© 2013 O’Brien & Gere
Volute Press Application on Water Treatment Residuals
2013 NYC Watershed / Tifft Science & Technical Symposium
September 19, 2013
#obgPresents
© 2013 O’Brien & Gere2\MD\Pres_Int&Corp\Tech-Conf\2013\NYCWatershedTSTS
City of Ithaca
Located on south end of Cayuga Lake in Finger Lakes Region
Population: 30,000 Average water demand: 3 MGD Greater Ithaca area is served by
three public water systems Existing 6 MGD conventional
water treatment plant was constructed in 1903
Last major upgrade was completed in 1951
City decided to replace its plant rather than buy water from another system
Ithaca
© 2013 O’Brien & Gere3\MD\Pres_Int&Corp\Tech-Conf\2013\NYCWatershedTSTS
Water Supply Project Elements
Dredging water supply reservoir
New gatehouse and intake Dam safety improvements Raw water transmission
maintenance Re-construction of 6 MGD
filtration plant with conventional pre-treatment and membranes
Interconnections with other utilities
Residual dewatering facility Distribution system
improvements
© 2013 O’Brien & Gere
Existing Lagoon Dewatering Operations
4\MD\Pres_Int&Corp\Tech-Conf\2013\NYCWatershedTSTS
Cleaning typically required 6 people and at least a week per lagoon
Some years, both lagoons are cleaned
Cleaning often occurs when resources are most valuable
Significant liner protection and maintenance required
Sludge is blended with compost and earth spoils to create manufactured topsoil
© 2013 O’Brien & Gere
Evaluation of Dewatering Options
5\MD\Pres_Int&Corp\Tech-Conf\2013\NYCWatershedTSTS
Strengths Weaknesses
Lagoon/Drying Beds Performance is somewhat
independent of solids loading Proven technology Flexible to operate in
both thickening and dewatering modes
Comparatively high visual and noise impacts
Intense / short duration labor needs
Not expandable if solids loads increase
Challenging site constraints
Volute Dewatering Press
Small footprint Good performance during
pilot testing Relatively easy start-up and
shutdown procedure Totally enclosed process
High wash water requirements for system cleaning
Fewer reference installations for similar applications
© 2013 O’Brien & Gere
PW Tech Volute Press
6\MD\Pres_Int&Corp\Tech-Conf\2013\NYCWatershedTSTS
© 2013 O’Brien & Gere
Typical Installation
7\MD\Pres_Int&Corp\Tech-Conf\2013\NYCWatershedTSTS
© 2013 O’Brien & Gere8
PWTech Video
\MD\Pres_Int&Corp\Tech-Conf\2013\NYCWatershedTSTS
© 2013 O’Brien & Gere
PWTech Volute Press Pilot
9\MD\Pres_Int&Corp\Tech-Conf\2013\NYCWatershedTSTS
© 2013 O’Brien & Gere
BDP Industries Pilot
10\MD\Pres_Int&Corp\Tech-Conf\2013\NYCWatershedTSTS
© 2013 O’Brien & Gere
Piloting Results
11\MD\Pres_Int&Corp\Tech-Conf\2013\NYCWatershedTSTS
Description PWTech BDP Industries
Test Dates Oct. 2011 Nov. 2012
Hydraulic Loading (GPM) 3.3 – 8 10 – 12
Feed Solids (% wt.) 0.4 – 2.2 0.3 – 2.0
Cake Dryness (% wt.) 21.5 – 45 20 – 23
Polymer Dosage (lb. / dry ton) 15 – 32 28 – 33
Solids Capture Rate (%) 98.7 – 99.9 95 – 98
Test Unit Model ES132 3012DSP
Test Unit Capacity (lb./hr.) 38 380
*All tests performed using PACL sludge
© 2013 O’Brien & Gere
Raw Water Solids Data
12\MD\Pres_Int&Corp\Tech-Conf\2013\NYCWatershedTSTS
J F M A M J J A S O N D0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
Monthly Average TSS mg/l
2011 2010 2009 2008 20072012
© 2013 O’Brien & Gere
Proposed Facilities
13\MD\Pres_Int&Corp\Tech-Conf\2013\NYCWatershedTSTS
© 2013 O’Brien & Gere
Proposed Building – North Elevation
14\MD\Pres_Int&Corp\Tech-Conf\2013\NYCWatershedTSTS
© 2013 O’Brien & Gere
Proposed Building – West Elevation
15\MD\Pres_Int&Corp\Tech-Conf\2013\NYCWatershedTSTS
© 2013 O’Brien & Gere
Current Project Status
16\MD\Pres_Int&Corp\Tech-Conf\2013\NYCWatershedTSTS
© 2013 O’Brien & Gere17\MD\Pres_Int&Corp\Tech-Conf\2013\NYCWatershedTSTS
Lessons learned
Coordinate pilot unit capacity with available sludge capacity
Consider the environmental conditions – polymer preparation is temperature dependent
Pilot all units under consideration at same time; Side-by-side pilot is much easier to evaluate
Pilot optional press features as needed to achieve performance
Water plant sludge is not the same as wastewater plant sludge
© 2013 O’Brien & Gere
QUESTIONS?