Date post: | 07-Jul-2018 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | captnishantrai |
View: | 223 times |
Download: | 0 times |
of 7
8/19/2019 history final.docx
1/16
NATIONAL LAW INSTITUTE UNIVERSITY, BHOPAL
History –I
PROJECT ON:
DEBATE OVER EXISTENCE OF ISLAMIC STATE
IN INDIA DURING 13TH-18TH CENTURY
Submitt! To: Submitt! By:
Pro"#$%r#& U!'y Pr't'( Si)*+ So)i' S+i-+'r
V Trimstr
./01BALLB1/
1 | P ' *
8/19/2019 history final.docx
2/16
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Contents
TABLE O2 CONTENTS#################################################################################################################.
INTRO%UCTION###########################################################################################################################3
STATE4ENT O2 PROBLE4########################################################################################################3
OBJECTIVE####################################################################################################################################3
RESEARCH 4ETHO%OLO5Y####################################################################################################3
THE 5ROWTH O2 CONCEPT O2 AN ISLA4IC STATE###########################################################1
%ELHI SULTANATE##################################################################################################################6
Asso7i'tio) 8it+ t+ Pro(+t#######################################################################################################6
T+ Ru9 o" L'8##########################################################################################################################
Tr'tm)t o" )o);4us9ims##########################################################################################################<
4U5HAL RULE######################################################################################################################0/
B"or Ab'r=s Ru9##################################################################################################################0/
Ab'r=s Ru9##############################################################################################################################0/
A"tr Ab'r=s Ru9#####################################################################################################################0.
ANALYSIS O2 AR5U4ENTS####################################################################################################01
CONCLUSION##############################################################################################################################06
BIBLIO5RAPHY##########################################################################################################################0
2 | P ' *
8/19/2019 history final.docx
3/16
INTRODUCTION
T+r +'s b) ' !b't 'bout 8+t+r t+r >ist! ') Is9'mi7 St't i) I)!i'# T+ 4us9im Ru9
i) I)!i' "rom 03t+ to 0ist)7 o" Is9'mi7 St't i) I)!i'#
OBJECTIVE0# To u)!rst')! t+ 7o)7(t o" Is9'mi7 st't ')! its mo!i"i7'tio)#.# To stu!y t+ 'r*um)ts i) "'-our o" ')! '*'i)st t+ b9i" o" >ist)7 o" ') Is9'mi7
st't !uri)* %9+i Su9t')'t ')! 4u*+'9 Em(ir i) I)!i'#3# To try to 7orr9't t+m 8it+ '7+ ot+r ')! 'rri- 't ' 7o)79usio)#
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY T+ mt+o! t+'t +'s b) m(9oy! is ')'9yti7'9#
3 | P ' *
8/19/2019 history final.docx
4/16
THE GROWTH OF CONCEPT OF AN ISLAMIC STATET+ t+o7r'ti7 Is9'mi7 St't 8's "ou)!! by t+ Pro(+t o" Is9'm# 2or ') Is9'mi7 st't, t+ ru9s
"or ' (uri"i! systm o" *o-r)')7 8r st u( by ; t+ ?ur'), t+ mu9ti(9 H'!is 7o997tio)s
')! t+ '!mi)istr'ti- '7ts ')! (ri)7i(9s o" t+ Pro(+t# T+ Is9'mi7 t+ory o" St't 8's b's!
o) t+r;"o9! i!' o" o) s7ri(tur $?ur')&, o) so-ri*) $im'm;t+ 9'!r '9so 7'99! +'9i"' or 7'9i(+, t+ (o9iti7'9 su77ssor o" t+ Pro(+t& ')! o) )'tio)$mi99't;t+ mus9im brot+r+oo!
T+s t+r 8r i)!i-isib9# T+ 7'9i(+ 8's t+ 'mir u9 mom)i);Dt+ 9'!r o" t+ "'it+"u9
97t! by t+ mi99't 8+o 8r t+ so-ri*) ')! + +'! t+ r9i*ious ob9i*'tio) to im(9m)t
t+ Is9'mi7 L'8 o) ')! "or t+ b)"it o" +is 4us9im subF7ts# To !trmi) 8+t+r ' st't 8's
') Is9'mi7 St't t8o 7ritri' 7') b st'b9is+! 8+i7+ 8r;
0# T+ st't, ru9i)* o) b+'9" o" ' !)omi)'tio)'9 5o!, 8ou9! us '99 its (o8r "or t+
7o)-rsio) o" its subF7ts to Is9'm ')! 8ou9! 9imi)'t '99 tr'7s o" )o);Is9'mi7
(rs)7 "rom its trritoris i## it 8ou9! b 7o)st')t9y )*'*! i) tr')s"ormi)* t+
7o)tst! 9')!, !'r '9;+'rb i)to !'r '9;Is9'm, 9')! o" Is9'm#.# O)9y t+ Furis!i7tio) o" S+'ri', Is9'mi7 9'8, 8ou9! (r-'i9 irrs(7ti- o" t+ r9i*ious
'""i9i'tio)s o" ')y o" its subF7ts#
It 8's to b mor i) t+ )'tur o" trib'9 o9i*'r7+y t+') t+'t o" t+ mo)'r7+y 8+i7+ Ir') +'! 't
t+'t tim# T+ Um'yy'!s, !i! )ot )Foy t+ rs(7t t+'t t+ "irst "our ri*+t9y *ui!! 7'9i(+s, t+
(r!7ssors +'! 7omm')!!, ')! Abb'si!s, 8+o o-rt+r8 t+ Um'yy'!s 7o)!m)! t+ir
ru9 's mu9 $i)*!om& or irr9i*ious i)*s+i( i) 7o)tr'st to t+ 'r9y 7'9i(+'t# T+is -i8
7+')*! !uri)* Abb'si!s 8it+ t+ tr')s9'tio)s o" t+ ')7i)t Ir')i') 4irror "or Pri)7s ')! t+
Is9'mi7i! -rsio)s o" t+is t>t 8ritt) by s7+o9'rs !uri)* t+ir 7'9i(+'t# T+is 9itr'ry *)r
u)ui-o7'99y 'ssrt! t+'t ru9rs 8r !i-i)9y '((oi)t! mo)'r7+s 8+o 8r '77ou)t'b9 o)9y
to 5o!# T+is 'ut+ority 7ou9! b 7+'99)*! ')! rmo-! by t+ 4us9im r9i*ious 9it $'+9 '9;
r'y& o) -io9'tio) o" t+ 9'8s o" s+'ri'#
T+ most si*)i"i7')t 7+')* +o8-r 7'm 8it+ t+ 7om(9tio) o" t+ S+'+)'m' by t+ *r't
Ir')i') (i7 (ot 2ir!'8si i) 0/0/# As 899 's ') '77ou)t o" t+ (i7 *9ory o" t+ ')7i)t Ir')i')
i)*s, t+ S+'+)'m' 9ou)t9y rmi)!! ru9rs ')! )ob9s t+'t mo)'r7+s 8r i)strum)ts i)
t+ >7utio) o" 5o!s 8i99 ')! t+'t t+ir 7omm')!s 8r t+r"or i)-io9't# T+ 7o)7(t o"
mysti7ism, *9ory ')! 7+'rism' o" t+ @i)* 8's Fusti"i! t+rou*+ 2') 8+i7+ symbo9i! t+
!i-i) "'-our 8+i7+ i)*s (ossss! 's 9o)* 's 5o! !i! )ot t' it '8'y "rom t+m# A9t+ou*+
t+ '((oi)tm)t o" C'9i(+ 8's )7ss'ry, it 8's !o) by t+ +o9!r o" t+ mi9it'ry (o8r 8+o
o8! '99*i')7 to +im# L'tr t+ 'ut+ority 7'm to b r9't! i)7r'si)*9y 8it+ r9i*io) ')! it8's s'i! t+'t '99 r9i*ious (rso) +'! to oby t+ i)*, -) i" + 8's b'rb'ri7 ')! t+'t 5o! +'!
)trust! subF7ts to t+ su9t')s 7'r, it bi)* o) o" t+ 9'ttrs (ri)7i('9 !utis to )sur t+ir
(rot7tio)# It 8's t+us +is !uty to ru9 8it+ im('rti'9ity ')! Fusti7, '99 t+s (ri)7i(9s '""7t!
by t+ Ir')i') mo)'r7+i'9 ru9s#
4'For 7+')*s '9so 7'm 'bout 9'tr 8+) t+ C'9i(+=s (o8r r!u7! ')! +is s'9 us! o)9y 's
' 8'y o" 9*itimii)* 'ut+ority 8+i9 i)* 8's +9! to b t+ s+'!o8 o" 5o! ')! t+ 8or!s
4 | P ' *
8/19/2019 history final.docx
5/16
7'9i(+ ')! su9t') 8's us! i)tr7+')*'b9y# T+s 7+')*s o77ur! !uri)* B'9b')=s ru9 8+o
'9so i)tro!u7! Ir')i') 7ourt 7ustoms ')! '9so stro)*9y '!+r! to t+ 79'ss ')! r'7i'9 (rFu!i7s
o" ')7i)t Ir')# H '!-o7't! t+ im(9m)t'tio) o" stri7t Fusti7 but o)9y "or t+ Su))is ')!
>79u!! t+ Hi)!us ')! !is7rimi)'t! '*'i)st t+ Ism'i9is ')! 4us9im (+i9oso(+rs# Wit+
>(9i7it ('tr)'9ism, +o8-r, + '9so ur*! +is su77ssors to )ot t+'t o)9y su7+ ru9rs !sr-!
to b 7'99! i)* 's +'! )ot ' si)*9 )'! or +u)*ry (rso) i) t+ir trritoris#
4o+'mm! Bi) Tu*+9' st'rt! ' )8 tr)! o" o8i)* '99*i')7 to ' !'! C'9i(+ 8+i7+ 8's
9'tr *i-) to +im by t+ )-oy o" Abb'si! C'9i(+ i) E*y(t, H'FFi S'i! S'rs'ri i) rtur) o" *i"ts#
B'r')i=s 8or +'! ' m'For im('7t o) t+ 7+')* i) t+ )'tur o" i)*s+i( i) 8+i7+ + Fusti"i!
t+ su9t')s to imit't t+ Ir')i') ru9rs ')! s+o8 -'9or, rut+9ss)ss ')! !omi)')7, 7o997tio) o"
t'>s, 'm'ssi)* +u* 8'9t+ t7 8+i7+ 8's (ro+ibit! by Is9'm# T+is 8's '99o8! to )"or7 t+
5o!=s 8or!# W+i9 m'i)t'i)i)* t+ !i-i)ity o" t+ i)*, t+ 97ti- mo! 8's r(9'7! by
+r!ity# T+ Hi)!us 8r to b !(ri-! o" t+ir 8'9t+ ')! 7o)-rsio) by 4us9ims 8's to b
(u)is+! i) or!r to m' it ' 9'!i)* r9i*io)#
%ELHI SULTANATE
T+ *ro8t+ o" su7+ (o9i7is +'! im('7t o-r t+ subsu)t ru9rs# T+ !b't +'s s(r'!
bt8) t8o 79'sss o" +istori')s to s 8+t+r t+r >ist! Is9'mi7 st't !uri)* t+ ru9 o"
%9+i Su9t')'t#
Asso7i'tio) 8it+ t+ Pro(+t
I) t+ Is9'mi7 8or9!, t+ C'9i(+ 8's r*'r!! 's t+ *u'r!i') o" r9i*io) ')! t+ u(+o9!r o" t+ (o9iti7'9 (o8r# T+orti7'99y, )o 4us9im 7ou9! st u( ') Gi)!()!)tG st't, bi* or sm'99,
8it+out (ro7uri)* t+ (rmissio) "rom t+ C'9i(+, 9s its 9*itim'7y 8ou9! b7om sus(7t
'mo)*st t+ 4us9ims# T+is (rmissio) 8's '7uir! by ' 9'r* )umbr o" ru9rs; B'9b'),
I9tutmis+ ')! +)7 t+ -i8 o" ') Is9'mi7 st't#
I) t+ory, t+ 7'9i(+ 8's t+ su(rm 9'!r ')! t+ su9t') 8's +is !(uty, t+ou*+, i) (r'7ti7,
t+ 7'9i(+ 8's too 8' to 'ssrt +is 'ut+ority t+r"or, +, '"tr *tti)* som 7ost9y (rs)ts,
'77(t! t+os 8+o (ossss! (o8r ')! 'ssum! i)!()!)7 i) +is trritoris# T+is +'s b)
+9! to b r!u7! to ' "orm o" 9*itimii)* (o8r 8+i7+ 8's ' mr "orm'9ity 8it+ 9itt9
'sso7i'tio) 8it+ r'9ity# T+ m!i-'9 7ourt +istoris 8r 7+ro)i79s "o99o8! ' "orm't; t+ tit98's )'m! '"tr t+ ru9r $Ab'r N'm', S+'+ J'+') N'm'&, t+ (r"'7 8ou9! b i) (r'is o"
5o!, A99'+ ')! t+ Pro(+t o" Is9'm, 4u+'mm'!, it 8ou9! b "o99o8! by ' 9o)* su)7 o"
7'9i(+s, su77ssors o" 4u+'mm'!, t+) t'i)* ' !-i'tio) to t+ 9i) o" t+ ('st 4us9im ru9rs o"
t+ 9')! ')! trmi)'ti)* 't t+ ri*) o" t+ 7urr)t ru9r, to *'i) 9*itim'7y i) t+ "orm o"
!(utis o" t+ 7'9i(+#
5 | P ' *
8/19/2019 history final.docx
6/16
I) r'9ity, +o8-r it is 'r*u! t+'t, t+ Su9t')s 8r so-ri*) ru9rs 8+o !i! )ot !ri- t+ir
(o8rs "rom, )or !()!! u(o) ')y >tr)'9 "or7# T+y 8r i)!()!)t ru9rs o" t+ir
trritori'9 (ossssio)s ')! !i! )ot o8 t+ir so-ri*)ty to ')y 8or9!9y (o8r, )it+r t+ 7'9i(+
)or t+ mi99't# But bi)* "ori*) (rso)s 7'99! u(o) to ru9 o-r -'st trritoris o" t+ 7ou)try,
i)+'bit't! m'i)9y by t+ Hi)!us, t+y t+ou*+t it (o9iti7'99y >(!i)t to m'i)t'i) "orm'9
7o)t'7ts 8it+ t+ Is9'mi7 8or9! to (ro!u7 ' (sy7+i7 o" "'r 'mo)* t+ Hi)!us by '99u!i)* to t+
(ot)ti'9 sour7 o" t+ir str)*t+# T+ r7o*)itio) o" ' C'9i(+ by t+ %9+i Su9t')s s) i) t+
*r')ti)* o" robs o" +o)our, 9ttr o" i)-stitur, bsto8i)* o" tit9s, +'-i)* t+ )'m o" t+
C'9i(+ i)s7rib! o) 7oi)s ')! r'!i)* o" +utb' i) 2ri!'y (r'yr i) +is )'m symbo9i! ')
'77(t')7 ')! ' 9i) 8it+ t+ Is9'mi7 8or9!, t+ou*+ i) r'9ity it o)9y;m')t ') '77(t')7 o" '
situ'tio) 8+rby ' ru9r +'! '9r'!y (9'7! +ims9" i) (o8r# T+ Su9t')s o" %9+i m'i)t'i)!
t+ "i7tio) o" t+ '77(t')7 o" t+ (ositio) o" t+ C'9i(+# U)!r t+ S'iyyi!s $0101;0160& ')!
t+ Lo!is $0160;06. A %& t+ 9*)!s o) t+ 7oi)s 7o)ti)u! i) t+ s)s o" ' tr'!itio) bi)*
m'i)t'i)! but it 8's (ur9y ' )omi)'9 '99*i')7# I) '7tu'9 ""7t, t+ C'9i(+'t, 8')! ')!
"'r rmo-! 's it 8's, +'! 9itt9 !ir7t ro9 to (9'y i) t+ %9+i Su9t')'t#
E-) t+ou*+, t+orti7'99y, t+ so-ri*)ty rsi!! i) mi9iti' 8+o 7ou9! 97t t+ Su9t') but i)
r'9ity, t+y 7ou9! o)9y -oi7 its '((ro-'9 or !is'((ro-'9 o" t+ (o9i7is ')! '7tio)s o" '
('rti7u9'r su9t') but 7ou9! )it+r 7+oos )or !(os ')y ru9r# T+ su77ssio) 8's m'i)9y
+r!it'ry or by 7o)ust# T+ )'tur o" i)*s+i( i) %9+i Su9t')'t mi9it'ts '*'i)st t+
t+o7r'7y +y(ot+sis#
T+ Ru9 o" L'8
T+orti7'99y i) ') Is9'mi7 st't, o)9y t+o9o*i')s 7ou9! b Furists i) ' 4us9im 7ou)try 's t+
7i-i9 9'8 8's mr*! ')! subor!i)'t! to t+ 7')o) 9'8 ')! t+ Furist t+r"or +'! to m'str t+
?ur') ')! t+ H'!is ')! must b ' 4'u9-i ')! t+is 79'ss 8's 7'99! t+ U9m'# T+y '!-is! t+
Su9t')s 8+o 8r bou)! by it# I) s+ort, t+ 9'8 8+i7+ obt'i)! (o8r i) m!i-'9 I)!i' u)!r
4us9im ru9 8's t+ S+'r' 8+i7+ 8's b's! )ot o) +um') >(ri)7 but o) !i-i) r-9'tio)# It
8's )ot ' s7u9'r 9'8# T+r"or it 8's b9i-! t+'t 4us9im st't 7ou9! )ot b ' s7u9'r st't#
Som mo!r) s7+o9'rs 9i %r# I#H# ?urs+i +'- r"us! t+ -i8 o" ') Is9'mi7 St't !uri)*
%9+i Su9t')'t i) I)!i' by +o9!i)* t+'t DT+ su(rm'7y o" t+ s+'ri' +'s mis9! som i)to
t+i)i)* t+'t t+ Su9t')'t 8's ' t+o7r'7y# T+ ss)ti'9 "'tur o" ' t+o7r'7y;t+ ru9 o" ')or!'i)! (rist+oo!;is +o8-r, missi)* i) t+ or*')is'tio) o" t+ 4us9im st't t+ Furists 'r
9'ym) 8+o 79'im )o s'7r!ot'9 immu)ity "rom rror# 5ibb is ri*+t i) 7'99i)* t+ Is9'mi7 (o9ity
t+o;7)tri7#
It +'s b) 'r*u! t+'t t+ su9t')s (ro"ss! to '!mi)istr t+ Is9'mi7 9'8 t+rou*+ t+ (o9iti7'9
i)stitutio)s but t+os st u( by t+m !i! )ot '98'ys 7o)"orm to t+ ort+o!o> Is9'mi7 (ri)7i(9s#
T+s 8r !(9y i)"9u)7! by t+ I)!i') tr'!itio)s ')! 7ustoms ')! i)7or(or't! m')y
6 | P ' *
8/19/2019 history final.docx
7/16
9m)ts o" t+ R'F(ut (o9ity 8it+ or 8it+out mo!i"i7'tio) ')! som 8r i) st'r o((ositio) to
t+ Is9'mi7 9'8# T+ su(riority 8's >r7is! by 7rt'i) su9t')s, 9i A9'u!!i) @+'9Fi, 8+o 8's
b'7! by ' stro)* 'rmy ')! 7ou9! '""or! to !"y t+ Is9'mi7 (ri)7i(9s o" *o-r)m)t ')!
'!mi)istr'tio), m'! t+ u9m' subsr-i)t to +im ')! !79'r! t+'t + 8's t+ st't ')! +is
8or! 8's t+ 9'8# T+ t's o" u9m' t+r"or b7'm t+ (ortr'yr o" Su9t') 's ') 'rbitr ')!
i)tr(rtr o" t+ %i-i) Wor!# T+y i)-o! t+ @or')i7 i)Fu)7tio);Oby A99'+,oby t+
A(ost9 ')! oby t+os i) ' 'ut+ority 'mo)* you#=; t+rby im(9yi)* t+'t t+ Su9t')=s 'ut+ority
7ou9! )ot b 7+'99)*! 's + 8's )o) ot+r t+') 5o!=s r(rs)t'ti- o) 'rt+# T+os 8+o +9!
t+ (o8r to sust'i) t+ir i)*!om ')! *'i) 9*itim'7y ot+r t+') t+rou*+ r9i*ious m')s !i!
'8'y 8it+ t+ u9m'# T+ "urt+r (roo" t+'t t+ Su9t')'t o" %9+i 8's )ot ' t+o7r'ti7 st't 7')
b 'ttribut! to t+ "'7t t+'t I9tutmis+ !ismiss! t+ 'ut+ority o" t+ u9m' to 7o)-rt t+ st't
i)to ' %'r;u9;Is9'm or t+ L')! o" Is9'm# H !79'r! t+'t + 8ou9! ru9 by J'+')!'ri $ru9 o" t+
Su9t') b's! o) +is s)s o" Fusti7, *oo!8i99 ')! or!r& ')! '8'bit $ru9 by (ro79'm'tio) o"
or!i)')7s So I9tutmis+ *'- ' (o9iti7'9 i!o9o*y to t+ Su9t')'t 8+i7+ 8's )ot b's! o) t+
S+'ri't $Is9'mi7 9'8s O" t+ "our 7o)!itio)s 8+i7+ B'r')i '!-iss t+ i)* to b'r i) mi)!8+) issui)* !7rs $'bit'+&, o) is t+'t i" ')y o" t+ (ro(os! or!i)')7s is "ou)! 7o)tr'ry to
t+ s+'ri'+, it )! )ot b 8it+!r'8) but, 's ') -i9 )7ssity is to b rt'i)! )ot 9o)*r t+') is
)7ss'ry#
E-) t+ m'Fority o" t+ u9m', t+ *u'r!i')s o" t+ s'7r! 9'8, 8r uttr9y m'tri'9isti7 i)
out9oo ')! o((ortu)ist i) 7o)!u7t# T+y )tr! i)to ') u)+o9y '99i')7 8it+ t+ s7u9'r
'ut+oritis ')! by !istorti)* t+ ru9s o" t+ s+'ri', "ou)! s')7tio) "or t+ Su9t')s ('*')
(r'7ti7s# E-) tr'!itio)s "rom t+ Pro(+t 8r 7o)7o7t! to *i- t+ i)*s !s(otism ' mor'9
b'7i)*#
I) summi)* u( +is '77ou)t o" t+ ori*i) ')! )'tur o" i)*s+i(, B'r')i rm'rs, t+ m')i)* o"
i)*s+i( is (o8r isti9', 8+t+r obt'i)! by 9'8"u9 m')s or by "or7 -) t+ o9!r ('*') 9'8
o" !y)'sti7 9*itim'7y "i)!s )o (9'7 i) t+ (rs)t i)*s+i(# T+ s+'ri', i) or!i)'ry (r'7ti7,
8's )o mor rs(7t! t+') ')y ot+r 9'8# B'r')i '!mits t+'t ' 7'(it'9 (u)is+m)t o" 4us9ims
8+i7+, + '!!s, 8's 7o)tr'ry to t+ S'7r! L'8, 8's )7ss'ry "or t+ >i*)7is o" bttr
*o-r)m)t#
Simi9'r9y, t+ 9'8 o" i)+rit')7, t+ stri7t !isti)7tio) bt8) +'9'9 ')! +'r'm ')! m')y ot+r
899;)o8) i)Fu)7tio)s 8r -io9't! t+ 779si'sti7s (rotst! but 8r 7o)str'i)! to "i)!
>7us# T+ 899;)o8) (ro+ibitio) o" t+ s+'ri' r*'r!i)* t+ t'i)* ')! *i-i)* o" i)trst o)
mo)t'ry tr')s'7tio) 8's o()9y !isr*'r!!#
T+ ot+r 79'ss o" +istori')s r"us t+ 'bo- -i8# T+y s'i! t+'t it is tru t+'t t+ Su9t')s
'!mitt! t+'t t+ 4us9im 9'8 8's )ot 'b9 to *ui! t+m i) -ry s(+r ')! 7o)su)t9y t+y
+'! to !('rt "rom t+ 9'8 i) 7rt'i) 7'ss, but t+'t 8's o)9y i) m'ttrs o" !t'i9 ')! !i! )ot
'""7t t+ b'si7 7o)7(t t+'t t+ Is9'mi7 st't 8's ') or*')i! '*)7y "ou)!! by 5o! Hims9"
to (ro('*'t Is9'm t+rou*+ t+ i)strum)t'9ity o" t+ 'rt+9y ru9rs# Is9'm 8's t+ r9i*io) o" t+
7 | P ' *
8/19/2019 history final.docx
8/16
st't ')! )o ot+r r9i*io) 8's r7o*)is!# A99 t+ sour7s o" t+ st't 8r m')t "or t+
(rot7tio) ')! s(r'! o" Is9'm# T+y (ut strss o) t+ >r7is ')! ""7ti- 7o)tro9 o-r t+
'!mi)istr'tio) by t+ U9'm's ')! t+y bi)* t+ so9 i)tr(rtrs o" Is9'mi7 9'8;r9i*ious ')!
'!mi)istr'ti-#
2urt+r su((ort "or Is9'mi7 st't ')! t+ '7tio)s o" @+i9Fi ')! I9tutmis+ +'- b) Fusti"i! "romiy'u!!i) B'r')i=s '77ou)ts i) 8+i7+ + '!-o7'ts t+'t i" t+ )"or7m)t o" t+ S+'ri't 8's
im(ossib9 or im(r'7ti7'b9, )8 9'8s s+ou9! b )'7t! by ru9rs# It is t+ !uty o" ' i)*, s'ys
+, to )"or7, i" + 7'), t+os roy'9 9'8s 8+i7+ +'- b7om (ro-rbi'9 o8i)* to t+ir
(ri)7i(9s o" Fusti7 ')! mr7y# But i" o8i)* to 7+')* o" tim ')! 7ir7umst')7s + is u)'b9 to
)"or7 t+ 9'8s o" t+ ')7i)ts $i## ')7i)t 4us9im ru9rs&, + s+ou9!, 8it+ t+ 7ou)s9 o" 8is
m) "r'm 9'8s suit! to +is tim ')! 7ir7umst')7s ')! (ro7! to )"or7 t+m# 4u7+
r"97tio) is )7ss'ry i) or!r t+'t 9'8s, suit! to +is ri*), 'r (ro(r9y "r'm! so t+'t t+y i)
)o 8'y 7o)tr'-) t+ t)ts o" Is9'm# T+s 9'8s B'r')i 7'99s '8'bis#
Tr'tm)t o" )o);4us9ims
T+ su((ortrs o" Is9'mi7 St't b's t+ir -i8 o) t+ "'7t t+'t t+ Is9'mi7 t+ory o" t+ st't
!os )ot (rmit t+ >ist)7 o" ')y ot+r r9i*io) >7(t Is'm;4us'9m')s '9o) 'r its 7iti)s#
I" t+r is ')y )o);4us9im i) ') Is9'mi7 st't, t+y 'r tr't! 's ' subF7t or !*r'!! (o(9#
T+ 4us9im 9'8 !i-i!s t+ mus9im (o(9 i)to t8o 79'sss; (ossssors o" r-'9!
s7ri(tur$'+9;it'b& ')! i!o9'tors $'"irs ')! mus+ris It 8's *i-) i) 79'r trms by t+ "our
'r9y ')! 'ut+orit'ti- 7omm)t'tors o" t+ s+'r; 4'9i Ab) A)'s, As+;S+'"i ')! A+m'! bi)
H')b'9 t+'t t+ i!o9'tors +'- )o ri*+t to 9i- i) ' 4us9im 7ou)try# But t+ "ourt+ 7omm)t'tor;
Abu H')i"'+ *'- t+ o(i)io) t+'t i!o9'tors mi*+t b *i-), bsi!s t+ 7+oi7 bt8) Is9'm
')! !'t+, o) mor '9tr)'ti-, )'m9y (rmissio) to 9i- 's immis$ 9i-i)* u)!r ' 7o)tr'7t& or
's i)"rior 7iti)s 8it+ ') ob9i*'tio) to ('y t+ Fiiy' $(o99 t'>& ')! to submit to 7rt'i) (o9iti7'9,
9*'9 ')! so7i'9 !is'bi9itis# T+is !i-isio) '99o8s t+ J8s, C+risti')s ')! oro'stri')s to rsi!
i) 4us9im st't o) ('ym)t o" t+ t'>#
4u+'mm'! bi) ?'sim, t+ 7o)uror o" Si)!+ is ') >'m(9 o" t+ ru9r 8+o '77or!! t+
st'tus o" immis to t+ Hi)!us o) ' som8+'t simi9'r 9i)s o" Om'r I, o) o" t+ "irst "our (ious
C'9i(+s 8+o >(99! t+ J8s ')! t+ C+risti')s "rom t+ 8+o9 o" t+ Ar'bi' to bri)* 'bout
7om(9t r9i*ious u)i"ormity i) t+ 7ity# Si)7 t+ Hi)!us i) t+is (rio! 8r )ot (rmitt! to
obsr- t+ir r9i*ious rit o()9y ')! (ub9i79y, to 7'rry o) 9*itim't r9i*ious (ro('*')!', bui9!
)8 tm(9s or r('ir o9! o)s ')! 8r tr't! 's !(rss! 79'sss o-r 8+om t+ 4us9ims
ru9! 's (ri-i9*! 79'ss; t+r"or t+s +istori')s su((ort! t+ -i8 t+'t I)!i' 't t+'t tim 8's
') Is9'mi7 st't#
8 | P ' *
8/19/2019 history final.docx
9/16
T+r 'r 7ou)t9ss >'m(9s o" (rFu!i7i'9 tr'tm)t mt! out to )o);4us9ims u)!r t+
t+o7r'ti7 *o-r)m)t# Amir @+usr'u 8rits t+'t u)!r J'9'u!!i) @+'9Fi $0.K/;K&, '"tr ' b'tt9,
8+'t-r 9i- Hi)!u "99 i)to t+ +')!s o" t+ -i7torious i)* 8's (ou)!! to bits u)!r t+ "t
o" t+ 9(+')ts# T+ 4us'9m') 7'(ti-s +'! t+ir 9i-s s('r!# Simi9'r9y, 4'9i @'"ur, t+
"'mous *)r'9 o" A9'u!!i) @+'9Fi $0.K;030&, 8+i9 o) +is >(!itio)s i) Sout+ I)!i', s('r!
t+ 9i-s o" 4us9ims "i*+ti)* o) t+ si! o" t+ Hi)!u R'i 's t+y !srt! to +is 'rmy# Riu99'+
4us+t'i is '99 (r'is "or Su9t') Si')!'r Lo!i $01
8/19/2019 history final.docx
10/16
B"or Ab'r=s Ru9
T+ "irst i)* o" t+ 4u*+'9 !y)'sty 8's '+iru!!i) 4u+'mm'! B'bur# H 7o)ur! ')!
ru9! 's ' )orm'9 4us9im i)*# H i)+rit! +is r9i*ious (o9i7y i) I)!i' "rom t+ Lo!is#
Si')!'r Lo!is "')'ti7ism must +'- b) t+ )orm o" o""i7i'9s 8+o 7o)ti)u! to sr- 8+)
B'bur 7'm to (o8r# B'bur +ims9" 8's ') ort+o!o> 4us9im# B'bur ')! +is o""i7rs broHi)!u tm(9s i) m')y ('rts o" t+ 7ou)try# H r'is! to8rs o" su99s o" t+ s9'i)
i)"i!9s# B'bur is s'i! to +'- b) ' s7u9'r i)* o) t+ b'sis o" +is '99*! Wi99 '!mo)is+i)*
Hum'yu) to b+'- 9ibr'99y to8'r!s t+ Hi)!us# But t+ Wi99 +'s b) "ou)! to b ' )o);
*)ui) !o7um)t# I) s+ort, B'bur 8's 7o)t)t to *o-r) Hi)!ust') i) t+ ort+o!o> "'s+io)#
Hum'yu) +'! )ot mu7+ 7+')7 o" !-9o(i)* ')y !isti)7t r9i*ious (o9i7y o" +is o8), '9t+ou*+
+ 8's 9ibr'9 to8'r!s t+ +rti7 S+i's# S+r S+'+ Suri too 8's )it+r 9ibr'9 )or "')'ti7# H
!-ot!9y b9i-! i) t+ S+'ri't ')! s'i! t+'t Git b+o-s i)*s )ot to !isoby t+
7omm')!m)ts o" 5o!, to i)s7rib t+ ('*s o" t+ir +istory 8it+ t+ 7+'r'7trs o" r9i*io), t+'t
t+ir sr-')ts ')! subF7ts m'y 9o- r9i*io) "or i)*s 'r ('rt'rs i) -ry '7t o" !-otio) ')!8ors+i( 8+i7+ (ro7!s "rom t+ (rists ')! t+ (o(9#G
Yt i) 7o)tr'st to t+is -i!)7 o" r9i*ious "')'tism, it +'s b) 'r*u! t+'t t+ 4u*+'9 st't
8's )ot Is9'mi7# T+ s-r'9 -i!)7s i) t+is r*'r! 7') b *'i)! "rom t+ +r!it'ry stru7tur
o" t+ i)*s+i(# 4oro-r t+ 9oy'9ty o" t+ m'sss 8's to8'r!s t+ i)* ')! )ot t+ C'9i(+#
A)! '9so t+ )7ssity o" (rist+oo! 8's )ot 7om(9i! 8it+ 8+r t+ i)* i)tr(rt! t+
r9i*io) ')! us! it i) +is o8) mo!i"i! "orm to >(')! +is ru9# 2urt+r t+r is ') im('7t o"
I)!i') 7u9tur o) t+ 9'8s, 'rt "orms, (o9ity t7# T+ 4u*+'9 i)* 8's t+ su(rm +'! o" t+
>7uti- ')! t+ 'rmy# H 8's t+ "ou)t'i);+'! o" Fusti7, 'ssist! by ' )umbr o" im(ri'9
o""i7rs;%i8'), 4ir B's+i, 4ir S'm') ')! S'!r;us;Su!ur '99 'sso7i't! 8it+ '!mi)istr'tio)')! )ot r9i*io) ')! t+ir '!-i7 8's )ot bi)!i)* o) +im# T+is is s'i! to b i)"9u)7! "rom t+
I)!i') 7o)7(t o" i)*s+i(#
Ab'r=s Ru9
T+ ru9 o" Ab'r is o) o" t+ most si*)i"i7')t i) t+ )tir 4us9im Ru9 i) I)!i' "'mous "or its
!ist')7 "rom t+o7r'7y ')! to8'r!s s7u9'rism#
T+ "irst r-o9utio)'ry st( o" Ab'r 8's t+ 'bo9itio) o" t+ Jiiy'+, t+ +'t! !is7rimi)'tory
t'> ('i! by Hi)!u immis# T+ Hi)!us, 's immis, +'! b7om s7o)! 79'ss 7iti)s i) t+ir
o8) +om9')! ')! 8r su""r! to 9i- u)!r 7rt'i) !is'bi9itis# A99 'r9ir 4us9im i)*s +'!
im(os! it i) its tru r9i*ious 7o))ot'tio) '9o)* 8it+ t+ )! to r'is r-)u# Wit+ its
'bo9itio) i) 061, Ab'r brou*+t Hi)!us o) ('r 8it+ 4us9ims 's 7ommo) 7iti)s o" t+ st't
r't+r t+') tr't t+m 's s7o)! 79'ss 7iti)s#
1! | P ' *
8/19/2019 history final.docx
11/16
Ab'r rmo-! rstri7tio)s o) t+ (ub9i7 r9i*ious 8ors+i( by )o);4us9ims# H 'bo9is+!
(i9*rim t'> o) Hi)!us $063& ')! rmo-! '99 rstri7tio)s o) t+ bui9!i)* o" (9'7s o" 8ors+i( o"
)o);4us9ims# T+is 9! to t+ bui9!i)* o" 7+ur7+s by C+risti') ')! tm(9s by Hi)!us#
A(ost'sy is (u)is+'b9 by !'t+ i) Is9'm )ot '99o8! u)!r 'r9ir i)*s# Su7+ '(ost'ts ('i!
8it+ t+ir 9i-s "or t+ir G"'99i)* o"" "rom *r'7G# Ab'r issu! or!rs (rmitti)* t+os Hi)!us8+o +'! b) "or7ib9y 7o)-rt! to Is9'm 'r9ir, to r7o)-rt to Hi)!uism# H '9so (ro+ibit!
m'i)* s9'-s o" (riso)rs o" 8'r# A99 t+is !i! )ot 7o)"orm 8it+ t+ ?ur') ')! t+ S+'ri't#
A77or!i)* to B'!'o)i, Ab'r 7+'99)*! t+ !o7tri)s o" Is9'm its9", ')! t+is m'! t+ 'ut+or
o" Muntakhab-ut-Tawarikh r'-# H 8rits: GAt t+ r9i*ious !is7ussio) mti)*s +9! by Ab'r,
't 8+i7+ -ry o)### mi*+t s'y or 's 8+'t + 9i!, t+ m(ror >'mi)! (o(9 'bout t+
7r'tio) o" t+ ?ur'), 9i7it! t+ir b9i", or ot+r8is, i) r-9'tio), ')! r'is! !oubts i) t+m
r*'r!i)* '99 t+i)*s 7o))7t! 8it+ t+ Pro(+t ')! t+ im'ms# H !isti)7t9y !)i! t+
>ist)7 o" Jins, o" ')*9s, ')! o" '99 ot+r bi)*s o" t+ i)-isib9 8or9!, 's 899 's t+ mir'79s
o" t+ Pro(+t#G
I) t+ +istory o" 4us9im ru9 i) I)!i', it 8's "or t+ "irst tim t+'t "r!om o" t+ou*+t ')! 7riti7'9
'((r'is'9 o" Is9'm 8's 8it)ss! i) t+ Court 7ir79s# O) o" t+ r'so) "or su7+ 7+')* 8's
Ab'rs 'sso7i'tio) 8it+ Hi)!u s7+o9'rs# Ab'r 8's by )'tur to9r')t# But + '9so "9t t+'t t+
s)tim)ts o" t+ -'st (o(u9'tio) o" t+ Hi)!us +'! to b rs(7t! i" ' stro)* ')! st'b9 )'tio)'9
st't 8's to b bui9t u(# H 8's '9so i)"9u)7! by t+ (+i9oso(+i7'9 t)ts o" Bu!!+ism ')!
J'i)ism o" )o);-io9)7#
T+is )8 !im)sio) 8's 7'(tur! by Abu0;2'9 A99';mi $0660;0/.& 8+o 8's i)s(ir! by '
)! to r'tio)'9i t+ bro'!9y b's! (o9i7is o" ('7 ')! 7o)7or! 8it+ '99 r9i*ious7ommu)itis i)iti't! by +is ('tro), Ab'r t+ 5r't# Bsi!s Ar'bi7 ')! Prsi') 8ors o)
i)*s+i( ')! *o-r)m)t, Abu0;2'9 +'! '77ss to t+ Prsi') tr')s9'tio)s o" t+ *r't Hi)!u
(i7s, t+ 4'+'b+'r't' ')! t+ R'm'y')', to t+ Ar'bi7 tr')s9'tio) o" t+ C+')'y' Niti, ')! to
t+ S')srit 8ors o" ')7i)t I)!i') r'F'mti $(o9ity H r"us! to 7o)7r) +ims9" 8it+ t+
Is9'mi7 t+oris 9*itimii)* t+ (tty mi9it'ry !i7t'tors 8+o "or7ib9y si! (o8r ')! 8r
t+) 'utom'ti7'99y r7o*)i! 's s+'!o8s o" 5o! ')! b9i-! t+'t "'rr;i i'!i 8's *r')t! to t+
i)!i-i!u'9 8+o +9! t+ o""i7 ')! )ot t+ i)*# Turtus+9 'ssrt! t+'t ') i)"i!9 i)* 8+o
*o-r)! +is i)*!om '77or!i)* to t+ ri*+t (ri)7i(9s o" i)*s+i( 8's (r"r'b9 to ' 4us9im
ru9r 8+o 8's s9i(s+o! i) "u9"i99i)* +is rs(o)sibi9itis ')! t'r!y i) im(osi)* Fusti7# T+is
(ri)7i(9, to 8+i7+ som 'r9ir su9t')s +'! ('i! 9i(;sr-i7, t)!! to str)*t+) t+ b'siso) 8+i7+ Ab'rs *o-r)m)t 8's "ou)!!#
11 | P ' *
8/19/2019 history final.docx
12/16
Sti99 t+r 'r +istori')s 8+o b9i- t+'t -) !uri)* Ab'r=s ru9 t+ i!o9o*is o" Is9'm ')!
t+ (r'7ti7 o" t+ S+'ri't 8r )ot b i*)or!# GT+ Akbar Nama, t+ Ain-i-Akbari ')! B'!'o)i
'99 +'- '*r! t+'t (rior to 06K3, som Hi)!us +'! b) 7o)-rt! to Is9'm "or7ib9y# Su7+ sm
to +'- b) ')! 7o)ti)u! to b t+ (o(u9'r (rFu!i7s '*'i)st t+ Hi)!usG, u)!r Ab'r ')! +is
su77ssors 's (r t+ ob9i*'tio)s o" t+ S+'ri't ')! (r'7ti7 o" Su))'+, 8rits S#R# S+'rm'# I)
+is 9ttrs to Ab!u99'+ @+') Ub 8ritt) i) 06 o) )o); 4us9ims&, 's
899 's to !(ri- Hi)!us o" '99 (osts o" rs(o)sibi9ity ')! trust but )o8+r !os + '!-o7't
rb99io)# But t+ >trm '((9i7'tio) 7') b s)# J'+')*ir, 8+) ' (ri)7, 't o) tim i)t)!!
!mo9is+i)* som o" t+ Hi)!u tm(9s 't B')'r's but !sist! t+r "rom o) 4') Si)*+s
i)tr-)tio)# I) +is ri*) 7o)-rsio)s to Is9'm 8r )7our'*!, 7o)-rsio)s b'7 "rom Is9'm to
Hi)!uism 8r (u)is+!# W+) + -isit! @')*r', + 79br't! t+ 4us9im o77u('tio) o" t+
"ort by !s7r'ti)* its "'mous tm(9# At Pus+'r + bro t+ im'* o" V'r'+' ')! ' bu99 8's
s'7ri"i7! to si*)i"y t+ -i7tory o" Is9'm o-r i!o9'try# I) +is ri*) 4us9ims b*') to b+'- 's
bu99is o)7 '*'i)#
U)!r S+'+F'+'), Ab'rs Sulehkul 8's '9most r-rs!# %uri)* +is ri*) tm(9s 8r
!stroy! i) 5uF'r't, B')'r's ')! A99'+'b'!, ')! 't Or7+'# Li J'+')*ir + sto((! m'rri'*s
bt8) 4us9im *ir9s ')! Hi)!u m)# A(ost'sy "rom Is9'm '*'i) b7'm ' 7'(it'9 7rim i)
'77or!')7 8it+ t+ t)ts o" t+ S+'ri't# %uri)* t+ ri*) o" S+'+F'+') tit9s i) us 'mo)*
@+'9i"'s ')! 5+')'-i!s 8r r-i-!# W+)-r t+ 4us9im st't us! to s+o8 si*)s o"
s7u9'rist 8')ss, t+ *9orious mmory o" 4'+mu! o" 5+')i us! to i)F7t ' s)s o" (ri!i) its (o9ity# T+ tit9 o" Y'mi)u!!'u9' $ri*+t +')! o" t+ st't& 8's bsto8! by t+ @+'9i"' '9;
?'!ir Bi99'+ o) 4'+mu! o" 5+')i# T+ bsto8'9 o" t+ tit9 o" Y'mi)u!!'u9' o) As'" @+')
its9" (oi)ts to t+ !ir7tio) i) 8+i7+ t+ st't 8's rs+'(i)* its9"# A99 t+'t Is9'm '!-o7't! 8's
mor or 9ss 7o)ti)u! u)!r '99 t+ 4u*+'9 mo)'r7+s# Ab'r ')! J'+')*ir, 9i B'bur ')!
S+'+F'+'), '!o(t! t+ tit9 o" 5+'i# 4us9im )ob9s ')! u9m' 8ou9! )ot 9t t+ 4us9im i)*s
str'y '8'y "rom t+ ('t+ o" Is9'm# A)y !-i'tio) 8's sou*+t to b 7orr7t! 't t+ "irst
12 | P ' *
8/19/2019 history final.docx
13/16
o((ortu)ity# Imm!i't9y '"tr t+ !'t+ o" Ab'r, G4u99' S+'+ A+m'!, o) o" t+ *r'tst
r9i*ious 9'!rs o" t+ '*, 8rot to -'rious 7ourt !i*)it'ris >+orti)* t+m to *t t+is st't o"
t+i)*s '9tr! i) t+ -ry b*i))i)* o" $J'+')*irs& ri*) b7'us ot+r8is it 8ou9! b !i""i7u9t
to '77om(9is+ ')yt+i)* 9'tr o)#G
%si*)i)* +is t+ory o" i)*s+i( to Fusti"y +is o8) '77ssio) to t+ t+ro) ')! to *'i) t+su((ort o" ort+o!o> Su))is "or +is ru9, Aur')*b 79'im! t+'t, si)7 '99 '7tio)s 'r !trmi)!
by t+ 8i99 o" 5o!, +is -i7tory o-r +is brot+rs 8's ' !i-i) *i"t# H st't! t+'t t+'t m') 8's
tru9y *r't 8+o 8's 'ssist! to obt'i) (o8r by 5o!# Aur')*b o()9y 79'im! to +'- "ou*+t
Gt+ '(ost'tG %'r' to r;st'b9is+ t+ 9'8 o" Is9'm# H 7om(9t! t+ (ro7ss o" tur)i)* t+ st't
s9')ti)* to8'r!s ') Is9'mi7 st't 8+i7+ +'! b*u) by S+'+ J'+') "rom t+ s7u9'rism o" Ab'r#
H rim(os! Fiiy'+ ')! !i! o)9y 8+'t 8's (rmitt! ')! ob9i*'tory "or ' 4us9im ru9r but
)ot+i)* byo)! t+'t, ')! + rs(7t! t+ o""i7i'9s 8+o (rs7ut! Hi)!us# H 8's s'i! by m')y
to b tru9y t+o7r'ti7 i) )'tur ')! s'i! t+'t +is 'ttm(t to tur) I)!i' i)to ') Is9'mi7 st't 8's t+
m'i) r'so) "or its "'99 u)!r t+ 4'r't+'s#
T+us it 8's +9! by m')y t+'t 8+t+r it is 7o)si!r! t+ i)"9u)7 o" t+ 4us9im r9i*ious
79'ss $t+ u9m'&, t+ '((9i7'tio) o" t+ 9'8 o" Is9'm $Sharia&, or t+ '7ti-itis o" t+ i)*s, it is
79'r byo)! !oubt t+'t t+ m!i-'9 st't 8's ' t+o7r'ti7 st't# A('rt "rom t+ ru9 o" Ab'r
')! s(7i'99y '"tr +is ru9, t+ st'b9is+m)t o" Is9'mi7 st't 7') b !!u7!# T+ 9'8 8+i7+
(r-'i9! i) I)!i' u)!r 4us9im ru9 8's t+ S+'ri't# GT+is 8's t+ '7tu'9 so-ri*) i) 4us9im
9')!s#G
T+is -i!)7 o" Is9'mi7 St't 'r sti99 rbutt! by ' )umbr o" +istori')s by 9'yi)* !o8) '
)umbr o" "'7ts# T+ 9'8s t+'t t+s ru9rs 79'im! to b Is9'mi7 8r, o-r ' (rio! o" tim, +'!
b) subF7t! to ' )umbr o" 7+')*s ')! i)"9u)7s "rom r9i*io)s ')! (+i9oso(+is bot+outsi! ')! i)si! I)!i' !u to its o())ss i) i)tr(rt'tio) by t+ u9m' 's 899 's t+ i)*s i)
7rt'i) 7'ss, 8+o 8r )ot '98'ys stu!i! ?ur') ')! ot+r r9i*ious t'7+i)*s#
O) ot+r r'so) is t+ (rs)7 o" 9'r* )umbr o" Hi)!us;'""9u)t ')! ot+rs 's 899 's t+
!o8)tro!!) 7o)!itio)s o" 7rt'i) 79'sss o" 4us9ims# T+ 9imit! )umbr o" 7o)-rsio)s o"
Hi)!us to Is9'm ')! t+ 7o)ti)uity o" t+ r9i*io) ')! t+ 7u9tur o" Hi)!us to ' 9'r* >t)t
t+rou*+out t+ 4us9im Em(ir ')! -) '"tr t+'t (oi)t, i" )ot to8'r!s s7u9'rism, but to '
!*r o" to9r')7 o" Hi)!us# T+ ot+r r'so) 7ou9! b t+ i)'bi9ity o" t+ ru9rs to im(os t+
Is9'mi7 t)ts o-r su7+ ' -'st Hi)!u m(ir#
13 | P ' *
8/19/2019 history final.docx
14/16
ANALYSIS OF ARGUMENTS
T+ Is9'mi7 st't i" 7o)si!r! to b t+ o) 8+i7+ 8's ori*i)'99y (ro('*'t!, t+) t+ 4us9im
ru9 !uri)* I)!i' or ')y m!i-'9 Asi') 7ou)try 7') b 7'99! 's ') Is9'mi7 st't, it bi)*
o((os! to t+ 7o)7(t o" mo)'r7+y, 8+i7+ 8's st'b9is+! by t+s ru9s#
Ho8-r, t+ 7+')* i) t+ ruirm)t o" Is9'mi7 st't is '99o8!, t+) ' mu9ti(9 o" rsu9ts
8ou9! "o99o8# Ri*+t "rom t+ Umm'y'!s 8+o 8r +r!it'ry i) )'tur, '99 ru9s ti99 Aur')*b
9! to 7rt'i) 7+')*s i) t+ st't stru7tur# T+ Is9'mi7 st't+oo! 8's i)tr(rt! !i""r)t9y, to
i)7r's t+ (o8rs ')! 'ut+oritis o" i)*s, >(')! t+ir trritoris ')! 8'9t+, ')! '9so to *'i)
9*itim'7y i) t+ir trritoris t+rou*+ "or*! '77(t')7s "rom C'9i(+s# I" t+s 'r st 's
b)7+m'rs "or ') Is9'mi7 St't, t+) ' )umbr o" t+m 8ou9! b '-'i9'b9# But i" t+
ruirm)t o" stri7t S+'ri' 9'8 is '((9i!, t+) t+is )umbr 8i99 '*'i) r!u7# T+is is b7'us
'9t+ou*+ t+ S+'ri' 8's t+ 9'8 o" t+ 9')!, yt it 8's su((9m)t! by ot+r t>ts ')! i) som
7'ss t+ i)*s 8r *i-) t+ (o8r to m' 9'8s t+ms9-s 8+i7+ o"t) +'! im('7t o" t+
9o7'9 7u9turs o" t+ ru9! trritory# H)7 t+ (urity o" t+ 9'8s is sti99 i) ustio)# 4oro-r
t+r is -i!)7 o" !i""r)t ru9rs ru9i)* i) '77or!')7 8it+ t+ir 8is+s, 'sso7i'ti)* 8it+ t+
9o7'9 )o);mu9sim t+i)rs, (+i9oso(+rs ')! ot+rs ')! bi)* im('7t! by t+m# T+is tr)!
7o)ti)ui)* ti99 t+ ru9 o" Ab'r s+o8s bot+ im'*s o" >trm to9r')7 ')! >trm -io9)7
'*'i)st t+ )o);4us9ims ')! >trm 7om(9i')7 ')! >trm )o);7om(9i')7 8it+ t+ 4us9im
9'8s# I) su7+ 7o)!itio), it is !i""i7u9t to 7om to ' (ro(r 7o)79usio) 8it+ r*'r! to t+ Is9'mi7
St't i) I)!i' ti99 Ab'r# Ab'r=s ru9 is ' 79'r >'m(9 o" )o);Is9'mi7 st't 8+i7+ s+o8s t+
(' o" to9r')7 ')! s7u9'rism ')! 7ou9! b '77(t! i" )ot "or t+ >ist)7 o" som o" t+
!o7um)ts rbutti)* t+is "'7t#
A"tr Ab'r, t+ ru9 '*'i) b7'm mor t+o7r'ti7 i) )'tur ')! it is 'r*u! t+'t i" )ot i) ot+rs,
t+) 't9'st !uri)* t+ ru9 o" Aur')*b, t+r 8's ') Is9'mi7 st't# T+is -i8 is su((ort! 's it
"u9"i9s 7rt'i) 7o)!itio)s ruir! 8it+ ') Is9'mi7 st't, t+'t o" (r(tu'tio) o" 4us9im L'8, ')!
)o);to9r')7 o" ot+r r9i*io)s ')! su(rm'7y o" Is9'm# But t+is "'7t 7') too b rbutt! by
s'yi)* t+'t -) t+ou*+ t+ (r'7ti7s m'y +'- b) Is9'mi7, but 8+t+r it 8's su77ss"u9 or
)ot i) '7+i-i)* its )! o" Is9'mi7 so-ri*)ty, 8+i7+ is '*'i) i) ustio) b7'us o" (rs)7 o"
' 9'r* )umbr o" )o);mus9ims -) !uri)* t+is (rio!# 4oro-r t+ +r!it'ry stru7tur ')!
t+ us o" i)*=s or!rs ')! 'bs)7 o" C'9i(+=s '((ro-'9 t7 (ro-i! ' 9ot o" 7o)str'i)ts to 7om
to t+is 7o)79usio)#
T+ !b't, 's 7') b s), is )7ss'ri9y b's! o) t+ "u9"i9m)t o" t+ ruirm)t o" t+
7o)!itio)s o" ' tru Is9'mi7 st't# T+ 7o)7(t o" mo)'r7+y its9" 8's o((os! to ori*i)'9
7o)7(t o" Is9'mi7 st't ')! +)7 t+ b)7+m'r 7+')*! o-r t+ 9o)* (rio! o" tim i) 8+i7+
-'rious ruirm)ts 8r 9'i! !o8) "or ' st't to b r7o*)i! 's Is9'mi7# No8, i" o) o" t+
b)7+m'r is t') i)to 7o)si!r'tio) i## t+ "u9"i9m)t o" t+ 7o)!itio)s o" so-ri*)ty o"
R9i*io) ')! its 9'8s, ')! )o);to9r')7 o" ot+r r9i*io)# E-i!)7s +'- b) *i-) bot+ "or
14 | P ' *
8/19/2019 history final.docx
15/16
')! '*'i)st su7+ -i8# T+s !i""r)7s o77ur b7'us o" !i""r)7 i) t+ i)tr(rt'tio) o" su7+
ruirm)ts '77or!i)* to t+ +istori')s subF7ti- -i8 '9o)* 8it+ t+ '-'i9'bi9ity o" t+
sour7s 8+i7+ !trmi) t+ir 7o)79usio)# T+is (rob9m o77urs 8it+ ')y o" t+ b)7+m'r "or
Is9'mi7 st't#
O) o" t+ ot+r (rob9ms 'sso7i't! 8it+ t+is b)7+m'r is its 'mbi*uity i) t99i)* t+'t 8+t+r ') Is9'mi7 St't is o) 8+i7+ "u9"i9s t+ ruirm)t o" im(osi)* t+ 9'8s o" Is9'm o) its subF7ts
')! tris to '7+i- +omo*)ity o" r9i*io) or ' st't 7') b 7'99! Is9'mi7 o)9y i" it su77!s to
!o so# T+r"or it is !i""i7u9t to 7om to ' ('rti7u9'r 7o)79usio) 8it+ r*'r!s to t+ (rs)7 o"
') Is9'mi7 st't i) I)!i' ')! )o o) -i8 7') b +9! to b "i)'9 b7'us o" !i""r)7s i) t+
b)7+m'rs#
CONCLUSIONT+us "rom t+ !is7ussio) 'bo-, it 7') b 7o)79u!! t+'t )o o) -i8 7') b "orm! 'bout t+
>ist)7 o" Is9'mi7 St't i) I)!i' 't9'st u)9ss ' u)i"orm m')i)* o" t+ trm; DIs9'mi7 St't
7') b !!u7!# T+us t+ !b't is sti99 o() ')! '!!itio)s 7') b m'! "rom bot+ t+ si!s ')!
7o)79usio)s !ri-! '77or!i)* to o)=s -i8 o" i)tr(rti)* t+ m')i)*#
BIBLIOGRAPHY
15 | P ' *
8/19/2019 history final.docx
16/16
• S#A#A# Ri-i, T+ Wo)!r T+'t W's I)!i' $Vo9# .&
• Vi(u9 si)*+, I)tr(rti)* 4!i-'9 I)!i' $6/;066/&
• 4urr'y T#Titus, I)!i') Is9'm
• 888# bst+istorysits#)t
• +tt(s:888#ss7)t#u79'#!usout+'si'History4u*+'9smu*+'9s#+tm9
16 | P ' *