APPLIED FINANCE CENTREFaculty of Business and Economics
Geopolitics in asset allocationAl Clark, Nikko AMGlobal Head of Multi-Asset
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
Cent
ral B
ank
Bala
nce
Shee
ts in
LO
C(R
ebas
ed to
100
as
of J
ul 2
000)
ECB Fed BoE BoJ PBoC
3
The Changing Face of Developed Markets
Central bank intervention is at historical extremes
Source: Bloomberg, as at Oct 2016
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
China India Thailand PhilippinesRussia Turkey Malaysia IndonesiaBrazil Mexico South Africa
4
The Changing Face of Emerging Markets
Political capacity to manage macro risk is an increasingly important driver of performance
Source: Bloomberg, 2016
EM Equity Returns in USD
5
Macro Risk Increasing in EM
Structural shift in risk favors top-down approach to EM
EM Balanced Portfolio Risk Decomposition
* Rolling risk attribution of Portfolio comprised of 30% EM equities and 35% each to EM local currency and EM hard currency bonds. Source: Bloomberg, 2016
0%10%20%30%40%50%60%70%80%90%
100%
Feb-06 Feb-07 Feb-08 Feb-09 Feb-10 Feb-11 Feb-12 Feb-13 Feb-14 Feb-15
Ris
k A
lloca
tion
Equities Local Currency Bonds Hard Currency Bonds FX
Post-2008 Crisis40% Equity Risk
60% Bond/ Currency Risk
Pre-2008 Crisis70% Equity Risk
30% Bond/ Currency Risk
Multi-Asset investment process integrates political risk in to our decision making
6
Political Insights
Eurasia Group is a specialist political analysis firm based in NY with 60+ analysts covering over 100 different countries
Nikko Multi-Asset Eurasia Group
Eurasia research
Eurasia Group quantifies political risk to easily compare across countries
Political trajectories are a forward-looking assessment of business impact
Global Political Risk Index (GPRI) Political Trajectories
Incorporating Political Insights
Eurasia Group’s political analysis is embedded in Multi-Asset investment process
A Comprehensive Collaborative 4-Step Process: Multi-Asset Emerging Market Process
Research Portfolio Construction
Risk Management Implementation
Nikko AM makes use of research and analysis provided by Eurasia Group to manage this strategy. Eurasia Group is not responsible for the investment management and operation of this strategy .
ValuationMulti Asset Quant models at the country level
MomentumQuantitative assessment of momentum by asset class
Macro/PoliticalQualitative score on a macro and political analysis, combining Multi Asset and Eurasia research
Adjust Neutral portfolio to reflect asset class hierarchies from research
Stock SelectionQuality screens combined with equity analysts inputs
Downside riskLayered approach to protecting downside
Tier 1− Countries with market
cap above 2%− Min 70% Max 100%
Tier 2− Countries with market
cap below 2%− Min 0% Max 30%
Eurasia ScreenRemove countries with GPRI below 45 and negative trajectory
-20%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Exce
ss R
etur
n
9
Comparing Trajectories
Change in Political Trajectory• Poland leans populist• Hungary tries reforms• Eurasia Group trajectories are adjusted
Supported by other inputs• Earnings momentum confirms trajectory shift
Execution• Sold Poland and bought Hungary
Poland Political Risk downgrade
Hungary Political Risk upgrade
Equity Performance of Hungary over Poland
Geopolitical flashpoints increasing due to:• changing US
foreign policy• emergence of
new global leaders
Social instability increasing due to:• uneven
distribution of globalisation
• central banks overstepping their mark
11
Increasing Importance of Geopolitics
China:Reform v growth
North Korea:Nuclear tests
Sth China Sea Disputes
India:Modi regime
Japan:Abenomics
Indonesia:Jokowi regime
Russia:Ukraine conflict
UK:Brexit
Turkey:Failed Coup
Syria:ISIS
Iran: Saudi tensions
Saudi:Yemen conflict
South Africa:Zuma v Gordhan
Argentina:Macri backslide
Brazil:Rousseff
Impeachment
US:Trump
Europe:Refugee
crisis
Trump is the manifestation of two deep seated issues:
• Policy settings have created a huge gap in equality
• Globalisation has impacted low wage earners more profoundly
12
US
Source: Minack AdvisorsSource:MinackAdvisors
Europe
Europe gripped by the same deep distrust in political institutions as shown by Brexit
BrexitJune 2016
Spanish ElectionJune 2016
Italian ReferendumOctober 2016
French ElectionMay 2017
German Election
September 2017
• Population unexpectedly votes to leave the European Union –Prime Minister resigns
• At the second attempt, still political gridlock as no party (or group of parties ) can form a majority
• Referendum to reduce the powers of the Senate and allow easier passage of structural reform – Renzi will resign if it fails
• Rise of populist, anti-Euro parties amid the security turmoil of last few years
• Merkel’s approval has dived since the refugee crisis, with CDU faring poorly in state elections. AfD continues to rise
What will Europe look like in 12 months?
-3-2-101234
Sep-06
Feb-07
Jul-0
7
Dec-07
May-08
Oct-0
8
Mar-09
Aug-09
Jan-10
Jun-10
Nov-10
Apr-1
1
Sep-11
Feb-12
Jul-1
2
Dec-12
May-13
Oct-1
3
Mar-14
Aug-14
Jan-15
Jun-15
Nov-15
Apr-1
6Japa
n C
PI T
okyo
ex
Fres
h Fo
od (Y
oY %
)
14
Japan
Confidence in Abenomics is starting to wane
Are policy settings the solution or the problem?
Source: Bloomberg
70
90
110
130
600
1100
1600
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
USD/
JPY
TPXInde
x
TPX Index JPY Curncy
15
Eastern Europe
Russia:• Gaining political
capital through handling of Syria
• Pushing for preferred outcome of a ‘frozen ‘ conflict in Ukraine
Turkey:• Erdogan
challenging secular roots with post coup cleanse
• Value to Europe increasing through immigration solution
N - NATO country
16
Middle East
Iran:• re-emerging
following the nuclear deal, with sanctions lifted and billions in assets unfrozen
Saudi :• struggling with
US pivot out of Middle East, lost oil revenues and a royal succession
Source: Bloomberg, Tehran Stock Exchange
Saudi Equity Index
Iran Equity Index
50
60
70
80
90
100
110
120
Sep-11 Mar-12 Sep-12 Mar-13 Sep-13 Mar-14 Sep-14 Mar-15 Sep-15 Mar-16
17
LATAM
Latamcurrency adjustment has been considerable, allowing necessary internal rebalancing to progress
Source: Bloomberg
Latam Currency Index
18
ASIA
Asia is experiencing a political ‘renaissance’ with strong, popular leaders enacting meaningful structural reform
Source: SIPRI
USD, bn
ASIA
EU
US
Growth in Military Expenditure
Equity Market Ranking
19
Equity Hierarchy
Any references to particular markets are for illustrative purposes only and are as at the date of publication of this material. This is not a recommendation in relation to any markets and no warranty or guarantee is provided.
Asia
Japan
Latam
US
Germany
Europe
EMEA
UK
• Geopolitical risk is increasing in both developed and emerging economies
• Disaffected masses calling for a rewriting of the social contract with their governments
• Embedding a political risk factor in to asset allocation decisions reduces the probability of adverse investment outcomes
• Asia appears the most politically stable in our research• Europe faces the most immediate challenges
Summary
APPLIED FINANCE CENTRE