Date post: | 17-Dec-2015 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | mlcalderone |
View: | 33,630 times |
Download: | 0 times |
!"#$%&'()"*+,$-.//01
23# 4&'()"*+,$5-5.1
6# )%2" &6%37#$28*+,$9959:1
;?@ABB?>>C?
:0D0%EFGHIJKLMILN+OGKP..5
6IHGQIRPJ3PLN %/5-/-
7PJ&S*T519-DU-955
4IVS*T519-DU:-55
R!(W"%+)&M#WR!3*$'+,$-05/:0/1
"%M32$ 26&X2%3+!$*$'+,$T/.:./1
32$%$4&Y%3W)2+2*$'+,$:.D./91
*%JJKZ[PIEFGKKPE1
\]^_` B?>>C?
9.4GaKb%cPQOP
$Pd'ZHeN$'555T
7PJ&S*--1-.DU0955
4IVS*--1-.DU09:.
%KKZHQPLfaZHXJIGQKGaaN
g=Ahh` h?=]^=ijAggA>]k?
]n` Bh]A?
+)%$$!$)#W)U,%++%"#oN
XJIGQKGaaN
c&
%"p%8223%%623# %IQE2)%,%"
+)#)%,#NGQbGfGQEGcGEOIJIQE
qHZaPffGZQIJrIqIrGKGPfN
RPaPQEIQKf&
IfP$Z&Ssssssssssssssssss
t?_muAh_?
?
@` uC>A]hl?n` B?_AuA^ mg?
?
?
XJIGQKGaa+bIQQZQ)GvbU,IffIJGe*w6f&)GvbU,IffIJGexZHwXJIGQKGaax1N[LIQEKbHZOvbbPH
OQEPHfGvQPErZOQfPJNMGvEZH""XNIfIQEaZHbPH ZFqJIGQKGQKbGfIrKGZQIvIGQfKRPaPQEIQKf%J
pIyPPHI%FPHGrI*w%JpIyPPHIxZHKbPw ZFqIQLx1IQE2bI[%J+bGbI[G*w%J+bGbI[Gx1
*rZJJPrKGcPJLNwRPaPQEIQKfx1NbPHP[LIJJPvPfIfaZJJZdfS
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
5
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
-5
-
--
-T
-:
-.
-0
-D
-9
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
5
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
-5
-
--
-T
-:
-.
-0
-D
-9
Case 2:15-cv-04427 Document 1 Filed 06/11/15 Page 1 of 26 Page ID #:1
-
hAlA]ug?
&z %JpIyPPHIdIfaZOQEPEGQ%FPHGrIZQKbPqHGQrGqJPfZaZaaPHGQvwOQ[GIfPENaIrKU
[IfPENGQUEPqKbfKZHGPfZa(&+&IQEGQKPHQIKGZQIJQPdfNxdbGJPIKKbPfIFPKGFP[PGQvvOGEPE[LI
fPJaUEPfGvQPEwFGffGZQxKZbIcPwGQKPvHGKLIQEHPfqPrKvOGEPZOHrZQEOrKGQKPHQIJJLIQE
PVKPHQIJJL&x
-&z 7bPKHOKbNOQaZHKOQIKPJLNqIGQKfIFOrbEIHePHIQE[JPIePHqGrKOHPNZQPdbPHP
KHOKbIQEZ[{PrKGcGKLIHPfPKIfGEPKZrIKPHKZKbP ZFqIQL|fqHZU%HI[GrqHP{OEGrPf&
T&z %fHIKGQvfaIGJPEKZJGcPOqKZKbPPVqPrKIKGZQfZaFIQIvPFPQKN%JpIyPPHIZqPQJL
EPrGEPEKZI[IQEZQIJJqHPKPQfPZaQPOKHIJGKLGQaIcZHZaqOKKGQvKbP%HI[GrcGPdqZGQKaHZQKIQE
rPQKPHNZqPQJLEPFIQEGQvKbIKqHZvHIFf[PIGHPEKbIKrHGKGrGyPErZOQKHGPffOrbIf%FPHGrIN#fHIPJ
IQE2vLqK&
:&z RPEGrIKPE{ZOHQIJGfKffOrbIf6f&)GvbU,IffIJGedPHPKZJEKbIKGaKbGf
I[IQEZQFPQKZa{ZOHQIJGfKGrGQKPvHGKLJPEqPZqJPKZEPPFKbPFwKPHHZHGfKfNxKbIKdIfIQ
IrrPqKI[JPHGfeaZHKbP ZFqIQLKZKIeP&
.&z 4ZHPVIFqJPNGQIFPPKGQvdGKbQPdfqHZEOrPHfN%JpIyPPHI|frZHqZHIKP
FIQIvPFPQKGQ}IKIHZOKHIvPZOfJLfKIKPEKbIKFIQLGQKbP%HI[dZHJE[PJGPcPEKbIKKbPIKKIref
ZQ%FPHGrIQZQ+PqKPF[PHN-55dPHPfKIvPE[LKbP #%KZIJJZd%FPHGrIKZdIvPIQOQ{OfK
dIHZQKbP%HI[GrdZHJEQrHPEG[JLNKbGfdIfbPJEZOKIfKbPKLqPZaPEGKZHGIJcGPdqZGQKKbP
ZFqIQLfbZOJEKIePvOGEIQrPaHZF&
0&z %JfZaZJJZdGQvKbGfEGHPrKGcPNPFqJZLPPfFIEPGQaJIFFIKZHLfKIKPFPQKffOrbIf
w#fHIPJGfIHPJGeP)GKJPHNxIQEw%QLZQPdbZfOqqZHKf#fHIPJfbZOJEEGPIaGPHLEPIKb&x3IKbPH
KbIQEGfrGqJGQPKbPfPZaaPQEGQvPFqJZLPPfNKbP ZFqIQL[HIyPQJLEPFZQfKHIKPEGKfKHOPaPPJGQvf
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
5
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
-5
-
--
-T
-:
-.
-0
-D
-9
Case 2:15-cv-04427 Document 1 Filed 06/11/15 Page 2 of 26 Page ID #:2
T
[LKPHFGQIKGQvKbPPFqJZLFPQKZaGQEGcGEOIJfdbZEIHPEfKIQEOqKZrZFqJIGQI[ZOKfOrb[JIKIQK
EGfrHGFGQIKGZQNPfqPrGIJJLrZFGQvaHZFIQZfKPQfG[JLOQ[GIfPEQPdfZHvIQGyIKGZQ&
D&z #KGfJGKKJPdZQEPHNvGcPQKbGfPEGKZHGIJFIQEIKPKbIKHIQKbHZOvbZOKKbP ZFqIQLN
KbIK%JpIyPPHI|fOQJIdaOJIQEEGfrHGFGQIKZHL[PbIcGZHPVKPQEPEKZGKfKHPIKFPQKZaGKf
PFqJZLPPf&
9&z 4IHaHZF[PGQvvZcPHQPEKbPwGQKPvHGKLIQEHPfqPrKxKbIKGKqO[JGrJLJIOEPENKbP
ZFqIQLbIfGQfKPIEfLfKPFIKGrIJJLaIcZHPEGKf%HI[GrIQEFIJPPFqJZLPPfNKHPIKGQvGKfQZQU
%HI[GrIQEaPFIJPPFqJZLPPfIffPrZQErJIffrGKGyPQfdbZIHPKbPrZQfKIQKKIHvPKfZaI[OfPIQE
EPvHIEIKGZQ&
/&z #QEGcGEOIJfdbZbIEQZFZHPPVqPHGPQrPKbIQFIQIvGQvIJZrIJ+OQvJIff)OK
dPHPqHZFZKPEKZePLJPIEPHfbGqqZfGKGZQfNdbGJPFZHP~OIJGaGPEQZQU%HI[GrN%FPHGrIQIQE
aPFIJPPFqJZLPPfrZQfGfKPQKJLfIdKbPGHqPHaZHFIQrPOQEPHFGQPEIQEKbPGHqHZaPffGZQIJ
HPfqZQfG[GJGKGPfKIePQIdILaHZFKbPF&
5&z %QLPFqJZLPPdbZZ[{PrKPEKZKbGfrZQEOrKNGQrJOEGQvXJIGQKGaaNdPHP
FIHvGQIJGyPEN[PJGKKJPENIQEOJKGFIKPJLKPHFGQIKPE&
&z 7bGfGfIQIrKGZQaZHEPrJIHIKZHLNGQ{OQrKGcPIQEFZQPKIHLHPJGPaKZHPEHPffKbP
OQJIdaOJEGfrHGFGQIKGZQNbZfKGJPdZHePQcGHZQFPQKIQEHPKIJGIKGZQrZFFGKKPEIvIGQfKXJIGQKGaa
KbHZOvbZOKbPHPFqJZLFPQKGQcGZJIKGZQZa+PrKGZQ/9ZaKbP GcGJ3GvbKf%rKZa900N:-
(&+& &/9*w+PrKGZQ/9x1NKbP$Pd'ZHe+KIKP)OFIQ3GvbKf"IdN$Pd'ZHe2VPrOKGcP
"Id-/5*w$'+)3"x1IQEKbP$Pd'ZHe GKL)OFIQ3GvbKf"IdN$Pd'ZHe GKL
%EFGQGfKHIKGcP ZEP9U5*w$' )3"x1&
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
5
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
-5
-
--
-T
-:
-.
-0
-D
-9
Case 2:15-cv-04427 Document 1 Filed 06/11/15 Page 3 of 26 Page ID #:3
:
-&z 4OHKbPHNRPaPQEIQKf|rZQEOrKbIf[HPIrbPEKbPrZQKHIrKXJIGQKGaabIEdGKbKbP
ZFqIQLNvZcPHQGQvKbPKPHFfIQErZQEGKGZQfZabPHPFqJZLFPQKNIQE[HPIrbPEKbPGFqJGPE
rZcPQIQKZavZZEaIGKbIQEaIGHEPIJGQvIKKPQEIQKKZKbIKrZQKHIrK&
T&z RPaPQEIQKf|rZQEOrKIJfZGfGQcGZJIKGZQZa7GKJPY##ZaKbP GcGJ3GvbKf%rKZa
/0:NIfIFPQEPEN:-(&+& &-555P*w7GKJPY##x1&+GFOJKIQPZOfJLdGKbKbPaGJGQvZa
KbGfIrKGZQNXJIGQKGaadGJJaGJPIrbIHvPZaEGfrHGFGQIKGZQdGKbKbP2~OIJ2FqJZLFPQK!qqZHKOQGKL
ZFFGffGZQ*w22! x1dGKbHPvIHEKZKbPfPcGZJIKGZQf&XJIGQKGaadGJJfPPeJPIcPKZaGJPIQ
%FPQEPE ZFqJIGQKaZJJZdGQvbPHHPrPGqKZaI$ZKGrPZa3GvbKKZ+OP&
t
.
D&z RPaPQEIQK%JpIyPPHI%FPHGrIGfIEZFPfKGrJGFGKPEJGI[GJGKLrZFqIQL
bPIE~OIHKPHPET5.MPfKT:KbfKHPPKN4GHfK4JZZHN$Pd'ZHeN$'555&%KIJJHPJPcIQKKGFPfN
RPaPQEIQK%JpIyPPHIFPKKbPEPaGQGKGZQZawPFqJZLPHxOQEPHIJJIqqJGrI[JPfKIKOKPf&
9&z RPaPQEIQK2bI[%J+bGbI[GGfIHPfGEPQKZaKbP+KIKPZa$Pd'ZHeIQEKbPGQKPHGF
bGPa2VPrOKGcP!aaGrPHZa%JpIyPPHINIQEKbP2VPrOKGcPRGHPrKZHaZH#QKPHQIKGZQIJ!qPHIKGZQf
aZH%JpIyPPHI&%KIJJHPJPcIQKKGFPfNRPaPQEIQK%J+bGbI[GfOqPHcGfPEKbPPFqJZLFPQKZa
XJIGQKGaaNIQENGQKbIKHZJPNbPbIEKbPIOKbZHGKLKZEGfrGqJGQPIQEaGHPXJIGQKGaaNEGHPrKbPHdZHe
IrKGcGKGPfNIffGvQbPH{Z[HPfqZQfG[GJGKGPfIQEFZQGKZHbPHqPHaZHFIQrP&%rrZHEGQvJLNIKIJJ
HPJPcIQKKGFPfNRPaPQEIQK%J+bGbI[GdIfIQwPFqJZLPHxdGKbGQKbPFPIQGQvZaIJJIqqJGrI[JP
fKIKOKPf&
CB` @m_?Bm
0
-T&z ,PaZHPrZFFPQrGQvbPHPFqJZLFPQKN6f&)GvbU,IffIJGedIfaZHrPEKZfGvQIQ
2FqJZLFPQK ZQKHIrKdGKb%JpIyPPHI*KbPw ZQKHIrKx1&
-:&z (QEPHKbPKPHFfZaKbP ZQKHIrKN6f&)GvbU,IffIJGedIfvOIHIQKPPEKbHPPLPIHfZa
PFqJZLFPQKdGKb%JpIyPPHINIQEbPHfIJIHLaZHKbPPQKGHPEOHIKGZQNGHHPfqPrKGcPZadbPKbPHbPH
PFqJZLFPQKdIfKPHFGQIKPE[LKbP ZFqIQL&
-.&z XHGZHKZ{ZGQGQv%JpIyPPHIN6f&)GvbU,IffIJGePQ{ZLPEIKHPFPQEZOfJL
IrrZFqJGfbPENIdIHEUdGQQGQvIQEfOrrPffaOJrIHPPHGQKbPKPJPcGfGZQIQE{ZOHQIJGfFGQEOfKHGPfN
GQrJOEGQvIK $$N$, IQE6+$, &
-0&z 7bHZOvbZOKbPHKPQOHPdGKb%JpIyPPHIN6f&)GvbU,IffIJGedIfOQGcPHfIJJL
qHIGfPEaZHbPHJPIEPHfbGqNcGfGZQIQEGQKPvHGKL&
-D&z ,ZKbbPHEGHPrKHPqZHKfIQErZJJPIvOPfGQFIQIvPFPQKHPrZvQGyPE6f&)GvbU
,IffIJGe|frZFFGKFPQKKZ~OIJGKLNbZQPfK{ZOHQIJGfFIQEbPHHZJPIfIfOqqZHKGcPrZdZHePHKZbPH
aPJJZdPFqJZLPPfIK%JpIyPPHI&?
-9&z #QaIrKN6f&)GvbU,IffIJGeZQJLIvHPPEKZ{ZGQ%JpIyPPHI[PrIOfPZaKbP
ZFqIQL|fZfKPQfG[JPfOqqZHKaZHKbPeGQEZaKHOKbaOJIQEZ[{PrKGcP{ZOHQIJGfFKbIKbIE[PPQI
bIJJFIHeZabPHrIHPPH&?
_?
D
cGPdqZGQKN[OKKZEGfrHGFGQIKPZQKbP[IfGfZaHIrPPKbQGrGKLIQEKZIEcIQrPIqHZU%HI[Gr6GEEJP
2IfKPHQIvPQEINZaKPQIKKbPPVqPQfPZapPdGfbqPZqJP&
T&z ,LdILZaPVIFqJPZQJLNEOHGQvIQEfbZHKJLIaKPHKbP#fHIPJWIyIrZQaJGrKGQ-5:N
KbPQPdfIQEqHZvHIFFGQvEPqIHKFPQKdIfPVqJGrGKJLGQfKHOrKPEKZaIcZHKbP6GEEJP2IfKPHQ
qZGQKZacGPdIQErIfK#fHIPJIfKbPcGJJIGQNrHPIKGQvKIvJGQPffOrbIfwWIyIOQEPH4GHPNxIQE
IGHGQvaGJFfrIJJPEw+bO{ILPIS6IffIrHPIKRIdQxIQEw7bPRIL#fHIPJ%KKIrePE%FPHGrI&x
T-&z #QaIrKN%JpIyPPHI|fqIHPQKrZFqIQLN%JpIyPPHI6PEGI$PKdZHeNPVqJGrGKJLKZJE
KbP ZFqIQL|fPFqJZLPPfKbIKKbPGHFGffGZQdIfKZw[HGQvKbP%HI[6OfJGFqPHfqPrKGcPxKZ
%FPHGrI&
TT&z 4ZHPVIFqJPNKbP ZFqIQL|fqHZEOrPHfdPHPKZJEZQZQPZrrIfGZQKbIKFOrbZa
KbP%HI[dZHJE[PJGPcPEKbIKKbPbZHHGaGrIKKIrefqPHqPKHIKPEZQ%FPHGrIZQ+PqKPF[PHN-55
dPHPIrKOIJJLfKIvPE[LKbP #%KZrHPIKPIaIJfP{OfKGaGrIKGZQaZHIdIHIvIGQfKKbP%HI[dZHJE
aZJJZdGQvKbPPQEZaKbP ZJEMIH&
T:&z 7bGfZOKHIvPZOfIQEqIKPQKJLZaaPQfGcPfKIKPFPQKdIfbPJEZOKIfIQPVIFqJPZa
KbPeGQEZacGPdqZGQKKbIK%JpIyPPHIfbZOJEePPqGQFGQEIfGKEPrGEPEZQKbPKZQPIQErZQKPQK
ZaGKfHPqZHKGQv&
T.&z !QIQZKbPHZrrIfGZQNKbPbPIEZaKbP ZFqIQL|f#QcPfKGvIKGcP(QGKfbZreGQvJL
KdPPKPEZOKKbIKw#fHIPJGfIHPJGeP)GKJPH&x
T0&z MbPQKbP ZFqIQL|fqHZEOrPHfKHGPEKZIGH[IJIQrPEQPdfHPqZHKfNKbPLdPHP
IrrOfPE[LFIQIvPFPQKZa[PGQvwcPHL[GIfPEaZH#fHIPJ&x
TD&z %fKbGfZcPHKJLIQKGU#fHIPJfKIQrPfqHPIEIQE[PvIQPQrHZIrbGQvZQKbPqHZvHIFf
IQEEZrOFPQKIHGPfaZHdbGrb6f&)GvbU,IffIJGedIfHPfqZQfG[JPNfbPHPqPIKPEJLHIGfPEbPH
Z[{PrKGZQfKZFIQIvPFPQK&
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
5
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
-5
-
--
-T
-:
-.
-0
-D
-9
Case 2:15-cv-04427 Document 1 Filed 06/11/15 Page 7 of 26 Page ID #:7
9
T9&z 4ZHPVIFqJPNfbPKZJEbPHfOqPHcGfZHfKbIK%JpIyPPHIdIfIrKGcPJLIEcZrIKGQvI
EGfrHGFGQIKZHLIKKGKOEPKZdIHEfqPZqJPdbZdPHPQZK6GEEJP2IfKPHQIQEZH%HI[GrNdbGrbdIfI
aJIvHIQKJLGFqHZqPHqZfGKGZQaZHIQLrZFqIQLKZKIePNPfqPrGIJJLIQZfKPQfG[JLZ[{PrKGcPQPdf
ZHvIQGyIKGZQ&
T/&z 6f&)GvbU,IffIJGeIJfZrZFqJIGQPEI[ZOKKbPaIrKKbIKKbP ZFqIQL|fFPffIvPf
IEcZrIKGQv%HI[GrcGPdqZGQKfZcPHIJJZKbPHfdPHPGQcGZJIKGZQZaGKfrI[JPrZQKHIrKfGQ%FPHGrIN
dbGrbHP~OGHPE%JpIyPPHIKZHPFIGQQPOKHIJGQIJJqZfGKGZQf&
:5&z +bPFIEPrJPIHKbIK%JpIyPPHI6PEGI$PKdZHe|fFIQIvPFPQKGQRZbIfbZOJE
QZKbIcP[PPQEGrKIKGQvKbPrZcPHIvPZaGKffOqqZfPEJLGQEPqPQEPQKfO[fGEGIHL&
:&z RPaPQEIQK%J+bGbI[GHPfqZQEPEKZKbPfPeGQEfZarZFqJIGQKf[LfKIKGQvKbIKKbP
ZFqIQLdIfQZK%JpIyPPHI%FPHGrI[OKw%JpIyPPHI%FPHGrIxIQEfrHPIFGQvIKIQLZQP
dbZZ[{PrKPEKZKbPfPcGPdqZGQKfKbIKKbPLdPHPQZJZQvPHdPJrZFPIKKbP ZFqIQL&
:-&z RPaPQEIQK%J+bGbI[GIEFGKKPEKZXJIGQKGaaKbIKbPdIfqOfbGQvKbP ZFqIQLKZ
I[IQEZQIJJqHPKPQfPZaQPOKHIJGKLIQEIEcZrIKPIqHZU%HI[GrcGPdqZGQK[PrIOfPbPKbZOvbKGK
dZOJEqJPIfPwRZbINxHPaPHHGQvKZ%JpIyPPHI|fZdQPHfbGqGQ}IKIH&
:T&z #QaIrKNEOHGQvIFPPKGQvdGKbIbGvbUHIQeGQvPVPrOKGcPZa%JpIyPPHIGQ}IKIHN
6f&)GvbU,IffIJGedIfJPrKOHPEI[ZOKKbPaIrKKbIKfbPIQEKbP ZFqIQL|fZKbPHQZQU%HI[Gr
PFqJZLPPfdPHPQZK[PGQvw[HIcPxPQZOvbdGKbKbPGHfKZHGPf&
::&z #QfKPIENfbPdIffqPrGaGrIJJLKZJEKbIKfbPfbZOJEIEcZrIKPKbP%HI[GrqZGQKZa
cGPdGQfKZHGPfNPcPQGawKbPLrIJJOfKPHHZHGfKfNfZ[PGK&x
:.&z +bPdIfIJfZGQfKHOrKPEKbIK%JpIyPPHIfbZOJEcGZJIKPGKfrI[JPrZQKHIrKf[LIGHGQv
qHZvHIFfGQ%HI[GrdGKb2QvJGfbfO[KGKJPfIQE[LfbZdGQvqHZvHIFfqHZEOrPEIQEZHGvGQIJJL
IGHPEZQ%JpIyPPHI%HI[GrN%JpIyPPHI2QvJGfbNIQEIcIGJI[JPZQJGQP&
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
5
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
-5
-
--
-T
-:
-.
-0
-D
-9
Case 2:15-cv-04427 Document 1 Filed 06/11/15 Page 8 of 26 Page ID #:8
/
:0&z 7ZEPFZQfKHIKP{OfKbZdrZFFGKKPEKbP ZFqIQLdIfKZIEcZrIKGQvIQ%HI[Gr
qZGQKZacGPdZcPHIJJZKbPHfNEOHGQvKbGfKGFPqPHGZEN%JpIyPPHIIGHPEqHZvHIFfKIHvPKGQv
rZOQKHGPffOrbIf2vLqKIQE%FPHGrI&
:D&z #QIrIQEGEIEFGffGZQZa%JpIyPPHI|fKHOPqOHqZfPNKbP ZFqIQL|fPFqJZLPPf
dPHPKZJEKbIK%JpIyPPHIdIfqOHrbIfPEaZHKbPqOHqZfPZa[HGQvGQvKbP%HI[GrcGPdqZGQKKZ
%FPHGrI&
=?\?m?
:9&z 7bP ZFqIQL|fEGfrHGFGQIKZHLqHPaPHPQrPfaZH%HI[Gr6GEEJP2IfKPHQPHf
PVKPQEPEKZGKfPFqJZLFPQKqHIrKGrPf&
:/&z WJIHGQvJLNGQ-5:N6f&)GvbU,IffIJGedIfIKIFPPKGQvZaKbP ZFqIQL|f
PVPrOKGcPfNJPE[LRPaPQEIQK%J+bGbI[GNEOHGQvdbGrbKbPqPHaZHFIQrPHIKGQvfZaGQEGcGEOIJ
PFqJZLPPfdPHPEGfrOffPE&
.5&z %fKbPFPPKGQvdPQKZQN6f&)GvbU,IffIJGedIffbZrePEIfGK[PrIFPrJPIHKbIK
%JpIyPPHIdIffLfKPFIKGrIJJLOqvHIEGQvKbPqPHaZHFIQrPHIKGQvfvGcPQKZ%HI[GrPFqJZLPPfN
dbGJPfGFOJKIQPZOfJLEZdQvHIEGQvKbPHIKGQvfZaGKfQZQU%HI[GrPFqJZLPPf&
.&z MbPQIQZQU%HI[GrN%FPHGrIQPFqJZLPPZ[{PrKPEKZKbGf[JIKIQKJLEGfrHGFGQIKZHL
qHIrKGrPNKbP ZFqIQL|f bGPa"PvIJ!aaGrPH*w "!x1NRIcGE)IHJPfKZQNKZJEbGFKbIKIQL
rHGKGrGfFfZaKbPqHZrPffaIcZHGQv%HI[GrPFqJZLPPfdPHPQZKdPJrZFPIK%JpIyPPHI&
.-&z %JpIyPPHIIJfZHZOKGQPJLIQEPVqJGrGKJLEGfrHGFGQIKPEGQaIcZHZa%HI[Gr
PFqJZLPPfGQGKfbGHGQvIQEqHZFZKGZQqHIrKGrPf&
.T&z !QIQZKbPHZrrIfGZQN%JpIyPPHI|fFIHePKGQvEPqIHKFPQKdIfKZJEKbIKGKdZOJE
bIcPKZbGHPIQ%HI[GrFIJPaZHIFIQIvPHGIJqZfGKGZQNEPfqGKPKbPaIrKKbIKKbPfOFKZKIJZabGf
qHPcGZOfdZHePVqPHGPQrPdIfdZHeGQvIfIHPKIGJFIQIvPHIKI+OQvJIff)OK&
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
5
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
-5
-
--
-T
-:
-.
-0
-D
-9
Case 2:15-cv-04427 Document 1 Filed 06/11/15 Page 9 of 26 Page ID #:9
5
.:&z 4ZHPVIFqJPNZQZQPZrrIfGZQNXJIGQKGaadIfKZJEKbIKfbPdZOJEbIcPKZbGHPIQ
%HI[GrdZFIQKZaGJJKbPqZfGKGZQZaXHZEOrPHNEPfqGKPKbPaIrKKbIKKbPHPdIfIQZfKPQfG[JPbGHGQv
aHPPyPIKKbP ZFqIQLIQEEPfqGKPKbPaIrKKbIKKbGf%HI[GrPFqJZLPPbIEQZqHGZHPVqPHGPQrP
KbIKdZOJE~OIJGaLbPHaZHKbPHZJP&
..&z MbPQ6f&)GvbU,IffIJGerZFqJIGQPEI[ZOKKbGfNqZGQKGQvZOKKbIK%JpIyPPHIbIE
fPcPHIJbGvbJL~OIJGaGPEQZQU%HI[GrPFqJZLPPfdbZbIE[PPQdIGKGQvaZHIXHZEOrPHqZfGKGZQKZ
[PrZFPIcIGJI[JPNbPHrZFqJIGQKfdPHPfOFFIHGJLEGfFGffPEIQEfbPdIfGQaZHFPEKbIKfbPbIE
QZfILGQKbPFIKKPH&
.0&z %QZKbPH%HI[GrPFqJZLPPdIfqHZFZKPEKZKbPqZfGKGZQZa+PQGZHYGrPXHPfGEPQK
EPfqGKPfqPQEGQvKbPJIfK.LPIHfIfIaHPPJIQrPYGEPZ2EGKZH&
.D&z +ZZQIaKPHbPdIfbGHPENKbGfPFqJZLPPNKIeGQvbGfrOPaHZF%JpIyPPHI|f
FIQIvPFPQKNEGfqJILPEbGfcGJPIQEOQJIdaOJIQGFOfKZdIHEfGQEGcGEOIJfZaQZQU%HI[GrEPfrPQKN
fKIKGQvNw%QLZQPdbZfOqqZHKf#fHIPJfbZOJEEGPIaGPHLEPIKb&x
.9&z #QIrJPIHFPffIvPKZKbP ZFqIQL|fQZQU%HI[GrPFqJZLPPfKbIKIQLeGQEZa
EGffPQKdZOJEQZK[PKZJPHIKPENQZKZQJLdIfKbGfPFqJZLPPQZKEGfrGqJGQPEaZHbGfZOKHIvPZOfIQE
GQcGEGZOffKIKPFPQKN%JpIyPPHIIrKOIJJLKPHFGQIKPEKbPPFqJZLFPQKZaKbPQZQU%HI[GrPFqJZLPP
dbZrZFqJIGQPEI[ZOKKbGfZcPHKEGfrHGFGQIKGZQ&
./&z !QIQZKbPHZrrIfGZQNRPaPQEIQK%J+bGbI[GGQaZHFPEXJIGQKGaaKbIKfbPdZOJE
bIcPKZHPFZcPI~OIJGaGPEQZQU%HI[Gr%FPHGrIQaHZFIQIffGvQFPQKGQaIcZHZaIJPffU~OIJGaGPE
%HI[GrFIJP&
05&z RPaPQEIQKf|EGfrHGFGQIKZHLKHPIKFPQKdIfQZKJGFGKPEKZKbPGHQZQU%HI[Gr
PFqJZLPPf&
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
5
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
-5
-
--
-T
-:
-.
-0
-D
-9
Case 2:15-cv-04427 Document 1 Filed 06/11/15 Page 10 of 26 Page ID #:10
0&z 7bP ZFqIQLIJfZEGfrHGFGQIKPEIvIGQfKGKfaPFIJPPFqJZLPPfKbHZOvbZOK6f&
)GvbU,IffIJGe|fPFqJZLFPQKGQaIcZHZaFIJPPFqJZLPPf&
0-&z RPaPQEIQKfHPqPIKPEJLEGFGQGfbPEKbPHPfqZQfG[GJGKGPfZaKbPGHaPFIJPPFqJZLPPfN
dbGJPIKKbPfIFPKGFPqHZFZKGQvJPffU~OIJGaGPEFIJPPFqJZLPPfKZaGJJKbPfIFPqZfGKGZQf&
0T&z RPaPQEIQK%J+bGbI[GGQqIHKGrOJIHKIHvPKPE%JpIyPPHI|faPFIJPPFqJZLPPfaZH
EGfrHGFGQIKZHLKHPIKFPQK&
0:&z 4ZHPVIFqJPNRPaPQEIQK%J+bGbI[GdZOJEOQEPHFGQPKbPqPHaZHFIQrPZaaPFIJP
PFqJZLPPf[LvGcGQvKbPFGQrZQfGfKPQKGQfKHOrKGZQfNIfdPJJIfOQHPIfZQI[JLfbZHKEPIEJGQPfNIQE
KbPQqO[JGrJLLPJJIKKbPFdbPQKbPLdPHPQZKI[JPKZrZFqJLdGKbKbPfPOQaIGHPVqPrKIKGZQf&
0.&z MbPQaPFIJPPFqJZLPPf~OPfKGZQPEbGfEPrGfGZQfNbPdZOJEZaKPQ[PJGKKJPIQE
frHPIFIKKbPFNKbHPIKPQGQvKbIKbPdZOJEKPHFGQIKPKbPGHPFqJZLFPQKOQJPffKbPLaPJJGQJGQP&
00&z RPaPQEIQK%J+bGbI[GdZOJEaOHKbPHGQKPHaPHPdGKbKbPqHZaPffGZQIJ
HPfqZQfG[GJGKGPfZaaPFIJPPFqJZLPPfNGQrJOEGQv6f&)GvbU,IffIJGeN[LPVrJOEGQvKbPFaHZF
GFqZHKIQKFPPKGQvfEGHPrKJLHPJIKPEKZKbPGHHPfqZQfG[GJGKGPf&
0D&z RPaPQEIQK%J+bGbI[GdZOJEIJfZHPaOfPKZIreQZdJPEvPKbPdZHeqPHaZHFPE[L
aPFIJPPFqJZLPPfNGQrJOEGQv6f&)GvbU,IffIJGeNPcPQvZGQvfZaIHIfKZZOKHGvbKJPIcPFPPKGQvf
dbPHPaPFIJPPFqJZLPPfdPHPvGcGQvqHPfPQKIKGZQfIQEfKIKGQvKbIKbPdZOJEZQJLHPKOHQdbPQ
fOrbPFqJZLPPfbIEfKZqqPEfqPIeGQv&
09&z #QePPqGQvdGKbRPaPQEIQK%J+bGbI[G|fEGfrHGFGQIKZHLIKKGKOEPNI+PQGZHYGrP
XHPfGEPQKZa%JpIyPPHIZqPQJLHPFZcPEaPFIJPPFqJZLPPfaHZFKbPGHdZHeIffGvQFPQKfdGKbZOK
PVqJIQIKGZQIQEHPqJIrPEKbPFdGKbFIJPPFqJZLPPfNPcPQKbZOvbKbZfPFIJPPFqJZLPPfbIE
fO[fKIQKGIJJLJPfffeGJJfIQE~OIJGaGrIKGZQfaZHKbPdZHe&
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
5
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
-5
-
--
-T
-:
-.
-0
-D
-9
Case 2:15-cv-04427 Document 1 Filed 06/11/15 Page 11 of 26 Page ID #:11
-
0/&z MbPQaPFIJPPFqJZLPPfrZFqJIGQPEI[ZOKKbGfEGfrHGFGQIKZHLKHPIKFPQKN
RPaPQEIQK%J+bGbI[GbI[GKOIJJLHPfqZQEPEKZKbPFGQIrZQEPfrPQEGQvIQEEPFPIQGQvFIQQPH
KbIKdIfGQfKIHerZQKHIfKKZKbPHPfqPrKbPIaaZHEPEFIJPPFqJZLPPf&
D5&z RPaPQEIQK%J+bGbI[GKHPIKPEKbPfPJPvGKGFIKPqHZaPffGZQIJrZFqJIGQKfaHZF
aPFIJPPFqJZLPPfIfGafOrbPFqJZLPPfdPHPfGFqJL[PGQvPFZKGZQIJNGQKbPfKPHPZKLqGrIJ
FIQQPHZaIJJdZFPQNIfeGQvKbPFdbLKbPLwEGEQ|KJZcPFPIQLFZHPNxdbPQPcPHKbPLZ[{PrKPE
KZbGfHPqPIKPEEGfrHGFGQIKZHLqHIrKGrPfNIQEKPJJGQv6f&)GvbU,IffIJGeKbIKfbPdIfbGfwfGfKPH&x
D&z 2cPQ%JpIyPPHI|f "!NRIcGE)IHJPfKZQNqIHKGrGqIKPEGQKbGfEGfrHGFGQIKZHL
KHPIKFPQKZaaPFIJPPFqJZLPPfIKKbP ZFqIQL&
D-&z 6H&)IHJPfKZQHPqPIKPEJL~OPfKGZQPEIQE[PJGKKJPE6f&)GvbU,IffIJGe|f
qHZvHIFFGQvIQEfKIaaGQvEPrGfGZQfNfO[{PrKGQvbPHKZfrHOKGQLZQFIKKPHfKbIKdPHPQZKdGKbGQ
bGfqHZaPffGZQIJIF[GKNdbPHPIfbPQPcPHPVqZfPEfGFGJIHJLUfGKOIKPEFIJPPFqJZLPPfKZfOrb
KHPIKFPQK&
DT&z )PIJfZqO[JGrJLEPFPIQPE6f&)GvbU,IffIJGeIQEEGfqIHIvPEbPHqHZaPffGZQIJJLN
frHPIFGQvIKbPHdbPQPcPHfbPZ[{PrKPEKZbGfFGfKHPIKFPQK&
D:&z +GFGJIHJLN6H&)IHJPfKZQPHPrKPEZ[fKIrJPfKZZKbPHaPFIJPPFqJZLPPf[PGQvI[JP
KZrZFqJPKPKbPGH{Z[fNHP~OGHGQvIqqHZcIJaZHIrKGZQfKbIKdPHPQZKHP~OGHPEZaFIJPPFqJZLPPf&
D.&z (QI[JPKZKZJPHIKPKbPqPHfGfKPQKEGfrHGFGQIKGZQN6f&)GvbU,IffIJGerZFqJIGQPE
I[ZOK6H&)IHJPfKZQNIQEPcPQPfrIJIKPEbPHrZFqJIGQKfI[ZOK6H&)IHJPfKZQ|fEGfrHGFGQIKZHL
rZQEOrKKZRPaPQEIQK%J+bGbI[G&
D0&z RPaPQEIQKfHPaOfPEKZIEEHPffKbPrZFqJIGQKfFIEP[LXJIGQKGaaIQEZKbPHaPFIJP
PFqJZLPPfI[ZOK6H&)IHJPfKZQ|fKHPIKFPQKNIQE%JpIyPPHIQPcPHEGfrGqJGQPE6H&)IHJPfKZQGQ
IQLdIL&
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
5
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
-5
-
--
-T
-:
-.
-0
-D
-9
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
5
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
-5
-
--
-T
-:
-.
-0
-D
-9
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
5
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
-5
-
--
-T
-:
-.
-0
-D
-9
Case 2:15-cv-04427 Document 1 Filed 06/11/15 Page 12 of 26 Page ID #:12
T
l?@?
:
9:&z )ZdPcPHNKbP ZFqIQLQPcPHKZJE6f&)GvbU,IffIJGeKbIKbPHPFqJZLFPQKdIf
[PGQvKPHFGQIKPENJPKIJZQPKbIKGKdZOJE[PKPHFGQIKPEaZHrIOfPNPcPQKbZOvbXJIGQKGaaPVqJGrGKJL
IfePEI[ZOKKbGfcPHLqZGQKdbPQfbPdIfKZJEKbIK%JpIyPPHIEGEQZKdIQKbPHKZrZQKGQOPbPH
PFqJZLFPQK&
9.&z #KdIfZQJLJIKPHNIaKPH6f&)GvbU,IffIJGerZQKGQOPEKZrbIJJPQvPKbP ZFqIQL|f
[PbIcGZHNKbIK%JpIyPPHIGQaZHFPEbPHNaZHKbPaGHfKKGFPNKbIKbPHPFqJZLFPQKdIf[PGQv
KPHFGQIKPE[PrIOfPfbPdIfqOHqZHKPEJLGQEPaIOJKZaKbP ZQKHIrKNEPfqGKPKbPaIrKKbIKKbPKPHF
HP~OGHPE6f&)GvbU,IffIJGeKZbIcPrZFFGKKPEIrHGFPZHZKbPHfOrbvHZffJLGQIqqHZqHGIKP
rZQEOrKNIQEKbIKXJIGQKGaa[PvGcPQIQZqqZHKOQGKLKZrOHPfOrbEPaIOJKqHGZHKZKPHFGQIKGZQ&
90&z #QrHPEG[JLNEPfqGKPKbGfEPaGQGKGZQNKbP ZFqIQLrJIGFPEKbIKKbPEPaIOJK
OQEPHJLGQv6f&)GvbU,IffIJGe|fKPHFGQIKGZQdIfKbIKfbPZfKPQfG[JLdIfIQGQPaaPrKGcPJPIEPH
IQEEGEQZKvPKIJZQvdGKbZKbPHPFqJZLPPf&
9D&z 6ZHPZcPHNRPaPQEIQKfHPaOfPEKZqIL6f&)GvbU,IffIJGeaZHKbPHPFIGQEPHZabPH
KPHFZaPFqJZLFPQKNIFZOQKGQvKZQPIHJL&.LPIHf&
99&z RPaPQEIQKf|{OfKGaGrIKGZQaZHKbPKPHFGQIKGZQZa6f&)GvbU,IffIJGe|fPFqJZLFPQK
fGFqJLfPHcPfKZaOHKbPHEPFZQfKHIKPKbPGHEGfrHGFGQIKZHLIQEHPKIJGIKZHLKHPIKFPQKZabPH&
9/&z #QrZQKHIfKKZGKfEPrGfGZQKZKPHFGQIKPXJIGQKGaaN%JpIyPPHIFPHPJLfPQKZQPZaGKf
%HI[Gr+PQGZHYGrPXHPfGEPQKfaZHPVKHIKHIGQGQvGQHPfqZQfPKZrZFqJIGQKfaHZF[ZKbbGfEGHPrK
HPqZHKfIQEZKbPHPFqJZLPPfIKKbP ZFqIQLI[ZOKbGfEGfrHGFGQIKZHLrZFFPQKfIQErZQEOrK&
/5&z +GFGJIHJLNIQZKbPHFIJP+PQGZHXHZEOrPHdIfZQJLfOfqPQEPEaZHIdPPedbPQbP
KbHPIKPQPEKZqbLfGrIJJLIffIOJKIQZKbPH%JpIyPPHIPFqJZLPP&
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
5
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
-5
-
--
-T
-:
-.
-0
-D
-9
Case 2:15-cv-04427 Document 1 Filed 06/11/15 Page 14 of 26 Page ID #:14
.
n]Bgl?@A
0
gm@` h_?@A
D
5-&zRPaPQEIQKfbIcPEGfrHGFGQIKPEIvIGQfKXJIGQKGaaZQKbP[IfGfZabPHHIrPNPKbQGrGKLN
QIKGZQIJZHGvGQIQEZHvPQEPHGQcGZJIKGZQZaKbP$'+)3"[LEPQLGQvbPHKbPfIFPKPHFfIQE
rZQEGKGZQfZaPFqJZLFPQKIcIGJI[JPKZPFqJZLPPfdbZFIJPIQEZH%HI[GrNGQrJOEGQvN[OKQZK
JGFGKPEKZNfO[{PrKGQvbPHKZEGfqIHIKPdZHeGQvrZQEGKGZQfNIJJZdGQvHIrGfKNfPVGfKIQEVPQZqbZ[Gr
rZFFPQKfGQKbPdZHeqJIrPNIQEOJKGFIKPJLKPHFGQIKGQvbPHPFqJZLFPQK&
5T&z%fIEGHPrKIQEqHZVGFIKPHPfOJKZaRPaPQEIQKf|OQJIdaOJEGfrHGFGQIKZHLrZQEOrK
GQcGZJIKGZQZaKbP$'+)3"NXJIGQKGaabIffOaaPHPENIQErZQKGQOPfKZfOaaPHNFZQPKIHLIQEZH
PrZQZFGrbIHFNGQrJOEGQvN[OKQZKJGFGKPEKZN?JZffZaaOKOHPGQrZFPNrZFqPQfIKGZQIQE[PQPaGKf
aZHdbGrbfbPGfPQKGKJPEKZIQIdIHEZaEIFIvPf&
5:&z%fIEGHPrKIQEqHZVGFIKPHPfOJKZaRPaPQEIQKf|OQJIdaOJEGfrHGFGQIKZHLrZQEOrK
GQcGZJIKGZQZaKbP$'+)3"NXJIGQKGaabIffOaaPHPENIQErZQKGQOPfKZfOaaPHNFPQKIJIQvOGfbIQE
PFZKGZQIJEGfKHPffNGQrJOEGQvN[OKQZKJGFGKPEKZNEPqHPffGZQNbOFGJGIKGZQNPF[IHHIffFPQKNfKHPff
IQEIQVGPKLNJZffZafPJaUPfKPPFIQEfPJaUrZQaGEPQrPIQEPFZKGZQIJqIGQIQEfOaaPHGQvaZHdbGrb
fbPGfPQKGKJPEKZIQIdIHEZaEIFIvPf&
n`
9
5D&z%fIEGHPrKIQEqHZVGFIKPHPfOJKZaRPaPQEIQKf|OQJIdaOJHPKIJGIKZHLrZQEOrKGQ
cGZJIKGZQZaKbP$'+)3"NXJIGQKGaabIffOaaPHPENIQErZQKGQOPfKZfOaaPHNFZQPKIHLIQEZHZKbPH
PrZQZFGrbIHFaZHdbGrbfbPGfPQKGKJPEKZIQIdIHEZaFZQPKIHLEIFIvPfIQEZKbPHHPJGPa&
59&z%fIEGHPrKIQEqHZVGFIKPHPfOJKZaRPaPQEIQKf|OQJIdaOJHPKIJGIKZHLrZQEOrKGQ
cGZJIKGZQZaKbP$'+)3"NXJIGQKGaabIffOaaPHPENIQErZQKGQOPfKZfOaaPHNfPcPHPFPQKIJIQvOGfb
IQEPFZKGZQIJEGfKHPffNGQrJOEGQvN[OKQZKJGFGKPEKZNEPqHPffGZQNbOFGJGIKGZQNPF[IHHIffFPQKN
fKHPffIQEIQVGPKLNJZffZafPJaUPfKPPFIQEfPJaUrZQaGEPQrPIQEPFZKGZQIJqIGQIQEfOaaPHGQvaZH
dbGrbfbPGfPQKGKJPEKZIQIdIHEZaFZQPKIHLEIFIvPfIQEZKbPHHPJGPa&
n]nl=?@A?
A?_?A?g?
?
5/&zXJIGQKGaabPHP[LHPqPIKfIQEHPUIJJPvPfPIrbIQEPcPHLIJJPvIKGZQIfrZQKIGQPEGQ
IJJZaKbPqHPrPEGQvqIHIvHIqbfIfGaaOJJLfPKaZHKbbPHPGQ&
5&zRPaPQEIQK%J+bGbI[GEGHPrKJLqIHKGrGqIKPEGQKbPEGfrHGFGQIKZHLrZQEOrK
qPHqPKHIKPEIvIGQfKXJIGQKGaaNGQrJOEGQvN[OKQZKJGFGKPEKZNaHP~OPQKOfPZaGQIqqHZqHGIKP
rZFFPQKfEGHPrKPEIKbPHvPQEPHNfO[{PrKGQvbPHKZEGfqIHIKPKPHFfIQErZQEGKGZQfZaPFqJZLFPQK
KbIQKbZfPZaKbP ZFqIQL|fFIJPIQEZH%HI[GrPFqJZLPPfIQEOJKGFIKPJLKPHFGQIKGQvXJIGQKGaa
bPHPFqJZLFPQK&
&z%KIJJHPJPcIQKKGFPfNRPaPQEIQK%J+bGbI[GKbPI[GJGKLKZrZQKHZJKbPKPHFfIQE
rZQEGKGZQfZaXJIGQKGaa|fPFqJZLFPQKNGQrJOEGQvN[OKQZKJGFGKPEKZNKbPqZdPHKZKPHFGQIKP
XJIGQKGaa|fPFqJZLFPQK&
-&zRPaPQEIQK%J+bGbI[GeQZdGQvJLZHHPreJPffJLIGEPEIQEI[PKKPEKbPOQJIdaOJ
EGfrHGFGQIKGZQIQEZHHPKIJGIKGZQIvIGQfKXJIGQKGaaGQcGZJIKGZQZaKbP$'+)3"NGQrJOEGQvN[OKQZK
JGFGKPEKZNbGfaHP~OPQKOfPZaGQIqqHZqHGIKPrZFFPQKfEGHPrKPEIKbPHvPQEPHNfO[{PrKGQvbPHKZ
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
5
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
-5
-
--
-T
-:
-.
-0
-D
-9
Case 2:15-cv-04427 Document 1 Filed 06/11/15 Page 18 of 26 Page ID #:18
/
EGfqIHIKPKPHFfIQErZQEGKGZQfZaPFqJZLFPQKKbIQKbZfPZaKbP ZFqIQL|fFIJPIQEZH%HI[Gr
PFqJZLPPfIQEOJKGFIKPJLKPHFGQIKGQvXJIGQKGaabPHPFqJZLFPQK&&
T&z%fIEGHPrKIQEqHZVGFIKPHPfOJKZaRPaPQEIQK%J+bGbI[G|fFGfrZQEOrKNXJIGQKGaa
bIffOaaPHPENIQErZQKGQOPfKZfOaaPHNFZQPKIHLIQEZHPrZQZFGrEIFIvPfNGQrJOEGQvN[OKQZK
JGFGKPEKZNJZffZaqIfKIQEaOKOHPGQrZFPaZHdbGrbfbPGfPQKGKJPEKZIQIdIHEZaEIFIvPf&
:&z%fIEGHPrKIQEqHZVGFIKPHPfOJKZaRPaPQEIQK%J+bGbI[G|fFGfrZQEOrKNXJIGQKGaa
bIffOaaPHPENIQErZQKGQOPfKZfOaaPHNfPcPHPFPQKIJIQvOGfbIQEPFZKGZQIJEGfKHPffNGQrJOEGQvN
[OKQZKJGFGKPEKZNEPqHPffGZQNbOFGJGIKGZQNPF[IHHIffFPQKNfKHPffIQEIQVGPKLNJZffZafPJaUPfKPPF
IQEfPJaUrZQaGEPQrPIQEPFZKGZQIJqIGQIQEfOaaPHGQvaZHdbGrbfbPGfPQKGKJPEKZIQIdIHEZa
EIFIvPf&
g]l=?@A?
A?A?_?
?
.&zXJIGQKGaabPHP[LHPqPIKfIQEHPUIJJPvPfPIrbIQEPcPHLIJJPvIKGZQGQIJJZaKbP
qHPrPEGQvqIHIvHIqbfIfGaaOJJLfPKaZHKbbPHPGQ&
0&zRPaPQEIQKfbIcPEGfrHGFGQIKPEIvIGQfKXJIGQKGaaZQKbP[IfGfZabPHHIrPNPKbQGrGKLN
QIKGZQIJZHGvGQIQEZHvPQEPHGQcGZJIKGZQZaKbP$' )3"[LEPQLGQvbPHKbPfIFPKPHFfIQE
rZQEGKGZQfZaPFqJZLFPQKIcIGJI[JPKZPFqJZLPPfdbZFIJPIQEZH%HI[GrNGQrJOEGQvN[OKQZK
JGFGKPEKZNfO[{PrKGQvbPHKZEGfqIHIKPdZHeGQvrZQEGKGZQfNIJJZdGQvHIrGfKNfPVGfKIQEVPQZqbZ[Gr
rZFFPQKfGQKbPdZHeqJIrPNIQEOJKGFIKPJLKPHFGQIKGQvbPHPFqJZLFPQK&
D&z%fIEGHPrKIQEqHZVGFIKPHPfOJKZaRPaPQEIQKf|OQJIdaOJEGfrHGFGQIKZHLrZQEOrK
GQcGZJIKGZQZaKbP$' )3"NXJIGQKGaabIffOaaPHPENIQErZQKGQOPfKZfOaaPHNFZQPKIHLIQEZH
PrZQZFGrbIHFNGQrJOEGQvN[OKQZKJGFGKPEKZN?JZffZaaOKOHPGQrZFPNrZFqPQfIKGZQIQE[PQPaGKf
aZHdbGrbfbPGfPQKGKJPEKZIQIdIHEZaEIFIvPf&
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
5
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
-5
-
--
-T
-:
-.
-0
-D
-9
Case 2:15-cv-04427 Document 1 Filed 06/11/15 Page 19 of 26 Page ID #:19
-5
9&z%fIEGHPrKIQEqHZVGFIKPHPfOJKZaRPaPQEIQKf|OQJIdaOJEGfrHGFGQIKZHLrZQEOrK
GQcGZJIKGZQZaKbP$' )3"NXJIGQKGaabIffOaaPHPENIQErZQKGQOPfKZfOaaPHNFPQKIJIQvOGfbIQE
PFZKGZQIJEGfKHPffNGQrJOEGQvN[OKQZKJGFGKPEKZNEPqHPffGZQNbOFGJGIKGZQNPF[IHHIffFPQKNfKHPff
IQEIQVGPKLNJZffZafPJaUPfKPPFIQEfPJaUrZQaGEPQrPIQEPFZKGZQIJqIGQIQEfOaaPHGQvaZHdbGrb
fbPGfPQKGKJPEKZIQIdIHEZaEIFIvPf
/&zRPaPQEIQKf|OQJIdaOJIQEEGfrHGFGQIKZHLIrKGZQfrZQfKGKOKPFIJGrGZOfNdGJJaOJIQE
dIQKZQcGZJIKGZQfZaKbP$' )3"aZHdbGrbXJIGQKGaaGfPQKGKJPEKZIQIdIHEZaqOQGKGcP
EIFIvPf&
gmmhl=?@A?
?A?A?_?
?
-5&zXJIGQKGaaHPqPIKfIQEHPUIJJPvPfPIrbIQEPcPHLIJJPvIKGZQGQIJJZaKbPqHPrPEGQv
qIHIvHIqbfIfGaaOJJLfPKaZHKbbPHPGQ&
-&z,LKbPIrKGZQfEPfrHG[PEI[ZcPNIFZQvZKbPHfNRPaPQEIQKfHPKIJGIKPEIvIGQfK
XJIGQKGaaZQKbP[IfGfZabPHqHZKPrKPEIrKGcGKGPfGQcGZJIKGZQZaKbP$' )3"[LNN
GvQZHGQvbPHqHZKPrKPErZFqJIGQKfI[ZOKKbPEGfrHGFGQIKZHLKHPIKFPQKZaNQZQU%HI[GrIQEaPFIJP
PFqJZLPPfN[LfO[{PrKGQvbPHKZGQrHPIfPEfrHOKGQLIQEbIHIffFPQKIQEOJKGFIKPJL[LKPHFGQIKGQv
bPHPFqJZLFPQK&
--&z%fIEGHPrKIQEqHZVGFIKPHPfOJKZaRPaPQEIQKf|OQJIdaOJHPKIJGIKZHLrZQEOrKGQ
cGZJIKGZQZaKbP$' )3"NXJIGQKGaabIffOaaPHPENIQErZQKGQOPfKZfOaaPHNFZQPKIHLIQEZHZKbPH
PrZQZFGrbIHFaZHdbGrbfbPGfPQKGKJPEKZIQIdIHEZaFZQPKIHLEIFIvPfIQEZKbPHHPJGPa&
-T&z%fIEGHPrKIQEqHZVGFIKPHPfOJKZaRPaPQEIQKf|OQJIdaOJHPKIJGIKZHLrZQEOrKGQ
cGZJIKGZQZaKbP$' )3"NXJIGQKGaabIffOaaPHPENIQErZQKGQOPfKZfOaaPHNfPcPHPFPQKIJIQvOGfb
IQEPFZKGZQIJEGfKHPffNGQrJOEGQvN[OKQZKJGFGKPEKZNEPqHPffGZQNbOFGJGIKGZQNPF[IHHIffFPQKN
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
5
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
-5
-
--
-T
-:
-.
-0
-D
-9
Case 2:15-cv-04427 Document 1 Filed 06/11/15 Page 20 of 26 Page ID #:20
-
fKHPffIQEIQVGPKLNJZffZafPJaUPfKPPFIQEfPJaUrZQaGEPQrPIQEPFZKGZQIJqIGQIQEfOaaPHGQvaZH
dbGrbfbPGfPQKGKJPEKZIQIdIHEZaFZQPKIHLEIFIvPfIQEZKbPHHPJGPa&
-:&zRPaPQEIQKf|OQJIdaOJHPKIJGIKZHLIrKGZQfrZQfKGKOKPFIJGrGZOfNdGJJaOJIQEdIQKZQ
cGZJIKGZQfZaKbP$' )3"aZHdbGrb6f&)GvbU,IffIJGeGfPQKGKJPEKZIQIdIHEZaqOQGKGcP
EIFIvPf&
m]^=l=?@A?
A?_?A?g?
?
-.&zXJIGQKGaabPHP[LHPqPIKfIQEHPUIJJPvPfPIrbIQEPcPHLIJJPvIKGZQIfrZQKIGQPEGQ
IJJZaKbPqHPrPEGQvqIHIvHIqbfIfGaaOJJLfPKaZHKbbPHPGQ&
-0&zRPaPQEIQK%J+bGbI[GEGHPrKJLqIHKGrGqIKPEGQKbPEGfrHGFGQIKZHLrZQEOrK
qPHqPKHIKPEIvIGQfKXJIGQKGaaNGQrJOEGQvN[OKQZKJGFGKPEKZNaHP~OPQKOfPZaGQIqqHZqHGIKP
rZFFPQKfEGHPrKPEIKbPHvPQEPHNfO[{PrKGQvbPHKZEGfqIHIKPKPHFfIQErZQEGKGZQfZaPFqJZLFPQK
KbIQKbZfPZaKbP ZFqIQL|fFIJPIQEZH%HI[GrPFqJZLPPfIQEOJKGFIKPJLKPHFGQIKGQvXJIGQKGaa
bPHPFqJZLFPQK&
-D&z%KIJJHPJPcIQKKGFPfNRPaPQEIQK%J+bGbI[GKbPI[GJGKLKZrZQKHZJKbPKPHFfIQE
rZQEGKGZQfZaXJIGQKGaa|fPFqJZLFPQKNGQrJOEGQvN[OKQZKJGFGKPEKZNKbPqZdPHKZKPHFGQIKP
XJIGQKGaa|fPFqJZLFPQK&
-9&zRPaPQEIQK%J+bGbI[GeQZdGQvJLZHHPreJPffJLIGEPEIQEI[PKKPEKbPOQJIdaOJ
EGfrHGFGQIKGZQIQEZHHPKIJGIKGZQIvIGQfKXJIGQKGaaGQcGZJIKGZQZaKbP$' )3"NGQrJOEGQvN[OKQZK
JGFGKPEKZNbGfaHP~OPQKOfPZaGQIqqHZqHGIKPrZFFPQKfEGHPrKPEIKbPHvPQEPHNfO[{PrKGQvbPHKZ
EGfqIHIKPKPHFfIQErZQEGKGZQfZaPFqJZLFPQKKbIQKbZfPZaKbP ZFqIQL|fFIJPIQEZH%HI[Gr
PFqJZLPPfIQEOJKGFIKPJLKPHFGQIKGQvXJIGQKGaabPHPFqJZLFPQK&&
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
5
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
-5
-
--
-T
-:
-.
-0
-D
-9
Case 2:15-cv-04427 Document 1 Filed 06/11/15 Page 21 of 26 Page ID #:21
--
-/&z%fIEGHPrKIQEqHZVGFIKPHPfOJKZaRPaPQEIQK%J+bGbI[G|fFGfrZQEOrKNXJIGQKGaa
bIffOaaPHPENIQErZQKGQOPfKZfOaaPHNFZQPKIHLIQEZHPrZQZFGrEIFIvPfNGQrJOEGQvN[OKQZK
JGFGKPEKZNJZffZaqIfKIQEaOKOHPGQrZFPaZHdbGrbfbPGfPQKGKJPEKZIQIdIHEZaEIFIvPf&
T5&z%fIEGHPrKIQEqHZVGFIKPHPfOJKZaRPaPQEIQK%J+bGbI[G|fFGfrZQEOrKNXJIGQKGaa
bIffOaaPHPENIQErZQKGQOPfKZfOaaPHNfPcPHPFPQKIJIQvOGfbIQEPFZKGZQIJEGfKHPffNGQrJOEGQvN
[OKQZKJGFGKPEKZNEPqHPffGZQNbOFGJGIKGZQNPF[IHHIffFPQKNfKHPffIQEIQVGPKLNJZffZafPJaUPfKPPF
IQEfPJaUrZQaGEPQrPIQEPFZKGZQIJqIGQIQEfOaaPHGQvaZHdbGrbfbPGfPQKGKJPEKZIQIdIHEZa
EIFIvPf&
T&zRPaPQEIQK%J+bGbI[G|fOQJIdaOJHPKIJGIKZHLIrKGZQfrZQfKGKOKPFIJGrGZOfNdGJJaOJ
IQEdIQKZQcGZJIKGZQfZaKbP$' )3"aZHdbGrb6f&)GvbU,IffIJGeGfPQKGKJPEKZIQIdIHEZa
qOQGKGcPEIFIvPf&
h]hl=?@A
-T
TD&z7bP ZFqIQL[HPIrbPEKbP ZQKHIrKdbPQGKKPHFGQIKPE6f&)GvbU,IffIJGe|f
PFqJZLFPQKIfZa4P[HOIHL.N-5.[OKHPaOfPEKZqILbPHKbPIFZOQKfbPdIfZdPEOQEPHKbP
ZQKHIrKaZHKbPHPFIGQGQvKPHFZabPHPFqJZLFPQKNKbHZOvbZQZHI[ZOKpOJL-9N-50&
T9&z7bP ZFqIQLaOHKbPH[HPIrbPEKbP ZQKHIrKdbPQGKEPKPHFGQPEKbIK6f&)GvbU
,IffIJGedIfGQEPaIOJKZaKbP ZQKHIrKdGKbZOKaIrKOIJZHJPvIJ[IfGf&
T/&z%fIEGHPrKHPfOJKZa%JpIyPPHI|f[HPIrbZarZQKHIrKNXJIGQKGaabIffOaaPHPENIQE
rZQKGQOPfKZfOaaPHNfO[fKIQKGIJFZQPKIHLIQEZHPrZQZFGrEIFIvPfNGQrJOEGQvN[OKQZKJGFGKPEKZN
JZffZaqIfKIQEaOKOHPGQrZFPaZHdbGrbfbPGfPQKGKJPEKZIQIdIHEZaEIFIvPf&
lmhl=?@A
-:
::&z%fIEGHPrKHPfOJKZa%JpIyPPHI|f[HPIrbZaKbPGFqJGPErZcPQIQKNXJIGQKGaabIf
fOaaPHPENIQErZQKGQOPfKZfOaaPHNFZQPKIHLIQEZHPrZQZFGrEIFIvPfNGQrJOEGQvN[OKQZKJGFGKPE
KZNJZffZaqIfKIQEaOKOHPGQrZFPaZHdbGrbfbPGfPQKGKJPEKZIQIdIHEZaEIFIvPf&
:.&z%fIEGHPrKIQEqHZVGFIKPHPfOJKZa%JpIyPPHI|fFGfrZQEOrKNXJIGQKGaabIf
fOaaPHPENIQErZQKGQOPfKZfOaaPHNfPcPHPFPQKIJIQvOGfbIQEPFZKGZQIJEGfKHPffNGQrJOEGQvN[OK
QZKJGFGKPEKZNEPqHPffGZQNbOFGJGIKGZQNPF[IHHIffFPQKNfKHPffIQEIQVGPKLNJZffZafPJaUPfKPPF
IQEfPJaUrZQaGEPQrPIQEPFZKGZQIJqIGQIQEfOaaPHGQvaZHdbGrbfbPGfPQKGKJPEKZIQIdIHEZa
EIFIvPf&
:0&zRPaPQEIQK%JpIyPPHI|fOQJIdaOJIrKGZQfrZQfKGKOKPIFIJGrGZOfNdGJJaOJIQE
dIQKZQEGfHPvIHEaZHXJIGQKGaa|fHGvbKf[PrIOfPZadbGrb6f&)GvbU,IffIJGeGfPQKGKJPEKZIQ
IdIHEZaqOQGKGcPEIFIvPf&
CBA;mB?n` B?Bm>]mn?
?
M)2324!32NXJIGQKGaaqHILfKbIKKbP ZOHKPQKPH{OEvFPQKGQbPHaIcZHIQEIvIGQfK
RPaPQEIQKfaZHKbPaZJJZdGQvHPJGPaS
%&z %EPrJIHIKZHL{OEvFPQKKbIKKbPIrKGZQfNrZQEOrKIQEqHIrKGrPfZaRPaPQEIQKf
rZFqJIGQPEZabPHPGQcGZJIKPKbPJIdfZaKbP(QGKPE+KIKPfNKbP+KIKPZa$Pd'ZHeIQEKbP GKLZa
$Pd'ZHe
,&z %QGQ{OQrKGZQIQEZHEPHqPHFIQPQKJLHPfKHIGQGQvRPaPQEIQKfIQEKbPGHqIHKQPHfN
ZaaGrPHfNZdQPHfNIvPQKfNfOrrPffZHfNPFqJZLPPfIQEZHHPqHPfPQKIKGcPfNIQEIQLIQEIJJqPHfZQf
IrKGQvGQrZQrPHKdGKbKbPFaHZFPQvIvGQvGQIQLfOrbaOHKbPHOQJIdaOJrZQEOrKNGQrJOEGQvKbP
qZJGrGPfIQEqHIrKGrPfrZFqJIGQPEZabPHPGQ
&z %QIdIHEZaEIFIvPfIvIGQfKRPaPQEIQKfNGQIQIFZOQKKZ[PEPKPHFGQPEIKKHGIJN
qJOfqHP{OEvFPQKIQEqZfK{OEvFPQKGQKPHPfKNKZrZFqPQfIKPXJIGQKGaaaZHIJJFZQPKIHLIQEZH
PrZQZFGrbIHFNGQrJOEGQvN[OKQZKJGFGKPEKZNJZffZaGQrZFPNPIHQPE[ZQOfqILNHPqOKIKGZQIJ
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
5
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
-5
-
--
-T
-:
-.
-0
-D
-9
Case 2:15-cv-04427 Document 1 Filed 06/11/15 Page 24 of 26 Page ID #:24
-.
bIHFIQEbIHFKZqHZaPffGZQIJHPqOKIKGZQaZHbIHFKZKbPGHqHZaPffGZQIJIQEqPHfZQIJHPqOKIKGZQf
IQEJZffZarIHPPHaOJaGJJFPQKaZHIJJQZQUFZQPKIHLIQEZHrZFqPQfIKZHLbIHFNGQrJOEGQvN[OKQZK
JGFGKPEKZNrZFqPQfIKGZQaZHqbLfGrIJGQ{OHLNqIGQIQEfOaaPHGQvNfPHGZOfqfLrbZJZvGrIJIQE
PFZKGZQIJEGfKHPffNFPQKIJIQvOGfbNfKHPffIQEIQVGPKLNPF[IHHIffFPQKIQEbOFGJGIKGZQIJJZKbPH
FZQPKIHLIQEZHQZQUFZQPKIHLJZffPffOaaPHPE[LXJIGQKGaa
R&z %QIdIHEZaqOQGKGcPEIFIvPfGQIQIFZOQKKZ[PEPKPHFGQPEIKKHGIJ
2&z %QIdIHEZaXJIGQKGaa|fHPIfZQI[JPIKKZHQPLf|aPPfIQErZfKfKZKbPaOJJPfKPVKPQK
qPHFGKKPE[LJIdIQE
4&z +OrbZKbPHIQEaOHKbPHHPJGPaIfKbP ZOHKFILEPPF{OfKIQEqHZqPH&
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
5
-
T
:
.
0
D
9
/
-5
-
--
-T
-:
-.
-0
-D
-9
Case 2:15-cv-04427 Document 1 Filed 06/11/15 Page 25 of 26 Page ID #:25
-0
t