+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Parliamentary Intelligence

Parliamentary Intelligence

Date post: 30-Dec-2016
Category:
Upload: vonhi
View: 213 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
2
405 the course of an operation on a patient suffering from influenza ; it was frequently seen during the influenza epidemic among the troops in France in 1918. I have been surprised to find how long ago this condition was recognised ; and perhaps the reference I have found is not by any means the earliest recorded. Lieutaud in his Historia Anatomico Medica (Vol. II., p. 329, Paris, 1767) quotes the case of a man, aged 30, who was seized with epidemic fever and died on the eighth day. Both recti abdominis were found ruptured. The appearances resembled those of rupture of the sterno-mastoid muscle seen in death by judicial haDcmo- Tam. Sir. vrmrs faithfullv. Clifton, Bristol, Feb. 10th, 1922. J. A. NIXON. GERMAN X RAY APPARATUS. To the Editor of THE LANCET. SIR,-A brief study of the contributions which have recently appeared in your pages discloses the unpleasant fact that the medical profession are already patronising German ’manufacturers by purchasing X ray and electro-medical apparatus of German origin, in particular equipments for deep therapy treatment. As equally good, if not superior, apparatus is manu- factured in this country, there is no excuse for purchasing these appliances from our late enemies. There are nearly 2,000,000 unemployed in this country, and it is therefore everyone’s duty to assist in stimu- 1ating home industries rather than those of Germany ; we wonder whether those who place their orders abroad appreciate the inevitable result of their action. If adequate support is not forthcoming for the British manufacturer, he obviously cannot continue, and will gradually cease, to construct British X ray and electro-medical apparatus, and seek the easier and possibly more remunerative path of representing .a foreign house and so satisfy the demands of the English medical profession. I am. Sir. vours faithfullv. A MANUFACTURER OF BRITISH APPARATUS. London, Feb. 14th, 1922. Parliamentary Intelligence. HOUSE OF COMMONS. TUESDAY, FEB. 14TH. Removal of the Sheli7eerd’s B1’8h Orthopaedie Hospital. Sir MATTHEW V’iLSOV asked the Minister of Pensions whether the hospital at Shepherd’s Bush, which has been specially equipped for orthopaedic surgical treatment, was to be transferred to the South African Hutment Hospital at Richmond ; and, if so, why.-Mr. MACPHERSON replied : The answer is in the affirmative. I received urgent represen- tations from the guardians of the parish of Hammersmith to the effect that the administration of relief in the parish was seriously hampered by my continued occupation of this - institution, which was formerly the workhouse and infirmary of the parish, and the guardians were only willing to assent to an extension of the tenancy of the building by my depart- ment in return for a very greatly increased rental, for which, dn my opinion, there was no justification. The opportunity having presented itself of acquiring equally suitable premises at the Richmond Hill Hospital from the Army Council free of rent, I found it possible to vacate the institution at Shepherd’s Bush, and in all the circumstances I deemed it advisable to do so. In answer to a later question, Mr. MACPHERSON stated that while the medical staff would naturally prefer to remain in - a building associated with so unique a standard of surgical efficiency, the question of removal did not resolve itself into .a purely medical one. He had no doubt that the trans- ference of the staff and the equipment to Richmond would be in no way detrimental to the interests of the patients. He understood that the estimate of the cost of removal and adaptation was not likely to exceed one half year’s rent that would have to be paid at Shepherd’s Bush. There was no lease of the Richmond Park Hospital, but a two years tenancy, rent free, was offered. [In reply to a further question, Major TRYON stated that the equipment, provided at a cost of £16,000 by the Red Cross, would be moved from the present institution and .installed elsewhere for the continued treatment of pensioners. ] Child Adoption. Mr. NEVILLE CHAMBERLAIN asked the Secretary for the Home Department whether he had considered the recom- mendations of the Departmental Committee on Child Adop- tion, presided over by Sir Alfred Hopkinson, K.C. ; and whether he proposed to introduce any legislation upon the subject in the course of the present session.-Mr. SHORTT replied : I hope a Bill may be introduced to give effect to the Committee’s recommendation as to the legitimation of children by the subsequent marriage of their parents ; but there appear to be very great difficulties in the way of carrying out the proposal for the legalisation of adoption. Lunatic Asylum Administration. Mr. ALFRED SHORT asked the Minister of Health whether, in view of the fact that the committee appointed to consider the administration of the lunatic asylums was predominantly representative of medical superintendents, the inefficiency of whose administration was the question to be inquired into, he would favourably consider strengthening the committee by the addition of representatives of the general public and of the Asylum Workers’ Union.-Sir A. MOND replied : The hon. Member is under a misapprehension. The committee in question is appointed to consider charges made by Dr. Lomax and not the general question of asylum administra- tion. Neither of the medical members of the committee has ever been associated with an asylum provided by a local authority. It would merely prolong the inquiry to add persons with no previous experience of asylum administration, and as regards the Asylum Workers’ Union, while I regret their refusal to give evidence, I am unable to regard this as a reason for appointing to the committee a representative of a class directly incriminated by Dr. Lomax’s charges. Food and Milk for Evpectant Mothers. Lieut.-Col. ASSHETON POWNALL asked the Minister of Health whether he had yet come to a decision as to the policy to be pursued during the next financial year with reference to the supply by local authorities of food and milk to expectant and nursing mothers and young children, which was the subject of Circular 267 issued by his department in December last.-Sir A. MOND replied: The circular in question was in part the outcome of my desire to carry on the policy adopted by my predecessor of reducing the expenditure on the supply of milk to expectant and nursing mothers and young children which he found to be excessive. The circular also embodied medical advice as to the value of supplying meals instead of milk, which I received from my medical advisers and from outside persons of great authority. I have now received replies from most of the local authorities which are generally to the effect that they prefer to continue the supply of milk in view of the difficulty of arranging for the general supply of meals. I therefore propose to continue during the next financial year the arrangements at present in force for the supply of milk under proper safe- guards against abuse, allowing local authorities to substitute meals for milk where they desire and are able to do so. Trained Nurses and Unemployment. Major BOYD-CARPENTER asked the Minister of Labour how many fully trained nurses for the sick, holding a three years’ certificate of training, had registered at a labour exchange for unemployment benefit.-Dr. MACNAMARA replied : On Jan. 10th there were 701 women nurses on the Live Register as unemployed, but without inquiry at every exchange concerned it is not possible to say whether they held a three years’ certificate or whether they were claiming benefit. Nurses and Hospitals and Unemployment Contributions. Colonel BURN asked the Minister of Labour if he would consider the advisability of relieving hospitals and the nursing staff from the application of the unemployment insurance contribution which entailed a considerable financial burden on hospitals, and prevented nurses from giving their services by reason of the large proportion of wages which had to be paid in respect of that tax. Major BOYD-CARPENTER asked the Minister of Labour if nurses employed in private nursing homes or associations were compelled to contribute to insurance funds and were not eligible for unemployed benefit when waiting for a case.- Dr. MACNAMARA replied : Nurses employed in hospitals or in private nursing homes or associations are liable to pay contributions under the Unemployment Insurance Acts, and I have no power to exclude them from the scope of insurance. The question whether benefit would be payable in any particular case would depend on the facts of that case, and would fall to be decided by the insurance officer with a right of appeal to the Court of Referees and the Umpire. Life Pensioners and Medical Boards. Mr. HOGGE asked the Minister of Pensions why it was possible for the Ministry to call a pensioner awarded a life pension before an examining board at any time, while the
Transcript

405

the course of an operation on a patient suffering frominfluenza ; it was frequently seen during the influenzaepidemic among the troops in France in 1918.

I have been surprised to find how long ago thiscondition was recognised ; and perhaps the referenceI have found is not by any means the earliest recorded.Lieutaud in his Historia Anatomico Medica (Vol. II.,p. 329, Paris, 1767) quotes the case of a man, aged 30,who was seized with epidemic fever and died onthe eighth day. Both recti abdominis were found

ruptured. The appearances resembled those of ruptureof the sterno-mastoid muscle seen in death by judicialhaDcmo- Tam. Sir. vrmrs faithfullv.

Clifton, Bristol, Feb. 10th, 1922. J. A. NIXON.

GERMAN X RAY APPARATUS.

To the Editor of THE LANCET.

SIR,-A brief study of the contributions whichhave recently appeared in your pages discloses theunpleasant fact that the medical profession are alreadypatronising German ’manufacturers by purchasingX ray and electro-medical apparatus of Germanorigin, in particular equipments for deep therapytreatment.As equally good, if not superior, apparatus is manu-

factured in this country, there is no excuse forpurchasing these appliances from our late enemies.There are nearly 2,000,000 unemployed in this country,and it is therefore everyone’s duty to assist in stimu-1ating home industries rather than those of Germany ;we wonder whether those who place their ordersabroad appreciate the inevitable result of their action.

If adequate support is not forthcoming for theBritish manufacturer, he obviously cannot continue,and will gradually cease, to construct British X rayand electro-medical apparatus, and seek the easierand possibly more remunerative path of representing.a foreign house and so satisfy the demands of theEnglish medical profession.

I am. Sir. vours faithfullv.A MANUFACTURER OF BRITISH APPARATUS.

London, Feb. 14th, 1922.

Parliamentary Intelligence.HOUSE OF COMMONS.

TUESDAY, FEB. 14TH.Removal of the Sheli7eerd’s B1’8h Orthopaedie Hospital.

Sir MATTHEW V’iLSOV asked the Minister of Pensionswhether the hospital at Shepherd’s Bush, which has beenspecially equipped for orthopaedic surgical treatment, was tobe transferred to the South African Hutment Hospital atRichmond ; and, if so, why.-Mr. MACPHERSON replied :The answer is in the affirmative. I received urgent represen-tations from the guardians of the parish of Hammersmith tothe effect that the administration of relief in the parish wasseriously hampered by my continued occupation of this- institution, which was formerly the workhouse and infirmaryof the parish, and the guardians were only willing to assentto an extension of the tenancy of the building by my depart-ment in return for a very greatly increased rental, for which,dn my opinion, there was no justification. The opportunityhaving presented itself of acquiring equally suitable premisesat the Richmond Hill Hospital from the Army Council freeof rent, I found it possible to vacate the institution atShepherd’s Bush, and in all the circumstances I deemed itadvisable to do so.

In answer to a later question, Mr. MACPHERSON stated thatwhile the medical staff would naturally prefer to remain in- a building associated with so unique a standard of surgicalefficiency, the question of removal did not resolve itself into.a purely medical one. He had no doubt that the trans-ference of the staff and the equipment to Richmond wouldbe in no way detrimental to the interests of the patients.He understood that the estimate of the cost of removal andadaptation was not likely to exceed one half year’s rent thatwould have to be paid at Shepherd’s Bush. There was nolease of the Richmond Park Hospital, but a two yearstenancy, rent free, was offered.

[In reply to a further question, Major TRYON stated thatthe equipment, provided at a cost of £16,000 by the RedCross, would be moved from the present institution and.installed elsewhere for the continued treatment of pensioners. ]

Child Adoption.Mr. NEVILLE CHAMBERLAIN asked the Secretary for the

Home Department whether he had considered the recom-mendations of the Departmental Committee on Child Adop-tion, presided over by Sir Alfred Hopkinson, K.C. ; andwhether he proposed to introduce any legislation upon thesubject in the course of the present session.-Mr. SHORTTreplied : I hope a Bill may be introduced to give effect tothe Committee’s recommendation as to the legitimation ofchildren by the subsequent marriage of their parents ; butthere appear to be very great difficulties in the way ofcarrying out the proposal for the legalisation of adoption.

Lunatic Asylum Administration.Mr. ALFRED SHORT asked the Minister of Health whether,

in view of the fact that the committee appointed to considerthe administration of the lunatic asylums was predominantlyrepresentative of medical superintendents, the inefficiencyof whose administration was the question to be inquired into,he would favourably consider strengthening the committeeby the addition of representatives of the general public andof the Asylum Workers’ Union.-Sir A. MOND replied : Thehon. Member is under a misapprehension. The committeein question is appointed to consider charges made by Dr.Lomax and not the general question of asylum administra-tion. Neither of the medical members of the committee hasever been associated with an asylum provided by a localauthority. It would merely prolong the inquiry to addpersons with no previous experience of asylum administration,and as regards the Asylum Workers’ Union, while I regrettheir refusal to give evidence, I am unable to regard this asa reason for appointing to the committee a representative ofa class directly incriminated by Dr. Lomax’s charges.

Food and Milk for Evpectant Mothers.Lieut.-Col. ASSHETON POWNALL asked the Minister of

Health whether he had yet come to a decision as to the policyto be pursued during the next financial year with referenceto the supply by local authorities of food and milk toexpectant and nursing mothers and young children, whichwas the subject of Circular 267 issued by his department inDecember last.-Sir A. MOND replied: The circular inquestion was in part the outcome of my desire to carry onthe policy adopted by my predecessor of reducing theexpenditure on the supply of milk to expectant and nursingmothers and young children which he found to be excessive.The circular also embodied medical advice as to the value ofsupplying meals instead of milk, which I received from mymedical advisers and from outside persons of great authority.I have now received replies from most of the local authoritieswhich are generally to the effect that they prefer to continuethe supply of milk in view of the difficulty of arranging forthe general supply of meals. I therefore propose tocontinue during the next financial year the arrangements atpresent in force for the supply of milk under proper safe-guards against abuse, allowing local authorities to substitutemeals for milk where they desire and are able to do so.

Trained Nurses and Unemployment.Major BOYD-CARPENTER asked the Minister of Labour

how many fully trained nurses for the sick, holding a threeyears’ certificate of training, had registered at a labourexchange for unemployment benefit.-Dr. MACNAMARAreplied : On Jan. 10th there were 701 women nurses on theLive Register as unemployed, but without inquiry at everyexchange concerned it is not possible to say whether theyheld a three years’ certificate or whether they were claimingbenefit.

Nurses and Hospitals and Unemployment Contributions.Colonel BURN asked the Minister of Labour if he would

consider the advisability of relieving hospitals and thenursing staff from the application of the unemploymentinsurance contribution which entailed a considerablefinancial burden on hospitals, and prevented nurses from

giving their services by reason of the large proportion ofwages which had to be paid in respect of that tax. MajorBOYD-CARPENTER asked the Minister of Labour if nurses

employed in private nursing homes or associations werecompelled to contribute to insurance funds and were noteligible for unemployed benefit when waiting for a case.-Dr. MACNAMARA replied : Nurses employed in hospitals or inprivate nursing homes or associations are liable to paycontributions under the Unemployment Insurance Acts, andI have no power to exclude them from the scope of insurance.The question whether benefit would be payable in anyparticular case would depend on the facts of that case, andwould fall to be decided by the insurance officer with a rightof appeal to the Court of Referees and the Umpire.

Life Pensioners and Medical Boards.Mr. HOGGE asked the Minister of Pensions why it was

possible for the Ministry to call a pensioner awarded a lifepension before an examining board at any time, while the

406

life pensioner could not appeal inside any stipulated periodagainst his award.-Mr. MACPHERSON replied : I amafraid that I am not clear what class of case my hon. friendhas in mind. I may point out, however, that Article 5 ofthe Royal Warrant expressly allows of the review by theMinistry of a permanent pension where error has been made.A permanent pensioner, on the other hand, can appeal to theMinistry against his award on any ground, and even wherea final award is made under the War Pensions Act, 1921, hehas a right of appeal for a year after the award is made.

Ex-Service Men in County and Borough Asylums.Captain LOSEBY asked the Minister of Pensions if ex-Service

men in county and borough lunatic asylums were treated asprivate patients ; and what was the average payment perhead per week made by the Ministry of Pensions in respect ofthe exceptional privileges accorded them.-Mr. MACPHERSONreplied : Certified patients, for the cost of whose maintenanceand treatment the Ministry has accepted liability, are

classified as " Service Patients," and are, by special arrange-ment with the Board of Control, received in asylums on thelegal footing of private patients. The average weekly costof a " Service Patient " is 3t6s. 9d. Of course, this amountdoes not include treatment allowances.

Maintenance of Mentally Affected Officers.Captain LOSEBY asked the Minister of Pensions the

average cost per head per week of officers mentally affectedmaintained in institutions conducted by the Ministry ofPensions, and the average payment per head per week paidin respect of officers detained in lunatic asylums.-Mr.MACPHERSON replied : I assume that my hon. and gallantfriend desires to compare the cost of maintenance in lunaticasylums with that in the Ministry institutions for the treat-ment of officers suffering from neurasthenia and similaruncertifiable disorders. as there are no mental hospitals undermy control. The average cost per head in such Ministryinstitutions is 87s. 6d. a week, as compared with an averagepayment of 89s. 10d. a week made by the Ministry in respectof officers in asylums.

A llowances for Home Treatment ot In.sane Soldiers.Captain LOSEBY asked the Minister of Pensions if the next-

of-kin of ex-Service men certified insane, who were willingand able to take charge of and provide adequate treatmentfor such ex-Service men in accordance with the Lunacy Laws,received from the Ministry of Pensions the same treatmentallowances as were paid in respect of ex-Service men confinedin lunatic asylums, and the number of cases, if any, inwhich such treatment allowances were paid in the year1921.-Mr. MACPHERSON replied: An ex-Service mandischarged from an asylum by the responsible authoritiesto the care of his relatives and in need of further treatmentfor a mental disability not certifiable but due to or aggravatedby service, would be eligible for the usual allowances appro-priate to home treatment. No separate record of suchcases is kept, and I am therefore unable to give the infor-mation asked for in the last part of the question.

Economy and the Mental Deficierzey Service.Mr. LESLIE SCOTT asked the Minister of Health whether

he had been able, in consultation with the Board of Controland the Treasury, to reconsider the position created by thecircular of the Board of Control of August last in relationto the financial limitation upon local authorities in regard todealing with urgent cases of mental deficiency : and, seeingthat such limitation, if adhered to, would prevent la.rgenumbers of urgent cases from being dealt with under theAct, that it was objectionable in the interest of the defectivesthemselves, of their families, and of the public that such casesshould be uncared for, and that the expense to the State inrates and taxes for police, justice, Poor-law, and otherpublic services, was many times greater if such defectiveswere at large than their whose cost of maintenance if caredfor under the Act, whether he would cause the circular inquestion to be withdrawn.-Sir A. MOND replied : In view ofthe economy which it should be possible to secure on theMental Deficiency Service generally, I hope that localauthorities can now make such provision as is essential toenable new urgent cases to be dealt with, and I am causingthe Board of Control to issue a circular accordingly.

MONDAY, FEB. 20TH.The Russian Famine.

Mr. GRATTAN DOYLE asked the Tender-Secretary of Statefor Foreign Affairs if he was in a position to give reliablefacts regarding the reported famine in Russia ; how manypeople were affected in the stricken area ; how many haddied from starvation ; and whether any of the food andmoney contributed by the allied nations had been diverted

and used to feed the Bolshevist army, and to the upkeep ofthe Soviet government.-Sir P. LLOYD GREAME (Secretary

of the Department of Overseas Trade) replied : I am unableto give any reliable figures in regard to the number of peopleaffected by the famine in Russia or of those who have diedof starvation. There can be no doubt, however, that thesituation in some parts of the famine area is one of extremegravity and that a population of many millions is affected.It is hoped that Sir Benjamin Robertson, who has justreturned from a tour in the famine areas on behalf of theRussian Famine Relief Fund, will be able to give valuableinformation in his report on the extent of the disaster. Asregards the last part of the question the answer is in thenegative so far as contributions from British sources areconcerned, and this also applies so far as H.M. Governmentare aware to contributions from other countries. ,

TUESDAY, FEB. 21sT.

Orderlies in Military Hospitals.Mr. Gom-REY LOCKER-LAMPSON asked the Minister of

Pensions how many orderlies were employed in Ministryhospitals and whether there was one orderly for every sixpatients.-Mr. MACPHERSON replied : There are 1879 orderliesemployed in Ministry hospitals and convalescent centreswhere there are 13,644 in-patients ; but less than 50 per cent.of these are employed on nursing duties or in the wards.The remainder of the orderlies so termed are merely employeesengaged on general domestic duties-e.g., as messengers,sanitary men, storemen, gatemen, dining-room orderlies,ga,rdeners, and ambulance drivers, and in the out-patientdepa,rtments where 17,861 patients are being treated.

i London Drunkenness Statistics.

Sir R. HALL asked the Home Secretary the number 01convictions for drunkenness in the metropolitan police arei.in the years 1913, 1920, and 1921.-Mr SHORTT replied:The figures are as follows : 1913, 64,783 ; 1914, 67,117: ..1915, 51,372 ; 1916, 29,095 ; 1917, 16,567 ; 1918, 9901: -.1919, 20,674; 1920, 29,956; 1921, 27,410 (Jan.-June 12th,736 ; July-Dec. 14th, 674).

Medical News.UNIVERSITY OF BRISTOL.-At examinations held

recently the following candidates were successful:-EXAMINATION FOR DEGREE OF CH.M.

Gynæcology.-Reginald S. S. Statham.Laryngology.-Eric Watson-Williams.

FINAL EXAMINATION FOR DEGREES OF M.B., CH.B.Percy Phillips (first-class honours), Macdonald Critchley

(second-class honours), and William K. A. Richards.Part II. (completing exantination).-Phyllis Beames, Madge E.

Golding, William A. Jackman, Winifred G. Nott, andVictoria S. Tryon.

Part I. (including Forensic Medicine and Toxicology).-Bertram A. Crook, John M. Evans, Constance L. Griffiths,Francis J. Hector, Marguerite G. Hughes, Frances M. Jones,Arthur J. Keevill, Eric C. K. Kenderdine, Doris M. Pullen,James A. L. Roberts, and Harry L. Shepherd.

Part 1. only.-Francis H. Bodman, Carrie H. Osmond, andHugh J. H. Spreadbury.EXAMINATION FOR DIPLOMA IN PUBLIC HEALTH.

Part I. only.-Bernard A. Astley-Weston.FINAL EXAMINATION FOR DIPLOMA IN DENTAL SURGERY.William Bayly and Leslie C. Bodey.

FINAL EXAMINATION FOR DEGREE OF B.D.S.George N. Season.

PSYCHOLOGICAL MEDICINE AND JUVENILE CRIME.-Presiding at a lecture on the Mind and What We Ought toKnow About It. given under the auspices of the People’sLeague of Health by Dr. R. S. Rows at the Royal Societyof Arts on Feb. 20th, the subject being the Association ofIdeas, Recognition and Memory, Mr. Clarke Hall, the OldStreet police court magistrate, whose work is largely con-nected with juvenile delinquency, said that such a campaignas that organised by the League was of importance in educatingand drawing together voluntary workers at a time of economicdifficulty. The work of the League stood pre-eminently forhuman happiness, of which the principal component washealth, and the great means of promoting health was know-ledge. Through ignorance of treatment, through want of abetter scientific knowledge or system, children drifted at anearly age into crime, to become eventually habitual criminals.As president of a Children’s Court in the East End of London,he was certain that the best means of dealing with infantiledelinquency was to spread knowledge of what was happeningto those children, and to point to how much the individualworker could do.


Recommended