+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP,...

Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP,...

Date post: 02-Apr-2015
Category:
Upload: aryanna-vergin
View: 217 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
Popular Tags:
64
Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic
Transcript
Page 1: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical

Regimen

Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP,

Co-Director, UNC Lipid and

Prevention Clinic

Page 2: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Disclosures

• Dr. Mendys is an employee of Pfizer and works as a Senior Director in Medical Affairs.

• Dr. Mendys carries both academic and clinical appointments at the University of North Carolina in the School of Medicine-Division of Cardiology and the School of Pharmacy- Pharmacotherapy and Experimental Therapeutics.

04/11/23 2

Page 3: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

04/11/23 3

Page 4: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Talk Objectives

Key Concepts in Medication Adherence Making the case for supporting Adherence

Programs – Case Study with Dyslipidemia Cardiac Rehabilitation – A Perfect Match to

Improve Patient Outcomes Patient Provider Quiz-

Facts and misperceptions

04/11/23 4

Page 5: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Heart medicine advances helppatients enjoy active life

British Heart Foundation July 9, 2011

• …In the 1960s, there was no treatment for a heart attack. If they survived, victims were confined to a hospital bed, given painkillers and told to take complete rest…If they died in their 50s or 60s…it was considered a fact of life…

04/11/23 5

Page 6: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

The Burden of Chronic Disease

“…poor adherence increases with the duration and complexity of treatment regimens…duration and complex treatment are inherent to chronic illnesses. Across diseases, adherence is the single most important modifiable factor that compromises treatment outcome.”

- World Health Organization, 2003

Page 7: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

The Five Dimensions of Adherence

Health System/Health Care Team Factors

Patient-related Factors

Social/Economic Factors

Condition-related Factors

Therapy-related Factors

World Health Organization. World Health Organization; Geneva, Switzerland. 2003.

HCT = health care team

Page 8: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Health Care System Factors That Affect Adherence

•Resources and set policies that support optimal practices

•Provision of preventive services

•Integration of other health care professionals as part of the treatment

•To augment role of primary providers•To provide more intensive intervention when needed

•Mandatory provisions that allow:•Educating providers about guidelines•Training in treatment strategies (including patient counseling)•Providing office support mechanisms

•Cost

Koeck C. BMJ. 1998;317:1267-1268; Ockene IS, et al. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2002;40:630-640.

Extent to which the health care system facilitates or impedes provider’s adherence-related activities

Organizational structures and processes

Page 9: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Case Study: Cholesterol ManagementWhen to Start Cholesterol Lowering Therapy in Patients with Coronary

Heart DiseaseA Statement for Healthcare Professionals From the AHA Task Force

on Risk Reduction

• several studies suggest that plasma lipoprotein

measurements can be made immediately upon admission to the hospital for acute coronary syndromes to establish a baseline cholesterol levels.

• If LDL cholesterol > 130 at time of discharge, a cholesterol-

reducing drug can reasonably be started at time of discharge• one important issue concerns responsibility for initiating cholesterol-lowering therapy in the setting of acute coronary events…divided responsibility often lead to no therapy at all.

Circulation. 1997; 95:1683-85

Page 10: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Improved Treatment of Coronary Heart Disease by Implementation of Cardiac

Hospitalization Atherosclerosis Management Program (CHAMP)

Fonarow G., et.al. Am J Cardiol; 2001; 87:819-22

Page 11: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Provider Factors

• Counseling skills• Involvement of patients in decision-

making/plan of care• Time constraints• Knowledge, awareness, adherence to

clinical practice guidelines • Individual vs team-provider approach

Page 12: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Recognizing Predictors of poor adherence

N Engl J Med 2005;353:487-97.

Page 13: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

World Health Organization. World Health Organization; Geneva, Switzerland, 2003.

What Drives Health Care Team to Improve Adherence?

• Knowledge of the broad determinants of nonadherence• Ability to assess, detect, and understand the potential for

nonadherence• Understand how patients might progress to adherence• Develop specific strategies for addressing adherence• Tailor interventions to the needs of individual patients

Page 14: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

A Tool to Improve Adherence

04/11/23 14

Page 15: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Patient Factors• Knowledge, attitudes, skills• Organic factors (memory, cognitive-

information processing)• Self-efficacy• Decision-making processes – discounting• Co-morbidities/complexity of therapeutic

regimen• Individual resources

Page 16: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Cheng JWM, et al. Pharmacotherapy. 2001;21:828-841.

Patient Reasons for Nonadherence

4%

1%

1%

2%

3%

6%

7%

7%

14%

55%

Don’t think it’s necessary all the time

Hate taking drugs

Don’t like being dependent

Drugs give me side effects

Don’t think drugs are working

Too expensive

Don’t like being told what to take

Just forget

Other

Supply will last longer

Prospective, open-label, interview-based study in metropolitan New York area pharmacies (N=821).

Page 17: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Health Literacy and Heart Disease

Over the past 50 years, we have learn a lot about the relationships between “risk factors” and the cause of cardiovascular illness, but we have much work yet to do in the area of preventing heart disease.

One’s ability to read, listen, and comprehend health information is a vital element of maintaining and improving health, including the prevention of chronic illness.

Evidence has shown that improved knowledge of one’s condition may improve patient adherence to lifestyle changes and the use of preventive medication, however-

Vascular Health and Risk Management 2006:2(4)

Page 18: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Literacy Skills and Calculated 10-Year Risk of Coronary Heart Disease

Literacy skills: 1. readingcomprehension,2.numeracy3. oral language (speaking)4. aural language (listening)

J Gen Intern MedDOI: 10.1007/s11606-010-1488-5, published online Aug 10, 2010

Page 19: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

A meta-analysis of the association between

adherence to drug therapy and mortality

• good adherence was associated with lower mortality

• association between good adherence to placebo and mortality supports the existence of the “healthy adherer” effect

• adherence to drug therapy may be a surrogate marker for overall healthy behavior. BMJ 2006;333;1-6

Page 20: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

What Drives Patients to Improve Adherence?

• People learn best by active participation• Individuals need to have adequate information• Individuals need to believe in their ability to make changes

(self-efficacy) and have positive expected outcomes• Individuals need skills, support, resources• Interventions need to be tailored to the individual or

organization and its social context

Bandura A. Social Foundations of Thought and Action: A Social Cognitive Theory. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall; 1986.

Page 21: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Adherence: Social/Economic Factors

• Formal/informal support from members of the community

• Awareness level of policy makers and health managers» Application of adherence materials to different socioeconomic settings

» Health system programs promoting adherence/self-management

• Socioeconomic status, literacy/education, employment, living conditions, distance from treatment center, transportation, medication cost, environment, culture/beliefs about illness/treatment, fear of health care system, and family dysfunction

» Poverty and chronic disease interrelationships, compounding non-adherence

World Health Organization. World Health Organization; Geneva, Switzerland. 2003.

Page 22: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Societal Factors

Examples:

Obesity• Food used to be expensive – now it’s cheap• Physical activity used to be cheap – now it’s

expensive

Smoking• Was associated with style and freedom of

choice –now its considered unhealthy and socially incorrect

Page 23: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Adherence: Condition-related Factors

Illness-related demands faced by the patient, affecting patients’ risk perception and the priority placed on adherence– Severity of symptoms and level of disability

– Severity of the disease and rate of disease progression

– Availability of effective treatments

– Co-morbidities, such as depression

– Drug and alcohol abuse

World Health Organization. World Health Organization; Geneva, Switzerland. 2003.

Page 24: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Better Knowledge Improves Adherence to Lifestyle Changes and Medication in Patients With CHD

Men and women, <71 years, who had a cardiac event (n=509)

392 interviewed, examined, and received a questionnaire 347 completed questionnaire about their general knowledge of CHD

risk factors, compliance to lifestyle changes, and drug adherence

Statistically significant correlation between CHD risk factor knowledge and compliance to certain lifestyle changes (weight, physical activity, stress management, diet, attaining lipid level goals, likelihood of taking prescribed antihypertensives)

No correlation between this knowledge and blood glucose or blood pressure levels nor smoking habits or treatment patterns for prescribed lipid- and blood glucose-lowering drugs

Knowledge correlated to patient behavior with respect to some risk factors, which should be recognized in prevention programs

Alm-Roijer C, et al. Eur J Cardiovasc Nurs. 2004;3:321-330.

Page 25: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Adherence: Therapy-related factors

• Complexity of the medical regimen, concomitant medications

• Frequency and duration of treatment• Previous treatment failures • Frequent changes in treatment• Immediacy of beneficial effects and side effects,

availability of medical support to deal with them

World Health Organization. World Health Organization; Geneva, Switzerland. 2003.

Page 26: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Adapted from cohort study using linked population-based administration data from Ontario, Canada (N=85,020). Jackevicius et al. JAMA. 2002;288:462-467.

Adherence continues to drop over time, particularly when treating the asymptomatic patient

Nonadherence to Statin Treatment begins early

Page 27: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Adherence Measurements

• Patient self-reports or questionnaires• Clinician perception• Pill counts• Electronic monitoring devices• Biochemical measurement or pharmacologic

tracers• Electronic prescription refill records (refill

rates)

Sikka R, et al. Am J Manag Care. 2005;11:449-457; World Health Organization. World Health Organization; Geneva, Switzerland, 2003.

Most adherence research is observational, rather than Conducted in a trial setting, to better reflect real-world

patient behavior.

Page 28: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Meta-analysis of trials of interventions

to improve medication adherence

Medication non-adherence has a profound negative impact on everyaspect of health care. For decades we have searched for that one perfect solution to the problem; however, there does not seem to be any oneintervention that robustly enhances adherence, perhaps because so many

variables affect a patient’s decision to take a drug. A combined approach intuitively may best address patients’ needs, but more data must be collected through standardized research methods. Studies focusing on the relationship between adherence and health outcome measures, specific interventions, and cost-effectiveness and between adherence and various combinations of interventions are needed

ConclusionMeta-analysis of studies of interventions to improve medication adherence

revealed an increase in adherence of 4–11%. No single strategy appeared to be best.

Am J Health-Syst Pharm—Vol 60 Apr 1, 2003

Page 29: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Thus, a Multifaceted Approach to Patient Treatment is Required

Patient

Payers(employers/HP/PBM)

Direct to

Consumer

Family/PeersNurse

Pharmacy

PhysicianPhysician

Direct Mail

AdhereRx

Pharmacy bag newsletter

HAL, CAVEAT Pilot

My Heart Wise

AdhereRx

Pharmacy bag newsletter

HAL, HEART

DTC Print

Physician direction to

patient

Starters Refill Reminder Letters

Follow-up with patient

Follow-up with patient

DTC TVWebsite

800# IVR

DTC Print

Physician direction to

patient

Starters Refill Reminder Letters

Follow -- up with patient

Follow--up with patient

DTC TVWeb

800# IVR

AdhereRxCareMark Refill

Reminder

IVR

Pharmacy First

Outbound Direct Mail

CVS Mailer

StartersHouse CallPoster

StartersHouse Call Radio

Page 30: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

The challenge of non-adherence

• More than 50% of patients with diabetes, hypertension, tobacco addiction, hyperlipidemia, congestive heart failure, asthma, depression, and chronic atrial fibrillation are currently managed inadequately.1-9

• 18,000 Americans die each year from heart attacks because they did not receive preventive medications, although they were eligible for them.10-11

• Low adherence to prescribed treatments is common; typical adherence rates for prescribed medications are ~50% with a range of 0–100+%.12

• 1/3 or more of ambulatory patients take prescribed doses at intervals that frequently are longer than prescribed—hours, days, sometimes weeks.13

• Within 6 months, 60% of patients discontinue their CV prevention medications.

1. Institute of Medicine, 2003c; 2. Clark et al., 2000; 3. Joint National Committee on Prevention, 1997; 4. Legorreta et al., 2000; 5. McBride et al., 1998; 6. Ni et al., 1998; 7. Perez-Stable and Fuentes-Afflick, 1998; 8. Samsa et al., 2000; 9. Young et al., 2001;10. Chassin, 1997; 11. Institute of Medicine, 2003a. 12. Sackett and Snow, 1979; 13. Houston, et al. 1997.

Page 31: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

0

1

2

3

4

5

Pa

tie

nts

Wit

h M

I (%

)Patients Nonadherent to Statin Therapy Are

Twice as Likely to Experience Subsequent MI

Total Patients <65 Years

Patients ≥65 Years

2.1

4.1

1.5

4.1

3.54.0

P=.047 P=.001P=.73

Adherent Nonadherent

Adherence defined as fill frequency ≥80% (n=661). Nonadherence defined as fill frequency ≤60% (n=395).

Blackburn DF, et al. Pharmacotherapy. 2005;25:1035-1043.

Page 32: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

As Adherence Goes Down, Health Care Costs and Hospitalizations Go Up

Sokol MC, et al. Med Care. 2005;43:521-530.

0

5000

Diabetes

Hypertension

Hypercholesterolemia

CHF

10000

15000

20000

25000

$ All-Cause Health Care Costs100

0

20

Diabetes

Hypertension

Hypercholesterolemia

CHF

40

60

80

% All-Cause Hospitalization Risk

1%-19% Adherence Level 80%-100% Adherence Level

Page 33: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

The great statin debate - Do they have magical properties?Dr. Topol: Do you believe that statins have pleiotropic effects or

“magical properties”?

Dr. Califf: Absolutely

Dr. Topol: Do you think its related to inflammatory markers, effect on endothelial function, or some unique effect on the vascular wall?

Dr. Califf: Nope

Dr. Topol: Is it about early treatment, early benefit or intensity?

Dr. Califf: Nah

Dr. Topol: What then do you attribute the magic of statins?

Dr. Califf: When patients actually take them….

Page 34: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

UNC LIPID AND PREVENTION CLINIC

Page 35: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Patient Knowledge of Coronary Risk ProfileImproves the Effectiveness of Dyslipidemia Therapy

Communicating risk is consistent with many of the recommendations to improve adherence, including enhancing self-monitoring and using the support of family and friends. Informing patients of their coronary risk may also increase the effectiveness of primary prevention by identifying individuals most likely to benefit from treatment while reassuring those at low risk.

Grover SA, et al. Arch Intern Med. 2007;167:2296-2303.

As a result of these changes, your cardiovascular age has dropped from 60.8 y to 53.8 y. Your 8-y cardiovascular risk has dropped from 24.5% to 7.5%

0 Sep2002

Dec2002

Mar2003

Jun2003

Sep2003

Dec2003

Month

3

21

24

15

18

9

12

6

8-y

Car

dio

vasc

ula

r R

isk,

% Low Risk

Moderate Risk

High Risk

Page 36: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Misperception among physicians and patients regarding the risks and benefits of statin treatment: the

potential role of direct-to-consumer advertisingRachel H. Kon, MD, Mark W. Russo, MD, Bridget Ory, MD, Phil Mendys, PharmD,

Ross J. Simpson, Jr., MD, PhD*

04/11/23 36

44

30

46

72

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

Non-physician Source Physician Source

Source of Risk Information

Nu

mb

er o

f P

ati

en

ts R

esp

on

din

g

Cause Liver Damage Prevent MI/Stroke

Page 37: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Physician Follow-up/Provider Continuity Associated With Long-term Adherence

• Statin use is dynamic; many patients have long periods of nonadherence• An estimated 48% restarted treatment within 1 year; 60% restarted within 2 years• Continuity of care combined with increased follow-up and cholesterol testing could

promote long-term adherence by shortening or eliminating long gaps in statin use

Brookhart MA, et al. Arch Intern Med. 2007;167:847-852.

Statin Therapy Start Date

No Statin Use in Past Year

Statin Rx 1

Statin Rx 2

Statin Rx 3

ControlPeriod

HazardPeriod

StatinRx n +1

Statin Therapy Restart Date

Statin Therapy Stop Date

90-d Gap inStatin Coverage

14 d 14 d

Page 38: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Point-of-Care Lipid Testing

• Address gap in testing to treatment

• Improves option to titrate, adjust Rx

• Gets additional patient engagement

• Improves goal attainment

Page 39: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Statin Titration and Goal Attainment:Start with the end in mind!

AJC, Vol 92 July 1, 2003

2829 high risk patients

At Goal on Starting Dose

Not At Goal

Titrated

NOT Titrated

Not At Goal

At Goal

48%

52%

(N=1464)

(N=203)

(N=813)

(N=448)

14% of patientsnot at goal on

initial dose reachedGoal by 6 months

Page 40: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

The relationship of vitamin D deficiency to statin myopathy

Both statins and vitamin D affect skeletal muscle metabolism and function. There is preliminary data to suggest that vitamin D deficiency is associated with increased statin-associated skeletal muscle complaints, but no definitive evidence that vitamin D contributes to statin myalgia or is effective in its treatment. Vitamin D supplementation reduced myalgic symptoms in some statin treated patients although a placebo effect cannot be excluded. Consequently, it is reasonable to determine vitamin D levels in statin-myalgic patients and to provide vitamin D supplementation in doses of 400–2000 IU to those with low vitamin D levels (<32 ng/mL) until definitive placebo controlled trials of this therapy are available.

04/11/23 40Atherosclerosis 215 (2011) 23–29

Page 41: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Cardiac rehabilitation

The perfect “fit” to improve adherence• Collaborative Team Approach• Emphasis on Continuity of Care• Multi-dimensional• Systematic Process of Care delivery

04/11/23 41

Page 42: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Patients' perspectives on cardiac rehabilitation, lifestyle change and taking

medicines: implications for service development

• Patients tended to talk about the exercise component of cardiac rehabilitation and only talk about the information provision component when prompted, which suggested they viewed the program as being primarily about exercise.

• There was little subsequent contact with health services, except routine six-monthly check-ups for their coronary heart disease.

• Unmet information needs were common, especially about medicines

Ensuring that individual patients' information needs about medicines and lifestyle are adequately met remains a key focus for cardiac rehabilitation development.

04/11/23 42jhsrp.2009.009103v1 15/suppl_2/47

Page 43: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

The challenge of improving evidence-basedtherapy adherence in the secondary

prevention of coronary artery disease: the next frontier of cardiac rehabilitation

• Non-adherence to prescribed drug regimens is an increasing medical problem affecting physicians and patients and contribute to negative outcomes, such as the increased risk of subsequent cardiovascular events. Analysis of various patient populations shows that the choice of drug, its tolerability and the duration of treatment influence the non-adherence. Intervention is required toward patients and health-care providers to improve medication adherence. This review deals about the prevalence of non-adherence to therapy after medical and surgical cardiac event, the risk factors affecting non-adherence and the strategies to implement it. Interventions that may successfully improve adherence should include improved physician compliance with guidelines, patient education and patient reminders, frequent visits or telephone calls from staff, simplification of the patient's drug regimen by reducing the number of pills and daily doses. Since single interventions do not appear efficacious, it is necessary to establish multiple interventions simultaneously addressing a number of barriers to adherence.

04/11/23 43Monaldi Arch Chest Dis. 2009, reference in Italian

Page 44: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Predictors of Smoking CessationAfter a Myocardial Infarction

04/11/23 44

While individual smoking cessation counseling was not associated with smoking cessation post-MI, hospital-based smoking cessation programs, as well as referral to cardiac rehabilitation, were strongly associated with increased smoking cessation rates.

Arch Intern Med. 2008;168(18):1961-1967

Page 45: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Long-term Medication Adherence after MyocardialInfarction: Experience of a Community

CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE

● More than 50% of the patients discontinue each of the cardio-protective medications after a myocardial infarction over a 3-year period.

● Clinical characteristics of the myocardial infarction were not associated with long-term medication adherence.

● Enrollment and use of cardiac rehab is associated with better long-term medication adherence.

04/11/23 45The American Journal of Medicine (2009) 122, 961.e7-961.e12

Page 46: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

ACCF/AHA/AMA–PCPI 2011 Performance Measures for Adults With Coronary Artery

Disease and Hypertension

3.3.2. Medication Adherence

…objection to the use of patient adherence as a measure of physician quality is that, although prescribing physicians have some influence on patient choices, adherence is largely not in the individual physician’s locus of control.

…reliable information on patient adherence is often difficult and expensive to obtain.

…it believed that measures of adherence, such as those included in HEDIS (Healthcare Effectiveness Data and Information Set), could be used at the health plan, employer, or health system levels as effective quality improvement tools.

04/11/23 46JACC Vol. 58, No. 3, 2011

Page 47: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Adherence as a Health Care Priority

04/11/23 47

Page 48: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Quiz

04/11/23 48

Page 49: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

The Framingham risk score estimates 10-year absolute risk for cardiovascular disease events and age contributes enormously to the end result, given that indeed age is the greatest contributor to absolute cardiovascular risk. However, the Framingham Risk Score is less robust in the elderly (age > 70) as this group because:

A) the likelihood of CV events decreases after age 70B) have already had their “age-based” exposureC) cholesterol management in this group appears to provide no benefitD) the risk benefit ratio of treating these patients limits treatment considerationsE) none of the above

QUESTIONS FOR LIPID MANAGEMENT IN THE ELDERLY

Evaluation, and Treatment of High Blood Cholesterol in Adults (Adult Treatment Panel III) Full Report; Final Report; nih.gov

Page 50: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

The Framingham risk score estimates 10-year absolute risk for cardiovascular disease events and age contributes enormously to the end result, given that indeed age is the greatest contributor to absolute cardiovascular risk. However, the Framingham Risk Score is less robust in the elderly (age > 70) as this group because:

A) the likelihood of CV events decreases after age 70B) have already had their “age-based” exposureC) cholesterol management in this group appears to provide no benefitD) the risk benefit ratio of treating these patients limits treatment considerationsE) none of the above

QUESTIONS FOR LIPID MANAGEMENT IN THE ELDERLY

Evaluation, and Treatment of High Blood Cholesterol in Adults (Adult Treatment Panel III) Full Report; Final Report; nih.gov

Page 51: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

QUESTIONS FOR LIPID MANAGEMENT IN THE ELDERLY

• The National Cholesterol Education Panel ATP III reaffirms their position that older persons who are at coronary disease higher risk and are in otherwise good health, are candidates for cholesterol-lowering therapy. As reported in the Cardiovascular Health Study in 2002, the use of statin therapy in study participants at baseline who were 65 years or older and free of cardiovascular disease, resulted in a

A) Greater than 50 lower risk of CV events and more than 40 % lower all cause

mortality.B) Greater than 50% risk reduction for CV events, but only 20% reduction in all

cause death.C) Equal reduction of risk in CV events and all cause mortalityD) Reduction in risk of CV events, but an increase of risk associated with adverse

events of statin therapyE) None of the above

Therapy with hydroxylmethylglutaryl Coenzyme A Reductase Inhibitors (Statins) and Associated Risk of Incident Cardiovascular Events in Older Adults – evidence from he Cardiovascular Health Study; Rozen LeMaitre, PhD, MHS et.al.; Arch IM 2002; 162: 1395-1400

Page 52: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

QUESTIONS FOR LIPID MANAGEMENT IN THE ELDERLY

• The National Cholesterol Education Panel ATP III reaffirms their position that older persons who are at coronary disease higher risk and are in otherwise good health, are candidates for cholesterol-lowering therapy. As reported in the Cardiovascular Health Study in 2002, the use of statin therapy in study participants at baseline who were 65 years or older and free of cardiovascular disease, resulted in a

A) Greater than 50 lower risk of CV events and more than 40 % lower all cause

mortality.B) Greater than 50% risk reduction for CV events, but only 20% reduction in all

cause death.C) Equal reduction of risk in CV events and all cause mortalityD) Reduction in risk of CV events, but an increase of risk associated with adverse

events of statin therapyE) None of the above

Therapy with hydroxylmethylglutaryl Coenzyme A Reductase Inhibitors (Statins) and Associated Risk of Incident Cardiovascular Events in Older Adults – evidence from he Cardiovascular Health Study; Rozen LeMaitre, PhD, MHS et.al.; Arch IM 2002; 162: 1395-1400

Page 53: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

QUESTIONS FOR LIPID MANAGEMENT IN THE ELDERLY

• Persons greater than the age of 65 account for approximately two out of three first major coronary events, and CHD deaths account for about ½ of all CHD events. If we accept the premise that statin therapy reduces risk for all CHD event categories, then the likely mortality benefit of statins is reasonably stated at:

A) 40%B) 33%C) 70%D) 50%E) None of the above

Ref: Evaluation, and Treatment of High Blood Cholesterol in Adults (Adult TreatmentPanel III) Full Report; Final Report; nih.gov

Page 54: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

QUESTIONS FOR LIPID MANAGEMENT IN THE ELDERLY

• Persons greater than the age of 65 account for approximately two out of three first major coronary events, and CHD deaths account for about ½ of all CHD events. If we accept the premise that statin therapy reduces risk for all CHD event categories, then the likely mortality benefit of statins is reasonably stated at:

A) 40%B) 33%C) 70%D) 50%E) None of the above

Ref: Evaluation, and Treatment of High Blood Cholesterol in Adults (Adult TreatmentPanel III) Full Report; Final Report; nih.gov

Page 55: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

QUESTIONS FOR LIPID MANAGEMENT IN THE ELDERLY

Choose the one best answer which addresses the issues of Therapeutic Lifestyle in older patients.

a) Weight reduction goals and increased physical activity are less critical for patients over the age of 65.

b) Patients should be encouraged to reduce intake of saturated fats (7% of total calories) and cholesterol (200 mg /day). This Step I diet is then followed by a more restrictive Step II diet to achieve more reasonable treatment goals

c) the clinician may consider drug therapy at a period of 4 to 6 weeks in older patients who are not approaching their respective treatment goal.

d) Plant stanols and soluble fiber should be restricted in older patients due to the risk of sever GI intolerance.

e) none of the above.

Lipid Management and the Elderly; Mi Michael H. Davidson, MD, Sara B. Kurlandsky, PhD, Ruth M. Kleinpell, PhD, RN, Kevin C. Maki, PhD Prev Cardiol 6(3):128-133, 2003

Page 56: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

QUESTIONS FOR LIPID MANAGEMENT IN THE ELDERLY

Choose the one best answer which addresses the issues of Therapeutic Lifestyle in older patients.

a) Weight reduction goals and increased physical activity are less critical for patients over the age of 65.

b) Patients should be encouraged to reduce intake of saturated fats (7% of total calories) and cholesterol (200 mg /day). This Step I diet is then followed by a more restrictive Step II diet to achieve more reasonable treatment goals

c) the clinician may consider drug therapy at a period of 4 to 6 weeks in older patients who are not approaching their respective treatment goal.

d) Plant stanols and soluble fiber should be restricted in older patients due to the risk of sever GI intolerance.

e) none of the above.

Lipid Management and the Elderly; Mi Michael H. Davidson, MD, Sara B. Kurlandsky, PhD, Ruth M. Kleinpell, PhD, RN, Kevin C. Maki, PhD Prev Cardiol 6(3):128-133, 2003

Page 57: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

BACK UP SLIDES

04/11/23 57

Page 58: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Poor health literacy: a ‘hidden’ risk factor

Low health literacy has been associated with non-adherence to treatment plans and medical regimens, poor

patient self-care, high healthcare costs, and increased risk of

hospitalization and mortality. realizing that health literacy affects prognosis affords the opportunity to better understand the causes of poor outcome and develop interventions to

address this issue. Many cardiovascular diseases have

complex mechanisms and etiologies and can be difficult for patients to

understand. low health literacy, therefore, presents a

particular challenge in treating the cardiac patient.

nature reviews | cardiology volume 7 | Sept 2010 |

Page 59: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Niacin in Patients with Low HDL Cholesterol Levels Receiving Intensive Statin Therapy- AIM HIGH

04/11/23 5910.1056/nejmoa1107579 nejm.org/NEJM Nov 15, 2011

Page 60: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

04/11/23 60

Primary Outcome by Treatment Group and Baseline Subgroup - ACCORD

SubgroupFenofibrate % Events

(Number in Grp)Place Events

(Number in Grp)Feno to Placebo

Hazard RatioInteraction

P-Value

Overall 10.5% (2,765) 11.3% (2,753)

LDL-c Tertile

<=84 mg/dl 9.4% (938) 12.2% (891) 0.1212

85–111 mg/dl 9.9% (934) 11.2% (922)

>=112 mg/dl 12.4% (877) 10.6% (927)

HDL-c Tertile

<=34 mg/dl 12.2% (964) 15.6% (906) 0.2374

35–40 mg/dl 10.1% (860) 9.5% (866)

>=41 mg/dl 9.1% (925) 9.0% (968)

Triglyceride Tertile

<=128 mg/dl 9.9% (891) 11.3% (939) 0.6422

129–203 mg/dl 10.5% (924) 9.9% (913)

>=204 mg/dl 11.1% (934) 12.8% (888)

Trig / HDL Combination

TG204+ / HDL<=34 12.4% (485) 17.3% (456) 0.0567

All Others 10.1% (2,264) 10.1% (2,284)

A1c Median

A1c<=8.0 8.7% (1,324) 10.6% (1,335) 0.2045

A1c 8.1+ 12.2% (1,435) 11.9% (1,415)

The ACCORD Study Group. NEJM 2010 362;17,1563-1574.0 1 2

Page 61: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Vitamin D deficiency, myositis–myalgia, and reversible statin intolerance

04/11/23 61Current Medical Research & Opinion Vol. 27, No. 9, 2011, 1683–1690

Page 62: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Practical support predicts medication adherence and attendance at cardiac rehabilitation following acute

coronary syndrome

04/11/23 62Journal of Psychosomatic Research 65 (2008) 581–586

Page 63: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

Erectile Dysfunction & Risk Factors

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

40 50 60 70

Age (Years)

ED

Pre

vale

nce

(%) Age

Smoking

Diabetes

Depression

Hypertension

Hyperlipidemia

Page 64: Enhancing our Patients Compliance with their Medical Regimen Phil Mendys, Pharm D, FAHA, CPP, Co-Director, UNC Lipid and Prevention Clinic.

The problem is…"Men with ED going to a general practitioner or a urologist

need to be referred for a cardiology workup to determine

existing cardiovascular disease and proper treatment,“…

"ED is an early predictor of cardiovascular disease."

Many men with ED see a general practitioner or a urologist to

get medication for ED, he said.

"The medication works and the patient doesn't show up

anymore," …"These men are being treated for the ED, but not the underlying cardiovascular disease. A whole segment of men is being placed at risk.“

Erectile Dysfunction Strong Predictor of Death, Cardiovascular OutcomesScienceDaily (Mar. 16, 2010)


Recommended