Capital in Chaos: The Subprime Mortgage Crisis and the Social Capital Response

8/14/2019 Capital in Chaos: The Subprime Mortgage Crisis and the Social Capital Response

1/48Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1124961

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%&'()!

"#$!

%&'()&*!(+!%,&-./!),0!.12'3(40!4-3)5&50!%3(.(.!&+6!),0!.-%(&*!%&'()&*!30.'-+.0!

3&74-+6!,8!230.%(&!!!!!!

! (8! *&9.:!+-34.!-;!)31.)!&+6!.-%(&*!%&'()&* 888888888888888888"#

! ((8! ),0!.12'3(40!4-3)5&50!%3(.(. 88888888888888888888888888888888888888 "="!! "#! $%&'%(&)!*+!,-&!./01'(2&!3*',454&!35'6&,!578!!! ! 9,:!9215;,!*7!!! B#! ?-&!$!

! ! "8! .INIBF?M!EOI!2ABBAPIBQ*I?JIB!3IKDEFA?GOFR88888888 ">"!! ! V!! ! T8! 1?JIBLDRFEDKFWIJ!*I?JIBG8888888888888888888888888888888888888 ">=!! ! V8! *FCFEG!A?!;ABXIDBD?LI888888888888888888888888888888888888888888">=!

! (((8! .-%(&*!%&'()&*!)-!),0!30.%10/!30Q(+;1.(+5!),0!! ! 4-3)5&50!'3-%0..!9(),!)31.):!41)1&*!! ! (+)0360'0+60+%0!&+6!(+)03+&*(Y06!3(.Z8888888888888888888888


2/48Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1124961

"#"! (%&':(,F! 578!


3/48

"[[=j!

(8!!*&9.:!+-34.!-;!)31.)!&+6!.-%(&*!%&'()&*!

(E!FG!?AP!PIKK!BILAM?FWIJ!EODE!EOI!?ABCG!D?J!?IEPABSG!EODE!JINIKAR!DG!D!BIGaKE!A@!F?EIBDLEFA?G! PFEOF?! LFNFK! GALFIEHgF8I8:! EODE! GROIBI! A@! OaCD?! F?EIBDLEFA?! EODE! FG!GIRDBDEI! @BAC! EOI! GEDEIgLD?! ODNI! D! JFGEF?LE! NDKaI! @AB! LBIDEF?M! EBaGE! D?J!EBaGEPABEOF?IGG8! ! ;AB! EOI! RaBRAGIG!A@! EOFG! &BEFLKI:! (! PFKK! cAF?! AEOIBG! F?!JIGLBFXF?M!EOIGI!?ABCG!D?J!?IEPABSG:!LAKKILEFNIKH:!DG!hGALFDK!LDRFEDK8i!!6BFNI?!XH!?ABCG!A@!EBaGE:!GODBIJ! F?EIBIGEG! D?J! MI?IBDKFWIJ! BILFRBALFEH:! GALFDK! LDRFEDK! RKDHG! D! LBFEFLDK! BAKI! F?!I?GaBF?M! EODE!?IFMOXABOAAJG:!CDBSIEG:! LACCa?FEFIG! D?J! ?DEFA?G! @a?LEFA?!PIKK!D?J!I@@FLFI?EKH8"!

)OI! BIKDEFNI! RBIGI?LI! AB! GEBI?MEO! A@! GALFDK! LDRFEDK! LD?! CID?! EOI! JF@@IBI?LI!XIEPII?!D!PIKKQ@a?LEFA?F?M!GALFIEH!D?J!A?I!EODE!FG!BFJJKIJ!XH!LABBaREFA?:!LBFCI:!KAP!KINIKG! A@! LFNFL! RDBEFLFRDEFA?! D?J! OFMO! KINIKG! A@! CFGEBaGE! A@! ?IFMOXABG:! LFNFL!F?GEFEaEFA?G:!D?J!IKILEIJ!A@@FLFDKG8!!3IGIDBLO!GOAPG!EODE!F?!LACCa?FEFIG!POIBI!GALFDK!LDRFEDK!FG!OFMO:!EOI!BIGFJI?EG!A@!EOAGI!LACCa?FEFIG!DBI!OIDKEOFIB:!PIDKEOFIB:!ODRRFIB:!

D?J! @IIK! GEBA?MIB!XA?JG! EA! EOIFB! ?IFMOXABG! F?! RDBEFLaKDB! D?J! EOIFB! LACCa?FEFIG! F?!MI?IBDK8

;AB!EOI!RaBRAGIG!A@!EOFG!&BEFLKI:!(!PFKK!XABBAP!EOI!JI@F?FEFA?!DBEFLaKDEIJ!IDBKFIB:!D?J!PFKK! aGI!EOI! EIBC!GALFDK!LDRFEDK! EA! BI@IB! EA!hGALFDK!?IEPABSG!D?J! EOI!DGGALFDEIJ!?ABCG! A@! BILFRBALFEH! D?J! EBaGEPABEOF?IGG8iU! ! .aLO! ?IEPABSG! D?J! ?ABCG! OIKR! EA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

".&&L! #L! 3-203)! 68! '1)+&4:! 2-9*(+5! &*-+0/! ),0! %-**&'.0! &+6! 30\(\&*! -;!&403(%&+! %-441+()7! $>! _"[[[ ]! 3-203)! %8! .-*-4-+! k! ;03+&+6-! ;*-30.:! 21(*6(+5!)31.)/!(+!21.(+0..:!'-*()(%.:!30*&)(-+.,('.:!&+6!*(;0!"[!_"[[$`8!!!

>`!_hd.jALFDK!LDRFEDK!FG!JI@F?IJ!DG! EOI! ?ABCG! D?J!GALFDK! BIKDEFA?G! ICXIJJIJ! F?! EOI!GALFDK! GEBaLEaBIG!A@! GALFIEH! EODE!I?DXKI!


4/48

"#U! >T`]!^DGA?! 4DWWA?I:! ?*)5'8:! "! .*;(5E! =`8!!!

#'aE?DC:!:/1'5!?AEI!V:!DE!"[8!!.&&!5E:*!6I?FGI!48!3AaGGIDa!IE!DK8:!G*,!.*!>(++&'&7,!"+,&'!"EEC! "!


5/48

"[[=j! 8!! &G!A?I!IDBKH!RBARA?I?E!A@!EOI!LA?LIRE!A@!GALFDK!LDRFEDK!DGGIBEG/! h1?KFSI! AEOIB! @ABCG! A@! LDRFEDK:! GALFDK! LDRFEDK! F?OIBIG! F?! EOI! GEBaLEaBI! A@! BIKDEFA?G!XIEPII?! DLEABG! D?J! DCA?M! DLEABG8! ! (E! FG! ?AE! KAJMIJ! IFEOIB! F?! EOI! DLEABG! EOICGIKNIG! AB! F?!ROHGFLDK!FCRKICI?EG!A@!RBAJaLEFA?8i!!%AKICD?:!:/1'5!?AEI!T:!DE!.>=8!

$$'1)+&4:!:/1'5!?AEI!":!DE!""8!!'aE?DC!MAIG!A?!EA!IbRKDF?!EODE!XA?JF?M!GALFDK!LDRFEDK!FG!hF?PDBJ!KAASF?M!D?J!EI?JdGj!EA!BIF?@ABLI!IbLKaGFNI!FJI?EFEFIG!D?J!OACAMI?IAaG!MBAaRG8i!! 988!DE!""8!! 2BFJMF?M! GALFDK!LDRFEDK! EI?JG!EA! XI!hAaEPDBJ!KAASF?M!D?J!I?LACRDGGdIGj! RIARKI!DLBAGG!JFNIBGI! GALFDK! LKIDNDMIG8i! !988! ! h6I?GI! ?IEPABSG! F?! IEO?FL! I?LKDNIG:! @AB! IbDCRKI:! RBANFJI!LBaLFDK!GALFDK!D?J!RGHLOAKAMFLDK!GaRRABE!@AB!KIGG!@ABEa?DEI!CICXIBG!A@!EOI!LACCa?FEH:!POFKI!@aB?FGOF?M! GEDBEQaR! @F?D?LF?M:!CDBSIEG:! D?J! BIKFDXKI! KDXAB! @AB! KALDK! I?EBIRBI?IaBG8! ! 2BFJMF?M!?IEPABSG:!XH!LA?EBDGE:!DBI!XIEEIB!@AB!KF?SDMIG!EA!IbEIB?DK!DGGIEG!D?J!@AB!F?@ABCDEFA?!JF@@aGFA?8i!!988! ! .&&!5E:*! %OBFGEFDD?!5BAAEDIBE! k!)OFIBBH! ND?!2DGEIKDIB:!P78&':,578(74!578! 3&5:/'(74!.*;(5E!


6/48

"#V! !,-1.8!'-*l7!602&)0!$##:!$#=!_$>>=`!_LFEDEFA?G!ACFEEIJ`8!! .&&!5E:*!9AAKLALS:! GaRBD!?AEI! >=`8!!!

$U.&&L!0:!'aE?DC:!:/1'5!?AEI!":!DE!


7/48

"[[=j!

$V)OFIBBH!ND?!2DGEIKDIB:!921&'+&;,!97+*'25,(*7L!.*;(5E!


8/48

"#=! >V`!_DGGIGGF?M!FCRDLE!A@!KDP!A?!JINIKARCI?E!A@!GALFDK!?ABCG`]!;BD?S!28!%BAGG:! D5)!578!?'/:,:!>

50-8! *8^8! $UT#! _"[[T`!_DGGIGGF?M! KIMDK!GHGEIClG!DXFKFEH!EA! @AGEIB!EBaGE! D?J! F?LBIDGI!RAGFEFNI!GALFDK! LDRFEDK ]! ^DGA?!4DWWA?I:!J-&7!!.73&%1.0!*8!30\8!$[:!$[U$!_$>>>`!_h&?!IbRBIGGFNI!@a?LEFA?!CDH:!F?!@DLE:!XI!EOI! CAGE! GFM?F@FLD?E! A?I! EODE! LAaBEG! RIB@ABCo ]! 3FLODBJ! ,8! 4L&JDCG:! ?-&! $'(4(7L!>&%&E*12&7,! 578!N&4/E5,(*7!*+!G*'2::!>V!4(%,8! *8! 30\8! # ! _D?DKHWF?M!IbEI?E! EA!POFLO!KDP!LD?!GEBI?MEOI?!AB!IBAJI!GALFIEDK!?ABCG`8!!(:,'/:,:!=$!2818!*8!30\8!U>T!_"[[$`!_DBMaF?M!EBaGE!FG!?AE!D!BIGAaBLI!EODE!LD?!GIBNI!DG!D!@ABC!A@!GALFDK!LDRFEDK`8!!!

"$3FLODBJ!,8!'FKJIG:!?-&!>&:,'/;,(*7!*+!.*;(5E!


9/48

"[[=j! :!DE!#]!'DaK!;8!9OFEIKH:!B;*7*2(;!I'*),-!578!.*;(5E!># !_LA?JaLEF?M!D! @ABEHQ?F?I!LAa?EBH!GEaJH!D?J!@F?JF?M!EODE!?DEFA?G!PFEO!GEBA?MIB!F?NIGEAB!RBAEILEFA?G!D?J!I?@ABLICI?E!ODJ!KDBMIB!D?J!CABI!BAXaGE!LDRFEDK!CDBSIEG`]!'DaK!^8!YDS!k!.EIROI?!Z?DLS:!?'/:,!578!I'*),-:!$$$!0%-+8!^8!">T:!!^8!*05&*!.)168!T=>[`!_DBMaF?M!EODE!LA?EBDLE!KDP! @AGEIBG! LAARIBDEFA?! XH!RIBCFEEF?M! RDBEFIG!EA! ANIBLACI!GaGRFLFA?`]!.FCA?!6IDSF?! IE! DK8:!


10/48

"=[!

GALFIEFIG!D?J!CDBSIEG!EOBAaMOAaE!EOI!PABKJ!EA!?IP!FJIDG:!LACCIBLI:!D?J!F?NIGECI?E8!!%ACCa?FEFIG! F?! ICIBMF?M! ILA?ACFIG! BILANIBF?M! @BAC! GEDEI! LA?EBAK! AB! F?EIMBDEF?M!EOIFB!ILA?ACFIG!F?EA!EOI!PABKJ!ILA?ACH!@AB!EOI!@FBGE!EFCI!ODNI!RBANI?!D!BFLO!@FIKJ!A@!GEaJH! EA! GEBIGG! EOI! FCRABED?LI! A@! GALFDK! LDRFEDK! F?! ILA?ACFL!JINIKARCI?E! F?! GaLO!GIEEF?MG8


11/48

"[[=j!


12/48

"="!


13/48

"[[=j!

U$.AaRODKD!%OACGFGI?MROIE!k!&?EOA?H!'I??F?MEA?Q%BAGG:! ?-&!B%*E/,(*7!*+!,-&!./01'(2&!3*',454&!35'6&,:!==!;068!30.8!2&+Z!-;!.)8!*-1(.!30\8!


14/48

"=U! HIDBG:!D!JFGRBARABEFA?DEI!GODBI!A@!@ABILKAGaBI!DLEFA?G!PFKK!F?NAKNI!XABBAPIBG!A@!LAKAB8!!;aBEOIBCABI:! EOI! LA?LI?EBDEFA?! A@! RBIJDEABH! GaXRBFCI! XABBAPF?M! F?! &@BFLD?Q

&CIBFLD?! D?J! *DEF?A!LACCa?FEFIG! LD??AE! XI!JFGRaEIJ:! D?J! FG! EOI! BIGaKE! A@!CD?H!JF@@IBI?E!@DLEABG8UU!!&G!GEDEIJ!F?!D!BIRABE!FGGaIJ!XH!GINIBDK!@IJIBDK!DMI?LFIG/!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

U"3AXIBE!28!&NIBH!IE!DK8:!O(4-&'H@'(;&8!O*2&!D&78(74!578!,-&!\aaZ!O3>"!>5,5:!;068!30.8!21**8!&$"


15/48

"[[=j!


16/48

"=V! !;068! 30.8!2&+Z!A@!+878!!0%-+8!'-*l7!30\8:!^a?I!"[[: !$=[!_?AEF?M!EODE!F?!"[[[:!A?KH!Vt!A@!

GaXRBFCI! BI@F?D?LI! KAD?G! PIBI! CDJI! XH! F?JIRI?JI?E! CABEMDMI! LACRD?FIG! D?J! LANIBIJ!F?GEFEaEFA?G!KI?JF?M!AaE!A@!EOIFB!%3&!DGGIGGCI?E!DBIDG`8!

T$4D?H!GaXRBFCI!KI?JIBG!DBI!h?A?QJIRAGFEABH!F?GEFEaEFA?G:i!D?J!EOaG!DBI!IbICRE!@BAC!EOI!%3&8! ! .&&! $"!18.8%8! vv!">[":!$=$

T".&&L!#:! $"!%;3!v!"T8U$_D ! _"[[T`!_JIGLBFXF?M!OAP! D! BIMaKDEIJ!I?EFEHlG!hDGGIGGCI?E!DBIDi!FG!IGEDXKFGOIJ!@AB!EOI!RaBRAGI!A@!%3&!BINFIP 8!;AB!D!LBFEFfaI!A@!EOI!KFCFEDEFA?G!A@!aGF?M!D?!DGGIGGCI?E!DBID!DRRBADLO!EA!%3&!BINFIP:!GII!4&3.(%-:!:/1'5!?AEI!U$:!DE!$##Q$#=8!

T


17/48

"[[=j!


18/48

"==! ="! _&4)'&`8V[! ! )OI! )Db! 3I@ABC! &LE! A@! $>=VV$!I?LAaBDMIJ! CABI! OACI! KI?JF?M! DG! EOI! F?EIBIGE! RDFJ! A?! BIGFJI?EFDK! CABEMDMIG!BICDF?IJ!DG!EOI!A?KH!LA?GaCIB!KAD?G!POIBI!EOI!F?EIBIGE!RDFJ!PDG!EDb!JIJaLEFXKI8 V"!(?!EOI!I?J:!JIBIMaKDEFA?!PDG!LBFEFLDK!EA!MIEEF?M!GaXRBFCI!KI?JF?M!A@@!EOI!MBAa?J8!!!

;IJIBDK!JIBIMaKDEFA?! RIBCFEEIJ! KI?JIBG! EA! LODBMI!D! BFGS!RBICFaC! EA! KIGG!

LBIJFEPABEOH! XABBAPIBG! F?! EOI! @ABC! A@! OFMOIB! F?EIBIGE! BDEIG! D?J! @IIG8!!0faDKKH! FCRABED?EKH:! JIBIMaKDEFA?! DKKAPIJ! KI?JIBG! EA! CDBSIE! ?IP! D?J!CABI! LACRKIb! EHRIG! A@! CABEMDMI! RBAJaLEG:! F?LKaJF?M! DJcaGEDXKI! BDEI!CABEMDMIG!D?J! KAD?G!PFEO! XDKKAA?! RDHCI?EG! D?J!?IMDEFNI!DCABEFWDEFA?:!POFLO!IbRD?JIJ!EOI!RAAK!A@!IKFMFXKI!XABBAPIBG!D?J!OIKRIJ!KI?JIBG!LA?EBAK!@AB!F?EIBIGEQBDEI!BFGS8V

9OFKI!EOI!MBAPEO!A@!GaXRBFCI!KI?JF?M!MI?IBDKKH!D?J!GILaBFEFWDEFA?!F?!RDBEFLaKDB!@FBGE! XIMD?! F?! EOI! CFJQ$>>[G:! faIGEFA?G! DXAaE! EOI! BFGS! F?NAKNIJ! F?! F?NIGEF?M! F?!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!JI@F?FEFA?!A@!RBIJDEABH!KI?JF?M8!!;AB!EOI!GDSI!A@!GFCRKFLFEH:!(!PFKK!aEFKFWI!EOI!EIBC!hGaXRBFCI!KI?JF?Mi8!!

T#=V:!'aX8!*8!+A8!>>QT$U:!$[[!.EDE8!"[=T8!!!

V"ZF@@!k!4FKKG:!:/1'5!?AEI!U[:!DE!


19/48

"[[=j! >#!!$%&'%(&)!*+!,-&!3*',454&!578!.&;/'(,(A5,(*7!@'*;&::!

(?!EOI!CAJIB?!CABEMDMI!EBD?GDLEFA?:!D!RBAGRILEFNI!XABBAPIB!LACCa?FLDEIG!PFEO!D!CABEMDMI! XBASIB! D?J! IbRBIGGIG! D?! F?EIBIGE! F?! RaBGaF?M! D! CABEMDMI! EA! RaBLODGI! D!OACI:!AB! GIISG!EA! BI@F?D?LI!D! LaBBI?E!CABEMDMI8! ! )OFG!BIKDEFA?GOFR!CDH! ODNI!XII?!RBIQIbFGEF?M!_F?!EOI!LDGI!A@!D!BI@F?D?LI:!EOI!XBASIB!CFMOE!ODNI!OD?JKIJ!EOI!a?JIBKHF?M!CABEMDMI`:! AB:!CDH! ODNI!XIMa?!DG! D! BIGRA?GI!EA!CDBSIEF?M! XH!EOI!XBASIB! JFBILEKH:!EOBAaMO!F?QRIBGA?!CDBSIEF?M:!EDBMIEIJ!CDFKF?M:!AB!!MI?IBDKKH:!EOBAaMO!RBF?E!AB!AEOIB!CIJFD! DJNIBEFGF?M8! ! (CRABED?EKH:! F?! CD?H! caBFGJFLEFA?G:! EOI! XBASIB! APIG! ?A!F?JIRI?JI?E!JaEH:!@FJaLFDBH!AB!AEOIBPFGI:!EA!GIIS!AaE!EOI!XIGE!CABEMDMI!RBAJaLE!@AB!EOI!XABBAPIB:!D?J!EOI!XABBAPIB:!POA!KFSIKH!ODG!F?LACRKIEI!_DE!XIGE`!S?APKIJMI!DXAaE!EOI!CDBSIE:!BIKFIG!OIDNFKH!A?!EOI!XBASIB!EA!AXEDF?!EOI!CAGE!@DNABDXKI!EIBCG8VV!!!

)OI! XBASIB! PFKK! EHRFLDKKH! MDEOIB! F?@ABCDEFA?! DXAaE! EOI! XABBAPIBlG!

LBIJFEPABEOF?IGG/! F8I8:!D?!DGGIGGCI?E!FG! CDJI!DXAaE! EOI!XABBAPIBlG!KFSIKH!DXFKFEH! EA!RDH!XDLS!D!KAD?8!!(?@ABCDEFA?!EODE!FG!MDEOIBIJ!PFKK!F?LKaJI!EOI!RBAGRILEFNI!XABBAPIBlG!PABS!D?J!LBIJFE! OFGEABH]!D?H!OFGEABH! A@!RBFAB! KFI?G:! caJMCI?EG!D?JmAB! XD?SBaRELFIG]!EOI! ?DEaBI!D?J! GFWI! A@!D?H! DGGIEG! OI!AB! GOI! CFMOE!RAGGIGG]!D?J! OFG! AB!OIB! F?LACI!DCAa?E!D?J!GAaBLIG8!!;DB!CABI!A@EI?!EOD?!?AE:!EOFG!F?@ABCDEFA?!FG!MDEOIBIJ!XH!D!LBIJFE!BDEF?M!DMI?LH:!D?J!D!GLABI!FG!LDKLaKDEIJ!XH!EODE!F?JIRI?JI?E!DMI?LH!XDGIJ!A?!EOIGI!D?J!AEOIB!@DLEABG8!!&?!IGEFCDEIJ!KAD?!DCAa?E!FG!EDSI?!F?EA!DLLAa?E:!D?J!D?!IGEFCDEIJ!CA?EOKH!RDHCI?E!FG!LDKLaKDEIJ!XDGIJ!A?!EOI!EIBCG!A@!EODE!KAD?8!!)OI!LBIJFE!GLABI!FG!F?EI?JIJ!EA!GIBNI!DG!D?!F?JFLDEAB!A@!EOI!XABBAPIBlG!DXFKFEH!EA!RDH!XDLS!D!KAD?!XDGIJ!A?! EOI! IbRILEIJ! EIBCG! _A?I! FCRABED?E! @DLEAB! EODE! FG! EDSI?! F?EA! DLLAa?E! FG! EOI!D?EFLFRDEIJ! CA?EOKH! RDHCI?EG! POI?! NFIPIJ! DMDF?GE! EOI! OAaGIOAKJlG! CA?EOKH!F?LACI`8V#!!!

2DGIJ!A?!EOFG!D?DKHGFG:!EOI!RBAJaLEG! EODE!CFMOE!XI!DNDFKDXKI! EA!EOI! RBAGRILEFNI!

XABBAPIB!DBI!FJI?EF@FIJ8!!(@!EOI!RBAGRILEFNI!XABBAPIB!ODG!D!OFMO!LBIJFE!BDEF?M:!OFMO!D?J!GEDXKI! F?LACI:! GFM?F@FLD?E!GDNF?MG:! D?J! KFEEKI!JIXE:! hRBFCIi!CABEMDMI!RBAJaLEG!PFKK!XI!DNDFKDXKI!EA!OIB8!!(@!EOI!RBAGRILEFNI!XABBAPIB!ODG!D!RAAB!LBIJFE!BDEF?M:!a?GEDXKI!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

VU%OACGFGI?MROIE!k!'I??F?MEA?Q%BAGG8:!:/1'5!?AEI!U$:!DE!U$QU


20/48

">[! 8!

#[98#:!DE!$


21/48

"[[=j! (?NIGEABGgCaEaDK! @a?JG:! RI?GFA?G:! OIJMI! @a?JG:! XBASIBDMI! OAaGIG:! D?J!F?JFNFJaDKGgEOI?! RaBLODGI! EOI! GILaBFEFIG! LBIDEIJ! D?J! XDLSIJ! XH! EOI! DGGIEG! F?! EOI!.'\8! ! &?! F?JIRI?JI?E! DMI?E:! S?AP?! DG! EOI! GIBNFLIB:! OD?JKIG! EOI! JDHQEAQJDH!CD?DMICI?E! A@! EOI! F?JFNFJaDK! CABEMDMIG!XDLSF?M! EOI! GILaBFEFIG8! ! )ODE! GIBNFLIB! FG!BIGRA?GFXKI!@AB!LAKKILEF?M!EOI!CA?EOKH!RDHCI?EG!A@!F?EIBIGE!D?J!RBF?LFRDK:!CA?FEABF?M!KAD?G! F?! JI@DaKE:! D?J! EHRFLDKKH! FG! BIGRA?GFXKI! @AB! RaBGaF?M! @ABILKAGaBIG! POIBI!

?ILIGGDBH8#U!!!

B#!!?-&!


22/48

">"!


23/48

"[[=j!

'&()*!+#(&,-

+.(./&*!)&01(23&(41&*-

5&4&16&*!1(7&$&*7!

.()!8$1(418.0-

!".(9

!!!!)OI! @FBGE! @FMaBI! BIRBIGI?EG! EOI! EBDJFEFA?DK!XABBAPIBQKI?JIB! BIKDEFA?GOFR:! PFEO!FEG!

GODBIJ! BIGRA?GFXFKFEFIG:!POIBI!CaEaDK! F?EIBJIRI?JI?LI! FG!LBFEFLDK! EA! FEG! @a?LEFA?F?M8!!)OI! GILA?J:! CABI! LACRKIb! @FMaBI! XIKAP! BIRBIGI?EG! EOI! LaBBI?E! PIX! A@! JF@@aGI!BIKDEFA?GOFRG:!POIBI!DLLAa?EDXFKFEH!@AB!XDJ!KAD?G!FG!ODBJ!EA!EBDLI8!

!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

##=5('!?&:,(2*7F:!:/1'5!?AEI!


24/48

">U! $#?!

.!'&()&$-!;

.!+#$7/./&!"$#9&$-!!@(!?.(,!4.*&*A!7

!!

!D.*8!!!

$$#-@!LAaBGI:!EOFG!DGGaCIG!?A!JFGLBFCF?DEFA?!AB!AEOIB!SF?JG!A@!GEIIBF?M!A?!EOI!RDBE!A@!EOI!KI?JIB8!!!


32/48

!.?"?B!D"J!NBM9BJ! d\AK8!TV/"#$!

;aBEOIBCABI:! GOAaKJ! EOAGI! DGGIGGCI?EG! RBANI! F?LABBILEgGOAaKJ! EOIBI! XI! D?!ILA?ACFL!JAP?EaB?:! D! LKAGF?M! A@! D! XaGF?IGG! AB! EOI! @KFMOE! A@!D! LACRD?H! @BAC! EOI!DBIDgEOI!KI?JIB!PFKK!S?AP!DXAaE!FE!PFEO!GACI!DJND?LI!PDB?F?M!D?J!PFKK!XI!DXKI!EA!LACCa?FLDEI! PFEO! EOI! XABBAPIB! DXAaE! RBAGRILEG! @AB! CDF?EDF?F?M! EODE! XABBAPIBlG!AXKFMDEFA?G!a?JIB!EOI!KAD?8!!.OABEQEIBC!CAJF@FLDEFA?G!A@!EOI!KAD?!LAaKJ!XI!CDJI!EA!DLLACCAJDEI!D!EICRABDBH!GIEXDLS!D?J!KA?MQEIBC!BIGEBaLEaBF?M!LAaKJ!XI!RaE!F?!RKDLI:!AB!D!RKD??IJ!GDKI!A@!EOI!RBARIBEH!LAaKJ!ALLaB:!PFEO!I?AaMO!KIDJ!EFCI!EA!RBIGIBNI!EOI!DGGIE!D?J!EOI!LBIJFE!OFGEABH!A@!EOI!XABBAPIB8!!!

(?!EOI!CAJIB?! BIKDEFA?GOFR:! ?AE! A?KH! FG! EOIBI!KFEEKI! LACCa?FLDEFA?! XIEPII?! EOI!XABBAPIB!D?J!EOI!GIBNFLIB!A@!EOI!JIXEgAEOIB!EOD?!EOI!CA?EOKH!CDFKF?M!PFEO!D!BIEaB?!I?NIKARI!@AB!RDHCI?EgEOI!XABBAPIB!CFMOE!?AE!INI?!S?AP!EOI!RIBGA?!EA!LDKK!POI?!OI! AB! GOI! @IDBG! D?! ILA?ACFL! GIEXDLS! PFKK! CDSI! JIKF?faI?LH! D! BIDK! RAGGFXFKFEH8!!;aBEOIBCABI:!XDGIJ!A?!EOFG!KDLS!A@!D!BIKDEFA?GOFR!PFEO!AB!S?APKIJMI!A@! EOI!GIBNFLIB:!D?J!AaE! A@! FM?ABD?LI!A@! EOI!@aKK!LA?GIfaI?LIG!A@!JI@DaKE:!D!XABBAPIB!CFMOE!FM?ABI!LDKKG!@BAC!EOI!GIBNFLIB!AB! D!LAKKILEFA?!DMI?LH!F?faFBF?M!DXAaE! EOI!XABBAPIBlG!DXFKFEH!EA!CIIE!OFG!AB!OIB!AXKFMDEFA?G8$$=!!!

)OIBI! DBI! DKGA! GEBaLEaBDK! XDBBFIBG! EA! @ABXIDBD?LI]! DG! GEDEIJ! IDBKFIB:! CD?H!GILaBFEFWDEFA?! DMBIICI?EG! LA?EDF?! KFCFEG! A?! EOI! IbEI?E! EA! POFLO! D! GIBNFLIB! LD?!?IMAEFDEI!EIBCG!PFEO!D!XABBAPIB!F?!JI@DaKE:!AB!CFMOE!KFCFE!EOI!RIBLI?EDMI!A@!KAD?G!F?!D!EBD?LOI!EODE!LD?!XI! CAJF@FIJ:!D?J!D! GIBNFLIB!CFMOE!BILIFNI!LACRI?GDEFA?!@BAC!EOI!OAKJIBG!A@!EOI!GILaBFEFIG!XDGIJ!A?!EOI!DCAa?E!EODE!FG!LAKKILEIJ!@BAC!EOI!XABBAPIB8!!!

(?!ABJIB!EA!DJJBIGG!EOI!DGHCCIEBFIG!A@!F?@ABCDEFA?:!EOI!PIDS!BIKDEFA?GOFRG!DCA?M!EOI! RDBEFIG:! EOI! DXGI?LI! A@! DLLAa?EDXFKFEH! KINIBG! F?! EOI!CDBSIE:! D?J! EOI! KFCFEG! A?!?IMAEFDXFKFEH:! POFLO! DBI! DKK! @DFKaBIG! A@! GALFDK! LDRFEDK:! DCA?M! AEOIB! EOF?MG:! EOI!@AKKAPF?M!FG!D!JFGLaGGFA?!A@!EOI!PDHG!EODE!EOI!GaXRBFCI!CABEMDMI!CDBSIE!LAaKJ!XI!BIQF?@aGIJ!PFEO!GALFDK!LDRFEDK!GA!EODE!F?@ABCDEFA?!GODBF?M:!EBaGE!D?J!DLLAa?EDXFKFEH!LD?!XI!BIGEABIJ!EA!D!GHGEIC!EODE!FG!DKK!EAA!A@EI?!KDLSF?M!F?!DKK!EOBII8!!!

"#!!3*',454&!='*6&'!";;*/7,50(E(,F!

(?!CD?H!F?GED?LIG:!RDBEFLaKDBKH!PFEO!GaXRBFCI!XABBAPIBG!POA!CFMOE!?AE!ODNI!D!RBIQIbFGEF?M!BIKDEFA?GOFR!PFEO!D!KI?JIB:!D!RBAGRILEFNI!CABEMDMABlG!@FBGE!@ABDH!F?EA!EOI!CABEMDMI!CDBSIE! FG!MaFJIJ! XH!D!CABEMDMI!XBASIB8! ! ;AB! EOI! EHRFLDK!a?GAROFGEFLDEIJ!XABBAPIB:! EOI! CABEMDMI! XBASIB! CDH! OAKJ! EOI! ILA?ACFL! @DEI! A@! EOI! RBAGRILEFNI!XABBAPIB!F?!OFG!AB!OIB!OD?J8!!)OI!RBAGRILEFNI!XABBAPIB!BIKFIG!A?!EOI!CABEMDMI!XBASIB!

DG!D?!DJNFGAB:!LA?@FJD?EI:!h@FbIBi!D?J!CDELOCDSIB8!!)OI!XABBAPIB!PFKK!A@EI?!ODNI!EOI!CABEMDMI!RBALIGG!IbRKDF?IJ! EA!OFC!AB!OIB!XH! EOI!CABEMDMI!XBASIB!D?J! EODE!XBASIB!PFKK!DGGIGG!EOI!LBIJFEPABEOF?IGG!D?J!NFDXFKFEH!A@!EOI!RBAGRILEFNI!XABBAPIB:!PFKK!OIKR!FJI?EF@H!CABEMDMI!RBAJaLEG!D?J!MI?IBDKKH!GOIROIBJ!EOI!XABBAPIB!EOBAaMO!EOI!RBALIGG:!@BAC!DGGFGEF?M!OFC!AB!OIB!F?!MDEOIBF?M!JALaCI?EDEFA?!A@!F?LACI!D?J!DGGIEG!GEBDFMOE!EOBAaMO!EA!EOI!CABEMDMI!LKAGF?M8!!!

)OI! CABEMDMI! XBASIB! EOIBI@ABI! GFEG! DE! D! LBFEFLDK! ca?LEaBI! F?! EOI! RBALIGG! D?J!XILACIG! ?AE! A?KH! D! GAaBLI! A@! F?@ABCDEFA?! DXAaE! EOI! RBALIGG! @AB! EOI! RBAGRILEFNI!XABBAPIB:!XaE!DKGA!aKEFCDEIKH!LAa?GIKG!EOI!XABBAPIB!A?!PODE!OI!AB!GOI!LD?!D@@ABJ!D?J!FJI?EF@FIG! EOI! CABEMDMI! RBAJaLE! EODE:! F?! EOI! XBASIBlG! D?J! KI?JIBlG! ARF?FA?:! FG!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

$$=^AO?!*IKD?J:!.)(+,!.,&1:!O&E1!"%&',!K*'&;E*:/'&:!(7!=5E,(2*'& :!+878!)(40.:!4DBLO!"V:!

"[[=:!DE!&$!_?AEF?M!D!EI?JI?LH!A@!XABBAPIBG!F?!JI@DaKE!EA!FM?ABI!I@@ABEG!A@!GIBNFLIBG!EA!LA?EDLE!EOAGI!XABBAPIBG`8!!


33/48

"[[=j! :!">$Q">"!_"[[#`8!

$"[.&&! 9HDEE! N8! 1?FA?! 4ABEMDMI! %A8:! T>=! '8"J! UT:! T[! _%DK8! $>#>`! _@F?JF?M:! a?JIB!%DKF@AB?FD!3IDK!0GEDEI!KDP!D?J!RBF?LFRKIG!A@!DMI?LH!KDP:!EODE!CABEMDMI!XBASIBG!API!@FJaLFDBH!JaEFIG!EA!XABBAPIBG`]!:&&!5E:*!3IJI!N8!5BIDE!&C8!;FBGE!.DN8!2D?S:!+A8!>TQTTV$V:!$>>#!18.8!&RR8! *0r(.!#U#:! DE! y"!_>EO!%FB8! ^D?8! $T:!$>>#`8! !>=`! _@F?JF?M! faIGEFA?! A@! @FJaLFDBH! BIKDEFA?GOFR! OF?MIG! A?! DLEG! A@!RDBEFIG! BINFIPIJ!a?JIB!RBF?LFRKIG!A@! DMI?LH!KDP`]!.OD@IB! N8!5.;!4ABEMDMI! %ABR8:!%$Q["Q$$VT:! "[[>p%\Q$T""&Q^0%:!"[[[!18.8!6FGE8!*0r(.!"[U[[:!DE!yT"!_+868!5D8!&aM8!>:!"[[[`!_@F?JF?M!@FJaLFDBH!BIKDEFA?GOFR!XIEPII?!XABBAPIB!D?J!XBASIB!a?JIB!RBF?LFRKIG!A@!DMI?LH!KDP`]!4L9OABEIB!N8!;ABJ!%A?GaCIB!;F?8!%A8:!V:!DE!y>!_+868!(KK8!4DH!$=:!"[[$`!_LA?GEBaF?M!(KKF?AFG!KDP!EA!@F?J!EODE!@FJaLFDBH!BIKDEFA?GOFR!CDH!IbFGE!XDGIJ!A?!DMI?LH!KDP]!LA?GEBaF?M!RBF?LFRDKG!A@!DMI?LH!KDP!


34/48

!_'D8!%ACCP8!%E8!"[[V`!_GDCI`8!!=/,!;+8!2BDWFIB!N8!.IL8!'DL8!4ABEMDMI:!(?L8:!"UT!;8!.aRR8!"J!$$

D?J!3IDK!0GEDEI!.IEEKICI?E!'BALIJaBIG!&LE!A@!$>#U:!$"!18.8%8!vv"V[$Q$#!_"[[V`!_30.'&`8!!9OFKI! 30.'&! JIDKG! CAGEKH! PFEO! JFGLKAGaBI! A@! LKAGF?M! LAGEG:! )(*&! JIDKG! RBFCDBFKH! PFEO!JFGLKAGaBIG! DXAaE! EOI! LAGE! DGGALFDEIJ!PFEO! EOI!JIDK!FEGIK@:! F8I8:! EOI!F?EIBIGE! BDEI! D?J!@F?D?LI!LODBMI8! ! .AQLDKKIJ!3IMaKDEFA?!Y:!POFLO!FCRKICI?EG!EOI!BIfaFBICI?EG!A@! )(*&:!GIEG!@ABEO!D!GIBFIG! A@! JFGLKAGaBI! BIfaFBICI?EG! FCRAGIJ! aRA?! EOI!LBIJFEAB:! GII:! I8M8:! $"! %8;838! v""V8$=!_"[[V`:!XaE!FCRAGIG!?A!JFGLKAGaBI!BIfaFBICI?EG!A?!XBASIBG8!!)OI!,ACI!-P?IBGOFR!D?J!0faFEH!'BAEILEFA?!&LE!A@! $>>U:!$T! 18.8%8!vv! $V[$:!$V["_DD`:!$V_D`Q_X`! _"[[V`!_,-0'& :!POFLO!DCI?JIJ! )(*&:! D?J! EOI! BIMaKDEFA?G! A@! POFLO! DBI! DKGA! @Aa?J! F?! 3IMaKDEFA?! Y:! BIfaFBI!DJJFEFA?DK!JFGLKAGaBIG!@AB!hOFMO!LAGEi:!LKAGIJQI?J!CABEMDMIG!_PFEO!F?EIBIGE!BDEIG!EODE!IbLIIJ!D!LIBEDF?!DCAa?E 8!! &E!EOI! EFCI! A@!RaXKFLDEFA?:! EOI!;IJIBDK!3IGIBNI!ODG! RBARAGIJ! LOD?MIG! EA!3IMaKDEFA?! Y! F?! BIGRA?GI! EA! EOI! GaXRBFCI! CABEMDMI! LBFGFG:! A?I! A@! POFLO! PFKK! KAPIB! EOI!hEBFMMIBi!A@!,-0'&!PFEO!BIGRILE!EA!EOI!F?EIBIGE!BDEI!EA!POFLO!FE!DRRKFIG:!XaE!GEFKK!ODG!?AE!GAaMOE!EA!FCRAGI!D?H!@FJaLFDBH!JaEFIG!A?!XBASIBG8!!.&&!)BaEO!F?!*I?JF?M:!#

*DPBI?LI!08!4FELOIKK:!?-&!921*',57;&!*+!=&(74!?'/:,&8:!=$!2818!*8!30\8!T>$:!V$UQV$T!_"[[$`8!


35/48

"[[=j! :! DE! $#>V! _DBMaF?M! @FJaLFDBH! KDP! h@BDCIGi!BIKDEFA?GOFRG!EA!I?LAaBDMI!EOI!F?EIB?DKFWDEFA?!A@!XIODNFAB!PABEOH!A@!EBaGE`8!!;AB!D?!DBMaCI?E!@AB!POH!XBASIBG!GOAaKJ!?AE!XI!@FJaLFDBFIG!A@!EOIFB!LKFI?EQXABBAPIBG:!:&&!6DNFJ!1?GIEO:!+AEI:!J-5,!D&%&E!*+!K(8/;(5'F!>/,F!.-*/E8!3*',454&!='*6&':!$)&!?-&('!=*''*)&':Q !#T!9&.,8!18!

*8!s8!$#>#`8!!!$"#2KDFB!k! .EAaE:!:/1'5! ?AEI!$>:! DE!$#==!_?AEF?M!PFJIQGRBIDJ!BILAM?FEFA?! EODE!GFEaDEFA?G!

POIBI!EOI!RBF?LFRDK!LD??AE!CA?FEAB!EOI!DMI?E!DBI!DRRBARBFDEI!@AB!EOI!FCRAGFEFA?!A@!@FJaLFDBH!JaEFIG`!_LFEDEFA?G!ACFEEIJ`8!!!

$"=(?!GEaJFIG! EODE! ODNI! KAASIJ! DE!EOI! FCRDLE!A@! GALFDK! LDRFEDK!A?! EOI!GaLLIGG! A@!KI?JF?M!RBAMBDCG:!BIGIDBLO!GOAPG!EODE!D!OFMO!KINIK!A@!EBaGE!XIEPII?!XABBAPIB!D?J!KI?JIB!FG!RAGFEFNIKH!BIKDEIJ! EA! EOI! GaLLIGG! A@! GaLO! RBAMBDCG:! D?J! OFMO! KINIKG! A@! GALFDK! LDRFEDK! OIKR! ANIBLACI!DGHCCIEBFIG!A@! F?@ABCDEFA?:!IGRILFDKKH!F?! EOI!CFLBAQKI?JF?M!LA?EIbE!POIBI! XaFKJF?M!NIBEFLDK!GALFDK!LDRFEDK!XIEPII?!EOI!XABBAPIB!D?J!KI?JIB!FG!GII?!DG!D!RBFABFEH8!!.&&L!#:!&GF@!6APKD:!97!


36/48

.EINI?!'8!,AB?XaBM:!.,'&74,-&7(74!,-&!


37/48

"[[=j! $


38/48


39/48

"[[=j! >T ! _LDEDKAMaF?M! GEDEI!RBALIJaBIG`]!6IXBD! 'AMBa?J!.EDBS:!K*'&;E*:(74!*7! ,-&!"2&'(;57!>'&52C! "7!B%5E/5,(*7!*+!.,5,&!578! K&8&'5E!K*'&;E*:/'&! D5)::!T$!-Z*&8! *8! 30\8! "">! _$>>=`!_JIGLBFXF?M! @ABILKAGaBI!BICIJFIG`8!!

$U[.&&!0MMIBE:!:/1'5!?AEI!


40/48


41/48

"[[=j!


42/48

!.?"?B!D"J!NBM9BJ! d\AK8!TV/"#$!

9ODE!LD?!EOI!DXGI?LI!A@!KIMDK!RBAEILEFA?G!EIKK!aG!DXAaE!EOI!I@@ILE!A@!KDP!A?!EOFG!!CDBSIEe! ! 'BFAB! EA! EOFG!CDBSIElG! LAKKDRGI:!CD?H! CFMOE! ODNI! ODFKIJ! EOI! EBFaCRO! A@!JIBIMaKDEFA?!D?J!ILA?ACFL!CDBSIEG!ANIB!DEEICREG!EA!KIMFGKDEI!DMDF?GE!JFGLBFCF?DEFA?8!!)OI! KAAGI?F?M! A@! BIGEBFLEFA?G! A?! LIBEDF?! EHRIG! A@! KI?JF?M! EOBAaMO! JIBIMaKDEFA?:!@IJIBDK!RBIQICREFA?!A@!GACI!GEDEI!I@@ABEG!EA!LACXDE!RBIJDEABH!KI?JF?M:$T"!D?J!D!PIX!A@!KDPG!JIGFM?IJ!EA!JFGLAaBDMI!hAKJ!@DGOFA?IJi!JFGLBFCF?DEFA?!F?!CABEMDMI!KI?JF?M:!I?LAaBDMIJ! GaXRBFCI! KI?JF?M! F?! RBINFAaGKH! hBIJKF?IJi! LACCa?FEFIG8! ! .aXRBFCI!KI?JIBG! @FKKIJ! EODE! NAFJ! D?J! IbRKAFEIJ! EODE! CDBSIE8! ! &?J! EOaG:! JFGLBFCF?DEFA?! F?!CABEMDMI! KI?JF?M! PDG! ?A! KA?MIB! D! RBAXKIC8! ! &! GEBA?M! OAaGF?M! CDBSIE! PDG! EOI!GAKaEFA?!EA!OAaGF?M!JFGLBFCF?DEFA?8!!*I?JF?M!JFGRDBFEFIG!F?!LACCa?FEFIG!A@!LAKAB!PIBI!D!BIGaKE!A@!KI?JIBG!LA?LIB?IJ!DXAaE!EOIFB!XAEEAC!KF?I:!?AE!CAEFNDEIJ!XH!XFDG!DMDF?GE!XABBAPIBG!AB!LIBEDF?!LACCa?FEFIG8!!*IE!EOI!CDBSIE!JA!FEG!cAX!D?J!JFGLBFCF?DEFA?!PFKK!EaB?!AaE!EA!XI!F?I@@FLFI?E8!!&E!KIDGE!EODE!PDG!EOI!EOIABH8$T

(E! FG! EBaI! EODE! EOI! BIKI?EKIGG! JBFNI! EA! GILaBFEFWI! RaGOIJ! KI?JIBG! F?EA! RBINFAaGKH!a?JIBGIBNIJ!LACCa?FEFIG!F?!D?!I@@ABE!EA!CDbFCFWI!RBA@FEG8!!)BDMFLDKKH:!EOI!XBASIBG!D?J!KI?JIBG!POA!XBAaMOE!EOIGI!RBAJaLEG!EA!EOIGI!LACCa?FEFIG!@Aa?J!EOICGIKNIG!PFEO!XAEO!D?!F?@ABCDEFA?DK!DJND?EDMI!ANIB!EOIFB!LaGEACIBG!D?J!PFEO!?A!DLLAa?EDXFKFEH!EA!EOIFB!F?NIGEABG8!!1KEFCDEIKH:!EOFG!CFb!ODG!RBANI?!EAbFL8!!&?J!EOI!KDPG!JIGFM?IJ!EA!BAAE!AaE!JFGLBFCF?DEABH!RBDLEFLIG!ODNI!RBANI?!JaKK!PIDRA?G!DMDF?GE!hBINIBGI!BIJKF?F?Mi/!EOI! F?@aGFA?! A@!CABEMDMI! RBAJaLEG! F?! RBINFAaGKH! a?JIBGIBNIJ!CDBSIEG8$TU! ! (?JIIJ:!KDPG!KFSI!,46&!D?J!EOI!%ACCa?FEH!3IF?NIGECI?E!&LE!DBI!JIGFM?IJ:!BIGRILEFNIKH:!

EA! CA?FEAB:! EOBAaMO! JFGLKAGaBI:! CABEMDMI! BIcILEFA?! D?J! DRRBANDK! RDEEIB?G! D?J! EOI!@DFKaBI!A@!LANIBIJ!XD?SG!EA!CIIE!EOI!LBIJFE!?IIJG!A@!EOI!LACCa?FEFIG!EOIH!GIBNI8!!(?!EOIGI!PDHG:! EOIH! RBFCDBFKH! EDBMIE! EOI! @DFKaBI! A@! XD?SG! EA! IbEI?J! KAD?! RBAJaLEG! EA!LACCa?FEFIG!A@!LAKAB8!!)OI!;DFB!,AaGF?M!&LE:!A?!EOI!AEOIB!OD?J:!DKEOAaMO!FEG!RBFCDBH!RaBRAGI!FG!EA!RBAOFXFE!EOI!BIcILEFA?!A@!KAD?!DRRKFLDEFA?G!XDGIJ!A?!BDLI:!DKGA!RBAOFXFEG!EOI! FCRAGFEFA?! A@!JF@@IBI?E! D?J! KIGG! @DNABDXKI! KAD?!EIBCG!XDGIJ! A?!EOI! BDLI!A@!EOI!XABBAPIB8! ! (?! KFEFMDEFA?! a?JIB! EOI! ;,&:! OAPINIB:! DG! PFEO! CD?H! AEOIB! D?EFQ

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

$T".&&! +FLOAKDG! 2DMKIH:! +AEI:! ?-&! P7)5''57,&8! N&4/E5,*'F! @'&&21,(*7! *+! @'&85,*'F!D&78(74!D5)::!#>!+87818!*8!30\8!""#U:!""#U!_"[[U`!_JIGLBFXF?M!I@@ABEG!XH!EOI!-@@FLI!A@!EOI!%ACREBAKKIB!A@!EOI!%aBBI?LH!EA!RBIQICRE!GACI!GEDEI!D?EFQRBIJDEABH!KI?JF?M!KDPG`8!!!

$TT#`! _DBMaF?M! EODE!

JFGLBFCF?DEFA?!FG! F?I@@FLFI?E! D?J!@BII!CDBSIEG:!?AE! BIMaKDEFA?:! PFKK! IKFCF?DEI! FE`]! ^I@@BIH!98!5a?EOIB:!.-*/E8!>#`8! ! .&&! 5E:*! (&+!&730.:!),0!0*1.(\0!+&)130!-;!6(.%3(4(+&)(-+/!'03\&.(\0!'30^16(%0e!1+%-+\0+)(-+&*!0\(60+%0!-;!3&%0!&+6!50+603!6(.%3(4(+&)(-+!_"[[


43/48

"[[=j!

'IBODRG! EFMOEKH! S?FE! LACCa?FEFIG! PFEO! JIIRKH! ICXIJJIJ! ?ABCG! A@! EBaGE! D?J!LAARIBDEFA?!LD?!@a?LEFA?!PIKK!PFEOAaE!CaLO!BILAaBGI!EA!EOI!KDP8$TV!!2aE!F?!CDBSIEG!F?!EBD?GFEFA?:! POIBI! EBDJFEFA?DK! BIKDEFA?GOFRG! A@! EBaGE! ODNI! XBASI?! JAP?! D?J! XII?!BIRKDLIJ!XH!CABI! FCRIBGA?DK! LACCa?FLDEFA?G!D?J!POIBI! EOI! KDPG! F?!RKDLI! JA!?AE!BIGRA?J!EA!EOI!LOD?MIG!F?!EOIGI!BIKDEFA?GOFRG:!?ABCG!A@!EBaGE!D?J!EOI!GD?LEFA?G!EODE!CFMOE! AEOIBPFGI! I?@ABLI! EOIC! RBANI! FKKaGABH8! ! (?@ABCDEFA?! DGHCCIEBFIG! D?J! EOI!RBAGRILE! A@! CABDK! ODWDBJ! DXAa?J8! ! 9FEOAaE! D! KIMDK! BIGRA?GI! EA! GaLO! CDBSIE!

EBD?G@ABCDEFA?G:!POIBI!KDP!LD?!OIKR!EA!GOABI!aR!EOIGI!BIKDEFA?GOFRG!F?!EBD?GFEFA?!D?J!F?GaKDEI!EOIC!@BAC!EOI!ODBGO!LA?GIfaI?LIG!A@!EOI!JIRDBEaBI!A@!GALFDK!LDRFEDK:!EBaGE!FG!BIRKDLIJ!XH!RBIJDEFA?8!!!

*DP!LD?!BIGEABI!EBaGE:!D?J!PFEO!FE:!GALFDK!LDRFEDK:!OAPINIB/!F?!A?I!IbDCRKI:!XH!EOI!LBIDEFA?!A@!@FJaLFDBH!JaEFIG!EODE!CDH!OIKR!EA!A@@GIE!F?@ABCDEFA?!DGHCCIEBFIG8!!4DBSIE!BIGRA?GIG! KFSI! XIEEIB! LA?GaCIB! IJaLDEFA?! LD?! DKGA! OIKR! EA! A@@GIE! GaLO! CDBSIE!JFGEABEFA?G8! ! ^aJFLFDK! BIGRA?GIG! EODE! DEEICRE! EA! BIXaFKJ! GALFDK! LDRFEDK! F?! JFGRaEI!BIGAKaEFA?gKFSI! EOI! RBAXKICQGAKNF?M! LAaBEG! JIGLBFXIJ! OIBIgLD?! DKGA! OIKR! BILEF@H!GEBaLEaBDK!FCRIJFCI?EG!EA!?IMAEFDEFA?G!EA!BIDLO!CaEaDKKH!XI?I@FLFDK!I?JG8!!!

&BI!EOIBI!AEOIB!CDBSIEG!EA!POFLO!EOFG!D?DKHGFG!CDH!XI!OIKR@aKe!!-?I!LKAGI!LAaGF?!EA!EOI!GaXRBFCI!CABEMDMI!CDBSIE!FG!EOI!LA?GaCIB!LBIJFE!CDBSIE8!!(?!D!GCDKK!EAP?!AB!EFMOEKH! S?FE! LACCa?FEH:! D! KALDK! CIBLOD?E! CFMOE! XI! PFKKF?M! EA! IbEI?J! LBIJFE! EA!LaGEACIBG!OI!AB!GOI!S?APG!AB!EBaGEG8!!.aLO!D!CIBLOD?E!PFKK!A?KH!RIBCFE!GaLO!LBIJFE!EA!

MBAP!GA!OFMO:!D?J!PFKK!BIF?!F?!LaGEACIBG!GIISF?M!EA!EDSI!DJND?EDMI!A@!MAAJ!PFKK8!!&E!EOI! GDCI! EFCI:! KAPQF?LACI! LACCa?FEFIG! D?J! LACCa?FEFIG! A@! LAKAB! ODNI! KA?M!Ga@@IBIJ!@BAC!EOI!OFMO!RBFLI!A@!LA?GaCIB!LBIJFE:!EOBAaMO!BI?EQEAQAP?!GLOICIG!D?J!LA?EBDLEG!A@!DJOIGFA?8!!9FEO!JIBIMaKDEFA?:!LA?GaCIBG!DBI!ANIBPOIKCIJ!XH!LBIJFE!LDBJ!A@@IBG:!D?J!EOI!PABSF?M!RAAB!DBI!DKK!EAA!A@EI?!GDJJKIJ!PFEO!OFMO!LAGE!LA?GaCIB!JIXE8!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

$TT.&&L! #:! %DGGD?JBD! ^A?IG!,DNDBJ:!>&2*;'5,(A(74!


44/48

*&:! .*;(5E!


45/48

"[[=j! TQV[>!_$>>=`]!3ALOIKKI!*I?EA:!&%&E*12&7,!=576(74!.,'5,&4F! +*'!N&%(,5E(A(74!$/'!!,AP8!*8^8!T`8!

$V";AB!D! BINFIP!A@! EOI!CFLBAQ@F?D?LI!CANICI?E! MI?IBDKKH:! GII! ^A?DEOD?!4ABJaLO:!?-&!3(;'*+(757;&!@'*2(:& :!!_$>>>`8!!.ACI!faIGEFA?!EOI!NFDXFKFEH!A@!EOI!5BDCII?!2D?S!CAJIK!MI?IBDKKH!D?J!FEG! DRRKFLDEFA?!F?!EOI!1?FEIJ!.EDEIG8! !.&&L!#:!3DGOCF!6HDKQ%OD?J:!N&+E&;,(*7!(7! 5!>(:,57,!3(''*'C!J-F!,-&! J&:,!-5:!3(:1&';&(%&8!,-&! I'52&&7!=576V:! M(:(*7! *+! 3(;'*;'&8(,:! U$!.)&+8! ^8! (+)l*! *8! "$#! _"[[T`]! *AaFGI! &8! ,APIKKG:! ?-&!>(2&7:(*7:! *+!3(;'*&7,&'1'(:&C! "!


46/48

OIKR!RBACAEI!EBaGE!D?J!F?EIMBDEFA?:!D?J!EOIBIXH!@AGEIB!EOI!LBIDEFA?!A@!GALFDK!LDRFEDK8!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

$V!)&r!*8!=$$:!$>"Q>

$V#%DBD!3aXF?GSH:!!


47/48

"[[=j!


48/48

Date post:	31-May-2018
Category:	Documents
Upload:	peter
View:	218 times
Download:	0 times

Capital in Chaos: The Subprime Mortgage Crisis and the Social Capital Response

Documents