or an later ears cash flow from
your investment. This risk is diversifiable and hence does not
What is the NPV of this asset in shekels, assuming the
n erna ona par y con ons o an e requ re re urns
are iILS = 15% and ICNY = 11.745% are the after-tax discount
rates.
24FINS3616 Peter Kjeld Andersen
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
25/26
CHAPTER 14 PROBLEM 9
A. The expropriation risk in Problem 14.9 differs from that in the
chapters Neverland project because there is a probability of
expropriation in each year, rather than just at the end of theproject.
Once ex ro riated ou will not receive an later cash flows
from your investment. This can be represented with a decision
25FINS3616 Peter Kjeld Andersen
5/20/2018 (2011-S2) - FINS3616 - Tutorial Slides - Week 09
26/26
CHAPTER 14 PROBLEM 9
A.
( ) ( ) ( )
CNY
0 1 2 3
200 0.9 500 0.9 300 0.9V 600
1 0.11745 1 0.11745 1 0.11745
= + + +
+ + +
CNY
0V 42.15m=
( ) ( )ILS CNY0V | i CNY 42.15m ILS 0.5526 / CNY= = ILS 23.29m
SIDE EFFECT PROJECT WITH SIDE EFFECT PROJECT WITHOUT SIDE EFFECTV V V=
= . .
CNY 152.24m=
26FINS3616 Peter Kjeld Andersen