CLEAN LABEL: INSTILLING CONSUMER CONFIDENCE IN GLOBAL FOOD AND BEVERAGES ALAN ROWNAN
FOOD MATTERS LIVE, LONDON 2016
© Euromonitor International
2
Euromonitor International is a global market research company
providing strategic intelligence on industries, companies,
economies and consumers around the world.
A trusted business intelligence source
Helping clients make informed decisions
Subscription services and custom research
800+ analysts in countries worldwide
Region and industry specialists
About Euromonitor International ABOUT EUROMONITOR INTERNATIONAL
CLEAN LABEL – GLOBAL PERSPECTIVE
CLEAN LABEL LEADS THE WAY TO RE-ESTABLISHING TRUST
WHAT DOES THE FUTURE HOLD FOR CLEAN LABEL?
© Euromonitor International
4
Introducing ethical labels DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
PEOPLE
Clean Label:
• All Natural • No Artificial Additives • No Artificial Colours • No Artificial Flavours • No Artificial Preservatives • No Artificial Sweeteners • No Monosodium Glutamate • GMO Free • BPA Free
Origin:
• Locally Sourced Prominent
Religious Labels:
• Halal • Kosher
Charity/Sponsorship
ENVIRONMENT/
SUSTAINABILITY
Sustainable Trade and Farming:
• Fairtrade • UTZ Certified • Other
Responsible Forestry:
• Rainforest Alliance • FSC • Other
Sustainable Palm Oil System
• RSPO/ISPO/MSPO • Other
Recycling Label:
• Widely recycled • Can be recycled • Terracycle • From Sustainable/Renewable Sources • Other
Carbon Footprint/No Air Miles Food
ANIMAL
WELFARE
Free Range
Marine Sustainability
Bird/Insects Friendly
Grass fed/pasture raised
Vegetarian/Vegan
© Euromonitor International
5
26 markets with the focus on developed countries, 26 thousand brands across packaged food, soft drinks and hot drinks
DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
Americas USA Canada Brazil Mexico
Middle East and Africa Israel UAE
Asia & Australasia • Australia • China • Hong Kong • Indonesia • Japan • Philippines • Singapore • South Korea • Taiwan
Europe Belgium Denmark Finland France Germany Italy Netherlands Poland Spain Sweden UK
© Euromonitor International
6
The global bastions of a clean label surge to US$165 billion DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
Clean label sales, World, 2015, US$ billion UK artificial colours concern
Chinese food scandals
US GMO labelling debate
© Euromonitor International
7
The U.S. leads global clean label, 3 times the size of the UK DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
© Euromonitor International
8
Nutrition, marketing, ethics or something else? What is clean label?
DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
Clear Transparent Robust Relevant
Euromonitor Clean Label Types All Natural
No Artificial Additives
No Artificial Colours
No Artificial Preservatives
No Artificial Flavours
No Artificial Sweeteners
GMO Free
BPA Free
No Monosodium Glutamate
© Euromonitor International
9
No single origin of clean label DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
1960’s 1970’s 2007 2008 2015 Emergence of ‘Clean Label’
globally
Southampton Study (UK)
GMO labelling debate in USA
Key factors in the evolution of clean label
Consumer interest in clean label accelerated by advances in information technology. Clean label reformulation is not exclusively based on hard evidence, a debate about the inclusion of a specific ingredient may be more damaging than reformulating.
Fears over E-number safety Melamine Scandals in China
MSG linked to health effects Fears over aspartame
Horse meat scandal
© Euromonitor International
10
Manufacturers respond to consumer concerns DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
© Euromonitor International
11
Labelling reflects the commitments DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
© Euromonitor International
12
Which claim is most important from the consumer perspective? DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
No artificial colours, flavours
and preservatives
No artificial colours
or flavours Zero added preservatives
Add taste, nothing else
Nothing artificial,
no added refined sugar
No artificial preservatives, no added
MSG, free from artificial colours
Made with real fruit, no artificial colours,
preservatives or sweeteners
100% pure & raw Water, lime cucumber, BC
…and that’s it
No added sugar,
no additives
No artificial colours
or preservatives
100% natural
ingredients, skin & collagen
No artificial colours, flavours or preservatives
No added MSG
Vegetarian, vegan and coeliac friendly
Gluten and lactose free
Cold pressed (never heat)
100% natural ingredients – yes!
Say no to…
Added sugar
Added sweeteners
Added preservatives
Added water
© Euromonitor International
13
Are clean label claims becoming a norm on children’s labels? DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
FREE FROM artificial colours and preservatives
Source of Ca, essential proteins, vit D, fruit pure
100% naturally sourced ingredients,
Vit D & Ca for strong bones
100% naturally sourced ingredients,
Vit D & Ca for strong bones, no added preservatives
No added sugar or nasties,
proudly supports Brown Lee Foundation
Fruit and veg yoghurts bursting with goodness
A great natural source of calcium, source of vit D, naturally
sweetened with concentrated fruit juice
Freezable, great for lunchboxes, no artificial sweeteners,
no colourings, suitable for vegetarians, gluten free
Natural colours derived from fruit and vegetables,
no artificial flavours or preservatives
Raw fruit, crunchies & nut, 100% natural ingredients, no added sugar, wheat, dairy
& gluten free,
My ingredients: dates, soya protein crunchies (soya, tapioca starch, salt), cashews,
raisins, banana, apple juice concentrate
CLEAN LABEL – GLOBAL PERSPECTIVE
CLEAN LABEL LEADS THE WAY TO RE-ESTABLISHING TRUST
WHAT DOES THE FUTURE HOLD FOR CLEAN LABEL?
© Euromonitor International
15
The WORLD is CHANGING DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
© Euromonitor International
16
Response to the change with the movement towards SUSTAINABILITY and TRANSPARENCY on labels
DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
PEOPLE
PLANET PROFIT Transparency Sustainability
Clean Label: After years of focus on margin opportunities, large companies have begun
to accelerate their efforts to reformulate the ingredients in their legacy products
to better align with consumer trends and reaccelerate sales growth.
© Euromonitor International
17
HEALTHY
• BFY: reduced sugar, salt, fat • FF • Free from lactose, gluten
NUTRITIOUS & NATURAL
• Protein • Energy • Fibre, • Good oils • Good carbs • Natural hydration
HUMAN SUSTAINABILITY
• Optimising health • Natural • Free from artificial ingredients,
GMOs, antibiotics, hormones
BACK TO BASICS:
• Authentic • Religious labels • Protected origin • Single origin
SUSTAINABILE FOR FARMERS & PLANET:
• Support of local production • Support of 3rd World farmers
and suppliers • Plant-based food, especially
protein • Organic • Palm oil
Respect to values and beliefs: Era of re-established trust DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
MALNUTRITION * OBESITY * ALLERGIES & IMMUNITY * INTOLERANCES * DIGESTIVE PROBLEMS * MUSCLE & JOINT PROBLEMS * ANTIBIOTIC RESISTANCE * MENTAL HEALTH * SAFETY SCANDALS *
MISTRUST IN FOOD QUALITY * LIFE STAGE NUTRITION
© Euromonitor International
18
Clean label a tool to re-establish trust DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
US$128b Packaged Food
US$34b Soft Drinks
US$3b Hot Drinks
© Euromonitor International
19
Consumer demand for clean label: World versus the U.S. DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
© Euromonitor International
20
Driving clean labels by key region DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
No Artificial Preservatives in W.
Europe
No Artificial Flavours popular across the
board
In Asia Pacific GMO is most prevalent
© Euromonitor International
21
Clean label extremely fragmented, an opportunity to establish or re-establish trust in brand’s identity
DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
© Euromonitor International
23
Focus: Clean label crisps in the U.S. DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
© Euromonitor International
24
Focus: Clean label ready meals in the U.S. DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
© Euromonitor International
25
Clean label a new standard for dairy, juice and ready meals DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
© Euromonitor International
26
Packaging versus CSR commitments: Let’s not forget about sustainability, origin and religious concerns when sourcing clean label
DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
© Euromonitor International
27
Is full disclosure as important as clean label? DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
OR
CLEAN LABEL – GLOBAL PERSPECTIVE
CLEAN LABEL LEADS THE WAY TO RE-ESTABLISHING TRUST
WHAT DOES THE FUTURE HOLD FOR CLEAN LABEL?
© Euromonitor International
29
…but it doesn’t stop there. Fears over safety linger around. Increase transparency and/or move towards natural. Advantage of the first mover
DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
2015 2017 2020 and
beyond Future of ‘Clean
Label’
Southampton Study (Red and Yellow) GMO labelling debate in USA
Fears over E-number safety Melamine Scandals in China
MSG linked to health effects
Fears over aspartame Horse meat scandal
Artificial Enzymes
Fears over safety and health impact of hormones Antibiotics
No added sugar
HFCS
Lactose
Sodium
Fruit and veg – at least 1 serving Wholegrains
Milk from cows treated with rBST
Stevia and new ingredients
ALL NATURAL No added colours No added flavours
Future factors in the evolution of clean label
Others Number of countries ingredients come from
© Euromonitor International
30
Keeping up with the commitments. Don’t just “trim around the edges”, but think of the overall ingredient makeover
DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
Mars to remove all colours from its human food portfolio
Mars Inc
Kraft/Heinz
Kraft/Heinz reformulating core brands
© Euromonitor International
31
Clean sourcing Product
composition and taste
Packaging Branding MEET ETHICAL
VALUE and ESTABLISHING
TRUST
Make clean label the foundation of product planning…but find the right balance, keep it simple, do not overwhelm consumers
DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
CLEAN LABEL IMPACTS EACH STAGE OF PRODUCT STRATEGY.
© Euromonitor International
32
The future of clean label DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
© Euromonitor International
34
Ethical labels methodology DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
© Euromonitor International
35
Clean label defined by packaging claims DELIVERING ON THE CLEAN LABEL EXPECTATION - NAVIGATING THE CONSUMER MARKET
GMO free/Non-GMO: GMO (genetically modified) foods involve introducing foreign genetic material into an organism artificially, usually to – increase yield, increase resistance to disease, extend shelf life or improve food properties (texture, flavour, nutrient value). This category quantifies sales of products under our coverage with a GMO-Free/Non-GMO claim.
All Natural/100% Natural: These terms refer to the natural properties of the product. Both All Natural and 100% Natural are to be recognised as the same ethical label. This includes references to 'all natural anything'.
Artificial Additives: This category aggregates sales of products with a claim "no artificial additives” and “free from artificial additives“ on product packaging.
Artificial Flavourings: This category aggregates sales of products with a claim "no artificial flavours/flavourings” and “free from artificial flavours/flavourings” on product packaging.
Artificial Colours: This includes all products with a claim "no/free from artificial colours". Several artificial colours have been banned by food standards authorities after being linked to an increased number of cases of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and are thus avoided by certain consumers.
Artificial Sweeteners: This category captures aggregated sales of all products with the claim "no/free from artificial sweeteners“ on product packaging.
Artificial Preservatives: This includes all products with a claim "no/free from artificial preservatives and products with a claim "no/free from parabens". Parabens are a form of artificial preservative and when present in food usually come in the form of E numbers.
BPA Free: All products with a claim referring to "BPA free". BPA (bisphenol A) is an industrial chemical that is used to make certain plastics and resins. BPA is often used in containers that store food and beverages, such as water bottles.
Lacking a formal definition, Passport: Ethical Label bases its definition in the various claims found on product packaging that stress a shift away from complex artificial ingredients, toward familiar, natural
alternatives.