+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Reviews and Notices of Books

Reviews and Notices of Books

Date post: 06-Jan-2017
Category:
Upload: vuthu
View: 213 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
2
609 amination. His growing conviction had been that instru- mentation was toc freely and too frequently had recourse to. He showed certain instruments, and explained their action.- Dr. A. Macdonald spoke of need of thorough evacuation of the uterine cavity in cases of abortion, whether the curette or fingers were used.-Professor Simpson had long been familiar with the curette.-Dr. J. B. BUIST read notes of a case of Retroversion of the Gravid Uterus. There had been difficulty in micturition since the cessation of menstruation five months previously, which rather suddenly increased after exertion. The bladder became much distended, and the enlarged and retroverted uterus was felt filling the pelvis. Attempts at forcible reduction having failed, a purgative dose of castor oil was administered, and the next day the uterus was found in the normal position. Some pelvic inflammation ensued. It was suggested that dis- tension of the bladder may have caused the retroversion. The pelvic inflammation was no doubt due to the dragging that had taken place on the uterine ligaments, and not to the force used in the attempt at reduction. - Drs. Keiller, Macdonald, and others spoke in the discussion that followed. GLASGOW MEDICO-CHIRURGICAL SOCIETY.-This Society met on March 15th, Dr. Scott Orr in the chair.-Dr. CHAR- TERIS initiated a discussion on the treatment of Acute Rheumatism. He gave a rapid review of the various modes of treatment which had been practised, from the compara- tively moderate venesection of Sydenham down to the more modern methods. Among these latter he specially adverted to the mode of blistering in succession the affected joints, and giving alkalies to neutralise the acid produced in the course of the disease. This was an improvement on former methods; it shortened the disease by ten days, and heart complications were believed to be reduced in frequency. The treatment by salicin or salicylic acid was then intro- duced, and this he looked upon as the best treatment for acute rheumatism at present known, and of the nature of a specific. Relief was experienced in from thirty-four to forty-eight hours, and the temperature also fell. Heart complications were not averted, except indirectly by the arrest of the disease. If the disease was very acute, with severe head symptoms, they must not trust to the salicylates, butto cold baths. Experience had led him to the conclusion that salicin should not be continued after the temperature reached 99°. If continued longer it exercised a depressing effect.-Dr. McCall Anderson agreed that for the ordinary run of cases salicin was the best treatment. But there were cases in which it failed, and even some in which the pyrexia was increased. But other subordinate points of treatment must be attended to, such as warmth, the state of the alimentary canal, dietary, &c. He could not look on salicin as a specific in the disease.-Dr. Gairdner insisted on the following points: (1) that no confidence could be placed in small doses of salicin; (2) in gonorrhoeal rheumatism it had no effect at all; (3) that the effect of the drug was not de- pendent upon, or not commensurate with, its antipyretic effect; there was something specific in its effect.-Dr. Scott Orr said that with salicin his results had only been fairly successful. He would still prefer acetate of potash.-The subject was further discussed by Drs. J. Reid, Renfrew,. Morton, Macmillan, Thomson, and others. Reviews and Notices of Books. Pathologische Anatomie des Ohres (A ug-al Pathology). Von Prof. SCHWARTZE. Berlin : Herschwald. 1878. THIS excellent book on Aural Pathology will be welcomed as a most important addition to the literature of the science of otology, towards the progress of which we think that it is likely to do a great deal. Indeed, in this respect, we regard its appearance now as quite opportune, because much of what we have had added to our knowledge of the pathology of ear diseases since Toynbee’s time has emanated from our German confrères; and this knowledge, hitherto for the Diost part scattered up and down in various journals, and therefore inaccessible, or nearly so, to most practitioners, is gathered up and presented to us in this volume as a com- plete study. Of course, in speaking thus, we do not overlook the value. and importance of the pathological labours of our own countrymen, nor does the author of this book do so ;, on the contrary, he ascribes to Toynbee the honour of having, " founded" aural pathology; and to Hinton, among others, he makes frequent reference, especially to his " Atlas of £ the. Membrana Tympani," which remains, as his other works also do, to form " stepping stones for others to ad- vance upon," and as lasting memorials of the valuable aid which this lately deceased and accomplished man gave to the specialty which he dignified and adorned. When we mention therefore that in this work by Professor Schwartze we have, and for the first time, a summary of the labours of the distinguished band of special pathologists who have risen into eminence in Germany since the death of Toynbee, and that indeed all that has been written on this subject, either before or since his time, is noticed in it, we state the grounds upon which our hope rests, that the appearance of this book now may effect a good purpose in respect to the progress of otology. To this summary of the labours of others the author bar, added the results of his own extensive and well-nigh, if not, quite, unparalleled experience as an aural pathologist, and which is not the least valuable feature of the volume. Indeed, it is this special qualification on the author’s part that would appear to have fitted him for undertaking that which he has so satisfactorily accomplished. We have therefore to express our entire satisfaction with the book ; indeed, its merits are very great. It is concise, complete, and exhaustive of the subject, in proof of which we need only state that within the compass of a little over 130 pages of widely-printed letter-press the author has managed to give us all the knowledge that at present exists on the pathology of ear diseases. Besides this, however, the literature of the subject of which the book treats is fully recorded in its pages, and for every statement of fact not observed by the author himself we have the authority given upon whose responsibility it. is made; this alone makes the book of great value as a work of reference to aural surgeons, and indeed to all who are interested in the subject of ear diseases-to whom we. cordially recommend it. We may add that it is very fully illustrated by well-executed woodcuts, and that most. of these are original and representative of specimens in the possession of the author. Altogether we congratulate Professor Schwartze upon the; excellence of his work, which we understand is in course of. being translated into English by Dr. Orme Green, of Boston, U.S.A. ____________ A Text-book of Physiology. By MICHAEL FOSTER, M.D., &c. Second Edition. Macmillan and Co. 1878. WE are glad to see that this treatise, published little more than a year ago, has already reached a second edition. It well deserves the position it has taken as one of the best manuals on the subject. It is curious to notice, however, the tendency to swell that exists in all works on physiology. Is it that the authors cannot bring themselves to expunge what has once been committed to paper ? or is it easier ta add than to correct and modify ? or do the authors know more ? or, lastly, is real work proceeding at so rapid a rate that, as in the case of the book before us, nearly a hundred pages have to be added in the course of one year ? Dr. Foster has not been contented to make only a few verbal additions,. but has very conscientiously worked over the whole subject" as is apparent from the alterations we meet with on every page. To the account of the blood he has now appended A. Schmidt’s theory of the ferment by which coagulation is produced—a theory that has been advocated by Dr. Bardon- Sanderson in his Lectures on Comparative Pathology. It seems to us that much more evidence must be adduced.
Transcript
Page 1: Reviews and Notices of Books

609

amination. His growing conviction had been that instru-mentation was toc freely and too frequently had recourse to.He showed certain instruments, and explained their action.-Dr. A. Macdonald spoke of need of thorough evacuation ofthe uterine cavity in cases of abortion, whether the curetteor fingers were used.-Professor Simpson had long beenfamiliar with the curette.-Dr. J. B. BUIST read notes of acase of Retroversion of the Gravid Uterus. There had beendifficulty in micturition since the cessation of menstruationfive months previously, which rather suddenly increasedafter exertion. The bladder became much distended, andthe enlarged and retroverted uterus was felt filling thepelvis. Attempts at forcible reduction having failed, a

purgative dose of castor oil was administered, and the nextday the uterus was found in the normal position. Somepelvic inflammation ensued. It was suggested that dis-tension of the bladder may have caused the retroversion.The pelvic inflammation was no doubt due to the draggingthat had taken place on the uterine ligaments, and notto the force used in the attempt at reduction. - Drs.Keiller, Macdonald, and others spoke in the discussion thatfollowed.GLASGOW MEDICO-CHIRURGICAL SOCIETY.-This Society

met on March 15th, Dr. Scott Orr in the chair.-Dr. CHAR-TERIS initiated a discussion on the treatment of AcuteRheumatism. He gave a rapid review of the various modesof treatment which had been practised, from the compara-tively moderate venesection of Sydenham down to the moremodern methods. Among these latter he specially advertedto the mode of blistering in succession the affected joints,and giving alkalies to neutralise the acid produced in thecourse of the disease. This was an improvement on formermethods; it shortened the disease by ten days, and heartcomplications were believed to be reduced in frequency.The treatment by salicin or salicylic acid was then intro-duced, and this he looked upon as the best treatment foracute rheumatism at present known, and of the nature of aspecific. Relief was experienced in from thirty-four toforty-eight hours, and the temperature also fell. Heartcomplications were not averted, except indirectly by thearrest of the disease. If the disease was very acute, withsevere head symptoms, they must not trust to the salicylates,butto cold baths. Experience had led him to the conclusionthat salicin should not be continued after the temperaturereached 99°. If continued longer it exercised a depressingeffect.-Dr. McCall Anderson agreed that for the ordinaryrun of cases salicin was the best treatment. But there werecases in which it failed, and even some in which the pyrexiawas increased. But other subordinate points of treatmentmust be attended to, such as warmth, the state of thealimentary canal, dietary, &c. He could not look on salicinas a specific in the disease.-Dr. Gairdner insisted on thefollowing points: (1) that no confidence could be placed insmall doses of salicin; (2) in gonorrhoeal rheumatism it hadno effect at all; (3) that the effect of the drug was not de-pendent upon, or not commensurate with, its antipyreticeffect; there was something specific in its effect.-Dr.Scott Orr said that with salicin his results hadonly been fairly successful. He would still prefer acetateof potash.-The subject was further discussed by Drs. J.Reid, Renfrew,. Morton, Macmillan, Thomson, and others.

Reviews and Notices of Books.Pathologische Anatomie des Ohres (A ug-al Pathology). Von

Prof. SCHWARTZE. Berlin : Herschwald. 1878.THIS excellent book on Aural Pathology will be welcomed

as a most important addition to the literature of the scienceof otology, towards the progress of which we think that it islikely to do a great deal. Indeed, in this respect, we regardits appearance now as quite opportune, because much ofwhat we have had added to our knowledge of the pathologyof ear diseases since Toynbee’s time has emanated from ourGerman confrères; and this knowledge, hitherto for theDiost part scattered up and down in various journals, andtherefore inaccessible, or nearly so, to most practitioners, isgathered up and presented to us in this volume as a com-plete study.

Of course, in speaking thus, we do not overlook the value.and importance of the pathological labours of our own

countrymen, nor does the author of this book do so ;, onthe contrary, he ascribes to Toynbee the honour of having," founded" aural pathology; and to Hinton, among others,he makes frequent reference, especially to his " Atlas of £the. Membrana Tympani," which remains, as his otherworks also do, to form " stepping stones for others to ad-vance upon," and as lasting memorials of the valuable aidwhich this lately deceased and accomplished man gave tothe specialty which he dignified and adorned.When we mention therefore that in this work by Professor

Schwartze we have, and for the first time, a summary of thelabours of the distinguished band of special pathologistswho have risen into eminence in Germany since the deathof Toynbee, and that indeed all that has been written onthis subject, either before or since his time, is noticed in it,we state the grounds upon which our hope rests, that theappearance of this book now may effect a good purpose inrespect to the progress of otology.To this summary of the labours of others the author bar,

added the results of his own extensive and well-nigh, if not,quite, unparalleled experience as an aural pathologist, andwhich is not the least valuable feature of the volume.

Indeed, it is this special qualification on the author’s partthat would appear to have fitted him for undertaking thatwhich he has so satisfactorily accomplished.We have therefore to express our entire satisfaction

with the book ; indeed, its merits are very great. It is

concise, complete, and exhaustive of the subject, in proof ofwhich we need only state that within the compass of a littleover 130 pages of widely-printed letter-press the authorhas managed to give us all the knowledge that at presentexists on the pathology of ear diseases.

Besides this, however, the literature of the subject ofwhich the book treats is fully recorded in its pages, and forevery statement of fact not observed by the author himselfwe have the authority given upon whose responsibility it.is made; this alone makes the book of great value as awork of reference to aural surgeons, and indeed to all whoare interested in the subject of ear diseases-to whom we.cordially recommend it. We may add that it is very fullyillustrated by well-executed woodcuts, and that most. ofthese are original and representative of specimens in thepossession of the author.Altogether we congratulate Professor Schwartze upon the;

excellence of his work, which we understand is in course of.being translated into English by Dr. Orme Green, ofBoston, U.S.A.

____________

A Text-book of Physiology. By MICHAEL FOSTER, M.D., &c.Second Edition. Macmillan and Co. 1878.

WE are glad to see that this treatise, published little morethan a year ago, has already reached a second edition. Itwell deserves the position it has taken as one of the bestmanuals on the subject. It is curious to notice, however,the tendency to swell that exists in all works on physiology.Is it that the authors cannot bring themselves to expungewhat has once been committed to paper ? or is it easier taadd than to correct and modify ? or do the authors knowmore ? or, lastly, is real work proceeding at so rapid a ratethat, as in the case of the book before us, nearly a hundredpages have to be added in the course of one year ? Dr. Fosterhas not been contented to make only a few verbal additions,.but has very conscientiously worked over the whole subject"as is apparent from the alterations we meet with on everypage. To the account of the blood he has now appendedA. Schmidt’s theory of the ferment by which coagulation isproduced—a theory that has been advocated by Dr. Bardon-Sanderson in his Lectures on Comparative Pathology. Itseems to us that much more evidence must be adduced.

Page 2: Reviews and Notices of Books

610

before it can be accepted as proven. In discussing thenervous mechanism of the submaxillary gland, the theoryof Schiff, which was only mentioned in the last edition, tothe effect that there are recurrent chorda fibres in the lingualnerve, is now more fully given, as well as the results ofBidder’s experiments. In the section on Sight, a paragraphupon "Sehpurpur," or vision-purple, which has recentlyattracted so much attention, has been inserted, togetherwith a short historical account of its discovery. The sectionon the Regulation of the Production of Heat in the Economyhas been considerably expanded. An additional chapter hasbeen added on the Phases of Life. In compliance with the re-commendation of friends, and evidently somewhat against hisown judgment, Dr. Foster has inserted a. considerable numberof illustrations, some of which-as that showing the differenceof the nervous supply of the heart in the rabbit and dog,-we venture to think, will materially assist the student in thecomprehension of the text. In our notice of the previousedition we strongly recommended the book to all who wishto make themselves acquainted with the present standpointof physiology, and we can only repeat that it will be foundto be one of the most reliable and intelligently writtenworks on physiology in this or any other language.

Tlte Year-booh; of Pharmacy, 1877, with the Transactions ofthe British Pharmaceutical Conference held in Plymouth.London : J. and A. Churchill.THIS work, which has been compiled by a committee com-

posed of Messrs. Stoddart, Carteighe, Groves, Benger, andAttfield, and has been edited by Professor Attfield, con-stitutes a most excellent J’ésurné of all pharmaceutical workthat has been done during the past year, and deserves everysupport that can be given to it by pharmaceutists throughoutthe kingdom. The first part is devoted to pharmaceuticalchemistry, and contains not only very full abstracts of allEnglish papers and memoirs on this subject, but numerousreferences to American, French, and German essays. Thusalmost on the first page is a very correct and useful transla-tion of Professor G. Dragendorff’s memoir on the "Processesfor the Detection of Alkaloids, from the American Chemist,which gives the details for the discovery of all the ordinaryalkaloids, and should be gone over by every toxicologist.Then comes a succession of abstracts of which we can onlyindicate the names : The Pharmacopoeia Test of QuinineSulphate, by Dr. B. H. Paul; Aricine and Allied Substances,by 0. Hesse; a Method of Detecting Castor Oil and otherfixed oils in Copaiba, by Dr. Muter; the Manufacture ofNitric Acid, by H. Gobel; the Determination of Nitric Acidby Indigo, by R. Warington ; a Method for the Analysis ofAlkaline Mineral Waters, by Professor R. Fresenius ; ButterAnalysis, by Dr. J. Muter, and another method by A. Dupré.The second part of the work is devoted to Materia Medica,and contains abstracts of papers on arnica, cotobark, angelica,cubebs, aconite, kosin ava, arrowroot, ergot, xanthium

spinosum, fucus, sumbul, ailanthus, mate, megarrhiza, andmany others. The third part is devoted to pharmacy, andthe fourth to notes and formulae. The last part of the workis occupied with a full report of the British PharmaceuticalConference, at which some really good papers appear to havebeen read. Taking one amongst the many "notes andformulav," we shall select the aromatic elixir of liquorice,which is most useful in enabling bitter substances to begiven to children and others to whom they are unpalatable.It has been suggested by Mr. J. P. Remington. It comprises:Cinnamon, 6; star anise, 4; coriander, 7; caraway, 7 ;tonqua, 4; canella, 2; nutmegs, 2; cloves (all in fine powder),2; ammoniacal glycerrhizin, 40; fresh oil of orange, 2;alcohol, 532 ; syrup, 1000 ; water, 475. Details are given asto the mode of preparation. If it be desired to administer

sulphate of quinia, all that is necessary is to pour into a tea-spoon a small quantity of the elixir; add the quinia and

swallow before the bitter salt dissolves to any extent, therfollow with a fresh teaspoonful of elixir, and the deceptioris complete.

SIX YEARS’ MORTALITY STATISTICS IN THETWO METROPOLITAN ASYLUMS FOR

IMBECILES.

I.

IT is more than ten years since the Metropolitan PoorAct (1867) was passed to facilitate the establishment in themetropolis of asylums for the sick, insane, and other classesof the poor, and for the distribution over the whole metropolisof portions of the charge for poor relief. Far from the least

important result of this Act has been the erection of asylumsfor imbeciles at Leavesden, Caterham, and Clapton, whichon the 1st of January, 1877, contained 4519 inmates, who,but for that Act, would have been either in county lunaticasylums, in workhouses, or living with relatives or others,supported by out-door relief. These 4519 inmates included2124 at Leavesden, 2063 at Caterham, and 332 at Clapton.The Act above alluded to enacts in Section 30 that "everysuch asylum shall be considered as a workhouse, within themeaning of the Lunacy Acts," and, therefore, in the reportsof the Lunacy Commissioners, all the inmates of these

metropolitan asylums for imbeciles are classed with insanepaupers maintained in workhouses. This is much to be

regretted, as in consequence the county percentages of

pauper lunatics, idiots, and persons of unsound mind, main-tained in lunatic asylums, in workhouses, and with relativesor others, afford a fallacious basis for comparison. Theinterests both of the general community and of the insanepaupers are best served by the treatment of such paupers inasylums for lunatics or for imbeciles especially adapted forthe purpose; and figures showing the proportions of insanepaupers under these three classes of treatment shouldafford a real clue to the amount of suitable provision for thecare of the pauper insane in the different counties. Classingthese metropolitan asylums as workhouses destroys the valueof the percentages given in the Lunacy Commissioners’

Report, as far as the three home counties of Middlesex,Surrey, and Kent are concerned. It there appears thatthe percentage of pauper lunatics detained in workhouseswas 41’2 per cent. in Middlesex, 34’9 per cent, in Surrey,and 21’8 per cent. in Kent, whereas the true proportionof insane paupers in workhouses, after excluding thoseunder treatment in the metropolitan asylums for imbeciles,was but 5’3 per cent. in Middlesex, 4’9 per cent. in Surrey,and 0’8 per cent. in Kent. It appears, from the report ofthe Lunacy Commissioners, that on the 1st of January, 1877,11,454 insane paupers were chargeable to the various unionsof the metropolis, and if to this number be added 682, re-

presenting a due proportion of the pauper lunatics charge-able to the three counties of Middlesex, Surrey, and Kent,the total number that may be attributed to the metropolisis raised to 12,136. Of this number, 55-3 per cent. were inthe two county lunatic asylums, 37’2 per cent. in the threemetropolitan asylums for imbeciles, 4-2 per cent. in work-houses, and only 3’3 were residing with relatives or others;thus, 92-5 per cent. were under asylum treatment. InEngland and Wales, exclusive of the metropolis, of 46,903pauper lunatics, only 63’9 per cent. were under asylumtreatment, whereas 23’5 per cent. were retained in work-houses, and 12’6 per cent. were residing with relatives orothers. It is evident, therefore, that the asylum accom-modation provided in the metropolis is very considerably inexcess of that which exists in other parts of England andWales. Such being the case, it becomes important to as-certain, so far as may be possible, the effect of asylum treat-ment upon the sanitary condition of the insane and imbecile.The effect of asylum treatment might be estimated fromtwo classes of statistics-those showing proportional re-

coveries, and those of mortality. On the present occasionit is proposed to deal exclusively with such mortality sta-


Recommended