University of Montana

ScholarWorks at University of Montana

6eses, Dissertations, Professional Papers Graduate School

1990

In-depth photojournalism projects as teaching toolsin journalism schools: An analysis of thePhilipsburg Montana project.Patricia J. Reksten�e University of Montana

Follow this and additional works at: h7p://scholarworks.umt.edu/etd

6is 6esis is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate School at ScholarWorks at University of Montana. It has been accepted forinclusion in 6eses, Dissertations, Professional Papers by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks at University of Montana. For moreinformation, please contact scholarworks@mail.lib.umt.edu.

Recommended CitationReksten, Patricia J., "In-depth photojournalism projects as teaching tools in journalism schools: An analysis of the PhilipsburgMontana project." (1990). �eses, Dissertations, Professional Papers. Paper 5062.

W2•x55j 2j: W|“5 Wv,mcPUTh TPf6v6J

t'><|j- 2””';5: 2z >x'?|:5: •j:5x >x'?|z|'jz '& /K5 c2|x ’z5 m5V/|'j '& /K5 ’NmN

t19J6P.Ob TvQA IoYRNvj< V'><|j- &'x V'XX5xV|2” >•x>'z5z

'x &|j2jV|2” -2|j X2< 05 •j:5x/2“5j 'j”< ;|/K /K5 2•/K'x§z ;x|//5j V'jz5j/N

’j|?5xz|/< '&8’­^W­W

udPeklgf lfpgp1p0hdi7uq8 lhp1k.gq

iq gki.fudv gpp7q ud 1p0hdi7uq8 q.fpp7qY

id idi7♦quq ps gfk lfu7ulqc0hv* 8 pdgidi lhp1k.g

c•

lW^];3;W 1T hKz*^K­

cT1T 0­;ZK]*;^• ’X 8 ;**’#];* J:CG

l]K*K­^KV ;­ $W]^;W? X#?X;??/ K­^ ’X ^"K ]K[#;]K/ K­^*

X’] ^"K VK6]KK ’X

8 W*^K] ’X i]^*

0 ­;ZK]*;^• ’X 8 ’­^W­W

J::O

i $$]’ZKV 2•

."W;]/ W­* c’W]V ’X k!W/;­K]*'

cKW­* v ]WV#W^K q3"’’l e

udghpe0.gupd

g]•;­6 ^’ ^KW3" $"’^’—’#]­W?;*/ *’ *^#VK­^* W]K ]KW??• $ ]K$W]KV ^’ 2K

$]’XK**;’­W?* + "K­ ^"K• ?KWZK *3"’’? ;* W 3"W??K­6KT g"K]K ;* *’ / #3" ^’

?KW]­T q ^#VK­^* ­’^ ’­?• / #*^ XKK? 3’/X’]^W2?K ;­ ^"K 3’??K6K *K^^;­6* ^"K•

/ #*^ ?KW]­ ^’ 3’/ / #­;3W^K ;­ ^"K o]KW? + ’]?VTo

g"K• / #*^ 2K W2?K ^’ / KK^ W ZW];K^• ’X $K’$?K* / WzK ^"’*K $K’$?K XKK? W^

KW*K ;­ X]’­^ ’X W 3W/K]W W­V ^"K­ 6K^ *^’]•P^K??;­6 $"’^’6]W$"* ’X ^"K/ T

g"K• / #*^ 2K W2?K ^’ ^K?? ’^"K] $K’$?KN* *^’];K* + ;^"’#^ 2;W*;­6 ^"K ]KWV;­6

W­V Z;K+ ;­6 W#V;K­3KT u^ +W* + ;^" ^";* 2K?;KX ;­ / ;­V ^"W^ u W^^K/ $^KV W­ ;­P

VK$ ^" $"’^’—’#]­W?;*/ $]’—K3^ W* W ^KW3";­6 / K^"’VT

u­ 8 W• J:GC* JL $"’^’—’#]­W?;*^* X]’/ ^"K 0 ­;ZK]*;^• ’X 8 ’­^W­WN*

q3"’’? ’X 1’#]­W?;*/ *$K­^ W + KKz X’3#*;­6 ^"K;] W^^K­^;’­ ’­ ^"K */ W?? ^’+ ­

’X l";?;$*2#]6T l";?;$*2#]6 ;* ’­K ’X ^"K ’?VK*^ ^’+ ­* ;­ 8 ’­^W­W W­V W 6’’V

VKW? ’X ^"K ^’+ ­ ;* W?]KWV• W $W]^ ’X ^"K d W^;’­W? hK6;*^K] ’X f;*^’];3 l?W3K*TJ

g"K $#]$’*K ’X ^"K $]’—K3^ + W* ^’ V’3#/ K­^* ^" ]’#6" $"’^’6]W$"* W­V

+ ’]V** ^"K $K’$?K ’X l";?;$*2#]6Y ^"K;] ?;XK*^•?K*F ]K?W^;’­*";$* ^’ KW3" ’^"K]

W­V ^’ ^"K 3’/ / #­;^• ;­ + ";3" ^"K• ?;ZKF ^"K;] ?;ZK* ;­ ^"K UO^" 3K­^#]• W*

*"W$KV 2• /’]K ^"W­ W 3K­^#]• ’X 2’’/ PW­VP2#*^ K3’­’/;3** W­V ^"K;] ]’?K*

| G 2 X 5 z 6N WVh'j2”:A 9K|”|>z0•x- O|z/'x|V 6 5z'• xV5 m • x ? 5< N iG2X 5z 6N WVh'j2”: vxVK|/5V/z 9NtNA IoCDjA >N LN

J

E

;­ W ]# ]W ? 3’// #­;^•T

l";?;$*2#]6 ;* W­ ;VKW? *K^^;­6 ;­ / W­• +W•*T g"K ^’+ ­ ;* *;/ ;?W] ^’

’ ^"K] */ W?? ^’+­* ;­ 8 ’­^W­WT u^* X’]^#­K* "WZK *+ #­6 + ;?V?• *;­3K JGSA*

V];ZK­ 2• ^"K #$* W­V V’+ ­* ’X /;­;­6* ?’66;­6 W­V W6];3#?^#]KT eK*$;^K ;^*

K3’­’/;3 ]’??K]P3’W*^K] ];VK* l";?;$*2#]6 "W* ]K/ W;­KV 3#];’#*?• *^W2?KT u^

*^;?? "W* W2’#^ ^"K *W/ K $’$#?W^;’­ W* ;­ ^"K JG:O*TU

cK3W#*K / #3" ’X ^"K ^’+ ­ +W* W?]KWV• ’­ ^"K d W^;’­W? hK6;*^K] ’X

f ;*^’];3 l?W3K** ;^ *KK/ KV W$$]’$];W^K ^’ ?W#­3" ’#] / W;VK­ V’3#/ K­^W]•

$"’^’6]W$"• $]’—K3^ ;­ W ^’+ ­ ^"W^ +W* ’­K ’X 8 ’­^W­WN* / W;VK­

*K^^?K/ K­^*T

i ­’^"K] /W—’] XW3^’] ;­ ^"K $]’—K3^N* *#33K** +W* ^"W^ ;^ +W* W2’#^ GO

/ ;?K* X]’/ 8;**’#?WT g"K *^#VK­^* V’3#/ K­^;­6 ^"K ^’+ ­ *^W•KV ^"K]K X’]

*;! ­;6"^*T cK3W#*K *^#VK­^* 3’#?V­ N^ ]KWV;?• ^]WZK? 2W3z W­V X’]^" ^"K• +K]K

;/ / K]*KV ;­ ^"K ^’+­* ;^* $K’$?K W­V ;^* 3#?^#]KT

g"K 6’W?* ’X ^"K l";?;$*2#]6 $]’—K3^ +K]K / #?^;$?KT l"’^’6]W$";­6 ^"K

$K’$?K ’X W */W?? ^’+ ­ + ’#?V ]K[#;]K *^#VK­^* ^’ ;­ ^K]W3^ W­V K*^W2?;*"

]W$$’ ]^ + ;^" ^"K/T q^#VK­^* + ’#?V ?KW]­ W2’#^ ^"K ^’+ ­*$K’$?KN* ?;XK*^•?K*

W­V ^"K;] ZW?#K *•*^K/*T q^#VK­^* + ’#?V 2K ^Wz;­6 ;­V ;Z ;V#W? $;3^#]K** $"’^’

*^’];K* W­V + ];^;­6 W2’#^ ^"K $K’$?K ^"K• $"’^’6]W$"KVT q’ ^"K• +K]K

]K[#;]KV ^’ #*K W ZW];K^• ’X 3’/ / #­;3W^;’­ W­V —’#]­W?;*/ *z;??*T

E’NmN h5>2x/X5j/ '& t'XX5xV5A f•x52• '& /K5 t 5j z• z A I o C F t 5 j z • z '& /K5 9'>•”2/|'jN i^'”N IA tK2x2V/5x|z/|Vz '& /K5 9'>•”2/|'jA W'j/2j2jA >/N ECN

L

i ­’^"K] 6’W? + W* ^’ *"’+ ]#]W? 8 ’­^W­W W* ;^ ;* ^’VW•T i* u *W;V ;­ ^"K

$]KXW3K ^’ ^"K 2’’z W2’#^ ^"K ^’+­ ^"W^ u $]’V#3KV X’] $#2?;3W^;’­ Y

f ;*^’]• ;* W?;ZK ;­ 8’­^W­WT g"K *^W^K ;* •’#­6 W­V $;’­KK]** + "’ "WZK ^]’#2?K ]K/ K/ 2K];­6 + "W^ "W$$K­KV •K*^K]VW• ’] ?W*^ +KKz* "WZK ];3" / K/ ’];K* ’X ^"K;] KW]?• ?;XK„’X ^"K ’ ?VK*^ ^]W$$K] ;­ ^"K W]KW* ^"K 6’?V / ;­;­6 VW•** ^"K 2#XXW?’ ]’W/ ;­6 ^"K;] ]W­6K** ^"K VW•* 2KX’]K V’6 ’]V;­W­3K*T

f;*^’];3 V;*$?W•* W]K ];3" +;^" •K??’+KV $"’^’6]W$"* ’X ^"K*K $K’$?K„W­V ^"K;] ;/W6K* W­V *^’];K* W]K ^"K]K X’] ^"K Z;K+;­6T c#^ ^;/ K* W]K 3"W­6;­6 W­V ^"K*K 6?;/$*K* ’X ?;XK W]K ­’ ^ 2K;­6 ]K3’]VKV W* ’X ’?VT

g"W^ 2K?;KX + W* ^"K ;/ $K^#* 2K";­V ^";* $]’—K3^T ♦KW]* X]’/ ­’+ * $K’$?K *"’#?V 2K W2?K ^’ ?’’z W^ ^"K;] W­3K*^’]* W­V $]KVK3K**’]* W­V *KK + "W^ ^"K*K $K’$?K +K]K ?;zKT g"K• *"’#?V 2K W2?K ^’ Z;K+ W ?;XK*^•?K ^"W^ +W* W­V $K]"W$* 6W;­ W­ #­VK]*^W­V ;­6 ’X ^"K $K’$?K +"’ 3W/K 2KX’]K ^"K/ TR

♦K^ W­’^"K] 6’W? +W* ^’ $]’Z;VK W $"’^’6]W$";3 W]3";ZK X’] X#^#]K

6K­K]W^;’­*T i ?/ ’*^ KW3" X]W/ K ’X ^"K JO*OOO ’] *’ X]W/ K* ’X X;?/ K!$’*KV

V#];­6 ^"K l";?;$*2#]6 Z;*;^ "W* 2KK­ ;VK­^;X;KVT 8 W­• *^#VK­^* 3’/$?K^KV

3’/ $]K"K­*;ZK 3W$^;’­ ;­X’]/ W^;’­* *’ ­’^ ’­?• +;?? ^"K ­K6W^;ZK* 2K

$]K*K]ZKV* 2# ^ *’ ^’’* ^"K ­W/K* W­V ^"K *^’];K* ’X ^"’*K $"’^’6]W$"KVT

g"K l";?;$*2#]6 $]’—K3^ +W* W33’/$?;*"KV ;­ *KZK]W? $"W*K*T iX^K] ^"K

^’+ ­ +W* *K?K3^KV W­V WX^K] ^"K $]K?;/ ;­W]• ;­[#;];K* "WV 2KK­ / WVK W2’#^

^"K XKW*;2;?;^• ’X 2];­6;­6 *^#VK­^* ^’ V’3#/ K­^ ;^* W V’3#/ K­^W]•

$"’^’6]W$"• 3?W** +W* ’]6W­;■KV X’] *^#VK­^*T g"K *^#VK­ ^* *$K­^ / ’*^ ’X ^"K

[#W]^K] $]K$W];­6 X’] ^"K V’3#/K­^W]•T g"K­ *^W]^;­6 ’­ 8 W• JA* J:GC* ^"K

*^#VK­^* ]K3’]VKV ^"K $K’$?K ’X ^"K ^’+­T x "K­ ^"K• ]K ^# ]­KV ^"K•

Lc'V•z 'j 9K|”|>z0•x-p v W'j/2j2 W|j|j2 b';jN mV'// tx2j:5””A 5:N 92//< 65“z/5jA i•j>•0”|zK5: 0''“A IooFjA >x5&2V5A >N BN

D

3’/ $?K^KV $"’^’ *^’];K* + ;^" ^K!^ W* $W]^ ’X ^"K;] X;­W? $]’—K3^* X’] ^"K [#W]^K]T

g"K• W?*’ + ’]zKV ’­ ^"K 3’/ $]K"K­*;ZK 3W$^;’­ ;­X’]/ W^;’­T

g"K ­K!^ $"W*K +W* ^’ KV;^ ^"K ­KW]?• JO*OOO X]W/ K* + ;^" ^+ ’ 6’W?* ;­

/ ;­VT g"K X;]*^ +W* W ^]WZK?;­6 $"’^’6]W$";3 K!";2;^T g"K X;­W? 6’W? +W* ^’

$#2?;*" W 2’’z ’X ^"K *^#VK­^*N +’]zT q3’^^ .]W­VK??* ^"K­ W 6]WV#W^K *^#VK­^

W^ ^"K 0­;ZK]*;^• ’X 8 ’­^W­W* + ]’^K / #3" ’X ^"K ^K!^T u WVVKV ^K!^* + ]’^K

3W$^;’­** KV;^KV* ?W;V ’#^ W­V VK*;6­KV ^"K 2’’z ’­ W 8 W3;­^’*" 3’/ $#^K]

#*;­6 $W6K ?W•’#^ *’X^+W]KT

p.0q pd

E

PDRGn

MM?l J «P

f;MYY

wLMr9UUU)8;K)8LLLq­

uquqMP * P P T

pp | | p/pp pB m "|3 m *3 |m m m m §mdH&|mm &//////////

kA ,hhh 8

u?;f?*XX?

P b—D

P»PBQQ[ T]*qDDDw

“DMDDD

dy

6 •*D¥\\\*W T$ r s

w"nyYA uq;8x

= I KJP=J= I EJ EJ C P K S J

BY ;N]

, .-3 -

l";?;$*2#]6

s’3#* 1, 6 DEHELO>QNCYR y©DBwDw yCDCD6 m©-D

pQ©B©68wzQ9 wD0 B5VB P' .DC3589CB' ©2 y©DBwDw

b4Q©©1 ©2 u©x8Dw1C9) bBx05DB9 wD0 Sw4x1B'

U0CBCD6 wD0 L59C6D P' pwBB' n5(9B5D

m5VB P' b4©BB T8wD0511

x12Y "66V 2Y UFU2EO­FU ­6 zOIIFL gI2FIo O Z6>ILO]2Y/ qI63FYY6Io &16 O]&O\Y FLE6>IO0FU 12Y Y­>UFL­Yk

x1OLVY ­6 /\ 1>Y"OLUo P2/ J6qq OLU /\ E12]UIFLo P6F] OLU JF^2Lo &16YF Y>qq6I­ /6­2^O­FU /F ­1I6>01 ­12Y qI6ZFE­k

yLU 32LO]]\o ­1OLVY ­6 yL0>Y :EJ6>0O]] kkk36I 12Y 2LYq2IO­26Lk

;- O­­\ 5FVY­FL

T©z'8C6QB 'OOs b4Q©©1 ©2 u©x8Dw1C9) .DC3589CB' ©2 y©DBwDw yC99©x1wi y©DBwDw

R11 8C6QB9 85958350h o© zw8B ©2 BQC9 P©©( )w' P5 85z8©0x450 CD wD' )wDD58 -QwB9©5358 -CBQ©xB BQ5 5Vz859950 z58)C99C©D ©2 BQ5 zxP1C9Q58i 5V45zB CD BQ5 4w95 ©2 P8C52 7x©BwBC©D9 CD w8BC4159 2©8 853C5-h

U0CB50 wD0 059C6D50 P' pwBB' n5(9B5Dm5VB P' b4©BB T8wD0511pQ©B©9 z8CDB50 P' M©P Tx9Q)wD

m5VB B'z5 CD 'st'' pw1wDBCD© TwzBC©D B'z5 CD 'st'' pw1wDBCD© CBw1C4 E5w01CD59 CD vsgz©CDB pw1wDBCD© 9)w11 4wz9 bxPQ5w09 CD 'Fgz©CDB ow88©- E5135BC4w M©10 pQ©B© 4850CB9 CD Fgz©CDB pw1wDBCD© CBw1C4 mQC9 P©©( -w9 50CB50 wD0 zw6CDwB50 ©D w yw4CDB©9Q 4©)zxB58 x9CD6 pw65yw(58 9©2B-w85 Ew12B©D5 D56wBC359 )w05 -CBQ w g1CD5

51CzCBC4w1 0©B 94855D pwz58 9B©4( C9 p8CDB50 wD0 P©xD0 P'

.6^FI -16­60IOq1jy/ \ RI2F0 U>I2L0 O : O\ Y16&FIo "\ PF33 AFII2Y1

];XX*

-16­6 "\ PF33 AFII2Y1

* «□pvO□

Pb |z/' x< |z 2”|?5 |j W'j/2j2N bK5 z/2/5 |z ”|j- 2j: >|'j55xzA ;K' K2?5 /x'•0”5 j5X05x|j- ;K2/ K2>>5j5: <5z/5x:2< 'x |/ ;55“A K2?5 x|VK X5X'x|5z '& /K5|x 52x”< w*'& /K5 '”:5z/ /x2>>5x |j /K5 2x52A /K5 -'”: |j|j- :2<zA /K5 0•&&2”' x'2X|j- /K5|x X5z/52:zA /K5 :2<z 05&'x5 :'- 'x:|j2jV5zNO|z/'x|V :|z>”2<z 2x5 x|VK ;|/K <5””';5: N'/'-x2>Kz '& /K5z5 >5'>”5—2j: /K5|x 2-5z 2j: z/'x|5z 2x5 /K5x5 &'x /K5 ?|5;|j-A |/ /|X5z 2x5 VK2j-|j- 2j: /K5z5 -”|X>z5z '& B 2x5 j'/ 05|j- x5V'x:5: 2z '& '”:N

b K 2/ 05”|5& ;2z /K5 |X>5/•z 05K|j: /K|z h"5V/N J52xz &x'X j';A >5'>”5 zK'•”: 05 ”5 /' ”''“ 2/ /K5|x 2jV5z/'xz 2j: 5:5V5zz'xz 2j: z55 ;K2/ /K5z5 >5'>”5 ;5x5 5N bK5< zK'•”: 05 20”5 /' ?|5; 2 ”|&5z/<”5 2/ ;2z 2j: >5xK2>z -2|j 2j •j:5xz/2j:|j- /K5 >5'>”5 ;K' V2X5 05&'x5 /K5XN

h'V•X5j/|j- zX2”” /';j vX5x|V2 |z 0< X52jz 2j 'x|-|j2” V'jV5>/A 0•/ /K2/ :'5zjd/

|z5j |/z |X>'x/2jV5N

P j IoYL vj-•z WVh'•-2”” 2j: f|”” ”<“5j:2””A >K'/' >x'&5zz'xzA /''“ /K5|x |:5j/z /' /K5 zX2”” W|zz'•x| x|?5x /';j '& |>•z /' :'V•X5j/ /K5 /';j 2j: /K5 >5'>”5A •x X'x5 zX2”” */';j 0''“z ;5x5 >x':•V5: >K'/'"'•xj2”|zX z/•:5j/z 2/ /K5 ’j|?5xz|/< W|zz'•x| |j /K5 j5q/ /5j <52xzN P 05”|5?5 fz5 0''“z 2x5 j'/ 'j”< ?2”•20”5 /' /K5 ?jz 2j: /' /K5 x5”2/|?5zA 0•/ 2”z' /' •zN |5< K5”> •z ?|z•2”|]5 2 ”|&5z/<”5 /K2/ X2< j'/ '•x ';jNbK5 9K|”|>z0•x- 0''“ |z >2//5xj5: 2&/5x

U W|zz'•x| 0''“zN vj-•z WVh'•-2””A j'; wx'&5zz'x 5X5x|/•z 2/ W|zz'•x|A V”|X05: X< 2 K|”” |j 9K|”|>z0•x- |j v>x|” IoCY ;K5j P zK';5: j '•x zX2”” /';jN

bK5x5 |z 'j5 zX2”” :|&&5x5jV5A K';5?5xN Q5 K2?5 /x|5: >x'?|:5 j'/ 'j”< :'V•X5j/2x< >K'/'-x2>Kz '& /K5 /';jA / 2”z' 2j 5q/5jz|?5 /5q/ /' >x'?|:5 2 05//5x •j:5xz/2j:|j- /K5 >5'>”5 2j: /K5|x >x'0”5Xz 2j: /x|•X>KzN mV'// 2j:5””A 2j 5:|/'xS:5z|-j5x &'x /K5 .x52/ c2””z bx|0•j5A 5j/ X2j< K'•xz |j/5x?|5;|j- /K5 >5'>”5 '& /K5 /';j ”5j K5 ;2z 2 -x2:•2/5 z/•:5j/ 2/ ’WN Pj K|z ';j ;'x:z | 2|X '& /K5 V'X0|j5: >K'/'z 2j: /5q/ |zp a /' >x':•V5 2 /|j- x5j:|/|'j |j 0'/K >K'/'-x2>Kz 2j: ;'x:z '& ”|&5 |j k zX2”” /';j '& 9K|”|>z0•x-Na

# P§?5 5:|/5: 2j: •>:2/5: /K5 /5q/A VK'z5j 2”” /K5 '/'-x2>Kz &'x /K5 0''“ 2j: ;x|//5j /K5 '•/”|j5z 2z ;5”” 2::5: /5q/N P ;|zK /' /K2j“ mV'//A vj-•z WVh'•-2””A : z'V|'”'-< >x'&5zz'x 92•” W|””5x &'x 2”” /K5|x K5”> 2j: >>'x/ |j X2“|j- /K|z 0''“ >'zz|0”5N

f'0 t•zKX2jA 2 &'xX5x ?|z|/|j- ”5V/•x5x 2/ ’WA

>x|j/5: 2”X'z/ 2”” /K5 >K'/'-x2>Kz &'x /K|z 0''“ 2j: &'x 2j 5qK|0|/N s

f • / X'z/ '& 2”” Pd: ”|“5 /' /K2j“ /K5 >5'>”5 '& 9K|”|>z0•x- &'x /K5|x >2/|5jV5A /K5|x V''>5x2/|'j 2j: /K5|x ;|””|j-j5zz /' zK2x5 /K5|x ”|?5z ;|/K '/K5xzN

bK5 z/•:5j/ >K'/'-x2>K5xz &'x /K|z 0''“ ;5x5p G|X h2?|:z'j '& h5V2/•xA .2Ny tK•V“ U”|2zz5j '& U2-”5 6|?5xA v”2z“2y G5&& .5xx|zK '& 6'j2jA W'j/Ny b':: .'':x|VK '& bx'<A W'j/Ny fx|2j H5””5x '& Q2•“5-2jA IIINy 6'-5x W2|5xA '& W|zz'•”2y mK5|”2 W5”?|j '& .x52/ c2””zy H2x5j ,|VK'”z '& m|”?5x m>x|j-A W:Ny Q5j:< ,'x-22x: '& W|zz'•”2y W|VK5””5 9'””2x: '& O5”5j2y G5&& mX|/K '& W|zz'•”2 2j:.x5- ^2j b|-K5X '& .x52/ c2””zN

Q5 K'>5 /' V'j/|j•5 :'V•X5j/|j- x•x2” ”|&5z/<”5z |j W'j/2j2N

'-O­­\ 5FVY­FL

W

G W; Q«4 j R OQW4 ;

JA S W□TP 4p Q.□ * vPQ

JG Q .□ Q 4 T ; Q 4jvV

RU V 4 R Q.

AA P4OWv: : Wp□

LS p v WQ.

SR » vBW;— v : WSW;—

GO — «4T W;— 4 :j

GS : Wp□ — 4□P 4 ;

GG Q . □ * «4b□OQ

2L YE166] /O­1 ­FOE1FI P2/ MF"LFY OF]qY P>Y­2L $2E­6I &6IV 6L O qI6"]F/k MF"LFY Y L6& IF­2IFUk -16­6 "\ AIF0 $OL x201F/

8 . 4 3 '*xpDJLg CxgLL

, 2 /• x 2 ” x5z'•xV5z[/K5|x 5q/x2V/|'j 2j: :5?5”'>X5j/[K2?5 2”;2<z 055j /K5 X2|jz/2< '& 9K|”|>z0•x-N

v :|&&5x5j/ 2>>x'2VK /' 9K|”|>z0•x-Yz x5z'•xV5zA K';55xA |z ?'|V5: 0< |j5 ”'V2” /52VK5x ;K' >x'V”2|XzA aJ'•/K |z /K5 'j”< x5z'•xV5 /K2/ x52””< X2//5xz |j /K|z /';jNa

v”/K'•-K /K|z 2zz5zzX5j/ X|-K/ j'/ 05 •j|?5xz2””< zK2x5:A /K5 <'•/K '& 9K|”|>z0•x- 2x5 2j |X>'x/2j/ &'V•z &'x 0'/K &2X|”< 2j: V'XX•j|/<N

9K|”|>z0•x- K2z LFF z/•:5j/z '& zVK''” 2-5A 2j: /K5|x 2V/|?|/|5z 2x5 2 X2|j 2//x2V/|'jA j'/ 'j”< &'x >2x5j/z 0•/ '/K5xz |j /';j QK5/K5x |/dz ”|//”5*”52-•5 02z502””A <'•/K ;x5z/”|j-A zVK''” X•z|V zK';z 'x K|-K zVK''” z>'x/z 5?5j/zA /';jz>5'>”5 2x5 ”|“5”< /' /2“5 2 :55> |j/5x5z/N

bK5 zVK''”zA '& V'•xz5A 2xV /K5 V5j/5x '& 2V/|?|/<NvVV'x:|j- /' &'xX5x zVK''” 0'2x: X5X05x h2?55 WV.•|x5AaQK2/ -'5z 'j /K5x5 |j /K5 zVK''” ;|/K /K5 “|:z |z /K5 K52x/ '& /K5 V'XX•j|/< 2j: /K5 ;K'”5 /';j x5?'”?5z 2x'•j: |/Na

b K 5 z|]5 '& /K5 /';j |z V'jz|:5x5: 0< X2j< >2x5j/z /' 05 2 0'j•z &'x /K5|x VK|”:x5jN h'•- W'xx|z'j z55z X•VK -x52/5x '>>'x/•j|/|5z 2?2|”20”5 &'x K|z /;' VK|”:x5jA >2x/|V•”2x”< |j z>'x/zA /K2j /K5< ;'•”: &|j: |j 2 ”2x-5x V'XX•j|/<N aU?5x<0':< >x5//< X•VK V2j >2x/|V|>2/5Aa K5 z2<zN T'j-/|X5 x5z|:5j/ h'””< 92-5 2::zA aJ'• V2j 'j”< 05 IEF >'•j:z 2j: >”2< &''/02”” |j 9K|”|>z0•x-A 2j: /K5 “|:z 2”” V2j X2“5 /K5 /52X 2j: :'Na

f5<'j: zVK''”A VK|”:x5j V2j >2x/|V|>2/5 |j 5?5x</K|j- &x'X zV'•/|j- /' z>'x/z /' VK•xVK -x'•>zA 0•/ j'/ 2”” /K5 '>>'x/•j|/|5z &'x VK|”:x5j 2x5 j5V5zz2x|”< 'x-2j|]5:N bK5x5 2x5 z/|”” >”5j/< '& VK2jV5z &'x z|X>”< >”2<|j-A 2z ;5”” 2z /K5 2x52dz X2j< '&&5x|j-z |j '•/:''x x5Vx52/|'jN

gP

”5X'/|Vz

MZ’d̂

F Y Y Y Y h

. uq *C mG"Vqrq m/yp z|>

C6I2 '1O& qIOE­2EFY /6/FL­Y "F36IF O E6LEFI­k-16­6 "\ x6UU A66UI2E1

' 6 E 2O ] ]23F 2Y 63­FL O 3O/ 2]\ O33O2IN MFIF AIOLUqO ­OVFY 12Y 0IOLUY6L OLU U60 36IO &O]V 6L -12]2qY">I0iY /O2L Y­IFF­k

-16­6 "\AIF0 $OL x201F/

4

“

9 6 > EOL OEE>/>]O­F O ]6­ 63 qOI­Y 2L r* \FOIY 63 6qFIO­26Lk y"6^Fo y] gF]] YFOIE1FY ­1I6>01 ­1F qOI­Y EO­O]60 36I O 0OY EOq ­1O­ &2]] 32­ O E>Y­6/FIiY IFEIFO­26LO] ^F12E]Fk MF &OY >LO"]F ­6 32LU ­1F EOq 2L ­1F E>IIFL­ 2L^FL­6I\ Y6 1F IFqO2IFU ­1F "I6VFL 6LF 2L ­1F 0OIO0Fk vOI ]F3­o Q5z M6qqo wx1F K6I­1 JOV6­O J>­E1/OLo’ ­OVFY ­2/F 6>­ ­6 1O^F O E20OIF­­F "F36IF &6IV2L0 6L ­1F v6IU ­I>EV "F12LU 12/k

-16­6Y "\ AIF0 $OL x201F/

ZI FF

■&& |■m |> ”<nmm|&5&V&|KKm|mf|Lr”L>$ * a

;0*8i82Vxj53

ffbIJ\ )J 1T ; / + + W

z2LL2L01633 :6­6IY 1OY "FFL 2L 6qFIO­26L Y2LEF e,c, OLU ­1F &O]]Y IF3]FE­ ­1F qOYY2L0 63 ­2/F OLU ­1F qFIY6LO]2­2FY 63 ­16YF &16 2 O­ ­1F 0OIO0Fk yY ­1F \FOIY 06 " \ o /6IF OLU /6IF 12Y­6I\ 2Y OUUFU ­6 ­1F &O]Vk -16­6 "\ AIF0 $OL x201F/

z|”?5x -”'x< :2<z |j 9K|”|>z0•x- 2j: .x2j|/5 z/|”” 20'•j:5:N Q|jj|j-K'&& j'/5z /K2/ ;K5j z|”?5x ;2z :5X'j5/2x|]5: |j /K5 ICoFzA a5?5x<0':< ;2”“5: '•/ '& 9K|”|>z0•x- 2j: .x2j|/5N Pj /K2/ :2< 2j: 2-5A ;K5j /K5 X|j5z V”'z5: :';jA /K5x5 ;2z j'/K|j- &'x /K5X /' :'N bK5< "•z/ ;2”“5: '&& 2j: ”5&/ 5?5x</K|j- •> /K5x5Na

m'X 5; K2/ x•5&•””<A Q|jj|j-K'&& x5V2””z '& K|z <'•/KA abK5x5 ;5x5 2”” “|j:z '& K'•z5z ”5&/ |j/2V/ |j .x2j|/5N Q5 0x'“5 X'x5 ;|j:';z 2j: :|zK5z /K2j P V'•”: x5X5X05xNa

vz K5 -2]5z '•/ /K5 ;|j:'; '& Q|jj|j-K'&& W'/'xzA K5 |z /'•VK5: 0< '/K5x X5X'x|5zA 2z K5 ;2/VK5z VK|”:x5j z”|:|j- :';j /K5 K|”” 05”'; /K5 zVK''”N aQK5j P ;2z 2 “|:A ;5 z”|: :';j /K2/ z2X5 K|””A /K5 z2X5 '”: K|”” &'x YB <52xz j';Na

Q|jj|j-K'&& x5X5X05xz /K5 0|- X2j-2j5z5 X|j|j- z•x-5 |j Q'x”: Q2x P |j 9K|”|>z0•x-N am|j-”5 X|j5xz V'X|j- |j K5x5 K2: 2 K5”” '& 2 /|X5 &|j:|j- 2 >”2V5 /' z/2<Aa Q|jj|j-K'&& z2<zA j'/|j- /K2/ /K5 /';j z;5””5: /' IABFF* EAFFF >5'>”5N a1j5 0'2x:|j- K'•z5 K2: /' x•j zK|&/zN 1j5 zK|&/ ;'•”: -5/ •> 2j: -' /' ;'x“ 2j: /K5 '/K5x ;'•”: V'X5 |j 2j: -' /' 05:Na

v z|X|”2x 0''X 0''z/5: 0< X2j-2j5z5 5j?5”'>5: /K5 /';j |j Q'x”: Q2x PPN a1•/z|:5 '& /K5X /;' /|X5zA /K5

/';j x5X2|j5: 20'•/ IAIFF >5'>”5[>x5//< z/20”5Aa Q|jj|j-K'&& z2<zN w— /K|j“ /K5 '?5x2”” >|V/•x5 '& 9K|”|>z0•x- K2z 055j 2 ”|//”5 0|/ X'x5 z/20”5 /K2j X'z/Na

O5dz j'/ z•x5 5q2V/”< ;K5x5 /K2/ z/20|”|/< V'X5z &x'X j'x |z K5 V5x/2|j ;K< Q|jj|j-K'&& W'/'xz K2z z•x?|?5: ”'j-N bK5 :52”5xzK|> |z /K5 z5V'j: '”:5z/ |j W'j/2j2N

m'X5 '& /K5 0•z|j5zzdz z•VV5zz X2< :5x|?5 &x'X Q|jj|j-K'&&dz 5?5x*zX|”|j- '>/|X|zX 2j: K|z z2/|z&2V/|V |j X2“|j- 9K|”|>z0•x- K|z K'X5N

bK2/ '>/|X|zX V2j 05 V'j/2-|'•zN vz K|-K zVK''” /52g m2j:< Q2//•”2 >•/z |/A aO5|j|5 Q|jj|j-K'&& 5>|/'X|]5z 5?5x</K|j- -'': 20'•/ /K|z /';jNa mK5 z2<z 9K|”|>z0•x- '”:/|X5xzA >2x/|V•”2x”< O5|j|5A aK2?5 5jx|VK5: X< ”|&5 05<'j: 05”|5&N bK5<d?5 -|?5j X5 |jz|-K/ /K2/ 9K|”|>z0•| ;|”” 05 K5x5 &'x5?5xNa

Q |j j |j -K '&&dz ”5-2V< X2< 05A /''N O|z z'jz 2x5 &'””';|j- K|X j'/ 'j”< |j 0•z|j5zzA 0•/ 2”z' |j 9K|”|>z0| x5z|:5jV5p 0'/K W|“5 2j: f'0 K2?5 055j ”|&5/|X5 9K|”|>z0•x-5xz 5qV5>/ &'x <52xz z>5j/ |j /K5 z5x?|V5 'x 2” V'””5-5N

QK2/ O5|j|5 Q|jj|j-K'&& K2z 0•|”/A 0'/K 'j 0•z|j5zz 2j: &2X|”< ”5?5”zA V'•”: ;5”” V'j/|j•5 2z 2j |j/5-x2” >2| 9K|”|>z0•x-dz &•/•x5N

5c

Q . □ * «4b□OQu*Nj W2< IoCY /K|x/55j z/•:5j/z 2j: /;' >K'/'"'•xj2”|zX

/52VK5xz z>5j/ z|q :2<z 2j: j|-K/z |j 2 zX2”” W'j/2j2 X|j|j- /';jN bK5 "'•xj2”|z/z ;5x5 /K5x5 /' x5V'x: /K5 ”|?5z '& /K5 >5'>”5 '& 9K|”|>z0•x-N bK5< ;5x5 /x<|j- /' V2>/•x5 /K5 ?|z•2” 5zz5jV5 '& /K5 /';jA 0•/ X'x5 z>5V|&|V2””< /' :'V•X5j/ /K5 :2<z 2j: j|-K/zA /K5 z/'x|5z '& /K5 x5z|:5j/zN

m|q :2<z |j /K5 ”|?5z '& /K5 >5'>”5 '& 2 zX2”” /';j |z j'/ X52j/ /' 05 2 V'X>”5/5 x5V'x:A X5x5”< 2 z2X>”|j- '& ;K2/ /K5 x5z|:5j/z 2x5 ”|“5 |j /K5 ”2/5 /;5j/|5/K V5j/•x<N

vz mV'// tx2j:5””A /K5 /5q/ 2•/K'x '& /K|z 0''“ z2|: |j 2j 2x/|V”5 &'x 2 X2-2]|j5 20'•/ /K5 >x'"5V/p

abK5< 5q>”'x5: 5?5x<;K5x5A &x'X /K5 K2””z '& /K5 K|-K zVK''” /' /K5 :2x“A z•0/5xx2j52j /•jj5”z '& /K5 f”2V“ 9|j5 z|”?5x X|j5y &x'X /K5 :';j/';j 02xz /' /K5 VK•xVK5z 'j /K5 K|”” 20'?5y &x'X /K5 :2<*V2x5 V5j/5x /' /K5 j•xz|j- K'X5 j5q/ :''xy 2j: 5?5j |j/' K'X5z &'x 2 ”''“ 2/ &2X|”< ”|&5Na

b K 5 >•x>'z5z '& /K5 >x'"5V/ ;5x5 X2j<p /' Vx52/5 2j 2xVK|?2” >'x/x2|/ '& 2 zX2”” /';jA /' -|?5 z/•:5j/z >x2V/|V2” 5q>5x|5jV5 |j >x':•V|j- |j*:5>/K >K'/' z/'x|5z |j x52” ”|&5 z|/•2/|'jz 2j: /' &'z/5x 2 -x52/5x :5-x55 '& •j:5xz/2j:|j- 0< z/•:5j/z 2j: x5z|:5j/zN

h•x|j- /K5|x z/2< z/•:5j/z ”|?5: |j X2“5zK|&/ ~•2x/5xz VK•xVK5zN bK5 ;'X5j z/2<5: |j /K5 9x5z0</5x|2j tK•x: 2j: /K5 X5j •z5: /K5 t2/K'”|V tK•xVK V'XX•j|/< x''X c|”X ;2z >x'V5zz5: /K5 z2X5 :2< |/ ;2z zK'/ |j /K5 K|-K zVK''” >K'/'-x2>K< ”20N U2VK j|-K/ 5q/5jz|?5 Vx|/|~•5 z5zz|'jz ;5x5 V'j:•V/5: 2j: z/•:5j/z ?5j/•x5: '•/ |j/' /K5 /';j 2j: |/z z•xx'•j:|j-z /' V'X>”5/5 /K5|x z/'x|5zN

b K 5 x5z•”/p IFAFFF &x2X5z '& 0”2V“*2j:*;K|/5 &|”XA /” 0''“ 2j: 2j 5qK|0|/ /K2/ '>5j5: 2/ /K5 ’j|?5xz|/< '& W'j/2j2 |j /K5 &2”” '& IoCC 2j: ;2z ”2z/ 'j :|z>”2< |j 9K|”|>z0•x- :•x|j- G•”< 2j: v•-•z/ '& IoCoN

bK5j z5j|'x b':: .'':x|VK ij'; 2 >K'/'-x2>K5x &'x O2?x5 h2|”< ,5;zj z2|: '& /K5 >x'"5V/p abK5 0|--5z/ /K|x -'/ '•/ '& |/ ;2z :52”|j- ;|/K >5'>”5 /K2/ V”'z5”<N J'• ”| ;|/K /K5Xy <'•dx5 |j /K5|x K'X5zN P/ K5”>5: X5 -5/ V”'z5 X< z•0"5V/z /K2j P§?5 5?5x 055j 05&'x5Na

Pj >x5>2x2/|'j &'x /K5 'j*z|/5 ?|z|/ /' 9K|”|>z0•x-A /K5 >K'/' V”2zz z/•:|5: /K5 z'V|'”'-< '& zX2”” /';jz 2j: /K5 K|z/'x< 2j: /5VKj|~•5z '& :'V•X5j/2x< >K'/'-x2>K<N b V”2zz 2”z' V'jz•”/5: ;|/K vj-•z WVh'•-2””A >x'&5zz'x 5X5x|/•z &x'X /K5 ’j|?5xz|/< '& W|zz'•x|A ;K' >|'j55x5 :'V•X5j/2x< V'?5x2-5 '& zX2”” /';jz 0< "'•xj2”|zX z/•:5j/zN

'­>UFL­Y OII2^F 2L -12]2qY">I0 2L :O\ e,Bn OLU OIF 02^FL O ­6>I 63 ­1F ­6&L "\ :2VF RO16Fo O LO­2^F IFY2UFL­A &16 &6>]ULi­ ]2^F OL\&1FIF F]YFk gF12LU ­1F/ 2Y ­1F 12Y­6I2E ZO2] ­1O­ Y­2]] 1OY O L66YF 1OL02L0 2L ­1F ­6&FI &2LU6&k -16­6 "\ -O­­\ 5F1

­­