+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability...

Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability...

Date post: 19-Jul-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 0 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
57
Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability Assessments Workshop 8 – 9 December 2011 EPRI UMIST UK EPRI - UMIST - UK 1
Transcript
Page 1: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability Assessments

Workshop

8 – 9 December 2011EPRI UMIST UKEPRI - UMIST - UK

1

Page 2: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

EU Innovative electricity ytransmission grids :

A technology roadmap About T&D Europe

A technology roadmap

• EU Transmission grid vs. generation/consumption scenarios - T&D Europe view

• T&D Europe Initiatives• T&D Europe Initiatives

• Technology needs - Short term view

• New technologies - Long term viewNew technologies Long term view

• Conclusions

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 2

Page 3: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

About T&D Europe• T&D EUROPE is the European association of the electricity transmission

and distribution equipment and services industry.

• The companies represented by T&D Europe account for a productionworth over €25 billion, and employ over 200,000 people in Europe.

about 400 othermanufacturers+

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 3

Page 4: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

ObjectivesObjectives

• T&D Europe aims to promote and to defend the common interestsf th E l t i it t i i d di t ib tiof the European electricity transmission and distribution

manufacturing industry towards and in cooperation with the EUinstitutions

• T&D Europe works in collaboration with European andinternational standardisation bodies, in order to establish a

h t t f ld id t d d d t ticoherent system of worldwide standards and testing

• T&D Europe is committed to the supply of equipment, systemsand services for electrical networks that are reliable andsustainable for the efficient transport and delivery of energy

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 4

Page 5: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

T&D Europe and some of its partners & stakeholdersstakeholders

Politics and regulators, e.g.EU-Commission

Equipment Manufacturer, e.g.

** EU-Commission

EU-Parliament

EU-Council

DG EN & Transp.*

*

*

*

EU Technology Platform Smart Grids

Grid operators/

Business Europe

User organizations, e.g.

Belong to ORGALIME community

*ENTSO-E

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 5

Page 6: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Our intention with this meeting

• Accelerate emergence of a long term roadmap for pan-european transmission grid and electrical system largely based on renewable energy, including financing scheme.including financing scheme.

• Assess risks and opportunities of large scale sharing at pan-european level of renewable energy and storage resources.of renewable energy and storage resources.

• Identify major risks (locks) and launch relevant R&D action plan in various critical fields: technology (transmission, generation, storage), energy critical fields: technology (transmission, generation, storage), energy market management...

• To pioneer, in Europe, the first "Super Grid" electrical system, worldwide. To pioneer, in Europe, the first Super Grid electrical system, worldwide.

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 6

Page 7: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

EU Innovative electricity ytransmission grids :

A technology roadmap• About T&D Europe

A technology roadmap

EU Transmission grid vs. generation/consumption scenarios - T&D Europe view

• T&D Europe Initiatives• T&D Europe Initiatives

• Technology needs - Short term view

• New technologies - Long term viewNew technologies Long term view

• Conclusions

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 7

Page 8: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Global Warming issue & CO2 reductionG g CO2

• Kyoto targets for 2012

• EU targets (by 2020)– 20% CO2 emission reduction– 20% increase in energy efficiency– 20% renewable energy0% e ewable e e gy

• OCDE Target 205050% CO2 emission reduction

• EU Energy road-Map 205013 December 2011

• Durban Climate Submit– 4 – 9 December 2011

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 8

Page 9: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Temperature increase scenarios

CO2 concentration Rise in temperature (°C) Rise in sea level (cm)

450 ppm 0.6 °C 14 cm

750 ppm 2.2 °C 22 cm

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 9

Page 10: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Increase of renewables EU scenarii

EU GHG emissions towards an 80% domestic reduction (100% =1990)Under study – Source SRA2035 draft

Source: [IEA]

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 10

Page 11: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Increased generation capacityDecreased consumption ec eased co su pt o

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 11

Page 12: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Joint forces for climate-compatible energy technologies and efficiency increasetechnologies and efficiency increase

Transmission Distribution

Long distance bulk power(“Supergrid / Overlay Grid”)

“Load follows Generation Concept” & integration of storage

Large electricity trading volumes /Interconnection

Integration of decentralized Generation, Grid Monitoring

Grid Integrity & Blackout Prevention

Smart Metering & Demand Side Management

Smart Grids

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 12

Page 13: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

EU Innovative electricity ytransmission grids :

A technology roadmap• About T&D Europe

A technology roadmap

• EU Transmission grid vs. generation/consumption scenarios - T&D Europe view

T&D Europe Initiatives T&D Europe Initiatives

• Electra

• SRA 2035

• Grid+

• MoDPEHS 2050

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 13

Page 14: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

ELECTRA Report ObjectivesELECTRA Report Objectives

Promote jobs and an industry growth rate well above the traditional 4% per year

By focusing public policy and industry measures to: Promote technologies to achieve the 20% energy efficiency and CO₂ 

emission reduction  Enhance future technologies made in Europe, focusing on lead customer 

markets (infrastructures or technologies responding to societal needs) O h i l d h k Open the internal and the exports markets

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 14 14

Page 15: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

EU response in a profoundly difi d i d i l l dmodified economic and social landscape

• Crisis hit world economy just a few months after publication of y j pELECTA Report: EEI growth was -20% in 2009, +9.7% in 2010 and + 6.9% (forecast) in 2011

• Three EU sets of answers • Three EU sets of answers • Recovery Plan (some EU funds and an attempt to

coordinate national responses)• Focus on a renewed Industrial Policy (new TFUE article 173,

d fl h l d bEurope 2020 and flagship initiatives), completed by strategic documents on Energy, Internal Market, Trade Policy, KETs, green vehicles, etc...

• May 2009 Council Conclusions reference to Electra and May 009 Cou c l Co clus o s e e e ce to lect a a d October 2009 Commission Communication on Electra

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 15 15

Page 16: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Chapter 3: Future technology d i made in Europe

• Some examples:Some examples:– Energy infrastructures priorities– A Digital Agenda for Europe

PPPs on green cars factories of the future energy efficient – PPPs on green cars, factories of the future, energy efficient buildings within the recovery plan

– Communication on KETsf d d l– Competitiveness-proofing exercise proposed in Industrial

Policy flagship Initiative

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 16 16

Page 17: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Conclusions of Evaluation

• The implementation of the Electra recommendations has beenfairly extensive, and the process is on-going, despite the extremelybad economic conditions though which industry had to go in2008/2010.

• The following weaknesses can be noticed:– Partial implementation, at national level, of energy efficiency action

plans– Timidity of provisions included in the Energy Performance of Buildings

Directive (recast)– Slow rate of progress in the development of smart grid (regulatory

f k itti diti )framework, permitting conditions)– Lack of implementation of mechanisms on industrial restructuring,

using, for example, the EU structural funds

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 17 17

Page 18: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Update of the smart grid ETPStrategic Research Agenda towards 2035

• T&D Europe has been asked to designate experts for the five research areas p g pdefined for the update of the smart grids ETP Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035. The experts held a first meeting on 27 June.

• The research areas are:– Research Area 1 – Smart Distribution Infrastructure (Small Customers and

Network Design)– Research Area 2 – Smart Operation, Energy Flows and Customer Adaptation

(Small Customers and Networks) (Small Customers and Networks) – Research Area 3 – Smart Grid Assets and Asset Management (Transmission

and Distribution)– Research Area 4 – European Interoperability of Smart Grids (Transmission – Research Area 4 – European Interoperability of Smart Grids (Transmission

and Distribution)– Research Area 5 – Smart Grid Cross-Cutting Issues and Catalysts

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 18

Page 19: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Strategic Research Agenda 2035P bli i h d lPublication schedule

• Sept 2011: We - the SG ETP core team - intend to propose a Sept 2011: We the SG ETP core team intend to propose a new structure for the SRA2035 which will then be discussed and reviewed by the steering committee of the SG ETP.

• October 2011: You will have the opportunity to comment on • October 2011: You will have the opportunity to comment on the draft again through email. An open consultation may also be done as well (to be decided).

D b 2011 W i t h d ft SRA 2035 d t • December 2011: We aim to have a draft SRA 2035 document ready for wide circulation.

• 2012. We plan to present it in a general assembly event (exact dates and venue to be confirmed, but most likely February-March 2012).

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 19

Page 20: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Grid+Grid+

• Overarching goal: to implement the management, planning and Overarching goal: to implement the management, planning and networking of the EEGI over the years 2012-2014, which will enhance the delivery by the European network operators of the new knowledge needed to deploy smart grid solutions the most effective way possible in the EU

• Participants : RSE (Italy), ENTSO-E, EDSO for Smart Grids, Participants : RSE (Italy), ENTSO E, EDSO for Smart Grids, ZABALA (Spain), TECHNOFI (France), SINTEF (Norway), VITO (Belgium), Bacher Energie (Switzerland), Catholic University of Leuven (KUL) (Belgium), University Pontificia Comillas (Spain), T&D Europe

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 20

Page 21: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Grid+Grid+• Timing :

– Proposal accepted by EU Commission end June/Final negotiations on 29th June– Administrative tasks and contract signature in August/September (on-going)– Start on 1st October

• Governance• Governance– Project coordinator (RSE)

– Management Board (RSE, ENTSO-E, EDSO for smart grids): decision-making body

– Technical Board (all 11 participants)

– Advisory Board (representing the stakeholders, such as Commission and Member States, consumers, energy retailers, NGOs and the participants if they wish)

– Work Package leaders (for WG3: EDSO for smart grids) manage the WP and report to Project coordinatorreport to Project coordinator

– T&D Europe internal governance :Steering Committee supervising the Grid+ employee; its members are the four WG Chairs and the Secretary General

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 21

Page 22: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Grid+ : Six objectivesGrid+ : Six objectives

T th h d l t d d t ti ti iti• To map the research, development and demonstration activities• To foster a networking process between EEGI projects and engage

with other smart grid initiatives• To support the definition, validation, updating and use of KPIs• To support scaling up and replication activities • To prepare the means and tools in view of the dissemination of the To prepare the means and tools in view of the dissemination of the

new knowledge from the demonstrators• To provide three revisions of the EEGI implementation plan

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 22

Page 23: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Grid+ : Eight work packagesGrid+ : Eight work packages

• WP1: MAP (support)WP2 INTERACT• WP2: INTERACT

• WP3: MONITOR • WP4: REPLICATE• WP5: DISSEMINATE• WP6: UPDATE DSO• WP7: UPDATE TSO• WP7: UPDATE TSO• WP8: MANAGE (support)

T&D E i i l d ti ll ith WP3 d t WP1 • T&D Europe is involved essentially with WP3, and supports WP1 (data collection) and WG8 (participation in Technical Board)

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 23

Page 24: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Grid+ : WP3 - MONITORGrid+ : WP3 MONITOR

• Revise KPIs and approach (evaluate benefits and update existing KPIs)

• Compare different KPI approaches (T&D Europe)• Template for labelling (elaborate template for EEGI project p g ( p p j

labelling)• Validate proposals (pre screen proposals in view to EEI Team

labelling)• Assess progress (assess process progress according to KPIs)• Finance engineering (elaborate innovative financing

mechanisms)mechanisms)

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 24

Page 25: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

MoDPEHS 2050Study Roadmap towards Modular Development Plan on Pan European Study Roadmap towards Modular Development Plan on Pan-European

Electricity Highways System 2050

• ENTSO-E 2050 3-year Study Roadmap :• ENTSO E 2050 3 year Study Roadmap :– Identifies necessary work streams required for Electricity Highways roadmap to 2050– In alignment with EC Comm. on infrastructure priorities for 2020 and beyond (Nov. 2010)– Covers all relevant issues to develop a credible long-term strategic plan to 2050

• EU FP7 Call ENERGY .2012.7.2.1 on Electricity Highways– ENTSO-E officially applied for the Consortium of the MoDPEHS Study Programme– and invited T&D Europe to join and invited T&D Europe to join.

• T&D Europe on behalf of its memberswill gather/coordinate the input of those companies which have applied – will gather/coordinate the input of those companies which have applied individually

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 25

Page 26: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

MoDPEHS 2050Study Roadmap towards Modular Development Plan on Pan European

• T&D Europe contribution :

Study Roadmap towards Modular Development Plan on Pan-European Electricity Highways System 2050

– WP1: Boundary Conditions,

– WP2: Scenarios,

– WP3: Technology Assessment,

WP4 I l t ti & O ti – WP4: Implementation & Operation,

– WP5: EHS Governance,

– WP6: Socio-economic Profitability,

WP7 St k h ld I l t – WP7: Stakeholder Involvement,

– WP8: MoDPEHS – The Plan,

– WP9: Dissemination. See further details in the Study Roadmap.

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 15/12/2011WG1 26

Page 27: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

EU Innovative electricity ytransmission grids :

A technology roadmap• About T&D Europe

A technology roadmap

• EU Transmission grid vs. generation/consumption scenarios - T&D Europe view

• T&D Europe Initiatives• T&D Europe Initiatives

Technology needs - Short term view

• New technologies - Long term viewNew technologies Long term view

• Conclusions

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 27

Page 28: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Technology needs - Short term view

Vision :10 development demonstration projects for consortium T&D members in 2012 and launch in 2013

•Examples : 2 HVDC l d• 2 HVDC on land

• HVDC/wind farm off shore, • 2 cable and substation technology, • 10 high voltage substations in cities • 10 high voltage substations in cities, • 5 next generation low loss efficiency products,• 3 storage projects

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 28

Page 29: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Technology needs - Short term viewT h l i d f d t ti 2013Technologies ready for demonstration <2013

•NCITs for AC and DC application •Digital substations (digital communication between NCITs, protection system, switchgear) y , g )•UHV (up to 1100kV) DC transmission based on LCC (line commutated) •HV DC transmission based on VSC technology (voltage source) AC Fa lt c rrent limiters •AC Fault current limiters

•UHV AC (up to 1200kV) •WAMS

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 29

Page 30: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Solution: Renewable integration HVDC

Keywords:Scope of supply:

•German HVDC offshore platforms (i.e. Borvin)

•DC voltage: 150 kV

Offshore DC grid connection systemCountry: GermanyYear: 2009

•Transmission capacity: 400 MW

•DC marine cable length = 125 km

•DC land cable = 75 km

•Weight: 4’800 tons

•380 kV AC onshore connection to German grid

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 30

Page 31: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Solution: Renewable integration HVAC

Keywords: Scope of supply:

Off h i d k i l t k ti•German AC offshore platform

•Generation capacity: 12x5 MW = 60 MW

Offshore wind park incl. network connectionCountry: GermanyYear: 2010

MW

•AC marine cable connection

•Cable length = 45 km

•Water depth about 40 m

•110 kV connection to German network

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 31

Page 32: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Solution: Compact underground substation

Country:USAClient: City of Anaheim CA

p g

Client: City of Anaheim CAScope: 8 x bays GIS type 8DN8 / 69 kV 2 x 132/11 kV 50 MVA transformers 20 x 12 kV panels

The substation is located under an existing park,in an exclusive residential area in Los Angeles, CA.

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 32

Page 33: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Solution : Gas Insulated Lines

Issue :•Substitution of a 400kV overhead line adjacent to a new runway

f th F kf t Ai tof the Frankfurt Airport •Transmission of 2x1800MVA continuous power (length 1km)•Long lifetime, no impact to the environment Solution :•Installation of a directly buried Gas Insulated Line (GIL)•Special backfill material surround GIL tubes to enhance power rating•GIL have passive/active corrosion protection, low EMFGIL have passive/active corrosion protection, low EMF radiation

• 400kV GIL installed directly buried• Power transmission is per system twice as high compared to a conventional cable solution• Electromagnetic field radiation (EMF) is negligible• Electromagnetic field radiation (EMF) is negligible • High overload capability• No external impact in case of internal failure (no explosion, no risk of fire)• Can be operated like an overhead line (auto-reclose functionality)

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011Page 33

Page 34: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Solution: Renewable integration in MV

Keywords:

• 43MWp - 600 000 Solar panels

g

43MWp 600 000 Solar panels.

• 3 No. 30kV Grid Substations.

• 36 No. inverter stations including 500kW

Scope of supply:

Solar farm Cellino San Marco Country: Italy - Puglia Year: 2010 inverters and 36kV switchboards.

• 1 300km of solar cables, 30km of trenches, 8.5km of fence.

Year: 2010

• 426 units array boxes.

• Monitoring system, security system (access control cameras lighting IR)control, cameras, lighting, IR).

• Performance Ratio Commitment.

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 34

Page 35: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Solution: MV Distribution EnergyManagement System

Keywords:•Smart City Malaga (ENDESA).

Management System

Scope of supply: y g ( )•Platform test for Smart Grid technologies.•80 MV/LV Transformer Substations and12,000 Customers.

p pp y

Smart City MalagaCountry: SpainYear: 2009-2012

•Advanced Meter Management (AMM).•MV/LV Transformer Substation Automation.•MV PLC and WiMax Communications.•Distributed Generation.•MV Electric Network Storage.•Electric Vehicle.•Power Flow Control.•Control Center (Showroom).

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 35

Page 36: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

EU Innovative electricity ytransmission grids :

A technology roadmap• About T&D Europe

A technology roadmap

• EU Transmission grid vs. generation/consumption scenarios - T&D Europe view

• T&D Europe Initiatives• T&D Europe Initiatives

• Technology needs - Short term view

New technologies - Long term viewNew technologies Long term view

• Conclusions

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 36

Page 37: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Technology needs - Long term view

Vision:• Triple interconnection capability• Develop a super grid (a “E HV1” from Milano to Amsterdam)

• Use state of art HV• 800 kV, HVDC, FACTS, phase shifters, DC breakers.• All these solutions are developed in Europe• All these solutions are developed in Europe

Means: Complement current 400 kV grid with additional overlay grid HVDC or AC.

Possible use of 800 KV AC voltages also needs to be considered.

Meshed grid/networks will require the use of DC circuit breakers with highpower breaking capacity.

Hybrid transmission consisting of HVAC 400KV and HVDC overlay network willrequire state of the art operation patterns.

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 37

Page 38: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Technology needs - Long term viewVision:

• Triple interconnection capability• Develop a super grid (a “E HV1” from Milano to Amsterdam)

Means:

Interoperability of converter stations from different suppliers

M t d it i f id i t t t ith l ti Management and monitoring of wide interstate areas with relativecontrol systems will be required

Address the potential problematic operations of managing such hybridtransmission systems having the contribution of many volatile sourcestransmission systems, having the contribution of many volatile sources.

Reliability of supply in the different phases of operations, with volatilesources, will have to be tested and supported by proper regulations.

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 38

Page 39: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Technology needs - Long term viewL t i (10 )

Some examples :

Long term view (10+ years)

Some examples :•HV DC breakers •Meshed HV DC grids •Hybrid AC-DC grids •Off-shore DC grids •Large scale control systems •Large scale control systems, integrating flexible generation and storage resources resources

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 39

Page 40: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

System Security, Observability and Blackout PreventionBlackout Prevention

Monitoring Met. ValuesMet. ValuesFault RecordsResults

Operator InformationResults

Operator Instructions

SIGUARD®-WAPC

Monitoring Results

IAP

WAMSFault Protocols WAPCS

InterpreterExpert System

Counter MeasuresExpert System

pOperator-Training

Adaptive Settings Expert System

Analyzing State EstimationShort-Circuit

LoadflowContingency

Fault location,Analysis &

Information System(SIMEAS-SAFIR)

Dynamic Security Assessment

Protection Security

Assessment

Phasor Data Concentrator and

Processor

European Patent: 06775872.2 / 2052451

Sta

te

Existing Components

New WAMS Components

rote

ctio

n D

ata

nam

ic D

ata

M iMetered Values

of

IEEE C37.118, 2006

Metered Valuesof

Metered Valuesof

Evaluation locally

Swit

chin

g Pr

Dyn

System Forecasts

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011

Measuring

1-5sec20ms-200ms1-10msSignal-Transmission Steps

ofTransducers

ofPMUs

ofRelays / Recorders

Page 41: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

EU Innovative electricity ytransmission grids :

A technology roadmap• About T&D Europe

A technology roadmap

• EU Transmission grid vs. generation/consumption scenarios - T&D Europe view

• T&D Europe Initiatives• T&D Europe Initiatives

• Technology needs - Short term view

• New technologies - Long term viewNew technologies Long term view

Conclusions

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 41

Page 42: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Conclusions

CO2 ReductionEfficiency

Direct effect (lower losses)

RenewablesSteady-state quality

( )

Indirect effect (parameters, bottlenecks)

Indirect effect (more efficiency)

T&D Manufacturers• Ready to provide State of art

Dynamic quality in

q y

Harmonic quality

Dynamic quality in distribution

• Ready to provide State of art technologies

• For Innovative electricity transmission grids Dynamic quality in

transmissiondistributiong

• With a prospective viewEg. : KPI’s for Replacement / refurbishment

of Power Components

T&D Europe meets DG ENER, Brussels, July 19, 2011 42

Page 43: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Smart GridSmart Grid Technologies/Components

Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk SystemImpact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability Assessments Workshop

8 9 December 20118 – 9 December 2011EPRI - UMIST - UK

J-Luc Bessède

Page 44: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Schneider position: 5 key Smart Grid domains… with a key position to optimize Supply and Demandwith a key position to optimize Supply and Demand

Utility network Consumers

Transmission Distribution ResidentialEfficient Home

Centralised Generation

Demand-response

Commercial

ResidentialEfficient homes

(incl. EV charging infrastructure)+

Commercial & Industrial Efficient Enterprise

Industry

Buildings

Flexible distribution + +Optimized

Supply & Demand

Data Centres

Infrastructure

Efficient Enterprise(incl. EV charging infrastructure)

+

Schneider Electric2

Renewable Energy Plants Distributed Generation

Smart Generation(bulk, distributed & renewable)

Page 45: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

SE scope: 5 key domains,all connected...

Centralised Generation

Transmission Distribution

ResidentialEfficient homes

FlexibleDistribution

( / / / )

Industry

Efficient homes (incl. EV charging infrastructure)

Demand Sidemanagement

(HV/MV, MV/MV, MV/LV)

Buildings

Data Centres

Electric Vehicles & Energy Storage

Smart GenerationEfficient Enterprise

(buildings, industries & datacenters

Infrastructure

Renewable Energy Plants Distributed GenerationDistributed Generation

(bulk, distributed & renewable)(buildings, industries & datacenters

+ EV charging infrastructure)

Schneider Electric 3- Company Overview

gy Distributed Generationst buted Ge e at o

Page 46: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Utilities Segment Solutions Focus - 3 Domains

Transmission Distribution

Centralized Generation

Flexible

I d t

Residential

Demand Side

Distribution(HV/MV, MV/MV, MV/LV) Efficient homes

(incl. EV charging infrastructure)

Industry

Buildings

Electric Vehicles

Demand Sidemanagement

Data Centres

Infrastructure

& Energy StorageSmart Generation

(bulk, distributed & renewable)

Efficient Enterprise(buildings, industries & datacenters

+ EV charging infrastructure)

Schneider Electric4

Renewable Energy Plants Distributed GenerationDistributed Generation

Page 47: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked
Page 48: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Flexible distribution offer

Distribution Automation: SCADA/ DMS/ OMS/ GISHV/MV Substation AutomationFA - Distribution AutomationUnderground / Aerial DistributionSmarter

AutomationAdvanced services

Renewable IntegrationSolutions for Wind and Solar Farms

gAutomation services

MV Primary cubicles Prefabricated MV/LV cubiclesfor secondary substation

MV ring main units MV Pole Mounted Reclosers

Schneider Electric6

Page 49: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Improving efficiency with MV/LV Substations

Solution offer

●Services: License contracts, dedicated support team

●Substations: Walk-in, non walk-in and half-buried with external operation undergroundburied – with external operation, underground kiosk

●Safety for public and operators●Cost savings: factory assembled and type tested ● 80 substations in Brazil –

Light & Celesc

Main references

● Time savings: plug and play solution ● Faster time-to-market: immediate availability

● 400 substations in Tatarstan, Russia with TATEK

● 200 substations in Iran with Tabesh Tablou

● 500 substations in India

Schneider Electric 7- Utility Solutions – Global Sales

Sudhir Gensets Ltd●Adaptation to meet local needs●References, customer proximity

Page 50: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Controlling the network through Distribution Automation SystemsAutomation Systems

Solution offer

●Network Management and Planning●Up-to-date information flow●Assistance for complex switching operations● Links with customer information services

Key benefits

● Improve reliability and quality of service● Lower operational and maintenance costs●Defer capital expenditures through

M i f step- by-step and easy implementationMain references● Unión Eléctrica – CUBA – SCADA / DMS● Régie Electrique de Tignes – FRANCE● Service de l’Electricité de Lausanne –

SWITZERLAND – SCADA / DMS Fl ibl & l bl hit t

Schneider Electric 8- Utility Solutions – Global Sales

SWITZERLAND SCADA / DMS ● Flexible & scalable architecture● Integrated distribution mgt functions

Page 51: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Distribution: Feeder automation

Customer benefits● Increased quality of service and

automation

network reliability● Operation and capital costs

reduction● Easier implementation than Scada

projectproject

Main references:● Brazil

7000 Reclosers/LBS/RM6 & 200 substations7000 Reclosers/LBS/RM6 & 200 substations● North Delhi Power Limited - INDIA

(2009)● Radema utility in Marrakech –

Morocco (2007)Automation of 40 substations

● Flexible & scalable architecture● Integrated distribution mgt functionsAutomation of 40 substations

● Utility in Irbid - JORDANIAAutomation of Fault Detectors

● Integrated distribution mgt functions

Schneider Electric 9- Utility Solutions – Global Sales

Page 52: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Multi-sites substation automation

Solution offer: IEC 61850

EHV & HVML/LV

HV & MV

Key benefits

●Provides scalable solution from single RTU to large sites●Allows for single or redundant searches all over the architecture●Smooth Integration and testing, with custom engineering tools

Schneider Electric 10- Utility Solutions – Global Sales

Smooth Integration and testing, with custom engineering tools●Communication backbone open to 3rd party components

Page 53: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Distribution: Power quality and metering

Solution offer● Equipments

and metering

● Equipments● Power Quality and Energy Metering (ION Meters)● Power Metering (PM800)

● Power management software (ION-E, EEM)● Services: Commissioning Customized report● Services: Commissioning, Customized report

HMI, Consulting● Global communication system

Customer Benefit● Quickly identify the cause of Power Quality events● Increase revenue (guaranty power quality to

customers)Sh li t P Q lit t d d

Main ReferencesJ k ill El t i A th it USA● Show compliance to Power Quality standards

● Lower operations costs with automated and accurate billing data acquisition

● Jacksonville Electric Authority - USADivide by 50 the Power Quality report analysis time

● NEPCO Utility (Jordan)Shared energy transaction management

● EPM Utility - Colombia

Schneider Electric 11- Utility Solutions – Global Sales

Real time energy data and remote control● China Light and Power Utility - HONG KONG (2008)

Page 54: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Connecting to the transmission grid

Solution offer

●Substation Automation and Protection Systems ●Multi-sites automation with IEC 61850●Services: Design, engineering, installation,

maintenance

Key benefits●Complete project management● Increased continuity of service●People and installation safety●Simple and reliable operation

Main references

● Over 700 substations automation, including supervisory, control, protection and metering s stems in Bra il India

● Standardized turn-key substation offer

Schneider Electric 12- Utility Solutions – Global Sales

and metering systems in Brazil, India, Turkey, Indonesia, USA, etc.

y● Short development time and low maintenance ● Flexible architectures

Page 55: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Flexible distribution referencesHV/MV substation control (Germany)

Digital control system for utility 110kV /20 kV primary substation

Northern Ireland Windfarm (UK)

A turnkey contract for a complete windfarm system grid connection

MV Feeder automation (S. Arabia)

Monitoring and control of 650 MV/LV utility substations

Energy Efficiency: Availability: Integration of renewables

The 30 MW Thanet Offshore windfarm

Energy Efficiency: Availability: Productivity

MV feeder automation system that enables

Energy Efficiency: Availability: Productivity

Distributed Protection & Control System fully compliant with IEC 61850 standard providing

SEPAM 20, 40, 60, 80Global supervision• PACiS and Network Control Center

saves 2,800 tons of CO2. The Pacis solution provides up to 30% more generation export to the grid

Global supervision• PACiS OI

Global supervision• Vijeo Citect

MV feeder automation system that enables fast fault restoration, remote monitoring of asset condition, network loading and power quality in strategic points in the network

compliant with IEC 61850 standard providing high level of availability and energy efficiency using full remote operation & supervision within turnkey project

Power management• Protection & Control of 110/20 kV s/s• Digital circuit breaker failure

protection and interlocking system • High availability remote control via

Power management• Metering• Local MV & HV protection & control• Renewables energy management• Micom relay with Dynamic Line

Power management• MV current and voltage sensors• Easegy T200 remote terminal unit• ION 6200 meter• RM6 motorised MV switchgear • High availability remote control via

redundant SCADA links • Cyber Security Gateway

Services• Project management• Design & engineering

Services

co e ay t y a c eRating functionality

• System design • Project management• Software configuration

g• Easergy Flite fault indicators• GPRS communication system

• System design • Project management• System installation

Services

Schneider Electric13

Design & engineering• Setting & configuration• Installation, Tests & Commissioning• Training • Remote maintenance service contract

• Software configuration• System installation• Tests & Commissioning• Training

System installation • Software configuration • Testing & Commissioning• Training

Page 56: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Some considerations on System ReliabilityTargetFocus on phase 3 of SG deploymentEnable gradual integration of ICTs into electric networks

Key issues

Enable gradual integration of ICTs into electric networks

●Cyber-security− availability, integrity, confidentiality

y

●Interoperability of information systems−IEC 61850 compliant components…

●Information system architecturey−Centralised/distributed ICT architecture

●Communication system failures−Electrical/Information networks

Schneider Electric 14- Utility Solutions – Global Sales

Electrical/Information networks interdependency & failure modes

Page 57: Impact of the Smart Grid on Bulk System Reliability ...mydocs.epri.com/docs/publicmeetingmaterials/1112...Strategic Research Agenda towards 2035 o r u ED•T& ppgpe has been asked

Make the most of your energy


Recommended