+ All Categories
Home > Documents > GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT...

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT...

Date post: 16-Jul-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 1 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
43
GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4 Citizens’ Advisory Committee Meeting #2 Tuesday, June 29th 5:30 -8:00 p.m. GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4
Transcript
Page 1: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

Citizens’ Advisory Committee Meeting #2

Tuesday, June 29th

5:30 -8:00 p.m.

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTSNeighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4

Page 2: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4 2

Page 3: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4 3

Foundation Phase

Land Use Concepts

Draft Plan

•Vision + Objectives•Technical Review•Great neighbourhood•Discuss Vision + Principles•Principles•Discuss Concepts•Discuss Transportation•Discuss Servicing•Discuss Naming

•Discuss Open House•Discuss Preferred Option•Preliminary Costs

•Discuss Draft NCP

•Discuss Open House•Recommended NCP

May 12

Jan 13

Mid-Sep

•Logistics•Background•Discuss Open House•Vision + Objectives

Open House

Open House

Open House

CAC #1: May 27

CAC #2: June 29

CAC #3: Sep 9

CAC #4: Nov 3

CAC #5: Dec 2

CAC #6: Jan 28

Page 4: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

1. Introduction

2. Environmental Discussion

3. CAC Protocol Items

4. Parks Discussion

5. What makes a Great Neighborhood?

6. Vision & Planning Principles

7. Sustainability Charter & Secondary Plans

8. Items from CAC Members

9. Next Steps

4

OUTLINE

Page 5: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4 5

Environment

Page 6: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

ENVIRONMENT -Streams

6

Page 7: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

ENVIRONMENT -Vegetation

7

Page 8: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

ENVIRONMENT -Wildlife

Corridors

8

Page 9: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

1. Minutes of Last Meeting

2. CAC Selection

3. New Member

4. Communication

5. Binder

9

CAC

Page 10: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4 10

Page 11: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4 11

Dinner Break

Page 12: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

1. Neighbourhood Requirements

2. Redwood Park

12

Parks Discussion

Page 13: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

Thursday, September 9th

Review Draft Planning Principles

Discuss the Draft Land Use and Urban Design Concepts

Discuss the Preliminary Servicing & Transportation Concepts

13

Next Meeting

Page 14: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4 14

Page 15: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

1. Paul Fenske Submission

2. Brad Lambert Submission

3. Venna Sandu Submission

4. Griesbach Neighbourhood

15

What makes a great neighbourhood?

Page 16: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4 16

Page 17: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4 17

Page 18: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4 18

Page 19: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4 19

Page 20: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4 20

Page 21: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

Wide array of demographics from seniors to young families

Healthy, visual, affordable

Not all housing should have the same look

Need affordable housing

21

Vena Sandhu’s Comments

Page 22: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4 22

Griesbach Neighbourhood

Page 23: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

Good urban design

Abundant services and amenities

Integration with the natural environment and natural areas

Strong community pride & identity

Diversity (all ages, needs, cultural backgrounds)

Sustainability

23

What makes a great neighborhood?

Page 24: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

What do we think of when we think of good Urban Design?

Visually interesting

Welcoming public spaces that encourage social interaction and activities

Landscaping

Harmony between the built and natural environment

Looks, feels, and is, safe

Good transportation linkages and choices

Design guidelines to ensure quality

24

What makes a great neighborhood? (cont’d)

Page 25: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

What do we think of when we think of abundant services and amenities?

Commercial stores (groceries, clothing, novelties, gardening and construction materials) that are within walking distance

Schools

Parks

Community centres

25

What makes a great neighborhood? (cont’d)

Page 26: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

What do we think of when we think of Integration with Nature and Natural Areas?

The built environment fits in with the natural setting

Minimal disturbance to existing natural systems

Usage of native plants and vegetation

26

What makes a great neighborhood?

Page 27: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity?

Attractive (street trees, flowers, places to sit and interact with people, details that are indigenous to the place)

Clean

Safe

Happy, healthy, active people

A plethora and diversity of artistic, cultural, and recreational events

27

What make a Great Neighborhood?

Page 28: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

What do we think of when we think of Sustainable?

Energy efficient

Good air quality

Good water quality (e.g. stormwater management approaches)

Protection of ALR land (buffers established through existing City policy)

Tree canopy protection and enhancement

28

What makes a great neighborhood? (cont’d)

Page 29: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

Open House #1 (From Comment Sheets)

CAC #1 (Word Exercise)

Visioning Issue Planning Principles

Leading Edge

Practical Implementation

Community Character

Comments Words

Comments

Comments Words

Words

Page 30: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

Open House #1 (From

Comment Sheets)

CAC #1 (Word Exercise)

Visioning Issue Planning Principles

•More creative planning

•Better development

•Creative•Enviable•Green•Model Community•Cluster development is key concept

•Housing Variety•Not the same/need more variety

Leading Edge?

Page 31: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

Open House #1 (From Comment Sheets)

CAC #1 (Word

Exercise)

Visioning Issue Planning Principles

• Protection of adjacent properties (Redwood Park)

• Equitable distribution of green space among all land owners

• Orderly development• Financially viable plan that protects riparian areas. Keep as much as possible

• Consideration of existing drainage challenge

• GLUP corrected to 2005 version

• Linkages• Services• The Plan goes ahead

• Workable• Livable• Balanced Profitable

• Endurable• Equity in location/ value

• Green space is necessary but judicious

• Consider context

Practical Implementation ?

Page 32: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

Open House #1 (From Comment Sheets)

CAC #1 (Word Exercise) Visioning Issue Planning Principles

• Village atmosphere

• Higher density

• Naturally green• Community Pride/Identity

• Friendly• Respectful• Tranquil• Village• Inviting• High-end• Place for my parents• Like the Town of Sidney

• Home• Healthy• Safe• Enjoyable• High quality materials

Community Character ?

Page 33: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

Draft VisionThis is a livable Village with a diversity of housing types, transportation choices and local amenities that serves a varied population of different ages and lifestyles.

We have an abundance of natural areas and parks that are protected and cherished. The neighbourhood is in harmony with the existing natural systems that make it sustainable now and in the future.

Our relationship with our neighbour communities is respectful. We work to preserve and enhance Grandview Heights’ natural and built assets.

Our community has been designed with innovation and quality; these unique features have made a place that is a happy and healthy ‘home’, embodied with community pride and spirit. Our neighborhood is a place that is safe and welcoming.

June 29, 2010

Page 34: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

Visioning Issue

Planning Principles (from Vision, GLUP, Surrey policy,

etc.)

Leading Edge •Servicing utilizes the most innovative technology and practices•Maintain and enhance water and air quality using best practices•Promote the benefits of a carbon neutral community•Increase the percentage of green buildings•Mitigate the effects of climate change and the heat effect utilizing existing tree canopy

Page 35: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

Visioning Issue

Planning Principles (from Vision, GLUP, Surrey policy,

etc.)

Practical Implement-

ation

•Recognize property boundaries without losing a comprehensive vision•Ensure equity between owners•Financially viable plan•Allow for economically phased development over time•Allow for clustering•Be sensitive to context: e.g. ALR buffer, Redwood Park, drainage impacts on agricultural lands

Page 36: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

Visioning Issue

Planning Principles (from Vision, GLUP, Surrey policy,

etc.)

COMMUNITY CHARACTER

•Interconnected with nature•Ensure there are designated parksadjacent to schools•Community’s local character is reflected to set it apart f other neighborhoods•Recognize local heritage features in creating a sense of place•Foster social interaction•Community has been planned with lots of activities for residents•Logical pattern—lots of interconnections, connections to services, schools, parks, nature

Page 37: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

Visioning Issue

Planning Principles (from Vision, GLUP, Surrey policy,

etc.)

COMMUNITY CHARACTER

•Provide multiple (+alternative) transportation modes—now and in the future•Ensure community is designed for safety•Accommodates a variety of ages and lifestyles in varied housing types•Provide variety of neighbourhood services•Landscaping—character, native, etc.•Emphasis on the quality of the public realm

Page 38: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4

Represents the City’s commitment to a sustainable future

Over-arching framework that guides the City’s actions

The framework contains a Vision, Goals and an Action Framework

38

The City of Surrey Sustainability Charter

Page 39: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4 39

Components of the Sustainability Charter

Page 40: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4 40

How this affects the Grandview #4 NCP

All new plans and policies must align with the Sustainability Charter and its vision, goals and actions.

There are specific vision statements and goal statements in the Sustainability Charter that apply to NCPs.

In the Scope of Sustainability document that supports the Sustainability Charter, there are actions that apply specific to NCPs.

Page 41: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4 41

Scope of Sustainability actions relevant to NCPs(Examples)

Social Actions:SC9 - Adequate, Appropriate and Affordable Housing

SC11 - Public Safety and Security

Economic Actions:EC3 - Sustainable Infrastructure Maintenance and Replacement

EC7 - Sustainable Building and Development Practices

Environmental Actions:EN8 - Sustainable Engineering Standards and Practices

EN15 - Sustainable Transportation Options

Page 42: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4 42

Items from CAC members

Page 43: GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS Neighbourhood Concept Plan Area # 4 · GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4. What do we think of when we think of Community Pride & Identity? Attractive

GRANDVIEW HEIGHTS NEIGHBOURHOOD CONCEPT PLAN AREA # 4 43

Next Meeting

CAC #3 Scheduled for Thursday, September 9 from 5:30 – 8:00 at the South Surrey Recreation Centre (14601 - 20 Ave), Multipurpose Room


Recommended