+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Prenatal Sono graphic Evaluation ofShort- limbed Dwarfism: … · 2015-12-11 · achondroplasia....

Prenatal Sono graphic Evaluation ofShort- limbed Dwarfism: … · 2015-12-11 · achondroplasia....

Date post: 06-Jun-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 2 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
20
Prenatal Sono graphic Evaluation of Short- limbed Dwarfism: An Algorithmic Approach1 Beverly A. Spirt, MD Michael Ol4hant, MD Ronald H. Gottlieb, MD2 Lawrence P. Gordon, MD Prenatal sonographic evaluation of short-limbed dwarfism is initiated when a significantly shortened femur is found or by referral of a pa- tient with a family history of skeletal dysplasia. If a short femur is demonstrated, all the long bones are measured and evaluated for bow- ing, fractures, and mineralization. The bone dysplasia is categorized according to whether it is mesomelic, rhizomelic, or micromelic and whether bowing or fractures are present. The fetal spine, head, tho- rax, hands, and feet are carefully evaluated to differentiate the type of bone dysplasia and to determine whether it is lethal. Serial examina- tions may be necessary. This approach will provide sufficient infor- mation to counsel the family, manage the pregnancy, and direct the postnatal evaluation. U INTRODUCTION Skeletal dysplasias occur in approximately 0.024% of births (1). A prenatal sono- graphic evaluation for a short-limbed dwarf may be initiated because of the mci- dental finding of a shortened or bowed extremity or as a result of a referral be- cause of a family history of skeletal dysplasia. It is essential to remember that the definitive diagnosis of bone dysplasia is made postnatably based on clinical and ra- diographic criteria. The purposes of prenatal detection are to counsel the family, manage the pregnancy, and direct the appropriate postnatal radiobogic evaluation. We present an organized approach to the detection and evaluation of bone dyspla- sias in utero. Index terms: Bones, osteochondrod’splasias, 40. 151 , 40. 1 52 #{149} Fetus, abnormalities, 856.87 1 , 856.873 #{149} Fetus, US studies, 856. 1 298 #{149} Pregnancy, US studies, 856.1298 RadloGraphics 1990; 10:217-236 i From the Departments ofRadiology (B.A.S., R.H.G.) and Pathology (L.P.G.), SUN5’ Health Science Center, 750 6 Ad- ams St. Syracuse, NY 1 32 10 and the I)epartments of Medical Imaging (M .0. ) and Pathology (L. PG . ). Crouse Irving Memorial Hospital, Syracuse. NY. From the 1988 RSNA annual meeting. Receivedjanuary 31 , 1989: revision request- ed April 20 and receivedjune 30; accepted November 1 5. Address reprint requests to B.A.S. 2 Current address: Department of Radiology. Wilson Memorial Hospital, Johnson City, NY. C RSNA. 1990 217
Transcript
Page 1: Prenatal Sono graphic Evaluation ofShort- limbed Dwarfism: … · 2015-12-11 · achondroplasia. Thegestational ages atwhich thedifferent skeletal dysplasias areseen vary; therefore,

Prenatal Sono graphicEvaluation of Short-limbed Dwarfism:An AlgorithmicApproach1Beverly A. Spirt, MD

Michael Ol4hant, MD

Ronald H. Gottlieb, MD2

Lawrence P. Gordon, MD

Prenatal sonographic evaluation of short-limbed dwarfism is initiatedwhen a significantly shortened femur is found or by referral of a pa-tient with a family history of skeletal dysplasia. If a short femur is

demonstrated, all the long bones are measured and evaluated for bow-ing, fractures, and mineralization. The bone dysplasia is categorized

according to whether it is mesomelic, rhizomelic, or micromelic and

whether bowing or fractures are present. The fetal spine, head, tho-rax, hands, and feet are carefully evaluated to differentiate the type of

bone dysplasia and to determine whether it is lethal. Serial examina-tions may be necessary. This approach will provide sufficient infor-mation to counsel the family, manage the pregnancy, and direct thepostnatal evaluation.

U INTRODUCTION

Skeletal dysplasias occur in approximately 0.024% of births (1). A prenatal sono-

graphic evaluation for a short-limbed dwarf may be initiated because of the mci-

dental finding of a shortened or bowed extremity or as a result of a referral be-cause of a family history of skeletal dysplasia. It is essential to remember that thedefinitive diagnosis of bone dysplasia is made postnatably based on clinical and ra-

diographic criteria. The purposes of prenatal detection are to counsel the family,

manage the pregnancy, and direct the appropriate postnatal radiobogic evaluation.We present an organized approach to the detection and evaluation of bone dyspla-

sias in utero.

Index terms: Bones, osteochondrod�’splasias, 40. 1 5 1 , 40. 1 52 #{149}Fetus, abnormalities, 856.87 1 , 856.873 #{149}Fetus, US

studies, 856. 1 298 #{149}Pregnancy, US studies, 856.1298

RadloGraphics 1990; 10:217-236

i From the Departments ofRadiology (B.A.S., R.H.G.) and Pathology (L.P.G.), SUN�5’ Health Science Center, 750 6 Ad-

ams St. Syracuse, NY 1 32 1 0 and the I)epartments of Medical Imaging (M .0. ) and Pathology (L. PG . ). Crouse Irving

Memorial Hospital, Syracuse. NY. From the 1988 RSNA annual meeting. Receivedjanuary 31 , 1989: revision request-

ed April 20 and receivedjune 30; accepted November 1 5. Address reprint requests to B.A.S.

2 Current address: Department of Radiology. Wilson Memorial Hospital, Johnson City, NY.

C RSNA. 1990

217

Page 2: Prenatal Sono graphic Evaluation ofShort- limbed Dwarfism: … · 2015-12-11 · achondroplasia. Thegestational ages atwhich thedifferent skeletal dysplasias areseen vary; therefore,

Prenatal evaluation for short-limbed dwarf initiated

because of

positive family history

normal femur length

seriai measurements beyond 27 weeks

io riek oui heterozygous achondropiasa

Nabnormal femur length

(<95th %ile)

measure all long bonesevaluate bones for bowing,

fracture, mineralizationmeasure cardiothoracic (C 1)

ratio; thoracic circumferenceevaluate spine: mineralization,

curvatureevaluate hands, feet: polydactyly,

Hitchhiker thumb, clubbingevaluate head: shape; hydro-

cephalus

Classification of short�limbed dwarfs by bone

measurements

_/1\_Mesomelic Rhizomelic Micromelic

Langer SyndromeNrevergeit SRe’nhardl SRob�riow SWerner S

Heterozygousachoridroplasra

chOndrOdyS�aasapunclala

I I IMiLd Mild. Bowed #{149}1e�reJeune Syndrome Osreogenesis mperiecia Thanaiophoric DwarfEihs-vancreveid S (Type iii) Homozygous achondropiasiaDrasirophrc Dwarf Campiomelic dwarf Achondrogenesis

Hypophosphaiasia

Osleogenesisimpertecta (Type ii)

Shod dbbed polydaoyiy

syndromes

Figure 3. Algorithm 2 for classification of short-limbed dwarfism on the basis of long-bone mea-surements. S = syndrome.

218 U RadioGrapbics U Spirt et a! Volume 10 Number 2

It is especially important to identify those

bone dysplasias that are lethal (listed in or-der of decreasing frequency [i -3]) : thanato-

phoric dysplasia; osteogenesis imperfecta,

type II; achondrogenesis, types I and II;Jeune syndrome (may be nonlethal) ; hypo-

phosphatasia (congenital lethal form) ; chon-

droectodermal dysplasia (usually nonlethal);

chondrodysplasia punctata, rhizomelic type;

camptomelic dysplasia; short-rib polydactyly

syndromes I, II, and III; and homozygous

achondroplasia.The gestational ages at which the different

skeletal dysplasias are seen vary; therefore,the diagnosis of an abnormality should not

be excluded if it is not visualized during a

single in utero examination. Often, serial ex-aminations are necessary (eg, for achondro-

plasia [4]) . The classification we present is

intended as a starting point and is based on

the present understanding of skeletal dyspla-sias. Although not all the abnormalities and

variants fit neatly into groups, the categories

are sufficiently broad to accommodate mostcases. All types are not illustrated, and someare not shown sonographically because of

their rarity.

U APPROACHThe diagnosis of short-limbed dwarfism

should be suspected when the femur length is

below the 95% confidence limits. To deter-

mine whether one is dealing with a general-

ized bone dysplasia, all long bones of the fe-

tus must be measured and evaluated for bow-ing, fractures, and mineralization (Fig 1).

The sonographic evaluation of minerabiza-tion is difficult. Useful signs of decreased

mineralization include an unusually promi-

nent falx (5) , absent or decreased visuabiza-

tion of the spine (6) , decreased bone echo-genicity, and nonuniform or weak acoustic

shadowing (7).The dysplasia can then be characterized

according to which limb segments are most

prominently involved and whether bowing is

Figure 1. Algorithm I for prenatal evaluation ofshort-limbed dwarfism.

the predominant feature (Figs 2 , 3) . Evalua-tion of the other parameters listed in algo-

rithm 1 aid in the differential diagnosis with-

in each classification (Figs 4-6).

A complete evaluation of the fetal head,spine, thorax, hands, and feet should be per-

formed (Fig i) . Examination of the thorax

should include measurement of the cardio-

thoracic ratio and thoracic circumference todifferentiate a cardiac from a pulmonary ab-

normality.

Page 3: Prenatal Sono graphic Evaluation ofShort- limbed Dwarfism: … · 2015-12-11 · achondroplasia. Thegestational ages atwhich thedifferent skeletal dysplasias areseen vary; therefore,

a. b. C.

d. e.

March 1990 Spirt et al U RadioGrapbics U 219

Figure 2. Drawings depict the skeletalcharacteristics of the three classificationsof short-limbed dwarfism as they are seenin the leg. (a) Normal leg. (b) In meso-melic dwarfism, there is disproportion-ate shortening of the tibia and fibula.(c) In rhizomelic dwarfism, there is dis-proportionate shortening of the femur.(d, e) In micromelic dwarfism, there isdisproportionate shortening of the entireleg. This classification is further subdi-vided into mild (d), mild and bowed,and severe (e).

Page 4: Prenatal Sono graphic Evaluation ofShort- limbed Dwarfism: … · 2015-12-11 · achondroplasia. Thegestational ages atwhich thedifferent skeletal dysplasias areseen vary; therefore,

Mesomelic: differential diagnosis, prognosis

normal C T ratio, thoracic circumference

normal spinenormal headno polydactyly

Syndromes as in Algorithm II:NONLETHAL

Rhizomelic: differential diagnosis, prognosis

has not been reported on

inutero ultrasound

Micromelic: differential diagnosis, prognosis

decreased horace circumferenceincreased C T ratio

normal spnemay have polydactyly

Micromelic: differential diagnosis, prognosis

mild, bowed

Camptomelic dwarf’LETHAL

Micromelic : differential diagnosis. prognosis

severe

increased C T ratio

decreased horace circumference

C-

220 U RadioGrapblcs U Spirt et al Volume 10 Number 2

‘If any of these parameters are abnormal, obtain serial

measurements and consider moving to another category.

Figure 4. Algorithm 3 for diagnosis of mesome-lic dwarfism. CT cardiothoracic.

stippled epiphyses

Chondrodysplasia punctata,

Rhizomelic formLETHAL

Heterozygous achondroplasia’

NONLETHAL

‘If initial measurements of femurare normal. do serial measurementsbeyond 27 weeks

Figure 5. Algorithm 4 for diagnosis of rhizome-licdwarfism. CT cardiothoracic.

normal C T ratio and thoraciccircumference

(hand and spine abnormalities

seen on postnatal radiographs

have risl been reported on in

utero utrasound I

mild

may have slightly decreased thoracic ratiomay have increased C T ratiomay have abnormal curvature of spineHitchhiker thumb. abnormal great toe

Jeune syndrome (ATD)’Ellis - Van Creveld”

Guarded Prognosis: _____________MAY BE LETHAL

. Evahiate fetal kidneys

Evaluate fetal heart

a.

Diastrophic dwarf

NONLETHAL(except for rare lethal form

associated with tracheal hypoplasial

normal mineralization, decreased mineralization, decreased mineralization.no fractures no fractures fractures

N\ IThanafophoric Dwarf Osteogenesis imperfectaHomozygous �ct�ondroptasia (Type It)(Achondro�enesis) (Hypophoaphatasla)

LETHAL \\\\ LETHAL

pof�actyly

AchondrogenesisHypophosphatasia

LETHAL

Short rib potydactyty syndrome

LETHAL

�normal cerveal spinefracturesnormal C T ratio increased C I ratio

decreased thoracic circumference

Osteogenesis imperfecta(Type Ill)

NONLETHAL

b.

‘ evaluate for abnormal scapula,disproportionate tibia\fibula

Figure 6. Algorithm 5 for diagnosis of mild (a),

mild and bowed (b), and severe (C) micromelicdwarfism. ATD = atrial septal defect, CT car-diothoracic.

U MESOMELIC DWARFISM

Mesomelic dwarfism (Fig 4) is characterized

by a shortening of the radius and ulna or tibia

and fibula (Fig 2b) . This sign is one of themajor characteristics of the Langer, Niever-

gelt, Reinhardt, Robinow, and Werner syn-

dromes. These syndromes are all hereditaryautosomal dominant conditions except for[anger syndrome, which is an autosomal re-cessive condition.

The mesomelic syndromes are not lethal,

and the definitive diagnosis is made postna-tally on the basis of clinical and radiographic

criteria. Patients with Robinow syndrome

may be mentally retarded; patients with the

Page 5: Prenatal Sono graphic Evaluation ofShort- limbed Dwarfism: … · 2015-12-11 · achondroplasia. Thegestational ages atwhich thedifferent skeletal dysplasias areseen vary; therefore,

80

60

Upper 99% Cl

40

20

9% Cl

0 -I.’ ________20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55

-���l’�”’\ �

�s,I .�:�:‘:

� #{149}i”��

,� ,‘,‘:‘:�‘60 65 70 75 80 85 90

Biparietal Diameter (mm)

i.e

C.

4w

Figure 7. Heterozygous achondroplasia. (a) Femur length (0) normal at 1 7 weeks gestational age.Growth curve flattened between 20 and 22 weeks. Cl = confidence limit. (Adapted from reference 4.)

(b) Sonogram obtained at 22 weeks shows short femur (length is below 95% confidence limits) . Bone ap-pears otherwise normal. (C) On xeroradiograph offetus, humeri appear slightly short. Although radio-graphic criteria are not apparent at this stage, diagnosis was confirmed by means of electron microscopy.(Fig 7b and 7c courtesy ofAbfred Kurtz, MD, ThomasJefferson University Hospital, Philadelphia.)

other syndromes should have normal intelli-gence.

U RHIZOMELIC DWARFISM

Rhizomelic dwarfism (Fig 5) is characterized

by shortening of the humerus or femur (Fig

2c) . Two conditions belong to this classifica-

tion: heterozygous achondropbasia and chon-

drodysplasia punctata, rhizomelic type.

Heterozygous Acbondroplasia.-This con-

dition is the most common nonlethal bone

dysplasia, with a prevalence of one in26,000 births (2) . The condition may be in-herited (autosomab dominant pattern) , or it

may arise due to new mutation of genes.

On in utero sonograms of a fetus with het-

erozygous achondroplasia, the proximal long

bones are shortened, have normal mineral-ization, and have no fractures. The cardio-

thoracic ratio is normal. Initially, the lengths

of the femurs are normal, but by 27 weeks

gestational age, the lengths are shorter than

the usual range (<95% confidence limit)

(Fig 7) . Therefore, one cannot exclude the

diagnosis of heterozygous achondroplasia

until after the third trimester.

On neonatal radiographs, the lumbar pedi-

des are shortened, and the normal progres-

sive widening of the lumbar interpedicubar

distance does not occur. Rhizomebic shorten-

ing of the bong bones is seen. The iliac bones

are flat and nonflared, with small sacrosciatic

100

March 1990 Spirt et a! U RadioGrapbics U 221

Page 6: Prenatal Sono graphic Evaluation ofShort- limbed Dwarfism: … · 2015-12-11 · achondroplasia. Thegestational ages atwhich thedifferent skeletal dysplasias areseen vary; therefore,

Figure 8. Chondrodysplasia punctata, rhizome-lic type. Neonatal radiograph shows large stippledepiphyses, most prominent in humeri and femurs.

222 U Ra4ioGrapbics U Spirt et a! Volume 10 Number 2

notches. The base of skull and foramen mag-

num are small, and the hands have a trident

shape.

Cbondrodysplasia Punctata.-The rhizo-melic type of this lethal condition is inherit-

ed in an autosomal recessive pattern.On neonatal radiographs, the vertebral

bodies are irregular, with coronal clefts. Rhi-

zomelic shortening, with metaphyseal splay.ing and stippled epiphyses, is seen in thebong bones (Fig 8) . Extracartilaginous stip-

pbing is seen as well.

Although, to our knowledge, antenatal di-

agnosis has not been reported, the findings

of hyperteborism and stippled epiphyses ac-

companying rhizomebic bone dyspbasia

would be suggestive of chondrodysplasia

punctata.

U MICROMELIC DWARFISM

Micromelic dwarfism may vary in severity,

the shape of the bone, and the degree of mm-

eralization. They may be categorized as mild,

mild and bowed, and severe.

. Mild Micromelic DwarfismThe algorithm for this classification is fea-

tured in Figure 6a. The differential diagnoses

include Jeune syndrome, Ellis-van Creveld

syndrome (or chondroectodermal dysplasia),

and diastrophic dwarfism.

Jeune Syndrome.-This often lethal syn-drome is also known as asphyxiating thoracic

dysplasia. It is a hereditary autosomal reces-

sive condition and cannot be distinguished

from Ellis-van Creveld syndrome in utero.

Associated renal disease may occur.

On in utero sonograms, the bong bones are

proportionately shortened. The thorax is

small, with a decreased circumference and

increased cardiothoracic ratio. Polydactyly is

occasionally seen.

On neonatal radiographs, the spine is nor-

mal. The extremities are shortened, with oc-

casionab polydactyby. The pelvis has a triden-

tate appearance, with small, flattened ilia,and the thorax is small in both anteroposteri-

or and transverse dimensions (Fig 9).

Ellis-van Creveld Syndrome-This heredi-

tary autosomab recessive condition is usually

not lethal. About 50% of the patients with

this syndrome have a cardiac anomaly (usual-

by atrial septal defect).

Page 7: Prenatal Sono graphic Evaluation ofShort- limbed Dwarfism: … · 2015-12-11 · achondroplasia. Thegestational ages atwhich thedifferent skeletal dysplasias areseen vary; therefore,

Figure 9. Jeune syndrome. Neonatal radiographshows small thorax, short limbs, and trident pci-vis (arrow). Note polydactyly of left hand.

March 1990 Spirt et al U Ra4ioGrapbics U 223

On in utero sonograms, the long bones areproportionately shortened. The thorax is

small, with a decreased thoracic circumfer-

ence and increased cardiothoracic ratio.

Congenital heart defects (usually atrial sep.

tab defect) and pobydactyly are frequently

seen.Radiographs of the neonate demonstrate a

normal spine and proportionately shortenedlong bones with frequent pobydactyly. A tn-

dent pelvis with small, flattened ilia is seen.The thorax appears small in both anteropos-tenor and transverse dimensions, and a cardi-

ac anomaly is commonly present.Ellis-van Creveld syndrome is difficult to

distinguish from Jeune syndrome, since poby-

dactyly, narrow thorax, and trident pelvis oc-

cur in both entities. Occasionally, a patient

with Ellis-van Creveld syndrome will havemesomelic shortening of the long bones.

However, the abnormal thorax enables theradiologist to distinguish this entity from

other mesomelic syndromes.

Diastropbic Dwarflsin-Infants with this

hereditary autosomal recessive conditionmay have a characteristic facial expression

and cauliflower ears. Normal intellectual de-

vebopment occurs, and the condition is usu-ally not lethal.

In uteno sonography demonstrates propor-tionately shortened long bones, with associ-ated hand and foot deformities (hitchhiker’s

thumb, clubfeet) (Figs 1 0, 1 1) . Joint con-

tractures and abnormal spinal curvature may

be seen.Neonatal radiography reveals moderately

flattened vertebral bodies. Progressive ky-phoscoliosis of the cervical, thoracic, or

lumbar spine occurs. The lumbar interpedi-cular spaces are narrow. Radiography alsoshows proportionate shortening of the long

bones, with flattened epiphyses and widened

metaphyses. The first metacarpal is hypoplas-

tic and oval (hitchhiker’s thumb); talipesequinovarus may be present (1 0, 1 1).

S Mild, Bowed Micromelic DwarfismThe algorithm for this classification is given

in Figure 6b. The differential diagnoses in-

dude camptomelic dysplasia and osteogene-

sis imperfecta, type III.

Camptomelic Dysplasia.-The inheritance

pattern for this condition is either sporadic

or autosomal recessive. The condition is usu-ally not lethal. When deaths occur, most are

due to respiratory insufficiency in the neona-tab period.

Page 8: Prenatal Sono graphic Evaluation ofShort- limbed Dwarfism: … · 2015-12-11 · achondroplasia. Thegestational ages atwhich thedifferent skeletal dysplasias areseen vary; therefore,

d.Figure 10. Diastrophic dwarfism. Sonograms obtained at 37 weeks gestational age show short femurs

(a) and abnormal thumb (arrowhead in b) . (C) Corresponding neonatal radiograph of hand shows hitch-hiker thumb and small, oval first metacarpal (arrow) . Note bone dysplasia and elbow dislocation.

(d) Lumbosacral lordosis (arrows) seen on sonogram is confirmed on neonatal lateral radiograph (e).

224 U RadioGrapbics U Spirt et a! Volume 10 Number 2

Page 9: Prenatal Sono graphic Evaluation ofShort- limbed Dwarfism: … · 2015-12-11 · achondroplasia. Thegestational ages atwhich thedifferent skeletal dysplasias areseen vary; therefore,

C. d.

March 1990 Spiil et a! U RadioGraphics U 225

Figure 11. Diastrophic dwarfism. (a) Graph of femoral and tibial measurements (in millimeters) ob-tamed from serial sonograms beginning at 1 5 weeks gestational age. Comparison of these measurementswith the usual ranges indicates the presence of micromelic shortening. (b, C) Scans obtained at 27 weeks

show short femur (cursors in b) and clubfoot (arrowheads in C) . Arrow = tibia. Visualization of the meta-

tarsal bones and tibia and fibula at right angles in the same coronal plane is diagnostic of clubfoot (8,9).(d) Neonatal anteroposterior radiograph shows oval first metacarpal (arrow) , mildly flattened vertebral

bodies, and hypoplastic cervical vertebrae. Kyphoscoliosis is not yet evident.

On in utero sonograms, femurs and tibiasare bowed and fibulas are short (Fig 12).

Thoracic circumference is decreased, and

scapulae are hypoplastic. Cleft palate may be

detected.Neonatal radiography reveals hypopbastic

vertebrae (especially in the lower cervical

area) and scapulae. Tracheal narrowing may

be present. Femurs are bowed. Tibias arebowed anteriorly, with an associated soft-tis-

sue dimple. Fibulas are short.

Page 10: Prenatal Sono graphic Evaluation ofShort- limbed Dwarfism: … · 2015-12-11 · achondroplasia. Thegestational ages atwhich thedifferent skeletal dysplasias areseen vary; therefore,

e f.Figure 12. Camptomelic dysplasia. (a, b) Sonograms obtained at 34 weeks gestational age show bowed

femur (arrows in a) and short fibula (arrowhead in b) . (c-e) Neonatal radiographs show angulation of dis-

tal tibias, hypoplastic scapulas (arrowheads in C) , and marked cervical lordosis. Note tracheal narrowing(arrow in d). (I) Pretibial dimple (arrow) is a classic clinical finding (cf arrow in e). (Figure 1 2a and 1 2bcourtesy of Gerald Segal, MD, Utica, NY.) (Reprinted, with permission, from reference 12.)

226 U RadioGraphics U Spirt et a! Volume 10 Number 2

Page 11: Prenatal Sono graphic Evaluation ofShort- limbed Dwarfism: … · 2015-12-11 · achondroplasia. Thegestational ages atwhich thedifferent skeletal dysplasias areseen vary; therefore,

a. b.

C. d.

March 1990 Spirt et a! U RadioGraphics U 227

Figure 13 Osteogenesis imperfecta, type III, progressive deforming type. (a, b) Sector scans obtained at27 weeks gestational age show short, thick, bowed left femur (arrow in a) and left tibia (arrowhead in b).Open arrow in b = foot. (C) Scan taken at 32 weeks shows short, bowed right femur (arrows) and bowedtibia (arrowheads) . Open arrow = foot. (d) Neonatal radiograph reveals the same findings in the lower cx-tremities. The mother was similarly affected. (Reprinted, with permission, from reference 1 2.)

Osteogenesis Imperfecta� Type 111.-This

nonlethal, progressively deforming disorderhas a heterogeneous inheritance pattern (ie,it can be autosomal dominant, autosomab re-

cessive, or sporadic).On in utero sonograms, the long bones are

short and bowed (Fig 1 3), with fractures.

However, the humeri may be almost nor-

mal in shape (1 3) . Acoustic shadowing ispresent. Thoracic size is within normallimits.

On neonatal radiographs, the vertebraeand pelvis are normal. Long bones are short,

bowed, and fractured. However, fracturesusually heal webb, in the shape of the bone.Humeri are usually less involved (13,14).

Rib fractures may be present.

Infants with type III osteogenesis imper-

fecta have normal sclerae. Joint hyperbaxity

is present in 50% of children with this disor-der (1 3). Progressive deformities of thelimbs occur during childhood. The spine be-

Page 12: Prenatal Sono graphic Evaluation ofShort- limbed Dwarfism: … · 2015-12-11 · achondroplasia. Thegestational ages atwhich thedifferent skeletal dysplasias areseen vary; therefore,

228 U RadioGrapbics U Spirt et a! Volume 10 Number 2

comes progressively abnormal during late

childhood or adolescence.

There are four major types of osteogenesis

imperfecta (1 3) . Types I and IV are autoso-mal dominant types: Type I is characterized

by blue sclerae, and type IV by normal

sclerae. Both are considered to be “tarda”

forms, being found after birth. (In type I

cases with fractures at birth, the fractures are

considered to have occurred during delivery

[1 3J.) Normal findings at in utero sonography

do not mean that the diagnoses of types I and

IV, or milder forms of type III, osteogenesisimperfecta should be excluded.

. Severe Micromelic DwarfismThe algorithm for this classification is pre-

sented in Figure 6c. The differential diag-

noses include thanatophoric dyspbasia; het-

erozygous achondroplasia; osteogenesis

imperfecta, type II; achondrogenesis; hypo-

phosphatasia, congenital lethal form; and

short-rib pobydactyly syndromes.

Thanatopboric Dysplasia.-This lethal

condition is the most common bone dyspla-

sia, with a prevalence of one in 6,400 (2) to

one in 16,700 (1) births. The inheritance

pattern is sporadic.

Distinguishing features on in utero sono-

grams include pobyhydramnios (7 1 % of

cases) , narrow thorax, macrocrania (includ-ing hydrocephabus), and cloverleaf skull de-

formity (Figs 1 4- 1 6) . Femurs may be

bowed. Major neonatal radiographic findingsinclude marked platyspondyly; short, broad,

bowed bong bones; small pelvis; narrow tho-

rax; macrocrania; and cloverleaf skull defor-mity.

Homozygous Acbondroplasia.-This rare

entity resembles thanatophoric dysplasia. It

is hereditary, with an autosomal dominant

pattern, and lethal.

Osteogenesis Imperfecta, Tjpe H (Perina-

ta,l Lethal Form).-This condition has ci-

ther an autosomab recessive or sporadic in-

heritance pattern (15).

In utero sonograms demonstrate fracturedlong bones and ribs, with minimal acoustic

shadowing from bones. Neonatal radiographs

reveal platyspondyby, spinal osteopenia, and

a poorly mineralized skull (Figs 17-19). Thelong bones have short thick shafts, general-

ized osteopenia, and multiple fractures.

Babies with type II osteogenesis imper-

fecta have blue scberae. Demise is usually

due to pulmonary hypoplasia.

Acbondrogenesis.-This autosomab reces-

sive condition may be subclassified into two

types. Both types are lethal. The radiobogic

findings of type 1 include poorly or nonossi-

fled spine and cabvaria; flared, fractured ribs;poorly ossified pelvis; absent sacrum; and ab-

sent pubis. In type 2 , there is variable ossifi-cation of the spine and skull, no rib frac-

tures, ossified iliac bones, and deficient sa-

crum and pubis (Figs 20, 21).

Hj�opbospbatasia (Congenital Letbal

Form).-Fetuses with this hereditary auto-

somal recessive condition have short, poorly

mineralized extremities; short, poorly ossi-

fled ribs; and poorly mineralized calvaria andspine on sonograms (Figs 22, 23).

On neonatal radiographs, the vertebrae arepoorly ossified, especially the neural arches.

No ossification of whole long bones is

present; irregular metaphyseal defects are

seen. Pelvic bones are small. Major portions

of the calvaria, base of the skull, and facial

bones are not ossified.

Sbort-Rib Polydactyly Syndromes.-Fetus-

es with this lethal, hereditary autosomab re-

cessive condition have a narrow thorax, short

ribs, and pobydactyby on sonograms. Major

neonatal radiographic findings include short,

horizontally oriented ribs and pobydactyly.

Page 13: Prenatal Sono graphic Evaluation ofShort- limbed Dwarfism: … · 2015-12-11 · achondroplasia. Thegestational ages atwhich thedifferent skeletal dysplasias areseen vary; therefore,

C. d.

Figure 14. Thanatophoric dysplasia. (a) Sonogram obtained at 26 weeks gestational age shows short fe-

mur (arrow) . (b) Another scan shows narrow thorax (black arrows) , macrocrania, and hydrocephalus(white arrow) . Photograph (C) and radiograph (d) of neonate show large head, narrow thorax, and severemicromelia. (Reprinted, with permission, from reference 1 2.)

March 1990 Spirt et a! U Ra4ioGrapbics U 229

Page 14: Prenatal Sono graphic Evaluation ofShort- limbed Dwarfism: … · 2015-12-11 · achondroplasia. Thegestational ages atwhich thedifferent skeletal dysplasias areseen vary; therefore,

Figure 15. Thanatophoric dysplasia. (a) Fetal

sonogram obtained at term shows short, non-

bowed femur. (b-e) Other scans reveal abnormal,lobular configuration of the caivaria (arrows in

, consistent with cloverleaf skull deformity.

This is distinguished from encephalocele by the

presence of calvaria around the entire brain. Alarge monoventricle (V) with a partial interhemi-spheric fissure (curved arrow in e) is seen, consis-tent with semilobar holoprosencephaly.

b. C.

d. e.

230 U RadioGrapbics U Spirt et a! Volume 10 Number 2

Page 15: Prenatal Sono graphic Evaluation ofShort- limbed Dwarfism: … · 2015-12-11 · achondroplasia. Thegestational ages atwhich thedifferent skeletal dysplasias areseen vary; therefore,

4*

_ . �;�5 on neonatal radiographs of the fetus in Figuredysplasia with cloverleaf skull (kleeblattsch#{227}del) deformity.

I, -i� � � � .;-�-� ,�v

1 5 confirm diagnosis of thanatophoric

.�t#{149}�

,“1iz_� . �

a. D.

March 1990 Spirt et a! U RadioGrapbics U 231

Figure 17. Osteogenesis imperfecta, type II.(a) Sonogram obtained at 1 8 weeks gestationalage shows short, angulated femur (cursors).Acoustic shadow is absent. (b) Cross-sectionalscan of the thorax shows fractured rib (arrows).

S = vertebral body. (C) Another scan shows un-usually bright falx (curved arrow) because of de-mineralization of skull (5).

Page 16: Prenatal Sono graphic Evaluation ofShort- limbed Dwarfism: … · 2015-12-11 · achondroplasia. Thegestational ages atwhich thedifferent skeletal dysplasias areseen vary; therefore,

Figure 18. Anteroposterior (a) and lateral (b) radiographs of same 1 8-week-old fetus as in Figure 17

show short, fractured, demineralized long bones and ribs, consistent with osteogenesis imperfecta, type II.Note demineralization of skull.

232 U RadioGrapbics U Spirt et a! Volume 10 Number 2

Page 17: Prenatal Sono graphic Evaluation ofShort- limbed Dwarfism: … · 2015-12-11 · achondroplasia. Thegestational ages atwhich thedifferent skeletal dysplasias areseen vary; therefore,

b. d.

Figure 19. Osteogenesis imperfecta, type II. (a) Sonogram obtained at 35 weeks gestational age showsshort, angulated humerus (cursors) with poor acoustic shadow. (b) Cross-sectional view of thorax showsabnormally increased cardiothoracic ratio (see cursors) . The thoracic circumference was decreased.(C) Scan of the fetal head taken at 30 weeks shows bright falx (arrow), a finding indicating poor mineral-ization of skull. (d) Findings on neonatal radiograph confirm the diagnosis.

March 1990 Spirt et a! U RadioGraphics U 233

Page 18: Prenatal Sono graphic Evaluation ofShort- limbed Dwarfism: … · 2015-12-11 · achondroplasia. Thegestational ages atwhich thedifferent skeletal dysplasias areseen vary; therefore,

a. b.

Figure 21. Neonatal photograph (a) and radiograph (b) of fetus in Figure 20 show severe micromelia.Spine is poorly mineralized, and sacrum and pubis are absent. Arrow femur.

234 U RadioGrapbics U Spirt et a! Volume 10 Number 2

Figure 20. Achondrogenesis, type II. (a, b) Son-ograms obtained at 33 weeks gestational age showvery short femur with poor acoustic shadow (cur-sors in a) and poorly visualized spine (arrow-heads in b), a finding indicating poor mineraliza-

iion. Arrow in b = nuchal cystic hygroma, H fe-tal head. Note lack of acoustic shadows fromspine. Compare b with C, a sonogram of a normalfetal spine at 25 weeks gestational age.

Page 19: Prenatal Sono graphic Evaluation ofShort- limbed Dwarfism: … · 2015-12-11 · achondroplasia. Thegestational ages atwhich thedifferent skeletal dysplasias areseen vary; therefore,

Figure 23. Neonatal radiographs of fetus in Fig-ure 22 show minimally ossified calvaria; thin,

and fibula. Arrows foot. (C) On sonogram ob-tamed at 22 weeks, the falx (arrow) is moreprominent than the calvaria, a finding indicating apoorly mineralized skull. (Courtesy of RichardGerle, MD, Syracuse, NY; reprinted, with permis-sion, from reference 12.)

short, poorly ossified long bones; and ribs with

widened, irregular ends. (Reprinted, with permis-sion, from reference 12.)

March 1990 Spirt et a! U RadioGrapbics U 235

Page 20: Prenatal Sono graphic Evaluation ofShort- limbed Dwarfism: … · 2015-12-11 · achondroplasia. Thegestational ages atwhich thedifferent skeletal dysplasias areseen vary; therefore,

236 U RadioGrapbics U Spirt et a! Volume 10 Number 2

U SUMMARYEvaluation of bone dysplasia is initiated by

the finding of a significantly shortened femur

or a referral of a pregnancy at risk. If a short

femur (length less than the 95% confidence

limit) is demonstrated, all long bones should

be measured and evaluated for bowing, frac-tures, and mineralization. In the case of sus-

pected heterozygous achondroplasia, serialmeasurements should be obtained up to at

least 27 weeks gestational age.

If a bone dysplasia is present, it should be

classified as mesomelic, rhizomebic, micro-

melic (mild or severe) , and bowed and/or

fractured. The fetal spine, head, thorax,

hands, and feet should be evaluated to aid in

the differential diagnosis.

It is important to determine whether the

fetus has a lethal or possibly lethal form of

short-limbed dwarfism. Although the final

diagnosis cannot be made until after birth,

the above evaluation will provide sufficient

information to counsel the family during the

pregnancy and to direct the postnatal evalua-

tion for definitive diagnosis.

U REFERENCES1 . Camera G, Mastroiacovo P. Birth preva-

lence of skeletal dysplasias in the Italianmulticentric monitoring system for birth de-

fects. In: Papadatos C, Bartsocas C, eds. Skel-etal dysplasias: proceedings of the Third In-ternational Clinical Genetics Seminar. New

York: Liss, 1982; 44 1-449.

2 . Jones UL. Smith’s recognizable patterns of

human malformation. 4th ed. Philadelphia:Saunders, 1988; 290.

3. Mulivor RA, Mennuti M, Zackai EH, Harris H.

Prenatal diagnosis of hypophosphatasia: ge-netic, biochemical, and clinical studies. AmJ Hum Genet 1978; 30:27 1-282.

4, Kurtz AB, Filly RA, Wapner RJ, et a!. Inutero analysis of heterozygous achondropla-

sia: variable time of onset as detected by fe-

mur length measurements. J Ultrasound Med1986; 5:137-140.

5. Laughlin CI, Lee TG. The prominent faixcerebri: new ultrasonic observation in hypo-

phosphatasia.JCU 1982; 10:37-38.

6. Mahoney BS, Filly RA, Cooperberg PL. Ante-

natal sonographic diagnosis of achondrogen-

esis.J Ultrasound Med 1984; 3:333-335.

7. HobbinsJC, Mahoney MJ. Skeletal dysplasia.

In: Sanders RC, James AE, eds. The princi-

pies and practice of ultrasonography in ob-

stetrics and gynecology. 3rd ed. Norwalk,

Conn: Appleton-Century-Crofts, 1985; 268.8. Benacerraf BR, Frigoletto FD. Prenatal ultra-

sound diagnosis of clubfoot. Radiology

1985; 155:211-213.

9. Jeanty P, Romero R, d’Alton M, Venus I, Hob-

binsJC. In utero sonographic detection of

hand and foot deformities. J Ultrasound Med1985; 4:595-601.

10. Saldino RM. Radiographic diagnosis of neo-

natal short-limbed dwarfism. Med Radiogr

Photogr 1973; 49:61-91.

1 1 . SprangerJw, Langer LO, Wiedemann HR.

Bone dysplasias: an atlas of constitutionaldisorders of skeletal development. Philadel-

phia: Saunders, 1974.

1 2 . Spin BA, Gordon LP, Oliphant M. Prenatalultrasound: a color atlas with anatomic and

pathologic correlation . New York: Churchill

Livingstone, 1987.

13. Sillence DO, Senn A, Danks DM. Genetic

heterogeneity in osteogenesis imperfecta. JMedGenet 1979; 16:101-116.

14. van der Harten HJ, Dijkstra PF, Meijer CJL, etal. Perinatal lethal osteogenesis imperfecta:

radiobogic and pathologic evaluation of 5ev-

en prenatally diagnosed cases. Pediatr

Pathol 1988; 8:233-252.15. Sillence DO, Barlow K.K, Garber AP, et al.

Osteogenesis imperfecta type II: delineation

of the phenotype with reference to genetic

heterogeneity. AmJ Med Genet 1984; 17:

407-423.


Recommended