Date post: | 06-Jul-2018 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | aisyah-shaumanur |
View: | 214 times |
Download: | 0 times |
of 31
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
1/31
HOLISTIC MODULE
PROBLEM BASED LEARNING
SCENARIO 2
TUTOR
dr. Danti Nur Indiastuti, M.ked
SCENARIO COMPOSER
Dr. Sri Umijati,dr.,MS
Dr. Sulistiawati,dr,Mkes
EDITOR
Prof. Dr. N. Margarita Rehatta, dr., Sp.AnI!., NA
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 1
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
2/31
COMPOSED BY
4B GROUP
LEADER
Muhammad Bagas Pratista !""#"""$$!%%&
SECRETARY
E'(i) Nu*u'isti)a !""#"""$$!%+&
NOTULEN
Ha)i,a Ima)sari !""#"""$$!%4&
MEMBERS
Ch-'i,ati) Nur Ardhi.ah !""#"""$$!#%&
Nur Imr-atu' Murs.idah !""#"""$$!#+&
Ismi Mas.ithah !""#"""$$!%!&
Ari)da Agu)g /atritama !""#"""$$!%2&
Er'.ta 0u',ai*ah !""#"""$$!1!&
Ris)a)da Putri Ras.da !""#"""$$!12&
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 2
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
3/31
!+N-NS
!o)er../
$roup mem0er...1
!ontents.2
!hapter I3 "rain Storming.4
/./ S'enario.....4/.1 Main Pro0lem....4
/.2 e(words..4
/.% &irst *(pothesis....4
/.4 #earning Issues I...5
!hapter II3 Pro0lem Anal(sis6
1./ Answer..6
1././ *ow is holisti' approa'h7..........61./.1 !auses and S(mptoms of u0er'ulosis, Asthma, Pneumonia,
-mph(sema and #ung !an'er...8
1./.2 9hat is 'ement and 'otton 'ontaining7............//1./.% *ow is a holisti' approa'h 0ased on the s'enario7............…………/%
1./.4 *ow 'an happen the pro0lem of medi'al 0ased on holisti'
approa'h7....................../41.1 Method and Steps to &ind Information.../8
1.2 &irst Mind Mapping..../:
!hapter III 3 utorial !on'lusion....1;
2./ Data Anal(sis .....1;
2.1 &inal *(pothesis.11
2.2 !on'ept Mapping....12
2.% Pathoph(siologi' D(spnea
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
4/31
!riti'al Appraisal.2%
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 4
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
5/31
CHAPTER I
BRAIN STORMING
"" S3)ari-
Nia is 12rd (ears old girl 'ome from =akarta. She feel that, she alwa(s 'ough and
sometimes d(spnea in 2 month after she mo)e to > 'it(. She 0oarding in house that
ha)e religious people . hat 0oarding house rather dust( 0e'ause it near to semen
fa'tor(.
"2 Mai) Pr-5'm
Nia has 'ough and d(spnea after she mo)e to > 'it(.
"$ /.6-rds
&rom the s'enario and main pro0lem, we use 2 ke(words for it. he( are 3
/. 12rd (ears old girl1. Mo)e to > 'it(
2. Religious en)ironmet.
%. he 0oarding house near to Semen fa'tor(
"4 7irst H.8-thsis&rom the s'enario and a main pro0lem that we 'hoose. 9e h(pothesi?e 3
/. Dust allergi'
1. u0er'ulosis2. Asthma
%. Pneumonia
4. -mfisema5. #ung !an'er
"# Lar)i)g Issus "
&rom all a0o)e, there are man( learning issues that we state. &or the learning
issues there are3/. 9hat is 'ough and d(spnea 7
1. 9hat are the 'auses and s(mptoms of tu0er'ulosis, asthma, pneumonia,
emph(sema and lung 'an'er7
2. 9hat is 'ement and 'otton 'ontaining 7%. *ow is holisti' approa'h7
4. *ow is holisti' approa'h 0ased on the s'enario7
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 5
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
6/31
5. *ow 'an happen the pro0lem of medi'al 0ased on holisti' approa'h7
CHAPTER II
PROBLEM ANALYSIS
2" A)s6rs
2"" C-ugh a)d D.s8)a
C-ugh
he 'ough is a natural response 0od( to 'lean mu'us or irritation fa'tor 'auses, likedust, smoke. Usuall( So it 'an go out from the respirator( s(stem. An irritant stimulates
ner)es there to send a 'ough impulse to the 0rain. hen, the 0rain gi)es the signal to a0domen
and 'hest wall. A0domen and 'hest wall will gi)e a push the air to the lungs and e@pel the
irritant.
!ough is the s(mptom of some diseases either a'ute or 'hroni'. he 'hroni' diseases
like allergies, asthma, 0ron'hitis, $-RD, and postnasal drip. he a'ute diseases like
influen?a, 'ommon 'old, pneumonia, and !+PD. !ough 'an 0e a'ute if it lasts than three
weeks while 'ough 'an 0e 'hroni' if it lasts longer than eight weeks Ma(o !lini', 1;/2B.
D.s8)a
D(spnea is a feeling diffi'ult to 0reathe. Usuall( it happen when ph(si'al a'ti)it(.
D(spnea has man( 'auses affe'ting either the 0reathing passages and lungs or the heart. he
d(spnea 'an o''urs graduall( or all of a sudden. he 'auses of d(spnea 'an 0e asthma,
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 6
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
7/31
0ron'hitis, pneumonia, pneumothora@, anemia, lung 'an'er, inhalation injur(, pulmonar(
em0olism, 'ongesti)e heart failure, allergi' rea'tion, anaph(la@is, interstitial lung disease,
o0esit(, tu0er'ulosis, emph(sema, pulmonar( arter( h(pertension, and aero0i' e@er'ise.
D(spnea 'an 0e asso'iated with s(mptoms of 'hest pain, di??iness, fainting, 'ough,whee?ing, ne'k pain, and 'hest injur( #ongo, 1;// 'ited in 9illiam, 1;/4B
2"2 Causs a)d S.m8t-ms -, Tu5r3u'-sis9 Asthma9 P)um-)ia9
Em8h.sma a)d Lu)g Ca)3r
A. u0er'ulosis
u0er'ulosis is a disease that 'aused 0( infe'tion of m('o0a'terium
tu0er'ulosis. his disease 'an transmitted to the other human through sali)a.
And the s(mptom is a 'ough with sputum a0out 2 weeks, 0lood( 'ough, high
0od(Cs temperature, sweat in a night da(, de'rease satiet(.
". Asthma
Asthma is a disease in whi'h the airwa(s narrow e@'essi)el( in response to
)arious stimuli in the presen'e of airwa( h(perresponsi)eness A*RB and
eosinophili' airwa( inflammation. In 'lassi' asthmaE !AB )aria0le airflow
o0stru'tion t(pi'all( leads to s(mptoms su'h as whee?e, d(spnea and 'ough.
Niimi.1;//B
Asthma 'aused 0( 2 fa'tors, first is geneti' fa'tor. $eneti' fa'tor is 0ig role
how asthma o''urred, if there is our famil( that suffer asthma, so we ha)e pro0a0ilit(
suffer asthma. Se'ond is allergi', like allergi' of dust, temperature, and humidit(.
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 7
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
8/31
Allergi' 'an trigger rea'tion in respirational tra't, and it will produ'e e@'essi)e
sputum and respirational tra't 0e'ome narrow, and asthma o''urred. hird is a
ps('hologi', emotion and stressed 'an 'ause asthma.
AsthmaCs s(mptoms are d(spnea with a whee?ing sound. &or the pre)ention,
asthma sufferer ha)e to 'lean their en)ironment like 'lean their 0ed from dust, a)oid
high humidit( room, pets and food that trigger allergi'.
!. Pneumonia
Pneumonia is a infe'tious disease that o''urred in lung tissue and 'aused 0(
0a'teria, )irus and fungi. Strepto'o''us 0a'teria, m('oplasma pneumonia are a
'ommon 0a'teria that 'an o''urred pneumonia. he s(mptoms are a 'ough with
sputum, 'hest pain, and d(spnea with high temperature.
D. -mph(sema
!hroni' o0stru'ti)e pulmonar( disease !+PDB is a disease 'hara'teri?ed 0(
airflow limitation that is not full( re)ersi0le. he pathogenesis of !+PD is thought to
0e 'hroni' inflammation throughout the airwa(s, paren'h(ma, and pulmonar(
)as'ulature. Pathologi' 'hanges 'hara'teristi' of !+PD o''ur in all these respirator(
stru'tures. Among these 'hanges, destru'tion of the lung paren'h(ma is 'ommonl(
referred to as pulmonar( emph(sema, defined as an a0normal permanent
enlargement of the air spa'e distal to the terminal 0ron'hioles, a''ompanied 0(
destru'tion of the al)eolar walls, and without o0)ious fi0rosisE
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 8
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
9/31
-mph(sema 'ause 0( smoke from 'igarettes, and la'k of aphaF/Fatitripsin
en?(me, 0e'ause of that al)eolus lost its elasti'it(. he s(mptoms are d(spnea in a
long period and 'annot 'ure 0( sal)e medi'ine. he de'rease of satiet(, and lost
0od(Cs weight is an e@ample of emph(semaCs s(mptoms.
-. #ung !an'er
#ung 'an'er is the most freGuentl( diagnosed 'an'er and the leading 'ause of
'an'erFrelated deaths worldwide. -)iden'e suggests that there is a relationship
0etween pre)ious respirator( disease PRDB, in'luding 'hroni' 0ron'hitis,
emph(sema, tu0er'ulosis, and pneumonia, and lung 'an'er diagnoses. o0a''o is a
shared risk fa'tor of PRD and lung 'an'er.
Main 'auses of lung 'an'er in the world is smoke from 'igarettes, it 'ontain
man( to@i' su0stan'es and if we inhales it, it will a''umulate in our lung for man(
(ears and trigger a 'ell mutation that 'an 'ause lung 'an'er. he other 'ause of lung
'an'er is radiation, other to@i' 'hemi'al su0stan'es and geneti' fa'tor.
he s(mptoms of lung 'an'er are 'ough, 'hest pain, d(spnea, 0lood( 'ough,
tired and de'rease of 0od(Cs weight. "ut, like the other 'an'er, the 'ommon s(mptom
of 'an'er will showed when the 'an'er has growth for along time and has spread all
o)er the 0od(.
2"2 Cm)t a)d C-tt-) C-)tai)
Cm)t
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 9
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
10/31
!ement is an essential ingredient and man( 'onne'ti)e used in ph(si'al
de)elopment in the 'i)il 'onstru'tion se'tor. If plus water, 'ement would 0e the
'ement paste. If the plus fine aggregate, 'ement paste will 0e the mortar that if
'oupled with the 'oarse aggregate will 0e a mi@ture of 'on'rete &resh after the
'on'rete hardens will 0e hard 'on'reteB.
Portland 'ement made from fine powder minerals 'r(stalline 'omposition is
primaril( 'al'ium and aluminum sili'ate. he addition of this mineral water produ'es
a pasta that if it dries will is as strong as a ro'k. Densit( produ'ed ranges 0etween
23/1 and 23/5 and the hea)( )olume a0out /4;; kg 'm2 Naw(, /:843 :B. he main
ingredient forming portland 'ement is lime !a+B, sili'a Si+2B, alumina Al1+2B, a
little magnesia Mg+B, and sometimes slightl( alkaline. o 'ontrol the 'omposition,
sometimes add iron o@ide, while g(psum !aS+%.*1+B was added to set the timing
0elt 'ement.
Semen that one 'an 0e distinguished with 'ement other 0ased on their 'hemi'al
'omposition and fineness 0utim(a. !omparison of main 'onstituent materials
portland 'ement is lime !a+B of a0out 5;H F54H, sili'a Si+1B of a0out 1;H F14H,
and iron o@ide as well as alumina &e1+2 and Al1+2B appro@imatel( 6H F/1H.
here are four %B 'ompound he main 'hemi'als that make portland 'ement,
namel(3
/. ri'al'ium Sili'ate 2!a+. Si+1B whi'h is a00re)iated 0e !2S.
1. Di'al'ium Sili'ate 1!a+. Si+1B whi'h is a00re)iated 0e !1S.2. ri'al'ium aluminate 2!a+. Al1+2B are in0riefl( 0e'ame !2A.
%. ertrakalsium aluminoferrit %!a+. A#1+2.&e1+2B is shortened to !%A&.
C-tt-)
!otton 'omes from randu trees. Man( people think that sleep on the kapuk is
more 'omforta0le and not hot 'oolerB. "ut a 0ed of 'otton 'an flat after 0eing used
for a long time. "ed from 'otton is not 0eing suggested for people who ha)e allergi'.
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 10
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
11/31
"e'ause 'atton keep the dust inside 0ed. apuk has smooth pie'ess that 'an inhale
on repirator( s(stem.
2"$ D,i)iti-) -, H-'isti3 A88r-a3h
*olism is deri)ed from the $reek, holos, whi'h means whole, was first used 0( South
Afri'an philosopher =an !hristian Smuts /:15B in *olism and -)olution Daniel and
-Gulinet, 1;;5B. *olisti' approa'h to medi'ine is we 'an see the whole person. he whole
person means their 0od(, mind, and spirit. he 'on'ept of holisti' approa'h is a link 0etween
ph(si'al health and the 'lose interrelation with that ph(si'al health like 0iologi'al,
ps('hologi'al, so'ial, and 'ultural. An holisti' approa'h is not onl( treating the s(ptoms 0ut
also thinking a0out the 'auses of those s(mptoms. It is usuall( 'alled the stor( 0ehind the
stor(E. Daniel Mengistu and -Gulinet Misganaw. 1;;5. !ommunit( *ealth Nursing. Page /1
*olisi' Approa'h di)ide into 2 part 3
AGENT
Agent is fa'tor outside the 0od( that ha)e a0ilit( to 'auses, triggers, or worsen
disease. Agent 'an 0e from ph(si'al ha?ard, "iologi'al *a?ard, !hemi'al *a?ard or
Ps('hoso'ial *a?ard. -a'h *a?ard des'ri0ed 0elow !om'are.go).au, 1;/%B.
" Ph.si3a' Ha*ardA ph(si'al ha?ard is defined as a fa'tor within the en)ironment that 'an harm
the 0od( without ne'essaril( tou'hing it. i0ration and noise are e@amples of
ph(si'al ha?ardsJ. Ph(si'al ha?ards in'lude 0ut arenKt limited to ele'tri'it(, radiation,
pressure, noise, heights and )i0ration amongst man( others.
2 Bi-'-g.3a' Ha*ard
"iologi'al ha?ards are organi' su0stan'es that pose a threat to the health
of humans and other li)ing organisms. "iologi'al ha?ards in'lude pathogeni'
mi'roForganisms, )iruses, to@ins from 0iologi'al sour'esB, spores, fungi and 0ioF
a'ti)e su0stan'es. "iologi'al ha?ards 'an also 0e 'onsidered to in'lude 0iologi'al
)e'tors or transmitters of disease.
"iologi'al ha?ards pose risks for man( people in a wide )ariet( of wa(s.
&or e@ample, workers in health 'are professions are e@posed to 0iologi'al ha?ards
)ia 'onta't with human 0odil( matter, su'h as 0lood, tissues, sali)a, mu'ous,
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 11
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
12/31
urine and fae'es, 0e'ause these su0stan'es ha)e a high risk of 'ontaining )iral or
0a'terial diseases. #ikewise, people who work with li)e animals or animal
produ'ts 0lood, tissue, milk, eggsB are e@posed to animal diseases and infe'tions,
some of whi'h ?oonosesB ha)e the potential to infe't humans for e@ample, LF
fe)er, a)ian flu or *endra )irusB or 'ause serious allerg( )ia sensitisation.
$ Chmi3a' Ha*ard
*a?ardous 'hemi'als in the workpla'e are su0stan'es, mi@tures and
materials that 'an 0e 'lassified a''ording to their health and ph(si'o'hemi'al
risks and dangers.
*ealth ha?ards in'lude skin irritants, 'ar'inogens or respirator( sensitisers that
ha)e an ad)erse effe't on a workerKs health as a result of dire't 'onta't with or
e@posure to the 'hemi'al, usuall( through inhalation, skin 'onta't or ingestion.
Ph(si'o'hemi'al ha?ards generall( result from a su0stan'eKs ph(si'al and
'hemi'al properties, as is the 'ase with flamma0le, 'orrosi)e, o@idising or
e@plosi)e su0stan'es.
4 S-3ia' Ha*ard
Ps('hoso'ial ha?ards in'lude 0ut arenCt limited to stress, )iolen'e and
other workpla'e stressors.
here are 'ir'umstan'es, howe)er, in whi'h work 'an ha)e ad)erse
'onseGuen'es for health and well0eing. Risks to ps('hologi'al health at work
ma( arise from organi?ational or personal fa'tors, with the major fa'tors 0eing
poor design of work and jo0s, poor 'ommuni'ation and interpersonal
relationships, 0ull(ing, o''upational )iolen'e and fatigue. Risks to ps('hologi'al
health due to work should 0e )iewed in the same wa( as other health and safet(
risks and a 'ommitment to pre)ention of workFrelated stress should 0e in'luded in
an organi?ationCs health and safet( poli'ies.
EN:IRONMENT
-n)ironment is fa'tor that 'an affe't on health. -n)ironment in'luding
Umijati, 1;/4B 3
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 12
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
13/31
/. &amil(
In'luding parents, dietar( ha0it, lifest(le, famil( 'ulture, famil(Cs e'onomi',
health and nutritional status, and Spiritual.
1. *ome -n)ironmentIn'luding home sanitation.
2. *ealth Ser)i'esIn'luding poli'ies and programs of nutrition and 'ompan( health ser)i'es.
%. 9ork -n)ironment
In'luding work pla'e sanitation, la0or 'ompensation, 0ioFps('hoFso'ioF
'ulture ha?ard, and so'ial and 'ultural 'onditions of so'iet(.
2"4 H-'isti3 A88r-a3h Basd -) S3)ari-
9e know that holisti' approa'h di)ide into 2, 0ased on s'enario that is 3
/. *+S
a. Age 3 9oman, 12 (ears old. 0. -du'ation 3 S/ "a'helor of -'onom(
'. 9ork 3 A''ountant
d. *(giene 3 *a)e a ha0it of 'oming home late at night after work e. *ealth Status 3
F Disease Profile3 /. Past3 -@perien'ed a dust allerg( at /1 (ears old
1. Now3 *a)e 'ough and shortness ronkiB and fe)er
emperature 26,4BF &amil( Profile3 *er father and aunt suffered 0ron'hial asthma and
allergi' rhinitis
f. #ife St(le 3 *a)e a ha0it 0u(ing food from outsiderestaurant
g. &amil( and so'ial roles 3&emale workers who go a0road
1. A$-N
a. "iologi'al *a?ard3 fungi and 0a'teria 0. !hemi'al *a?ard3
'. Ph(si'al *a?ard3 !ement dust, humidit(
d. So'ial *a?ard3 "oarding near0( friends also ha)e 'ough and shortness
2. -NIR+NM-N
a. ost
• he si?e is 1; m @ 4 m 9ide *ouse
• +nl( has 2 openedFwindows with si?e 1 m @ / m less
)entilation
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 13
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
14/31
• #i)ed 0( 5 person too man( person in a house
• "ed were 0uilt 0( kapok
• *umidit( 84 H too high
• #i)e with religious famil(
• *er friend has 'ough and asthma too
• #o'ated near 'ement fa'tor(
0. 9ork
• Ma'hine !ompan(
• As a'ountant
2"# Mdi3a' Pr-5'm 5as) -) h-'isti3 a88r-a3h
In this 'ase a''ording to the holisti' approa'h, we 'an not dire'tl( diagnose
the disease suffered 0( the woman, whi'h we 'an do is how the woman ma(
e@perien'e medi'al pro0lems seen from a holisti' approa'h. As e@plained pre)iousl(,
a holisti' approa'h 'an 0e di)ided into 2 parts in ad)an'e, namel( *ost, Agent and
-n)ironment. hrough 2 of them, we 'an anal(?e how a medi'al pro0lem o''urs in a
woman .
If we look from the *ost, we 'an di)ided again into se)eral small parts su'h
as age, se@, o''upation, lifest(le, h(giene, life status and medi'al histor(. 9e 'an take
some parts and we 'an make the anal(sis of wh( women ma( e@perien'e medi'al
pro0lems. hese things are lifest(le, o''upation and medi'al histor(. As our
dis'ussion, this woman has a jo0 as an a''ountant in a ma'hine 'ompan(. &or us, an
a''ountant must ha)e worked just fo'us on the task and regardless of the work
en)ironment so that her health is less well preser)ed. he se'ond is her lifest(le, if we
look more deepl( a0out her lifest(le, he often ate outside and often go home at night,
often eat outside that ena0ling redu'ed h(giene and food eaten 'an 'ontain dangerous
mi'roorganisms that 'an ad)ersel( affe't the 0od( and 'ause a medi'al pro0lem su'h
as in this 'ase. +ften go home the e)ening 'an also 'ause a medi'al pro0lem su'h as
in this 'ase. he fourth is the histor( of the disease, it is )er( important 0e'ause 0(
knowing how the medi'al histor( we 'an 'ertainl( know what she was e@posed to
medi'al pro0lems. As we know at the age of /1 (ears, he is allergi' to dust, and it is
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 14
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
15/31
in line with how the disease o''urs 0e'ause of the home en)ironment that is 'lose to a
'ement plant and a large housing 'onditions without air 'ir'ulation .
If we look at the se'ond aspe't , namel( agents, it is in'reasingl( o0)ious
influen'e. Agent 'an 0e seen in four parts, namel( the threat of 0iologi'al , 'hemi'al ,
ph(si'al and so'ial . +f the 0iologi'al threat , we 'an menngetahui humidit( le)el of
the house of the woman is )er( high . !ausing his house to 0e a pla'e that is )er(
good for the growth of fungi and other mi'roorganisms that 'an 'ause medi'al
pro0lems . "esides the mattress he used made of 'otton that 'an 'ause 'oughing and
0reathing diffi'ulties if inhaled.
"oth are part of a 'hemi'al threat , as the information we know , theen)ironment around the house is a 'ement fa'tor( whi'h will ine)ita0l( happen
deplo(ment of su0stan'es deri)ed from 'ement and )er( dangerous if it gets inhaled
0( the woman. !hemi'als su'h as sili'ates in 'ement 0( inhalation would 0e )er(
harmful to the human 0od( . he sili'ate 'an also 'ause a disease that is one of the
s(mptoms of 'ough and shortness of 0reath . he third is the ph(si'al threat in the
form of dust in the house of the woman , as the information we re'ei)e , the home of
the woman is Guite large 0ut has a )er( slight amount of )entilation . So that the
'ir'ulation 0e'omes )er( less and the dust would 0e harmful if inhaled , 'an 'ause
tightness and 'oughing . he fourth is a so'ial threat , 0oarding a friend Ks woman has
the same disease with the woman , whi'h means there is a possi0ilit( that a friend of
his 0oarding 'an transmit the disease in women.
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 15
Cough and
shortness of
breath
Host
Job
Often hanging out at
evening
Eat outside
edi!a" histor#
!auses
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
16/31
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
17/31
1.1./ +pen we0 0rowser and t(pe the ke(words, su'h as 3 holisti' approa'h, holisti',
holisti' approa'h to medi'ine,ph(si'al ha?ard et'.
1.1.1 Sear'h engine and we0 address that we used are 3
www.google.'om
www.s'holar.google.'om
www.gopu0med.orgwe0gopu0med
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 17
&gent
'io"ogi
!a"
(h#si!
a"
Che)i!a"
%o!ia"
i!roorganis
)s and
fungus
dust
%i"i!a in,ort"and se)en
House
)ate
&gent
'io"ogi
!a"
(h#si!
a"
Che)i!
a-"
%o!ia"
i!roorganis)
s and fungus
dust
%i"i!a in
,ort"and
se)enHouse )ate
Cough an
shortness
breath
Host
Job
Often hang
outEat
outside
edi!a"
histor#
!ause
HO.+%/+
http://www.google.com/http://www.scholar.google.com/http://www.gopubmed.org/web/gopubmed/http://www.google.com/http://www.scholar.google.com/http://www.gopubmed.org/web/gopubmed/
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
18/31
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
19/31
CHAPTER $
TUTORIAL CONCLUSION
$" Data A)a'.sis
!ough and d(spnea are 'ommon s(mptoms of some diseases related to
lung or 'ardia'. 9e donCt dis'uss a0out what the disease host suffered 0ut we just
'an anal(?e a0out wh( 'ough and d(spnea happened. In this modul, we use the
holisti' approa'h. It is like knowing the stor( 0ehind the stor(E.
"ased on holisti' approa'h, we 'an use a model 'alled epidemiolog( triangle.
It is a model usuall( used to stud( a0out the health pro0lems 'ough and d(spneaB.
hese health pro0lems 'an 0e asso'iated with three major fa'tors. hese fa'tors are 3
/. *ost the person with the health pro0lemsBhe host is a woman 12 (ears old. She is an a''ountant in a 'ompan(
0ased ma'hine. She has past medi'al histor(, had e@perien'ed dust allerg(
sin'e /1 (ears old. *er families her father and auntB ha)e rhinitis allergi' and
0ron'hiale asthma. She mo)es from her domi'ile to 'it( >. She li)es in a
kosE whi'h is owned 0( religious people. After three months she li)es in her
new domi'ile, she has the health pro0lems 'ough and d(spneaB
1. Agent ha?ards in the en)ironmentB
"iologi'al ha?ard 3 Mi'roorganims
!hemi'al ha?ard 3 he 'omposition of 'ement dust, Si+1 Sili'on
dio@ideB
Ph(si'al ha?ard 3 84H humidit( in the houseSo'ial ha?ard 3 people around the host
2. -n)ironment pla'e in whi'h the host and the agent intera'tB
he en)ironment 'an 0e di)ided into3/. Mi'ro en)ironment 3 *er new domi'ile
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 19
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
20/31
1. Meso en)ironment 3 *er new domi'ile is near the 'ement
fa'tor(, her work en)ironmen
he new domi'ile of the host 'hanges the en)ironment of the host. &rom the
data we got, there are mi'ro and meso en)ironment 'hanges. he mi'ro en)ironment
is the pla'e where the host li)es. It has si?e1; m > 4 m 0ut with minimum
)entilation. here are onl( 2 windows in that house. he meso en)ironment is the
en)ironment around the host li)ing. It is near the 'ement fa'tor(. he meso
en)ironment 'an 0e the pla'e where the host works. It is a ma'hine 'ompan(. he
'hanges of the en)ironment mean the 'hanges of the agent. &rom mi'ro en)ironment,
so man( agents (ang didapatkan. he ph(si'al agent is the 84H humidit( in that
house. It 'an 0e 'aused 0( that house whi'h has minimum )entilation and windows.
he dust in the house is also the ph(si'al agent. he hostC 0ed is made from 'otton.
A'tuall(, 'otton is soft and 'omforta0le for sleeping. "ut, 'otton is not re'ommended
for people who ha)e dust allerg( 0e'ause 'otton 'an a''umulate dust around it so it
'an 0e inhaled while sleeping. &rom the meso en)ironment, there is 'ement dust
e@posure. he 0iologi'al agent is there will 0e )er( 0ig pro0a0ilit( of mi'roorganisms
li)e in that house 0e'ause of the a0normal houseCs humidit(. he 'hemi'al agent is
from the 'omposition of 'ement dust like Si+1 Sili'on dio@ideB. It is tin( parti'les'an enter into small air sa's in the lungs. If it is often inhaled, it 'an 'ause 'ough,
d(spnea, and whee?ing.
he so'ial agent 'an 0e anal(?ed from the people around the host. he host
li)es in the house whi'h is owned 0( religious people. he host 'an get the pressure
from them 0e'ause of Nia ha0it who often go home at night. In addition, when
)iewed from the side of the hostKs role in the famil(, she is a woman who works and
migrated out of the 'it(, this ma( trigger ps('hologi'al host. Stress 'an o''ur 0e'ause
she is a woman who must work and also to adapt to the new ligkungan and should far
from her famil(. And the last, it is a0out the hostCs medi'al histor( and her famil(Cs
medi'al histor(. It 'an make the pro0a0ilit( of the host to has 'ough and d(spnea. he
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 20
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
21/31
host has past medi'al histor(, had e@perien'ed dust allerg( sin'e /1 (ears old. *er
families her father and auntB ha)e rhinitis allergi' and 0ron'hiale asthma.
If all three se'tions are 'onne'ted to the host, agent and en)ironment as the
'ause medi'al pro0lems, it 'an 0e found links 0etween ea'h other. !hanges in the
en)ironment on the host would 'ause 'hanges to the agent, so there will 0e man(
fa'tors that affe't the health of the host. It is not onl( host, agent, or en)ironment
itself. "ut, all of those are linked ea'h other.
$2 7i)a' H.8-thsis
he en)ironment 'hange will 0e follow 0( the agent 'hanges that will affe't
the host so that arose s(mptoms su'h as 'ough and d(spnea. A''ording holisti'
approa'h, asthma is a disease that has most likel( suffered 0( the host.
$$ C-)38t Ma88i)g
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 21
&E/
"iologi'al *a?ard 3
Mold
!hemi'al *a?ard 3
!ement dust
Ps('hologi'al *a?ard 3
dust
So'ial *a?ard 3 stress
a0out work
HO%
/
E+OE
/
#ife St(le ost
9orkpla'e
!ough and D(spnea
Pstolog(
Solution
&irst *ost
Medi'al dan Medi'al &amil( *istor(
Domi'ile
Mo)ement
Causing a !hange
to
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
22/31
$4 Path-8h.si-'-gi3 ma88i)g
Path-8h.si-'-g. -, D.s8)a
A. De'reased tissue o@(genation
Disease or a'utel( 'ertain 'ir'umstan'es 'an 'ause the speed of deli)er( of
o@(gen to all tissues de'reases . A de'rease in tissue o@(genation will impro)e
shortness of 0reath . +@(gen depends on transport 0e'ause of the 'ir'ulation of 0lood
and hemoglo0in le)els , then some 'ir'umstan'es su'h as 0leeding , anemia
hemol(sis B , 'hange in hemoglo0in sulfhemoglo0in , methemoglo0in ,
'ar0o@(hemoglo0in B ma( 'ause shortness of 0reath .
Paren'h(ma lung disease that 'auses intrapulmonar( shunt , )entilation
disorders also 'ause asph(@iation . So , shortness of 0reath 'an 0e 'aused 0( diseases
of 0ron'hial asthma, 0ron'hitis and pulmonar( 0lood )essels disease group su'h as
em0oli , )as'ulitis and primar( pulmonar( h(pertension .
". he need of o@(gen in'reasesDisease or 'ondition suddenl( in'reased o@(gen reGuirement would gi)e the
sensation of shortness of 0reath . &or e@ample , a'ute infe'tion will reGuire more
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 22
D(spnea intensit( and
Gualit(
entilator(Mus'les
S)s-r. C-rt;
&eed0a'k
&eedFforward
-rror Signal
-rror Signal
Motor
!orte@
!hemore'eptors
Respirator( 'enters
Respirator( dri)eB
Me'hanore'eptors
Meta0ore'eptors
!orollar(
dis'harge
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
23/31
o@(gen due to in'reased meta0olism . In'rease in 0od( temperature due to material
p(rogens or stimuli in the 'entral ner)ous 'ausing in'reased o@(gen demand and
e)entuall( lead to shortness of 0reath . #ikewise with th(roto@i'osis disease , 0asal
meta0oli' rate is in'reased so that the o@(gen demand is also in'reasing . Ph(si'al
a'ti)it( also reGuires more o@(gen , 'ausing suffo'ation .
!. he work of 0reathing in'reases
Paren'h(m lung disease su'h as pneumonia , swollen lungs whi'h 'auses redu'ed
lung elasti'it( and disease that 'auses narrowing of the airwa(s su'h as 0ron'hial
asthma, 0ron'hitis and 0ron'hiolitis 'an lead to de'reased lung )entilation . o
'ompensate for this situation and that the o@(gen demand also remains 'an 0e met ,
the respirator( mus'les are for'ed to work harder , or in other words the in'reased
work of 0reathing . his situation raises the meta0olism in'reases and e)entuall(
meta0olites that are in the 0lood stream in'reases. Meta0olites 'onsisting of la'ti'
a'id and p(ru)i' a'id will stimulate the 'entral ner)ous s(stem . +@(gen demand
in'reases in o0esit( also leads to in'reased work of 0reathing .
D. Stimulate In !entral Ner)ous S(stemA disease that atta'ks the 'entral ner)ous s(stem 'an lead to an atta'k of shortness of
0reath suddenl( . *ow to atta'k this , until now un'lear , su'h as meningitis ,
'ere0ro)as'ular a''ident and others . Idiopathi' h(per)entilation also found ,
although the me'hanism is un'lear .
-. Neuromus'ular diseases
Luite a lot of diseases that 'an 'ause disorders of the respirator( s(stem , espe'iall( if
the disease was a0out diaphragms , su'h as m(asthenia gra)is and am(otrophi' 0een
literall( s'lerosis . he me'hanism that 'auses shortness of 0reath due to
neuromus'ular disease is as (et un'lear .
$# Pr-5'm S-'(i)g
Solutions "ased +n *olisti'
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 23
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
24/31
S(mptoms of health pro0lem that was taken 0( host is 'aused 0( some fa'tors
depends on holisti'. In e)er( part of host, agent, and en)ironment 'an support hostCs
health pro0lem. herefore, to sol)e this health pro0lem, we should fi@ e)er( part of
host, agent, and en)ironment depends on holisti'.In holisti', the solution of fa'tors that support health pro0lem are 3
a. *ost
In host, part that support health pro0lem are edu'ation, life st(le, medi'al histor(,
and so'ial roles. he edu'ation means host with s/ 0a'helor of e'onomi's ma(0e has
less health edu'ation. So, 0( in'reasing health edu'ation also 'an in'rease hostCs
health le)el.
he se'ond is life st(le, someoneCs 0ad ha0it will influen'e hostCs health
'ondition. In this s'enario, host often going home late until night, this 'ondition gi)es
0ad impa't to host 0e'ause night wind has low temperature. "( this low temperature,
ma(0e hostCs immunit( 'an not 'ontrol it or ma(0e host has nightFwind allergi'.
Moreo)er, this 'ondition 'an trigger pneumonia. herefore, host should de'rease her
0ad ha0it not to going home late at night often.
he third is medi'al histor(, medi'al histor( are medi'al histor( in the past and
famil(. &or disease histor(, host was e)er taken allergi' to dust at /1 (ears old.
Allerg( 'an appear for the se'ond time if there are some triggers.
he last is so'ial roles. In this s'enario, so'ial roles means host roles as female
who works outside town far from her famil(, this 'ondition 'an 0uild stress to host.
So, the solution are de'reasing work portion and fi@ing her 'ommuni'ation with her
famil(.
0. Agent
In agent, there are some fa'tors that support this health pro0lem. here are
0iologi'al ha?ard, ph(si'al and so'ial ha?ard. "iologi'al ha?ard is a0out
mi'roorganism and fungi that 'ause this health pro0lem 0ased on the 'ondition in
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 24
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
25/31
s'enario. So, wa(s to sol)e and pre)ent this health pro0lem are adding more
)entilation in the kost and 'leaning kost regularl(.
Se'ond is ph(si'al ha?ard. Ph(si'al ha?ard 0ased on s'enario means the dust that
was inhaled 0( host then flew in host respirator( s(stem and humidit(. #e)elhumidit( in s'enario is too high, so it 'an triggers 'ough and d(spnea. o 0alan'ing
humidit(, host should keep the kost dr( and setting air 'ir'ulation. hen, to de'rease
the dust, host should keep the )entilation onl( open when wind outside kost is 'alm.
'. -n)ironment
In en)ironment, some fa'tors that 'ause s(mptom of 'ough and sesak are house
en)ironment and workpla'e. In house en)ironment 0ased on s'enario, hostCs kost
lo'ated near 'ement 'ompan( with less )entilation and kost area is too wide. *ostCs
workpla'e 0ased on s'enario is ma'hine 'ompan(. o pre)ent new health pro0lem,host must 'lean kost and workpla'e where she often spend her most time there
regularl( and ma(0e host needs use masker in kost or at work.
Solution +f !ough And D(spnea In !ommon
A medi'al pro0lem suffered 0( host is 'ough and d(spnea. Ds(pnea 'an 'ause
la'k of o@(gen in the 0od(, it happened 0e'ause of trou0le in 0reathing. hus, the
solutions are plant more trees, dail( e@er'ise and li)e in a 'lean and wide
en)ironment.
!hroni' d(spnea sufferer ha)e to a)oid a food and drink that 'ontain a high
sugar like milk, white sugar, 'and(, wheat, and ri'e. "eside unhealth( food and
drinks, sufferer must 'onsume fruit and )egeta0le, and also enough mineral water.
D(spnea 'an 0e pre)ented and 'ured 0( a dail( e@er'ise, the fun'ion of the
e@er'ise are to in'rease mo)ement of 0a'k and 'hest that 'an train mus'le around
lung, diaphragm and 0lood 'ir'ulation. "est e@er'ise is swimming 0e'ause all of the
0od( mo)e in swimming.
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 25
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
26/31
Medi'ines that 'an 'ure d(spnea is a kind of drug that 'an enlarge respirator(
tra't. he main reaseon wh( d(spnea 'an o''ur in human 0od( is a ps('hologi'
pressure that trigger d(spnea. hud, we ha)e to enjo( our life and dont think to mu'h.
Sigit Nugroho 1;;:B 'ited in 9ara ushartanti 1;;1B said that 0reathing
e@er'ise must 0e done e)er(da( in few minutes. hese are the dire'tion 3
a. -@hale air through nose until mu'us is pulled up. 0. ake short inhale pass through nose and take long e@hale through mouth so it
'an produ'es )oi'e.
'. #oose 'lothes or pants then setting air 0reath. ell someone if there is ngikE
)oi'es during first few minutes from diaphragm 0reathing.
d. Drink a glass of water 0efore and after take an e@er'ise.
R,r)3s
!. Shiel =r., 9illiam. 1;/4. Shorness of "reath D(spneaB. Medi'ineNet, In'.
http3www.medi'inenet.'oms'riptmainmo0ileart.asp7arti'leke(O2%%2% onlineBA''essed 11 No). 1;/4Q.
!om'are.go).au, 1;/%B. Managing hazards. onlineQ A)aila0le at3
http3www.'om'are.goF).aupre)entingha?ards A''essed 11 No). 1;/4Q.
Denholm, Ra'hel, et al. JIs pre)ious respirator( disease a risk fa'tor for lung
'an'er7.J Ameri'an journal of respirator( and 'riti'al 'are medi'ine /:;.4 1;/%B3
4%:F44:.
$oogle.'o.id, 1;/4B. Semen. onlineQ A)aila0le at3 https3www.google.'o.idurl7
saOtr'tOjGOesr'Ossour'eOwe0'dO1'adOrjaua'tO8)edO;ahU-wiR4
#:@j=AhR0%*@4"I;L&gggMA-urlOhttpH2AH1&
H1&kk.mer'u0uana.a'.idH1&elearningH1&filesTmodulH1&//;;%F6F
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 26
http://www.medicinenet.com/script/main/mobileart.asp?articlekey=34434http://www.comcare.go-v.au/preventing/hazards/https://www.google.co.id/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=2&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwiR5YL9xKjJAhVRbY4KHZx5BI0QFgggMAE&url=http%3A%2F%2Fkk.mercubuana.ac.id%2Felearning%2Ffiles_modul%2F11004-7-901570378753.pdf&usg=AFQjCNG6w6TC46xn7ewYhXuiOlBQuzuSsw&sig2=eU8sGo8q97RQXrlmKOGmZAhttps://www.google.co.id/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=2&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwiR5YL9xKjJAhVRbY4KHZx5BI0QFgggMAE&url=http%3A%2F%2Fkk.mercubuana.ac.id%2Felearning%2Ffiles_modul%2F11004-7-901570378753.pdf&usg=AFQjCNG6w6TC46xn7ewYhXuiOlBQuzuSsw&sig2=eU8sGo8q97RQXrlmKOGmZAhttps://www.google.co.id/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=2&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwiR5YL9xKjJAhVRbY4KHZx5BI0QFgggMAE&url=http%3A%2F%2Fkk.mercubuana.ac.id%2Felearning%2Ffiles_modul%2F11004-7-901570378753.pdf&usg=AFQjCNG6w6TC46xn7ewYhXuiOlBQuzuSsw&sig2=eU8sGo8q97RQXrlmKOGmZAhttps://www.google.co.id/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=2&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwiR5YL9xKjJAhVRbY4KHZx5BI0QFgggMAE&url=http%3A%2F%2Fkk.mercubuana.ac.id%2Felearning%2Ffiles_modul%2F11004-7-901570378753.pdf&usg=AFQjCNG6w6TC46xn7ewYhXuiOlBQuzuSsw&sig2=eU8sGo8q97RQXrlmKOGmZAhttp://www.medicinenet.com/script/main/mobileart.asp?articlekey=34434http://www.comcare.go-v.au/preventing/hazards/https://www.google.co.id/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=2&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwiR5YL9xKjJAhVRbY4KHZx5BI0QFgggMAE&url=http%3A%2F%2Fkk.mercubuana.ac.id%2Felearning%2Ffiles_modul%2F11004-7-901570378753.pdf&usg=AFQjCNG6w6TC46xn7ewYhXuiOlBQuzuSsw&sig2=eU8sGo8q97RQXrlmKOGmZAhttps://www.google.co.id/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=2&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwiR5YL9xKjJAhVRbY4KHZx5BI0QFgggMAE&url=http%3A%2F%2Fkk.mercubuana.ac.id%2Felearning%2Ffiles_modul%2F11004-7-901570378753.pdf&usg=AFQjCNG6w6TC46xn7ewYhXuiOlBQuzuSsw&sig2=eU8sGo8q97RQXrlmKOGmZA
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
27/31
:;/46;268642.pdfusgOA&Lj!N$5w5!%5@n6ewh>ui+l"Lu?uSswsig1OeU8
s$o8G:6RL>rlm+$mA A''essed 1% No). 1;/4Q.
#ongo, D.#., et al. 1;//. *arrisonCs Prin'iples of Internal Medi'ine., /8th ed. United
States3 M'$rawF*ill Professional
Mengistu Daniel and -Gulinet Misganaw. 1;;5. !ommunit( *ealth Nursing. Page /1
PD&B A''essed 1% No). 1;/4Q
+0er, !arole, and sung!hieh ao. Jhe geneti's of asthma and allergi' disease3 a
1/st 'entur( perspe'ti)e.J Immunologi'al re)iews 1%1./ 1;//B3 /;F2;.
Nugroho, Sigit, Dosen Pendidikan +lahraga esehatan &akultas Ilmu, and
eolahragan Uni)ersitas Negeri. Jerapi Pernapasan Pada Penderita Asma.J 1;;8B.
Pres'ott, *allie !., Mi'hael 9. Sjoding, and heodore =. Iwash(na. JDiagnoses of
-arl( and #ate Readmissions after *ospitali?ation for Pneumonia. A S(stemati'
Re)iew.J Annals of the Ameri'an hora'i' So'iet( //.6 1;/%B3 /;:/F//;;.
Umijati, Sri. KModul Pendekatan *olistik Manusia Dan #ingkunganK. 1;/4. #e'ture.
#IN 3
http3mitaunairFfk/1.we0.unair.a'.id
http3www.alodokter.'om0atukF0atuk
http3www.ma(o'lini'.orgdiseasesF'onditions0arrettsFesophagusmultimedia)idF1;;68415
http3artikel.'o61sesakFnafasFdanFsolusin(a.html
http3www.medi'inenet.'oms'riptmainmo0ileart.asp7arti'leke(O2%%2%
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 27
https://www.google.co.id/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=2&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwiR5YL9xKjJAhVRbY4KHZx5BI0QFgggMAE&url=http%3A%2F%2Fkk.mercubuana.ac.id%2Felearning%2Ffiles_modul%2F11004-7-901570378753.pdf&usg=AFQjCNG6w6TC46xn7ewYhXuiOlBQuzuSsw&sig2=eU8sGo8q97RQXrlmKOGmZAhttps://www.google.co.id/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=2&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwiR5YL9xKjJAhVRbY4KHZx5BI0QFgggMAE&url=http%3A%2F%2Fkk.mercubuana.ac.id%2Felearning%2Ffiles_modul%2F11004-7-901570378753.pdf&usg=AFQjCNG6w6TC46xn7ewYhXuiOlBQuzuSsw&sig2=eU8sGo8q97RQXrlmKOGmZAhttp://mitaunair-fk12.web.unair.ac.id/http://www.alodokter.com/batuk-batuk/http://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/barretts-esophagus/multimedia/vid-20078526http://artikel.co/72/sesak-nafas-dan-solusinya.htmlhttps://www.google.co.id/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=2&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwiR5YL9xKjJAhVRbY4KHZx5BI0QFgggMAE&url=http%3A%2F%2Fkk.mercubuana.ac.id%2Felearning%2Ffiles_modul%2F11004-7-901570378753.pdf&usg=AFQjCNG6w6TC46xn7ewYhXuiOlBQuzuSsw&sig2=eU8sGo8q97RQXrlmKOGmZAhttps://www.google.co.id/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=2&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwiR5YL9xKjJAhVRbY4KHZx5BI0QFgggMAE&url=http%3A%2F%2Fkk.mercubuana.ac.id%2Felearning%2Ffiles_modul%2F11004-7-901570378753.pdf&usg=AFQjCNG6w6TC46xn7ewYhXuiOlBQuzuSsw&sig2=eU8sGo8q97RQXrlmKOGmZAhttp://mitaunair-fk12.web.unair.ac.id/http://www.alodokter.com/batuk-batuk/http://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/barretts-esophagus/multimedia/vid-20078526http://artikel.co/72/sesak-nafas-dan-solusinya.html
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
28/31
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
29/31
a. Purpose of resear'h 3 o de)elop and e)aluate an e@pert panel s'oring methodof the ha?ard potential of -UR+*A!+N landfill sites, and to in)estigate
whether sites 'lassified as posing a greater potential ha?ard.
a. Resear'h method
Itm Rsu't
Design !aseF!ontrol Stud(
hierar'h( of e)iden'e %
Sample he sample is landfill sites whi'h
'ontained
ha?ardousE waste of nonFdomesti'
origin as defined in the
-! dire'ti)e :/58: on *a?ardous
9aste/2B in the regions 'o)ered
0( the parti'ipating 'entres
Sample Si?e 1; landfill sites in /% stud(
areas
-@'lusion !riteria geographi' site 'oordinates used in initial
anal(ses pro)ed
in'orre't
Sampling &rame Random Sampling
Measurement and or assessment And &inal ha?ard s'ores after 'hanges
were madeB of the four
e@perts were a)eraged to form the final
o)erall, water, and air
ha?ard s'oring. *igh, medium, and low
ha?ard 'ategories were 'reated using
tertiles of the ha?ard s'ores as 'ut off
points.
Instrument Guestionnaires
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 29
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
30/31
Randomi?ation F
Inter)ention F
Anal(sis Method In order to assess the agreement 0etween
e@perts in 0oth initial
and final s'ores, intra'lass 'orrelation
'oeffi'ients I!!B
were 'al'ulated 0( anal(sis of )arian'e.
In addition, the
relia0ilit( of the a)erage e@pert s'ores
I!!kB was 'al'ulated.
aB !ompati0ilit( of he Design and he +0je'ti)e of he Stud( 3
'ompati0le 0B !ompati0ilit( of he Measurement he instruments 3
'ompati0le
!ons'lusion 3 :a'id Not alid
2. IMP+RAN!- +& R-S-AR!*
A. P O ;.;5, if the resear'h was reheld /;; times, 5 among of them didnCtgi)e results as this resear'h.
+R O ;,6: ;.4//.1/B in the low ha?ard 'ategor(, /.%2 /./;/.85B in the
medium, to /.5; /./51.1/B in the high water ha?ard 'ategor(.
". !on'lusion 3 Im8-rta)3Not Importan'e.
P"# $roup %" &a'ult( of Medi'ine Airlangga Uni)ersit(
*olisti' Module Page 30
8/18/2019 PBL HOLISTIK.doc
31/31